Assessment of the Topology and Oligomerisation States of Coiled Coils Using Metadynamics with Conformational Restraints
Open accessThe DOI matches its Crossref record; 133 of the 133 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; 32 of the 117 sources its claims cite were checked for support.
Abstract
protein design due to their established sequence-to-structure relationships and ability to switch conformations in response to external stimuli, such as changes in pH or temperature. However, the computational design of multistate coiled-coil protein assemblies is challenging, as it requires accurate estimates of the free energy differences between multiple alternative coiled-coil conformations. Here, we demonstrate how this challenge can be tackled using metadynamics simulations with orientational, positional and conformational restraints. We show that, even for subtle sequence variations, our protocol can predict the preferred topology of coiled-coil dimers and trimers, the preferred oligomerization states of coiled-coil dimers, trimers, and tetramers, as well as the switching behavior of a pH-dependent multistate system. Our approach provides a method for predicting the stability of coiled-coil designs and offers a new framework for computing binding free energies in protein-protein and multiprotein complexes.
Overview
CoChat Summary
TL;DR
The paper presents a metadynamics-based free-energy protocol with orientational, positional, helical, and RMSD restraints for predicting coiled-coil topology, oligomerization state, and pH-dependent switching. It reports that the method correctly recovers the preferred states of several designed coiled coils and outperforms unrestrained or funnel metadynamics, which often produce misfolded bound states.
Key findings
- The restrained metadynamics protocol correctly predicted topology for two dimers: CC-Di as a parallel dimer and apCC-Di as an antiparallel dimer; it also recovered the preferred trimer topology of CC-Tri.
- For oligomerization state, the method matched experiment for CC-Di, CC-Tri, and CC-Tet: dimer, trimer, and tetramer were each preferred in the corresponding native systems.
- The pH-switchable CC-Hex*-L24E system was also captured: the parallel hexamer is more favorable at low pH, while the antiparallel tetramer is more favorable at high pH; the paper reports ΔGbind,total°/helix values of −5.3 ± 1.3 kcal mol–1 for the low-pH hexamer and −5.4 ± 1.1 kcal mol–1 for the high-pH tetramer.
- For the stable coiled coils, the paper reports ΔGbind,total°/helix < −10 kcal mol–1 for CC-Di, CC-Tri, and CC-Tet, except for the dimeric CC-Tet at −9.5 ± 0.8 kcal mol–1; apCC-Di had a lower value of −5.3 ± 0.5 kcal mol–1.
Methods
- The study used well-tempered metadynamics in OpenMM 7.5 with Boresch restraints, plus additional helical ϕ/ψ and RMSD restraints, to compute binding free energies for coiled-coil assemblies treated as fully folded α-helices.
- Systems analyzed included CC-Di, apCC-Di, CC-Tri, CC-Tet, and CC-Hex*-L24E; structures were obtained from PDBe or designed in ISAMBARD, and CC-Hex*-L24E was modeled by fixed protonation states for low vs high pH.
- Simulations were run in implicit solvent with the AMBER ff96/OBC2 force field at 298.15 K; unrestrained metadynamics, funnel metadynamics, and restrained Boresch-metadynamics protocols were compared, with three independent replicates used in several runs.
Limitations
- The paper states that the protocol does not account for the folding free energy of isolated monomers into helices prior to assembly; this could affect the estimated total energetic cost of association.
- The pH treatment is simplified: only low and high pH conditions with fixed protonation states were examined, and the authors say a constant-pH MD approach would be more realistic.
- The text makes evident that the method depends on having plausible starting structures and that implicit solvent can struggle with hydrophobic length-scale effects, interfacial water, and interfaces with many salt bridges; the authors note explicit solvent may be needed in such cases.
Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Figures








Verification
Claims the paper makes
17 Valid · 1 Not valid · 36 Not checked · 104 Own results and interpretations
The cited sources support only part of this claim — read each source’s verdict below.
In the paper
“The free energy landscape of coiled coils is complex, consisting of multiple local, energetically close minima.32,33”
§ Assessment of the Topology and Oligomerisation States of Coiled Coils Using Metadynamics with Conformational Restraints > Introduction Coiled coils are bundles of two or more α-helices that wrap around each other to form superhelical complexes.1 Coiled coils can adopt a variety of parallel, antiparallel or mixed (e.g., up–down–up) topologies, which can be characterized with three geometric descriptors: the coiled coil radius, interface (Crick) angle and pitch (Figure 1A).2 The assemblies possess a distinctive type of packing termed knobs-into-holes (KIH), where a side chain from one helix (“knob”) packs into a diamond-shaped cavity (“hole”) formed by four side chains in a different helix of the bundle.3 This distinguishes coiled coils from other helical bundles, which are characterized by less intimate packing.4,5 This packing arrangement is supported by sequence repeats of hydrophobic (h) and polar (p) residues,3 usually in heptad repeats hpphppp, often denoted in the form of an abcdefg register. In these heptad repeats, the hydrophobic residues have an average spacing of 3.5 residues, giving rise to amphipathic helices, composed of a hydrophobic and a hydrophilic face. Since there is a small spacing deviation between 3.5 in heptad repeats and 3.6 in ideal α-helices, the hydrophobic face of a helix with 3.5 spacing proceeds around the helix, leading to supercoiling of helices upon assembly rather than packing in a straight manner.6 Coiled-coil assembly is driven by the hydrophobic effect, where the helices assemble to bury their hydrophobic faces in a hydrophobic core.7 The nature of the hydrophobic residues at the a and d positions of the heptad repeat largely determines the oligomerization state of coiled-coil dimers, trimers and tetramers.8,9 Further helices can be recruited to the assembly via the expansion of the hydrophobic interface, achieved by introducing hydrophobic residues at the e and g positions.10 The wealth of knowledge about these topological arrangements have contributed to turning coiled coils into an attractive scaffold for de novo computational protein design. However, the majority of de novo designed coiled coils are hyperstable, with melting points exceeding 100 °C.11,12 Natural coiled coils, on the other hand, are dynamic and play central roles in a multitude of biological functions.13−17 As a consequence, attention has shifted to the de novo design of switchable coiled coils. While this has been accomplished in a number of cases,18−31 achieving the desired balance between multiple target coiled-coil states often requires several rounds of trial-and-error and a detailed understanding of the energetic factors that discriminate between alternative topologies and oligomerization states. For these reasons, achieving quantitative predictions of coiled-coil stability by calculating the free energy of oligomerization has been deemed one of the outstanding challenges in coiled coil research.32 Such capability would pave the way for the computational design of switchable proteins for a variety of biotechnological applications. The free energy landscape of coiled coils is complex, consisting of multiple local, energetically close minima.32,33 Currently, little experimental free energy data are available for de novo designed coiled coils, due to their high thermostability. Initial attempts on predicting oligomerization states in coiled coils focused on distinguishing dimers from trimers.34−39 Further studies expanded predictions to higher order oligomerization states (up to pentamers) and alternative topologies.40−42 More recently, deep learning methods have been employed to distinguish dimers, trimers and tetramers.43−45 However, the ability of the aforementioned approaches to predict the stability of higher order oligomerization states has been limited by the dearth of available experimental structural data for model training and calibration. Furthermore, these approaches do not account for external stimuli during the prediction of oligomerization state (e.g., change in the pH or temperature, or addition of ligands), and are consequently not suitable for multistate coiled-coil design. Methods such as MM-PBSA and MM-GBSA,46,47 which are based on molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, offer an alternative route for computing the binding free energies of protein–protein systems48−50 including coiled-coil complexes.42,51,52 However, when applied to protein assemblies, these methods frequently produce binding free estimates with large statistical errors53 and make a number of approximations, such as neglecting or partially accounting for the effects of changes in internal energy and entropy on protein association free energies, resulting in limited accuracy.54 More rigorous free energy methods such as alchemical binding free energy calculations have become established for the computation of binding free energies of small molecules to proteins with MD.55−60 While in theory an alchemical pathway could be constructed via decoupling a binding partner in a protein–protein complex from its environment in the bound and unbound states, the alchemical decoupling of a complete protein molecule will usually result in poor convergence61 due to large free energy changes.62 This is expected to be particularly problematic for coiled coils, given the magnitude of electrostatic interactions present due to their multiple charged residues. Alternatively, a so-called path-based approach may be adopted to compute protein–protein binding free energies with MD methods. In this approach, the potential of mean force (PMF) for dissociating a protein assembly can be computed via a variety of enhanced sampling techniques applied to preselected collective variables (CVs).62 While the path-based PMF approach appears more tractable, it is still difficult to obtain converged free energy estimates for large biomolecules with complex geometries.53,62−68 More precise free energy changes can be obtained through the application of restraints which ensure that the relative orientation and position of the ligand with respect to the receptor is preserved and therefore the available phase space to be sampled during the simulations is reduced.54,63−65 To this end, Woo and Roux pioneered the so-called geometrical route for binding free energy calculations, where the binding process is decomposed into distinct, independent processes, each described by a unique CV, which corresponds to a specific slow degree of freedom of the system. In the original implementation of the geometrical route,54 three atom centers are chosen on both binding counterparts, constructing a local frame of reference. The orientation of the ligand with respect to the receptor is then defined by the three Euler angles Θ, Φ, Ψ, and the position of the ligand with respect to the receptor is defined by the polar angles θ and ϕ. The ligand is additionally restrained in the average conformation it adopts when bound to its receptor with the application of an RMSD restraint. The binding free energy is then quantified by means of a series of sequential PMF calculations on the above CVs. In each PMF calculation, the only restraints present are those that have been added beforehand. The final PMF calculation involves the physical separation of the two binding partners along the Euclidean distance r between their centers of mass and is carried out in the presence of all restraints. Simulations without such restraints have been reported to fail to converge and to yield binding free energies inconsistent with experimental data.62,65,69 The geometrical route has been automated with quaternion-based angle restraints67 as CVs in the NAMD70,71 and GROMACS72 MD engines. Additional variations of the framework have also been introduced, with various implementations of RMSD restraints applied on both receptor and ligand in the bound and unbound states.62,62,65,69 The protocol has so far been successfully used in calculating the binding free energy of a variety of protein–protein complexes, in good agreement with experimental data,54,62,64,65,67,73−76 including a homodimeric α-helical complex.69 An alternative set of orientational and positional restraints has been proposed by Boresch et al.77 in the context of small molecule-protein binding free energy calculations. Boresch restraints are constructed by selecting three anchor points (atoms or groups of atoms) on the receptor and three on the ligand. The restraints correspond to the external degrees of freedom of the ligand, and consist of a distance r, two angles θA, θB and three dihedrals ϕA, ϕB, ϕC. The Boresch angles and dihedrals play the same role as the Euler and polar angles used in the geometrical route, but are easier to implement in other MD software, such as OpenMM.78 Numerous techniques having been developed to facilitate the automated selection of anchor points.79−85 To the best of our knowledge, Boresch restraints have not been used so far in binding free energy calculations via a geometrical route. We decided to employ the Boresch angles and dihedrals instead of the Euler and polar angles, since no quaternion implementation is available in OpenMM to date. In principle, the binding free energy should be independent of the type of restraints, the atom centers selected for the construction of the restraints, or the values of the force constants,64,77,86 provided stable restraints that have been appropriately selected.87 In the present work, we combine well-tempered metadynamics (WT-metaD)88 with Boresch restraints77 in OpenMM78 to explore the oligomerization and topology preferences of de novo designed coiled coils. The overall pipeline is summarized in Figure 1. We demonstrate the applicability of our protocol by predicting: the topology (parallel vs antiparallel) preferences of CC-Di, CC-Tri and apCC-Di, the oligomerization state preferences of CC-Di, CC-Tri and CC-Tet, and the pH switching behavior of the CC-Hex*-L24E system, which forms a parallel hexamer at low pH and an antiparallel tetramer at high pH (Figure 2).29,33,89 We also show that employing WT-metaD88 and funnel metadynamics90 in the absence of orientational and positional restraints fails to yield reliable free energy estimates. Overall our results demonstrate the potential of path-based MD methods to act as a late stage filter in multistate protein design.
What the sources say
- Partly supportedcites [32] sourceExperimental — accuracy not yet measured
The “Current rules and challenges in coiled-coil design” section describes a complex free-energy landscape with multiple states close in energy, using CC-Hex as an example. “A note of caution” likewise says multiple states may be accessible for the short, low-to-medium-complexity de novo coiled coils discussed there. These passages support the central idea, but not its unqualified extension to coiled coils generally. (LLM, conf=0.82)
- Not checked — no full text of the sourcecites [33] source
plain- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Partly supported
The cited sources support only part of this claim — read each source’s verdict below.
In the paper
“However, the majority of de novo designed coiled coils are hyperstable, with melting points exceeding 100 °C.11,12”
§ Assessment of the Topology and Oligomerisation States of Coiled Coils Using Metadynamics with Conformational Restraints > Introduction Coiled coils are bundles of two or more α-helices that wrap around each other to form superhelical complexes.1 Coiled coils can adopt a variety of parallel, antiparallel or mixed (e.g., up–down–up) topologies, which can be characterized with three geometric descriptors: the coiled coil radius, interface (Crick) angle and pitch (Figure 1A).2 The assemblies possess a distinctive type of packing termed knobs-into-holes (KIH), where a side chain from one helix (“knob”) packs into a diamond-shaped cavity (“hole”) formed by four side chains in a different helix of the bundle.3 This distinguishes coiled coils from other helical bundles, which are characterized by less intimate packing.4,5 This packing arrangement is supported by sequence repeats of hydrophobic (h) and polar (p) residues,3 usually in heptad repeats hpphppp, often denoted in the form of an abcdefg register. In these heptad repeats, the hydrophobic residues have an average spacing of 3.5 residues, giving rise to amphipathic helices, composed of a hydrophobic and a hydrophilic face. Since there is a small spacing deviation between 3.5 in heptad repeats and 3.6 in ideal α-helices, the hydrophobic face of a helix with 3.5 spacing proceeds around the helix, leading to supercoiling of helices upon assembly rather than packing in a straight manner.6 Coiled-coil assembly is driven by the hydrophobic effect, where the helices assemble to bury their hydrophobic faces in a hydrophobic core.7 The nature of the hydrophobic residues at the a and d positions of the heptad repeat largely determines the oligomerization state of coiled-coil dimers, trimers and tetramers.8,9 Further helices can be recruited to the assembly via the expansion of the hydrophobic interface, achieved by introducing hydrophobic residues at the e and g positions.10 The wealth of knowledge about these topological arrangements have contributed to turning coiled coils into an attractive scaffold for de novo computational protein design. However, the majority of de novo designed coiled coils are hyperstable, with melting points exceeding 100 °C.11,12 Natural coiled coils, on the other hand, are dynamic and play central roles in a multitude of biological functions.13−17 As a consequence, attention has shifted to the de novo design of switchable coiled coils. While this has been accomplished in a number of cases,18−31 achieving the desired balance between multiple target coiled-coil states often requires several rounds of trial-and-error and a detailed understanding of the energetic factors that discriminate between alternative topologies and oligomerization states. For these reasons, achieving quantitative predictions of coiled-coil stability by calculating the free energy of oligomerization has been deemed one of the outstanding challenges in coiled coil research.32 Such capability would pave the way for the computational design of switchable proteins for a variety of biotechnological applications. The free energy landscape of coiled coils is complex, consisting of multiple local, energetically close minima.32,33 Currently, little experimental free energy data are available for de novo designed coiled coils, due to their high thermostability. Initial attempts on predicting oligomerization states in coiled coils focused on distinguishing dimers from trimers.34−39 Further studies expanded predictions to higher order oligomerization states (up to pentamers) and alternative topologies.40−42 More recently, deep learning methods have been employed to distinguish dimers, trimers and tetramers.43−45 However, the ability of the aforementioned approaches to predict the stability of higher order oligomerization states has been limited by the dearth of available experimental structural data for model training and calibration. Furthermore, these approaches do not account for external stimuli during the prediction of oligomerization state (e.g., change in the pH or temperature, or addition of ligands), and are consequently not suitable for multistate coiled-coil design. Methods such as MM-PBSA and MM-GBSA,46,47 which are based on molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, offer an alternative route for computing the binding free energies of protein–protein systems48−50 including coiled-coil complexes.42,51,52 However, when applied to protein assemblies, these methods frequently produce binding free estimates with large statistical errors53 and make a number of approximations, such as neglecting or partially accounting for the effects of changes in internal energy and entropy on protein association free energies, resulting in limited accuracy.54 More rigorous free energy methods such as alchemical binding free energy calculations have become established for the computation of binding free energies of small molecules to proteins with MD.55−60 While in theory an alchemical pathway could be constructed via decoupling a binding partner in a protein–protein complex from its environment in the bound and unbound states, the alchemical decoupling of a complete protein molecule will usually result in poor convergence61 due to large free energy changes.62 This is expected to be particularly problematic for coiled coils, given the magnitude of electrostatic interactions present due to their multiple charged residues. Alternatively, a so-called path-based approach may be adopted to compute protein–protein binding free energies with MD methods. In this approach, the potential of mean force (PMF) for dissociating a protein assembly can be computed via a variety of enhanced sampling techniques applied to preselected collective variables (CVs).62 While the path-based PMF approach appears more tractable, it is still difficult to obtain converged free energy estimates for large biomolecules with complex geometries.53,62−68 More precise free energy changes can be obtained through the application of restraints which ensure that the relative orientation and position of the ligand with respect to the receptor is preserved and therefore the available phase space to be sampled during the simulations is reduced.54,63−65 To this end, Woo and Roux pioneered the so-called geometrical route for binding free energy calculations, where the binding process is decomposed into distinct, independent processes, each described by a unique CV, which corresponds to a specific slow degree of freedom of the system. In the original implementation of the geometrical route,54 three atom centers are chosen on both binding counterparts, constructing a local frame of reference. The orientation of the ligand with respect to the receptor is then defined by the three Euler angles Θ, Φ, Ψ, and the position of the ligand with respect to the receptor is defined by the polar angles θ and ϕ. The ligand is additionally restrained in the average conformation it adopts when bound to its receptor with the application of an RMSD restraint. The binding free energy is then quantified by means of a series of sequential PMF calculations on the above CVs. In each PMF calculation, the only restraints present are those that have been added beforehand. The final PMF calculation involves the physical separation of the two binding partners along the Euclidean distance r between their centers of mass and is carried out in the presence of all restraints. Simulations without such restraints have been reported to fail to converge and to yield binding free energies inconsistent with experimental data.62,65,69 The geometrical route has been automated with quaternion-based angle restraints67 as CVs in the NAMD70,71 and GROMACS72 MD engines. Additional variations of the framework have also been introduced, with various implementations of RMSD restraints applied on both receptor and ligand in the bound and unbound states.62,62,65,69 The protocol has so far been successfully used in calculating the binding free energy of a variety of protein–protein complexes, in good agreement with experimental data,54,62,64,65,67,73−76 including a homodimeric α-helical complex.69 An alternative set of orientational and positional restraints has been proposed by Boresch et al.77 in the context of small molecule-protein binding free energy calculations. Boresch restraints are constructed by selecting three anchor points (atoms or groups of atoms) on the receptor and three on the ligand. The restraints correspond to the external degrees of freedom of the ligand, and consist of a distance r, two angles θA, θB and three dihedrals ϕA, ϕB, ϕC. The Boresch angles and dihedrals play the same role as the Euler and polar angles used in the geometrical route, but are easier to implement in other MD software, such as OpenMM.78 Numerous techniques having been developed to facilitate the automated selection of anchor points.79−85 To the best of our knowledge, Boresch restraints have not been used so far in binding free energy calculations via a geometrical route. We decided to employ the Boresch angles and dihedrals instead of the Euler and polar angles, since no quaternion implementation is available in OpenMM to date. In principle, the binding free energy should be independent of the type of restraints, the atom centers selected for the construction of the restraints, or the values of the force constants,64,77,86 provided stable restraints that have been appropriately selected.87 In the present work, we combine well-tempered metadynamics (WT-metaD)88 with Boresch restraints77 in OpenMM78 to explore the oligomerization and topology preferences of de novo designed coiled coils. The overall pipeline is summarized in Figure 1. We demonstrate the applicability of our protocol by predicting: the topology (parallel vs antiparallel) preferences of CC-Di, CC-Tri and apCC-Di, the oligomerization state preferences of CC-Di, CC-Tri and CC-Tet, and the pH switching behavior of the CC-Hex*-L24E system, which forms a parallel hexamer at low pH and an antiparallel tetramer at high pH (Figure 2).29,33,89 We also show that employing WT-metaD88 and funnel metadynamics90 in the absence of orientational and positional restraints fails to yield reliable free energy estimates. Overall our results demonstrate the potential of path-based MD methods to act as a late stage filter in multistate protein design.
What the sources say
- Partly supportedcites [11] sourceExperimental — accuracy not yet measured
The paper reports a designed helical bundle with no melting transition up to 130°C, supporting the existence of exceptionally stable designs (section labelled Abstract; page unavailable). It does not support the claim that a majority have melting points above 100°C: it identifies only two of nine tested designs as hyperstable, and reports stability only up to 95°C for several others. (LLM, conf=0.87)
- Could not verifycites [12] sourceExperimental — accuracy not yet measured
Our copy of Thomson et al. (2014) contains only the institutional-repository (Pure/Handle) metadata record — title, authors, affiliations, journal/volume/pages, DOI, related projects and citation exports — with no scientific body text. Four searches (melting temperature/hyperstable coiled coil above 100 C; de novo designed coiled coils thermal stability unfolding; α-helical barrel heptad superhelix oligomerization; circular dichroism thermal melt Tm/AUC/crystal structure) returned only those same metadata passages, none of which report thermal-denaturation data or any statement about the stability of de novo coiled coils. Nothing in our copy contradicts the claim either, so it cannot be confirmed or disputed on this evidence. (LLM, conf=0.75)
plain- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Partly supported
Every source the paper cites for this claim was checked and supports it.
In the paper
“However, the computational design of multistate coiled-coil protein assemblies is challenging, as it requires accurate estimates of the free energy differences between multiple alternative coiled-coil conformations.”
§ Assessment of the Topology and Oligomerisation States of Coiled Coils Using Metadynamics with Conformational Restraints > Abstract
What the sources say
- Supportedcites [32] source
“Current rules and challenges in coiled-coil design” describes multiple assembly states close in energy and a complex free-energy landscape that must be navigated carefully. “Conclusion and outlook” says current methods cannot calculate accurate energies for coiled-coil assemblies in silico. Together, these support the stated challenge in computational design. (LLM, conf=0.90)
plainstates a cause- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Supported
The sources with a verdict support this claim; the rest weren’t checked yet, have no full text we could read, or their verdicts aren’t rated yet.
In the paper
“While in theory an alchemical pathway could be constructed via decoupling a binding partner in a protein–protein complex from its environment in the bound and unbound states, the alchemical decoupling of a complete protein molecule will usually result in poor convergence61 due to large free energy changes.62”
§ Assessment of the Topology and Oligomerisation States of Coiled Coils Using Metadynamics with Conformational Restraints > Introduction Coiled coils are bundles of two or more α-helices that wrap around each other to form superhelical complexes.1 Coiled coils can adopt a variety of parallel, antiparallel or mixed (e.g., up–down–up) topologies, which can be characterized with three geometric descriptors: the coiled coil radius, interface (Crick) angle and pitch (Figure 1A).2 The assemblies possess a distinctive type of packing termed knobs-into-holes (KIH), where a side chain from one helix (“knob”) packs into a diamond-shaped cavity (“hole”) formed by four side chains in a different helix of the bundle.3 This distinguishes coiled coils from other helical bundles, which are characterized by less intimate packing.4,5 This packing arrangement is supported by sequence repeats of hydrophobic (h) and polar (p) residues,3 usually in heptad repeats hpphppp, often denoted in the form of an abcdefg register. In these heptad repeats, the hydrophobic residues have an average spacing of 3.5 residues, giving rise to amphipathic helices, composed of a hydrophobic and a hydrophilic face. Since there is a small spacing deviation between 3.5 in heptad repeats and 3.6 in ideal α-helices, the hydrophobic face of a helix with 3.5 spacing proceeds around the helix, leading to supercoiling of helices upon assembly rather than packing in a straight manner.6 Coiled-coil assembly is driven by the hydrophobic effect, where the helices assemble to bury their hydrophobic faces in a hydrophobic core.7 The nature of the hydrophobic residues at the a and d positions of the heptad repeat largely determines the oligomerization state of coiled-coil dimers, trimers and tetramers.8,9 Further helices can be recruited to the assembly via the expansion of the hydrophobic interface, achieved by introducing hydrophobic residues at the e and g positions.10 The wealth of knowledge about these topological arrangements have contributed to turning coiled coils into an attractive scaffold for de novo computational protein design. However, the majority of de novo designed coiled coils are hyperstable, with melting points exceeding 100 °C.11,12 Natural coiled coils, on the other hand, are dynamic and play central roles in a multitude of biological functions.13−17 As a consequence, attention has shifted to the de novo design of switchable coiled coils. While this has been accomplished in a number of cases,18−31 achieving the desired balance between multiple target coiled-coil states often requires several rounds of trial-and-error and a detailed understanding of the energetic factors that discriminate between alternative topologies and oligomerization states. For these reasons, achieving quantitative predictions of coiled-coil stability by calculating the free energy of oligomerization has been deemed one of the outstanding challenges in coiled coil research.32 Such capability would pave the way for the computational design of switchable proteins for a variety of biotechnological applications. The free energy landscape of coiled coils is complex, consisting of multiple local, energetically close minima.32,33 Currently, little experimental free energy data are available for de novo designed coiled coils, due to their high thermostability. Initial attempts on predicting oligomerization states in coiled coils focused on distinguishing dimers from trimers.34−39 Further studies expanded predictions to higher order oligomerization states (up to pentamers) and alternative topologies.40−42 More recently, deep learning methods have been employed to distinguish dimers, trimers and tetramers.43−45 However, the ability of the aforementioned approaches to predict the stability of higher order oligomerization states has been limited by the dearth of available experimental structural data for model training and calibration. Furthermore, these approaches do not account for external stimuli during the prediction of oligomerization state (e.g., change in the pH or temperature, or addition of ligands), and are consequently not suitable for multistate coiled-coil design. Methods such as MM-PBSA and MM-GBSA,46,47 which are based on molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, offer an alternative route for computing the binding free energies of protein–protein systems48−50 including coiled-coil complexes.42,51,52 However, when applied to protein assemblies, these methods frequently produce binding free estimates with large statistical errors53 and make a number of approximations, such as neglecting or partially accounting for the effects of changes in internal energy and entropy on protein association free energies, resulting in limited accuracy.54 More rigorous free energy methods such as alchemical binding free energy calculations have become established for the computation of binding free energies of small molecules to proteins with MD.55−60 While in theory an alchemical pathway could be constructed via decoupling a binding partner in a protein–protein complex from its environment in the bound and unbound states, the alchemical decoupling of a complete protein molecule will usually result in poor convergence61 due to large free energy changes.62 This is expected to be particularly problematic for coiled coils, given the magnitude of electrostatic interactions present due to their multiple charged residues. Alternatively, a so-called path-based approach may be adopted to compute protein–protein binding free energies with MD methods. In this approach, the potential of mean force (PMF) for dissociating a protein assembly can be computed via a variety of enhanced sampling techniques applied to preselected collective variables (CVs).62 While the path-based PMF approach appears more tractable, it is still difficult to obtain converged free energy estimates for large biomolecules with complex geometries.53,62−68 More precise free energy changes can be obtained through the application of restraints which ensure that the relative orientation and position of the ligand with respect to the receptor is preserved and therefore the available phase space to be sampled during the simulations is reduced.54,63−65 To this end, Woo and Roux pioneered the so-called geometrical route for binding free energy calculations, where the binding process is decomposed into distinct, independent processes, each described by a unique CV, which corresponds to a specific slow degree of freedom of the system. In the original implementation of the geometrical route,54 three atom centers are chosen on both binding counterparts, constructing a local frame of reference. The orientation of the ligand with respect to the receptor is then defined by the three Euler angles Θ, Φ, Ψ, and the position of the ligand with respect to the receptor is defined by the polar angles θ and ϕ. The ligand is additionally restrained in the average conformation it adopts when bound to its receptor with the application of an RMSD restraint. The binding free energy is then quantified by means of a series of sequential PMF calculations on the above CVs. In each PMF calculation, the only restraints present are those that have been added beforehand. The final PMF calculation involves the physical separation of the two binding partners along the Euclidean distance r between their centers of mass and is carried out in the presence of all restraints. Simulations without such restraints have been reported to fail to converge and to yield binding free energies inconsistent with experimental data.62,65,69 The geometrical route has been automated with quaternion-based angle restraints67 as CVs in the NAMD70,71 and GROMACS72 MD engines. Additional variations of the framework have also been introduced, with various implementations of RMSD restraints applied on both receptor and ligand in the bound and unbound states.62,62,65,69 The protocol has so far been successfully used in calculating the binding free energy of a variety of protein–protein complexes, in good agreement with experimental data,54,62,64,65,67,73−76 including a homodimeric α-helical complex.69 An alternative set of orientational and positional restraints has been proposed by Boresch et al.77 in the context of small molecule-protein binding free energy calculations. Boresch restraints are constructed by selecting three anchor points (atoms or groups of atoms) on the receptor and three on the ligand. The restraints correspond to the external degrees of freedom of the ligand, and consist of a distance r, two angles θA, θB and three dihedrals ϕA, ϕB, ϕC. The Boresch angles and dihedrals play the same role as the Euler and polar angles used in the geometrical route, but are easier to implement in other MD software, such as OpenMM.78 Numerous techniques having been developed to facilitate the automated selection of anchor points.79−85 To the best of our knowledge, Boresch restraints have not been used so far in binding free energy calculations via a geometrical route. We decided to employ the Boresch angles and dihedrals instead of the Euler and polar angles, since no quaternion implementation is available in OpenMM to date. In principle, the binding free energy should be independent of the type of restraints, the atom centers selected for the construction of the restraints, or the values of the force constants,64,77,86 provided stable restraints that have been appropriately selected.87 In the present work, we combine well-tempered metadynamics (WT-metaD)88 with Boresch restraints77 in OpenMM78 to explore the oligomerization and topology preferences of de novo designed coiled coils. The overall pipeline is summarized in Figure 1. We demonstrate the applicability of our protocol by predicting: the topology (parallel vs antiparallel) preferences of CC-Di, CC-Tri and apCC-Di, the oligomerization state preferences of CC-Di, CC-Tri and CC-Tet, and the pH switching behavior of the CC-Hex*-L24E system, which forms a parallel hexamer at low pH and an antiparallel tetramer at high pH (Figure 2).29,33,89 We also show that employing WT-metaD88 and funnel metadynamics90 in the absence of orientational and positional restraints fails to yield reliable free energy estimates. Overall our results demonstrate the potential of path-based MD methods to act as a late stage filter in multistate protein design.
What the sources say
- Not checked yetcites [61] source
Checked before — its earlier verdict is held back until a new check runs.
- Supportedcites [62] source
The Introduction says that decoupling an entire macromolecule is unmanageable because of its very large solvation free energy and a corresponding difficulty. This supports the attributed explanation that decoupling a complete protein poses convergence problems due to large free-energy changes. (LLM, conf=0.90)
plainstates a cause- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Not checked yet
The cited sources support only part of this claim — read each source’s verdict below.
In the paper
“More precise free energy changes can be obtained through the application of restraints which ensure that the relative orientation and position of the ligand with respect to the receptor is preserved and therefore the available phase space to be sampled during the simulations is reduced.54,63−65”
§ Assessment of the Topology and Oligomerisation States of Coiled Coils Using Metadynamics with Conformational Restraints > Introduction Coiled coils are bundles of two or more α-helices that wrap around each other to form superhelical complexes.1 Coiled coils can adopt a variety of parallel, antiparallel or mixed (e.g., up–down–up) topologies, which can be characterized with three geometric descriptors: the coiled coil radius, interface (Crick) angle and pitch (Figure 1A).2 The assemblies possess a distinctive type of packing termed knobs-into-holes (KIH), where a side chain from one helix (“knob”) packs into a diamond-shaped cavity (“hole”) formed by four side chains in a different helix of the bundle.3 This distinguishes coiled coils from other helical bundles, which are characterized by less intimate packing.4,5 This packing arrangement is supported by sequence repeats of hydrophobic (h) and polar (p) residues,3 usually in heptad repeats hpphppp, often denoted in the form of an abcdefg register. In these heptad repeats, the hydrophobic residues have an average spacing of 3.5 residues, giving rise to amphipathic helices, composed of a hydrophobic and a hydrophilic face. Since there is a small spacing deviation between 3.5 in heptad repeats and 3.6 in ideal α-helices, the hydrophobic face of a helix with 3.5 spacing proceeds around the helix, leading to supercoiling of helices upon assembly rather than packing in a straight manner.6 Coiled-coil assembly is driven by the hydrophobic effect, where the helices assemble to bury their hydrophobic faces in a hydrophobic core.7 The nature of the hydrophobic residues at the a and d positions of the heptad repeat largely determines the oligomerization state of coiled-coil dimers, trimers and tetramers.8,9 Further helices can be recruited to the assembly via the expansion of the hydrophobic interface, achieved by introducing hydrophobic residues at the e and g positions.10 The wealth of knowledge about these topological arrangements have contributed to turning coiled coils into an attractive scaffold for de novo computational protein design. However, the majority of de novo designed coiled coils are hyperstable, with melting points exceeding 100 °C.11,12 Natural coiled coils, on the other hand, are dynamic and play central roles in a multitude of biological functions.13−17 As a consequence, attention has shifted to the de novo design of switchable coiled coils. While this has been accomplished in a number of cases,18−31 achieving the desired balance between multiple target coiled-coil states often requires several rounds of trial-and-error and a detailed understanding of the energetic factors that discriminate between alternative topologies and oligomerization states. For these reasons, achieving quantitative predictions of coiled-coil stability by calculating the free energy of oligomerization has been deemed one of the outstanding challenges in coiled coil research.32 Such capability would pave the way for the computational design of switchable proteins for a variety of biotechnological applications. The free energy landscape of coiled coils is complex, consisting of multiple local, energetically close minima.32,33 Currently, little experimental free energy data are available for de novo designed coiled coils, due to their high thermostability. Initial attempts on predicting oligomerization states in coiled coils focused on distinguishing dimers from trimers.34−39 Further studies expanded predictions to higher order oligomerization states (up to pentamers) and alternative topologies.40−42 More recently, deep learning methods have been employed to distinguish dimers, trimers and tetramers.43−45 However, the ability of the aforementioned approaches to predict the stability of higher order oligomerization states has been limited by the dearth of available experimental structural data for model training and calibration. Furthermore, these approaches do not account for external stimuli during the prediction of oligomerization state (e.g., change in the pH or temperature, or addition of ligands), and are consequently not suitable for multistate coiled-coil design. Methods such as MM-PBSA and MM-GBSA,46,47 which are based on molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, offer an alternative route for computing the binding free energies of protein–protein systems48−50 including coiled-coil complexes.42,51,52 However, when applied to protein assemblies, these methods frequently produce binding free estimates with large statistical errors53 and make a number of approximations, such as neglecting or partially accounting for the effects of changes in internal energy and entropy on protein association free energies, resulting in limited accuracy.54 More rigorous free energy methods such as alchemical binding free energy calculations have become established for the computation of binding free energies of small molecules to proteins with MD.55−60 While in theory an alchemical pathway could be constructed via decoupling a binding partner in a protein–protein complex from its environment in the bound and unbound states, the alchemical decoupling of a complete protein molecule will usually result in poor convergence61 due to large free energy changes.62 This is expected to be particularly problematic for coiled coils, given the magnitude of electrostatic interactions present due to their multiple charged residues. Alternatively, a so-called path-based approach may be adopted to compute protein–protein binding free energies with MD methods. In this approach, the potential of mean force (PMF) for dissociating a protein assembly can be computed via a variety of enhanced sampling techniques applied to preselected collective variables (CVs).62 While the path-based PMF approach appears more tractable, it is still difficult to obtain converged free energy estimates for large biomolecules with complex geometries.53,62−68 More precise free energy changes can be obtained through the application of restraints which ensure that the relative orientation and position of the ligand with respect to the receptor is preserved and therefore the available phase space to be sampled during the simulations is reduced.54,63−65 To this end, Woo and Roux pioneered the so-called geometrical route for binding free energy calculations, where the binding process is decomposed into distinct, independent processes, each described by a unique CV, which corresponds to a specific slow degree of freedom of the system. In the original implementation of the geometrical route,54 three atom centers are chosen on both binding counterparts, constructing a local frame of reference. The orientation of the ligand with respect to the receptor is then defined by the three Euler angles Θ, Φ, Ψ, and the position of the ligand with respect to the receptor is defined by the polar angles θ and ϕ. The ligand is additionally restrained in the average conformation it adopts when bound to its receptor with the application of an RMSD restraint. The binding free energy is then quantified by means of a series of sequential PMF calculations on the above CVs. In each PMF calculation, the only restraints present are those that have been added beforehand. The final PMF calculation involves the physical separation of the two binding partners along the Euclidean distance r between their centers of mass and is carried out in the presence of all restraints. Simulations without such restraints have been reported to fail to converge and to yield binding free energies inconsistent with experimental data.62,65,69 The geometrical route has been automated with quaternion-based angle restraints67 as CVs in the NAMD70,71 and GROMACS72 MD engines. Additional variations of the framework have also been introduced, with various implementations of RMSD restraints applied on both receptor and ligand in the bound and unbound states.62,62,65,69 The protocol has so far been successfully used in calculating the binding free energy of a variety of protein–protein complexes, in good agreement with experimental data,54,62,64,65,67,73−76 including a homodimeric α-helical complex.69 An alternative set of orientational and positional restraints has been proposed by Boresch et al.77 in the context of small molecule-protein binding free energy calculations. Boresch restraints are constructed by selecting three anchor points (atoms or groups of atoms) on the receptor and three on the ligand. The restraints correspond to the external degrees of freedom of the ligand, and consist of a distance r, two angles θA, θB and three dihedrals ϕA, ϕB, ϕC. The Boresch angles and dihedrals play the same role as the Euler and polar angles used in the geometrical route, but are easier to implement in other MD software, such as OpenMM.78 Numerous techniques having been developed to facilitate the automated selection of anchor points.79−85 To the best of our knowledge, Boresch restraints have not been used so far in binding free energy calculations via a geometrical route. We decided to employ the Boresch angles and dihedrals instead of the Euler and polar angles, since no quaternion implementation is available in OpenMM to date. In principle, the binding free energy should be independent of the type of restraints, the atom centers selected for the construction of the restraints, or the values of the force constants,64,77,86 provided stable restraints that have been appropriately selected.87 In the present work, we combine well-tempered metadynamics (WT-metaD)88 with Boresch restraints77 in OpenMM78 to explore the oligomerization and topology preferences of de novo designed coiled coils. The overall pipeline is summarized in Figure 1. We demonstrate the applicability of our protocol by predicting: the topology (parallel vs antiparallel) preferences of CC-Di, CC-Tri and apCC-Di, the oligomerization state preferences of CC-Di, CC-Tri and CC-Tet, and the pH switching behavior of the CC-Hex*-L24E system, which forms a parallel hexamer at low pH and an antiparallel tetramer at high pH (Figure 2).29,33,89 We also show that employing WT-metaD88 and funnel metadynamics90 in the absence of orientational and positional restraints fails to yield reliable free energy estimates. Overall our results demonstrate the potential of path-based MD methods to act as a late stage filter in multistate protein design.
What the sources say
- Supportedcites [54] source
Split into 2 atoms — 2 confirmed, 0 partially supported, 0 disputed, 0 misattributed, 0 unverifiable. Expand the claim to see per-atom verdicts.
- Partly supportedcites [63] sourceExperimental — accuracy not yet measured
Split into 2 atoms — 1 confirmed, 1 partially supported, 0 disputed, 0 misattributed, 0 unverifiable. Expand the claim to see per-atom verdicts.
- Supportedcites [64] source
Split into 2 atoms — 2 confirmed, 0 partially supported, 0 disputed, 0 misattributed, 0 unverifiable. Expand the claim to see per-atom verdicts.
- Not checked — no full text of the sourcecites [65] source
plainstates a cause- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Supported
56 more claims
Create a free account to see all 158 claims and to verify the 30 references still open.
- Probably not a substantial claim. 31
- It may state two separate claims as one. 68
- The quote only partly states this claim. 2
Citations
Cites
Abraham, M. J., Murtola, T., Schulz, R., Páll, S., Smith, J. C., Hess, B., & Lindahl, E. (2015) · SoftwareX · doi:10.1016/j.softx.2015.06.001 · Cited by 27,190
Scalable molecular dynamics with NAMD
Phillips, J. C., Braun, R., Wang, W., Gumbart, J., Tajkhorshid, E., Villa, E., Chipot, C., Skeel, R. D., Kalé, L., & Schulten, K. (2005) · Journal of Computational Chemistry · doi:10.1002/jcc.20289 · Cited by 16,914 · cited 1×
“62,65,69 The geometrical route has been automated with quaternion-based angle restraints 67 as CVs in the NAMD 70,71 and GROMACS 72 MD engines.”
Kollman, P. A., Massova, I., Reyes, C., Kuhn, B., Huo, S., Chong, L., Lee, M., Lee, T., Duan, Y., Wang, W., et al. (2000) · Accounts of Chemical Research · doi:10.1021/ar000033j · Cited by 4,978
Well-Tempered Metadynamics: A Smoothly Converging and Tunable Free-Energy Method
Barducci, A., Bussi, G., & Parrinello, M. (2008) · Physical Review Letters · doi:10.1103/physrevlett.100.020603 · Cited by 3,184 · cited 6×
“Initial WT-metaD simulations of the coiled coil dimers CC-Di and apCC-Di were run in the presence of only the helical ϕ , ψ restraints for 1 μ s with three independent replicates, with the same starting conformation but different starting velocities.”
InfluentialOpenMM 7: Rapid development of high performance algorithms for molecular dynamics
Eastman, P., Swails, J., Chodera, J. D., McGibbon, R. T., Zhao, Y., Beauchamp, K. A., Wang, L.-P., Simmonett, A. C., Harrigan, M. P., Stern, C. D., et al. (2017) · PLOS Computational Biology · doi:10.1371/journal.pcbi.1005659 · Cited by 2,748
Onufriev, A., Bashford, D., & Case, D. A. (2004) · Proteins: Structure, Function, and Bioinformatics · doi:10.1002/prot.20033 · Cited by 2,507
The packing of α-helices: simple coiled-coils
Crick, F. H. C. (1953) · Acta Crystallographica · doi:10.1107/s0365110x53001964 · Cited by 1,578 · cited 2×
“3 This distinguishes coiled coils from other helical bundles, which are characterized by less intimate packing.”
A Switch Between Two-, Three-, and Four-stranded Coiled Coils in GCN4 Leucine Zipper Mutants
Harbury, P. B., Zhang, T., Kim, P. S., & Alber, T. (1993) · Science · doi:10.1126/science.8248779 · Cited by 1,490 · cited 1×
“8,9 Further helices can be recruited to the assembly via the expansion of the hydrophobic interface, achieved by introducing hydrophobic residues at the e and g positions.”
Wang, L., Wu, Y., Deng, Y., Kim, B., Pierce, L., Krilov, G., Lupyan, D., Robinson, S., Dahlgren, M. K., Greenwood, J., et al. (2015) · Journal of the American Chemical Society · doi:10.1021/ja512751q · Cited by 1,313
Using collective variables to drive molecular dynamics simulations
Fiorin, G., Klein, M. L., & Hénin, J. (2013) · Molecular Physics · doi:10.1080/00268976.2013.813594 · Cited by 1,053
Cited by
Sequence Prediction, Structural Modelling and the Challenges of Plasticity in Coiled Coils
Wood, C. W., Rhys, G. G., & Notari, E. (2026) · Sub-cellular biochemistry/Subcellular biochemistry · doi:10.1007/978-3-032-05273-5_1
Self-citationNifosì, R., & Bellucci, L. (2026) · Journal of Chemical Information and Modeling · doi:10.1021/acs.jcim.5c02565
Tian, L., Tian, L., (14984), X. L., & Wang, C. (2026) · European Journal of Medicinal Chemistry · doi:10.1016/j.ejmech.2026.119042
Metadata
- Authors
- Notari, E., Wood, C. W., & Michel, J.
- Affiliations
- University of Edinburgh (GB)
- Corresponding author
- Michel, Julien
- Venue
- Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation
- Publisher
- American Chemical Society (ACS)
- Published
- 2025-03-05
- Volume
- 21
- Issue
- 6
- Pages
- 3260-3276
- ISSN
- 1549-9618 (ISSN-L)
- 1549-9626
- PMC
- PMC11948332
- OpenAlex
- W4408219584
- Semantic Scholar
- 90a58d4ddfa3fba05b6d98eaaa3eb4671ad7664d
- Cited by
- 4
- References
- 133
- Citations by year
- 2026: 4
- FWCI
- 1.19
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- hybrid
- doi.org
- Licence
- Locations
- Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation (publishedVersion, cc-by)
- Europe PMC (PubMed Central) (publishedVersion, cc-by)
- PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
- PubMed (publishedVersion)
- Edinburgh Research Explorer (University of Edinburgh) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
- Funders
- Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (2664327, BB/X003027/1)
- Topics
- Life Sciences › Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology › Molecular Biology › Protein Structure and Dynamics
- Physical Sciences › Chemistry › Physical and Theoretical Chemistry › Advanced Physical and Chemical Molecular Interactions
- Physical Sciences › Chemistry › Organic Chemistry › Chemical Synthesis and Analysis
- Keywords
- coiled coil, protein design, metadynamics, conformational restraints, oligomeric state, binding free energy, protein-protein complex, protein complexes
- MeSH terms
- Hydrogen-Ion Concentration, Protein Conformation, Proteins, Thermodynamics, Protein Multimerization, Molecular Dynamics Simulation
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
The claim verdicts this report counts are experimental: their accuracy is not yet measured.
A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-10-10, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).
A second model labelled each claim on 2026-10-10 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).
Cited sources are checked with a language model’s help (gpt-6-sol and qwen3.8-omni-flash).
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.