Toward the delineation of therapeutic change principles

Abstract

Abstract There is a growing discontent among therapists of varying orientations. Psychoanalytic, behavioral, and humanistically oriented clinicians are starting to raise serious questions about the limits of their respective approaches and are becoming more open to contributions from other paradigms. This article documents this trend within the field, which resembles a Kuhnian-type crisis, noting some of the political, economic, and social forces apt to affect our likelihood of ever reaching a consensus within the field and presenting an approach to the delineation and study of commonalities across various orientations.

Cites (55)

1. <i>The Structure of Scientific Revolutions</i>
   Kuhn, Thomas S., Schlegel, Richard · 1963 · Physics Today
2. Principles of behavior modification
   Albert Bandura · 1969 · Medical Entomology and Zoology
3. Client-Centered Therapy
   John O. Meany, Carl Ransom Rogers, Elaine Dorfman, Thomas Gordon, Nicholas Hobbes · 1951 · The American Catholic Sociological Review
4. Social learning and clinical psychology.
   Julian B. Rotter · 1954 · Prentice-Hall, Inc eBooks
5. Psychotherapy by reciprocal inhibition
   Joseph Wolpe · 1968 · Pavlovian Journal of Biological Science
6. HUMAN SEXUAL INADEQUACY
   1971 · The Medical Journal of Australia
7. The practice of behavior therapy
   Joseph Wolpe · 1969
8. Systems of psychotherapy a transtheoretical analysis
   James O. Prochaska, John C. Norcross · 2010
9. Comparative Studies of Psychotherapies: Is It True That "Everyone Has Won and All Must Have Prizes"?
   Luborsky, Lester · 1975 · Archives of General Psychiatry
10. Strategies of psychotherapy.
    Jay Haley · 1963 · Grune & Stratton eBooks
11. Strategy of outcome research in psychotherapy.
    Gordon L. Paul · 1967 · Journal of Consulting Psychology
12. Behavior Therapy and Beyond
    Neil B. Edwards · 1972 · Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry
13. The psychology of science: a reconnaissance
    Abraham H. Maslow · 1966 · CERN Document Server (European Organization for Nuclear Research)
14. Clinical Behavior Therapy
    Marvin R. Goldfried, Gerald C. Davison · 1976 · Medical Entomology and Zoology
15. Premature Ejaculation
    James H. Semans · 1956 · Southern Medical Journal
16. The Forty-Nine Percent Majority: The Male Sex Role
    Jack W. Sattel, Deborah S. David, Robert Brannon · 1978 · Teaching Sociology
17. The practice of behavior therapy, 2nd ed.
    Joseph Wolpe · 1973
18. Changing Frontiers in the Science of Psychotherapy
    Irving Babbitt · 2017 · Routledge eBooks
19. Clinical psychologists in the 1970s.
    Sol L. Garfield, Richard M. Kurtz · 1976 · American Psychologist
20. Effects of self-monitoring on normal smoking behavior.
    Richard M. McFall · 1970 · Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
21. Critique and reformulation of "learning-theory" approaches to psychotherapy and neurosis.
    Louis Breger, James Lafayette McGaugh · 1965 · Psychological Bulletin
22. Problems of Psychoanalytic Technique
    Otto Fenichel · 1938 · The Psychoanalytic Quarterly
23. Psychoanalysis and Behavior Therapy
    Paul L. Wachtel · 1977
24. Processes of fear reduction in systematic desensitization: animal studies.
    G. Wilson, Gerald C. Davison · 1971 · Psychological bulletin
25. Modern Clinical Psychology
    Sheldon J. Korchin · 1976
26. Behavior therapy: Observations and reflections.
    Marjorie H. Klein, Allen T. Dittman, Morris B. Parloff · 1969 · Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
27. Can psychotherapy research guide the policymaker? A little knowledge may be a dangerous thing.
    Morris B. Parloff · 1979 · American Psychologist
28. The end of ideology in behavior modification.
    Perry London · 1972 · American Psychologist
29. Encounter: group processes for interpersonal growth
    Gerard Egan · 1970 · Brooks/Cole Pub. Co. eBooks
30. Clinical Prediction in Psychotherapy
    Leonard Horwitz · 1974 · Medical Entomology and Zoology
31. Misunderstandings of the self
    Victor C. Raimy · 1975 · Jossey-Bass Publishers eBooks
32. What makes behavior change possible
    Arthur Burton · 1976 · Brunner/Mazel eBooks
33. Has behavior therapy outlived its usefulness?
    Arnold A. Lazarus · 1977 · American Psychologist
34. Psychoanalysis and Behavior Therapy
    Lee Birk, Word W. BRINKLEY-BIRK · 1974 · American Journal of Psychiatry
35. How People Change
    Allen Wheelis · 1975 · Medical Entomology and Zoology
36. Psychodynamic Behavior Therapy
    Ben W. Feather · 1972 · Archives of General Psychiatry
37. Dynamic Psychotherapy and Behavior Therapy
    Judd Marmor · 1971 · Archives of General Psychiatry
38. Transfer during systematic desensitization therapy
    W. Stewart Agras · 1967 · Behaviour Research and Therapy
39. Face to Face: The Small-Group Experience and Interpersonal Growth
    Gerard Egan · 1973 · Medical Entomology and Zoology
40. Psychotherapy Today or Where Do We Go From Here?
    Carl Ransom Rogers · 1963 · American Journal of Psychotherapy
41. What Does It Mean to Be a Behavior Therapist?
    Carl E. Thoresen, Thomas J. Coates · 1978 · The Counseling Psychologist
42. The idealization of insight.
    S A Appelbaum · 1975 · PubMed
43. Learning-based client-centered therapy
    David G. Martin · 1972
44. The Unconscious Fantasy as Therapeutic Agent in Psychoanalytic Treatment
    Lloyd H. Silverman · 1979 · Journal of the American Academy of Psychoanalysis
45. The future and the past in the behaviorism-humanism dialogue.
    Leonard Krasner · 1978 · American Psychologist
46. Some psychoanalytic considerations of non-psychoanalytic therapies: On the possibility of integration treatment approaches and related issues.
    Lloyd H. Silverman · 1974 · Psychotherapy
47. Out in inner space : a psychoanalyst explores the new therapies
    Stephen A. Appelbaum · 1979 · Anchor Press/Doubleday eBooks
48. A Description of the Erhard Seminars Training in the Terms of Behavior Analysis
    Donald M. Baer, Stephanie B. Stolz · 1978
49. THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN BEHAVIORAL AND CONVENTIONAL PSYCHOLOGY
    Charles B. Ferster · 1974 · The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease
50. Behavior modification in education
    Carl E. Thoresen, Herman G. Richey · 1973 · Medical Entomology and Zoology
51. Humanism and Behaviorism: Toward New Syntheses
    David F. Ricks, Abraham H. Wandersman, Paul J. Poppen · 1976 · Elsevier eBooks
52. Toward a general concept of the therapeutic process.
    P A Dewald · 1976 · PubMed
53. Concurrent Psychotherapy and Behavior Therapy
    Robert Taylor Segraves, Robert Craft Smith · 1980 · Springer eBooks
54. Appropriate Expression Training: Humanistic Behavior Therapy
    Alan J. Goldstein · 1976 · Elsevier eBooks
55. New perspectives for psychoanalytic psychotherapy.
    Leonard Horwitz · 1976 · PubMed

Cited by (23)

1. In search of how people change: Applications to addictive behaviors.
   Prochaska, James O., DiClemente, Carlo C., Norcross, John C. · 1992 · American Psychologist
2. Transtheoretical therapy: Toward a more integrative model of change.
   Prochaska, James O., DiClemente, Carlo C. · 1982 · Psychotherapy: Theory, Research &amp; Practice
3. Toward a Comprehensive Model of Change
   Prochaska, James O., Diclemente, Carlo C. · 1986 · Treating Addictive Behaviors
4. Are patient expectations still relevant for psychotherapy process and outcome
   Greenberg, Roger P., Constantino, Michael J., Bruce, Noah · 2006 · Clinical Psychology Review
5. Manual-based treatments: The clinical application of research findings
   Wilson, G.Terence · 1996 · Behaviour Research and Therapy
6. A transdiagnostic minority stress treatment approach for gay and bisexual men's syndemic health conditions
   Pachankis, John E. · 2015 · Archives of Sexual Behavior
7. Research on the alliance: Knowledge in search of a theory
   Horvath, Adam O. · 2018 · Psychotherapy Research
8. The role of relationship and technique in therapeutic change
   Goldfried, Marvin R., Davila, Joanne · 2005 · Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, Practice, Training
9. Psychotherapy, psychopathology, research and practice: Pathways of connections and integration
   Castonguay, Louis G. · 2011 · Psychotherapy Research
10. Group Cognitive Behavioural Therapy for Depression Outcomes Predicted by Willingness to Engage in Homework, Compliance with Homework, and Cognitive Restructuring Skill Acquisition
    Neimeyer, Robert A., Kazantzis, Nikolaos, Kassler, Dina M., Baker, Kurt D., Fletcher, Richard · 2008 · Cognitive Behaviour Therapy
11. Waiting for a digital therapist: three challenges on the path to psychotherapy delivered by artificial intelligence
    Grodniewicz, J. P., Hohol, Mateusz · 2023 · Frontiers in Psychiatry
12. Psychotherapy and social support.
    Barker, Chris, Pistrang, Nancy · 2002 · Clinical Psychology Review
13. Research strategies to discern active psychological therapy components: A scoping review
    Leijten, Patty, Weisz, John R., Gardner, Frances · 2021 · Clinical Psychological Science
14. Predicting personalized process-outcome associations in psychotherapy using machine learning approaches-A demonstration.
    Rubel, Julian A., Zilcha-Mano, Sigal, Giesemann, Julia, Prinz, Jessica, Lutz, Wolfgang · 2020 · Psychotherapy Research
15. Mechanisms, determinants and processes of change in the modification of drinking behavior
    DiClemente, Carlo C. · 2007 · Alcoholism Clinical and Experimental Research
16. Common and specific treatment mechanisms in psychosocial pain interventions: The need for a new research agenda
    Thorn, Beverly E., Burns, John W. · 2011 · Pain
17. Feasibility of an Emotion Regulation Intervention to Improve Mental Health and Reduce HIV Transmission Risk Behaviors for HIV-Positive Gay and Bisexual Men with Sexual Compulsivity
    Parsons, Jeffrey T., Rendina, H. Jonathon, Moody, Raymond L., Gurung, Sitaji, Starks, Tyrel J., Pachankis, John E. · 2017 · AIDS and Behavior
18. Developing an Online Health Intervention for Young Gay and Bisexual Men
    Pachankis, John E., Lelutiu-Weinberger, Corina, Golub, Sarit A., Parsons, Jeffrey T. · 2013 · AIDS and Behavior
19. Intervention strategies and clinical process in transdiagnostic cognitive–behavioral therapy.
    Boswell, James F. · 2013 · Psychotherapy
20. Searching for therapy change principles: Are we there yet?
    Goldfried, Marvin R. · 2009 · Applied and Preventive Psychology
21. The influence of expectancy persuasion techniques on socially anxious analogue patients' treatment beliefs and therapeutic actions
    Ametrano, Rebecca M., Constantino, Michael J., Nalven, Tessa · 2017 · International Journal of Cognitive Therapy
22. The relative association between individual difference variables and general psychotherapy outcome expectation in socially anxious individuals†
    Constantino, Michael J., Coyne, Alice E., McVicar, Erin L., Ametrano, Rebecca M. · 2017 · Psychotherapy Research
23. WHAT HAS PSYCHOTHERAPY INHERITED FROM CARL ROGERS?
    Goldfried, Marvin R. · 2007 · Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, Practice, Training

Related (10)

1. Electoral Politics and Social Change in the Contemporary Philippines: A Mixture of Change and Continuity
   박승우 · 2007 · The Southeast Asian Review
2. INDIVIDUAL CHANGE IN THE MIDST OF SOCIAL AND POLITICAL CHANGE
   Joel Samuel Migdal · 2001 · Cambridge University Press eBooks
3. The Revolutionary Process in Mexico: Essays on Political and Social Change, 1880-1940:The Revolutionary Process in Mexico: Essays on Political and Social Change, 1880-1940.
   Richard A. Bradley · 1992 · Latin American Anthropology Review
4. A Consideration of the Development and Change of World Social Parties in the Post-Cold War Era
   Zhong We · 2010 · Beijing Xingzheng Xueyuan xuebao
5. Social change in post-independence India
   A. K. Lal, Sohail Ahmad · 2001 · Rawat Publications eBooks
6. Political Development and Social Change.
   Robert T. Daland, Jason L. Finkle, Richard W. Gable · 1967 · Social Forces
7. Turkish economic, social, and political change : the development of a more prosperous and open society
   Edwin J. Cohn · 1970 · Medical Entomology and Zoology
8. Political Engineering and Social Change: A Case Study of Bukoba District, Tanzania
   Göran Hydén · 1977 · Springer eBooks
9. Political Development and Social Change in Libya
   Ann Williams · 1981 · International Affairs
10. Revolution or Evolution is the Inevitable Change in Bulgaria
    Venelin Krastev Terziev, Marin Petrov Georgiev, Denis B. Solovev · 2021 · Smart innovation, systems and technologies