Do logistic regression and signal detection identify different subgroups at risk? Implications for the design of tailored interventions.

Kiernan, Michaela, Anonymous, Winkleby, Marilyn A., King, Abby C., Taylor, C. Barr·2001·Psychological Methods

Abstract

Identifying subgroups of high-risk individuals can lead to the development of tailored interventions for those subgroups. This study compared two multivariate statistical methods (logistic regression and signal detection) and evaluated their ability to identify subgroups at risk. The methods identified similar risk predictors and had similar predictive accuracy in exploratory and validation samples. However, the 2 methods did not classify individuals into the same subgroups. Within subgroups, logistic regression identified individuals that were homogeneous in outcome but heterogeneous in risk predictors. In contrast, signal detection identified individuals that were homogeneous in both outcome and risk predictors. Because of the ability to identify homogeneous subgroups, signal detection may be more useful than logistic regression for designing distinct tailored interventions for subgroups of high-risk individuals.

Cites (9)

  1. Overweight and obesity in the United States: prevalence and trends, 1960–1994
    Flegal, KM, Carroll, MD, Kuczmarski, RJ, Johnson, CL · 1998 · International Journal of Obesity
  2. Coming to terms with the terms of risk
    Kraemer, Helena Chmura · 1997 · Archives of General Psychiatry
  3. Clinical Prediction Rules: Applications and Methodological Standards
    Wasson, John H., Sox, Harold C., Neff, Raymond K., Goldman, Lee · 1985 · New England Journal of Medicine
  4. Analysis and interpretation of treatment effects in subgroups of patients in randomized clinical trials
    Yusuf, Salim · 1991 · JAMA: The Journal of the American Medical Association
  5. Executive Summary of the Clinical Guidelines on the Identification, Evaluation, and Treatment of Overweight and Obesity in Adults
    1998 · Archives of Internal Medicine
  6. Physical Fitness as a Predictor of Cardiovascular Mortality in Asymptomatic North American Men
    Ekelund, Lars-Göran, Haskell, William L., Johnson, Jeffrey L., Whaley, Fredrick S., Criqui, Michael H., Sheps, David S., The Lipid Research Clinics Mortality Follow-up Study · 1988 · New England Journal of Medicine
  7. Group- vs Home-Based Exercise Training in Healthy Older Men and Women: A Community-Based Clinical Trial
    King, Abby C. · 1991 · JAMA
  8. Can we identify who will adhere to long-term physical activity? Signal detection methodology as a potential aid to clinical decision making.
    King, Abby C., Kiernan, Michaela, Oman, Roy F., Kraemer, Helena C., Hull, Mary, Ahn, David · 1997 · Health Psychology
  9. The Stanford Nutrition Action Program: a dietary fat intervention for low-literacy adults.
    Howard-Pitney, B, Winkleby, M A, Albright, C L, Bruce, B, Fortmann, S P · 1997 · American Journal of Public Health

Show all 9 references

Cited by (12)

  1. A review of psychosocial pre‐treatment predictors of weight control
    Teixeira, P. J., Going, S. B., Sardinha, L. B., Lohman, T. G. · 2005 · Obesity Reviews
  2. Family environments, adrenarche and sexual maturation: a longitudinal test of a life history model
    Ellis, Bruce J, Essex, Marilyn J · 2007 · Child Development
  3. Predictors of the Incident Metabolic Syndrome in Adults
    Palaniappan, Latha, Carnethon, Mercedes R., Wang, Yun, Hanley, Anthony J.G., Fortmann, Stephen P., Haffner, Stephen M., Wagenknecht, Lynne · 2004 · Diabetes Care
  4. Which treatment for whom for ADHD? Moderators of treatment response in the MTA.
    Owens, Elizabeth B., Hinshaw, Stephen P., Kraemer, Helen C., Arnold, L. Eugene, Abikoff, Howard B., Cantwell, Dennis P., Conners, C. Keith, Elliott, Glen, Greenhill, Laurence L., Hechtman, Lily et al. · 2003 · Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
  5. What variables are associated with successful weight loss outcomes for bariatric surgery after 1 year?
    Robinson, Athena H., Adler, Sarah, Stevens, Helen B., Darcy, Alison M., Morton, John M., Safer, Debra L. · 2014 · Surgery for Obesity and Related Diseases

See all 152

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Do logistic regression and signal detection identify different subgroups at risk? Implications for the design of tailored interventions. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1037//1082-989x.6.1.35
The paper
Kiernan, M., Anonymous, Winkleby, M. A., King, A. C., & Taylor, C. B. (2001). Do logistic regression and signal detection identify different subgroups at risk? Implications for the design of tailored interventions. Psychological Methods. https://doi.org/10.1037//1082-989x.6.1.35

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.