Cranial Modularity Shifts during Mammalian Evolution
The DOI matches its Crossref record; 56 of the 56 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Abstract
The mammalian skull has been studied as several separate functional components for decades, but the study of modularity is a more recent, integrative approach toward quantitative examination of independent subsets of highly correlated traits, or modules. Although most studies of modularity focus on developmental and genetic systems, phenotypic modules have been noted in many diverse morphological structures. However, few studies have provided empirical data for comparing modules across higher taxonomic levels, limiting the ability to assess the broader evolutionary significance of modularity. This study uses 18-32 three-dimensional cranial landmarks to analyze phenotypic modularity in 106 mammalian species and demonstrates that cranial modularity is generally conserved in the evolution of therian mammals (marsupials and placentals) but differs between therians and monotremes, the two extant subclasses of Mammalia. Within therians, cluster analyses identify six distinct modules, but only three modules display significant integration in all species. Monotremes display only two highly integrated modules. Specific hypotheses of functional and developmental influences on cranial bones were tested. Theoretical correlation matrices for bones were constructed on the basis of shared function, tissue origin, or mode of ossification, and all three of these models are significantly correlated with observed correlation matrices for the mammalian cranium.
Overview
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
Claims other papers make about this one
Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?
In the citing paper
“Together, these findings suggest that strong within-module trait correlations, related to developmental origin, constrain both the rate of evolution and the potential for the evolution of high diversity in some avian cranial modules, as in mammals (23).”
From Developmental origins of mosaic evolution in the avian cranium (2018) · cites this paper as [23]
In the citing paper
“This mirrors the finding that, in mammals, anatomical modules with high developmental complexity have low within-module integration (23).”
From Developmental origins of mosaic evolution in the avian cranium (2018) · cites this paper as [23]
Citations
Cites
American Journal of Physical Anthropology
(2006) · American Journal of Physical Anthropology · doi:10.1002/(issn)1096-8644 · Cited by 2,700
Vertebrate Paleontology and Evolution
Ostrom, J. H., & Carroll, R. L. (1988) · PALAIOS · doi:10.2307/3514548 · Cited by 1,665 · cited 1×
“Second, the fossil record of mammals is sufficiently complete for testing hypotheses of morphological evolution and for incorporating morphologies not represented in extant taxa (Carroll 1988).”
BackgroundThe triple origin of skull in higher vertebrates: a study in quail-chick chimeras
Couly, G. F., Coltey, P. M., & Douarin, N. M. L. (1993) · Development · doi:10.1242/dev.117.2.409 · Cited by 1,023
Modularity in development and evolution
Schlosser, G., & Thieffry, D. (2000) · BioEssays · doi:10.1002/1521-1878(200011)22:11<1043::aid-bies11>3.0.co;2-c · Cited by 891 · cited 1×
“…pathways, novelty, life-history strategies, and macroevolutionary trends (Cheverud 1982, 1996a, 1996b; Cheverud et al. 1983, 1991, 1997, 2004; Wagner 1995, 1996; Klingenberg and Leamy 2001; Klingenberg et al. 2001a, 2004; Ehrich et al. 2003; Pigliucci and Preston 2004; Schlosser and Wagner 2004).”
BackgroundPHENOTYPIC, GENETIC, AND ENVIRONMENTAL MORPHOLOGICAL INTEGRATION IN THE CRANIUM
Cheverud, J. M. (1982) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/j.1558-5646.1982.tb05070.x · Cited by 856 · cited 4×
“…2000, 2004; Klingenberg and Leamy 2001; Klingenberg et al. 2001a, 2003; Cheverud 2004; Klingenberg 2004; Polly 2005), and the mammalian skull (Cheverud 1982, 1988, 1989, 1995, 1996a, 1996b; Cheverud et al. 1983; Zelditch 1988; Zelditch and Carmichael 1989a, 1989b; Steppan 1997a, 1997b;…”
BackgroundInfluentialHomologues, Natural Kinds and the Evolution of Modularity
WAGNER, G. P. (1996) · American Zoologist · doi:10.1093/icb/36.1.36 · Cited by 805 · cited 1×
“…pathways, novelty, life-history strategies, and macroevolutionary trends (Cheverud 1982, 1996a, 1996b; Cheverud et al. 1983, 1991, 1997, 2004; Wagner 1995, 1996; Klingenberg and Leamy 2001; Klingenberg et al. 2001a, 2004; Ehrich et al. 2003; Pigliucci and Preston 2004; Schlosser and Wagner…”
BackgroundVertebrate paleontology and evolution
Guérin, C. (1988) · Geobios · doi:10.1016/s0016-6995(88)80066-4 · Cited by 777
Developmental Integration and the Evolution of Pleiotropy
CHEVERUD, J. M. (1996) · American Zoologist · doi:10.1093/icb/36.1.44 · Cited by 757 · cited 8×
“Cheverud (1996a) and Ackermann and Cheverud (2004b) have suggested that the weak integration of the cranial vault in primates may allow for the great expansion of the brain during primate evolution.”
BackgroundInfluentialQuantitative genetics and developmental constraints on evolution by selection
Cheverud, J. M. (1984) · Journal of Theoretical Biology · doi:10.1016/s0022-5193(84)80050-8 · Cited by 710 · cited 1×
“…al. 1983, 1997, 2004; Atchley 1993; Klingenberg and Leamy 2001; Klingenberg et al. 2001a, 2004) and between development and phenotypic integration (Cheverud 1984, 1996a; Zelditch 1988; Zelditch and Carmichael 1989a, 1989b; Atchley and Hall 1991; Atchley 1993; Klingenberg and Nijhout 1999;…”
BackgroundA MODEL FOR DEVELOPMENT AND EVOLUTION OF COMPLEX MORPHOLOGICAL STRUCTURES
ATCHLEY, W. R., & HALL, B. K. (1991) · Biological Reviews · doi:10.1111/j.1469-185x.1991.tb01138.x · Cited by 586 · cited 2×
“…et al. 2001a, 2004) and between development and phenotypic integration (Cheverud 1984, 1996a; Zelditch 1988; Zelditch and Carmichael 1989a, 1989b; Atchley and Hall 1991; Atchley 1993; Klingenberg and Nijhout 1999; Klingenberg and Zaklan 2000; Klingenberg et al. 2001b, 2003; Klingenberg 2002,…”
Background
Research works printed but not linked: 9
- 10.1002/(SICI)1096-8644(200004)111:4<489::AID-AJPA5>3.0.CO;2-U · DOI · Paper page
- Atchley W. R., Genetic and developmental aspects of variability in the mammalian mandible. Pages 207–247 in J
- Bolker J. A., 2000, American Zoologist, 40, 770
- Cheverud J. M., Modular pleiotropic effects of quantitative trait loci on morphological traits. Pages 132–153 in G
- Cheverud J. M., 1991, Journal of Craniofacial Genetics and Developmental Biology, 11, 122
- Gilbert B. M., Mammalian osteology
- 10.1111/j.1558-5646.1999.tb03772.x · DOI · Paper page
- 10.1534/genetics.166.4.1909 · doi:10.1534/genetics.166.4.1909 · Paper page
- 10.1002/1096-8644(2000)43:31+<117::AID-AJPA5>3.3.CO;2-9 · doi:10.1002/1096-8644(2000)43:31+<117::aid-ajpa5>3.3.co;2-9
Cited by
Items 101–200 of 279
Pérez‐Barrales, R., Simón‐Porcar, V. I., Santos‐Gally, R., & Arroyo, J. (2014) · Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences · doi:10.1098/rstb.2013.0258 · Cited by 35
The evolution of ontogenetic allometric trajectories in mammalian domestication
Wilson, L. A. B. (2018) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/evo.13464 · Cited by 34
“This has been reported at the adult level (e.g., de Oliveira et al. 2009; Goswami 2006; Porto et al. 2009; Klingenberg 2013; Young et al. 2017) and is evident for some comparisons of postnatal ontogeny, such that ancestor to descendent modifications to ontogenetic trajectories are most commonly…”
BackgroundSelba, M. C., Oechtering, G. U., Heng, H. G., & DeLeon, V. B. (2019) · The Anatomical Record · doi:10.1002/ar.24184 · Cited by 33
“In that case, those areas can be considered modules (Goswami, 2006; Mitteroecker and Bookstein, 2008; Drake, 2011).”
BackgroundSuzuki, T. K. (2013) · BMC Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1186/1471-2148-13-158 · Cited by 34
Spandrels and trait delimitation: No such thing as “architectural constraint”
Olson, M. E. (2019) · Evolution & Development · doi:10.1111/ede.12279 · Cited by 32
“…diversity, and which intraspecificmodule delimitations coincidewith those actually observed in across-species diversity (Adams & Collyer, 2009; Beltrao, Cagney, & Krogan, 2010; Drake & Klingenberg, 2010; Goswami, 2006; Goswami & Polly, 2010b; Hunt, 2007; Parsons, Márquez, & Albertson, 2012).”
BackgroundThe many faces of synapsid cranial allometry
Krone, I. W., Kammerer, C. F., & Angielczyk, K. D. (2019) · Paleobiology · doi:10.1017/pab.2019.26 · Cited by 32
“…geometric morphometric techniques to address questions of disparity and allometry within a variety of major tetrapod groups (e.g., Stayton 2005; Goswami 2006; Goswami and Polly 2010; Angielczyk and Ruta 2012; Bhullar et al. 2012; Brusatte et al. 2012; Foth and Rauhut 2013; Zelditch and…”
BackgroundJojić, V., Blagojević, J., & Vujošević, M. (2012) · Journal of Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1111/j.1420-9101.2012.02612.x · Cited by 36
“On the other hand, it could facilitate modifications of related traits (Wagner & Altenberg, 1996; Goswami, 2006).”
BackgroundConserved but flexible modularity in the zebrafish skull: implications for craniofacial evolvability
Parsons, K. J., Son, H., Crespel, A., Thambithurai, D., Killen, S. S., Harris, M. P., & Albertson, R. C. (2018) · Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences · doi:10.1098/rspb.2017.2671 · Cited by 33
Decoupled evolution of the cranium and mandible in carnivoran mammals
Law, C. J., Blackwell, E. A., Curtis, A. A., Dickinson, E., Hartstone‐Rose, A., & Santana, S. E. (2022) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/evo.14578 · Cited by 38
“Although previous studies identified patterns of evolutionary and developmental integration within skull components (Goswami 2006; Piras et al. 2014; Bardua et al. 2020; Conith et al. 2020; Michaud et al. 2020; Rhoda et al. 2020; Arbour et al. 2021), less is known about whether and how different…”
Morphometric Study of Phylogenetic and Ecologic Signals in Procyonid (Mammalia: Carnivora) Endocasts
Ahrens, H. E. (2014) · The Anatomical Record · doi:10.1002/ar.22996 · Cited by 34
Bärmann, E. V., & Sánchez-Villagra, M. R. (2011) · Journal of Mammalian Evolution · doi:10.1007/s10914-011-9176-8 · Cited by 30
“Minor changes were made in cases where the Marcot phylogeny was not well supported (within Cervidae and within Bovidae): we changed the topology to match the results of the more recent modelbased analyses by Gilbert et al. (2006) for Cervidae, and Bärmann (in review) for Bovidae.”
BackgroundResultThe evolution of orbit orientation and encephalization in the Carnivora (Mammalia)
Finarelli, J. A., & Goswami, A. (2009) · Journal of Anatomy · doi:10.1111/j.1469-7580.2009.01061.x · Cited by 30
“Significant correlations were observed between encephalization and orbit orientation; however, these were restricted to the families Felidae and Canidae.”
BackgroundMethodSelf-citationMorphology, Paleontology, and Placental Mammal Phylogeny
Asher, R. J., Geisler, J. H., & Sánchez-Villagra, M. R. (2008) · Systematic Biology · doi:10.1080/10635150802033022 · Cited by 28
“, 2006), and the consideration of modularity and possible nonindependence among characters (O’Keefe and Wagner 2001; Polly, 2005; Goswami, 2006) in character weighting and definition.”
BackgroundMethodNeaux, D. (2016) · American Journal of Physical Anthropology · doi:10.1002/ajpa.23163 · Cited by 31
Early bursts of disparity and the reorganization of character integration
Wagner, P. J. (2018) · Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences · doi:10.1098/rspb.2018.1604 · Cited by 30
Covariation in the skull modules of cats: the challenge of growing saber-like canines
Meloro, C., & Slater, G. J. (2012) · Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology · doi:10.1080/02724634.2012.649328 · Cited by 30
“…the skull as a discrete functional structure, however, whereas many recent studies support the idea that the vertebrate skull is the complex result of developmental and functional integration of different subunits called modules that may or may not covary with one another (Goswami, 2006a,b, 2007).”
BackgroundResultInfluentialdel Castillo, D. L., Viglino, M., Flores, D. A., & Cappozzo, H. L. (2016) · Journal of Morphology · doi:10.1002/jmor.20629 · Cited by 26
“This result is in general accordance to what other authors have found as a general trend for mammalian skulls (e.g., Goswami, 2006; Marroig et al., 2009; Goswami and Polly, 2010), although these authors used other modules than those proposed here.”
ResultGoswami, A., & Polly, P. D. (2010) · Cambridge University Press eBooks · doi:10.1017/cbo9781139193436.006 · Cited by 25
“Landmarks were distributed across the skull and are assigned to one of the six modules based on previous study of correlations (Goswami, 2006a).”
BackgroundMethodResultInfluentialSelf-citationCraniofacial growth and morphology among intersecting clinical categories
Knigge, R. P., Hardin, A. M., Middleton, K. M., McNulty, K. P., Oh, H. S., Valiathan, M., Duren, D. L., & Sherwood, R. J. (2022) · The Anatomical Record · doi:10.1002/ar.24870 · Cited by 30
“…et al., 2012; Marroig et al., 2003; Singh et al., 2012), whereas others have divided the craniofacial complex into smaller structural or functional units (Cheverud, 1982, 1995; Goswami, 2006a, 2006b; Gunz & Harvati, 2007; Harvati et al., 2011; Makedonska et al., 2012; Marroig et al., 2003).”
BackgroundThe contribution of developmental palaeontology to extensions of evolutionary theory
Wilson, L. A. B. (2011) · Acta Zoologica · doi:10.1111/j.1463-6395.2011.00539.x · Cited by 28
Benítez, H. A., Lemić, D., Bažok, R., Bravi, R., Buketa, M., & Püschel, T. A. (2014) · Zoologischer Anzeiger · doi:10.1016/j.jcz.2014.06.001 · Cited by 26
“…of modules through hypothesis testing is essential in the study and analysis of integration (Klingenberg and Zaklan, 2000; Klingenberg et al., 2001; Goswami, 2006; Drake and Klingenberg, 2010; Jamniczky and Hallgrímsson, 2011; MartinezAbadias et al., 2012; Klingenberg and Marugán-Lobon, 2013;…”
MethodAre more diverse parts of the mammalian skull more labile?
Linde‐Medina, M., Boughner, J. C., Santana, S. E., & Diogo, R. (2016) · Ecology and Evolution · doi:10.1002/ece3.2046 · Cited by 26
“However, for the most part, the authors found no significant difference in morphological disparity between cranial modules defined a priori (Goswami 2006) and randomly selected modules.”
Evolutionary selection and morphological integration in the vertebral column of modern humans
Arlegi, M., Couture, C., & Gómez‐Olivencia, A. (2019) · American Journal of Physical Anthropology · doi:10.1002/ajpa.23950 · Cited by 25
Morphological evolution in a time of phenomics
Goswami, A., & Clavel, J. (2025) · Paleobiology · doi:10.1017/pab.2024.35 · Cited by 28
“…in patterns of modularity are observed between large clades, with a high degree of conservation in pattern (if not in magnitude) within major vertebrate clades (Goswami 2006; Porto et al. 2009; Felice et al. 2019b; Watanabe et al. 2019; Bardua et al. 2020; Fabre et al. 2020; Navalón et al. 2020).”
Self-citationIvanović, A., & Arntzen, J. W. (2014) · Biological Journal of the Linnean Society · doi:10.1111/bij.12314 · Cited by 26
“…from mammals (Cheverud, 1982, 1989, 1995; Marroig & Cheverud, 2001; Nicola et al., 2003; Zelditch & Moscarella, 2004; Monteiro & Dos Reis, 2005; Goswami, 2006a, b; Cardini & Elton, 2008a, b; Hallgrímsson et al., 2009) and a few other vertebrate groups (amphibians: Ivanović & Kalezić, 2010;…”
Ferreira‐Cardoso, S., Billet, G., Gaubert, P., Delsuc, F., & Hautier, L. (2019) · Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society · doi:10.1093/zoolinnean/zlz096 · Cited by 28
“The differences in the ontogenetic allometric patterns between the two size–shape spaces (multivariate vs. PC1 of the predicted values) might also suggest strong cranial modularity (i.e. rostrum module; Goswami, 2006).”
BackgroundMethodBrocklehurst, N., & Benevento, G. L. (2020) · PeerJ · doi:10.7717/peerj.8744 · Cited by 26
“, 2014; Billet & Bardin, 2018), with many traits or regions forming integrated modules that change as a unit (Goswami, 2006; Goswami, 2007; Goswami & Polly, 2010).”
BackgroundInfluentialA comparison of metrics for quantifying cranial suture complexity
White, H., Clavel, J., Tucker, A. S., & Goswami, A. (2020) · Journal of The Royal Society Interface · doi:10.1098/rsif.2020.0476 · Cited by 24
Self-citationGrieco, T. M., & Rizk, O. T. (2010) · Journal of Morphology · doi:10.1002/jmor.10839 · Cited by 25
Timing of ontogenetic changes of two cranial regions in Sotalia guianensis (Delphinidae)
Sydney, N. V., Machado, F. A., & Hingst‐Zaher, E. (2012) · Mammalian Biology · doi:10.1016/j.mambio.2012.04.007 · Cited by 23
Cuthill, J. F. H. (2015) · Interface Focus · doi:10.1098/rsfs.2015.0049 · Cited by 24
Developmental origin underlies evolutionary rate variation across the placental skull
Goswami, A., Noirault, E., Coombs, E. J., Clavel, J., Fabre, A., Halliday, T. J. D., Churchill, M., Curtis, A. A., Watanabe, A., Simmons, N. B., et al. (2023) · Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences · doi:10.1098/rstb.2022.0083 · Cited by 22
“Numerous studies have quantified modularity and integration in the vertebrate cranium, assessing patterns, causes and consequences of its modular organization [25,28,33 – 42].”
BackgroundInfluentialSelf-citationBurns, M. D., Collyer, M. L., & Sidlauskas, B. L. (2022) · Evolution · doi:10.1093/evolut/qpac070 · Cited by 26
Similar rates of morphological evolution in domesticated and wild pigs and dogs
Geiger, M., & Sánchez-Villagra, M. R. (2018) · Frontiers in Zoology · doi:10.1186/s12983-018-0265-x · Cited by 22
“Second, the different linear skull dimensions are not independent from one another and parts of the skull function as non-independent, integrated modules [56, 57].”
BackgroundMultilevel assessment of the Lacertid lizard cranial modularity
Urošević, A., Ljubisavljević, K., & Ivanović, A. (2018) · Journal of Zoological Systematics & Evolutionary Research · doi:10.1111/jzs.12245 · Cited by 24
“The “mammalian morphometric hypothesis” (Sanger et al., 2011), which reflects cellular origins of the dorsal cranium and suggests facial and braincase (neurocranial) modules, was derived from extensive studies of mammalian skull modularity (Goswami, 2006a,b).”
BackgroundBenitez‐Vieyra, S., Pérez‐Alquicira, J., Sazatornil, F. D., Domínguez, C. A., Boege, K., Pérez‐Ishiwara, R., & Fornoni, J. (2019) · Journal of Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1111/jeb.13480 · Cited by 22
“Whereas patterns of trait association re‐ main conserved across some large clades (e.g. Andrade Machado, Gonçalves Zahn, & Marroig, 2018; Goswami, 2006; Goswami, Smaers, Soligo, & Polly, 2014), genetic correlations may change due to artificial selection in few generations (Delph, Steven, Anderson,…”
BackgroundMorphological consequences of artificial cranial deformation: Modularity and integration
Püschel, T. A., Friess, M., & Manríquez, G. (2020) · PLOS ONE · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0227362 · Cited by 22
Jamniczky, H. A., Harper, E. E., Garner, R., Cresko, W. A., Wainwright, P. C., Hallgrímsson, B., & Kimmel, C. B. (2013) · Biological Journal of the Linnean Society · doi:10.1111/bij.12203 · Cited by 26
“Promising foci of modularity research are head and jaw structures, including skull lever systems that function in jaw movement, as a result of the prominent role these structures play in acquiring resources in animals (Atchley & Hall, 1991; Albertson et al., 2005; Goswami, 2006; Tokita, Kiyoshi & Armstrong, 2007; Zeld…”
BackgroundOrr, D. J. A., Teeling, E. C., Puechmaille, S. J., & Finarelli, J. A. (2016) · Journal of Anatomy · doi:10.1111/joa.12510 · Cited by 21
“It has been argued (Pedersen, 1995, 1998; Santana & Lofgren, 2013) that these nasal domes constitute a novel mammalian cranial module (Goswami, 2006), whose evolution has been driven by the demands of nasal echolocation.”
BackgroundEvolution of the bovid cranium: morphological diversification under allometric constraint
Bibi, F., & Tyler, J. M. B. (2022) · Communications Biology · doi:10.1038/s42003-021-02877-6 · Cited by 23
Hanot, P., Bayarsaikhan, J., Guintard, C., Haruda, A. F., Mijiddorj, E., Schafberg, R., & Taylor, W. T. T. (2021) · BMC Ecology and Evolution · doi:10.1186/s12862-021-01907-5 · Cited by 24
“Goswami A, Watanabe A, Felice RN, Bardua C, Fabre A-C, Polly PD. Highdensity morphometric analysis of shape and integration: the good, the bad, and the not-really-a-problem.”
BackgroundMethodInfluentialLaurin, M. (2014) · Journal of Experimental Zoology Part B Molecular and Developmental Evolution · doi:10.1002/jez.b.22575 · Cited by 21
“Some, like clustering methods, have the drawback that linked elements in each cluster may exhibit similarity, but not necessarily covariation (Goswami, ‟06: 274).”
Integration of the mammalian shoulder girdle within populations and over evolutionary time
Sears, K. E., Bianchi, C., Powers, L. E., & Beck, A. L. (2013) · Journal of Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1111/jeb.12160 · Cited by 21
“…relatively few studies have compared patterns of morphological integration within and among species, and most of these have been restricted to the within-family and order levels (Marroig & Cheverud, 2001, 2005; Ackerman & Cheverud, 2004; Goswami, 2006; Kolbe et al., 2011; Sanger et al., 2012).”
BackgroundCovariation between the cranium and the cervical vertebrae in hominids
Arlegi, M., Pantoja‐Pérez, A., Couture, C., & Gómez‐Olivencia, A. (2021) · Journal of Human Evolution · doi:10.1016/j.jhevol.2021.103112 · Cited by 19
Morphological integration of the kinetic skull inNatrixsnakes
Andjelković, M., Tomović, L., & Ivanović, A. (2017) · Journal of Zoology · doi:10.1111/jzo.12477 · Cited by 22
Martín‐Serra, A., Nanova, O. G., Varón‐González, C., Ortega, G., & Figueirido, B. (2019) · Biology Letters · doi:10.1098/rsbl.2019.0406 · Cited by 18
Ferraz, T., Rossoni, D. M., Althoff, S. L., Pissinatti, A., Paixão‐Côrtes, V. R., Bortolini, M. C., González‐José, R., Marroig, G., Salzano, F. M., GONÇALVES, G. L., et al. (2018) · Scientific Reports · doi:10.1038/s41598-018-26225-7 · Cited by 17
Newton, A. H., Weisbecker, V., Pask, A. J., & Hipsley, C. A. (2021) · Communications Biology · doi:10.1038/s42003-020-01569-x · Cited by 17
Modular diversification of the locomotor system in damselfishes (Pomacentridae)
Aguilar‐Medrano, R., Frédérich, B., & Barber, P. H. (2016) · Journal of Morphology · doi:10.1002/jmor.20523 · Cited by 20
Biodiversity and evolution in the light of morphometrics: From patterns to processes
Laffont, R., Firmat, C., Alibert, P., David, B., Montuire, S., & Saucède, T. (2010) · Comptes Rendus Palevol · doi:10.1016/j.crpv.2010.10.004 · Cited by 23
Villmoare, B. A., Dunmore, C., Kilpatrick, S., Oertelt, N., Depew, M. J., & Fish, J. L. (2014) · Journal of Human Evolution · doi:10.1016/j.jhevol.2014.06.014 · Cited by 16
“Within primates and even across mammals, patterns of character co-variation are broadly conserved, suggesting that patterns of morphological integration in the skull are similar even in morphologically diverse species (Cheverud, 1996; Ackermann and Cheverud, 2000; Marroig and Cheverud, 2001; Gonzalez-Jose et al., 2004…”
BackgroundMultilevel analysis of integration and disparity in the mammalian skull
Sherratt, E., & Kraatz, B. (2023) · Evolution · doi:10.1093/evolut/qpad020 · Cited by 16
Pedomorphosis in the ancestry of marsupial mammals
White, H., Tucker, A. S., Fernández, V., Miguez, R. P., Hautier, L., Herrel, A., Urban, D. J., Sears, K. E., & Goswami, A. (2023) · Current Biology · doi:10.1016/j.cub.2023.04.009 · Cited by 20
Self-citationVerger, K. L., Hautier, L., Gerber, S., Bardin, J., Delsuc, F., Ruiz, L. R. G., Amson, E., & Billet, G. (2023) · Evolution · doi:10.1093/evolut/qpad214 · Cited by 19
Cranial Suture Closure Patterns in Sciuridae: Heterochrony and Modularity
Wilson, L. A. B. (2013) · Journal of Mammalian Evolution · doi:10.1007/s10914-013-9242-5 · Cited by 17
Functional modularity in lake-dwelling characin fishes of Mexico
Ornelas‐García, C. P., Bautista, A., Herder, F., & Doadrio, I. (2017) · PeerJ · doi:10.7717/peerj.3851 · Cited by 16
“…respect, skull modularity has been associated with ecological diversification processes not only in fish but also in other groups of vertebrates such as marsupials Ornelas-García et al. (2017), PeerJ, DOI 10.7717/peerj.3851 14/22 and lizards (Goswami, 2006; Goswami, 2007; Goswami & Polly, 2010).”
BackgroundInfluentialBlomquist, G. E. (2008) · American Journal of Physical Anthropology · doi:10.1002/ajpa.20963 · Cited by 19
“For example, Goswami’s (2007) study of ossification centers in the mammalian cranium failed to find any significant modules although cranial modularity is well documented by covariation in morphometric data (Cheverud, 1982; Goswami, 2006).”
Jeffery, N. S., Humphreys, C., & Manson, A. (2021) · The Anatomical Record · doi:10.1002/ar.24736 · Cited by 17
“…different length scales as well as between anatomical regions, individuals and species according to differences of phylogeny, development, function, and architectural conformity (see Goswami, 2006; Zollikofer, Bienvenu, & Ponce de Le on, 2017; Mitteroecker & Bookstein, 2008; Jeffery et al., 2021).”
BackgroundEvolution, conservatism and overlooked homologies of the mammalian skull
Koyabu, D. B. (2023) · Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences · doi:10.1098/rstb.2022.0081 · Cited by 19
How ubiquitous is adaptation? A critique of the epiphenomenist program
Valen, L. M. V. (2008) · Biology & Philosophy · doi:10.1007/s10539-008-9142-x · Cited by 16
“There is some divergence among therian mammals in the modularity of their skulls, but only a comparison with monotremes found nearly complete reorganization ( Goswami 2006 ).”
BackgroundPérez‐Claros, J. A., Arenas, J. M. J., & Palmqvist, P. (2015) · PLoS ONE · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0131055 · Cited by 17
Farina, S. C., Knope, M. L., Corn, K. A., Summers, A. P., & Bemis, W. E. (2019) · Integrative and Comparative Biology · doi:10.1093/icb/icz022 · Cited by 14
“Therefore, there is not always a clear relationship between evolutionary integration and functions of structures (Goswami 2006; Claverie and Patek 2013; Klingenberg and Marug an-Lob on 2013).”
Rutland, J. W., Delman, B. N., Bellaire, C. P., Napoli, J. G., Shuman, W. H., Rutland, E. A., Ranti, D. L., Margulies, I. G., Goel, P., Sayegh, F., et al. (2020) · Journal of Craniofacial Surgery · doi:10.1097/scs.0000000000006787 · Cited by 13
Palate Variation and Evolution in New World Leaf-Nosed and Old World Fruit Bats (Order Chiroptera)
Sorensen, D. W., Butkus, C. E., Cooper, L. N., Cretekos, C. J., Rasweiler, J. J., & Sears, K. E. (2014) · Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1007/s11692-014-9291-6 · Cited by 15
“These results are consistent with other studies that have found a relatively high degree of conservation of patterns of variation across mammalian crania and mandibles (Goswami 2006; Porto et al. 2009; Goswami et al. 2014).”
ResultBolfíková, B. Č., Evin, A., Knitlová, M., Loudová, M., Sztencel-Jabłonka, A., Bogdanowicz, W., & Hulva, P. (2020) · Animals · doi:10.3390/ani10101803 · Cited by 16
“As the function of the lower jaw connects mainly with feeding [47,52], in contrast to the cranium reflecting additional functions related to sensory organs and the brain [53,54], it is reasonable to ascribe respective patterns to evolutionary forces within the trophic niche.”
BackgroundPatterns and magnitudes of craniofacial covariation in extant cercopithecids
Monson, T. A. (2020) · The Anatomical Record · doi:10.1002/ar.24398 · Cited by 14
“The orbital region of the skull, although less discussed, has been recognized as an independent module in the generalized mammalian cranium (Goswami, 2006).”
BackgroundModularity in the trilobite head consistent with the hypothesized segmental origin of the eyes
Vargas-Parra, E. E., & Hopkins, M. J. (2022) · Evolution & Development · doi:10.1111/ede.12418 · Cited by 12
“The number and arrangement of modules are of interest here as they may indicate developmental or functional factors contributing to head organization (Goswami & Polly, 2010; Goswami, 2006).”
BackgroundDisentangling Mechanical and Sensory Modules in the Radiation of Noctilionoid Bats
Mutumi, G. L., Hall, R. P., Hedrick, B. P., Yohe, L. R., Sadier, A., Davies, K. T. J., Rossiter, S. J., Sears, K. E., Dávalos, L. M., & Dumont, E. R. (2023) · The American Naturalist · doi:10.1086/725368 · Cited by 14
“…correlation relative to their correlation with other modules, with some of these correlations conserved across mammals (Atchley and Hall 1991; Goswami 2006; Porto et al. 2009; Goswami and Polly 2010; Assis et al. 2016; Goswami and Finarelli 2016; Evans et al. 2017; Felice and Goswami 2017;…”
BackgroundAnderson, P. S. L., Smith, D. C., & Patek, S. N. (2016) · Evolution & Development · doi:10.1111/ede.12190 · Cited by 12
“This idea has led to a wide range of studies attempting to infer developmental linkages through the study of morphological integration and modularity (e.g., Klingenberg 2003; Goswami 2006; Zelditch et al. 2008).”
BackgroundChanging Modular Patterns in the Carnivoran Pelvic Girdle
Martín‐Serra, A., Figueirido, B., & Palmqvist, P. (2018) · Journal of Mammalian Evolution · doi:10.1007/s10914-018-9454-9 · Cited by 12
“However, while the modularity of the skull has been the object of several studies (e.g., see Goswami 2006a, b for mammals; Sanger et al. 2012 for lizards; Felice and Goswami 2017 for birds), the modularity of the pelvic girdle has been comparatively less studied.”
BackgroundBenítez, H. A., Püschel, T. A., & Suazo, M. J. (2022) · Biology · doi:10.3390/biology11040567 · Cited by 11
“, the modules), but is comparatively weak between these modules [3,5,6].”
BackgroundFunctional reorganisation of the cranial skeleton during the cynodont–mammaliaform transition
Lautenschlager, S., Fagan, M. J., Luo, Z., Bird, C. M., Gill, P. G., & Rayfield, E. J. (2023) · Communications Biology · doi:10.1038/s42003-023-04742-0 · Cited by 13
Building blocks of a fish head: Developmental and variational modularity in a complex system
Lehoux, C., & Cloutier, R. (2015) · Journal of Experimental Zoology Part B Molecular and Developmental Evolution · doi:10.1002/jez.b.22639 · Cited by 11
A 150-Year Conundrum: Cranial Robusticity and Its Bearing on the Origin of Aboriginal Australians
Curnoe, D. (2011) · International Journal of Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.4061/2011/632484 · Cited by 14
“Moreover, this pattern seems to characterise humans, chimpanzees, and gorillas [106, 120, 124, 125] and is known to be phylogenetically conserved in mammals [107, 126].”
BackgroundRoberts, A. S., Farina, S. C., Goforth, R. R., & Gidmark, N. J. (2018) · Zoology · doi:10.1016/j.zool.2018.06.006 · Cited by 11
Abadías, N. M. (2007) · Cited by 11
Stevens, R. D., & Guest, E. E. (2022) · Biological Journal of the Linnean Society · doi:10.1093/biolinnean/blac117 · Cited by 11
The Implications of Stratigraphic Compatibility for Character Integration among Fossil Taxa
Wagner, P. J., & Estabrook, G. F. (2015) · Systematic Biology · doi:10.1093/sysbio/syv040 · Cited by 11
“Examples of strong phylogenetic conservation of integration patterns also exist for chordates (e.g., Goswami 2006a, 2006b; Sears et al. 2007, 2011; Finarelli and Goswami 2009) and echinoderms (e.g., McKinney 1986; Kjaer and Thomsen 1999).”
BackgroundInfluentialFerreira‐Cardoso, S., Claude, J., Goswami, A., Delsuc, F., & Hautier, L. (2022) · BMC Ecology and Evolution · doi:10.1186/s12862-022-02030-9 · Cited by 13
“In fact, these eight architectures (III–X) are all variations of two previously proposed hypotheses [30, 31].”
BackgroundMethodResultInfluentialSelf-citationFGFR1 signaling is associated with the magnitude of morphological integration in human head shape
Hünemeier, T., Gómez‐Valdés, J., de Azevedo, S., Quinto‐Sánchez, M., Passaglia, L. M. P., Salzano, F. M., Sánchez‐Mejorada, G., Acuña-Alonzo, V., Martínez‐Abadías, N., Bortolini, M. C., et al. (2013) · American Journal of Human Biology · doi:10.1002/ajhb.22496 · Cited by 10
“…key determinants of evolvability since they facilitate rapid evolution due to canalization of pervasively integrated traits, as well as simultaneous independent response to selection avoiding “side-effects” (Griswold, 2006; Hallgr ımsson et al., 2009; Hansen and Houle, 2008; Raff and Sly, 2000).”
BackgroundLlambrich, S., González, R., Albaigès, J., Wouters, J., Marain, F., Himmelreich, U., Sharpe, J. A., Dierssen, M., Gsell, W., Martínez‐Abadías, N., et al. (2022) · Frontiers in Medicine · doi:10.3389/fmed.2022.815739 · Cited by 9
“This is in line with previous studies in mouse models for Apert and Crouzon syndromes (67), in which despite severe dysmorphologies, the correlation pattern between brain and skull is not altered, thus confirming the high stability of integration in the vertebrate head (7, 9, 12, 68).”
BackgroundResultFinlay, S., & Cooper, N. (2015) · PeerJ · doi:10.7717/peerj.927 · Cited by 11
Wilson, L. A. B., Hand, S. J., López‐Aguirre, C., Archer, M., Black, K. H., Beck, R. M. D., Armstrong, K. N., & Wroe, S. (2016) · Alcheringa An Australasian Journal of Palaeontology · doi:10.1080/03115518.2016.1196434 · Cited by 10
“…based on the analysis of landmark configurations (Bookstein 1991, Dryden & Mardia 1998, Adams et al. 2013), have been employed to quantify shape and size in a wide range of studies on mammals (e.g., Goswami 2006, Cardini et al. 2009, Drake & Klingenberg 2010, Wilson et al. 2011, Wilson 2013).”
Asymmetry drives modularity of the skull in the common dolphin (Delphinus delphis)
Churchill, M., Miguel, J., Beatty, B. L., Goswami, A., & Geisler, J. H. (2018) · Biological Journal of the Linnean Society · doi:10.1093/biolinnean/bly190 · Cited by 16
“This is in contrast to other modularity studies, which have employed five (Goswami, 2006a) or 14 (Parr et al.”
BackgroundMethodResultInfluentialSelf-citationKavanagh, K. D. (2019) · Evolution & Development · doi:10.1111/ede.12323 · Cited by 12
“…most often from a genetic covariation perspective, rather than following variational rates during the sequence of developmental events, even in structurally‐integrated traits such as the scapula or the cranium (Goswami, 2006; Marroig & Cheverud, 2001; Rolian, 2009; Sears, 2004; Young, 2004).”
InfluentialA test for rate‐coupling of trophic and cranial evolutionary dynamics in New World bats
Shi, J. J., Westeen, E. P., & Rabosky, D. L. (2021) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/evo.14188 · Cited by 12
“Bat crania, like those of other mammals, can be highly modular and linked to other aspects of behavior or sensory ecology (Goswami 2006; Machado et al. 2007; Curtis and Simmons 2017).”
BackgroundCorrelation patterns in roe deer cranium: sexual dimorphism across different habitats
Milošević-Zlatanović, S. M., Kolarov, N. T., Vukov, T., & Stamenković, S. (2016) · Journal of Zoology · doi:10.1111/jzo.12383 · Cited by 9
Morphometric and Genetic Description of Trophic Adaptations in Cichlid Fishes
DeLorenzo, L., DeBrock, V., Baez, A. C., Ciccotto, P. J., Peterson, E. N., Stull, C., Roberts, N. B., Roberts, R. B., & Powder, K. E. (2022) · Biology · doi:10.3390/biology11081165 · Cited by 9
“However, studies in mammals, birds, and the Archosaur group have identified modularity within the skull based on developmental origins [53–55] or function and articulation [54,56].”
BackgroundModularidad e integración morfológica en cráneos humanos: un enfoque morfométrico geométrico
Püschel, T. (2014) · International Journal of Morphology · doi:10.4067/s0717-95022014000100048 · Cited by 8
Complete metamorphosis promotes morphological and functional diversity in Caudata
Louppe, V., Verger, K. L., Clavel, J., Ferreira, G. S., Kyriakouli, C., Stanley, E. L., Watt, E. C., Bardua, C., Pérez-Ben, C. M., Fröbisch, N. B., et al. (2025) · Functional Ecology · doi:10.1111/1365-2435.70044 · Cited by 11
Self-citationPatterns of Trophic Evolution: Integration and Modularity of the Cichlid Skull
Hu, Y., & Albertson, R. C. (2021) · Springer eBooks · doi:10.1007/978-94-024-2080-7_20 · Cited by 8
Phylogeny, Ecology, and Morphological Evolution in the Atelid Cranium
Bjarnason, A., Soligo, C., & Elton, S. (2015) · International Journal of Primatology · doi:10.1007/s10764-015-9839-z · Cited by 10
“Separate cranial regions have been proposed for the face, cranial vault, and cranial base, with further subdivision into palate, temporal, orbit, and zygomatic regions (Cheverud 1982, 1995; Goswami 2006; Hallgrimsson et al. 2004).”
BackgroundOntogeny of the morphology‐performance axis in an amphibious fish (Kryptolebias marmoratus)
Styga, J. M., Houslay, T. M., Wilson, A. J., & Earley, R. L. (2017) · Journal of Experimental Zoology Part A Ecological and Integrative Physiology · doi:10.1002/jez.2150 · Cited by 8
“Several studies have found that strong integration among traits may constrain future responses to selection (Goswami, 2006; Wroe & Milne, 2007).”
BackgroundMarcy, A. E., Mitchell, D. R., Guillerme, T., Phillips, M. J., & Weisbecker, V. (2024) · Ecology and Evolution · doi:10.1002/ece3.11588 · Cited by 8
“…landmark variation are impacted by the ‘Pinocchio-Effect’, where variation in the tip of a triangular shape – such as most vertebrate rostra – is exaggerated (summarised Modularity and integration results averaged across the whole skull (a) our five-module framework (Goswami, 2006.”
BackgroundMethodBuilding a predator: macroevolutionary patterns in the skull of abelisaurid dinosaurs
Pereyra, E. E. S., Ezcurra, M. D., Paschetta, C., & Méndez, A. H. (2025) · Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences · doi:10.1098/rspb.2025.0943 · Cited by 7
Artuso, S., Gamisch, A., Staedler, Y. M., Schönenberger, J., & Comes, H. P. (2022) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/evo.14621 · Cited by 8
Roston, R. A., & Roth, V. L. (2021) · Journal of Anatomy · doi:10.1111/joa.13492 · Cited by 6
“In most mammals, the external bony nares and rostral tip covary, and consequently appear to form a single evolutionary “oronasal” module (Goswami, 2006; Porto et al., 2009); several mammalian taxa, however, demonstrate a decoupling of the external bony nares and alveolar point (prosthion).”
BackgroundConith, A. J., Meagher, M. A., & Dumont, E. R. (2021) · Journal of Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1111/jeb.13944 · Cited by 8
Rutland, J. W., Delman, B. N., Bellaire, C. P., Napoli, J. G., Villavisanis, D. F., Margulies, I. G., Goel, P., Urata, M. M., & Taub, P. J. (2021) · Journal of Craniofacial Surgery · doi:10.1097/scs.0000000000007564 · Cited by 8
Divergent patterns of cranial suture fusion in marsupial and placental mammals
White, H., Tucker, A. S., & Goswami, A. (2024) · Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society · doi:10.1093/zoolinnean/zlae060 · Cited by 7
“Instead, it is possible that the modular nature of the mammalian skull (Goswami 2006, Porto et al. 2009, Goswami and Finarelli 2016, Parr et al. 2016), which enables various cranial regions to respond semi-independently to selective pressures, might have instead supported the morphological…”
Self-citation
Metadata
- Authors
- Goswami, A.
- Affiliations
- Field Museum of Natural History (US)
- Corresponding author
- Goswami, Anjali
- ORCID
- Goswami, Anjali
- Venue
- The American Naturalist
- Publisher
- University of Chicago Press
- Published
- 2006-08
- Volume
- 168
- Issue
- 2
- Pages
- 270-280
- ISSN
- 0003-0147 (ISSN-L)
- 1537-5323
- OpenAlex
- W2065023905
- Cited by
- 280
- References
- 55
- Citations by year
- 2026: 9 · 2025: 15 · 2024: 4 · 2023: 10 · 2022: 17 · 2021: 24 · 2020: 21 · 2019: 22 · 2018: 20 · 2017: 16 · 2016: 15 · 2015: 15 · 2014: 18 · 2013: 17 · 2012: 9
- FWCI
- 9.63
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- closed
- Locations
- The American Naturalist (publishedVersion)
- PubMed (publishedVersion)
- Department of Earth Sciences EPrints Repository (acceptedVersion)
- UCL Discovery (University College London) (submittedVersion)
- Topics
- Life Sciences › Agricultural and Biological Sciences › Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics › Morphological variations and asymmetry
- Physical Sciences › Earth and Planetary Sciences › Paleontology › Evolution and Paleontology Studies
- Health Sciences › Medicine › Anatomy › Comparative Animal Anatomy Studies
- Keywords
- cranial integration, marsupials, placentals, monotremes, cranial landmarks, correlation matrix, tissue of origin, functional morphology
- MeSH terms
- Animals, Biological Evolution, Fossils, Mammals, Skull
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.