Cranial Modularity Shifts during Mammalian Evolution
The DOI matches its Crossref record; 56 of the 56 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Abstract
The mammalian skull has been studied as several separate functional components for decades, but the study of modularity is a more recent, integrative approach toward quantitative examination of independent subsets of highly correlated traits, or modules. Although most studies of modularity focus on developmental and genetic systems, phenotypic modules have been noted in many diverse morphological structures. However, few studies have provided empirical data for comparing modules across higher taxonomic levels, limiting the ability to assess the broader evolutionary significance of modularity. This study uses 18-32 three-dimensional cranial landmarks to analyze phenotypic modularity in 106 mammalian species and demonstrates that cranial modularity is generally conserved in the evolution of therian mammals (marsupials and placentals) but differs between therians and monotremes, the two extant subclasses of Mammalia. Within therians, cluster analyses identify six distinct modules, but only three modules display significant integration in all species. Monotremes display only two highly integrated modules. Specific hypotheses of functional and developmental influences on cranial bones were tested. Theoretical correlation matrices for bones were constructed on the basis of shared function, tissue origin, or mode of ossification, and all three of these models are significantly correlated with observed correlation matrices for the mammalian cranium.
Overview
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
Claims other papers make about this one
Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?
In the citing paper
“Together, these findings suggest that strong within-module trait correlations, related to developmental origin, constrain both the rate of evolution and the potential for the evolution of high diversity in some avian cranial modules, as in mammals (23).”
From Developmental origins of mosaic evolution in the avian cranium (2018) · cites this paper as [23]
In the citing paper
“This mirrors the finding that, in mammals, anatomical modules with high developmental complexity have low within-module integration (23).”
From Developmental origins of mosaic evolution in the avian cranium (2018) · cites this paper as [23]
Citations
Cites
American Journal of Physical Anthropology
(2006) · American Journal of Physical Anthropology · doi:10.1002/(issn)1096-8644 · Cited by 2,700
Vertebrate Paleontology and Evolution
Ostrom, J. H., & Carroll, R. L. (1988) · PALAIOS · doi:10.2307/3514548 · Cited by 1,665 · cited 1×
“Second, the fossil record of mammals is sufficiently complete for testing hypotheses of morphological evolution and for incorporating morphologies not represented in extant taxa (Carroll 1988).”
BackgroundThe triple origin of skull in higher vertebrates: a study in quail-chick chimeras
Couly, G. F., Coltey, P. M., & Douarin, N. M. L. (1993) · Development · doi:10.1242/dev.117.2.409 · Cited by 1,023
Modularity in development and evolution
Schlosser, G., & Thieffry, D. (2000) · BioEssays · doi:10.1002/1521-1878(200011)22:11<1043::aid-bies11>3.0.co;2-c · Cited by 891 · cited 1×
“…pathways, novelty, life-history strategies, and macroevolutionary trends (Cheverud 1982, 1996a, 1996b; Cheverud et al. 1983, 1991, 1997, 2004; Wagner 1995, 1996; Klingenberg and Leamy 2001; Klingenberg et al. 2001a, 2004; Ehrich et al. 2003; Pigliucci and Preston 2004; Schlosser and Wagner 2004).”
BackgroundPHENOTYPIC, GENETIC, AND ENVIRONMENTAL MORPHOLOGICAL INTEGRATION IN THE CRANIUM
Cheverud, J. M. (1982) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/j.1558-5646.1982.tb05070.x · Cited by 856 · cited 4×
“…2000, 2004; Klingenberg and Leamy 2001; Klingenberg et al. 2001a, 2003; Cheverud 2004; Klingenberg 2004; Polly 2005), and the mammalian skull (Cheverud 1982, 1988, 1989, 1995, 1996a, 1996b; Cheverud et al. 1983; Zelditch 1988; Zelditch and Carmichael 1989a, 1989b; Steppan 1997a, 1997b;…”
BackgroundInfluentialHomologues, Natural Kinds and the Evolution of Modularity
WAGNER, G. P. (1996) · American Zoologist · doi:10.1093/icb/36.1.36 · Cited by 805 · cited 1×
“…pathways, novelty, life-history strategies, and macroevolutionary trends (Cheverud 1982, 1996a, 1996b; Cheverud et al. 1983, 1991, 1997, 2004; Wagner 1995, 1996; Klingenberg and Leamy 2001; Klingenberg et al. 2001a, 2004; Ehrich et al. 2003; Pigliucci and Preston 2004; Schlosser and Wagner…”
BackgroundVertebrate paleontology and evolution
Guérin, C. (1988) · Geobios · doi:10.1016/s0016-6995(88)80066-4 · Cited by 777
Developmental Integration and the Evolution of Pleiotropy
CHEVERUD, J. M. (1996) · American Zoologist · doi:10.1093/icb/36.1.44 · Cited by 757 · cited 8×
“Cheverud (1996a) and Ackermann and Cheverud (2004b) have suggested that the weak integration of the cranial vault in primates may allow for the great expansion of the brain during primate evolution.”
BackgroundInfluentialQuantitative genetics and developmental constraints on evolution by selection
Cheverud, J. M. (1984) · Journal of Theoretical Biology · doi:10.1016/s0022-5193(84)80050-8 · Cited by 710 · cited 1×
“…al. 1983, 1997, 2004; Atchley 1993; Klingenberg and Leamy 2001; Klingenberg et al. 2001a, 2004) and between development and phenotypic integration (Cheverud 1984, 1996a; Zelditch 1988; Zelditch and Carmichael 1989a, 1989b; Atchley and Hall 1991; Atchley 1993; Klingenberg and Nijhout 1999;…”
BackgroundA MODEL FOR DEVELOPMENT AND EVOLUTION OF COMPLEX MORPHOLOGICAL STRUCTURES
ATCHLEY, W. R., & HALL, B. K. (1991) · Biological Reviews · doi:10.1111/j.1469-185x.1991.tb01138.x · Cited by 586 · cited 2×
“…et al. 2001a, 2004) and between development and phenotypic integration (Cheverud 1984, 1996a; Zelditch 1988; Zelditch and Carmichael 1989a, 1989b; Atchley and Hall 1991; Atchley 1993; Klingenberg and Nijhout 1999; Klingenberg and Zaklan 2000; Klingenberg et al. 2001b, 2003; Klingenberg 2002,…”
Background
Research works printed but not linked: 9
- 10.1002/(SICI)1096-8644(200004)111:4<489::AID-AJPA5>3.0.CO;2-U · DOI · Paper page
- Atchley W. R., Genetic and developmental aspects of variability in the mammalian mandible. Pages 207–247 in J
- Bolker J. A., 2000, American Zoologist, 40, 770
- Cheverud J. M., Modular pleiotropic effects of quantitative trait loci on morphological traits. Pages 132–153 in G
- Cheverud J. M., 1991, Journal of Craniofacial Genetics and Developmental Biology, 11, 122
- Gilbert B. M., Mammalian osteology
- 10.1111/j.1558-5646.1999.tb03772.x · DOI · Paper page
- 10.1534/genetics.166.4.1909 · doi:10.1534/genetics.166.4.1909 · Paper page
- 10.1002/1096-8644(2000)43:31+<117::AID-AJPA5>3.3.CO;2-9 · doi:10.1002/1096-8644(2000)43:31+<117::aid-ajpa5>3.3.co;2-9
Cited by
Size, shape, and form: concepts of allometry in geometric morphometrics
Klingenberg, C. P. (2016) · Development Genes and Evolution · doi:10.1007/s00427-016-0539-2 · Cited by 1,057
“…such as size-and-shape space or allometric space, but also has been called form space, involves a superimposition of the landmark configurations without standardizing to unit centroid size (Ziezold 1977, 1994; Kendall 1989; Dryden and Mardia 1992; Le 1995; Langlade et al. 2005; Goswami 2006a).”
BackgroundMethodInfluentialMorphological integration and developmental modularity
Klingenberg, C. P. (2008) · Annual Review of Ecology Evolution and Systematics · doi:10.1146/annurev.ecolsys.37.091305.110054 · Cited by 863
“The analyses showed that the patterns of cranial modularity in the broad range of mammals studied were consistently associated with the phylogenetic distances between taxa, but diet had only a clear effect in a few of the taxa (Goswami 2006b, 2007).”
BackgroundMethodEvolution and development of shape: integrating quantitative approaches
Klingenberg, C. P. (2010) · Nature Reviews Genetics · doi:10.1038/nrg2829 · Cited by 705
Klingenberg, C. P. (2009) · Evolution & Development · doi:10.1111/j.1525-142x.2009.00347.x · Cited by 509
Large‐Scale Diversification of Skull Shape in Domestic Dogs: Disparity and Modularity
Drake, A. G., & Klingenberg, C. P. (2010) · The American Naturalist · doi:10.1086/650372 · Cited by 425
“…may also influence the observed patterns, a comparison across the order Carnivora found that patterns of cranial integration within species are mostly similar (Goswami 2006b) and that there are some shared patterns of integration even across therian mammals (Goswami 2006a; Porto et al. 2009).”
BackgroundKlingenberg, C. P., & Marugán-Lobón, J. (2013) · Systematic Biology · doi:10.1093/sysbio/syt025 · Cited by 415
Studying morphological integration and modularity at multiple levels: concepts and analysis
Klingenberg, C. P. (2014) · Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences · doi:10.1098/rstb.2013.0249 · Cited by 377
“Even in comparisons of integration or modularity among species or other groups, the patterns that are being compared are most often computed at the static level [15,39–44].”
BackgroundThe macroevolutionary consequences of phenotypic integration: from development to deep time
Goswami, A., Smaers, J. B., Soligo, C., & Polly, P. D. (2014) · Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences · doi:10.1098/rstb.2013.0254 · Cited by 359
Self-citationThe Influence of Modularity on Cranial Morphological Disparity in Carnivora and Primates (Mammalia)
Goswami, A., & Polly, P. D. (2010) · PLoS ONE · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0009517 · Cited by 271
“Marsupials have the same general pattern of cranial modularity as placentals [32], and monotremes, although having very different patterns of cranial modularity than those observed in therian, are not diverse enough for statistically significant analyses.”
BackgroundMethodInfluentialSelf-citationDevelopmental origins of mosaic evolution in the avian cranium
Felice, R. N., & Goswami, A. (2018) · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences · doi:10.1073/pnas.1716437115 · Cited by 249
“This mirrors the finding that, in mammals, anatomical modules with high developmental complexity have low within-module integration (23).”
BackgroundSelf-citationThe evolutionary role of modularity and integration in the Hominoid cranium
Mitteroecker, P., & Bookstein, F. (2008) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/j.1558-5646.2008.00321.x · Cited by 267
Adams, D. C. (2016) · Methods in Ecology and Evolution · doi:10.1111/2041-210x.12511 · Cited by 257
“…work has shown that landmarks that are physically close to one another are more correlated than are those found more distantly on the structure (Goswami 2006), suggesting that if the landmarks are otherwise uncorrelated from the perspective of underlying biological mechanisms, they will not be…”
Larger mammals have longer faces because of size-related constraints on skull form
Cardini, A., & Polly, P. D. (2013) · Nature Communications · doi:10.1038/ncomms3458 · Cited by 246
Epigenetics: linking genotype and phenotype in development and evolution
(2012) · Choice Reviews Online · doi:10.5860/choice.49-2642 · Cited by 220
CARDINI, A., & ELTON, S. (2008) · Biological Journal of the Linnean Society · doi:10.1111/j.1095-8312.2008.01011.x · Cited by 199
“However, despite a great interest in the modularity and integration of complex structures such as the mammal cranium (Goswami, 2006) and the rapid adoption of geometric morphometrics in evolutionary developmental biology (evo-devo), little work appears to have been done in the context of…”
BackgroundCranial integration and modularity: insights into evolution and development from morphometric data
(2013) · Bollettino del CILEA (CILEA) · doi:10.4404/hystrix-24.1-6367 · Cited by 199
Heritability of human cranial dimensions: comparing the evolvability of different cranial regions
Martínez‐Abadías, N., Esparza, M., Sjøvold, T., González‐José, R., Santos, M., & Hernández, M. (2009) · Journal of Anatomy · doi:10.1111/j.1469-7580.2008.01015.x · Cited by 191
“evolvability; heritability; human skull; quantitative genetics.”
BackgroundEcomorphological diversification in squamates from conserved pattern of cranial integration
Watanabe, A., Fabre, A.-C., Felice, R. N., Maisano, J. A., Müller, J., Herrel, A., & Goswami, A. (2019) · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences · doi:10.1073/pnas.1820967116 · Cited by 175
“In addition, cranial modularity and integration clearly evolve across vertebrate clades, as differences across mammals (54, 55), birds (28), and now squamates indicate.”
BackgroundSelf-citationA fly in a tube: Macroevolutionary expectations for integrated phenotypes
Felice, R. N., Randau, M., & Goswami, A. (2018) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/evo.13608 · Cited by 162
“…in mammals, with several studies across various parts of the skeleton (e.g., Cheverud 1995; Marroig and Cheverud 2001; Klingenberg et al. 2003; Goswami 2006b; Young 2006; Porto et al. 2008; Zelditch et al. 2008; Bennett and Goswami 2011; Kelly and Sears 2011) allowing for some determination…”
BackgroundInfluentialSelf-citationMethods for Studying Morphological Integration and Modularity
Goswami, A., & Polly, P. D. (2010) · The Paleontological Society Papers · doi:10.1017/s1089332600001881 · Cited by 159
Self-citationGoswami, A., Milne, N., & Wroe, S. (2011) · Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences · doi:10.1098/rspb.2010.2031 · Cited by 157
Self-citationApproaches to Macroevolution: 1. General Concepts and Origin of Variation
Jablonski, D. (2017) · Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1007/s11692-017-9420-0 · Cited by 159
“For example, the strength of developmental integration, or its converse modularity, and the eccentricity of phenotypic covariation within populations around a multivariate centroid, appears to influence the differential evolution of skull disparity between mammalian clades (Goswami 2006; Porto et al. 2013; Goswami et…”
BackgroundModularity of the rodent mandible: Integrating bones, muscles, and teeth
Zelditch, M. L., Wood, A. R., Bonett, R. M., & Swiderski, D. L. (2008) · Evolution & Development · doi:10.1111/j.1525-142x.2008.00290.x · Cited by 151
“We use Ward’s method (1963) of hierarchical clustering, one of the most widely used in studies of morphological integration (e.g., Cheverud 1982; Goswami 2006; Willmore et al. 2006), because it aims to produce compact, spherical clusters by minimizing the variance of intra-cluster distances.”
MethodSanger, T. J., Mahler, D. L., Abzhanov, A., & Losos, J. B. (2012) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/j.1558-5646.2011.01519.x · Cited by 129
“For example, general patterns of cranial integration are conserved among therian mammals, but trait complexes vary in degree of integration (Goswami 2006a,b; Marroig et al. 2009; Porto et al. 2009 Drake and Klingenberg 2010).”
BackgroundMethodInfluentialMartínez-Abadías, N., Esparza, M., Sjøvold, T., González-José, R., Santos, M., Hernández, M., & Klingenberg, C. P. (2012) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/j.1558-5646.2011.01496.x · Cited by 126
Adams, D. C., & Collyer, M. L. (2019) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/evo.13867 · Cited by 132
“Some studies have investigated whether patterns of modularity are conserved across taxa (e.g., Goswami 2006; Marshall et al. 2019), however, direct quantitative or statistical comparisons of modularity patterns are generally lacking.”
BackgroundDenton, J. S. S., & Adams, D. C. (2015) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/evo.12743 · Cited by 134
“…Klingenberg 2008), the macroevolutionary implications of modular organization are only beginning to be understood through studies combining hypothesis tests of modularity with inferred rates of morphological evolution (Goswami 2006; Wagner et al. 2007; Márquez 2008; 2 4 2 5 C© 2015 The Author(s).”
BackgroundShirai, L. T., & Marroig, G. (2010) · Journal of Experimental Zoology Part B: Molecular and Developmental Evolution · doi:10.1002/jez.b.21367 · Cited by 115
“Attempts to address the role of modules in a phylogenetic context are, however, still scarce (but see Smith, ’96; Marroig and Cheverud, 2001; Goswami, 2006; Marroig et al., 2009; Oliveira et al., 2009; Porto et al., 2009).”
BackgroundEvolution of Covariance in the Mammalian Skull
Hallgrimsson, B., Lieberman, D. E., Young, N. M., Parsons, T., & Wat, S. (2006) · Novartis Foundation Symposia · doi:10.1002/9780470319390.ch12 · Cited by 111
“A striking result that comes out of comparative analyses of covariation structure in related species is how conservative covariation structure can be (Goswami 2006b, Marroig & Cheverud 2001, Young 2004, Young & Hallgrimsson 2005).”
BackgroundMorphological evolution and modularity of the caecilian skull
Bardua, C., Wilkinson, M., Gower, D. J., Sherratt, E., & Goswami, A. (2019) · BMC Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1186/s12862-018-1342-7 · Cited by 116
“, division of the cranium into anterior and posterior modules, dorsal and ventral modules, and medial and lateral modules), a six-module model analogous to the therian mammal six-module model [29] and extensions of this model by further partitioning some of the original six modules into small subunits.”
BackgroundMethodSelf-citationZelditch, M. L., Wood, A. R., & Swiderski, D. L. (2008) · Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1007/s11692-008-9034-7 · Cited by 116
“Hierarchical clustering methods are routinely used in studies of morphological integration (e.g., Cheverud 1982; Atchley 1993; Monteiro et al. 2005; Goswami 2006a; Willmore et al. 2006), but preliminary analysis indicated that this method is poorly suited to our data for two major reasons.”
MethodGoswami, A., & Finarelli, J. A. (2016) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/evo.12956 · Cited by 99
“This is in approximate agreement 390 with previous analyses of integration patterns in mammalian crania (Goswami 2006a).”
BackgroundMethodResultInfluentialDevelopmental modularity and the marsupial–placental dichotomy
Goswami, A., Weisbecker, V., & Sánchez‐Villagra, M. R. (2009) · Journal of Experimental Zoology Part B: Molecular and Developmental Evolution · doi:10.1002/jez.b.21283 · Cited by 99
Self-citationGoswami, A., Binder, W. J., Meachen, J., & O'Keefe, F. R. (2015) · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences · doi:10.1073/pnas.1403667112 · Cited by 101
“One interesting exception is that of extinct saber-toothed cats (Smilodon fatalis), in which patterns of cranial integration diverge from those of extant and extinct conical-toothed cats (53) by fragmentation of the anterior face into two new modules (11) (SI Text), possibly due to strong sexual selection on canine si…”
Self-citationCranial modularity and sequence heterochrony in mammals
Goswami, A. (2007) · Evolution & Development · doi:10.1111/j.1525-142x.2007.00161.x · Cited by 97
“Cranial landmarks, used in analysis of evolutionary modules (Goswami 2006), shown on Echymipera kalubu.”
BackgroundMethodInfluentialSelf-citationMakedonska, J., Wright, B. W., & Strait, D. S. (2012) · PLoS ONE · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0040398 · Cited by 95
“Further differences between Goswami’s [45] and Porto et al.”
BackgroundResultInfluentialEvolvability of the Primate Pelvic Girdle
Lewton, K. L. (2011) · Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1007/s11692-011-9143-6 · Cited by 104
Mitterœcker, P. (2009) · Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1007/s11692-009-9075-6 · Cited by 88
“Consequently, attempts to test several alternative models of modularity often do not lead to an exclusive support for a single model (e.g., Zelditch 1987; Hallgrimsson 2004; Monteiro et al. 2005; Goswami 2006; Lawler 2008 ;M a´rquez 2008; Zelditch et al. 2008).”
BackgroundMorphological Diversification under High Integration in a Hyper Diverse Mammal Clade
Hedrick, B. P., Mutumi, G. L., Munteanu, V. D., Sadier, A., Davies, K. T. J., Rossiter, S. J., Sears, K. E., Dávalos, L. M., & Dumont, E. R. (2019) · Journal of Mammalian Evolution · doi:10.1007/s10914-019-09472-x · Cited by 91
“We note that several other studies have found that mammal crania are made up of as many as six modules (Cheverud 1995; Goswami 2006; Goswami and Finarelli 2016).”
BackgroundResultInfluentialThe Intertwined Evolution and Development of Sutures and Cranial Morphology
White, H., Goswami, A., & Tucker, A. S. (2021) · Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology · doi:10.3389/fcell.2021.653579 · Cited by 82
“It could be hypothesised that the large scale cranial morphological disparity observed across mammals (Goswami, 2006; Koyabu et al., 2014; Usui and Tokita, 2018) is shaped to some degree by the sutural variation, in terms of suture fusion status, developmental processes, and morphology.”
BackgroundSelf-citationPatterns of morphological integration in the appendicular skeleton of mammalian carnivores
Martín‐Serra, A., Figueirido, B., Pérez‐Claros, J. A., & Palmqvist, P. (2014) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/evo.12566 · Cited by 90
Tseng, Z. J. (2013) · PLoS ONE · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0065305 · Cited by 83
“indicate that certain complex features evolved as integrated units [13,14].”
BackgroundDevelopmental constraints on behavioural flexibility
Holekamp, K. E., Swanson, E. M., & Meter, P. E. V. (2013) · Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences · doi:10.1098/rstb.2012.0350 · Cited by 87
“Subsequent workers found that the primate cranial vault and other skull modules are indeed significantly less integrated than the same modules in carnivores [127,128].”
BackgroundShape variation and modularity of skull and teeth in domesticated horses and wild equids
Heck, L., Wilson, L. A. B., Evin, A., Stange, M., & Sánchez-Villagra, M. R. (2018) · Frontiers in Zoology · doi:10.1186/s12983-018-0258-9 · Cited by 74
“Goswami’s mammalian module hypothesis contains six modules, these are anterior oral-nasal (AON), cranial base (CB), cranial vault (CV), orbit (ORB), molar (MR), and zygomaticpterygoid (ZP) (Fig.”
BackgroundMethodResultInfluentialMachado, F. A., Zahn, T. M. G., & Marroig, G. (2018) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/evo.13495 · Cited by 81
“Studies in the field of comparative quantitative genetics may use a variety of different matrix comparison techniques (e.g., Steppan 1997; Goswami 2006b; Marroig and Cheverud 2010; Blankers et al. 2017), which may provide different information regarding covariance structure, similarity, and…”
BackgroundMethodResultInfluentialBillet, G., Hautier, L., & Lebrun, R. (2015) · Journal of Mammalogy · doi:10.1093/jmammal/gyv074 · Cited by 74
“They have shown that the impact of morphological integration on phylogenetic analysis is not to be neglected (see Goswami 2006; Goswami and Polly 2010).”
BackgroundClaverie, T., & Patek, S. N. (2013) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/evo.12185 · Cited by 75
“Phylogenetic comparison of morphological variation Raptorial appendages Present work Other Rodent mandibles (Monteiro et al. 2005); Mammal skulls (Goswami 2006) external stimuli (chemical or physical; Hallgrı́msson et al. 2007).”
BackgroundInfluentialLessner, E. J., & Holliday, C. M. (2020) · The Anatomical Record · doi:10.1002/ar.24550 · Cited by 82
“The cranial modules grow at different rates (Goswami, 2006; Watanabe et al., 2019), yet the cranial nerves maintain their origins and targets during development regardless of the distance between (Vogel, 1992).”
BackgroundEvolutionary Integration and Modularity in the Archosaur Cranium
Felice, R. N., Watanabe, A., Cuff, A. R., Noirault, E., Pol, D., Witmer, L. M., Norell, M. A., O’Connor, P. M., & Goswami, A. (2019) · Integrative and Comparative Biology · doi:10.1093/icb/icz052 · Cited by 72
“…to the growing body of evidence that patterns of integration are largely conserved within major clades but they are not immutable and can evolve (Goswami 2006; Piras et al. 2014; Haber 2015; D ow nloaded from https://academ ic.oup.com /icb/article/59/2/371/5497794 by guest on 22 M arch…”
BackgroundInfluentialSelf-citationEvolution of craniofacial novelty in parrots through developmental modularity and heterochrony
Tokita, M., Kiyoshi, T., & Armstrong, K. N. (2007) · Evolution & Development · doi:10.1111/j.1525-142x.2007.00199.x · Cited by 67
“…pseudomasseter as modular traits Based on anatomical observations, Zusi (1993) postulated that the suborbital arch andM. pseudomasseter in parrots are a morphologically integrated complex (Olson and Miller 1958; Vermeji 1973; Emerson and Hastings 1998; Pigliucci and Preston 2004; Goswami 2006a, b).”
BackgroundShape, variance and integration during craniogenesis: contrasting marsupial and placental mammals
GOSWAMI, A., POLLY, P. D., MOCK, O. B., & SÁNCHEZ‐VILLAGRA, M. R. (2012) · Journal of Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1111/j.1420-9101.2012.02477.x · Cited by 66
“2004; Marroig & Cheverud, 2004; Marroig et al., 2004; de Oliveira et al., 2009) and Carnivora (Goswami, 2006b), and across Mammalia (Hallgrimsson et al., 2004; Goswami, 2006a; Porto et al., 2009) have bridged the microevolutionary and macroevolutionary scales and provided data supporting the relative conservation of p…”
BackgroundResultInfluentialSelf-citationDoes nasal echolocation influence the modularity of the mammal skull?
Santana, S. E., & Lofgren, S. E. (2013) · Journal of Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1111/jeb.12235 · Cited by 72
“, 2012), mammals have maintained the same two major cranial modules during their 100 + million-year history and over an extraordinary diversity in ecologies and cranial shapes (Goswami, 2006; Porto et al., 2009; Drake & Klingenberg, 2010).”
BackgroundHeterochrony and developmental modularity of cranial osteogenesis in lipotyphlan mammals
Koyabu, D. B., Endo, H., Mitgutsch, C., Suwa, G., Catania, K. C., Zollikofer, C. P., Oda, S., Koyasu, K., Andō, M., & Sánchez-Villagra, M. R. (2011) · EvoDevo · doi:10.1186/2041-9139-2-21 · Cited by 64
“However, very few studies have explicitly examined the relationship between modularity and sequence heterochrony [10,95].”
BackgroundResultGoswami, A., Randau, M., Polly, P. D., Weisbecker, V., Bennett, V., Hautier, L., & Sánchez-Villagra, M. R. (2016) · Integrative and Comparative Biology · doi:10.1093/icb/icw039 · Cited by 62
“Previous study also suggests that they share the same general pattern of cranial integration as other marsupials (Goswami 2006, 2007).”
BackgroundSelf-citationSánchez-Villagra, M. R. (2010) · Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences · doi:10.1098/rspb.2009.2005 · Cited by 69
Rossoni, D. M., Costa, B. M. A., Giannini, N. P., & Marroig, G. (2019) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/evo.13715 · Cited by 64
“…between morphological elements) are remarkably conserved in most taxa (Cheverud 1996b; Ackermann and Cheverud 2000; Marroig and Cheverud 2001; Goswami 2006b; Oliveira et al. 2009; Porto et al. 2009, 2015; Haber 2015; Hubbe et al. 2016), while magnitudes (i.e., the intensity of association…”
BackgroundResultInfluentialMartínez-Abadías, N., Heuzé, Y., Wang, Y., Jabs, E. W., Aldridge, K., & Richtsmeier, J. T. (2011) · PLoS ONE · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0026425 · Cited by 61
“Extensive research has shown that cranial integration is highly conserved across placental mammals [27,28] and that this shared pattern of skull covariation can be preserved even under genetic and developmental alterations [29,30], disease [31], and cultural deformation practices [32].”
BackgroundParr, W. C., Wilson, L. A. B., Wroe, S., Colman, N. J., Crowther, M. S., & Letnic, M. (2016) · Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1007/s11692-016-9371-x · Cited by 65
“Our exploratory modules compare broadly with the functional modules recovered by Goswami (2006), who, based on the study of therian mammal crania, found six modules, these were: anterior oral-nasal, molar, orbit, zygomaticpterygoid , vault, and basicranium.”
BackgroundResultInfluentialVidal‐García, M., & Keogh, J. S. (2017) · BMC Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1186/s12862-017-0993-0 · Cited by 67
Fluctuations in Evolutionary Integration Allow for Big Brains and Disparate Faces
Evans, K. M., Waltz, B. T., Tagliacollo., V. A., Sidlauskas, B. L., & Albert, J. S. (2017) · Scientific Reports · doi:10.1038/srep40431 · Cited by 62
Santana, S., Alfaro, J. L., Noonan, A. P., & Alfaro, M. (2013) · Nature Communications · doi:10.1038/ncomms3765 · Cited by 50
Unravelling intravertebral integration, modularity and disparity in Felidae (Mammalia)
Randau, M., & Goswami, A. (2017) · Evolution & Development · doi:10.1111/ede.12218 · Cited by 57
“Interestingly, however, those two definitions are not contradictory and complex traits may present overall high integration and still be modular (Bookstein 2015), such as the mammalian skull (Goswami 2006a,b; Goswami and Polly 2010c).”
BackgroundSelf-citationGrieco, T. M., Rizk, O. T., & Hlusko, L. J. (2012) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/j.1558-5646.2012.01757.x · Cited by 58
“…make it difficult to identify genetic modules beyond the division between the face and neurocranium (Cheverud 1982, 1995; Halgrı́msson et al. 2004; Goswami 2006; Drake and Klingenberg 2010) or the alveolar and ascending ramus modules recognized by Klingenberg et al. (2004; see also Zelditch et…”
BackgroundRandau, M., Goswami, A., Hutchinson, J. R., Cuff, A. R., & Pierce, S. E. (2016) · Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society · doi:10.1111/zoj.12403 · Cited by 60
“Morphological, developmental and functional modularity has been studied in the mam- malian skeleton, with many examples focusing on the skull (Goswami, 2006; Goswami et al., 2012; Meloro & Slater, 2012; Piras et al., 2013) but also on the vertebral column and limbs (Polly, Head & Cohn, 2001;…”
Self-citationEstimating Correlated Rates of Trait Evolution with Uncertainty
Caetano, D. S., & Harmon, L. J. (2018) · Systematic Biology · doi:10.1093/sysbio/syy067 · Cited by 61
Challenges in identifying and interpreting organizational modules in morphology
Esteve‐Altava, B. (2017) · Journal of Morphology · doi:10.1002/jmor.20690 · Cited by 60
“Finally, we can validate the identified variational modules of the morphometric data using statistical tests (e.g., Fisher’s z-transformation and Student’s t-test, as in Goswami, 2006).”
MethodRhoda, D., Polly, P. D., Raxworthy, C. J., & Segall, M. (2020) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/evo.14130 · Cited by 59
“While additional 612 patterns of developmental integration potentially contributing to morphological integration in the 613 snake skull are less understood but surely exist, the high amount morphological integration in the 614 kinetic feeding system of snakes is striking when considering the complex patterns of modula…”
BackgroundSkeletal ossification and sequence heterochrony in xenarthran evolution
Hautier, L., Weisbecker, V., Goswami, A., Knight, F. M., Kardjilov, N., & Asher, R. J. (2011) · Evolution & Development · doi:10.1111/j.1525-142x.2011.00503.x · Cited by 54
“These observations may suggest the heterochronic shifts conform to the boundaries of modules previously identified for the mammalian cranium (Goswami 2006).”
BackgroundSelf-citationMilenković, M., Jojić, V., Blagojević, J., Tatović, S., & Vujošević, M. (2010) · Journal of Mammalogy · doi:10.1644/09-mamm-a-265.1 · Cited by 55
Evolutionary integration of the frog cranium
Bardua, C., Fabre, A., Bon, M., Das, K., Stanley, E. L., Blackburn, D. C., & Goswami, A. (2020) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/evo.13984 · Cited by 54
“Other studies of tetrapod cranial modularity have recovered weaker or less complex modular structures, including six-module models (mammals, Cheverud 1982; Goswami 2006; Goswami and Polly 2010; Goswami and Finarelli 2016), twomodule models (Alpine newt, Ivanović and Kalezić 2010; Anolis lizards Sanger et al.”
BackgroundSelf-citationThe Evolution of Morphological Integration in the Ruminant Skull
Haber, A. (2014) · Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1007/s11692-014-9302-7 · Cited by 50
“However, P is often used as a proxy for G for practical reasons (e.g., Ackermann and Cheverud 2002; Marroig and Cheverud 2001; Goswami 2006a; Porto et al. 2009), and is also evolutionarily meaningful in its own right (Burger 1986; Zelditch et al. 1990; Steppan 1997b; Arnold and Phillips 1999; Roff…”
BackgroundMethodInfluentialComparison of Mandibular Phenotypic and Genetic Integration between Baboon and Mouse
Willmore, K. E., Roseman, C. C., Rogers, J., Cheverud, J. M., & Richtsmeier, J. T. (2009) · Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1007/s11692-009-9056-9 · Cited by 54
“In fact, cranial integration has been found to be widely similar across therian mammals with strong within-module integration of the oral-nasal region and the anterior cranial base (Goswami 2006).”
InfluentialCurth, S., Fischer, M. S., & Kupczik, K. (2017) · Zoology · doi:10.1016/j.zool.2017.06.002 · Cited by 50
Marshall, A. F., Bardua, C., Gower, D. J., Wilkinson, M., Sherratt, E., & Goswami, A. (2019) · Biological Journal of the Linnean Society · doi:10.1093/biolinnean/blz001 · Cited by 45
“A six-module pattern has been reported for placental mammals (Cheverud, 1982; Goswami, 2006a; Porto et al., 2009; Goswami & Finarelli, 2016), and Felice & Goswami (2018) found a seven-module structure in the avian skull that showed some concordance with mammalian structures.”
BackgroundMethodResultInfluentialSelf-citationPhylogeny, Diet, and Cranial Integration in Australodelphian Marsupials
Goswami, A. (2007) · PLoS ONE · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0000995 · Cited by 42
“Analytical methods follow previous studies [10,11], and a brief review of methodology is provided here.”
BackgroundMethodSelf-citationBasicranium and face: Assessing the impact of morphological integration on primate evolution
Neaux, D., Sansalone, G., Ledogar, J. A., Ledogar, S. H., Luk, T. H. Y., & Wroe, S. (2018) · Journal of Human Evolution · doi:10.1016/j.jhevol.2018.02.007 · Cited by 44
Sensory adaptations reshaped intrinsic factors underlying morphological diversification in bats
Arbour, J. H., Curtis, A. A., & Santana, S. E. (2021) · BMC Biology · doi:10.1186/s12915-021-01022-3 · Cited by 49
“We calculated the covariance matrix of all pairwise landmark comparisons as the dot product of the landmark coordinates minus the mean configuration, and divided by the pooled variance of the two landmarks [42, 78].”
BackgroundMethodResultInfluentialDo modern humans and Neandertals have different patterns of cranial integration?
Roseman, C. C., Weaver, T. D., & Stringer, C. B. (2011) · Journal of Human Evolution · doi:10.1016/j.jhevol.2010.04.010 · Cited by 44
Diet and bite force in red foxes: ontogenetic and sex differences in an invasive carnivore
Forbes‐Harper, J. L., Crawford, H. M., Dundas, S. J., Warburton, N. M., Adams, P. J., Bateman, P. W., Calver, M. C., & Fleming, P. A. (2017) · Journal of Zoology · doi:10.1111/jzo.12463 · Cited by 41
“…the largest Vulpes species (Macdonald & Reynolds, 2004), red foxes (Vulpes vulpes) typically take small prey items and their skulls are characterized by relatively elongate jaws and generalist dentition, with fast-closing jaw muscles ideal for smaller prey (Goswami, 2006; Slater et al., 2009).”
BackgroundRandau, M., & Goswami, A. (2018) · Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1007/s11692-017-9443-6 · Cited by 42
“2014; or across the vertebral column; Randau and Goswami 2017a) and within different components of individual elements (e.g., within the skull; Goswami 2006a; Goswami and Polly 2010a; within humeral shape; Arias-Martorell et al.”
BackgroundInfluentialSelf-citationCetacean Skull Telescoping Brings Evolution of Cranial Sutures into Focus
Roston, R. A., & Roth, V. L. (2019) · The Anatomical Record · doi:10.1002/ar.24079 · Cited by 44
“What does telescoping suggest about how patterns and magnitudes of covariance (reflecting integration) or the relative independence of parts (modularity) can evolve (Goswami, 2006; Marroig et al., 2009; Porto et al., 2009; del Castillo et al., 2017)?”
BackgroundSafety of estrogen/androgen regimens.
Simon, J. A. (2001) · PubMed · Cited by 41
A 3D geometric morphometric dataset quantifying skeletal variation in birds
Bjarnason, A., & Benson, R. (2021) · MorphoMuseuM · doi:10.18563/journal.m3.125 · Cited by 42
“…and Mahler, 2010; Yoder et al., 2010), functional adaptation (e.g. Vrba, 1983; Hansen, 1997, 2012), patterns of integration and modularity (Olson and Miller, 1952; Cheverud, 1982; Goswami, 2006; Klingenberg, 2010; Klingenberg and Marugán-Lobón, 2013), innovation and evolvability (Vermeij, 1973).”
Floral Morphology in Nicotiana : Architectural and Temporal Effects on Phenotypic Integration
Bissell, E. K., & Diggle, P. K. (2008) · International Journal of Plant Sciences · doi:10.1086/523875 · Cited by 41
“However, phenotypic modularity often reflects underlying genetic modularity, and as such, the phenotypic modules identified here may represent evolutionary modules (Atchley et al. 1981; Cheverud 1988; Roff 1996; Arnold and Phillips 1999; Marroig and Cheverud 2001; Goswami 2006).”
BackgroundEvolutionary Lability of Integration in Cambrian Ptychoparioid Trilobites
Webster, M., & Zelditch, M. L. (2011) · Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1007/s11692-011-9110-2 · Cited by 41
“The extent to which the structure of integration is conserved through deep time can be inferred from comparison over a broad sampling of extant taxa (e.g., Goswami 2006a, b, 2007), but the fossil record offers a more direct documentation of phylogenetic conservatism and this has yet to be exploited.”
BackgroundWilson, L. A. B., Carsten Schradin, A., Mitgutsch, C., Galliari, F. C., Mess, A., & Sánchez-Villagra, M. R. (2010) · Organisms Diversity & Evolution · doi:10.1007/s13127-010-0020-4 · Cited by 40
“Elements displaying the least variability in the present study are not confined exclusively to previously reported modules of the mammalian cranium (Goswami 2006).”
BackgroundHautier, L., Billet, G., Eastwood, B., & Lane, J. (2014) · The Anatomical Record · doi:10.1002/ar.22916 · Cited by 42
Jones, K. E., Smaers, J. B., & Goswami, A. (2015) · BMC Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1186/s12862-015-0285-5 · Cited by 45
“Wireframe used to present shape var data) are described in [71,72] and [31].”
MethodSelf-citationCreating diversity in mammalian facial morphology: a review of potential developmental mechanisms
Usui, K., & Tokita, M. (2018) · EvoDevo · doi:10.1186/s13227-018-0103-4 · Cited by 44
Arnold, P. (2020) · Journal of Mammalian Evolution · doi:10.1007/s10914-020-09506-9 · Cited by 44
“The interplay and relationship of the different types of modules and the structured associations between the evolutionary divergence in different traits finally result in evolutionary modularity (Goswami 2006; Klingenberg 2008; Goswami et al. 2014).”
On the Unique Perspective of Paleontology in the Study of Developmental Evolution and Biases
Urdy, S., Wilson, L. A. B., Haug, J. T., & Sánchez-Villagra, M. R. (2013) · Biological Theory · doi:10.1007/s13752-013-0115-1 · Cited by 39
“Among mammals, several macroevolutionary studies of primates and carnivorans have documented patterns of modularity in the adult cranium (e.g., Goswami 2006; Marroig et al. 2009; de Oliveira et al. 2009; Shirai and Marroig 2010).”
BackgroundQuantifying the impact of development on phenotypic variation and evolution
Sears, K. E. (2014) · Journal of Experimental Zoology Part B Molecular and Developmental Evolution · doi:10.1002/jez.b.22592 · Cited by 41
Álvarez, A., Pérez, S. I., & Verzi, D. H. (2015) · Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1007/s11692-015-9326-7 · Cited by 43
“Given the seemingly widespread pattern of high covariation between cranial modules among mammals (e.g. facial and basicranial modules; Goswami 2006), it could be expected a similar pattern among caviomorph rodents.”
BackgroundInfluentialFunctional and phylogenetic constraints in Rhinocerotinae craniodental morphology
Piras, P., Maiorino, L., Raia, P., Marcolini, F., Salvi, D., Vignoli, L., & Kotsakis, T. (2010) · Archivio Istituzionale della Ricerca - Università degli Studi dell Aquila · Cited by 47
Functional constraints during development limit jaw shape evolution in marsupials
Fabre, A., Dowling, C., Miguez, R. P., Fernández, V., Noirault, E., & Goswami, A. (2021) · Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences · doi:10.1098/rspb.2021.0319 · Cited by 36
“A handful of studies have included a broad sample of placental and marsupial mammals [8,16,19], and focused on the limb elements [7,12,16,22,23] or the skull, but none have focused on the morphological evolution of the jaw, the one structure that is uniformly and unambiguously functioning in neonatal marsupials.”
BackgroundSelf-citationIvanović, A., & Kalezić, M. L. (2010) · Journal of Experimental Zoology Part B: Molecular and Developmental Evolution · doi:10.1002/jez.b.21358 · Cited by 37
Law, C. J., & Mehta, R. S. (2018) · Evolution · doi:10.1111/evo.13514 · Cited by 39
Leiser‐Miller, L. B., & Santana, S. E. (2020) · Functional Ecology · doi:10.1111/1365-2435.13561 · Cited by 40
“Morphological diversity may evolve through various mechanisms, including modularity (Goswami, 2006; Goswami & Polly, 2010).”
BackgroundFunctional constraints on tooth morphology in carnivorous mammals
Smits, P. D., & Evans, A. R. (2012) · BMC Evolutionary Biology · doi:10.1186/1471-2148-12-146 · Cited by 44
“Identifying strongly integrated features and the patterns of this integration has been a very active field of research [15] and systems ranging from insect wings [16,17] and mammal mandibles [18,19], to trilobites [20-22] have all been analyzed under various contexts.”
BackgroundRandau, M., Sanfelice, D., & Goswami, A. (2019) · Royal Society Open Science · doi:10.1098/rsos.190201 · Cited by 36
Self-citation
Metadata
- Authors
- Goswami, A.
- Affiliations
- Field Museum of Natural History (US)
- Corresponding author
- Goswami, Anjali
- ORCID
- Goswami, Anjali
- Venue
- The American Naturalist
- Publisher
- University of Chicago Press
- Published
- 2006-08
- Volume
- 168
- Issue
- 2
- Pages
- 270-280
- ISSN
- 0003-0147 (ISSN-L)
- 1537-5323
- OpenAlex
- W2065023905
- Cited by
- 280
- References
- 55
- Citations by year
- 2026: 9 · 2025: 15 · 2024: 4 · 2023: 10 · 2022: 17 · 2021: 24 · 2020: 21 · 2019: 22 · 2018: 20 · 2017: 16 · 2016: 15 · 2015: 15 · 2014: 18 · 2013: 17 · 2012: 9
- FWCI
- 9.63
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- closed
- Locations
- The American Naturalist (publishedVersion)
- PubMed (publishedVersion)
- Department of Earth Sciences EPrints Repository (acceptedVersion)
- UCL Discovery (University College London) (submittedVersion)
- Topics
- Life Sciences › Agricultural and Biological Sciences › Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics › Morphological variations and asymmetry
- Physical Sciences › Earth and Planetary Sciences › Paleontology › Evolution and Paleontology Studies
- Health Sciences › Medicine › Anatomy › Comparative Animal Anatomy Studies
- Keywords
- cranial integration, marsupials, placentals, monotremes, cranial landmarks, correlation matrix, tissue of origin, functional morphology
- MeSH terms
- Animals, Biological Evolution, Fossils, Mammals, Skull
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.