Do AI chatbots improve students learning outcomes? Evidence from a meta‐analysis

Cited by (574)

Items 401–500 of 574

1. The Role of GenAI in EFL: Impact on Learning Motivation and Outcome
   TAO WANG, Bowen Xue · 2024 · Research Square
2. Barriers to AI Course Assistant Adoption: Understanding Student Non-Utilization at LAPU
   George Hanshaw · 2024 · Research Square
3. Integration of a Collaborative Artificial Intelligence in Improving Student Learning Outcomes in Data Analytics
   Jay R San Pedro, Fridolin Sze Thou Ting · 2026 · Research Square
4. ATTITUDES OF PRE-SERVICE BIOLOGY TEACHERS TOWARDS THE APPLICATION OF CHATGPT IN THE UNIVERSITY LEARNING PROCESS
   Vladislav Slavov, Rubén García-Vidal, Kamelia Yotovska, Asya E. Asenova · 2023 · ICERI proceedings
5. Analysis of Learning Characteristics of Online Learners in the Context of Smart Education
   Weihua Weihua · 2024 · ICST Transactions on Scalable Information Systems
6. OPTIMALISASI PEMBELAJARAN TEKNOLOGI PENDIDIKAN DENGAN BANTUAN GPT AI
   Muh Husein Baysha, Endah Resnandari Puji Astuti · 2024 · EDUTECH Jurnal Inovasi Pendidikan Berbantuan Teknologi
7. The application of artificial intelligence technologies in management
   Giedrius Čyras, Vita Marytė Janušauskienė · 2024 · Business and management
8. Amplifying Learning and Teaching Effectiveness through Generative Artificial Intelligence: A Qualitative Approach with Case Studies on Supply Chain and Cold Chain Management
   V. Tang, L. Wong, H.-Y. Lam, Yuk-Ming Tang · 2024 · International Conference Data Science and Management
9. Einflüsse von ChatGPT auf Lernmotivation und Technologieakzeptanz bei Studierenden
   Antje Rybandt, Corinna Behrendt, Anja C. Lepach-Engelhardt · 2025 · Zeitschrift für Hochschulentwicklung
10. A Case on Artificial Intelligence Technologies Using for Tutoring and Achieving Learning Outcomes
    Daina Gudonienė, Evelina Stanevičienė, Edgaras Dambrauskas, Justyna Janik, Yolanda E-Martín, Gerhard Fischerauer · 2025 · Communications in computer and information science
11. Generative Artificial Intelligence: Verification of Educational Applications Model
    Jacek Pyżalski · 2024 · Forum Pedagogiczne
12. Exploring the Impact of Artificial Intelligence Creative Tools in Graphic Design Education: A Systematic Review
    Yang Suk Lan · 2025 · Semarak International Journal of Creative Art and Design
13. AI Integration in Academic Pursuits: A Phenomenological Exploration
    Lenny Godinez, Angela Gabrielle Bacang · 2025 · Journal of interdisciplinary perspectives
14. Emerging Technologies, Especially Artificial Intelligence, and the Future of Higher Education
    2025 · IGI Global eBooks
15. Long Short-Term Memory Models for High-Accuracy Chatbot Development
    Vijay Kumar · 2025 · Advances in computational intelligence and robotics book series
16. Artificial Intelligence Chatbots: Are Chatbots Programmed to Provide Financial Wellness Counseling to College Students?
    ZW Taylor, Andrew Marx, Dez Nixon, Sara K. Ray, Richard Simonds, Mallorie Smith, Sara Glass, Joseph Mesa, Jenny Becker, Aly Blakeney et al. · 2025 · SSRN Electronic Journal
17. Innovation and technology in language teaching: challenges and opportunities
    Azucena Barahona Mora · 2025 · Verbeia.
18. AI CHATBOTS INTEGRATION IN ONLINE SHOP IN NUEVA ECIJA, PHILIPPINES: STUDY UTILIZING THE EXPECTATION CONFIRMATION THEORY AND ISO/IEC 25010 CRITERIA
    Dave M. Pastorfide, Johannah Mae C. Vasquez · 2025 · International Journal of Engineering Applied Sciences and Technology
19. The Impact of Generative Artificial Intelligence Applications on Language Output of English Learners—The Meta-Analysis
    Yi Wang, H Li · 2025 · SSRN Electronic Journal
20. Studies on the Ethics and Effects of AI Chatbots/Tools in Providing Task Assistance for School Assignments and Tasks
    Abhinav Balamurugan · 2025 · International Journal for Research in Applied Science and Engineering Technology
21. Impact of AI-powered Game Simulation on Adults' Cognitive Functions
    Nabeela Sulaiman, Hina Amin · 2025 · Advances in computational intelligence and robotics book series
22. The role of ChatGPT technologies in enhancing the educational performance of teachers in secondary schools in Saudi Arabia
    Fouad Ahmed Al-Modafar · 2025 · International Journal of Education and Practice
23. Erweiterung des Coachings durch Generative KI: Einblicke in Nutzung, Effektivität und Zukunftspotenziale
    Jennifer Haase · 2025 · Organisationsberatung Supervision Coaching
24. Towards Better Social and Emotional Learning: The Way Forward
    Yang Lan, Jiesi Guo, Ricci W. Fong · 2025 · Advancing inclusive and special education in the Asia-Pacific
25. Personality-Aware Conversational Intelligent Tutoring System with GenAI: Studying the Effect on Learners in Introductory Programming
    Amani Alrobai, Alexandra Ioana Cristea · 2025 · Communications in computer and information science
26. Researching Students’ Attitude and Use of AI Chatbots: A Two-Year Study
    Tina Beranič, Luka Pavlič, Marjan Heričko · 2025 · Communications in computer and information science
27. A Meta-analysis of Pedagogical Agents promoting Self-Regulated Learning
    Xinghan Yin, Junmin Ye, Shuang Yu, Sheng Luo, Mengting Nan, Gang Zhao, Yiliang Xie, Lei Zheng · 2025 · International Conference on Computer Science and Technologies in Education (CSTE)
28. AI-Powered Chatbot Assistant for Course Organization
    Alessio Magnolfi, Eugenio Vicario, Leonardo Boncinelli · 2025 · Communications in computer and information science
29. LLM-Enhanced Exploratory Learning with LaLaMoSuLe: Understanding the Interplay Between AI-Powered Educational Interfaces, Eudaimonic Experience, Autonomy, and Competence Perceptions
    Julian Marvin Joers, Ernesto William De Luca · 2025 · Lecture notes in computer science
30. Design and Development of an LLM-Empowered Arguing Pedagogical Agent with a Personalized Avatar, Movements, and Voice
    Qingtang Liu, Yunfan Zuo, Ruiqiu Ye, Yubei Chang, Xing Zhang, Linjing Wu · 2025 · Communications in computer and information science
31. Der Einsatz generativer KI zur Förderung des Textverstehens im schulischen Fachunterricht
    Lea Schulz, Gesa Gunkel · 2025
32. AI Tutors and Open-Source Textbooks: Bridging the Gap in Digital Learning
    Joseph J. Slade, Alina Hyk · 2025 · Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting
33. Evaluating Students' Attitude of the AI-integrated Tasks in TCSOL Classroom Using the CAC Model
    Haixia Wang, Henghua Su · 2025
34. Employing Artificial Intelligence to Foster Moral Emotions in English Language Education: A Review
    Mansour Amini, Ali Zahabi, Wang Yi-qiu · 2025 · Studies in computational intelligence
35. Awareness to Adoption
    Adi Nuraishah Mohd Radzi, Maizaitulaidawati Md Husin · 2025 · Advances in computational intelligence and robotics book series
36. Pre‐Service Teachers' Process of Developing and Using Content With AI
    Nihal Dulkadir Yaman · 2025 · European Journal of Education
37. Virtual Tutors for Science Labs: Exploring the Impact of GPT Integration and 3D Tutor Avatars on Student Engagement and Learning Outcomes
    Serene Cheon, Austin Jerald Stanbury, Juan Francisco Lam, Kun Xu, Hyo Kang · 2025 · ACM Conference on Computer Supported Cooperative Work (CSCW)
38. University Students’ Use and Assessment of Chatbots as an Information Resource: An Exploratory Study
    Erica Shusas, Andrea Forte · 2025 · Proceedings of the Association for Information Science and Technology
39. СОВРЕМЕННЫЕ ПОДХОДЫ К ПРЕПОДАВАНИЮ МАТЕМАТИКИ С ПОМОЩЬЮ SMART-ТЕХНОЛОГИЙ
    А. Тенгаева, А. Анафина, И. Овсянников · 2025 · Habaršy. Fizika-matematikalyķ ġylymdary seriâsy
40. MULTILINGUAL AUTOMATIC SPEECH RECOGNITION INTERFACE FOR TYPING: USABILITY STUDY AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION FOR KAZAKH, RUSSIAN, AND ENGLISH
    Zhanat Makhataeva, Nursultan Atymtay, Rakhat Meiramov, Guldana Nauryzbaikyzy, Kulzat Sadirova, Hüseyin Atakan Varol · 2025 · Scientific Journal of Astana IT University
41. Systematically Reviewing Artificial Intelligence-Generated Embodied Virtual Teachers: Effectiveness in Diverse Contexts and Educational Impacts
    Lin Yu-peng, Zhonggen Yu · 2025 · Research Square
42. Generative AI in management education Effects on motivation, learning outcomes, and behavioral response
    Shu-Hao Chang, Sam Davis, Su‐Yen Chen · 2025 · SSRN Electronic Journal
43. A Meta-Model Analysis of Students’ Autonomous Interaction With General-Purpose LLMs
    Marine Cloux, Davy Monticolo, Raphaël Bary · 2025 · International Generative AI and Computational Language Modelling Conference (GACLM)
44. Lehren und Lernen mit Multimedia
    Juliane Richter · 2025 · Springer eBooks
45. Mentoring Faculty on Artificial Intelligence: Balancing Support, Preserving Human Connection, and Exploring Mentoring as a Way Forward
    Rachel L. Wlodarsky, Geleana Drew Alston · 2025 · New Directions for Adult and Continuing Education
46. Friend, tool, or threat? High school students’ and teachers’ perspectives on AI in learning
    Thseen Nazır, Ayşe Özçiçek · 2025 · Interactive Learning Environments
47. Einstellungen von DaF-Lehramtsstudierenden zur Künstlichen Intelligenz: Einflussfaktoren und Analyse
    Mehmet Doğan, Yusuf Yerkazan · 2025 · Diyalog Interkulturelle Zeitschrift Für Germanistik
48. Integration of Digital Solutions into the University Educational Process
    Inna Golovanova, Tatiana Yu. Gorskaya, Diliara Gainanova · 2025 · Lecture notes in networks and systems
49. College students’ acceptance and adoption of chatbots for learning and their associations with learning outcomes
    Peipei Mao, Zhihui Cai, Xingyu Luo, Yue Zhang, Jingjing Liu, Xiaojun Sun · 2025 · Interactive Learning Environments
50. The role of AI chatbots in enhancing performance expectancy in higher education – a multigroup SEM approach
    Venkateswarlu Nalluri, A. Sai Manideep, Somya Agrawal, Priyanka Sinha, Mazharunnisa · 2025 · Journal of Applied Research in Higher Education
51. MathBuddy: An LLM-Based Chatbot for Elementary Math Education
    Saba Iqbal, Solomon B. Pobee, Akriti Adhikari, Benjamin L Schooley · 2026 · Lecture notes in computer science
52. Chatbots in Schools: Opportunities and Considerations
    Damian Maher · 2025 · Digital education and learning
53. Dynamic EEG Patterns Reflecting User Engagement and Adaptation During Human-AI Interaction
    Dong-Meau Chang, Ye Mei, Jie Yang · 2025 · International Conference on Dependable Systems and Their Applications (DSA)
54. Emotion AI: Challenges and Future Directions
    Anjali Thakur, Gaurav Gupta · 2026 · Information systems engineering and management
55. Putting critical online reasoning in perspective: contributions and challenges
    Patricia A. Alexander · 2026 · Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaft
56. Fostering Student Responsibility and Sustainability Literacy Through AI-Based Learning Tools
    Nhu Lam Thi Quynh, Linh Nguyen Thi Yen, Giang Tien Thi Nguyen, Luan Huynh Vu, Hiep Dac Nguyen, Luan Trong Nguyen · 2025 · International Conference on Educational Communications and Technology (ICTAECT)
57. Investigating the Usability of an Educational AI Chatbot by Middle School Teachers and Students for Enhanced Learning
    Kholoud Khalil Aldous, Joni O. Salminen, Soon-gyo Jung, Jinan Y. Azem, Johanne Medina, Salar M. Khan, Amani Alabed, Bernard J. Jansen · 2025 · International Conference on Foundation and Large Language Models (FLLM)
58. Gamified AI Strategies for Enhancing Emotional Engagement in Children with Dyslexia
    Fatimaezzahra Benmarrakchi · 2025 · International Conference on Education Technology and Computer
59. Understanding GenAI-Assisted English Learning Among College Students: A TAM- and SRL-Based Interview Study
    XingYu Long, Minmin Tu, ZiJun Cheng, MeiYi Shi · 2026 · Literature Language and Cultural Studies
60. Process Collapse or Compensatory Strategy? Profiling and Scaffolding Help-Seeking with an AI Tutor
    Manuel Valle Torre, Ruben Weijers, Marcus M. Specht, Catharine Oertel · 2026 · SSRN Electronic Journal
61. The future of learning in student writing assignments: How AI-assisted language learning changing the course of EFL students writings
    Dyah Kurniawati, Kusumo Hadi Santoso, Dholiful Hadi, Mansur Mansur · 2026 · AIP conference proceedings
62. The impact of AI-assisted writing on students’ learning effectiveness and perceptions: a mixed-methods study
    Tae-An Yoo, Ho-Suk Yang, Minkyu Kim, Ji‐Bum Chung · 2026 · Interactive Learning Environments
63. Does AI-assisted Learning Improve Students' Learning Outcomes? Evidence From A Meta-analysis
    Cong Liu, Hui Meng, HengWei Zhu, Chuiting Rong · 2026 · The Asia-Pacific Education Researcher
64. Accounting teachers’ voices on the integration of ChatGPT in Accounting Education: A Case of South Africa
    Wellington Itai Manzi, Motalenyane Alfred Modise · 2026 · Journal of Education and Learning Technology
65. AI-Supported Educational Interventions for Enhancing Computational Thinking: A Meta-Analysis
    Jin Zhang, Na Man, Yaxin Wu, Yitong Huang · 2026 · Lecture notes in computer science
66. How Do Undergraduate Students Make Decisions When Adopting Generative Artificial Intelligence for Academic Purposes?
    Hui-Chieh Candice Lu · 2026 · CHI Conference Extended Abstracts on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI EA)
67. The Evolution of Generative Artificial Intelligence in Education
    Tarık Kışla, Alev Ateş Çobanoğlu · 2026 · Advances in computational intelligence and robotics book series
68. Uncovering the effect of Gen AI-assisted learning on students’ creativity: A meta-analysis from quasi-experimental evidence
    Huanyou Chai, Fangqi Guo, Jinjin Wang, Xinyi Song, Tianhui Hu · 2026 · Thinking Skills and Creativity
69. Smart Starts
    Gökçe Nur Türkmen, Kürşat Cesur, Tatyana Mikhailova · 2026 · Advances in computational intelligence and robotics book series
70. A Systematic Review of Gemini and Mathematics Education
    Ali Mazı · 2026 · Advances in computational intelligence and robotics book series
71. Challenges of secondary mathematics pre-service teachers in using ChatGPT in mathematics learning
    Jody May Miñao Dangculos, Maria Rhoda Damos Sosas, Judith M. Aleguen, Fitzgerald C. Kintanar · 2026 · Contemporary Mathematics and Science Education
72. Blockchain-Based “Job-Course-Competition Certificate” Full-Process Learning Achievement Record and Trusted Digital Resume System
    Yadong Zhang, Yujuan Zheng, Chen Yin, Wei Wang · 2025
73. The Role of AI Chatbots in the Evolutionary Culturology Educational Ecosystem
    J. T. Velikovsky · 2026 · Advances in computational intelligence and robotics book series
74. Challenges and Opportunities of Integrating Chatbot in English Language Curricula for Vocabulary Learning
    Mohamad Safwat Ashahri Mohd Salim, Mohd Nur Fitri Mohd Salim, Dianna Suzieanna Mohamad Shah, Airil Haimi Mohd Adnan, Salwa Othman, Vivine Nurcahyawati · 2026 · Lecture notes in networks and systems
75. Relationship between education students’ knowledge of ChatGPT in education and their academic performance
    Vanjoreeh A. Madale · 2026 · Discover Education
76. AI-Augmented Student-Centered Learning: Personalization and Agency
    Kuok Ho Daniel Tang · 2026 · Acta Pedagogia Asiana
77. Artificial intelligence in sport management education: A students' perspective
    Samuel López‐Carril, Mario Alguacil, Cristian Gregori-Faus, Christos Anagnostopoulos · 2026 · The International Journal of Management Education
78. Integrating Conversational AI into Philippine Educational Practices: A Promising Framework for Enhancing Learning Outcomes and Educational Equity
    Armida P. Salazar, Rodolfo C. Raga · 2025 · International Conference on Education and E-Learning (ICEEL)
79. Students’ Use of Generative AI Tools in Multiple Choice Exams
    Nicoleta Serban, Tuba Ketenci, Joel Sokol · 2026 · INFORMS Transactions on Education
80. An Empirical Study of Students’ Intention to Use AI Chatbots for Academic Assistance
    Tashya Putri Bangun, Andi muhammad, Adele Bernadet Lingkan Mailangkay · 2026 · International Conference on ICT for Smart Society (ICISS)
81. Teaching in the Virtual Worlds
    Nansy Kouroupi · 2026 · Advances in computational intelligence and robotics book series
82. Exploring Artificial Intelligence in Higher Education through Lightweight Natural Language Processing
    Antonio Matas Terrón, José Manuel Ríos Ariza, A. Luque de la Rosa, José Jesús Sánchez Amate · 2026 · IJERI International Journal of Educational Research and Innovation
83. Adaptive Conversational Virtual Reality Laboratory for Chemistry Education: Effects on Conceptual Understanding, Presence, and Perceived Usefulness
    Lei Cao, Kien Tsong Chau, Wan Ahmad Jaafar Wan Yahaya · 2026 · Journal of Educational Computing Research
84. From Consumers to Creators
    Alberto Carpio · 2026 · Advances in computational intelligence and robotics book series
85. Discourse on Interrogative-Learning
    Rod Lastra, Gary Hepburn · 2026 · IGI Global eBooks
86. Balancing Promise and Peril: Artificial Intelligence and Green Technology for Education 4.0 in Sub‐Saharan Africa to Achieve SDG ‐4
    Babar Nawaz Abbasi, Yifan Mao, Lina Wei · 2026 · Sustainable Development
87. Enhancing Learning in Graduate Nursing Education Through a Co‐Designed AI Virtual Tutor: A Mixed‐Methods Evaluation
    Charlene H. Chu, Lindsay Jibb, Neal MacInnes, Cordelia C. Shan, Shan Mohammed, Stephanie M. Nanos, Mary O'Sullivan, Carles Muntaner, Heather Thomson, Kimberley A. Widger · 2026 · Journal of Clinical Nursing
88. LLM Chatbots in High School Programming: Exploring Behaviors and Interventions
    Manuel Valle Torre, Marcus M. Specht, Catharine Oertel · 2026 · ACM Symposium on Applied Computing
89. Artificial intelligence and academic anxiety? a meta-analysis
    Weihao Wang, Long Diao, Jingting Yu · 2026 · BMC Psychology
90. AI-Assisted and Peer-Collaborative Notetaking in Engineering Education: Benefits, Challenges, and Links to Academic Performance
    Jan Kevin A. Galicia · 2026 · IEEE Global Engineering Education Conference (EDUCON)
91. AI-assisted autonomous learning and reduced academic accomplishment in vocational higher education: the mediating role of hardiness
    Wenli Wang, Qiuyan Zhang · 2026 · Frontiers in Psychology
92. AI-informed Collective Intelligence for Inclusive Research Capacity in Global Education: A UK-Pakistan Empirical Framework
    Preeti Patel, Bilal Hassan, Amanullah Yasin, Muhammad Farooq Wasiq, Malika Rani, Shanawer Niaz, Khadija Naveed · 2026 · IEEE Global Engineering Education Conference (EDUCON)
93. A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW ON ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE-BASED ACADEMIC AND PSYCHOSOCIAL INTERVENTIONS FOR STUDENTS WITH ATTENTION-DEFICIT/HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER
    Ilias Tsolakidis, Thanos Touloupis, Anastasia Alevriadou, Stergiani Giaouri, Dimitrios Chasapis · 2026 · International Online Journal of Primary Education
94. Pre-service mathematics teachers’ views on the usefulness of ChatGPT: the validity of the obtained responses matters!
    Büşra ÇAYLAN ERGENE, Özkan Ergene, Igor’ Kontorovich · 2026 · International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology
95. Can DeepSeek Intelligent Chatbot’s Emotion Induction Enhance College Students’ English Learning Ability?
    Lin Fan, Zhigang Li · 2026 · SAGE Open
96. Review of the impact of artificial intelligence (AI) in education through chatbots based on Natural Language Processing (NLP) technology
    Effransia Tzagkaraki, Stamatios Papadakis, Michail Kalogiannakis · 2026 · Discover Education
97. The Impact of AI Rendering on Design Outcome Quality: A Case Study in the Prototyping Digital Future Course
    Andi Pramono, Riefky Prabowo, Hilmi Dzakaaul Islam · 2026 · International Conference on Green Technology and Sustainable Development (GTSD)
98. The effect of AI–supported reading comprehension instruction on students' 4C skills: A systematic review
    Birjan Duygu ÇELIK, Selçuk DOĞAN, Bayram Baş, Mazhar Bal · 2026 · Thinking Skills and Creativity
99. Human-Centered Design of LLM-Powered Educational Chatbots: A Study with Secondary Teachers
    Heidi Reichert, Daniel Briceno, Benyamin T. Tabarsi, Tiffany M. Barnes · 2026 · Lecture notes in computer science
100. The Impact of Generative AI Tools on Student Academic Performance: Machine Learning Approach
     Vladan Čolić, Enes Sukić, Milica Tufegdžić, Marija Mojsilović, Veljko Spasojević · 2026 · Lecture notes in networks and systems