Do AI chatbots improve students learning outcomes? Evidence from a meta‐analysis

Cited by (574)

Items 101–200 of 574

1. Navigating the New Frontier: Recommendations to Address the Crisis and Potential of AI in the Classroom
   Joseph J. Slade, Stephanie M. Byers, Kathryn A. Becker‐Blease, Regan A. R. Gurung · 2024 · Teaching of Psychology
2. UNESCO's AI Competency Framework
   A. M. Mutawa, Sai Sruthi · 2024 · Advances in educational technologies and instructional design book series
3. Chatbots in higher education: a systematic review
   Eyasu Anjulo Lambebo, Hsiu‐Ling Chen · 2024 · Interactive Learning Environments
4. Exploring graduate students’ perception and adoption of AI chatbots in Zimbabwe: Balancing pedagogical innovation and development of higher-order cognitive skills
   Arthur William Fodouop Kouam, Regis Misheal Muchowe · 2024 · Journal of Applied Learning & Teaching
5. Generative artificial intelligence in education: analysis of trends and prospects
   Поспелова Екатерина Андреевна, Отоцкий Петр Леонидович, Evgeniya N. Gorlacheva, Rinat Vasilovich Faizullin · 2024 · Vocational education and labour market
6. The impact of generative artificial intelligence on students’ higher order thinking: evidence from a three-level meta-analysis
   Nie, Xinxiao, Tian, Yuan, Liu, Mengjie, Wu, Di, Guo, Yunxiao · 2025 · Education and Information Technologies
7. Exploring the role of generative AI in international students’ sociocultural adaptation: a cognitive-affective model
   Huajun Ma, Qingnan You, Zhiyuan Jin, Xuanchang Liu, Zimeng Chen · 2025 · Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence
8. Analyzing the network structure of students’ motivation to learn AI: a self-determination theory perspective
   Jiajing Li, Jianhua Zhang, Ching Sing Chai, Vivian Wing Yan Lee, Xuesong Zhai, Xingwei Wang, Ronnel Bornasal King · 2025 · npj Science of Learning
9. Instructional Video and GenAI ‐Supported Chatbot in Digital Game‐Based Learning: Influences on Science Learning, Cognitive Load and Game Behaviours
   Shih-Kun Huang, Ching‐Huei Chen · 2025 · Journal of Computer Assisted Learning
10. Impact Pathways of AI-Supported Instruction on Learning Behaviors, Competence Development, and Academic Achievement in Engineering Education
    Yu Wan, Rui Li, Wenjie Li, Hongbo Du · 2025 · Sustainability
11. The impact mechanism of artificial intelligence dependence on college students’ innovation capability: an empirical study from China
    Zhixin Yang, Hao Deng, Nan Jiang · 2025 · Frontiers in Psychology
12. Improving students’ programming performance: an integrated mind mapping and generative AI chatbot learning approach
    Xindong Ye, Wenyu Zhang, Yuxin Zhou, Xiaozhi Li, Qiang Zhou · 2025 · Humanities and Social Sciences Communications
13. Potential risks of generative artificial intelligence integration into K-12 education: A scoping review
    Sisi Tao, Min Lan, Minjuan Wang, Hui Li · 2026 · Computers and Education Artificial Intelligence
14. Factors Shaping the Adoption of AI Tools among Gen Z: An Extended UTAUT2 Model Investigation Using CB-SEM
    K. Kavitha, V. P. Joshith · 2024 · Bulletin of Science Technology & Society
15. Falling Behind and Getting Ahead: Student Use of Generative AI in Education
    Yaroslav I. Kuzminov, Ekaterina V. Kruchinskaia, Ivan Gruzdev, Alexey Naumov · 2025 · Высшее образование в России
16. The Use of Artificial Intelligence in Nursing Education: A Scoping Review
    Toni Doston, Justin Fontenot, Dawn L. Morris, Michael Hebert · 2025 · Journal of Nursing Education
17. Generative artificial intelligence in secondary STEM education in the light of Human Flourishing: a scoping literature review
    Alissa Fock, Hans-Stefan Siller · 2025 · International Journal of STEM Education
18. ChatGPT’s impact on student learning outcomes: a meta-analysis of 35 experimental studies
    Xinning Wu, Pei Zhu, Jinliang Zhang, Mengwei Yin, Yingxi Wang · 2026 · Humanities and Social Sciences Communications
19. Emerging Technology-Based Motivational Strategies: A Systematic Review with Meta-Analysis
    Jhon Alé-Silva, María Luisa Arancibia Muñoz · 2025 · Education Sciences
20. The impact of Generative AI on students’ learning: a study of learning satisfaction, self-efficacy and learning outcomes
    Xiaozhe Yang, Xin Liu, Yihe Gao · 2025 · Educational Technology Research and Development
21. Insights Into the Effectiveness of Artificial Intelligence‐Integrated Speaking Instruction in Enhancing Speaking Skills and Social–Emotional Competence as Well as Reducing Demotivation and Shyness
    Wenwen Shi, Goodarz Shakibaei · 2025 · European Journal of Education
22. A Systematic Review of UTAUT and UTAUT2 for AI Adoption in Education
    Liangyong Xue, Norliza Ghazali, Jazihan Mahat · 2025 · International Journal of Human-Computer Interaction
23. Transforming Driver Education: A Comparative Analysis of LLM-Augmented Training and Conventional Instruction for Autonomous Vehicle Technologies
    Mohsin Murtaza, Chi‐Tsun Cheng, Mohammad Fard, John Zeleznikow · 2024 · International Journal of Artificial Intelligence in Education
24. Summative assessment with artificial intelligence: Qualitative analysis and comparison of technology acceptance in student and teacher populations
    Sofie van den Berg, Pantelis M. Papadopoulos · 2024 · Innovations in Education and Teaching International
25. Unveiling the impact of ChatGPT: investigating self-efficacy, anxiety and motivation on student performance in blended learning environments
    Ridwan Daud Mahande, M. Miftach Fakhri, Irwansyah Suwahyu, Dwi Rezky Anandari Sulaiman · 2025 · Journal of Applied Research in Higher Education
26. AI chatbots as reading companions in self‐directed out‐of‐class reading: A self‐determination theory perspective
    Mengru Pan, Chun Lai, Kai Guo · 2025 · British Journal of Educational Technology
27. RETRACTED ARTICLE: The unified theory of acceptance and use of DingTalk for educational purposes in China: an extended structural equation model
    Yukun Hou, Zhonggen Yu · 2023 · Humanities and Social Sciences Communications · Retracted
28. Leveraging ChatGPT and bard for academic librarians and information professionals: a case study of developing pedagogical strategies using generative AI models
    Jonathan M. Torres · 2024 · Journal of Business & Finance Librarianship
29. ChatGPT for Operating Systems: Higher-Order Thinking in Focus
    Mohammed Ahmed Kofahi, Anas Husain · 2025 · Journal of Information Technology Education Research
30. From Passive Watching to Active Learning: Empowering Proactive Participation in Digital Classrooms with AI Video Assistant
    Anna Bodonhelyi, Enkeleda Thaqi, Süleyman Özdel, Efe Bozkir, Enkelejda Kasneci · 2025 · CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems
31. The role of changes in pronunciation ability and anxiety through Gen-AI on EFL learners’ self-directed speaking motivation and social interaction confidence - A CHAT perspective
    Whyun Young Choi · 2025 · System
32. Can ChatGPT enhance business student creativity? Evidence from a randomised controlled trial
    Rosemary Fisher, Taylor Diarmuid Gogan, James S. Williams, Richard Laferriere, Gordon Campbell, Asanka N. Gunasekara, Jeremy Nguyen · 2025 · Studies in Higher Education
33. Effectiveness of Generative AI in Automated Written Corrective Feedback With Prompting
    Jiahui Wu, Jianwei Li, Zi-Gang Ge, Mingrui Xu, Lin Li, Ru Zhang · 2025 · Journal of Educational Computing Research
34. Generative AI and academic scientists in US universities: Perception, experience, and adoption intentions
    Arroyo-Machado, Wenceslao, Ma, Jinghuan, Chen, Tipeng, Johnson, Timothy P., Islam, Shaika, Michalegko, Lesley, Welch, Eric · 2025 · PLOS One
35. Enhancing enthusiasm for STEM education with AI: Domain-specific chatbot as personalized learning assistant
    Cilia Ricarda Rücker, S. Becker · 2025 · Computers and Education Open
36. Effectiveness of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in language teaching
    Peter Joseph Torres, Yunus Emre Kahveci · 2025 · Computers and Education Artificial Intelligence
37. Generative AI in Self-Directed Learning: a thematic scoping review
    Jasper Roe, Mike Perkins · 2025 · Interactive Learning Environments
38. Teacher training in the age of AI: impact on AI literacy and teachers’ attitudes
    Julia Lademann, Jannik Henze, Nadine Honke, Caroline Wollny, S. Becker · 2026 · Frontiers in Education
39. BENEFITS AND CHALLENGES IN USING AI-POWERED EDUCATIONAL TOOLS
    2023 · Education and new developments
40. ChatGPT y educación universitaria. Posibilidades y límites de ChatGPT como herramienta docente
    Mireia Ribera, Oliver Díaz · 2024
41. ChatGPT in Education
    Song Yang, Ying Dong, Zhong Gen Yu · 2024 · International Journal of Information and Communication Technology Education
42. Generative AI-Enabled Conceptualization: Charting ChatGPT’s Impacts on Sustainable Service Design Thinking With Network-Based Cognitive Maps
    Chenhan Jiang, Rui Huang, Tao Shen · 2024 · Journal of Computing and Information Science in Engineering
43. The Impact of Large Language Models on Students: A Randomised Study of Socratic vs. Non-Socratic AI and the Role of Step-by-Step Reasoning
    Andrea Blasco, Vicky Charisi · 2024 · SSRN Electronic Journal
44. Advancing self-directed learning in STEM education: integrating GPT-based learning aid with multimodal learning analytics
    Chia‐Ju Lin, Wei‐Sheng Wang, Hsin‐Yu Lee, Pin‐Hui Li, Yueh‐Min Huang, Ting‐Ting Wu · 2025 · Journal of Research on Technology in Education
45. A Systematic Review Exploring AI’s Role in Self-Regulated Learning Within Education Contexts
    Liling Ren, Kerry Maree Lee, Lawrence May · 2025 · IEEE Access
46. Investigating the motivational and knowledge affordances of conversational AI using induction, concretization and exemplification in math learning
    Chenglu Li, Bailing Lyu · 2025 · British Journal of Educational Technology
47. Artificial intelligence and critical thinking: a case study with educational chatbots
    José Paulo Gomes Brazão, Luis Alexander de Fonseca Tinoca · 2025 · Frontiers in Education
48. Surging currents: a systematic review of the literature on dynamic stakeholder engagements in higher education in the generative artificial intelligence era
    Jiaxi Yang, Han Qiu, Wenxuan Yu · 2024 · Journal of Asian Public Policy
49. CreAItive Collaboration? Users' Misjudgment of AI-Creativity Affects Their Collaborative Performance
    Bangerl, Mia Magdalena, Disch, Leonie, David, Tamara, Pammer-Schindler, Viktoria · 2025 · Proceedings of the 2025 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems
50. The impact of artificial intelligence on students’ 4C skills: A meta-analysis
    Qian Tian, Xudong Zheng · 2025 · Educational Research Review
51. Exploring undergraduates’ computational thinking and human-computer interaction patterns in generative progressive prompt-assisted programming learning
    Xin Gong, Weiqi Xu, Ailing Qiao · 2025 · International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education
52. Questioning the role of AI as collaborator: a systematic literature review of generative AI-supported knowledge construction
    Yeonji Jung, Sung-Hee Jin · 2025 · Interactive Learning Environments
53. STEM-5E Socio-Scientific Argumentation with Generative AI-Driven Scaffolding: Exploring the Interplay between Epistemic Beliefs and Learning Outcomes
    Chi‐Jung Sui, Chun‐Yen Chang, Miao-Hsuan Yen · 2025 · Journal of Science Education and Technology
54. The impact of artificial intelligence-assisted teaching on medical students’ learning outcomes: an integrated model based on the ARCS model and constructivist theory
    Xinyu Pang, Jinyan Zou, Xiaopeng Zhang, Yingying Li, Hao Zhang, Fu‐Dong Wang, Yuanyuan Zhang, Xiyi Chen · 2025 · BMC Medical Education
55. Artificial intelligence in K-12 education: An umbrella review
    Ruiping Huang, Yue Yin, Na Zhou, Fei Lang · 2025 · Computers and Education Artificial Intelligence
56. The association between groups' interactions with the Visual-GenAI learning analytics feedback and student engagement in CSCL
    Xinghan Yin, Junmin Ye, Shuang Yu, H Li, Qingtang Liu, Gang Zhao · 2025 · Computers & Education
57. Opinion of Spanish Teachers About Artificial Intelligence and Its Use in Education
    Juan Francisco Álvarez Herrero · 2024 · EAI/Springer Innovations in Communication and Computing
58. Unleashing the power of virtual learning environment: exploring the impact on learning outcomes through a meta-analysis
    Yuhui Jing, Jian Dai, Chengliang Wang, Shusheng Shen, Rustam Shadiev · 2024 · Interactive Learning Environments
59. ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN HIGHER EDUCATION. A LITERATURE REVIEW
    Jesús Heredia-Carroza, Raluca Stoica · 2024 · Journal of Public Administration, Finance and Law
60. Student satisfaction with artificial intelligence chatbots in Ethiopian academia
    A Subaveerapandiyan, Shashvath Radhakrishnan, Neelam Tiwary, Sisay Mulate Guangul · 2024 · IFLA Journal
61. Artificial intelligence and pain medicine education: Benefits and pitfalls for the medical trainee
    Michael Glicksman, Sheri Wang, Samir Yellapragada, Christopher Louis Robinson, Vwaire Orhurhu, Trent D. Emerick · 2024 · Pain Practice
62. A Comparative Study on AI-Based Learning Behaviors: Evidence from Vietnam
    Nam Tien Duong, Thuy Dung Pham Thi, Van Kien Pham · 2024 · International Journal of Human-Computer Interaction
63. Consumers’ Intentions to Use AI Chatbots on Online Shopping Platforms
    Thuy Dung Pham Thi, Nam Tien Duong · 2025 · Journal of Computer Information Systems
64. Developing the AIlessphobia in education scale and examining its psychometric characteristics
    D. Gezgin, Tuğba Türk Kurtça · 2024 · Education and Information Technologies : Official Journal of the IFIP technical committee on Education
65. Unraveling the Impact of Blended Learning vs. Online Learning on Learners’ Performance: Perspective of Self-Determination Theory
    Qing Yu, Kun Yu, Jiyao Wang · 2025 · Behavioral Sciences
66. The Vision of University Students from the Educational Field in the Integration of ChatGPT
    Sara Cebrián Cifuentes, Empar Guerrero Valverde, Sabina Checa Caballero · 2024 · Digital
67. Revolutionising costume design education: a case study on the impact of Microsoft Copilot
    Nik Ashri Nik Harun, Md Azalanshah Md Syed, Fadli Abdullah · 2024 · Quality Assurance in Education
68. Coexisting with ChatGPT: Evaluating a tool for AI-based paper revision
    Matthew J. Manierre, Lisa Propst, Alex Cohen, JoAnn Rogers · 2025 · Computers & composition/Computers and composition
69. AI and ChatGPT in Higher Education: Greek Students’ Perceived Practices, Benefits, and Challenges
    Απόστολος Κώστας, Vasilios Paraschou, Dimitrios Spanos, Filippos Tzortzoglou, Alivisos Sofos · 2025 · Education Sciences
70. Investigating AI Chatbots’ Role in Online Learning and Digital Agency Development
    Irina Engeness, Magnus Nohr, Trine Fossland · 2025 · Education Sciences
71. Artificial Intelligence in Language Learning
    Anqi Dou, Wei Xu, Xiangyu Li, Shan Zhang, Jiawang Zhang · 2025 · International Journal of Distance Education Technologies
72. Exploring barriers to AI course assistant adoption: a mixed-methods study on student non-utilization
    George Hanshaw, Christopher Sullivan · 2025 · Discover Artificial Intelligence
73. A pedagogical approach: toward leveraging mathematical modeling and AI to support integrating humanities into STEM education
    Quintana M. Clark · 2025 · Frontiers in Education
74. Impact of generative AI chatbots and interaction modes on the speaking proficiency of adolescent EFL learners
    Tzu‐Yu Tai, Howard Hao-Jan Chen · 2025 · Computer Assisted Language Learning
75. Adoption of AI-coding assistants in programming education: exploring trust and learning motivation through an extended technology acceptance model
    Farman Ali Pirzado, Awais Ahmed, Mohammad Amin Alipour, Hugo Terashima‐Marín · 2025 · Journal of Computers in Education
76. Agriculture students’ use of generative artificial intelligence for microcontroller programming
    Donald M. Johnson, William Doss, Christopher M. Estepp · 2024 · Natural sciences education
77. The effects of text-based conversational teachable agents’ communicative features on student math learning: Tone style and emoji use
    Bailing Lyu, Chenglu Li, Hai Li, Wanli Xing · 2025 · Journal of Research on Technology in Education
78. Why do graduate students use generative AI in thesis writing? the influence of self-efficacy, time pressure, and trust
    Chun-Yi Lin, Chih‐Chien Wang · 2025 · Current Psychology
79. Unraveling the influential factors driving persistent adoption of ChatGPT in learning environments
    Sedigheh Moghavvemi, Farooq Ahmed Jam · 2025 · Education and Information Technologies
80. Gender and Educational Attainment Dynamics on Artificial Intelligence Anxiety Among Educators with Emerging Understanding
    Judith M. Maghanoy, Maisora T. Tahil, Josephine Sulasula, Rubén González Vallejo, Alexandhrea Hiedie Dumagay, Ericson O. Alieto · 2025 · Lecture notes on data engineering and communications technologies
81. Artificial Intelligence in Higher Education: Examining the AI Policy Landscape at U.S. Institutions
    Kim, Daniel, Wu, Jue · 2024 · The 25th Annual Conference on Information Technology Education
82. Unveiling the effects of GenAI on motivation of learning English as a second/foreign language: Evidence from meta-analysis
    Meng Xiong, Timothy P. Teo · 2025 · Educational Research Review
83. Conversational AI agents in education: an umbrella review of current utilization, challenges, and future directions for ethical and responsible use
    Amrita Ganguly, Nafisa Mehjabin, Aqdas Naveed Malik, Aditya Johri · 2025 · AI and Ethics
84. Artificial intelligence in gamification: A systematic review
    Aydın Bulut, Fadime Ulusoy · 2026 · Entertainment Computing
85. Artificial intelligence agents in computer-supported collaborative learning: A systematic literature review
    Shen Ba, Xuechun SHI, Shuang Wu, Guoqing Lu · 2026 · Computers and Education Artificial Intelligence
86. The impact of perceived experience with ChatGPT on online consumers' information searching behavior: an empirical study of Iranian college students
    Hamid Alizadeh, Hamed Nazarpour Kashani · 2024 · Asia Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics
87. Personalised learning in project management education: Insights from an artificial intelligence-driven chatbot
    Helgi Þór Ingason, Kirsi Aaltonen, Atli Snaer Asmundarson, Þórður Víkingur Friðgeirsson, Daniel Huemann, Martina Huemann, Jaakko Kujala, Hannele Lampela, Mauro Mancini, Costanza Mariani et al. · 2025 · Project Leadership and Society
88. AI literacy as a key driver of user experience in AI-powered assessment: insights from Socratic mind
    Meryem Yılmaz Soylu, Jeonghyun Lee, Jui-Tse Hung, Christopher Cui, David A. Joyner · 2025 · Interactive Learning Environments
89. Communication Design for an Educational AI Chatbot: Analyzing Cipherbot's Communication Style and Challenges
    Joni O. Salminen, Soon‐gyo Jung, Johanne Medina, Kholoud Khalil Aldous, Jinan Y. Azem, Waleed Akhtar, Essi Häyhänen, Bernard J. Jim Jansen · 2024 · International Academic Mindtrek Conference (Mindtrek)
90. Shaping the future of education: a cluster analysis of generative AI’s transformative impact
    Hussein-Elhakim Al Issa, Greeni Maheshwari · 2025 · Interactive Technology and Smart Education
91. A Systematic Scoping Review of Self‐Regulated Learning With AI in Language Education
    Zheng Zhang, Sihan Zhou, Barry Bai · 2025 · International Journal of Applied Linguistics
92. Divergent Role of AI in Social Development: A Comparative Study of Teachers’ and Students’ Perceptions in Online and Physical Classrooms
    Qianye Wen, Jianliang Wang, Zhuoqi Guo, Daniel Bădulescu · 2025 · Behavioral Sciences
93. Agentic AI in Education
    Lampropoulos, Georgios, López-Belmonte, Jesús, Pozo-Sánchez, Santiago, Marín-Marín, José-Antonio · 2026 · Advances in Computational Intelligence and Robotics
94. The micropolitical landscape of publicly discoverable policies for generative AI in large US school districts
    Mary Frances Rice · 2024 · Technology Pedagogy and Education
95. A call for caution and evidence–based research on the impact of artificial intelligence in education
    Martin Sposato · 2025 · Quality Education for All
96. Development and validation of the artificial intelligence self-regulated learning scale (AI-SRLS) for teachers
    Wenjun Zhang, Yimin Ning, Na Yu, Dengming Yao, Haifeng Wu, Jia Wu, Bowen Fang · 2025 · Education and Information Technologies
97. Exploring the Role and Potential of Chatbots in Learning From the Perspective of Nursing Students: A Systematic Review of Qualitative Studies
    Shibo Zhang, Xia Yang, Lingyun Zhang, Huarong Liu, Xiaolin Chen, Xin Yang, Yan Hu, Qin Liu, Yang He · 2025 · International Nursing Review
98. Effects of Generative AI Feedback and Interactive Video Assessment on Student Learning Achievement in Philological Content Creation Courses
    Νικόλαος Πέλλας · 2025 · Journal of Educational Computing Research
99. Teacher questioning strategies and student achievement: insights from AI Chatbot-Assisted interactive learning environments
    Jia Hao, Shumin Liu, Xiyang Li, Jianhou Gan · 2025 · Education and Information Technologies
100. The Impact of Chatbots on Adolescent Mental Health Development: A Comprehensive Literature Review
     Yidong Wu, Tong Wu, Kerun Zhu, Xia Liu, Jiarui Liu, Yuyan Wang, Ruojin Shi, Jia Xiong, Xinyue Xing, Yao Lv et al. · 2026 · Journal of Multidisciplinary Healthcare