Student or educator? Sign up with your school email and get 6 months of Pro free.
CoChat

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 44 of the 44 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

Dissociation of Broca’s area from Broca’s aphasia in patients undergoing neurosurgical resections

Open access

Abstract

OBJECTIVE: Broca’s aphasia is a syndrome of impaired fluency with retained comprehension. The authors used an unbiased algorithm to examine which neuroanatomical areas are most likely to result in Broca’s aphasia following surgical lesions. METHODS: Patients were prospectively evaluated with standardized language batteries before and after surgery. Broca’s area was defined anatomically as the pars opercularis and triangularis of the inferior frontal gyrus. Broca’s aphasia was defined by the Western Aphasia Battery language assessment. Resections were outlined from MRI scans to construct 3D volumes of interest. These were aligned using a nonlinear transformation to Montreal Neurological Institute brain space. A voxel-based lesion-symptom mapping (VLSM) algorithm was used to test for areas statistically associated with Broca’s aphasia when incorporated into a resection, as well as areas associated with deficits in fluency independent of Western Aphasia Battery classification. Postoperative MRI scans were reviewed in blinded fashion to estimate the percentage resection of Broca’s area compared to areas identified using the VLSM algorithm. RESULTS: A total of 289 patients had early language evaluations, of whom 19 had postoperative Broca’s aphasia. VLSM analysis revealed an area that was highly correlated (p < 0.001) with Broca’s aphasia, spanning ventral sensorimotor cortex and supramarginal gyri, as well as extending into subcortical white matter tracts. Reduced fluency scores were significantly associated with an overlapping region of interest. The fluency score was negatively correlated with fraction of resected precentral, postcentral, and supramarginal components of the VLSM area. CONCLUSIONS: Broca’s aphasia does not typically arise from neurosurgical resections in Broca’s area. When Broca’s aphasia does occur after surgery, it is typically in the early postoperative period, improves by 1 month, and is associated with resections of ventral sensorimotor cortex and supramarginal gyri.

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.3171/2022.6.jns2297

Cites

44 of 44 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Figures

FIG. 1. Broca’s aphasia after surgery. A: A 3D reconstruction of the MNI brain, with Brodmann areas 44/45 outlined in white dashed lines and labeled. These correspond to pars triangularis and pars opercularis of the inferior frontal gyrus—classic Broca’s area. The central sulcus is overlaid with a red dashed line. B–E: Example of a neurosurgical resection outside of Brodmann areas 44/45 that resulted in Broca’s aphasia. Preoperative sagittal (B) and axial (C) T2 FLAIR sequences (upper images) and postoperative sagittal (D) and axial (E) sequences (lower images), with Broca’s area outlined in white dashed lines. The central sulcus is overlaid with red dashed lines. F–I: MRI scans obtained in a patient with a resection in Broca’s area who had mild, nonspecific anomia on language testing postoperatively. Preoperative sagittal (F) and axial (G) T2 FLAIR sequences (upper images) and postoperative sagittal (H) and axial (I) sequences (lower images), with Broca’s area outlined in white dashed lines. The central sulcus is overlaid with red dashed lines.
FIG. 1. Broca’s aphasia after surgery. A: A 3D reconstruction of the MNI brain, with Brodmann areas 44/45 outlined in white dashed lines and labeled. These correspond to pars triangularis and pars opercularis of the inferior frontal gyrus—classic Broca’s area. The central sulcus is overlaid with a red dashed line. B–E: Example of a neurosurgical resection outside of Brodmann areas 44/45 that resulted in Broca’s aphasia. Preoperative sagittal (B) and axial (C) T2 FLAIR sequences (upper images) and postoperative sagittal (D) and axial (E) sequences (lower images), with Broca’s area outlined in white dashed lines. The central sulcus is overlaid with red dashed lines. F–I: MRI scans obtained in a patient with a resection in Broca’s area who had mild, nonspecific anomia on language testing postoperatively. Preoperative sagittal (F) and axial (G) T2 FLAIR sequences (upper images) and postoperative sagittal (H) and axial (I) sequences (lower images), with Broca’s area outlined in white dashed lines. The central sulcus is overlaid with red dashed lines.CC BY-NC-ND · PubMed Central
FIG. 2. VLSM power and overlay. A: Axial cuts through areas of interest on the MNI brain, ranging from inferior (left) to superior (right), overlaid with the power calculated by the VLSM algorithm. The sagittal cut to the far right shows the inferior and superior margins of the axial slices depicted in the sagittal plane. B: Axial cuts of the MNI brain at the same levels as in panel A, overlaid with a lesion heat map with each pixel’s color corresponding to the number of resections overlapping with that area of space. The sagittal cut to the far right shows the inferior and superior margins of the axial slices depicted in the sagittal plane.
FIG. 2. VLSM power and overlay. A: Axial cuts through areas of interest on the MNI brain, ranging from inferior (left) to superior (right), overlaid with the power calculated by the VLSM algorithm. The sagittal cut to the far right shows the inferior and superior margins of the axial slices depicted in the sagittal plane. B: Axial cuts of the MNI brain at the same levels as in panel A, overlaid with a lesion heat map with each pixel’s color corresponding to the number of resections overlapping with that area of space. The sagittal cut to the far right shows the inferior and superior margins of the axial slices depicted in the sagittal plane.CC BY-NC-ND · PubMed Central
FIG. 3. VLSM analysis. A: 3D reconstructions of the voxels (red) most highly associated with Broca’s aphasia (p < 0.001) overlaid on the MNI brain. For anatomical reference, the white dashed line outlines Broca’s area and the red dashed line lies over the central sulcus. B: Axial slices through the t-maps of the voxels depicted in panel A, windowed for t-scores corresponding to p values < 0.001. C and D: 3D reconstructions (C) and 2D cuts (D) through t-maps of voxels associated with reductions in fluency scores independent of WAB diagnosis (i.e., without regard to a diagnosis of Broca’s aphasia). E: Overlay of the voxels statistically associated with Broca’s aphasia and those associated with deficits in fluency. F: Axial slices with the t-maps of Broca’s aphasia and fluency deficits overlaid. G: 3D reconstructions of the voxels (violet) most highly associated with Broca’s aphasia (p < 0.001) when both resection area and diffusion-restricting areas are included in the volumes of interest. H: Axial slices through the t-maps of the voxels depicted in panel G. +dwi = diffusion-weighted imaging, shorthand referring to the inclusion of diffusion-restricting areas in resectional analyses.
FIG. 3. VLSM analysis. A: 3D reconstructions of the voxels (red) most highly associated with Broca’s aphasia (p < 0.001) overlaid on the MNI brain. For anatomical reference, the white dashed line outlines Broca’s area and the red dashed line lies over the central sulcus. B: Axial slices through the t-maps of the voxels depicted in panel A, windowed for t-scores corresponding to p values < 0.001. C and D: 3D reconstructions (C) and 2D cuts (D) through t-maps of voxels associated with reductions in fluency scores independent of WAB diagnosis (i.e., without regard to a diagnosis of Broca’s aphasia). E: Overlay of the voxels statistically associated with Broca’s aphasia and those associated with deficits in fluency. F: Axial slices with the t-maps of Broca’s aphasia and fluency deficits overlaid. G: 3D reconstructions of the voxels (violet) most highly associated with Broca’s aphasia (p < 0.001) when both resection area and diffusion-restricting areas are included in the volumes of interest. H: Axial slices through the t-maps of the voxels depicted in panel G. +dwi = diffusion-weighted imaging, shorthand referring to the inclusion of diffusion-restricting areas in resectional analyses.CC BY-NC-ND · PubMed Central
FIG. 4. Broca’s aphasia and fluency deficits by pathology. Glioma resections made up 83% of this cohort and it is possible that intrinsic differences among these tumors, specifically HGG (WHO grade III or IV) versus LGG (WHO grade I or II), might influence the results. A: A total of 142 HGGs were analyzed using VLSM for association with Broca’s aphasia on a binary scale (yes or no). For anatomical reference, the white dashed line outlines Broca’s area and the red dashed line lies over the central sulcus. Voxels in red in this panel show the 3D reconstruction of voxels meeting the p < 0.001 threshold. B: Axial slices through the t-maps of the voxels depicted in panel A, windowed for t-scores corresponding to p values < 0.001. C and D: 3D reconstructions (C) and 2D cuts (D) through t-maps of voxels associated with reductions in fluency scores independent of WAB diagnosis (i.e., without regard to WAB diagnosis of Broca’s aphasia). E: A total of 97 LGGs were analyzed using VLSM for association with Broca’s aphasia on a binary scale. Voxels in red in this panel show the 3D reconstruction of voxels meeting the p < 0.001 threshold. F: Axial slices through the t-maps of the voxels depicted in panel A, windowed for t-scores corresponding to p values < 0.001. G and H: 3D reconstructions (G) and 2D cuts (H) through t-maps of voxels associated with reductions in fluency scores for a p < 0.005 in the LGG cohort.
FIG. 4. Broca’s aphasia and fluency deficits by pathology. Glioma resections made up 83% of this cohort and it is possible that intrinsic differences among these tumors, specifically HGG (WHO grade III or IV) versus LGG (WHO grade I or II), might influence the results. A: A total of 142 HGGs were analyzed using VLSM for association with Broca’s aphasia on a binary scale (yes or no). For anatomical reference, the white dashed line outlines Broca’s area and the red dashed line lies over the central sulcus. Voxels in red in this panel show the 3D reconstruction of voxels meeting the p < 0.001 threshold. B: Axial slices through the t-maps of the voxels depicted in panel A, windowed for t-scores corresponding to p values < 0.001. C and D: 3D reconstructions (C) and 2D cuts (D) through t-maps of voxels associated with reductions in fluency scores independent of WAB diagnosis (i.e., without regard to WAB diagnosis of Broca’s aphasia). E: A total of 97 LGGs were analyzed using VLSM for association with Broca’s aphasia on a binary scale. Voxels in red in this panel show the 3D reconstruction of voxels meeting the p < 0.001 threshold. F: Axial slices through the t-maps of the voxels depicted in panel A, windowed for t-scores corresponding to p values < 0.001. G and H: 3D reconstructions (G) and 2D cuts (H) through t-maps of voxels associated with reductions in fluency scores for a p < 0.005 in the LGG cohort.CC BY-NC-ND · PubMed Central
FIG. 5. Aphasia diagnoses for Broca’s area versus VLSM area resections. A: The distribution of aphasia diagnoses (dx) for resections involving Broca’s area (BA rsxn). A total of 75 resections involved Broca’s area. At postoperative day 2, 34.7% of patients with Broca’s area resections had language testing within normal limits (WNL), 37.3% were associated with a WAB diagnosis of anomia (WAB score ranges: fluency 5–10, comprehension 7–10, repetition 7–10, naming 0–9), 8.0% had Broca’s aphasia, 5.3% had global aphasia, 5.3% had Wernicke’s aphasia, 4.0% had conduction aphasia, 2.7% had transcortical motor aphasia, and 2.7% had transcortical sensory aphasia. B: Fractional resections of Broca’s area on the y-axis and aphasia diagnosis on the x-axis, for each patient with a resection involving Broca’s area. C: Lateral diagrammatic overlay of all resections that involved Broca’s area, superimposed with dashed outlines of Broca’s area (labeled "BA") and the area identified by the VLSM algorithm as significantly associated with Broca’s aphasia (labeled "VLSM"). D: Overlays of the 6/75 patients with Broca’s area resections who had Broca’s aphasia postoperatively, colored violet in the 3 whose resections did not overlap with the VLSM area, and colored pink in the 3 whose resections overlapped with the VLSM area. E: The distribution of aphasia diagnoses for resections involving the area identified by the VLSM algorithm as significantly associated with Broca’s aphasia (i.e., VLSM area). A total of 44 patients had resections in the VLSM area. Of these, 40.9% had language within normal limits. A total of 25.0% had Broca’s aphasia, 18.2% had anomia, 9.1% had conduction aphasia, 4.5% had global aphasia, 2.3% had transcortical motor aphasia, and none had transcortical sensory or Wernicke’s aphasia. F: Fractional resections of VLSM area on the y-axis and aphasia diagnosis on the x-axis, for each patient with a resection involving the VLSM area. G: Outlines of all 44 resections involving the VLSM area, superimposed with dashed outlines of Broca’s area and the VLSM area. H: The 11/44 resections involving the VLSM area that were associated with Broca’s aphasia. The 8 VLSM resections that did not involve Broca’s area are in pink, whereas the 3 that colocalized to Broca’s area are in violet.
FIG. 5. Aphasia diagnoses for Broca’s area versus VLSM area resections. A: The distribution of aphasia diagnoses (dx) for resections involving Broca’s area (BA rsxn). A total of 75 resections involved Broca’s area. At postoperative day 2, 34.7% of patients with Broca’s area resections had language testing within normal limits (WNL), 37.3% were associated with a WAB diagnosis of anomia (WAB score ranges: fluency 5–10, comprehension 7–10, repetition 7–10, naming 0–9), 8.0% had Broca’s aphasia, 5.3% had global aphasia, 5.3% had Wernicke’s aphasia, 4.0% had conduction aphasia, 2.7% had transcortical motor aphasia, and 2.7% had transcortical sensory aphasia. B: Fractional resections of Broca’s area on the y-axis and aphasia diagnosis on the x-axis, for each patient with a resection involving Broca’s area. C: Lateral diagrammatic overlay of all resections that involved Broca’s area, superimposed with dashed outlines of Broca’s area (labeled "BA") and the area identified by the VLSM algorithm as significantly associated with Broca’s aphasia (labeled "VLSM"). D: Overlays of the 6/75 patients with Broca’s area resections who had Broca’s aphasia postoperatively, colored violet in the 3 whose resections did not overlap with the VLSM area, and colored pink in the 3 whose resections overlapped with the VLSM area. E: The distribution of aphasia diagnoses for resections involving the area identified by the VLSM algorithm as significantly associated with Broca’s aphasia (i.e., VLSM area). A total of 44 patients had resections in the VLSM area. Of these, 40.9% had language within normal limits. A total of 25.0% had Broca’s aphasia, 18.2% had anomia, 9.1% had conduction aphasia, 4.5% had global aphasia, 2.3% had transcortical motor aphasia, and none had transcortical sensory or Wernicke’s aphasia. F: Fractional resections of VLSM area on the y-axis and aphasia diagnosis on the x-axis, for each patient with a resection involving the VLSM area. G: Outlines of all 44 resections involving the VLSM area, superimposed with dashed outlines of Broca’s area and the VLSM area. H: The 11/44 resections involving the VLSM area that were associated with Broca’s aphasia. The 8 VLSM resections that did not involve Broca’s area are in pink, whereas the 3 that colocalized to Broca’s area are in violet.CC BY-NC-ND · PubMed Central
FIG. 6. Fractional resections of Broca’s area and VLSM area gyral components versus fluency score. Resections of Broca’s area and the VLSM area were parsed into their component gyri and quantified based on the estimated fractional resection (from 0 = no involvement to 1 = total resection of the component in that gyrus) of each component. Broca’s area was divided into pars triangularis and pars opercularis and the VLSM area was divided into its components within precentral, postcentral, and supramarginal gyri. Fluency scores are plotted on the y-axis and fractional resections (0 = no resection, 1.0 = complete resection) on the x-axis. A–C: Components of Broca’s area, pars triangularis (A) and pars opercularis (B), with the fractional resections of Broca’s area as a whole (C). None of these showed significant correlations of fluency with fractional resection (A: p = 0.51, B: p = 0.63, C: p = 0.19). D–F: Fractional resections of the components of the VLSM area: precentral gyrus component (D), postcentral gyrus component (E), and supramarginal gyrus component (F). G: The VLSM area resection as a whole is shown. All 3 subcomponents of the VLSM area as well as the VLSM area treated as a whole were significantly correlated with reduced fluency (D: p = 0.006, E: p = 0.002, F: p < 0.001, G: p = 0.001). *Statistically significant at p < 0.05. Post-C = postcentral gyrus; Pre-C = precentral gyrus.
FIG. 6. Fractional resections of Broca’s area and VLSM area gyral components versus fluency score. Resections of Broca’s area and the VLSM area were parsed into their component gyri and quantified based on the estimated fractional resection (from 0 = no involvement to 1 = total resection of the component in that gyrus) of each component. Broca’s area was divided into pars triangularis and pars opercularis and the VLSM area was divided into its components within precentral, postcentral, and supramarginal gyri. Fluency scores are plotted on the y-axis and fractional resections (0 = no resection, 1.0 = complete resection) on the x-axis. A–C: Components of Broca’s area, pars triangularis (A) and pars opercularis (B), with the fractional resections of Broca’s area as a whole (C). None of these showed significant correlations of fluency with fractional resection (A: p = 0.51, B: p = 0.63, C: p = 0.19). D–F: Fractional resections of the components of the VLSM area: precentral gyrus component (D), postcentral gyrus component (E), and supramarginal gyrus component (F). G: The VLSM area resection as a whole is shown. All 3 subcomponents of the VLSM area as well as the VLSM area treated as a whole were significantly correlated with reduced fluency (D: p = 0.006, E: p = 0.002, F: p < 0.001, G: p = 0.001). *Statistically significant at p < 0.05. Post-C = postcentral gyrus; Pre-C = precentral gyrus.CC BY-NC-ND · PubMed Central

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Claims other papers make about this one

Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Citations

Cites

Show all 44 references

Research works printed but not linked: 2

  1. Benzagmout M, Gatignol P, Duffau H. Resection of World Health Organization Grade II gliomas involving Broca’s area: methodological and functional considerations. Neurosurgery. 2007;61(4):741–753.17986935
  2. Mohr JP, Pessin MS, Finkelstein S, Funkenstein HH, Duncan GW, Davis KR. Broca aphasia: pathologic and clinical. Neurology. 1978;28(4):311–324.565019

Cited by

See all 39

Metadata

Authors
Andrews, J. P., Cahn, N., Speidel, B. A., Chung, J. E., Levy, D. F., Wilson, S. M., Berger, M. S., & Chang, E. F.
Affiliations
  • University of California, San Francisco (US)
  • Vanderbilt University Medical Center (US)
Corresponding author
Chang, Edward F.
Venue
Journal of Neurosurgery
Published
2023-03-01
Volume
138
Issue
3
Pages
847-857
ISSN
  • 0022-3085 (ISSN-L)
  • 1933-0693
OpenAlex
W4289885484
Cited by
37
References
44
Citations by year
2026: 4 · 2025: 9 · 2024: 9 · 2023: 13
FWCI
4.25
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Locations
  • Journal of neurosurgery (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc-nd)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc-nd)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
  • eScholarship (California Digital Library) (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc-nd)
Funders
  • National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders (F32DC020096)
  • National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke (U01NS098971)
Topics
  • Life Sciences › Neuroscience › Cognitive Neuroscience › Neurobiology of Language and Bilingualism
  • Social Sciences › Psychology › Developmental and Educational Psychology › Reading and Literacy Development
  • Life Sciences › Neuroscience › Neurology › Neurology and Historical Studies
Keywords
Broca's aphasia, Broca's area, surgical resection, voxel-based lesion-symptom mapping, speech fluency, supramarginal gyrus, inferior frontal gyrus, postoperative language deficits
MeSH terms
Aphasia, Broca, Brain, Brain Mapping, Frontal Lobe, Humans, Magnetic Resonance Imaging, Broca Area

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Dissociation of Broca’s area from Broca’s aphasia in patients undergoing neurosurgical resections. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.3171/2022.6.jns2297
The paper
Andrews, J. P., Cahn, N., Speidel, B. A., Chung, J. E., Levy, D. F., Wilson, S. M., Berger, M. S., & Chang, E. F. (2023). Dissociation of Broca’s area from Broca’s aphasia in patients undergoing neurosurgical resections. Journal of Neurosurgery. https://doi.org/10.3171/2022.6.jns2297

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.