CoChat

Clumped Isotope Reordering and Kinetic Differences in Co-Hosted Calcite and Dolomite Minerals throughout Burial Diagenesis and Exhumation

Open access

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 133 of the 133 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; 36 of the 136 sources its claims cite were checked for support.

Abstract

The clumped isotope paleo-thermometer has become a valuable proxy for the burial history reconstruction of carbonate formations. To maximise the accuracy of these reconstructions, post-depositional alterations, such as recrystallisation and Δ47 isotope exchange reactions, must be understood. In this study, we examine the isotopic behaviour of calcites and early dolomite samples from the same stratigraphic intervals, and thus with similar burial history. This approach provides additional constraints on the kinetics of Δ47 reordering in dolomite during exhumation. Clumped isotope measurements were performed on 19 calcites and 15 early dolomites from the Permian, Jurassic, and Cretaceous periods from four locations in Oman spanning different burial regimes. The calcite and dolomite samples were collected from the rock matrix, based on the assumption that fine material was more susceptible to recrystallisation. Our results show that calcites and dolomites record different Δ47 values despite being subjected to the same thermal history. The maximum Δ47 temperature recorded in dolomites (181 ± 13 °C) corresponds to the oldest and most deeply buried Permian rock. This value is approximately 35 °C higher than those measured in the co-located and coeval calcite matrix (145 ± 14 °C). This discrepancy suggests that calcite and dolomite have different kinetic parameters. Our data confirm (1) that dolomite Δ47 values are more resistant to alteration during burial and exhumation than Δ47 calcite values, and (2) that dolomite has a higher Δ47 closing temperature than calcite during cooling. The presence of two mineral phases with distinct kinetic parameters in the same stratigraphic unit provides additional constraints on models of burial and uplift. In addition, mineralogical data coupled with Δ47 and burial depths suggest that the progressive development of dolomite cation ordering is driven by temperature elevation, as previously suggested.

Overview

CoChat Summary

TL;DR

Co-hosted calcite and early dolomite from Permian, Jurassic, and Cretaceous carbonates in Oman/UAE record different Δ47 temperatures despite similar burial histories, with dolomite generally more resistant to reordering and having a higher closing temperature. Forward models show paired calcite–dolomite records can constrain burial/exhumation histories, including a previously undetected uplift in the offshore Arabian Gulf and peak burial temperatures of ~280 °C in Jabal Akhdar.

Key findings

  • In the deepest Permian Jabal Akhdar samples, dolomite mean Δ47 temperature is 181 ± 13 °C versus 145 ± 14 °C for co-located calcite; the abstract describes this as ~35 °C higher, while Table 3 lists a maximum dolomite–calcite disparity of 45 ± 19 °C.
  • The maximum Δ47 temperature disparity between dolomite and calcite increases with maximum burial: 5 ± 4 °C at Haushi-Huqf, 29 ± 17 °C offshore Arabian Gulf, 61 ± 23 °C in Jurassic Jabal Akhdar, and 45 ± 19 °C in Permian Jabal Akhdar. The Musandam Peninsula is an exception attributed to dedolomitisation and low dolomite abundance (<35%).
  • Dolomite Δ47 values are more resistant to alteration during burial and exhumation than calcite Δ47 values, and dolomite has a higher Δ47 closing temperature during cooling. Cation ordering correlates positively with Δ47 temperature in the Jurassic and Permian intervals, but stoichiometry and cation ordering show no interrelationship.
  • Forward modeling indicates solid-state reordering alone cannot explain the Arabian Gulf records; a 190 °C peak with 1.32 °C/Ma heating is needed, implying ~1750 m deeper burial (~4700 m) or a higher geothermal gradient/minimum 200 m uplift. For Jabal Akhdar, an exhumation model requires a 280 °C peak and 3.18 °C/Ma cooling to match measured Δ47 values (calcite predicted 0.350 ± 0.020‰ vs measured 0.346 ± 0.001‰; dolomite predicted 0.325 ± 0.031‰ vs measured 0.313 ± 0.014‰).

Methods

  • 34 samples (19 calcites, 15 early dolomites) from Permian, Jurassic, and Cretaceous intervals at four locations in Oman and the United Arab Emirates; fine rock-matrix material was sampled with a dental drill, crushed, and sieved.
  • Petrography and cathodoluminescence, FTIR, and XRD were used for mineralogy, dolomite abundance, stoichiometry, and cation ordering. Clumped isotopes and δ18O/δ13C were measured at Imperial College London using the IBEX system, corrected to I-CDES, with temperatures calculated using the Anderson et al. (2021) calibration.
  • Forward solid-state reordering models were run with isotopylog, testing a paired-diffusion model for calcite and a disordered kinetic model for calcite and dolomite under Arabian Gulf burial and Jabal Akhdar exhumation scenarios.

Limitations

  • The paper states that the Musandam Peninsula similarity between calcite and dolomite is attributed to dedolomitisation and low dolomite abundance (<35%); Haushi-Huqf’s shallow burial was insufficient to trigger Δ47 reordering; and model scenarios depend on assumed initial/final temperatures and burial histories.
  • Evident from the text: per-area mineral sample sizes are small (n = 2–5 in Table 3), and the Arabian Gulf interpretation requires either deeper burial or a higher geothermal gradient than published burial histories indicate.

Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.3390/min13121466

Cites

133 of 133 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Nothing to recompute.

Figures

Figure 1 Study locations from shallow to deep burial tectonic se tt ings: (1) the Haushi-Huqf in Oman; (2) offshore Arabian Gulf; (3) the Musandam Peninsula; and (4) the Jabal Akhdar, Central Oman mountains. Regional map modified from Loosveld et al. [49] and Cooper et al. [50]. Figure 1. Study locations from shallow to deep burial tectonic settings: (1) the Haushi-Huqf in Oman; (2) offshore Arabian Gulf; (3) the Musandam Peninsula; and (4) the Jabal Akhdar, Central Oman mountains. Regional map modified from Loosveld et al. [49] and Cooper et al. [50].
Figure 1 Study locations from shallow to deep burial tectonic se tt ings: (1) the Haushi-Huqf in Oman; (2) offshore Arabian Gulf; (3) the Musandam Peninsula; and (4) the Jabal Akhdar, Central Oman mountains. Regional map modified from Loosveld et al. [49] and Cooper et al. [50]. Figure 1. Study locations from shallow to deep burial tectonic settings: (1) the Haushi-Huqf in Oman; (2) offshore Arabian Gulf; (3) the Musandam Peninsula; and (4) the Jabal Akhdar, Central Oman mountains. Regional map modified from Loosveld et al. [49] and Cooper et al. [50].From the PDF
Figure 2 The sample position on the stratigraphic column of each region was modified from Loosveld et al. [49] and Cooper et al. [50]. (1) The Cretaceous Thamama Group in the Haushi-Huqf; (2) the Cretaceous Thamama Group in the offshore Arabian Gulf; (3) the Jurassic Mudandam Group in the Musandam Peninsula; and (4) the Jurassic Sahtan Group and Permian Akhdar Group on the Jabal Akhdar, Central Oman Mountains. The wavy line on top of the formation represents the unconformity/sequence boundary, and the dashed line reflects the correlation to the other adjacent region. Figure 2. The sample position on the stratigraphic column of each region was modified from Loosveld et al. [49] and Cooper et al. [50]. (1) The Cretaceous Thamama Group in the Haushi-Huqf; (2) the Cretaceous Thamama Group in the offshore Arabian Gulf; (3) the Jurassic Mudandam Group in the Musandam Peninsula; and (4) the Jurassic Sahtan Group and Permian Akhdar Group on the Jabal Akhdar, Central Oman Mountains. The wavy line on top of the formation represents the unconformity/sequence boundary, and the dashed line reflects the correlation to the other adjacent region.
Figure 2 The sample position on the stratigraphic column of each region was modified from Loosveld et al. [49] and Cooper et al. [50]. (1) The Cretaceous Thamama Group in the Haushi-Huqf; (2) the Cretaceous Thamama Group in the offshore Arabian Gulf; (3) the Jurassic Mudandam Group in the Musandam Peninsula; and (4) the Jurassic Sahtan Group and Permian Akhdar Group on the Jabal Akhdar, Central Oman Mountains. The wavy line on top of the formation represents the unconformity/sequence boundary, and the dashed line reflects the correlation to the other adjacent region. Figure 2. The sample position on the stratigraphic column of each region was modified from Loosveld et al. [49] and Cooper et al. [50]. (1) The Cretaceous Thamama Group in the Haushi-Huqf; (2) the Cretaceous Thamama Group in the offshore Arabian Gulf; (3) the Jurassic Mudandam Group in the Musandam Peninsula; and (4) the Jurassic Sahtan Group and Permian Akhdar Group on the Jabal Akhdar, Central Oman Mountains. The wavy line on top of the formation represents the unconformity/sequence boundary, and the dashed line reflects the correlation to the other adjacent region.From the PDF
Figure 3 Limestone photomicrographs with cold cathodoluminescence. ( A ) Ibrahim6840 Cretaceous sample from Area 2 comprises wackestone-packstone texture, recrystallised skeletal grain, and inhomogenous crystal-sized micrite with series of dark to bright red luminescence. ( B ) WN625_Gry Jurassic sample from Area 3 comprises micritised-ooids wackestone with dolomite rhombs floating in a calcite cement matrix and ooids. A trace of calcitification (dull luminescence) is recognised inside dolomite rhombs. ( C ) Mist-6 Jurassic sample from Area 4 comprises micrite-dominated mudstone-wackestone with patch of sparite or equant-blocky calcite crystal. ( D ) Ak-7 Permian sample from Area 4 consists of mudstone with inhomogenous crystal-sized micrite. 'Rec.': recrystallised form; 'Dol': dolomite cement; 'Ms': micro-seam fracture; 'ic': interlocking contact; 'Bc': equant-blocky calcite. Figure 3. Limestone photomicrographs with cold cathodoluminescence. ( A ) Ibrahim6840 Cretaceous sample from Area 2 comprises wackestone-packstone texture, recrystallised skeletal grain, and inhomogenous crystal-sized micrite with series of dark to bright red luminescence. ( B ) WN625_Gry Jurassic sample from Area 3 comprises micritised-ooids wackestone with dolomite rhombs floating in a calcite cement matrix and ooids. A trace of calcitification (dull luminescence) is recognised inside dolomite rhombs. ( C ) Mist-6 Jurassic sample from Area 4 comprises micrite-dominated mudstonewackestone with patch of sparite or equant-blocky calcite crystal. ( D ) Ak-7 Permian sample from Area 4 consists of mudstone with inhomogenous crystal-sized micrite. 'Rec.': recrystallised form; 'Dol': dolomite cement; 'Ms': micro-seam fracture; 'ic': interlocking contact; 'Bc': equant-blocky calcite.
Figure 3 Limestone photomicrographs with cold cathodoluminescence. ( A ) Ibrahim6840 Cretaceous sample from Area 2 comprises wackestone-packstone texture, recrystallised skeletal grain, and inhomogenous crystal-sized micrite with series of dark to bright red luminescence. ( B ) WN625_Gry Jurassic sample from Area 3 comprises micritised-ooids wackestone with dolomite rhombs floating in a calcite cement matrix and ooids. A trace of calcitification (dull luminescence) is recognised inside dolomite rhombs. ( C ) Mist-6 Jurassic sample from Area 4 comprises micrite-dominated mudstone-wackestone with patch of sparite or equant-blocky calcite crystal. ( D ) Ak-7 Permian sample from Area 4 consists of mudstone with inhomogenous crystal-sized micrite. 'Rec.': recrystallised form; 'Dol': dolomite cement; 'Ms': micro-seam fracture; 'ic': interlocking contact; 'Bc': equant-blocky calcite. Figure 3. Limestone photomicrographs with cold cathodoluminescence. ( A ) Ibrahim6840 Cretaceous sample from Area 2 comprises wackestone-packstone texture, recrystallised skeletal grain, and inhomogenous crystal-sized micrite with series of dark to bright red luminescence. ( B ) WN625_Gry Jurassic sample from Area 3 comprises micritised-ooids wackestone with dolomite rhombs floating in a calcite cement matrix and ooids. A trace of calcitification (dull luminescence) is recognised inside dolomite rhombs. ( C ) Mist-6 Jurassic sample from Area 4 comprises micrite-dominated mudstonewackestone with patch of sparite or equant-blocky calcite crystal. ( D ) Ak-7 Permian sample from Area 4 consists of mudstone with inhomogenous crystal-sized micrite. 'Rec.': recrystallised form; 'Dol': dolomite cement; 'Ms': micro-seam fracture; 'ic': interlocking contact; 'Bc': equant-blocky calcite.From the PDF
Figure 4 Dolomite photomicrographs with cold cathodoluminescence. ( A ) Ibrahim652 Cretaceous sample from Area 2 consists of fine to medium nonplanar-a to planar-e dolomite crystals with irregular or extensively interlocking contact. ( B ) WN526_Gry Jurassic sample from Area 3 consists of fine to medium nonplanar-a to planar-e dolomite crystals with trace of calcitification/dedolomitisation (dull luminescence) recognised inside rhomb nuclei. ( C ) Mist-9 Jurassic sample from Area 4 comprises dark luminescent planar-e to planar-s dolomite with interlocking crystals. The micritic matrix appears to have brighter luminescence compared to the medium-sized rhomb crystals. ( D ) Ak-25 Permian samples from Area 4 consist of fine to medium planar-e to nonplanar-a dolomite crystals interlocking each other. 'Dd': dedolomitisation; 'ic': interlocking contact; 'Np-a': nonplanar-a. Figure 4. Dolomite photomicrographs with cold cathodoluminescence. ( A ) Ibrahim652 Cretaceous sample from Area 2 consists of fine to medium nonplanar-a to planar-e dolomite crystals with irregular or extensively interlocking contact. ( B ) WN526_Gry Jurassic sample from Area 3 consists of fine to medium nonplanar-a to planar-e dolomite crystals with trace of calcitification/dedolomitisation (dull luminescence) recognised inside rhomb nuclei. ( C ) Mist-9 Jurassic sample from Area 4 comprises dark luminescent planar-e to planar-s dolomite with interlocking crystals. The micritic matrix appears to have brighter luminescence compared to the medium-sized rhomb crystals. ( D ) Ak-25 Permian samples from Area 4 consist of fine to medium planar-e to nonplanar-a dolomite crystals interlocking each other. 'Dd': dedolomitisation; 'ic': interlocking contact; 'Np-a': nonplanar-a.
Figure 4 Dolomite photomicrographs with cold cathodoluminescence. ( A ) Ibrahim652 Cretaceous sample from Area 2 consists of fine to medium nonplanar-a to planar-e dolomite crystals with irregular or extensively interlocking contact. ( B ) WN526_Gry Jurassic sample from Area 3 consists of fine to medium nonplanar-a to planar-e dolomite crystals with trace of calcitification/dedolomitisation (dull luminescence) recognised inside rhomb nuclei. ( C ) Mist-9 Jurassic sample from Area 4 comprises dark luminescent planar-e to planar-s dolomite with interlocking crystals. The micritic matrix appears to have brighter luminescence compared to the medium-sized rhomb crystals. ( D ) Ak-25 Permian samples from Area 4 consist of fine to medium planar-e to nonplanar-a dolomite crystals interlocking each other. 'Dd': dedolomitisation; 'ic': interlocking contact; 'Np-a': nonplanar-a. Figure 4. Dolomite photomicrographs with cold cathodoluminescence. ( A ) Ibrahim652 Cretaceous sample from Area 2 consists of fine to medium nonplanar-a to planar-e dolomite crystals with irregular or extensively interlocking contact. ( B ) WN526_Gry Jurassic sample from Area 3 consists of fine to medium nonplanar-a to planar-e dolomite crystals with trace of calcitification/dedolomitisation (dull luminescence) recognised inside rhomb nuclei. ( C ) Mist-9 Jurassic sample from Area 4 comprises dark luminescent planar-e to planar-s dolomite with interlocking crystals. The micritic matrix appears to have brighter luminescence compared to the medium-sized rhomb crystals. ( D ) Ak-25 Permian samples from Area 4 consist of fine to medium planar-e to nonplanar-a dolomite crystals interlocking each other. 'Dd': dedolomitisation; 'ic': interlocking contact; 'Np-a': nonplanar-a.From the PDF
Figure 5 Cross-plot of δ 18 Oand δ 13 C of each area used in this study. ( A ) Comparison of δ 18 Oand δ 13 C composition, including the burial history information on each area. Calcite and early dolomite are labelled in order to best highlight trends in geographic areas and sample ages. ( B ) Cretaceous samples from an outcrop in Haushi-Huqf and subsurface core in the offshore Arabian Gulf. Published bulk isotope composition from Sena et al. [63], John [9], and Adlan and John [33] are also shown. ( C ) Jurassic samples from an outcrop in the Musandam Peninsula and Jabal Akhdar area, Central Oman Mountains. ( D ) Permian samples from Central Oman Mountains. Within figures ( B -D ), the Cretaceous, Jurassic, and Permian subsurface samples from clumped isotopes studied in Central Oman High (HM well; HM-13-1 at 1115 m depth and HM-14-1 at 1199 m) by Bergmann et al. [37] are also shown.
Figure 5 Cross-plot of δ 18 Oand δ 13 C of each area used in this study. ( A ) Comparison of δ 18 Oand δ 13 C composition, including the burial history information on each area. Calcite and early dolomite are labelled in order to best highlight trends in geographic areas and sample ages. ( B ) Cretaceous samples from an outcrop in Haushi-Huqf and subsurface core in the offshore Arabian Gulf. Published bulk isotope composition from Sena et al. [63], John [9], and Adlan and John [33] are also shown. ( C ) Jurassic samples from an outcrop in the Musandam Peninsula and Jabal Akhdar area, Central Oman Mountains. ( D ) Permian samples from Central Oman Mountains. Within figures ( B -D ), the Cretaceous, Jurassic, and Permian subsurface samples from clumped isotopes studied in Central Oman High (HM well; HM-13-1 at 1115 m depth and HM-14-1 at 1199 m) by Bergmann et al. [37] are also shown.From the PDF
Figure 6 The Δ 47 temperature versus the calculated δ 18 O of the diagenetic fluid. Values were reconstructed using the Friedman and O'Neil [104] equation for calcite and the Horita [113] equation for dolomite. The isolines showed the mineral composition ( δ 18 Oca) of the samples. ( A ) Overall data according to area, including the burial history information. ( B ) Cretaceous samples from an outcrop in Haushi-Huqf and subsurface core in the offshore Arabian Gulf. Published bulk isotope composition from Sena et al. [63], John [9], and Adlan and John [33] are also shown. ( C ) Jurassic samples from outcrops in the Musandam Peninsula and Jabal Akhdar. ( D ) Permian samples from outcrop in Jabal Akhdar. Figure 6. The D 47 temperature versus the calculated δ 18 O of the diagenetic fluid. Values were reconstructed using the Friedman and O'Neil [104] equation for calcite and the Horita [113] equation for dolomite. The isolines showed the mineral composition ( δ 18 Oca) of the samples. ( A ) Overall data according to area, including the burial history information. ( B ) Cretaceous samples from an outcrop in Haushi-Huqf and subsurface core in the offshore Arabian Gulf. Published bulk isotope composition from Sena et al. [63], John [9], and Adlan and John [33] are also shown. ( C ) Jurassic samples from outcrops in the Musandam Peninsula and Jabal Akhdar. ( D ) Permian samples from outcrop in Jabal Akhdar.
Figure 6 The Δ 47 temperature versus the calculated δ 18 O of the diagenetic fluid. Values were reconstructed using the Friedman and O'Neil [104] equation for calcite and the Horita [113] equation for dolomite. The isolines showed the mineral composition ( δ 18 Oca) of the samples. ( A ) Overall data according to area, including the burial history information. ( B ) Cretaceous samples from an outcrop in Haushi-Huqf and subsurface core in the offshore Arabian Gulf. Published bulk isotope composition from Sena et al. [63], John [9], and Adlan and John [33] are also shown. ( C ) Jurassic samples from outcrops in the Musandam Peninsula and Jabal Akhdar. ( D ) Permian samples from outcrop in Jabal Akhdar. Figure 6. The D 47 temperature versus the calculated δ 18 O of the diagenetic fluid. Values were reconstructed using the Friedman and O'Neil [104] equation for calcite and the Horita [113] equation for dolomite. The isolines showed the mineral composition ( δ 18 Oca) of the samples. ( A ) Overall data according to area, including the burial history information. ( B ) Cretaceous samples from an outcrop in Haushi-Huqf and subsurface core in the offshore Arabian Gulf. Published bulk isotope composition from Sena et al. [63], John [9], and Adlan and John [33] are also shown. ( C ) Jurassic samples from outcrops in the Musandam Peninsula and Jabal Akhdar. ( D ) Permian samples from outcrop in Jabal Akhdar.From the PDF
Figure 7 Difference between maximum Δ 47 temperature recorded in dolomite and calcite with respect to its maximum burial reached (see Table 3). Published temperature difference from Bergmann et al. [37], and Lu et al. [114] are also shown. The disparity between temperatures recorded in both minerals increases as the rock formation is buried deeper. Figure 7. Difference between maximum D 47 temperature recorded in dolomite and calcite with respect to its maximum burial reached (see Table 3). Published temperature difference from Bergmann et al. [37], and Lu et al. [114] are also shown. The disparity between temperatures recorded in both minerals increases as the rock formation is buried deeper.
Figure 7 Difference between maximum Δ 47 temperature recorded in dolomite and calcite with respect to its maximum burial reached (see Table 3). Published temperature difference from Bergmann et al. [37], and Lu et al. [114] are also shown. The disparity between temperatures recorded in both minerals increases as the rock formation is buried deeper. Figure 7. Difference between maximum D 47 temperature recorded in dolomite and calcite with respect to its maximum burial reached (see Table 3). Published temperature difference from Bergmann et al. [37], and Lu et al. [114] are also shown. The disparity between temperatures recorded in both minerals increases as the rock formation is buried deeper.From the PDF
Figure 8 Dolomite {015}:{110} cation ordering and Δ 47 temperature relationship. Cation ordering correlates positively with Δ 47 temperature in two of the largest datasets, showing that high-temperature (low Δ 47 ) dolomite corresponds to well-ordered dolomite. Figure 8. Dolomite {015}:{110} cation ordering and D 47 temperature relationship. Cation ordering correlates positively with D 47 temperature in two of the largest datasets, showing that high-temperature (low D 47 ) dolomite corresponds to well-ordered dolomite.
Figure 8 Dolomite {015}:{110} cation ordering and Δ 47 temperature relationship. Cation ordering correlates positively with Δ 47 temperature in two of the largest datasets, showing that high-temperature (low Δ 47 ) dolomite corresponds to well-ordered dolomite. Figure 8. Dolomite {015}:{110} cation ordering and D 47 temperature relationship. Cation ordering correlates positively with D 47 temperature in two of the largest datasets, showing that high-temperature (low D 47 ) dolomite corresponds to well-ordered dolomite.From the PDF
Figure 9 Result of forward model ( A ) with peak burial at present-day formation temperature of 130 °C, where the prediction and actual clumped isotope temperature are inaccurate. Forward model Figure 9. Result of forward model ( A ) with peak burial at present-day formation temperature of 130 ◦ C, where the prediction and actual clumped isotope temperature are inaccurate. Forward model ( B ) with peak burial scenario of 190 ◦ C, where the model hardly fits the prediction. The results of the Stolper and Eiler [7] equation on calcite minerals and the Hemingway and Henkes [17] equation on both calcite and dolomite are shown.
Figure 9 Result of forward model ( A ) with peak burial at present-day formation temperature of 130 °C, where the prediction and actual clumped isotope temperature are inaccurate. Forward model Figure 9. Result of forward model ( A ) with peak burial at present-day formation temperature of 130 ◦ C, where the prediction and actual clumped isotope temperature are inaccurate. Forward model ( B ) with peak burial scenario of 190 ◦ C, where the model hardly fits the prediction. The results of the Stolper and Eiler [7] equation on calcite minerals and the Hemingway and Henkes [17] equation on both calcite and dolomite are shown.From the PDF
Figure 10 Results of the forward model from peak burial 280 °C cooled down to 25 °C. Using the Hemingway and Henkes model [17], the prediction fits the actual clumped isotope temperature. The result of the Stolper and Eiler [7] equation is also shown. Figure 10. Results of the forward model from peak burial 280 ◦ C cooled down to 25 ◦ C. Using the Hemingway and Henkes model [17], the prediction fits the actual clumped isotope temperature. The result of the Stolper and Eiler [7] equation is also shown.
Figure 10 Results of the forward model from peak burial 280 °C cooled down to 25 °C. Using the Hemingway and Henkes model [17], the prediction fits the actual clumped isotope temperature. The result of the Stolper and Eiler [7] equation is also shown. Figure 10. Results of the forward model from peak burial 280 ◦ C cooled down to 25 ◦ C. Using the Hemingway and Henkes model [17], the prediction fits the actual clumped isotope temperature. The result of the Stolper and Eiler [7] equation is also shown.From the PDF

Verification

Claims the paper makes

29 Valid · 4 Not valid · 34 Not checked · 101 Own results and interpretations

72 more claims · 7 with their cited sources checked

Create a free account to see all 168 claims and every source verdict.

See all claims — free account
  • Probably not a substantial claim. 42
  • It may state two separate claims as one. 56

Create a free account to see these claims.

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

Each contradiction between two passages listed here was confirmed by an independent check.

5 of 8 · the rest aren’t loaded

3 more findings

Create a free account to see every finding of this check.

See all findings — free account

Citations

Cites

Show all 133 references

Research works printed but not linked: 4

  1. Hashem, 2009, Post-obduction deformations of the northwestern end of the Hatta Shear Zone, El Rawdah area, Northern Oman Mountains, Math. Comput. Sci. Eng., 18, 79
  2. Alsharhan, A.S., and Nairn, A.E.M. (2003). Sedimentary Basins and Petroleum Geology of the Middle East, Elsevier Science B.V.
  3. Choquette, 1990, Limestones—The burial diagenetic environment, Geosci. Can. Repr. Ser., 4, 75
  4. Hantschel, T., and Kauerauf, A.I. (2009). Fundamentals of Basin and Petroleum Systems Modeling, Springer.

Cited by

See all 6

Metadata

Authors
Adlan, Q., Kaczmarek, S., & John, C.
Affiliations
  • Imperial College London (GB)
  • Western Michigan University (US)
Corresponding author
John, Cédric
Venue
Minerals
Publisher
MDPI AG
Published
2023-11-22
Volume
13
Issue
12
Pages
1466
ISSN
2075-163X (ISSN-L)
OpenAlex
W4388900799
Cited by
6
References
129
Citations by year
2026: 2 · 2025: 3 · 2024: 1
FWCI
0.67
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Locations
Minerals (publishedVersion, cc-by)
Funders
Indonesia Endowment Fund for Education
Topics
  • Physical Sciences › Earth and Planetary Sciences › Geology › Hydrocarbon exploration and reservoir analysis
  • Physical Sciences › Earth and Planetary Sciences › Paleontology › Paleontology and Stratigraphy of Fossils
  • Physical Sciences › Earth and Planetary Sciences › Geochemistry and Petrology › Geological and Geochemical Analysis
Keywords
clumped isotopes, calcite, recrystallization, burial diagenesis, exhumation, burial history, paleothermometry, kinetic parameters, Permian, Jurassic, Cretaceous, Oman

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

The claim verdicts this report counts are experimental: their accuracy is not yet measured.

A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-09-28, under version 3 of the claim definition (prompt extract-v3).

A second model labelled each claim on 2026-09-28 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).

Cited sources are checked with a language model’s help (gpt-6-sol).

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Clumped Isotope Reordering and Kinetic Differences in Co-Hosted Calcite and Dolomite Minerals throughout Burial Diagenesis and Exhumation. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.3390/min13121466
The paper
Adlan, Q., Kaczmarek, S., & John, C. (2023). Clumped Isotope Reordering and Kinetic Differences in Co-Hosted Calcite and Dolomite Minerals throughout Burial Diagenesis and Exhumation. Minerals. https://doi.org/10.3390/min13121466

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.