The Past Hypothesis and the Nature of Physical Laws

“ther PH can count as a fundamental Lewisian law and whether SP can count as objective probabilities on the best-system account. Anticipating the need to add a boundary condition into the best system, Lewis (1983) writes, A law is any regularity that earns inclusion in the ideal system. (Or, in case of ties, in every i…”

“s of non-Humean theories: 1.Primitivism: fundamental laws are primitive facts in the world. 2. Reductionism: fundamental laws are analyzed in terms of something outside the mosaic. Carroll (1994) and Maudlin (2007) maintain primitivist versions of non-Humeanism. Hildebrand (2013) provides a survey of the reductionist…”

“hese ideas can be found in (Albert 2000, 2012) and (Loewer 2007), and they are also discussed in (Frisch 2005, 2007), (Demarest 2019), (Fernandes, this volume), (Callender 2004), (Horwich 1987), and (Reichenbach 1956). The records arrow. We have photographs and videos of WWII but no photographs of the next major world…”

“3For more on the notion of typicality and its application in statistical mechanics, see (Goldstein 2012), (Lazarovici & Reichert 2015), and (Wilhelm 2019). degrees of freedom are in a special state, providing a sense that the total state of the early universe has low entropy.”

“states of higher entropy in the future direction. But there is nothing earlier than t 0, as it is stipulated to be the initial time, say, the time of the Big Bang.12 11Boltzmann’s original H-theorem (Boltzmann 1964)[1898] is an attempt to show this. Lanford (1975) produces an exact result for a simple system of hard s…”

“sh between two types of non-Humean theories: 1.Primitivism: fundamental laws are primitive facts in the world. 2. Reductionism: fundamental laws are analyzed in terms of something outside the mosaic. Carroll (1994) and Maudlin (2007) maintain primitivist versions of non-Humeanism. Hildebrand (2013) provides a survey o…”

“ial conditions, and for each entropic trajectory there can be short-lived, shallow, and infrequent decreases of entropy (see Second Laws for X and for ). Recognizing the importance of the Second Law, Eddington (1928) suggests: If someone points out to you that your pet theory of the universe is in disagreement with Ma…”

“lar time and physical systems (e.g. dinosaurs) that exist at an earlier time, but no strong correlations between physical records and events at a later time. The Past Hypothesis oers an explanation. Albert (2000) suggests that a record is a relation between two temporal ends of a physical process. A record enables us…”

“But there is nothing earlier than t 0, as it is stipulated to be the initial time, say, the time of the Big Bang.12 11Boltzmann’s original H-theorem (Boltzmann 1964)[1898] is an attempt to show this. Lanford (1975) produces an exact result for a simple system of hard spheres where the Boltzmann equation is shown to be…”

“sense: we have to give up the expectation that experimental outcomes are unique and determinate. Instead, our experiences are to be understood as experiences of agents in an emergent multiverse (see (Wallace 2012)). Second, in the Bohmian version, in addition to the wave function that evolves unitarily according to th…”

“7 3 Why the Past Hypothesis is Law-Like It is clear that PH has a special status in the Boltzmannian account. It has been suggested that PH is like a law of nature. For example, this is emphasized by Feynman (2017)[1965] as quoted in the epigraph. Making a similar point about classical statistical mechanics, Goldstein…”

“explanatory success of the Boltzmannian account, which is assumed in this paper. It is clear that PH is not a law of mathematics. 19This is di erent from the notion of metaphysical explanation. See (Loewer 2012), (Hicks & van Elswyk 2015). On some views, a fundamental law of nature is metaphysically explained (but…”

“beyond subjective credences? (In so far as typicality plays a similar explanatory role as probability, TP may face the same prima facie problem as SP.) Humeanism has resources to solve this problem. Loewer (2001) suggests that deterministic“chances”cangainentryintheLewsianbestsystembytheinformativeness 29 they bring a…”

“Nomological interpretation: on this view, the fundamental space is the physical space(time) and the fundamental ontology consists in particles, fields, or flashes on that space; the wave function represents a physical law (Dürr et al. 1996), (Goldstein & Teufel 2001) and (Goldstein & Zanghì 2013).”

“For recent discussions, see (Albert 2000), (Goldstein 2001), (Callender 2004, 2011), (Lebowitz 2008), (North 2011), (Loewer 2020), and (Goldstein et al. 2020).”

“nd not completely rigorous (Frigg 2007). Second, some criticize the answer to the Hard Part, such as the charge that PH is not even false because the entropy of the early universe is not well-defined (Earman 2006), the charge that PH is not sucient to explain the thermodynamic behaviors of subsystems (Winsberg 2004), a…”

“Nomological interpretation: on this view, the fundamental space is the physical space(time) and the fundamental ontology consists in particles, fields, or flashes on that space; the wave function represents a physical law (Dürr et al. 1996), (Goldstein & Teufel 2001) and (Goldstein & Zanghì 2013).”

“Nomological interpretation: on this view, the fundamental space is the physical space(time) and the fundamental ontology consists in particles, fields, or flashes on that space; the wave function represents a physical law (Dürr et al. 1996), (Goldstein & Teufel 2001) and (Goldstein & Zanghì 2013).”

“See (Goldstein et al. 2010b, section 2.2) for a discussion of von Neumann’s ideas.”

“Of course, the minimalist account is at odds with the idea about “dynamical governing”: 17To my knowledge, the W-GRW equations first appear in (Allori et al. 2013).”

“For recent discussions, see (Albert 2000), (Loewer 2020), (Callender 2004, 2011), (North 2011), (Lebowitz 2008), (Goldstein 2001), and (Goldstein et al. 2020).”

“Low-dimensional multi-field: on this view, the fundamental space is the physical space(time); the wave function represents a “multi-field” that assigns physical quantities to every spatial region composed of N points (Forrest 1988, Belot 2012, Chen 2017, Hubert & Romano 2018).”

“…of 16This version of the guidance equation is first proposed by Bell (1980), then recast as the dynamical equation for the fundamental density matrix in Dürr et al. (2005). nature of order 10−15 s−1):17 WT+ = Λk(X)1/2WT−Λk(X)1/2 tr(WT−Λk(X)) , (31) where WT− is the pre-collapse density…”

“Many of these ideas can be found in (Albert 2000, 2012) and (Loewer 2007), and they are also discussed in (Frisch 2005, 2007), (Demarest 2019), (Fernandes, this volume), (Callender 2004), (Horwich 1987), and (Reichenbach 1956).”

“nother postulate that can be called the Fluctuation Hypothesis) and discussed in (Feynman 2017)[1965]. For recent discussions, see (Albert 2000), (Loewer 2020), (Callender 2004, 2011), (North 2011), (Lebowitz 2008), (Goldstein 2001), and (Goldstein et al. 2020). (The memorable phrase ‘Past Hypothesis’ is coined by Alb…”

“3For more on the notion of typicality and its application in statistical mechanics, see (Goldstein 2012), (Lazarovici & Reichert 2015), and (Wilhelm 2019). degrees of freedom are in a special state, providing a sense that the total state of the early universe has low entropy.”

“so an open question whether it really succeeds in recovering the manifest image of low-dimensional objects. 2. Low-dimensional multi-field: this view has been explored by Forrest (1988), Belot (2012), Chen (2017) and Hubert & Romano (2018). However, this view has awkward consequences. For the Bohmian framework, the…”

“nomic status of the Past Hypothesis, without which they would be left completely mysterious. Many of these ideas can be found in (Albert 2000, 2012) and (Loewer 2007), and they are also discussed in (Frisch 2005, 2007), (Demarest 2019), (Fernandes, this volume), (Callender 2004), (Horwich 1987), and (Reichenbach 1956)…”

“16This version of the guidance equation is first proposed by Bell (1980), then discussed for a fundamental density matrix in Dürr et al. (2005). 17To my knowledge, the W-GRW equations first appear in (Allori et al.”

“Many of these ideas can be found in (Albert 2000, 2012) and (Loewer 2007), and they are also discussed in (Frisch 2005, 2007), (Demarest 2019), (Fernandes, this volume), (Callender 2004), (Horwich 1987), and (Reichenbach 1956).”

“See Chen (2022) for a discussion of this possibility, called “fundamental nomic vagueness.” On MinP, fundamental nomic vagueness implies that there are vague fundamental facts. Whether fundamental nomic vagueness exists in our world is a subtle question. (It is related to the issue of whether the ontic quantum state o…”

“40See, for example, Dürr et al. (2005), Maroney (2005), Wallace (2011, 2012), and Chen (2018).”

“4 Suggestions that PH is an additional law of nature can be found in Feynman (2017), Albert (2000), Goldstein (2001), Callender (2004), Loewer (2012), Goldstein et al. (2020) and Chen (2020b).”

“For a more in-depth discussion, see Chen (2023b).”

“Following Albert and Loewer, let us call this package the Mentaculus: 1See Albert (2000), Goldstein (2001), Callender (2004, 2011), Lebowitz (2008), North (2011), Wallace (2023), Loewer (2020), Goldstein et al. (2020), and Chen (2023).”

“EPH 0 R and EPH ≤ mR are not entirely factorization-invariant, but they do not depend on any particular factorization as they quantify over all factorizations of a certain class R , to be specified as part of the theory.”

“Our reason for assigning low prior in those theories may just be the general rule favoring simpler theories, such as Bohmian mechanics and spontaneous collapse theories (Chen 2020a).”

“For generalizations of some of those solutions to density-matrix theories such as the Everettian Wentaculus, see Chua and Chen (2023). that it makes sense to talk about Born-rule probability, either through how much I prefer certain rewards or how likely I am located in a particular branch of the…”

“A common claim is that when formulated this way, the paradox is fully resolved by the fact that past entropy was lower in the past than it is now (the “past hypothesis”) [6–9].”

“Fourth, suppose that some initial conditions of the universe are dictated by a law (cf. Albert (2004) and Chen (2020)).”

“With Everettian Wentaculus, the initial density matrix is pinned down by a law, and the multiverse evolution is too (Chen 2024b, 2023b).”

“A common explanation for the thermodynamic arrow of time is the Past Hypothesis: the assumption that the system, or the universe as a whole, began in a very low-entropy macrostate [9–12].”