Spontaneous inflation and the origin of the arrow of time

Each of the other cosmological scenarios (pre-Big-Bang, ekpyrotic/cyclic, Aguirre-Gratton, and Bojowald loop quantum gravity) invokes special low-entropy conditions on some Cauchy surface, either asymptotically in the far past or at some moment of minimum size for the universe.

“To the best of our understanding, each of these proposals invokes special low-entropy conditions on some Cauchy surface, either asymptotically in the far past or at some moment of minimum size for the universe.”

• cites [94] [94] M. Gasperini and G. Veneziano, 'The pre-big bang scenario in string cosmology,' Phys. Rept. 373 , 1 (2003) [arXiv:hep-th/0207130]. - sourceDisputed

  For the pre-big-bang scenario, Section 3 (Initial conditions; page unavailable) describes an initially highly entropic state and proposes that gravitational collapse generates the low-entropy region corresponding to our universe. The paper does impose asymptotic-past-triviality in a simplified model, but it does not describe this as a special low-entropy condition on a Cauchy surface. This source does not establish the claim about the other named scenarios. (LLM, conf=0.86)

  Checked by a reasoning model — may be wrong.

  Experimental — accuracy not yet measured
• cites [95] [95] J. E. Lidsey, D. Wands and E. J. Copeland, 'Superstring cosmology,' Phys. Rept. 337 , 343 (2000) [arXiv:hep-th/9909061]. - sourcePartly supported

  Section 9.2 (page unavailable) describes the pre-Big-Bang scenario as starting from a cold, empty, flat vacuum with sufficiently homogeneous initial conditions, and discusses its asymptotic past. It does not characterize those conditions as low-entropy conditions on a Cauchy surface or address the other three named scenarios, so it supports only the pre-Big-Bang portion of the claim. (LLM, conf=0.85)

  Experimental — accuracy not yet measured
• cites [96] [96] J. Khoury, B. A. Ovrut, P. J. Steinhardt and N. Turok, 'Density perturbations in the ekpyrotic scenario,' Phys. Rev. D 66 , 046005 (2002) [arXiv:hep-th/0109050]. - sourceSupported
• cites [97] [97] J. Khoury, B. A. Ovrut, N. Seiberg, P. J. Steinhardt and N. Turok, 'From big crunch to big bang,' Phys. Rev. D 65 , 086007 (2002) [arXiv:hep-th/0108187]. - sourcePartly supported

  Section VIII, “Cosmological Implications” (page unavailable), describes the ekpyrotic model as beginning in a nearly vacuous, quasistatic state with a specified brane configuration, supporting the claim that this scenario assumes a special early state. It does not characterize that state as low-entropy or place it on a Cauchy surface, and the passages found do not establish the claim for all the other named scenarios. (LLM, conf=0.76)

  Experimental — accuracy not yet measured
• cites [98] [98] P. J. Steinhardt and N. Turok, 'Cosmic evolution in a cyclic universe,' Phys. Rev. D 65 , 126003 (2002) [arXiv:hep-th/0111098]. - sourcePartly supported

  The opening summary says the cyclic model requires flat, vacuous conditions before ekpyrosis, and the Introduction says entropy density is diluted before the next bounce. But the paper describes those conditions as produced by accelerated expansion, not specified on a Cauchy surface; it also says total entropy grows across cycles. This source does not address the other named scenarios. (LLM, conf=0.83)

  Experimental — accuracy not yet measured
• cites [99] [99] A. Aguirre and S. Gratton, 'Inflation without a beginning: A null boundary proposal,' Phys. Rev. D 67 , 083515 (2003) [arXiv:gr-qc/0301042]. - sourcePartly supported

  The section on (semi-)classical boundary conditions specifies a particularly simple state on an infinite null hypersurface, and the Summary and Conclusions says time flows away from it. But the paper explicitly distinguishes its null boundary from a spacelike initial-value surface; it does not place the conditions on a Cauchy surface. The cited paper also cannot establish the sentence’s claim about the other named proposals. (LLM, conf=0.88)

  Experimental — accuracy not yet measured

In the presence of a small positive vacuum energy, systems will tend to initially empty out to an approximate de Sitter vacuum.

“In the presence of a small positive vacuum energy (such as seems to exist in our universe [16, 17, 18]), systems will tend to initially empty out to an approximate de Sitter vacuum.”

• cites [16] [16] A. G. Riess et al. [Supernova Search Team Collaboration], 'Observational Evidence from Supernovae for an Accelerating Universe and a Cosmological Constant,' Astron. J. 116 , 1009 (1998) [arXiv:astro-ph/9805201]. - sourceSupported
• cites [17] [17] S. Perlmutter et al. [Supernova Cosmology Project Collaboration], 'Measurements of Omega and Lambda from 42 High-Redshift Supernovae,' Astrophys. J. 517 , 565 (1999) [arXiv:astro-ph/9812133]. - sourceSupported
• cites [18] [18] S. M. Carroll, 'The cosmological constant,' Living Rev. Rel. 4 , 1 (2001) [arXiv:astroph/0004075]. - sourceNot checked yet

  Checked before — its earlier verdict is held back until a new check runs.

The Big Bang in our past is not a unique moment in the history of the universe; it is simply one of the many times that inflation spontaneously began from a background de Sitter phase.

“The Big Bang in our past is not a unique moment in the history of the universe; it is simply one of the many times that inflation spontaneously began from a background de Sitter phase, similar to the proposal of Garriga and Vilenkin [35].”

• cites [35] [35] J. Garriga and A. Vilenkin, 'Recycling universe,' Phys. Rev. D 57 , 2230 (1998) [arXiv:astro-ph/9707292]. - sourcePartly supported

  The Introduction describes thermalized regions approaching de Sitter geometry and fluctuating back into an inflating state, with each new region seeding further inflation. But the Conclusions call it an open question whether this recycling pattern extends indefinitely into the past. The paper therefore supports repeated spontaneous beginnings of inflation, not the definite claim that the Big Bang in our past was one of them or was not unique. (LLM, conf=0.86)

  Experimental — accuracy not yet measured

Bousso's covariant entropy bound places a limit on the entropy that can be contained within a region.

“A concrete consequence of the holographic principle is Bousso's covariant entropy bound, which places a limit on the entropy that can be contained within a region [63].”

• cites [63] [63] R. Bousso, 'A Covariant Entropy Conjecture,' JHEP 9907 , 004 (1999) [arXiv:hepth/9905177]. - sourcePartly supported

  Section 3 states that Bousso’s conjecture bounds the entropy on a surface’s light-sheets by a quarter of its area. Section 3.4 derives a bound for spatial regions only under specified conditions, so the claim’s unqualified reference to entropy contained within a region is broader than the source supports. (LLM, conf=0.84)

  Experimental — accuracy not yet measured

The causal-patch description of spacetime derives from the holographic principle and black-hole complementarity.

“An interesting perspective on the likelihood of different initial conditions for the universe arises from the causal-patch description of spacetime [52, 53, 54, 55]. 1 This view derives from two profound lessons of black-hole physics: the holographic principle [59, 60, 61] and blackhole complementarity [62].”

• cites [52] [52] T. Banks, 'Cosmological breaking of supersymmetry or little Lambda goes back to the future. II,' arXiv:hep-th/0007146. -Not matched

  Couldn’t be matched to a paper in Crossref, so it can’t be checked.

• cites [53] [53] T. Banks and W. Fischler, 'M-theory observables for cosmological space-times,' arXiv:hep-th/0102077. -Not matched

  Couldn’t be matched to a paper in Crossref, so it can’t be checked.

• cites [54] [54] L. Dyson, J. Lindesay and L. Susskind, 'Is there really a de Sitter/CFT duality,' JHEP 0208 , 045 (2002) [arXiv:hep-th/0202163]. - sourceSupported
• cites [55] [55] L. Susskind, 'Twenty years of debate with Stephen,' arXiv:hep-th/0204027. -Not matched

  Couldn’t be matched to a paper in Crossref, so it can’t be checked.

• cites [59] [59] G. 't Hooft, 'Dimensional reduction in quantum gravity,' arXiv:gr-qc/9310026. -Not matched

  Couldn’t be matched to a paper in Crossref, so it can’t be checked.

• cites [60] [60] L. Susskind, 'The World as a hologram,' J. Math. Phys. 36 , 6377 (1995) [arXiv:hepth/9409089]. - sourceNot checked — no full text of the source
• cites [61] [61] R. Bousso, 'The holographic principle,' Rev. Mod. Phys. 74 , 825 (2002) [arXiv:hepth/0203101]. - sourcePartly supported

  In “Properties and implications” (page unavailable), Bousso connects a holographic theory of cosmology with an observer’s causally connected region and says black-hole complementarity suggests restricting attention to one causal region. The paper supports the conceptual connection, but presents it as a suggestion rather than establishing that the causal-patch description derives from both principles. (LLM, conf=0.82)

  Experimental — accuracy not yet measured
• cites [62] [62] L. Susskind, L. Thorlacius and J. Uglum, 'The Stretched horizon and black hole complementarity,' Phys. Rev. D 48 , 3743 (1993) [arXiv:hep-th/9306069]. - sourceSupported

In order for inflation to begin, there must be a region that is smooth, dominated by potential energy, and of radius L_I larger than H^{-1}_I.

“In order for inflation to begin, there must be a region that is smooth, dominated by potential energy, and of radius L I larger than H -1 I [46, 47, 48, 49].”

• cites [46] [46] A. D. Linde, 'Initial Conditions For Inflation,' Phys. Lett. B 162 , 281 (1985). - sourceNot checked — no full text of the source
• cites [47] [47] A. Albrecht, R. H. Brandenberger and R. Matzner, 'Inflation With Generalized Initial Conditions,' Phys. Rev. D 35 , 429 (1987). - sourceNot checked — no full text of the source
• cites [48] [48] D. S. Goldwirth and T. Piran, 'Initial conditions for inflation,' Phys. Rept. 214 , 223 (1992). - sourceNot checked — no full text of the source
• cites [49] [49] T. Vachaspati and M. Trodden, 'Causality and cosmic inflation,' Phys. Rev. D 61 , 023502 (2000) [arXiv:gr-qc/9811037]. - sourcePartly supported

  On p. 2, the paper assumes that vacuum energy dominates a region larger than the inflationary horizon; on p. 3, it concludes that the initial patch must be larger than that horizon and homogeneous on super-Hubble scales. But the summary on p. 4 limits this requirement to models based on classical Einstein equations, the weak energy condition, and trivial topology, and describes ways inflation may occur without initial large-scale homogeneity. The citing sentence states the requirement without those qualifications. (LLM, conf=0.84)

  Experimental — accuracy not yet measured

A mechanism for such an instability may be provided by the small positive cosmological constant that has apparently been discovered.

“A mechanism for such an instability may be provided by the small positive cosmological constant that has apparently been discovered [16, 17, 18].”

• cites [16] [16] A. G. Riess et al. [Supernova Search Team Collaboration], 'Observational Evidence from Supernovae for an Accelerating Universe and a Cosmological Constant,' Astron. J. 116 , 1009 (1998) [arXiv:astro-ph/9805201]. - sourcePartly supported

  The paper reports that high-redshift supernova observations strongly favor a positive cosmological constant (models section; page not supplied), supporting the sentence’s reference to an apparent discovery. It does not propose the cosmological constant as a mechanism for the instability mentioned by the citing authors. (LLM, conf=0.85)

  Experimental — accuracy not yet measured
• cites [17] [17] S. Perlmutter et al. [Supernova Cosmology Project Collaboration], 'Measurements of Omega and Lambda from 42 High-Redshift Supernovae,' Astrophys. J. 517 , 565 (1999) [arXiv:astro-ph/9812133]. - sourceSupported
• cites [18] [18] S. M. Carroll, 'The cosmological constant,' Living Rev. Rel. 4 , 1 (2001) [arXiv:astroph/0004075]. - sourcePartly supported

  The Observational Tests section says evidence had led many experts to believe in a positive vacuum energy, supporting the claim’s cautious reference to an apparently discovered cosmological constant. The Introduction describes the Einstein static universe as unstable to small deviations, but does not say that the observed small positive cosmological constant provides a mechanism for the instability meant by the citing sentence. (LLM, conf=0.82)

  Experimental — accuracy not yet measured

It is quite natural for de Sitter to be unstable to the onset of inflation.

“The crucial point is that it is quite natural for de Sitter to be unstable to the onset of inflation, as has also been argued elsewhere [34, 35].”

• cites [34] [34] A. D. Linde, 'Hard art of the universe creation (stochastic approach to tunneling and baby universe formation),' Nucl. Phys. B 372 , 421 (1992) [arXiv:hep-th/9110037]. -Not matched

  Couldn’t be matched to a paper in Crossref, so it can’t be checked.

• cites [35] [35] J. Garriga and A. Vilenkin, 'Recycling universe,' Phys. Rev. D 57 , 2230 (1998) [arXiv:astro-ph/9707292]. - sourceSupported

The initial conditions for our observable universe have extremely low entropy.

“The initial conditions for our observable universe thus have extremely low entropy.”

The remaining temperature-dependent contribution to the correlation function is a finite integral.

“The remaining temperature-dependent contribution is a finite integral,”

The early patch and the currently observable patch appear very different in volume, total energy, and number of particles.

“they appear very different - different volumes, different total energies, different numbers of particles.”

The probability for the spontaneous onset of eternal inflation in a spacetime volume of radius H_e^-1 in an ambient de Sitter spacetime with temperature T is extremely tiny.

“Putting in (23), we obtain an appropriately tiny answer.”

• AssumptionThe authors state this as an assumption: Minkowski spacetime should be stable.

For m ∼ 10^13 GeV, the condition for quantum fluctuations to become comparable to the classical motion implies φ_e ∼ 10^3 M_pl, with a corresponding Hubble parameter.

“For m ∼ 10 13 GeV, this implies φ e ∼ 10 3 M pl , with a corresponding Hubble parameter”

The probability for the spontaneous onset of eternal inflation, calculated in the context of a specific model, is nonzero.

“The important feature of this probability, calculated in the context of a specific model, is not its actual numerical value, but simply the fact that it is nonzero (which is certainly not a surprise, given our assumptions).”

• AssumptionThe authors state this as an assumption: Minkowski spacetime should be stable.

In the absence of inflation, systems coupled to gravity usually evolve asymptotically to the vacuum, which is the only natural state in a thermodynamic sense.

“In the absence of inflation, we argue that systems coupled to gravity usually evolve asymptotically to the vacuum, which is the only natural state in a thermodynamic sense.”

Generic initial states empty out and approach de Sitter space.

“Generic initial states empty out and approach de Sitter space.”

Spontaneous eternal inflation can provide a natural explanation for the thermodynamic arrow of time.

“We suggest that spontaneous eternal inflation can provide a natural explanation for the thermodynamic arrow of time”

Ordinary inflation does not directly explain the origin of the arrow of time if one believes in unitary evolution.

“concluding that ordinary inflation does not directly explain the origin of the arrow of time if one believes in unitary evolution.”

If there is at least one scalar inflaton field with an appropriate potential, quantum fluctuations in this field will eventually create an inflating patch.

“If there is also at least one scalar inflaton field with an appropriate potential, however, there is an instability: quantum fluctuations in this field will eventually create an inflating patch”

Once eternal inflation starts, the entropy of the universe can grow without bound, never reaching thermal equilibrium.

“Once eternal inflation starts, the entropy of the universe can grow without bound, never reaching thermal equilibrium.”

In the presence of a small positive vacuum energy and an appropriate inflaton field, the de Sitter vacuum is unstable to the spontaneous onset of inflation at a higher energy scale.

“In the presence of a small positive vacuum energy and an appropriate inflaton field, the de Sitter vacuum is unstable to the spontaneous onset of inflation at a higher energy scale.”

In the presence of an inflaton field, the de Sitter vacuum will be unstable to the onset of eternal inflation.

“In the presence of an inflaton field, the de Sitter vacuum will be unstable to the onset of eternal inflation.”

Starting from a generic state, inflation eventually occurs towards both the past and future, erasing any information about the 'initial' conditions.

“starting from a generic state, inflation eventually occurs towards both the past and future, erasing any information about the 'initial' conditions.”

In the process of increasing the entropy, eternal inflation creates large regions of space similar to our observable universe.

“In the process of increasing the entropy, eternal inflation creates large regions of space similar to our observable universe.”

Our overall universe is statistically time-symmetric about some Cauchy surface of minimum entropy.

“Our overall universe is therefore statistically time-symmetric about some Cauchy surface of minimum entropy.”

The conventional big-bang model invokes unnatural initial conditions.

“The conventional big-bang model clearly invokes unnatural initial conditions”

In the absence of vacuum energy or inflation, systems coupled to gravity generically evolve to flat, empty space.

“in the absence of a vacuum energy or inflation of any sort, systems coupled to gravity generically evolve to flat, empty space.”

Fluctuations into eternal inflation dominate over fluctuations into a conventional Big Bang.

“There is another, perhaps more persuasive, argument that fluctuations into eternal inflation dominate over those into a conventional Big Bang”

Quantum fluctuations are superimposed on the classical motion of the inflaton field.

“However, superimposed on this classical motion are quantum fluctuations in the field, as shown in Figure 8.”

It seems very difficult to derive a true arrow of time from fluctuations about an equilibrium background.

“It seems very difficult to derive a true arrow of time from fluctuations about an equilibrium background.”

In de Sitter spacetime, the holographic principle and black-hole complementarity lead to the causal patch perspective: only physics inside a single causal patch bounded by the de Sitter horizon should be considered.

“In the context of a de Sitter spacetime, these two ideas lead to the causal patch perspective, which states that we should only consider the physics inside a single causal patch bounded by the de Sitter horizon.”

The idea that degrees of freedom are neither created nor destroyed dramatically undercuts the hope that it is not too unlikely to find a patch of the universe in an appropriately proto-inflationary configuration.

“In other words, the idea that degrees of freedom are neither created nor destroyed dramatically undercuts the hope that it is not too unlikely to find a patch of the universe in an appropriately proto-inflationary configuration.”

A very small proto-inflationary region can naturally evolve into our observable patch today, explaining its high degree of homogeneity and isotropy.

“In this way, a very small proto-inflationary region can naturally evolve into our observable patch today, explaining its high degree of homogeneity and isotropy.”

Given some generic state defined on a Cauchy surface, evolving it to both the past and future will in both cases empty out into a cold de Sitter phase, after which inflation will occasionally begin.

“Given some generic state defined on a Cauchy surface, we evolve it to both the past and future, and it both cases it will empty out into a cold de Sitter phase, after which inflation will occasionally begin.”

• AssumptionRests on an assumption: The universe starts in some generic state defined on a Cauchy surface.

If the conditions in our universe are randomly chosen, it is much easier to choose our current universe than to choose a small proto-inflationary patch.

“Therefore, if we are imagining that the conditions in our universe are randomly chosen, it is much easier to choose our current universe than to choose a small proto-inflationary patch.”

• AssumptionRests on an assumption: In conventional thermodynamics, random fluctuations into configurations with lower entropy occur with exponentially smaller likelihood.

The specification of the boundary condition will leave no observable imprint on our universe.

“according to our picture this specification will leave no observable imprint on our universe, and in that sense is truly irrelevant.”

The measure on the space of conditions that anti-inflate in a contracting universe is a negligible fraction of that on the space that collapse inhomogeneously, or even relatively homogeneously but without anti-inflation.

“The reversibility critique is thus very simple: the measure on the space of conditions that anti-inflate in a contracting universe is a negligible fraction of that on the space that collapse inhomogeneously (or even relatively homogeneously, but without anti-inflation);”

Both sets of observers will think of the others as living in their 'past.'

“Both sets of observers will think of the others as living in their 'past.'”

• AssumptionRests on an assumption: The universe starts in some generic state defined on a Cauchy surface.

A fluctuation in which a contracting universe is gradually assembled, smoothes itself out, and anti-inflates seems much less likely than contraction to a highly inhomogeneous Big Crunch.

“We can certainly imagine a fluctuation in which a contracting universe is gradually assembled, smoothes itself out, and anti-inflates; but for the same reasons given in the previous subsection, this seems much less likely than contraction to a highly inhomogeneous Big Crunch.”

Black holes and other inhomogeneities may form, but they will eventually decay away, so that the universe approaches empty space.

“Black holes and other inhomogeneities may form, but they will eventually decay away, so that the universe approaches empty space.”

The early patch and the currently observable patch simply represent different subsets of the state space of the comoving volume corresponding to our universe.

“they simply represent different subsets of the state space of (the comoving volume corresponding to) our universe.”

In a harmonic oscillator potential without false vacua, the inflaton can simply fluctuate up without tunneling.

“In our discussion is that we examine the case of an harmonic oscillator potential without any false vacua; in such a potential we can simply fluctuate up without any tunneling.”

• AssumptionThe authors state this as an assumption: The inflaton potential is a harmonic oscillator potential without false vacua.

In the presence of a positive vacuum energy and an appropriate inflaton field, the resulting de Sitter phase is unstable to the spontaneous onset of inflation, instigated by the thermal fluctuations of the inflaton.

“However, in the presence of a positive vacuum energy and an appropriate inflaton field, the resulting de Sitter phase is unstable to the spontaneous onset of inflation, instigated by the thermal fluctuations of the inflaton.”

It is extremely unlikely that the universe would smooth out and anti-inflate in a contracting phase.

“Certainly it seems extremely unlikely that the universe would smooth out and 'anti-inflate,' with a period of re-freezing in which hot matter cleverly assembles itself into a smooth inflaton field which then rolls up its potential into a contracting quasi-de Sitter phase.”

This chain of events happens both to the past and to the future of the specified Cauchy surface, leading to a statistically time-symmetric universe.

“This chain of events happens both to the past and the future of the specified Cauchy surface, leading to a statistically time-symmetric universe as portrayed in Figure 9.”

The generic evolution of a system coupled to gravity is to dilute excitations via the expansion of spacetime.

“We argued in Section 4 that the generic evolution of a system coupled to gravity is to dilute excitations via the expansion of spacetime.”

If we evolve states resembling our present universe backwards in time, or consider collapsing universes with similar conditions, we generically expect an increasing departure from homogeneity as space contracts and gravitational perturbations grow.

“If we take states in this set and evolve them backwards in time, or equivalently consider collapsing universes with conditions otherwise similar to our own, we generically expect an increasing departure from homogeneity as space contracts and gravitational perturbations grow.”

Assuming Liouville's theorem holds, within the set of initial conditions that evolve into a universe like ours, the subset that does not pass through an inflationary phase is much larger than the one that does.

“Assuming Liouville's theorem holds, the reversibility critique is simply the statement that, within the set of initial conditions that evolve into a universe like ours, the subset that does not pass through an inflationary phase is much larger than the one that does.”

• AssumptionRests on an assumption: Liouville's theorem holds: dynamical evolution preserves the measure on phase space.

An appropriate Robertson-Walker universe has a much higher entropy than a proto-inflationary patch.

“As discussed in Section 3, an appropriate Robertson-Walker universe has a much higher entropy than a proto-inflationary patch, so we might expect the inflationary universe to be correspondingly less likely to be spontaneously created.”

The entropy of our early inflationary state is larger than that of the tiny comoving volume of de Sitter from which it arose.

“Although the entropy of our early inflationary state is extremely low, it is nevertheless larger than that of the tiny comoving volume of de Sitter from which it arose, in perfect accord with our conventional understanding of the Second Law.”

By taking seriously the ability of spacetime to expand and dilute degrees of freedom, the paper claims to have shown how an arrow of time can naturally arise dynamically in the course of evolution from a generic boundary condition.

“By taking seriously the ability of spacetime to expand and dilute degrees of freedom, we claim to have shown how an arrow of time can naturally arise dynamically in the course of the evolution from a generic boundary condition.”

On Hubble-radius scales these fluctuations are given by the Gibbons-Hawking temperature.

“On Hubble-radius scales these fluctuations are given by the Gibbons- Hawking temperature (15), or for any field value φ ≥ φ e , where”

There is some chance that the field can spontaneously fluctuate all the way up to φ_e in a patch of radius H_e^-1, thereby providing an appropriate initial condition for the onset of inflation.

“There is therefore some chance that the field can spontaneously fluctuate all the way up to φ e in a patch of radius H -1 e , thereby providing an appropriate initial condition for the onset of inflation.”

There is no reason to expect randomly-chosen or generic conditions to feature large curvatures and Planck-scale fluctuations.

“Consequently, there is no reason to expect randomly-chosen or generic conditions to feature large curvatures and Planck-scale fluctuations.”

Given the specification of the conditions on the 'initial' surface, the same set of events will naturally occur to the past as well as to the future.

“An interesting feature of this story is that, given the specification of the conditions on the 'initial' surface, the same set of events will naturally occur to the past as well as to the future.”

If this point is reached, inflation never truly ends.

“If this point is reached, inflation never truly ends.”

Fluctuating into inflation is ultimately inevitable, since the total spacetime volume in the cold de Sitter phase is infinite.

“Although the probability (45) is quite small, fluctuating into inflation is ultimately inevitable, since the total spacetime volume in the cold de Sitter phase is infinite.”

• AssumptionThe authors state this as an assumption: The decay rate of the de Sitter phase is sufficiently slow that the physical volume of de Sitter grows without bound.

The emptying-out of the universe under typical evolution of a generic state can provide appropriate initial conditions for the onset of inflation, which then leads to regions that look like our universe.

“Thus, the emptying-out of the universe under typical evolution of a generic state can actually provide appropriate initial conditions for the onset of inflation, which then leads to regions that look like our universe.”

A way out of the conundrum is possible if empty space is not perfectly stable, but is subject to instabilities that can produce universes like our own.

“A way out of this conundrum is possible if 'empty space' is not a perfectly stable state, but rather is subject to instabilities that can produce universes like our own.”

The cacophony of matter and radiation in our observable patch of universe appears as a mere byproduct of the relentless evolution of the larger spacetime toward states of higher entropy.

“Indeed, the cacophony of matter and radiation in our observable patch of universe appears in this picture as a mere byproduct of the relentless evolution of the larger spacetime toward states of higher entropy.”

The low entropy of the proto-inflationary patch is not a sign of how natural a starting point it is, but of how extremely difficult it would be to find ourselves there from a generic state.

“The low entropy of the proto-inflationary patch is not a sign of how natural a starting point it is, but of how extremely difficult it would be to simply find ourselves there from a generic state.”

The entropy of the configuration is increased by spreading out fluctuations into an ever-larger spatial volume, leaving us with an empty de Sitter solution with a small cosmological constant.

“The entropy of the configuration is increased by spreading out fluctuations into an ever-larger spatial volume, leaving us with an empty de Sitter solution with a small cosmological constant.”

Since the area of the de Sitter horizon is finite, the causal patch has only a finite number of degrees of freedom.

“Since the area of such a horizon is finite (with radius R dS = √ 3 / Λ), the causal patch has only a finite number of degrees of freedom.”

Our currently observable universe and the small patch of early universe that grows into it are not two different physical systems; they are two different configurations of the same system.

“The crucial point here is that our currently observable universe and the small patch of early universe that grows into it are not two different physical systems; they are two different configurations of the same system .”

If evolution is truly unitary, there are a fantastically large number of degrees of freedom that need to be in their vacuum state for a small region to begin inflating, most corresponding to modes with frequencies above the Planck scale, and each must be separately put into its vacuum state.

“If the evolution is truly unitary, there are a fantastically large number of such degrees of freedom, most of which would correspond in a Fourier decomposition to modes with frequencies well above the Planck scale, and each of these degrees of freedom needs to be separately put into its vacuum state.”

Even if fluctuations into radiation-dominated universes are more likely than fluctuations into inflation, most observers will find themselves living in a post-inflationary region because of the infinite volume factor associated with eternal inflation.

“Therefore, even if fluctuations into radiation-dominated universes (or anything similar) are more likely than fluctuations into inflation, most observers will find themselves to be living in a post-inflationary region just because of the infinite volume factor associated with eternal inflation.”

One can increase the entropy of any configuration on a spacelike hypersurface by taking the same set of excitations and spreading them apart by increasing the scale factor, thereby increasing the allowed phase space for each particle.

“Another way to reach the same conclusion is to simply take any configuration defined on a spacelike hypersurface, and realize that we can increase the entropy by taking the same set of excitations (whether in matter fields or gravitational waves) and spread them apart by increasing the scale factor, thereby increasing the allowed phase space for each particle.”

If the beginning of inflation relies on a random fluctuation from chaotic initial conditions, it is unclear what is gained by invoking a fluctuation to a configuration with such an unnecessarily low entropy.

“If the beginning of inflation relies on a random fluctuation from chaotic initial conditions, it is unclear what is gained by invoking a fluctuation to a configuration with such an unnecessarily low entropy.”

According to the scenario, there is no such thing as a state of maximal entropy, since the entropy can always increase without bound.

“According to our scenario, this is not in any way a restriction; there is no such thing as a state of maximal entropy, since the entropy can always increase without bound.”

• AssumptionRests on an assumption: The initial condition was not an equilibrium state with maximal entropy.

From the point of view of a theory of initial conditions, the low entropy of the proto-inflationary patch strongly undermines the idea that inflation can naturally arise from a random fluctuation.

“But from the point of view of a theory of initial conditions, it strongly undermines the idea that inflation can naturally arise from a random fluctuation.”

• AssumptionRests on an assumption: In conventional thermodynamics, random fluctuations into configurations with lower entropy occur with exponentially smaller likelihood.

An arrow of time is dynamically generated in both the past and the future, as the universe continually acts to increase its entropy.

“An arrow of time is dynamically generated in both the past and the future, as the universe continually acts to increase its entropy.”

This Gibbons-Hawking temperature gives rise to thermal fluctuations in any fields in the theory.

“This temperature gives rise to thermal fluctuations in any fields in the theory.”

If the initial value of the scalar field is sufficiently large, inflation will occur for more than the sixty e-folds of accelerated expansion necessary to bring our entire currently observable universe into causal contact.

“If the initial value of the scalar field is sufficiently large, inflation will occur for more than the sixty e -folds of accelerated expansion necessary to bring our entire currently observable universe into causal contact.”

We do not need the de Sitter decay rate to be strictly zero or smaller than the inflationary-fluctuation rate; all that is required is that the decay rate per Hubble volume be substantially less than unity.

“However, we don't need the decay rate to be strictly zero, or even smaller than the inflationary-fluctuation rate (45); all we require is that the decay rate per Hubble volume be substantially less than unity.”

It is exponentially easier to fluctuate into a universe that is anthropically allowed but thermodynamically nonsensical than into a universe that evolved normally from an extremely low-entropy initial state.

“Unfortunately, as discussed above, it is exponentially easier to fluctuate into a universe which is anthropically allowed but thermodynamically nonsensical than into a universe that evolved normally from an extremely low-entropy initial state.”

The ratio of the measure on anti-inflating conditions to that on inhomogeneous collapse is the same as the ratio of the measure on inflationary initial conditions to that on all conditions that evolve into a universe macroscopically like ours.

“but the ratio of these measures is the same as the ratio of the measure on the space of inflationary initial conditions to that on the space of all conditions that evolve into a universe macroscopically like ours.”

Given the nonzero Gibbons-Hawking temperature, there will necessarily be fluctuations in the scalar field over and above the zero-point fluctuations expected in a Minkowski background.

“Given the nonzero Gibbons-Hawking temperature, there will necessarily be fluctuations in the scalar field over and above the zero-point fluctuations expected in a Minkowski background.”

In a theory with gravity and vanishing vacuum energy, the closest thing to a maximal-entropy, thermal-equilibrium state is flat empty space.

“The examples considered in this section provide anecdotal evidence for a straightforward claim: in a theory with gravity (and vanishing vacuum energy), the closest thing to a maximal-entropy, thermal-equilibrium state is flat empty space.”

• AssumptionThe authors state this as an assumption: In Section 4, the vacuum energy is zero, so that empty space is flat.

Nothing about the description involved intrinsically time-asymmetric physics, other than the fact that the initial condition was not an equilibrium state with maximal entropy.

“Nothing about our description involved intrinsically time-asymmetric physics, other than the fact that the initial condition was not an equilibrium state with maximal entropy.”

• AssumptionRests on an assumption: The initial condition was not an equilibrium state with maximal entropy.

The entropy of the universe has been increasing since the onset of inflation.

“From the point of view of the Second Law, this makes sense; the entropy has been increasing since the onset of inflation.”

Eventually, thermal fluctuations in this background allow a scalar inflaton field to bounce sufficiently high up its potential that eternal inflation begins with a large vacuum energy.

“Eventually, thermal fluctuations in this background allow a scalar inflaton field to bounce sufficiently high up its potential that eternal inflation begins with a large vacuum energy.”

The entropy of the patch that begins to inflate and expands into our observable universe is far less than our current entropy, or even than the entropy at earlier stages in our comoving volume, given approximately by the matter entropy.

“The point of the entropy argument is then very simple: the entropy of the patch that begins to inflate and expands into our observable universe is far less than our current entropy (4), or even than the entropy at earlier stages in our comoving volume, given approximately by the matter entropy (1).”

• cites [4] [4] R. Penrose, The Emperor's New Mind , ch. 7 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1989), and references therein. - sourceNot checked — no full text of the source
• cites [1] [1] H. Price, in Time's Arrows Today , ed. S. Savitt (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994); arXiv:gr-qc/9310022. -Not checked yet

  Not checked in the free run.

In the presence of a nonzero vacuum energy and an appropriate inflaton field, thermal fluctuations from de Sitter space into eternal inflation provide the correct mechanism for creating regions of spacetime resembling our observable universe.

“In the presence of a nonzero vacuum energy and an appropriate inflaton field, we suggest that thermal fluctuations from de Sitter space into eternal inflation provide precisely the correct mechanism.”

The answer to the conundrum of why the entropy of our observable universe appears extremely small in the past must lie in the process by which inflation begins.

“The answer to this conundrum must lie in the process by which inflation begins; we have proposed a scenario in which this happens naturally from the evolution of some arbitrarilychosen state.”

• AssumptionRests on an assumption: The entropy of our observable universe was extremely small in the past.

If initial conditions are truly chosen randomly, inflationary conditions are much less likely to be chosen than some other conditions that evolve into our universe.

“Therefore, if our initial conditions are truly chosen randomly, inflationary conditions are much less likely to be chosen than some other conditions that evolve into our universe (which are still a tiny fraction of all possible initial conditions).”

Given a spacelike region with boundary, the amount of entropy that can pass through an appropriately constructed inward-pointing null surface emanating from the boundary is given by the area of the boundary in Planck units.

“More specifically, given a spacelike region Σ with boundary ∂ Σ, the amount of entropy that can pass through an appropriately constructed inward-pointing null surface emanating from the boundary is given by the area of ∂ Σ as measured in Planck units.”

• cites [63] [63] R. Bousso, 'A Covariant Entropy Conjecture,' JHEP 9907 , 004 (1999) [arXiv:hepth/9905177]. - sourceNot checked yet

  Not checked in the free run.

The answer obtained corresponds to the probability of the field jumping up the potential over one proto-inflationary Hubble volume, much smaller than the Hubble volume of the ambient de Sitter space in which the fluctuation occurs.

“The answer we obtain will thus correspond to the probability of the field jumping up the potential over one proto-inflationary Hubble volume (much smaller than the Hubble volume of the ambient de Sitter space in which the fluctuation occurs).”

Large curvatures are entropically disfavored, tending to ultimately smooth themselves out under ordinary evolution.

“According to everything we know about gravity, large curvatures are entropically disfavored, tending to ultimately smooth themselves out under ordinary evolution.”

Observers in the very far past of our universe will also detect an arrow of time, but one that will be reversed from ours with respect to some global time coordinate throughout the entire spacetime.

“Observers in the very far past of our universe will also detect an arrow of time, but one that will be reversed from ours with respect to some (completely unobservable) global time coordinate throughout the entire spacetime.”

• AssumptionRests on an assumption: The universe starts in some generic state defined on a Cauchy surface.

From a starting point of empty de Sitter, it is easier for a single mode of wavelength H_e^-1 to fluctuate up its potential than for a large collection of modes to simultaneously fluctuate into a configuration describing a radiation-dominated Robertson-Walker universe.

“From such a starting point, it is easier for a single mode of wavelength H -1 e to fluctuate up its potential than for a large collection of modes to simultaneously fluctuate into a configuration describing a radiation-dominated RobertsonWalker universe.”

A generic state in a theory with gravity is close to empty space.

“Rather than a state with large fluctuations at or near the Planck scale, we will suggest that a generic state is close to empty space.”

These modes would generically be excited in a time-reversed or collapsing universe, as inhomogeneities grew and black holes were formed.

“These modes would generically be excited in a time-reversed or collapsing universe, as inhomogeneities grew and black holes were formed.”