How reliable are field-derived biomagnification factors and trophic magnification factors as indicators of bioaccumulation potential? Conclusions from a case study on per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances
Open accessThe DOI matches its Crossref record; 14 of the 14 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Abstract
This review examines the usefulness of the metrics BMF (biomagnification factor) and TMF (trophic magnification factor), derived from field measurements of the levels of contaminants in naturally occurring biota, for characterizing the bioaccumulation potential (“B”) of chemicals. Trophic magnification factor and BMF values greater than 1.0 are often considered to be the most conclusive indicators of B status, and the TMF criterion has been referred to as the “gold standard” for B categorization. Although not wishing to dispute the theoretical primacy of field-derived BMFs and TMFs as B metrics, we make the case that, in practice, the study-to-study (and even within-study) variability of the results is so great that they are of very restricted usefulness for assessing B status, at least in the case of the per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs), on which we focus here. This conclusion is based on an analysis of the results of 24 peer-reviewed studies reporting field-derived BMFs or TMFs for 14 PFASs, for which BMF values often range over several orders of magnitude from <<1.0 to >>1.0, sometimes even in the same study. For TMFs, the range is a factor of approximately 20 for the most intensely studied PFASs (perfluorooctanoic acid [PFOA] and perfluorooctanesulfonic acid [PFOS]). We analyze the possible causes for such variability: To some extent it results from the differing ways in which the metrics are expressed, but most of the scatter is likely attributable to such factors as nonachievement of the tacitly assumed steady-state conditions, uncertainties in the feeding ecology, the impact of metabolism of precursor compounds, and so forth. As more trustworthy alternatives to field-derived BMFs and TMFs, we suggest the implementation of dietary BMF studies performed under strictly controlled conditions on aquatic, terrestrial, and avian species, as well as the consideration of measured elimination half-lives, which have been demonstrated to be directly related to BMF values. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2016;12:6–20. © 2015 The Author. Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. on behalf of SETAC. Key Points We analyze 24 studies in which BMFs and TMFs, key metrics used in a holistic assessment of the bioaccumulation potential of organic chemicals, derived from field measurements, were determined for 14 per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs). Our review shows that, in practice, field-derived BMFs and TMFs are of limited use in assigning a ‘B’ or ‘non-B’ status to a candidate chemical, at least in the case of PFASs, due to reported BMF values extending over several orders of magnitude, and ratios of extreme TMF values reaching about 20. We analyze possible causes for the huge observed variability and conclude that it is likely due to implicit assumptions made by the investigators that are in fact hardly verifiable but nevertheless affect the result obtained (e.g., uncertain feeding ecology). As more trustworthy alternatives to field-derived BMFs and TMFs, we advocate the use of "benchmarked" dietary BMF studies, performed under carefully controlled laboratory or "semi-field" conditions, on aquatic, terrestrial, and avian species.
Overview
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Self-check
Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.
The self-check needs the paper’s full text.
Citations
Cites
Buck, R. C., Franklin, J., Berger, U., Conder, J. M., Cousins, I. T., de Voogt, P., Jensen, A. A., Kannan, K., Mabury, S. A., & van Leeuwen, S. P. (2011) · Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management · doi:10.1002/ieam.258 · Cited by 4,641
Self-citationOlsen, G. W., Burris, J. M., Ehresman, D. J., Froehlich, J. W., Seacat, A. M., Butenhoff, J. L., & Zobel, L. R. (2007) · Environmental Health Perspectives · doi:10.1289/ehp.10009 · Cited by 2,049
Conder, J. M., Hoke, R. A., Wolf, W. D., Russell, M. H., & Buck, R. C. (2008) · Environmental Science & Technology · doi:10.1021/es070895g · Cited by 1,206 · cited 1×
“This would be in line with the conclusions of Conder et al. (2008) based mainly on BCF values.”
ResultMonitoring of Perfluorinated Compounds in Aquatic Biota: An Updated Review: PFCs in Aquatic Biota
Houde, M., De Silva, A. O., Muir, D. C. G., & Letcher, R. J. (2011) · Environmental Science & Technology · doi:10.1021/es104326w · Cited by 847 · cited 1×
“The organisms sampled and analyzed in the studies on PFASs have not always been characterized in terms of sex, age (or body size), and other biological variables, but these factors may exert some influence on biota concentrations of PFASs, and hence on the BMFs derived from them (Houde et al. 2011).”
BackgroundTrophic magnification factors: Considerations of ecology, ecosystems, and study design
Borgå, K., Kidd, K. A., Muir, D. C., Berglund, O., Conder, J. M., Gobas, F. A., Kucklick, J., Malm, O., & Powell, D. E. (2012) · Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management · doi:10.1002/ieam.244 · Cited by 531
Biomonitoring of Perfluoroalkyl Acids in Human Urine and Estimates of Biological Half-Life
Zhang, Y., Beesoon, S., Zhu, L., & Martin, J. W. (2013) · Environmental Science & Technology · doi:10.1021/es401905e · Cited by 530 · cited 1×
“Nevertheless, this conclusion is in line with the observation that PFHxS has a longer half-life in humans than PFOS, despite its shorter chain-length (Olsen et al. 2007; Zhang et al. 2013).”
ResultPerfluoroalkyl Contaminants in a Food Web from Lake Ontario
Martin, J. W., Whittle, D. M., Muir, D. C. G., & Mabury, S. A. (2004) · Environmental Science & Technology · doi:10.1021/es049331s · Cited by 514 · cited 3×
“In other studies, BMFs were deduced solely from whole-body measurements performed on both predator and prey (e.g., Martin et al. 2004; Houde et al. 2008) or mainly from liver concentrations in both predator and prey (e.g., Sinclair et al. 2006; Haukås et al. 2007; Butt et al. 2008; Quinete et al.…”
BackgroundBioaccumulation of Perfluorinated Alkyl Acids: Observations and Models
Ng, C. A., & Hungerbühler, K. (2014) · Environmental Science & Technology · doi:10.1021/es404008g · Cited by 393
Trophic Magnification of Poly- and Perfluorinated Compounds in a Subtropical Food Web
Loi, E. I. H., Yeung, L. W. Y., Taniyasu, S., Lam, P. K. S., Kannan, K., & Yamashita, N. (2011) · Environmental Science & Technology · doi:10.1021/es200432n · Cited by 335
Martin, J. W., Asher, B. J., Beesoon, S., Benskin, J. P., & Ross, M. S. (2010) · Journal of Environmental Monitoring · doi:10.1039/c0em00295j · Cited by 311 · cited 21×
“For TMFs, the ratio of themaximum to minimum reported values is not so great, but it reaches about 20 for the most intensely studied PFASs (PFOA and PFOS).”
BackgroundInfluentialBioconcentration of perfluorinated alkyl acids: How important is specific binding?
Ng, C. A., & Hungerbühler, K. (2013) · Environmental Science & Technology · doi:10.1021/es400981a · Cited by 241 · cited 1×
“This is indeed reasonable, because PFASs tend to bind to proteins and tomembrane phospholipids rather than to storage lipids (e.g., Jones et al. 2003; Weiss et al. 2009; Bischel et al. 2011; Ng and Hungerb€uhler 2013, 2014).”
Quinete, N., Wu, Q., Zhang, T., Yun, S. H., Moreira, I., & Kannan, K. (2009) · Chemosphere · doi:10.1016/j.chemosphere.2009.07.079 · Cited by 206
Bischel, H. N., MacManus-Spencer, L. A., Zhang, C., & Luthy, R. G. (2011) · Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry · doi:10.1002/etc.647 · Cited by 182 · cited 1×
“This is indeed reasonable, because PFASs tend to bind to proteins and tomembrane phospholipids rather than to storage lipids (e.g., Jones et al. 2003; Weiss et al. 2009; Bischel et al. 2011; Ng and Hungerb€uhler 2013, 2014).”
BackgroundToxicokinetics of Seven Perfluoroalkyl Sulfonic and Carboxylic Acids in Pigs Fed a Contaminated Diet
Numata, J., Kowalczyk, J., Adolphs, J., Ehlers, S., Schafft, H., Fuerst, P., Müller-Graf, C., Lahrssen-Wiederholt, M., & Greiner, M. (2014) · Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry · doi:10.1021/jf405827u · Cited by 92 · cited 6×
“In the work by Numata et al. (2014), PFHxS constitutes an outlier, in that its BMF and elimination half-life are greater than those of the longer-chain PFHpS and PFOS.”
Influential
Cited by
Lewis, A. J., Yun, X., Spooner, D. E., Kurz, M. J., McKenzie, E. R., & Sales, C. M. (2022) · Science of The Total Environment · doi:10.1016/j.scitotenv.2022.153561 · Cited by 184
Evidence for the trophic transfer of perfluoroalkylated substances in a temperate macrotidal estuary
Munoz, G., Budzinski, H., Babut, M., Drouineau, H., Lauzent, M., Menach, K. L., Lobry, J., Selleslagh, J., Simonnet-Laprade, C., & Labadie, P. (2017) · Environmental Science & Technology · doi:10.1021/acs.est.7b02399 · Cited by 165
Munoz, G., Mercier, L., Duy, S. V., Liu, J., Sauvé, S., & Houde, M. (2022) · Environmental Pollution · doi:10.1016/j.envpol.2022.119739 · Cited by 160
Pan, C.-G., Xiao, S.-K., Yu, K.-F., Wu, Q., & Wang, Y.-H. (2021) · Journal of Hazardous Materials · doi:10.1016/j.jhazmat.2020.123618 · Cited by 157
Lan, Z., Yao, Y., Xu, J., Chen, H., Ren, C., Fang, X., Zhang, K., Jin, L., Hua, X., Alder, A. C., et al. (2020) · Environmental Pollution · doi:10.1016/j.envpol.2020.114487 · Cited by 94
Metadata
- Authors
- Franklin, J.
- Venue
- Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management
- Publisher
- Oxford University Press (OUP)
- Published
- 2015-04-01
- Volume
- 12
- Issue
- 1
- Pages
- 6-20
- ISSN
- 1551-3777 (ISSN-L)
- 1551-3793
- OpenAlex
- W1561425020
- Cited by
- 92
- References
- 14
- FWCI
- 3.33
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- hybrid
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.