Re-Assessing the Need for Apatite- and Dolomite-Specific Calibrations of the Carbonate Clumped Isotope Thermometer
Open accessThe DOI matches its Crossref record; 70 of the 70 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; 29 of the 98 sources its claims cite were checked for support.
Abstract
A few key methodological uncertainties remain for the carbonate clumped isotope community. One is how to compare data among published data sets that are not anchored to the InterCarb Carbon Dioxide Equilibrium Scale (I‐CDES). A second is how temperature calibrations of calcite compare to those of other carbonate minerals in the I‐CDES—particularly dolomite and apatite—which can elucidate several Earth system dynamics. Previous calibrations of the clumped isotope thermometer for dolomite are discrepant from one another and variably (dis)agree with calibrations developed for calcite; apatite calibrations have not yet been compared between laboratories using carbonate‐based standardization. Here we report I‐CDES standardized values for a suite of 11 carbonates that are commonly measured by the clumped isotope community to aid future comparisons of non‐I‐CDES data sets. In addition, 17 dolomite samples (25–1,200°C) and five apatite samples (1–38°C) of known precipitation temperature were measured using carbonate‐based standardization. Excellent agreement between calcites and dolomites heated to similar temperatures (1,100–1,200°C) suggests no mineral‐specific differences in absolute acid fractionation factor. We show that calcite and dolomite regressions largely agree but are sensitive to sample characteristics, regression method, and how equations are statistically compared. We suggest that there is no need for a dolomite‐specific clumped isotope calibration, although our results suggest that further work is necessary to determine the influence of sample characteristics on this relationship. The apatite calibration equation defined in this study is statistically indistinguishable from calcite‐based calibrations; we corroborate previous findings that an apatite‐specific calibration is unnecessary.
Overview
CoChat Summary
## TL;DR
This paper re-evaluates whether dolomite and apatite need their own clumped-isotope thermometer calibrations using I-CDES-standardized measurements of 11 carbonate standards, 17 dolomites, and 5 apatites. The authors conclude that a dolomite-specific calibration is unnecessary and that apatite can be dated with existing calcite-based I-CDES calibrations, especially near Earth-surface temperatures.
## Key findings
- The study reports I-CDES values for 11 commonly used carbonate standards, including 2 dolomites, and says these can help project non-InterCarb data into the InterCarb Carbon Dioxide Equilibrium Scale.
- For dolomite, the linear regression from this study is statistically indistinguishable from Anderson et al. (2021) at the p > 0.05 level using ANCOVA, and the authors find “no resolvable difference in absolute acid fractionation factors” between dolomite and calcite from heated samples.
- Heated dolomites at 1,100–1,200°C gave Δ47 values of 0.180, 0.183, 0.184, and 0.184‰, within 10 ppm of calcite predictions and consistent with the calcite calibration.
- For apatite, the calibration from 5 unique samples is statistically indistinguishable from Anderson et al. (2021), Löffler et al. (2019), and Griffiths et al. (2023); the authors recommend using established calcite calibrations for apatites formed near Earth-surface temperatures (<40°C).
## Methods
- The study measured 17 dolomites spanning 1–1,200°C and 5 apatites spanning 1–38°C, plus 11 carbonate standards commonly used in clumped-isotope work; samples came from prior studies and new materials produced or collected for this work.
- Clumped-isotope analyses were done at MIT from January 2018 to November 2022 on a Nu Perspective dual-inlet IRMS, with 70°C phosphoric-acid digestion and projection to I-CDES using InterCarb anchor values.
- The authors compared calibrations with Monte Carlo linear regressions, York regressions, bootstrapped regressions, and ANCOVA, and tested effects of reaction time, magnesium concentration, dolomite cation ordering, precipitation method, and the use of samples outside carbonate-anchor coverage.
## Limitations
- The paper states that the apatite calibration is defined by only five unique samples spanning a relatively narrow temperature range, and therefore recommends calcite calibrations for apatites near Earth-surface temperatures; this is a stated limitation.
- The authors note that data above 40°C for apatite are lacking, so it remains unclear whether high-temperature apatites truly diverge from calcite; this is stated in the paper.
- The text makes evident that several dolomite tests are underpowered or confounded by sample selection: some groups do not overlap in formation temperature, some subsets are only n=4 or n=6, and many well-ordered samples are also outside or poorly constrained by the I-CDES reference frame.
Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Figures















Verification
Claims the paper makes
26 Valid · 0 Not valid · 44 Not checked · 65 Own results and interpretations
The cited sources support only part of this claim — read each source’s verdict below.
In the paper
“Dolomite non-InterCarb anchors measured here (SRM-88b and Rodolo) and in other studies (Defliese etal.,2015; Lucarelli etal.,2023; Müller etal.,2019; Murray etal.,2016; Upadhyay etal.,2021) have a relatively narrow range of Δ 47 (0.52-0.63‰) and δ 47 (-0.8-4.8‰; Figure S2 in Supporting InformationS1).”
What the sources say
- Not checked — no full text of the sourcecites Defliese et al., 2015 source
- Could not verifycites Lucarelli et al., 2023 sourceExperimental — accuracy not yet measured
The Results (§Δ47 and Δ48 Results; page unavailable) say the paper measured Δ47 values for carbonate standards and samples, but the retrieved passages do not identify SRM-88b or Rodolo or give the claimed dolomite ranges. Searches for both names, dolomite, and the stated numerical ranges found no passage that verifies this attribution. (LLM, conf=0.70)
- Partly supportedcites Müller et al., 2019 sourceExperimental — accuracy not yet measured
Section 3.4 and Table 3 report Δ47 values of 0.522‰ for NIST SRM 88b and 0.632‰ for Rodolo, matching the cited range when rounded. Our copy does not report δ47 values for these anchors or establish the claimed −0.8 to 4.8‰ range; its δ13C and δ18O values are different measurements. Page numbers were not available in the indexed passages. (LLM, conf=0.86)
plain- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
Every source the paper cites for this claim was checked and supports it.
In the paper
“Four heated dolomite samples reported in this study (three formed at ETH at 1,100°C and measured at ETH; one formed at IPG Paris at 1,200°C and measured at MIT) have Δ 47 values within 10ppm of those predicted for calcites with the Anderson etal.(2021) calibration equation (Figure4).”
What the sources say
- Supportedcites Anderson et al. (2021) source
Split into 2 atoms — 2 confirmed, 0 partially supported, 0 disputed, 0 misattributed, 0 unverifiable. Expand the claim to see per-atom verdicts.
plainn = 4- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Supported
Every source the paper cites for this claim was checked and supports it.
In the paper
“The two samples with the lowest magnesium concentration (100-A3 and Leeds 20) show very small residuals from the Anderson etal.(2021) calibration (Figure S6 in Supporting InformationS1).”
What the sources say
- Supportedcites Anderson et al. (2021) source
The Conclusions (§4; page unavailable) identify a Δ47–temperature calibration defined by this paper’s data, and the sample table (§3.1; page unavailable) includes IPGP_100-A3. The citation identifies the calibration used for the comparison; the residuals and Figure S6 are the citing authors’ own analysis, not a result attributed to Anderson et al. (LLM, conf=0.91)
plainstates an associationn = 2- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: unclear — It is unclear whether the paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Supported
Every source the paper cites for this claim was checked and supports it.
In the paper
“For the third order regression, three out of four regression coefficients show worse agreement with Anderson etal.(2021) when the variable AFF is applied.”
What the sources say
- Supportedcites Anderson et al. (2021) source
Section 3.3 reports a third-order polynomial regression through Anderson et al.’s data, establishing the cited work as the comparison calibration. The assessment that applying variable AFF worsens agreement for three of four coefficients is the citing authors’ own comparison, not a result attributed to Anderson et al. (LLM, conf=0.85)
plainstates a cause- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Supported
Every source the paper cites for this claim was checked and supports it.
In the paper
“Samples with magnesium concentrations closer to stoichiometric dolomite show a broad range of offsets from Anderson etal.(2021).”
What the sources say
- Supportedcites Anderson et al. (2021) source
The citation identifies Anderson et al. (2021) as the calibration from which the citing authors measured offsets in their own samples. Section 4 (Conclusions) states that the paper presents a temperature–Δ47 regression applicable to carbonate material. The claim does not attribute the citing authors’ magnesium measurements or observed range of offsets to Anderson et al. (LLM, conf=0.88)
plainstates an association- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: unclear — It is unclear whether the paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Supported
61 more claims · 3 with their cited sources checked
Create a free account to see all 135 claims and every source verdict.
- Probably not a substantial claim. 31
- It may state two separate claims as one. 52
- The quote only partly states this claim. 2
Self-check
Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.
Each contradiction between two passages listed here was confirmed by an independent check.
Rated minor: it would not touch a result — a value no result rests on, a p-value that stays on the same side of the significance level, or a conflict that is clerical, resolved elsewhere in the paper, or outside its own findings.
In the paper
§ Re-Assessing the Need for Apatite- and Dolomite-Specific Calibrations of the Carbonate Clumped Isotope Thermometer
“In addition, 17 dolomite samples (25-1,200°C) and five apatite samples (1-38°C) of known precipitation temperature were measured using carbonate-based standardization.”
§ 2.3. Apatites
“American crocodile ( Crocodylus acutus ) was obtained from the Harvard University Museum of Comparative Zoology collection and was originally from Bahía de Cabañas, Cuba. Reptilian body temperature estimates are not straightforward as they reflect both ambient environmental temperature and basking behavior (and other variables, such as body size); we use a temperature of 28.7±5°C”
Citations
Cites
Unified equations for the slope, intercept, and standard errors of the best straight line
York, D., Evensen, N. M., Martı́nez, M. L., & De Basabe Delgado, J. (2004) · American Journal of Physics · doi:10.1119/1.1632486 · Cited by 1,197 · cited 1×
“In the second approach, “York” regression was calculated accounting for propagated error in Δ 47 (95% CL) and stated error in temperature (York et al., 2004; Zaarur et al., 2013).”
MethodKoch, P. L., Tuross, N., & Fogel, M. L. (1997) · Journal of Archaeological Science · doi:10.1006/jasc.1996.0126 · Cited by 957 · cited 1×
“Tooth enamel is nearly anorganic, non-porous, highly crystalline and composed of large crystals with relatively few structural defects, rendering it highly resistant to isotopic alteration via post-depositional processes (Koch et al., 1997; LeGeros, 1981).”
Background13C–18O bonds in carbonate minerals: a new kind of paleothermometer
Ghosh, P., Adkins, J., Affek, H., Balta, B., Guo, W., Schauble, E. A., Schrag, D., & Eiler, J. M. (2006) · Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta · doi:10.1016/j.gca.2005.11.014 · Cited by 914 · cited 1×
“…calibrations for the calcite clumped isotope thermometer have been created over the past ∼15 years (Anderson et al., 2021; Bernasconi et al., 2018; Ghosh et al., 2006; Huntington et al., 2009; Jautzy et al., 2021; Kele et al., 2015; Kelson et al., 2017; Petersen et al., 2019), and recent efforts…”
BackgroundAn isotopic study of siderites, dolomites and ankerites at high temperatures
Rosenbaum, J., & Sheppard, S. M. F. (1986) · Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta · doi:10.1016/0016-7037(86)90396-0 · Cited by 827
“Clumped-isotope” geochemistry—The study of naturally-occurring, multiply-substituted isotopologues
Eiler, J. M. (2007) · Earth and Planetary Science Letters · doi:10.1016/j.epsl.2007.08.020 · Cited by 774
Apatites in biological systems
Zapanta LeGeros, R. (1981) · Progress in Crystal Growth and Characterization · doi:10.1016/0146-3535(81)90046-0 · Cited by 622
Schauble, E. A., Ghosh, P., & Eiler, J. M. (2006) · Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta · doi:10.1016/j.gca.2006.02.011 · Cited by 483 · cited 3×
“This conclusion aligns with the theoretical literature that shows minimal discrepancy between clumped isotope equilibrium between dolomite and calcite (Hill et al., 2020; Schauble et al., 2006).”
BackgroundResultHuntington, K. W., Eiler, J. M., Affek, H. P., Guo, W., Bonifacie, M., Yeung, L. Y., Thiagarajan, N., Passey, B., Tripati, A., Daëron, M., et al. (2009) · Journal of Mass Spectrometry · doi:10.1002/jms.1614 · Cited by 436 · cited 1×
“…calcite clumped isotope thermometer have been created over the past ∼15 years (Anderson et al., 2021; Bernasconi et al., 2018; Ghosh et al., 2006; Huntington et al., 2009; Jautzy et al., 2021; Kele et al., 2015; Kelson et al., 2017; Petersen et al., 2019), and recent efforts using…”
BackgroundSelf-citationPhosphoric acid fractionation factors for calcite and aragonite between 25 and 75 °C: Revisited
Kim, S.-T., Mucci, A., & Taylor, B. E. (2007) · Chemical Geology · doi:10.1016/j.chemgeo.2007.08.005 · Cited by 374 · cited 1×
“…data were processed using the “D47crunch” Python package using IUPAC 17 O parameters, 70°C 18 O acid fractionation factor of 1.00871 for apatite (Kim et al., 2007) and 1.009926 for dolomite (Rosenbaum and Shepard, 1986), and projected to the I-CDES with values for ETH-1–4 and IAEA-C2 anchors…”
MethodInfluentialBernasconi, S. M., Daëron, M., Bergmann, K. D., Bonifacie, M., Meckler, A. N., Affek, H. P., Anderson, N., Bajnai, D., Barkan, E., Beverly, E., et al. (2021) · Geochemistry Geophysics Geosystems · doi:10.1029/2020gc009588 · Cited by 340 · cited 7×
“…IUPAC 17 O parameters, 70°C 18 O acid fractionation factor of 1.00871 for apatite (Kim et al., 2007) and 1.009926 for dolomite (Rosenbaum and Shepard, 1986), and projected to the I-CDES with values for ETH-1–4 and IAEA-C2 anchors from the InterCarb project (Bernasconi et al., 2021; Daëron, 2021).”
BackgroundMethodInfluentialSelf-citation
Research works printed but not linked: 4
- 10.1130/G49422.1/5543257/g49422.pdf · doi:10.1130/g49422.1/5543257/g49422.pdf
- Bonifacie M., 2023, Goldschmidt conference
- 10.1130/G49634.1/5583260/g49634.pdf · doi:10.1130/g49634.1/5583260/g49634.pdf
- Ross S. M., 2003, Peirce's criterion for the elimination of suspect experimental data, Journal of Engineering Technology, 20, 1
Cited by
Daëron, M., & Vermeesch, P. (2024) · Chemical Geology · doi:10.1016/j.chemgeo.2023.121881 · Cited by 28
Li, L., Garzione, C. N., Lu, H., & Quade, J. (2024) · Earth and Planetary Science Letters · doi:10.1016/j.epsl.2024.118961 · Cited by 25
Li, L., DeCelles, P. G., Kapp, P., Garzione, C. N., Quade, J., & Yanay, N. (2024) · Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta · doi:10.1016/j.gca.2024.04.007 · Cited by 15
Origins and Alteration of Ediacaran Carbonates Recording the Shuram Excursion in Oman
Bergmann, K., Osburn, M. R., Anderson, N. T., Hayhow, C., Wilcots, J., Cantine, M. D., Fischer, W. W., & Bonifacie, M. (2025) · Geochemistry Geophysics Geosystems · doi:10.1029/2025gc012161 · Cited by 10
“Raw voltage measurements were transferred to the Intercarb Carbon Dioxide Equilibrium Scale using Clum-pyCrunch and BLIMP to calculate both Δ 47 and Δ 48 (Anderson et al., 2024; Bernasconi et al., 2021; Daëron, 2021; Dennis et al., 2011).”
Self-citationEffects of mineralogy on Δ47 and Δ48 of carbonate-derived CO2 below analytical resolution
Bernecker, M., Bonifacie, M., Staudigel, P. T., Meijer, N., Siebert, J., Wehr, N., Haussühl, E., Bernasconi, S. M., Petrash, D. A., Dietzel, M., et al. (2025) · Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta · doi:10.1016/j.gca.2025.06.004 · Cited by 9
Self-citation
Metadata
- Authors
- Anderson, N. T., Bonifacie, M., Jost, A. B., Siebert, J., Bontognali, T., Horita, J., Müller, I. A., Bernasconi, S. M., & Bergmann, K. D.
- Affiliations
- Massachusetts Institute of Technology (US)
- Institut de physique du globe de Paris (FR)
- University of Basel (CH)
- Texas Tech University (US)
- University of Geneva (CH)
- ETH Zurich (CH)
- Corresponding author
- Anderson, N. T.
- ORCID
- Venue
- Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems
- Publisher
- American Geophysical Union (AGU)
- Published
- 2024-01
- Volume
- 25
- Issue
- 1
- ISSN
- 1525-2027 (ISSN-L)
- OpenAlex
- W4391097330
- Cited by
- 13
- References
- 68
- Citations by year
- 2026: 5 · 2025: 4 · 2024: 2
- FWCI
- 2.01
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- gold
- doi.org
- Licence
- Locations
- Geochemistry Geophysics Geosystems (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc)
- HAL (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc-nd)
- DSpace@MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc)
- Repository for Publications and Research Data (ETH Zurich) (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc)
- ETH Zürich Research Collection
- Funders
- National Science Foundation (2221963)
- NASA Astrobiology Institute (80NSSC19K0464)
- David and Lucile Packard Foundation (2018‐68044)
- Topics
- Physical Sciences › Earth and Planetary Sciences › Atmospheric Science › Geology and Paleoclimatology Research
- Physical Sciences › Earth and Planetary Sciences › Paleontology › Paleontology and Stratigraphy of Fossils
- Physical Sciences › Earth and Planetary Sciences › Geochemistry and Petrology › Geological and Geochemical Analysis
- Keywords
- carbonate clumped isotopes, clumped isotope thermometry, apatite, dolomite, calcite, temperature calibration, regression model comparison, sample characteristics
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
The claim verdicts this report counts are experimental: their accuracy is not yet measured.
A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-10-09, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).
A second model labelled each claim on 2026-10-09 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).
Cited sources are checked with a language model’s help (gpt-6-sol).
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
How to cite
Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.
- This page
- CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Re-Assessing the Need for Apatite- and Dolomite-Specific Calibrations of the Carbonate Clumped Isotope Thermometer. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1029/2023gc011049
- The paper
- Anderson, N. T., Bonifacie, M., Jost, A. B., Siebert, J., Bontognali, T., Horita, J., Müller, I. A., Bernasconi, S. M., & Bergmann, K. D. (2024). Re-Assessing the Need for Apatite- and Dolomite-Specific Calibrations of the Carbonate Clumped Isotope Thermometer. Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems. https://doi.org/10.1029/2023gc011049
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.