CoChat

Re-Assessing the Need for Apatite- and Dolomite-Specific Calibrations of the Carbonate Clumped Isotope Thermometer

Open access

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 70 of the 70 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; 29 of the 98 sources its claims cite were checked for support.

Abstract

A few key methodological uncertainties remain for the carbonate clumped isotope community. One is how to compare data among published data sets that are not anchored to the InterCarb Carbon Dioxide Equilibrium Scale (I‐CDES). A second is how temperature calibrations of calcite compare to those of other carbonate minerals in the I‐CDES—particularly dolomite and apatite—which can elucidate several Earth system dynamics. Previous calibrations of the clumped isotope thermometer for dolomite are discrepant from one another and variably (dis)agree with calibrations developed for calcite; apatite calibrations have not yet been compared between laboratories using carbonate‐based standardization. Here we report I‐CDES standardized values for a suite of 11 carbonates that are commonly measured by the clumped isotope community to aid future comparisons of non‐I‐CDES data sets. In addition, 17 dolomite samples (25–1,200°C) and five apatite samples (1–38°C) of known precipitation temperature were measured using carbonate‐based standardization. Excellent agreement between calcites and dolomites heated to similar temperatures (1,100–1,200°C) suggests no mineral‐specific differences in absolute acid fractionation factor. We show that calcite and dolomite regressions largely agree but are sensitive to sample characteristics, regression method, and how equations are statistically compared. We suggest that there is no need for a dolomite‐specific clumped isotope calibration, although our results suggest that further work is necessary to determine the influence of sample characteristics on this relationship. The apatite calibration equation defined in this study is statistically indistinguishable from calcite‐based calibrations; we corroborate previous findings that an apatite‐specific calibration is unnecessary.

Overview

CoChat Summary

## TL;DR

This paper re-evaluates whether dolomite and apatite need their own clumped-isotope thermometer calibrations using I-CDES-standardized measurements of 11 carbonate standards, 17 dolomites, and 5 apatites. The authors conclude that a dolomite-specific calibration is unnecessary and that apatite can be dated with existing calcite-based I-CDES calibrations, especially near Earth-surface temperatures.

## Key findings

  • The study reports I-CDES values for 11 commonly used carbonate standards, including 2 dolomites, and says these can help project non-InterCarb data into the InterCarb Carbon Dioxide Equilibrium Scale.
  • For dolomite, the linear regression from this study is statistically indistinguishable from Anderson et al. (2021) at the p > 0.05 level using ANCOVA, and the authors find “no resolvable difference in absolute acid fractionation factors” between dolomite and calcite from heated samples.
  • Heated dolomites at 1,100–1,200°C gave Δ47 values of 0.180, 0.183, 0.184, and 0.184‰, within 10 ppm of calcite predictions and consistent with the calcite calibration.
  • For apatite, the calibration from 5 unique samples is statistically indistinguishable from Anderson et al. (2021), Löffler et al. (2019), and Griffiths et al. (2023); the authors recommend using established calcite calibrations for apatites formed near Earth-surface temperatures (<40°C).

## Methods

  • The study measured 17 dolomites spanning 1–1,200°C and 5 apatites spanning 1–38°C, plus 11 carbonate standards commonly used in clumped-isotope work; samples came from prior studies and new materials produced or collected for this work.
  • Clumped-isotope analyses were done at MIT from January 2018 to November 2022 on a Nu Perspective dual-inlet IRMS, with 70°C phosphoric-acid digestion and projection to I-CDES using InterCarb anchor values.
  • The authors compared calibrations with Monte Carlo linear regressions, York regressions, bootstrapped regressions, and ANCOVA, and tested effects of reaction time, magnesium concentration, dolomite cation ordering, precipitation method, and the use of samples outside carbonate-anchor coverage.

## Limitations

  • The paper states that the apatite calibration is defined by only five unique samples spanning a relatively narrow temperature range, and therefore recommends calcite calibrations for apatites near Earth-surface temperatures; this is a stated limitation.
  • The authors note that data above 40°C for apatite are lacking, so it remains unclear whether high-temperature apatites truly diverge from calcite; this is stated in the paper.
  • The text makes evident that several dolomite tests are underpowered or confounded by sample selection: some groups do not overlap in formation temperature, some subsets are only n=4 or n=6, and many well-ordered samples are also outside or poorly constrained by the I-CDES reference frame.

Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1029/2023gc011049

Cites

70 of 70 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Nothing to recompute.

Figures

Figure 1 Linear (black) and third-order (red dashed) 1/T 2 -Δ47 regressions for dolomite samples measured in this study and that from Anderson et al. (2021). Filled circles represent samples measured in this study that were originally analyzed by Bonifacie et al. (2017; green) and Müller et al. (2019; purple). Filled squares show new samples produced and measured in this study. Open squares show data from the same samples in their original studies, with Bonifacie et al. (2017) data reported with respect to the CDES90 reference frame and Müller et al. (2019) re-processed to the InterCarb Carbon Dioxide Equilibrium Scale (I-CDES) reference frame. Linear regressions through these data agree with Anderson et al. (2021) using analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) and 1 SD error of the estimate; third-order regressions do not agree within 1 SD error of the estimate (see Table 3 and Table S4).
Figure 1 Linear (black) and third-order (red dashed) 1/T 2 -Δ47 regressions for dolomite samples measured in this study and that from Anderson et al. (2021). Filled circles represent samples measured in this study that were originally analyzed by Bonifacie et al. (2017; green) and Müller et al. (2019; purple). Filled squares show new samples produced and measured in this study. Open squares show data from the same samples in their original studies, with Bonifacie et al. (2017) data reported with respect to the CDES90 reference frame and Müller et al. (2019) re-processed to the InterCarb Carbon Dioxide Equilibrium Scale (I-CDES) reference frame. Linear regressions through these data agree with Anderson et al. (2021) using analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) and 1 SD error of the estimate; third-order regressions do not agree within 1 SD error of the estimate (see Table 3 and Table S4).From the PDF
Image 2
From the PDF
Figure 2 Comparison of calculated temperatures for 0-500°C (top panel) and 0-60°C (bottom panel) using regressions through all data in this study, all data in this study with δ 47 values >-30, and all data in this study with δ 47 values >-30 plus the data from Müller et al. (2019) reprocessed into the InterCarb Carbon Dioxide Equilibrium Scale (I-CDES). The regression from Equation 1 of Anderson et al. (2021) is used to calculate the datum; the Δ 47 -T relationships of Bonifacie et al. (2017), Müller et al. (2019), and Petersen et al. (2019) are shown for comparison. The calculated temperatures based on regression through all data in this study are 0-3°C higher than the calculated temperatures from Anderson et al. (2021) until ∼250°C, where they become lower.
Figure 2 Comparison of calculated temperatures for 0-500°C (top panel) and 0-60°C (bottom panel) using regressions through all data in this study, all data in this study with δ 47 values >-30, and all data in this study with δ 47 values >-30 plus the data from Müller et al. (2019) reprocessed into the InterCarb Carbon Dioxide Equilibrium Scale (I-CDES). The regression from Equation 1 of Anderson et al. (2021) is used to calculate the datum; the Δ 47 -T relationships of Bonifacie et al. (2017), Müller et al. (2019), and Petersen et al. (2019) are shown for comparison. The calculated temperatures based on regression through all data in this study are 0-3°C higher than the calculated temperatures from Anderson et al. (2021) until ∼250°C, where they become lower.From the PDF
Figure 3 Comparison of normalized Δ 47 values for a subset of samples that were run at both 25 and 90 min acid reaction time. There is no statistically significant difference in Δ 47 between these two populations.
Figure 3 Comparison of normalized Δ 47 values for a subset of samples that were run at both 25 and 90 min acid reaction time. There is no statistically significant difference in Δ 47 between these two populations.From the PDF
Image 5
From the PDF
Figure 4 Solid symbols show difference in Δ 47 between dolomite samples measured in this study (closed shapes), measured values from previous studies (open shapes), and the prediction from the Anderson et al. (2021) calibration. Lines compare regressions from subsets of data from this study with Anderson et al. (2021) and Fiebig et al. (2021).
Figure 4 Solid symbols show difference in Δ 47 between dolomite samples measured in this study (closed shapes), measured values from previous studies (open shapes), and the prediction from the Anderson et al. (2021) calibration. Lines compare regressions from subsets of data from this study with Anderson et al. (2021) and Fiebig et al. (2021).From the PDF
Image 7
From the PDF
Image 8
From the PDF
Figure 6 (a) Ordering of dolomite as measured by the ratio of (015) to (110) XRD spectra peaks compared with offset from Anderson et al. (2021) calibration; 'well-ordered' samples, here arbitrarily defined as ordering ratio of 0.3, tend to fall further from the Anderson et al. (2021) calibration. Squares show Bonifacie et al. (2017) samples, circles show Müller et al. (2019) samples. (b) Comparisons of calibrations only considering poorly or well-ordered dolomites. Poorly ordered dolomites define a statistically indistinguishable calibration to that of Anderson et al. (2021); well-ordered samples do not.
Figure 6 (a) Ordering of dolomite as measured by the ratio of (015) to (110) XRD spectra peaks compared with offset from Anderson et al. (2021) calibration; 'well-ordered' samples, here arbitrarily defined as ordering ratio of 0.3, tend to fall further from the Anderson et al. (2021) calibration. Squares show Bonifacie et al. (2017) samples, circles show Müller et al. (2019) samples. (b) Comparisons of calibrations only considering poorly or well-ordered dolomites. Poorly ordered dolomites define a statistically indistinguishable calibration to that of Anderson et al. (2021); well-ordered samples do not.From the PDF
Image 10
From the PDF
Figure 7 (a) Comparison of offsets from Anderson et al. (2021) predicted values and values measured in this study using precipitation method. Samples precipitated from amorphous gels and natural precipitates (brown circles) have lower residuals than dolomitized powders and direct precipitates (blue squares). (b) Regression of samples precipitated from amorphous gels and natural precipitates compared to that of direct precipitates and dolomitized powders. The former agrees more closely with Anderson et al. (2021).
Figure 7 (a) Comparison of offsets from Anderson et al. (2021) predicted values and values measured in this study using precipitation method. Samples precipitated from amorphous gels and natural precipitates (brown circles) have lower residuals than dolomitized powders and direct precipitates (blue squares). (b) Regression of samples precipitated from amorphous gels and natural precipitates compared to that of direct precipitates and dolomitized powders. The former agrees more closely with Anderson et al. (2021).From the PDF
Image 12
From the PDF
Figure 8 (a) Comparison of third-order polynomial regressions with all data with δ 47 > -30 (dashed) and all natural or amorphous gel precipitates (dash-dot); the latter is within 1 SD of the third-order polynomial regression of Anderson et al. (2021). Third-order polynomials show high sensitivity to the removal of individual samples. (b) Same as plot from A but including reprocessed data from Müller et al. (2019).
Figure 8 (a) Comparison of third-order polynomial regressions with all data with δ 47 > -30 (dashed) and all natural or amorphous gel precipitates (dash-dot); the latter is within 1 SD of the third-order polynomial regression of Anderson et al. (2021). Third-order polynomials show high sensitivity to the removal of individual samples. (b) Same as plot from A but including reprocessed data from Müller et al. (2019).From the PDF
Image 14
From the PDF
Figure 9 Linear 1/T 2 -Δ47 regression and 95% CI for apatite samples measured in this study (blue circles) and that from Löffler et al. (2019; open squares) and Griffiths et al. (2023; gray squares). The apatite regression from this study agrees with the regressions of both Anderson et al. (2021), Griffiths et al. (2023), and Löffler et al. (2019).
Figure 9 Linear 1/T 2 -Δ47 regression and 95% CI for apatite samples measured in this study (blue circles) and that from Löffler et al. (2019; open squares) and Griffiths et al. (2023; gray squares). The apatite regression from this study agrees with the regressions of both Anderson et al. (2021), Griffiths et al. (2023), and Löffler et al. (2019).From the PDF

Verification

Claims the paper makes

26 Valid · 0 Not valid · 44 Not checked · 65 Own results and interpretations

61 more claims · 3 with their cited sources checked

Create a free account to see all 135 claims and every source verdict.

See all claims — free account
  • Probably not a substantial claim. 31
  • It may state two separate claims as one. 52
  • The quote only partly states this claim. 2

Create a free account to see these claims.

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

Each contradiction between two passages listed here was confirmed by an independent check.

1 of 1

Citations

Cites

Show all 70 references

Research works printed but not linked: 4

  1. 10.1130/G49422.1/5543257/g49422.pdf · doi:10.1130/g49422.1/5543257/g49422.pdf
  2. Bonifacie M., 2023, Goldschmidt conference
  3. 10.1130/G49634.1/5583260/g49634.pdf · doi:10.1130/g49634.1/5583260/g49634.pdf
  4. Ross S. M., 2003, Peirce's criterion for the elimination of suspect experimental data, Journal of Engineering Technology, 20, 1

Cited by

See all 13

Metadata

Authors
Anderson, N. T., Bonifacie, M., Jost, A. B., Siebert, J., Bontognali, T., Horita, J., Müller, I. A., Bernasconi, S. M., & Bergmann, K. D.
Affiliations
  • Massachusetts Institute of Technology (US)
  • Institut de physique du globe de Paris (FR)
  • University of Basel (CH)
  • Texas Tech University (US)
  • University of Geneva (CH)
  • ETH Zurich (CH)
Corresponding author
Anderson, N. T.
Venue
Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems
Published
2024-01
Volume
25
Issue
1
ISSN
1525-2027 (ISSN-L)
OpenAlex
W4391097330
Cited by
13
References
68
Citations by year
2026: 5 · 2025: 4 · 2024: 2
FWCI
2.01
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Locations
  • Geochemistry Geophysics Geosystems (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc)
  • HAL (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc-nd)
  • DSpace@MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc)
  • Repository for Publications and Research Data (ETH Zurich) (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc)
  • ETH Zürich Research Collection
Funders
  • National Science Foundation (2221963)
  • NASA Astrobiology Institute (80NSSC19K0464)
  • David and Lucile Packard Foundation (2018‐68044)
Topics
  • Physical Sciences › Earth and Planetary Sciences › Atmospheric Science › Geology and Paleoclimatology Research
  • Physical Sciences › Earth and Planetary Sciences › Paleontology › Paleontology and Stratigraphy of Fossils
  • Physical Sciences › Earth and Planetary Sciences › Geochemistry and Petrology › Geological and Geochemical Analysis
Keywords
carbonate clumped isotopes, clumped isotope thermometry, apatite, dolomite, calcite, temperature calibration, regression model comparison, sample characteristics

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

The claim verdicts this report counts are experimental: their accuracy is not yet measured.

A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-10-09, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).

A second model labelled each claim on 2026-10-09 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).

Cited sources are checked with a language model’s help (gpt-6-sol).

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Re-Assessing the Need for Apatite- and Dolomite-Specific Calibrations of the Carbonate Clumped Isotope Thermometer. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1029/2023gc011049
The paper
Anderson, N. T., Bonifacie, M., Jost, A. B., Siebert, J., Bontognali, T., Horita, J., Müller, I. A., Bernasconi, S. M., & Bergmann, K. D. (2024). Re-Assessing the Need for Apatite- and Dolomite-Specific Calibrations of the Carbonate Clumped Isotope Thermometer. Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems. https://doi.org/10.1029/2023gc011049

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.