InterCarb: A Community Effort to Improve Interlaboratory Standardization of the Carbonate Clumped Isotope Thermometer Using Carbonate Standards
Open accessThe DOI matches its Crossref record; 70 of the 71 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; 21 of the 53 sources its claims cite were checked for support.
Abstract
Abstract Increased use and improved methodology of carbonate clumped isotope thermometry has greatly enhanced our ability to interrogate a suite of Earth‐system processes. However, interlaboratory discrepancies in quantifying carbonate clumped isotope (Δ 47 ) measurements persist, and their specific sources remain unclear. To address interlaboratory differences, we first provide consensus values from the clumped isotope community for four carbonate standards relative to heated and equilibrated gases with 1,819 individual analyses from 10 laboratories. Then we analyzed the four carbonate standards along with three additional standards, spanning a broad range of δ 47 and Δ 47 values, for a total of 5,329 analyses on 25 individual mass spectrometers from 22 different laboratories. Treating three of the materials as known standards and the other four as unknowns, we find that the use of carbonate reference materials is a robust method for standardization that yields interlaboratory discrepancies entirely consistent with intralaboratory analytical uncertainties. Carbonate reference materials, along with measurement and data processing practices described herein, provide the carbonate clumped isotope community with a robust approach to achieve interlaboratory agreement as we continue to use and improve this powerful geochemical tool. We propose that carbonate clumped isotope data normalized to the carbonate reference materials described in this publication should be reported as Δ 47 (I‐CDES) values for Intercarb‐Carbon Dioxide Equilibrium Scale.
Overview
CoChat Summary
## TL;DR
InterCarb is a community interlaboratory comparison showing that carbonate reference materials can standardize carbonate clumped isotope measurements as well as, or better than, heated/equilibrated gas standards. Using 5,329 analyses across 25 mass spectrometers in 22 laboratories, the authors propose a new carbonate-based reporting scale, Δ47(I-CDES).
## Key findings
- The study compiled 1,819 individual analyses from 10 laboratories to derive consensus Δ47 values for the four ETH standards relative to heated/equilibrated gases, then used 5,329 analyses on 25 mass spectrometers from 22 laboratories to test carbonate-based standardization.
- The four unknown carbonate standards showed laboratory-average standard deviations of 0.011‰ (ETH-4), 0.011‰ (IAEA-C1), 0.018‰ (IAEA-C2), and 0.024‰ (MERCK); the largest scatter was for MERCK, the sample farthest outside the anchor triangle.
- With fully propagated uncertainties, the interlaboratory sigma-deviations were consistent with a normal distribution (p = 0.19), whereas HG/EG standardization showed scatter larger than expected from known analytical errors (p = 0.005).
- The reassessed ETH anchor values were on average more positive than in Bernasconi et al. (2018) by 0.035‰ and 0.040‰ for ETH-1 and ETH-2, 0.010‰ for ETH-3, and 0.031‰ for ETH-4 when projected back to 25 °C.
## Methods
- Community intercomparison: seven carbonate standards were distributed to participating labs; three were treated as anchors (ETH-1, ETH-2, ETH-3) and four as unknowns (ETH-4, IAEA-C1, IAEA-C2, MERCK).
- Data came from 25 mass spectrometers in 22 laboratories; instrumentation included custom and commercial sample preparation systems, with reactions typically at 70 °C or 90 °C.
- Raw data from all labs were processed with a single Python script; the analysis used session-specific standardization against the three anchor carbonates, error-weighted averages, and a Kolmogorov–Smirnov test to compare observed scatter with analytical uncertainty.
## Limitations
- The paper states that carbonate standardization has a smaller Δ47 range than heated/equilibrated gases, so some cases require extrapolation beyond the anchor carbonate space; this increases uncertainty and the need for replication.
- The study says the approach was tested only for calcites, so effects for dolomite, siderite, and aragonite remain to be tested; this is a stated limitation.
- Evident from the text: all participating laboratories provided “publication-grade” data, so the exercise does not assess poor-quality laboratories or grade individual lab performance.
Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Figures








Verification
Claims the paper makes
16 Valid · 1 Not valid · 17 Not checked · 71 Own results and interpretations
Every source the paper cites for this claim was checked and supports it.
In the paper
“In addition, normalizing results to accepted carbonate reference material values, as is commonly done with conventional carbon and oxygen isotope analysis in carbonates, removes the requirement to precisely quantify acid fractionation factors at different temperatures (Bernasconi et al., 2018).”
§ InterCarb: A Community Effort to Improve Interlaboratory Standardization of the Carbonate Clumped Isotope Thermometer Using Carbonate Standards > Introduction Carbonate clumped isotope (Δ47) thermometry is the most developed branch of the rapidly evolving field of clumped isotope geochemistry. Given the broad range of applications in Earth Sciences (e.g., Affek & Eiler, 2006; Dale et al., 2014; Eagle et al., 2010; Ferry et al., 2011; Ghosh, Adkins, et al., 2006; Ghosh, Garzione, & Eiler, 2006; Grauel et al., 2013; Guo & Eiler, 2007; Huntington et al., 2011; Mangenot et al., 2018; Passey & Henkes, 2012; Veillard et al., 2019) and the improvement of analytical methods including automation (Adlan et al., 2020; Bernasconi et al., 2018, 2013; Defliese & Lohmann, 2015; Dennis et al., 2011; Fiebig et al., 2019; Ghosh, Adkins, et al., 2006; He et al., 2012; Hu et al., 2014; Huntington et al., 2009; Meckler et al., 2014; Müller, Fernandez, et al., 2017; Passey et al., 2010; Petersen et al., 2016, 2019; Schmid & Bernasconi, 2010), the last 5–10 years have seen an increasing number of laboratories implementing this technique. The great potential of this thermometer can only be fully exploited if precision and accuracy are sufficient to resolve differences of a few degrees in formation temperatures. In addition, widely available reference materials that match the sample matrices are necessary so that data can be robustly compared across laboratories (Meier‐Augenstein & Schimmelmann, 2019). Currently the situation in the field of carbonate clumped isotope geochemistry is far from satisfactory. Published values for the ETH reference materials, the only carbonates that have been recently measured in many different laboratories worldwide, differ by up to 0.053‰ (see Bernasconi et al., 2018; Thaler et al., 2020 for recent comparisons). For paleoclimate applications, however, a repeatability across laboratories of 0.01‰ or better is a necessary goal for meaningful data comparison. This clearly calls for better standardization procedures to improve laboratory comparability. The data normalization scheme currently used in clumped isotope geochemistry of carbonates in many laboratories is based on the comparison of the composition of the CO2 liberated from carbonates by reaction with phosphoric acid with that of a set of CO2 gases with different bulk and clumped isotope compositions (Dennis et al., 2011). These gases are prepared either by heating CO2 at 1000 °C (heated gases; HG) or by CO2 equilibration with water at low temperatures (equilibrated gases at e.g., 25 °C, 50 °C; EG). By comparing the measured compositions with the theoretical predictions of the equilibrium thermodynamic abundance of multiply substituted isotopologues in heated and equilibrated gases (Wang et al., 2004; and updates in Petersen et al., 2019), the measurements are standardized to the scale that was named the “absolute reference frame” (ARF) by Dennis et al. (2011). In more recent publications, the ARF is often referred to as the “Carbon Dioxide Equilibration Scale” (CDES), a terminology introduced by Passey and Henkes (2012). This approach was designed to allow different laboratories to link their measurements to an internationally recognized scale firmly anchored to theory using relatively easy and established laboratory protocols to produce CO2 standard gases of known isotopic composition. Early comparisons of Δ47 CDES values for carbonates analyzed in different laboratories and corrected with HG/EG normalization were promising (Dennis et al., 2011). While Bonifacie et al. (2017) reported similar Δ47 CDES values for nine dolomite samples covering a range of almost 0.4‰ measured both at Caltech and IPGP laboratories with HG/EG normalization, Spooner et al. (2016) found that carbonate standardization improved agreement between data they obtained on samples analyzed both at Caltech and WHOI laboratories, compared to when they were using HG/EG normalization. Such recurrent cases of poor interlaboratory reproducibility (see also Bernasconi et al., 2018; Thaler et al., 2020) suggest that there are still unexplained differences in the results among laboratories (see Petersen et al., 2019 for a recent review). Apart from preservation problems, two known issues still limiting the reliability of this method to yield accurate temperature reconstructions are: (1) the lack of internationally recognized carbonate reference materials for a precise interlaboratory calibration, and (2) that published Δ47‐temperature calibrations produced in different laboratories have differed in both temperature dependence (slope) and absolute value (intercept). Possible reasons for the differences in slopes and intercepts of the Δ47 temperature dependence have been widely discussed in the literature (e.g., Bonifacie et al., 2017; Daëron et al., 2016; Fernandez et al., 2017; Katz et al., 2017; Kelson et al., 2017; Kluge et al., 2015; Petersen et al., 2019; Schauer et al., 2016). Discrepancies have been attributed to analytical artifacts such as CO2‐acid re‐equilibration at different acid digestion temperatures (see Swart et al., 2019; Wacker et al., 2013, for a recent discussion) and to slight pressure imbalances between sample and reference gas (Fiebig et al., 2016). Other factors proposed to influence the calculated slopes of the calibrations are the limitations of the data sets used in the individual studies, in particular in terms of the number of samples and replicates and of the temperature range covered by the available samples (Bonifacie et al., 2017; Fernandez et al., 2017). However, the discrepancies in the intercepts of the calibrations, for example, between Kelson et al. (2017) and Peral et al. (2018), and a generally poor laboratory comparability remain problems that could be mitigated by using a more robust standardization method. Petersen et al. (2019), in a recent effort to resolve differences in calibrations, compiled raw data of a number of published temperature calibrations and recalculated them all in a consistent way using the revised IUPAC correction parameters to correct for the 17O abundance (Daëron et al., 2016; Schauer et al., 2016). The goal was to test whether data processing differences and/or the use of consistent but incorrect 17O‐correction parameters in the calculations were the root causes of inconsistencies. The result of this study was that differences among calibrations were reduced but not eliminated by the recalculation, implying that other factors must be responsible for the remaining discrepancies. These differences have pushed many laboratories to use laboratory‐specific calibrations performed with the same analytical approach, as they at least partially take into consideration possible procedural differences (Petersen et al., 2019). However, if a laboratory changes analytical procedures or has not generated a robust in‐house calibration, this approach is problematic. Achieving an interlaboratory reproducibility at the level of accuracy necessary for meaningful interpretations of the observed variations is a requirement for Δ47 thermometry to reach its potential as a mature analytical method with broad acceptance and quantitative usefulness. While the definition of the CDES was a major milestone (Dennis et al., 2011), a known problem with this approach is that while the CO2 standard gases equilibrated at known temperature (HG or EG) can be confidently used for correction of mass spectrometric fractionations/nonlinearities and for effects of the purification procedures, they cannot account for the effects of the phosphoric acid reaction on the composition of the produced CO2. Among the factors responsible for discrepant calibrations and laboratory comparability, two important ones cannot be tested with a gas‐based standardization: (1) the absolute value and temperature dependence of the phosphoric acid fractionation factor (see Petersen et al., 2019 for a recent compilation) and (2) possible CO2 equilibration effects during acid digestion of the sample. Swart et al. (2019) presented evidence that equilibration of CO2 with water or hot metal surfaces during phosphoric acid reaction and transfer of the CO2 to the mass spectrometer could be a factor leading to the alteration of the apparent temperature dependence of clumped isotopes in carbonates and on the absolute value of calculated Δ47. As many laboratories use custom built extraction lines with different designs and volumes of tubing and of acid vessels, these factors are impossible to precisely quantify for each laboratory and may further contribute to interlaboratory discrepancies. We propose that these issues can be circumvented if carbonates, which undergo the same acid digestion as the samples, are used for normalization instead of or in addition to gases, consistent with the principle of identical treatment of sample and standards (Carter & Fry, 2013; Werner & Brand, 2001). In addition, normalizing results to accepted carbonate reference material values, as is commonly done with conventional carbon and oxygen isotope analysis in carbonates, removes the requirement to precisely quantify acid fractionation factors at different temperatures (Bernasconi et al., 2018). A carbonate standardization approach was introduced by Schmid and Bernasconi (2010) and improved by Meckler et al. (2014), with the following benefits: (1) the use of carbonates can more easily be fully automated, eliminating time‐consuming and possibly error‐prone manual preparation of CO2 standard gases (equilibrated at known temperature) by individual users on separate extraction lines; (2) in some automated systems designed for the measurement of small carbonate samples (e.g., the Kiel Device), the heated and equilibrated gases had to be measured through a different capillary than the gases produced by acid digestion of carbonates with potential biases that would go unrecognized; and (3) in these same systems the equilibrated and heated gases are measured at constant ion beam intensity in bellow mode, whereas the samples are measured with decreasing ion beams in microvolume mode. These features argue in favor of carbonate standardization a priori, but it remains critical to assess a posteriori whether the results of this approach are as robust and accurate as expected and whether they significantly improve the interlaboratory reproducibility of Δ47 measurements. Discussions at the Sixth International Clumped Isotope Workshop in Paris in 2017 led to the present interlaboratory comparison exercise (InterCarb) to evaluate the benefits and drawbacks of a carbonate‐based standardization approach as an alternative to the use of gas standards. The primary goal of this study was to test whether the exclusive use of carbonate reference materials as a substitute for heated and equilibrated gases can minimize interlaboratory discrepancies and provide an alternative to the measurement of heated and equilibrated gases for the entire community. This is particularly important because of the increasing number of laboratories using commercial small‐sample automated devices which cannot easily be standardized using the HG‐EG approach. The InterCarb exercise also provides an opportunity to define the best community‐derived consensus Δ47 values for the ETH standards of Meckler et al. (2014). Although these standards are already used in many laboratories, their current nominal Δ47 values are based on measurements from the ETH laboratory only. The InterCarb exercise can similarly establish community accepted values for other common carbonate reference materials, some of which have been in use for several years, in order to provide the community with a self‐consistent set of carbonate reference materials with a broad range of bulk and clumped isotope compositions.
What the sources say
- Supportedcites Bernasconi et al., 2018 source
The section “Calculation of Δ47 and the Effect of the 17O Correction” says that normalizing measurements to internationally accepted carbonate standards eliminates the need for precise knowledge of phosphoric acid fractionation factors at different temperatures. “Carbonate Standards for Optimized Data Correction and Linkage to the ARF” likewise says laboratories can normalize to the same accepted values regardless of digestion temperature. (LLM, conf=0.94)
plainstates a cause- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Supported
The cited sources support only part of this claim — read each source’s verdict below.
In the paper
“In addition, a reanalysis of samples from five previous calibrations by Anderson et al. (2021) using carbonate standardization revealed no significant differences in temperature dependence of Δ47 between the different sample sets.”
§ InterCarb: A Community Effort to Improve Interlaboratory Standardization of the Carbonate Clumped Isotope Thermometer Using Carbonate Standards > Introduction Carbonate clumped isotope (Δ47) thermometry is the most developed branch of the rapidly evolving field of clumped isotope geochemistry. Given the broad range of applications in Earth Sciences (e.g., Affek & Eiler, 2006; Dale et al., 2014; Eagle et al., 2010; Ferry et al., 2011; Ghosh, Adkins, et al., 2006; Ghosh, Garzione, & Eiler, 2006; Grauel et al., 2013; Guo & Eiler, 2007; Huntington et al., 2011; Mangenot et al., 2018; Passey & Henkes, 2012; Veillard et al., 2019) and the improvement of analytical methods including automation (Adlan et al., 2020; Bernasconi et al., 2018, 2013; Defliese & Lohmann, 2015; Dennis et al., 2011; Fiebig et al., 2019; Ghosh, Adkins, et al., 2006; He et al., 2012; Hu et al., 2014; Huntington et al., 2009; Meckler et al., 2014; Müller, Fernandez, et al., 2017; Passey et al., 2010; Petersen et al., 2016, 2019; Schmid & Bernasconi, 2010), the last 5–10 years have seen an increasing number of laboratories implementing this technique. The great potential of this thermometer can only be fully exploited if precision and accuracy are sufficient to resolve differences of a few degrees in formation temperatures. In addition, widely available reference materials that match the sample matrices are necessary so that data can be robustly compared across laboratories (Meier‐Augenstein & Schimmelmann, 2019). Currently the situation in the field of carbonate clumped isotope geochemistry is far from satisfactory. Published values for the ETH reference materials, the only carbonates that have been recently measured in many different laboratories worldwide, differ by up to 0.053‰ (see Bernasconi et al., 2018; Thaler et al., 2020 for recent comparisons). For paleoclimate applications, however, a repeatability across laboratories of 0.01‰ or better is a necessary goal for meaningful data comparison. This clearly calls for better standardization procedures to improve laboratory comparability. The data normalization scheme currently used in clumped isotope geochemistry of carbonates in many laboratories is based on the comparison of the composition of the CO2 liberated from carbonates by reaction with phosphoric acid with that of a set of CO2 gases with different bulk and clumped isotope compositions (Dennis et al., 2011). These gases are prepared either by heating CO2 at 1000 °C (heated gases; HG) or by CO2 equilibration with water at low temperatures (equilibrated gases at e.g., 25 °C, 50 °C; EG). By comparing the measured compositions with the theoretical predictions of the equilibrium thermodynamic abundance of multiply substituted isotopologues in heated and equilibrated gases (Wang et al., 2004; and updates in Petersen et al., 2019), the measurements are standardized to the scale that was named the “absolute reference frame” (ARF) by Dennis et al. (2011). In more recent publications, the ARF is often referred to as the “Carbon Dioxide Equilibration Scale” (CDES), a terminology introduced by Passey and Henkes (2012). This approach was designed to allow different laboratories to link their measurements to an internationally recognized scale firmly anchored to theory using relatively easy and established laboratory protocols to produce CO2 standard gases of known isotopic composition. Early comparisons of Δ47 CDES values for carbonates analyzed in different laboratories and corrected with HG/EG normalization were promising (Dennis et al., 2011). While Bonifacie et al. (2017) reported similar Δ47 CDES values for nine dolomite samples covering a range of almost 0.4‰ measured both at Caltech and IPGP laboratories with HG/EG normalization, Spooner et al. (2016) found that carbonate standardization improved agreement between data they obtained on samples analyzed both at Caltech and WHOI laboratories, compared to when they were using HG/EG normalization. Such recurrent cases of poor interlaboratory reproducibility (see also Bernasconi et al., 2018; Thaler et al., 2020) suggest that there are still unexplained differences in the results among laboratories (see Petersen et al., 2019 for a recent review). Apart from preservation problems, two known issues still limiting the reliability of this method to yield accurate temperature reconstructions are: (1) the lack of internationally recognized carbonate reference materials for a precise interlaboratory calibration, and (2) that published Δ47‐temperature calibrations produced in different laboratories have differed in both temperature dependence (slope) and absolute value (intercept). Possible reasons for the differences in slopes and intercepts of the Δ47 temperature dependence have been widely discussed in the literature (e.g., Bonifacie et al., 2017; Daëron et al., 2016; Fernandez et al., 2017; Katz et al., 2017; Kelson et al., 2017; Kluge et al., 2015; Petersen et al., 2019; Schauer et al., 2016). Discrepancies have been attributed to analytical artifacts such as CO2‐acid re‐equilibration at different acid digestion temperatures (see Swart et al., 2019; Wacker et al., 2013, for a recent discussion) and to slight pressure imbalances between sample and reference gas (Fiebig et al., 2016). Other factors proposed to influence the calculated slopes of the calibrations are the limitations of the data sets used in the individual studies, in particular in terms of the number of samples and replicates and of the temperature range covered by the available samples (Bonifacie et al., 2017; Fernandez et al., 2017). However, the discrepancies in the intercepts of the calibrations, for example, between Kelson et al. (2017) and Peral et al. (2018), and a generally poor laboratory comparability remain problems that could be mitigated by using a more robust standardization method. Petersen et al. (2019), in a recent effort to resolve differences in calibrations, compiled raw data of a number of published temperature calibrations and recalculated them all in a consistent way using the revised IUPAC correction parameters to correct for the 17O abundance (Daëron et al., 2016; Schauer et al., 2016). The goal was to test whether data processing differences and/or the use of consistent but incorrect 17O‐correction parameters in the calculations were the root causes of inconsistencies. The result of this study was that differences among calibrations were reduced but not eliminated by the recalculation, implying that other factors must be responsible for the remaining discrepancies. These differences have pushed many laboratories to use laboratory‐specific calibrations performed with the same analytical approach, as they at least partially take into consideration possible procedural differences (Petersen et al., 2019). However, if a laboratory changes analytical procedures or has not generated a robust in‐house calibration, this approach is problematic. Achieving an interlaboratory reproducibility at the level of accuracy necessary for meaningful interpretations of the observed variations is a requirement for Δ47 thermometry to reach its potential as a mature analytical method with broad acceptance and quantitative usefulness. While the definition of the CDES was a major milestone (Dennis et al., 2011), a known problem with this approach is that while the CO2 standard gases equilibrated at known temperature (HG or EG) can be confidently used for correction of mass spectrometric fractionations/nonlinearities and for effects of the purification procedures, they cannot account for the effects of the phosphoric acid reaction on the composition of the produced CO2. Among the factors responsible for discrepant calibrations and laboratory comparability, two important ones cannot be tested with a gas‐based standardization: (1) the absolute value and temperature dependence of the phosphoric acid fractionation factor (see Petersen et al., 2019 for a recent compilation) and (2) possible CO2 equilibration effects during acid digestion of the sample. Swart et al. (2019) presented evidence that equilibration of CO2 with water or hot metal surfaces during phosphoric acid reaction and transfer of the CO2 to the mass spectrometer could be a factor leading to the alteration of the apparent temperature dependence of clumped isotopes in carbonates and on the absolute value of calculated Δ47. As many laboratories use custom built extraction lines with different designs and volumes of tubing and of acid vessels, these factors are impossible to precisely quantify for each laboratory and may further contribute to interlaboratory discrepancies. We propose that these issues can be circumvented if carbonates, which undergo the same acid digestion as the samples, are used for normalization instead of or in addition to gases, consistent with the principle of identical treatment of sample and standards (Carter & Fry, 2013; Werner & Brand, 2001). In addition, normalizing results to accepted carbonate reference material values, as is commonly done with conventional carbon and oxygen isotope analysis in carbonates, removes the requirement to precisely quantify acid fractionation factors at different temperatures (Bernasconi et al., 2018). A carbonate standardization approach was introduced by Schmid and Bernasconi (2010) and improved by Meckler et al. (2014), with the following benefits: (1) the use of carbonates can more easily be fully automated, eliminating time‐consuming and possibly error‐prone manual preparation of CO2 standard gases (equilibrated at known temperature) by individual users on separate extraction lines; (2) in some automated systems designed for the measurement of small carbonate samples (e.g., the Kiel Device), the heated and equilibrated gases had to be measured through a different capillary than the gases produced by acid digestion of carbonates with potential biases that would go unrecognized; and (3) in these same systems the equilibrated and heated gases are measured at constant ion beam intensity in bellow mode, whereas the samples are measured with decreasing ion beams in microvolume mode. These features argue in favor of carbonate standardization a priori, but it remains critical to assess a posteriori whether the results of this approach are as robust and accurate as expected and whether they significantly improve the interlaboratory reproducibility of Δ47 measurements. Discussions at the Sixth International Clumped Isotope Workshop in Paris in 2017 led to the present interlaboratory comparison exercise (InterCarb) to evaluate the benefits and drawbacks of a carbonate‐based standardization approach as an alternative to the use of gas standards. The primary goal of this study was to test whether the exclusive use of carbonate reference materials as a substitute for heated and equilibrated gases can minimize interlaboratory discrepancies and provide an alternative to the measurement of heated and equilibrated gases for the entire community. This is particularly important because of the increasing number of laboratories using commercial small‐sample automated devices which cannot easily be standardized using the HG‐EG approach. The InterCarb exercise also provides an opportunity to define the best community‐derived consensus Δ47 values for the ETH standards of Meckler et al. (2014). Although these standards are already used in many laboratories, their current nominal Δ47 values are based on measurements from the ETH laboratory only. The InterCarb exercise can similarly establish community accepted values for other common carbonate reference materials, some of which have been in use for several years, in order to provide the community with a self‐consistent set of carbonate reference materials with a broad range of bulk and clumped isotope compositions. > Nomenclature and Data Processing
What the sources say
- Partly supportedcites Anderson et al. (2021) sourceExperimental — accuracy not yet measured
Split into 2 atoms — 0 confirmed, 2 partially supported, 0 disputed, 0 misattributed, 0 unverifiable. Expand the claim to see per-atom verdicts.
plain- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Partly supported
The cited sources support only part of this claim — read each source’s verdict below.
In the paper
“These studies yielded statistically indistinguishable slopes and intercepts despite the use of independent sample sets and in the case of Peral et al. (2018), a different analytical system.”
§ InterCarb: A Community Effort to Improve Interlaboratory Standardization of the Carbonate Clumped Isotope Thermometer Using Carbonate Standards > Introduction Carbonate clumped isotope (Δ47) thermometry is the most developed branch of the rapidly evolving field of clumped isotope geochemistry. Given the broad range of applications in Earth Sciences (e.g., Affek & Eiler, 2006; Dale et al., 2014; Eagle et al., 2010; Ferry et al., 2011; Ghosh, Adkins, et al., 2006; Ghosh, Garzione, & Eiler, 2006; Grauel et al., 2013; Guo & Eiler, 2007; Huntington et al., 2011; Mangenot et al., 2018; Passey & Henkes, 2012; Veillard et al., 2019) and the improvement of analytical methods including automation (Adlan et al., 2020; Bernasconi et al., 2018, 2013; Defliese & Lohmann, 2015; Dennis et al., 2011; Fiebig et al., 2019; Ghosh, Adkins, et al., 2006; He et al., 2012; Hu et al., 2014; Huntington et al., 2009; Meckler et al., 2014; Müller, Fernandez, et al., 2017; Passey et al., 2010; Petersen et al., 2016, 2019; Schmid & Bernasconi, 2010), the last 5–10 years have seen an increasing number of laboratories implementing this technique. The great potential of this thermometer can only be fully exploited if precision and accuracy are sufficient to resolve differences of a few degrees in formation temperatures. In addition, widely available reference materials that match the sample matrices are necessary so that data can be robustly compared across laboratories (Meier‐Augenstein & Schimmelmann, 2019). Currently the situation in the field of carbonate clumped isotope geochemistry is far from satisfactory. Published values for the ETH reference materials, the only carbonates that have been recently measured in many different laboratories worldwide, differ by up to 0.053‰ (see Bernasconi et al., 2018; Thaler et al., 2020 for recent comparisons). For paleoclimate applications, however, a repeatability across laboratories of 0.01‰ or better is a necessary goal for meaningful data comparison. This clearly calls for better standardization procedures to improve laboratory comparability. The data normalization scheme currently used in clumped isotope geochemistry of carbonates in many laboratories is based on the comparison of the composition of the CO2 liberated from carbonates by reaction with phosphoric acid with that of a set of CO2 gases with different bulk and clumped isotope compositions (Dennis et al., 2011). These gases are prepared either by heating CO2 at 1000 °C (heated gases; HG) or by CO2 equilibration with water at low temperatures (equilibrated gases at e.g., 25 °C, 50 °C; EG). By comparing the measured compositions with the theoretical predictions of the equilibrium thermodynamic abundance of multiply substituted isotopologues in heated and equilibrated gases (Wang et al., 2004; and updates in Petersen et al., 2019), the measurements are standardized to the scale that was named the “absolute reference frame” (ARF) by Dennis et al. (2011). In more recent publications, the ARF is often referred to as the “Carbon Dioxide Equilibration Scale” (CDES), a terminology introduced by Passey and Henkes (2012). This approach was designed to allow different laboratories to link their measurements to an internationally recognized scale firmly anchored to theory using relatively easy and established laboratory protocols to produce CO2 standard gases of known isotopic composition. Early comparisons of Δ47 CDES values for carbonates analyzed in different laboratories and corrected with HG/EG normalization were promising (Dennis et al., 2011). While Bonifacie et al. (2017) reported similar Δ47 CDES values for nine dolomite samples covering a range of almost 0.4‰ measured both at Caltech and IPGP laboratories with HG/EG normalization, Spooner et al. (2016) found that carbonate standardization improved agreement between data they obtained on samples analyzed both at Caltech and WHOI laboratories, compared to when they were using HG/EG normalization. Such recurrent cases of poor interlaboratory reproducibility (see also Bernasconi et al., 2018; Thaler et al., 2020) suggest that there are still unexplained differences in the results among laboratories (see Petersen et al., 2019 for a recent review). Apart from preservation problems, two known issues still limiting the reliability of this method to yield accurate temperature reconstructions are: (1) the lack of internationally recognized carbonate reference materials for a precise interlaboratory calibration, and (2) that published Δ47‐temperature calibrations produced in different laboratories have differed in both temperature dependence (slope) and absolute value (intercept). Possible reasons for the differences in slopes and intercepts of the Δ47 temperature dependence have been widely discussed in the literature (e.g., Bonifacie et al., 2017; Daëron et al., 2016; Fernandez et al., 2017; Katz et al., 2017; Kelson et al., 2017; Kluge et al., 2015; Petersen et al., 2019; Schauer et al., 2016). Discrepancies have been attributed to analytical artifacts such as CO2‐acid re‐equilibration at different acid digestion temperatures (see Swart et al., 2019; Wacker et al., 2013, for a recent discussion) and to slight pressure imbalances between sample and reference gas (Fiebig et al., 2016). Other factors proposed to influence the calculated slopes of the calibrations are the limitations of the data sets used in the individual studies, in particular in terms of the number of samples and replicates and of the temperature range covered by the available samples (Bonifacie et al., 2017; Fernandez et al., 2017). However, the discrepancies in the intercepts of the calibrations, for example, between Kelson et al. (2017) and Peral et al. (2018), and a generally poor laboratory comparability remain problems that could be mitigated by using a more robust standardization method. Petersen et al. (2019), in a recent effort to resolve differences in calibrations, compiled raw data of a number of published temperature calibrations and recalculated them all in a consistent way using the revised IUPAC correction parameters to correct for the 17O abundance (Daëron et al., 2016; Schauer et al., 2016). The goal was to test whether data processing differences and/or the use of consistent but incorrect 17O‐correction parameters in the calculations were the root causes of inconsistencies. The result of this study was that differences among calibrations were reduced but not eliminated by the recalculation, implying that other factors must be responsible for the remaining discrepancies. These differences have pushed many laboratories to use laboratory‐specific calibrations performed with the same analytical approach, as they at least partially take into consideration possible procedural differences (Petersen et al., 2019). However, if a laboratory changes analytical procedures or has not generated a robust in‐house calibration, this approach is problematic. Achieving an interlaboratory reproducibility at the level of accuracy necessary for meaningful interpretations of the observed variations is a requirement for Δ47 thermometry to reach its potential as a mature analytical method with broad acceptance and quantitative usefulness. While the definition of the CDES was a major milestone (Dennis et al., 2011), a known problem with this approach is that while the CO2 standard gases equilibrated at known temperature (HG or EG) can be confidently used for correction of mass spectrometric fractionations/nonlinearities and for effects of the purification procedures, they cannot account for the effects of the phosphoric acid reaction on the composition of the produced CO2. Among the factors responsible for discrepant calibrations and laboratory comparability, two important ones cannot be tested with a gas‐based standardization: (1) the absolute value and temperature dependence of the phosphoric acid fractionation factor (see Petersen et al., 2019 for a recent compilation) and (2) possible CO2 equilibration effects during acid digestion of the sample. Swart et al. (2019) presented evidence that equilibration of CO2 with water or hot metal surfaces during phosphoric acid reaction and transfer of the CO2 to the mass spectrometer could be a factor leading to the alteration of the apparent temperature dependence of clumped isotopes in carbonates and on the absolute value of calculated Δ47. As many laboratories use custom built extraction lines with different designs and volumes of tubing and of acid vessels, these factors are impossible to precisely quantify for each laboratory and may further contribute to interlaboratory discrepancies. We propose that these issues can be circumvented if carbonates, which undergo the same acid digestion as the samples, are used for normalization instead of or in addition to gases, consistent with the principle of identical treatment of sample and standards (Carter & Fry, 2013; Werner & Brand, 2001). In addition, normalizing results to accepted carbonate reference material values, as is commonly done with conventional carbon and oxygen isotope analysis in carbonates, removes the requirement to precisely quantify acid fractionation factors at different temperatures (Bernasconi et al., 2018). A carbonate standardization approach was introduced by Schmid and Bernasconi (2010) and improved by Meckler et al. (2014), with the following benefits: (1) the use of carbonates can more easily be fully automated, eliminating time‐consuming and possibly error‐prone manual preparation of CO2 standard gases (equilibrated at known temperature) by individual users on separate extraction lines; (2) in some automated systems designed for the measurement of small carbonate samples (e.g., the Kiel Device), the heated and equilibrated gases had to be measured through a different capillary than the gases produced by acid digestion of carbonates with potential biases that would go unrecognized; and (3) in these same systems the equilibrated and heated gases are measured at constant ion beam intensity in bellow mode, whereas the samples are measured with decreasing ion beams in microvolume mode. These features argue in favor of carbonate standardization a priori, but it remains critical to assess a posteriori whether the results of this approach are as robust and accurate as expected and whether they significantly improve the interlaboratory reproducibility of Δ47 measurements. Discussions at the Sixth International Clumped Isotope Workshop in Paris in 2017 led to the present interlaboratory comparison exercise (InterCarb) to evaluate the benefits and drawbacks of a carbonate‐based standardization approach as an alternative to the use of gas standards. The primary goal of this study was to test whether the exclusive use of carbonate reference materials as a substitute for heated and equilibrated gases can minimize interlaboratory discrepancies and provide an alternative to the measurement of heated and equilibrated gases for the entire community. This is particularly important because of the increasing number of laboratories using commercial small‐sample automated devices which cannot easily be standardized using the HG‐EG approach. The InterCarb exercise also provides an opportunity to define the best community‐derived consensus Δ47 values for the ETH standards of Meckler et al. (2014). Although these standards are already used in many laboratories, their current nominal Δ47 values are based on measurements from the ETH laboratory only. The InterCarb exercise can similarly establish community accepted values for other common carbonate reference materials, some of which have been in use for several years, in order to provide the community with a self‐consistent set of carbonate reference materials with a broad range of bulk and clumped isotope compositions. > Nomenclature and Data Processing
What the sources say
- Not checked — no full text of the sourcecites Meinicke et al. (2020) source
- Partly supportedcites Peral et al. (2018) sourceExperimental — accuracy not yet measured
Section 4.6 says three carbonate-standardized calibrations have virtually identical slopes, and the Conclusion calls this dataset indistinguishable from the reprocessed Kele et al. calibration. But Section 4.6 also says the cave-pearl calibration predicts slightly lower Δ47 values; it does not establish that all three intercepts are statistically indistinguishable. Section 2.3.1 identifies Peral et al.’s instrument, but does not establish the claimed difference from the other studies’ analytical systems. (LLM, conf=0.85)
- Partly supportedcites Piasecki et al. (2019) sourceExperimental — accuracy not yet measured
The Results (§4) and Species-Specific Considerations (§5.1; page unavailable) say this study’s calibration falls within error of the Bonifacie and recalculated Kele calibrations; Table 3 also lists their slopes and intercepts. The copy does not establish that Peral et al. (2018) was among the studies compared or used a different analytical system, nor does it explicitly assess the statistical indistinguishability of all the cited slopes and intercepts. (LLM, conf=0.85)
plain- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
The cited sources support only part of this claim — read each source’s verdict below.
In the paper
“Published values for the ETH reference materials, the only carbonates that have been recently measured in many different laboratories worldwide, differ by up to 0.053‰ (see Bernasconi et al., 2018; Thaler et al., 2020 for recent comparisons).”
§ InterCarb: A Community Effort to Improve Interlaboratory Standardization of the Carbonate Clumped Isotope Thermometer Using Carbonate Standards > Introduction Carbonate clumped isotope (Δ47) thermometry is the most developed branch of the rapidly evolving field of clumped isotope geochemistry. Given the broad range of applications in Earth Sciences (e.g., Affek & Eiler, 2006; Dale et al., 2014; Eagle et al., 2010; Ferry et al., 2011; Ghosh, Adkins, et al., 2006; Ghosh, Garzione, & Eiler, 2006; Grauel et al., 2013; Guo & Eiler, 2007; Huntington et al., 2011; Mangenot et al., 2018; Passey & Henkes, 2012; Veillard et al., 2019) and the improvement of analytical methods including automation (Adlan et al., 2020; Bernasconi et al., 2018, 2013; Defliese & Lohmann, 2015; Dennis et al., 2011; Fiebig et al., 2019; Ghosh, Adkins, et al., 2006; He et al., 2012; Hu et al., 2014; Huntington et al., 2009; Meckler et al., 2014; Müller, Fernandez, et al., 2017; Passey et al., 2010; Petersen et al., 2016, 2019; Schmid & Bernasconi, 2010), the last 5–10 years have seen an increasing number of laboratories implementing this technique. The great potential of this thermometer can only be fully exploited if precision and accuracy are sufficient to resolve differences of a few degrees in formation temperatures. In addition, widely available reference materials that match the sample matrices are necessary so that data can be robustly compared across laboratories (Meier‐Augenstein & Schimmelmann, 2019). Currently the situation in the field of carbonate clumped isotope geochemistry is far from satisfactory. Published values for the ETH reference materials, the only carbonates that have been recently measured in many different laboratories worldwide, differ by up to 0.053‰ (see Bernasconi et al., 2018; Thaler et al., 2020 for recent comparisons). For paleoclimate applications, however, a repeatability across laboratories of 0.01‰ or better is a necessary goal for meaningful data comparison. This clearly calls for better standardization procedures to improve laboratory comparability. The data normalization scheme currently used in clumped isotope geochemistry of carbonates in many laboratories is based on the comparison of the composition of the CO2 liberated from carbonates by reaction with phosphoric acid with that of a set of CO2 gases with different bulk and clumped isotope compositions (Dennis et al., 2011). These gases are prepared either by heating CO2 at 1000 °C (heated gases; HG) or by CO2 equilibration with water at low temperatures (equilibrated gases at e.g., 25 °C, 50 °C; EG). By comparing the measured compositions with the theoretical predictions of the equilibrium thermodynamic abundance of multiply substituted isotopologues in heated and equilibrated gases (Wang et al., 2004; and updates in Petersen et al., 2019), the measurements are standardized to the scale that was named the “absolute reference frame” (ARF) by Dennis et al. (2011). In more recent publications, the ARF is often referred to as the “Carbon Dioxide Equilibration Scale” (CDES), a terminology introduced by Passey and Henkes (2012). This approach was designed to allow different laboratories to link their measurements to an internationally recognized scale firmly anchored to theory using relatively easy and established laboratory protocols to produce CO2 standard gases of known isotopic composition. Early comparisons of Δ47 CDES values for carbonates analyzed in different laboratories and corrected with HG/EG normalization were promising (Dennis et al., 2011). While Bonifacie et al. (2017) reported similar Δ47 CDES values for nine dolomite samples covering a range of almost 0.4‰ measured both at Caltech and IPGP laboratories with HG/EG normalization, Spooner et al. (2016) found that carbonate standardization improved agreement between data they obtained on samples analyzed both at Caltech and WHOI laboratories, compared to when they were using HG/EG normalization. Such recurrent cases of poor interlaboratory reproducibility (see also Bernasconi et al., 2018; Thaler et al., 2020) suggest that there are still unexplained differences in the results among laboratories (see Petersen et al., 2019 for a recent review). Apart from preservation problems, two known issues still limiting the reliability of this method to yield accurate temperature reconstructions are: (1) the lack of internationally recognized carbonate reference materials for a precise interlaboratory calibration, and (2) that published Δ47‐temperature calibrations produced in different laboratories have differed in both temperature dependence (slope) and absolute value (intercept). Possible reasons for the differences in slopes and intercepts of the Δ47 temperature dependence have been widely discussed in the literature (e.g., Bonifacie et al., 2017; Daëron et al., 2016; Fernandez et al., 2017; Katz et al., 2017; Kelson et al., 2017; Kluge et al., 2015; Petersen et al., 2019; Schauer et al., 2016). Discrepancies have been attributed to analytical artifacts such as CO2‐acid re‐equilibration at different acid digestion temperatures (see Swart et al., 2019; Wacker et al., 2013, for a recent discussion) and to slight pressure imbalances between sample and reference gas (Fiebig et al., 2016). Other factors proposed to influence the calculated slopes of the calibrations are the limitations of the data sets used in the individual studies, in particular in terms of the number of samples and replicates and of the temperature range covered by the available samples (Bonifacie et al., 2017; Fernandez et al., 2017). However, the discrepancies in the intercepts of the calibrations, for example, between Kelson et al. (2017) and Peral et al. (2018), and a generally poor laboratory comparability remain problems that could be mitigated by using a more robust standardization method. Petersen et al. (2019), in a recent effort to resolve differences in calibrations, compiled raw data of a number of published temperature calibrations and recalculated them all in a consistent way using the revised IUPAC correction parameters to correct for the 17O abundance (Daëron et al., 2016; Schauer et al., 2016). The goal was to test whether data processing differences and/or the use of consistent but incorrect 17O‐correction parameters in the calculations were the root causes of inconsistencies. The result of this study was that differences among calibrations were reduced but not eliminated by the recalculation, implying that other factors must be responsible for the remaining discrepancies. These differences have pushed many laboratories to use laboratory‐specific calibrations performed with the same analytical approach, as they at least partially take into consideration possible procedural differences (Petersen et al., 2019). However, if a laboratory changes analytical procedures or has not generated a robust in‐house calibration, this approach is problematic. Achieving an interlaboratory reproducibility at the level of accuracy necessary for meaningful interpretations of the observed variations is a requirement for Δ47 thermometry to reach its potential as a mature analytical method with broad acceptance and quantitative usefulness. While the definition of the CDES was a major milestone (Dennis et al., 2011), a known problem with this approach is that while the CO2 standard gases equilibrated at known temperature (HG or EG) can be confidently used for correction of mass spectrometric fractionations/nonlinearities and for effects of the purification procedures, they cannot account for the effects of the phosphoric acid reaction on the composition of the produced CO2. Among the factors responsible for discrepant calibrations and laboratory comparability, two important ones cannot be tested with a gas‐based standardization: (1) the absolute value and temperature dependence of the phosphoric acid fractionation factor (see Petersen et al., 2019 for a recent compilation) and (2) possible CO2 equilibration effects during acid digestion of the sample. Swart et al. (2019) presented evidence that equilibration of CO2 with water or hot metal surfaces during phosphoric acid reaction and transfer of the CO2 to the mass spectrometer could be a factor leading to the alteration of the apparent temperature dependence of clumped isotopes in carbonates and on the absolute value of calculated Δ47. As many laboratories use custom built extraction lines with different designs and volumes of tubing and of acid vessels, these factors are impossible to precisely quantify for each laboratory and may further contribute to interlaboratory discrepancies. We propose that these issues can be circumvented if carbonates, which undergo the same acid digestion as the samples, are used for normalization instead of or in addition to gases, consistent with the principle of identical treatment of sample and standards (Carter & Fry, 2013; Werner & Brand, 2001). In addition, normalizing results to accepted carbonate reference material values, as is commonly done with conventional carbon and oxygen isotope analysis in carbonates, removes the requirement to precisely quantify acid fractionation factors at different temperatures (Bernasconi et al., 2018). A carbonate standardization approach was introduced by Schmid and Bernasconi (2010) and improved by Meckler et al. (2014), with the following benefits: (1) the use of carbonates can more easily be fully automated, eliminating time‐consuming and possibly error‐prone manual preparation of CO2 standard gases (equilibrated at known temperature) by individual users on separate extraction lines; (2) in some automated systems designed for the measurement of small carbonate samples (e.g., the Kiel Device), the heated and equilibrated gases had to be measured through a different capillary than the gases produced by acid digestion of carbonates with potential biases that would go unrecognized; and (3) in these same systems the equilibrated and heated gases are measured at constant ion beam intensity in bellow mode, whereas the samples are measured with decreasing ion beams in microvolume mode. These features argue in favor of carbonate standardization a priori, but it remains critical to assess a posteriori whether the results of this approach are as robust and accurate as expected and whether they significantly improve the interlaboratory reproducibility of Δ47 measurements. Discussions at the Sixth International Clumped Isotope Workshop in Paris in 2017 led to the present interlaboratory comparison exercise (InterCarb) to evaluate the benefits and drawbacks of a carbonate‐based standardization approach as an alternative to the use of gas standards. The primary goal of this study was to test whether the exclusive use of carbonate reference materials as a substitute for heated and equilibrated gases can minimize interlaboratory discrepancies and provide an alternative to the measurement of heated and equilibrated gases for the entire community. This is particularly important because of the increasing number of laboratories using commercial small‐sample automated devices which cannot easily be standardized using the HG‐EG approach. The InterCarb exercise also provides an opportunity to define the best community‐derived consensus Δ47 values for the ETH standards of Meckler et al. (2014). Although these standards are already used in many laboratories, their current nominal Δ47 values are based on measurements from the ETH laboratory only. The InterCarb exercise can similarly establish community accepted values for other common carbonate reference materials, some of which have been in use for several years, in order to provide the community with a self‐consistent set of carbonate reference materials with a broad range of bulk and clumped isotope compositions.
What the sources say
- Supportedcites Bernasconi et al., 2018 source
Table 3 (section “Does Use of the Brand Parameters Solve All Interlaboratory Inconsistencies?”; page unavailable) lists published ETH-1 values of 0.258‰ and 0.311‰ from different laboratories. Their difference is 0.053‰, matching the claimed maximum. (LLM, conf=0.94)
- Partly supportedcites Thaler et al., 2020 sourceExperimental — accuracy not yet measured
Section 2.3 compares ETH reference-material values from this study with Bernasconi et al. (2018) and other published values, reporting systematic offsets. It does not give an offset of 0.053‰ or establish that ETH materials are the only carbonates recently measured in many laboratories. Page numbers are unavailable in our copy. (LLM, conf=0.86)
plain- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Supported
The sources with a verdict support this claim; the rest weren’t checked yet, have no full text we could read, or their verdicts aren’t rated yet.
In the paper
“The number of necessary replicates to reach a target temperature uncertainty can be reduced by improving the external reproducibility of the measurements (see also Bonifacie et al., 2017; Daëron, 2021; Fernandez et al., 2017; Kocken et al., 2019).”
§ InterCarb: A Community Effort to Improve Interlaboratory Standardization of the Carbonate Clumped Isotope Thermometer Using Carbonate Standards > Results and Discussion > Guidelines for Minimizing Uncertainties in Clumped Isotope Analyses
What the sources say
- Not checked — no full text of the sourcecites Bonifacie et al., 2017 source
- Not matchedcites Daëron, 2021
Couldn’t be matched to a paper in Crossref, so it can’t be checked.
- Supportedcites Fernandez et al., 2017 source
Section 3.1 (page unavailable) compares measurement precision across different external reproducibilities and numbers of replicates. It reports smaller 95% margins of error with better reproducibility at the same replicate count, supporting the inference that fewer replicates are needed to reach a given temperature uncertainty. (LLM, conf=0.90)
plainstates a cause- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
55 more claims · 3 with their cited sources checked
Create a free account to see all 105 claims and to verify the 1 reference still open.
- It may state two separate claims as one. 36
- Probably not a substantial claim. 13
Claims other papers make about this one
Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?
The source backs part of the claim, not all of it — or backs it for a different population, condition or comparison.
In the citing paper
“Clumped isotope data are increasingly normalized to carbonate reference materials for which community-accepted 47 values are defined and ultimately referenced back to the gas-based CDES reference frame”
From Frontiers of Carbonate Clumped Isotope Thermometry (2023) · cites this paper as Bernasconi et al. 2021
Experimental — accuracy not yet measuredThe source backs part of the claim, not all of it — or backs it for a different population, condition or comparison.
In the citing paper
“This carbonate-based reference frame [Intercarb-carbon dioxide equilibrium scale (I-CDES)] is more similar to bulk isotope correction schemes and should be mathematically identical to and interchangeable with CDES, although small differences remain (Bernasconi et al. 2021).”
From Frontiers of Carbonate Clumped Isotope Thermometry (2023) · cites this paper as Bernasconi et al. 2021
Experimental — accuracy not yet measuredThe source backs part of the claim, not all of it — or backs it for a different population, condition or comparison.
In the citing paper
“the ∆ 47 values projected in the inter-laboratory absolute reference frame or Intercarb Carbon Dioxide Equilibrated Scale (I-CDES) [81] based on our routinely measured ETH1, ETH2, ETH3, ETH4, and our internal Carrara marble (ICM) carbonate standards [81,82].”
From Clumped Isotope Reordering and Kinetic Differences in Co-Hosted Calcite and Dolomite Minerals throughout Burial Diagenesis and Exhumation (2023) · cites this paper as [81]
Experimental — accuracy not yet measuredThe source backs part of the claim, not all of it — or backs it for a different population, condition or comparison.
In the citing paper
“Finally, the value of Merck itself is poorly constrained with respect to the other InterCarb anchors (Bernasconi etal.,2021), with an uncertainty roughly double IAEA-C1's uncertainty, and with some labs reporting mean values ∼50ppm from the community consensus value from the InterCarb exercise (cf. max ∼25ppm offset for IAEA-C1).”
From Re-Assessing the Need for Apatite- and Dolomite-Specific Calibrations of the Carbonate Clumped Isotope Thermometer (2024) · cites this paper as Bernasconi et al., 2021
Experimental — accuracy not yet measuredThe cited source says what the claim attributes to it.
In the citing paper
“Isotope data were processed using the free software Easotope (John and Bowen, 2016) and the I-CDES carbonate standards (Bernasconi et al., 2021).”
From Reconstructing the temperature and origin of CO2 mineralisation in CarbFix calcite using clumped, carbon and oxygen isotopes (2024) · cites this paper as Bernasconi et al., 2021
Citations
Cites
The Kolmogorov-Smirnov Test for Goodness of Fit
Massey, F. J. (1951) · Journal of the American Statistical Association · doi:10.1080/01621459.1951.10500769 · Cited by 7,210
The Kolmogorov-Smirnov Test for Goodness of Fit
Massey, F. J. (1951) · Journal of the American Statistical Association · doi:10.2307/2280095 · Cited by 3,690
Coplen, T. B. (2011) · Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometry · doi:10.1002/rcm.5129 · Cited by 1,831
Referencing strategies and techniques in stable isotope ratio analysis
Werner, R. A., & Brand, W. A. (2001) · Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometry · doi:10.1002/rcm.258 · Cited by 1,033 · cited 3×
“We propose that these issues can be circumvented if carbonates, which undergo the same acid digestion as the samples, are used for normalization instead of or in addition to gases, consistent with the principle of identical treatment of sample and standards (Carter & Fry, 2013; Werner & Brand, 2001).”
Method13C–18O bonds in carbonate minerals: a new kind of paleothermometer
Ghosh, P., Adkins, J., Affek, H., Balta, B., Guo, W., Schauble, E. A., Schrag, D., & Eiler, J. M. (2006) · Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta · doi:10.1016/j.gca.2005.11.014 · Cited by 914
Self-citationDefining an absolute reference frame for ‘clumped’ isotope studies of CO2
Dennis, K. J., Affek, H. P., Passey, B. H., Schrag, D. P., & Eiler, J. M. (2011) · Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta · doi:10.1016/j.gca.2011.09.025 · Cited by 627
Self-citationPassey, B. H., Levin, N. E., Cerling, T. E., Brown, F. H., & Eiler, J. M. (2010) · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences · doi:10.1073/pnas.1001824107 · Cited by 449
Self-citationHuntington, K. W., Eiler, J. M., Affek, H. P., Guo, W., Bonifacie, M., Yeung, L. Y., Thiagarajan, N., Passey, B., Tripati, A., Daëron, M., et al. (2009) · Journal of Mass Spectrometry · doi:10.1002/jms.1614 · Cited by 436 · cited 1×
“, 2019) and the improvement of analytical methods including automation (Adlan et al., 2020; Bernasconi et al., 2018, 2013; Defliese & Lohmann, 2015; Dennis et al., 2011; Fiebig et al., 2019; Ghosh, Adkins, et al., 2006; He et al., 2012; Hu et al., 2014; Huntington et al., 2009; Meckler et al., 2014; Müller, Fernandez,…”
BackgroundSelf-citationRapid Uplift of the Altiplano Revealed Through 13 C- 18 O Bonds in Paleosol Carbonates
Ghosh, P., Garzione, C. N., & Eiler, J. M. (2006) · Science · doi:10.1126/science.1119365 · Cited by 390
Self-citationBrand, W. A., Assonov, S. S., & Coplen, T. B. (2010) · Pure and Applied Chemistry · doi:10.1351/pac-rep-09-01-05 · Cited by 385
Cited by
Full Propagation of Analytical Uncertainties in Δ 47 Measurements
(2021) · doi:10.1029/2020gc009592 · Cited by 131
Self-citationCenozoic evolution of deep ocean temperature from clumped isotope thermometry
Meckler, A. N., Sexton, P. F., Piasecki, A. M., Leutert, T. J., Marquardt, J., Ziegler, M., Agterhuis, T., Lourens, L. J., Rae, J. W. B., Barnet, J., et al. (2022) · Science · doi:10.1126/science.abk0604 · Cited by 120
Self-citationCalibration of the dual clumped isotope thermometer for carbonates
Fiebig, J., Daëron, M., Bernecker, M., Guo, W., Schneider, G., Boch, R., Bernasconi, S. M., Jautzy, J., & Dietzel, M. (2021) · Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta · doi:10.1016/j.gca.2021.07.012 · Cited by 110
Self-citationOn the delimitation of the carbonate burial realm
Immenhauser, A. (2022) · The Depositional Record · doi:10.1002/dep2.173 · Cited by 95
“Moreover, carbonate clumped isotope analysis was established as highly promising (but non- trivial) approach in carbonate diagenesis research (Bernasconi et al., 2021; Millán et al., 2016; Murray & Swart, 2017; Pan et al., 2020; Ritter et al., 2015; Staudigel & Swart, 2019).”
MethodClumped isotopes in modern marine bivalves
Huyghe, D., Daëron, M., de RAFÉLIS, M., Blamart, D., Sébilo, M., Paulet, Y., & Lartaud, F. (2021) · Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta · doi:10.1016/j.gca.2021.09.019 · Cited by 73
Self-citation
Metadata
- Authors
- Bernasconi, S. M., Daëron, M., Bergmann, K. D., Bonifacie, M., Meckler, A. N., Affek, H. P., Anderson, N., Bajnai, D., Barkan, E., Beverly, E., Blamart, D., Burgener, L., Calmels, D., Chaduteau, C., Clog, M., Davidheiser‐Kroll, B., Davies, A., Dux, F., Eiler, J., Elliott, B., Fetrow, A. C., Fiebig, J., Goldberg, S., Hermoso, M., Huntington, K. W., Hyland, E., Ingalls, M., Jaggi, M., John, C. M., Jost, A. B., Katz, S., Kelson, J., Kluge, T., Kocken, I. J., Laskar, A., Leutert, T. J., Liang, D., Lucarelli, J., Mackey, T. J., Mangenot, X., Meinicke, N., Modestou, S. E., Müller, I. A., Murray, S., Neary, A., Packard, N., Passey, B. H., Pelletier, E., Petersen, S., Piasecki, A., Schauer, A., Snell, K. E., Swart, P. K., Tripati, A., Upadhyay, D., Vennemann, T., Winkelstern, I., Yarian, D., Yoshida, N., Zhang, N., & Ziegler, M.
- Affiliations
- ETH Zurich (CH)
- Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (FR)
- Massachusetts Institute of Technology (US)
- Bjerknes Centre for Climate Research (NO)
- Hebrew University of Jerusalem (IL)
- Goethe University Frankfurt (DE)
- University of Michigan (US)
- North Carolina State University (US)
- Scottish Universities Environmental Research Centre (GB)
- University of Colorado Boulder (US)
- Stockholm University (SE)
- The University of Melbourne (AU)
- California Institute of Technology (US)
- University of California, Los Angeles (US)
- University of Washington (US)
- Imperial College London (GB)
- Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (DE)
- Utrecht University (NL)
- Institute of Earth Sciences, Academia Sinica (TW)
- Institute of Earth Sciences Academia Sinica Taipei Taiwan
- University of New Mexico (US)
- Macquarie University (AU)
- Dartmouth College (US)
- University of Miami (US)
- University of Lausanne (CH)
- Tokyo Institute of Technology (JP)
- Corresponding author
- Bernasconi, S. M.
- Daëron, M.
- ORCID
- Bernasconi, S. M.
- Daëron, M.
- Bergmann, K. D.
- Bonifacie, M.
- Meckler, A. N.
- Affek, H. P.
- Anderson, N.
- Bajnai, D.
- Barkan, E.
- Beverly, E.
- Blamart, D.
- Burgener, L.
- Calmels, D.
- Clog, M.
- Davidheiser‐Kroll, B.
- Davies, A.
- Dux, F.
- Eiler, J.
- Elliott, B.
- Fetrow, A. C.
- Fiebig, J.
- Goldberg, S.
- Hermoso, M.
- Huntington, K. W.
- Hyland, E.
- Ingalls, M.
- Jaggi, M.
- John, C. M.
- Jost, A. B.
- Katz, S.
- Kelson, J.
- Kluge, T.
- Kocken, I. J.
- Laskar, A.
- Leutert, T. J.
- Lucarelli, J.
- Mackey, T. J.
- Mangenot, X.
- Meinicke, N.
- Modestou, S. E.
- Müller, I. A.
- Murray, S.
- Passey, B. H.
- Petersen, S.
- Piasecki, A.
- Schauer, A.
- Snell, K. E.
- Swart, P. K.
- Tripati, A.
- Upadhyay, D.
- Vennemann, T.
- Winkelstern, I.
- Yoshida, N.
- Zhang, N.
- Ziegler, M.
- Venue
- Geochemistry Geophysics Geosystems
- Publisher
- American Geophysical Union (AGU)
- Published
- 2021-05
- Volume
- 22
- Issue
- 5
- Pages
- e2020GC009588-e2020GC009588
- ISSN
- 1525-2027 (ISSN-L)
- PMC
- PMC8244079
- OpenAlex
- W3119951374
- Cited by
- 340
- References
- 71
- Citations by year
- 2026: 46 · 2025: 71 · 2024: 57 · 2023: 79 · 2022: 58 · 2021: 28
- FWCI
- 19.44
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- hybrid
- doi.org
- Licence
- Locations
- Geochemistry Geophysics Geosystems (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc)
- PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc)
- PubMed (publishedVersion)
- SERVAL (Université de Lausanne) (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc)
- ENLIGHTEN (Jurnal Bimbingan dan Konseling Islam) (acceptedVersion, cc-by-sa)
- HAL (submittedVersion, other-oa)
- Deep Blue (University of Michigan) (submittedVersion)
- IRIS (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc)
- Repository for Publications and Research Data (ETH Zurich) (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc)
- CaltechAUTHORS (California Institute of Technology) (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc)
- Research Online (University of Wollongong) (submittedVersion)
- NORA - Norwegian Open Research Archives (submittedVersion, other-oa)
- DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) (submittedVersion)
- Utrecht University Repository (Utrecht University) (submittedVersion, other-oa)
- eScholarship (California Digital Library) (submittedVersion)
- eScholarship (California Digital Library) (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc)
- Figshare (submittedVersion)
- LillOA (Université de Lille (University Of Lille)) (submittedVersion, other-oa)
- OSTI OAI (U.S. Department of Energy Office of Scientific and Technical Information) (submittedVersion)
- GoeScholar The Publication Server of the Georg-August-Universität Göttingen (Georg-August-Universität Göttingen) (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc)
- ETH Zürich Research Collection
- Funders
- Schweizerischer Nationalfonds zur Förderung der Wissenschaftlichen Forschung (200021_143485, 200020_160046)
- National Aeronautics and Space Administration (80NSSC19K0464)
- Division of Earth Sciences (1933130, 1713275, 1156134, 1925973, 1524785)
- Stiftung zur Förderung der Ernährungsforschung in der Schweiz (206021‐164032)
- H2020 European Research Council (638467, 724097)
- Basic Energy Sciences (DE‐FG02‐13ER16402, DE‐SC0016561)
- Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JP17H06105)
- Nederlandse Organisatie voor Wetenschappelijk Onderzoek (VIDI 016.161.365)
- Israel Science Foundation (171/16 and 1000/16)
- Topics
- Physical Sciences › Earth and Planetary Sciences › Atmospheric Science › Geology and Paleoclimatology Research
- Physical Sciences › Earth and Planetary Sciences › Paleontology › Paleontology and Stratigraphy of Fossils
- Physical Sciences › Earth and Planetary Sciences › Geochemistry and Petrology › Geological and Geochemical Analysis
- Keywords
- carbonate clumped isotope thermometry, Δ47, interlaboratory standardization, carbonate reference materials, mass spectrometry calibration, analytical uncertainty
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
The claim verdicts this report counts are experimental: their accuracy is not yet measured.
A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-10-10, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).
A second model labelled each claim on 2026-10-10 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).
Cited sources are checked with a language model’s help (gpt-6-sol).
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
How to cite
Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.
- This page
- CoChat. (2026). Citation check: InterCarb: A Community Effort to Improve Interlaboratory Standardization of the Carbonate Clumped Isotope Thermometer Using Carbonate Standards. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1029/2020gc009588
- The paper
- Bernasconi, S. M., Daëron, M., Bergmann, K. D., Bonifacie, M., Meckler, A. N., Affek, H. P., Anderson, N., Bajnai, D., Barkan, E., Beverly, E., Blamart, D., Burgener, L., Calmels, D., Chaduteau, C., Clog, M., Davidheiser‐Kroll, B., Davies, A., Dux, F., Eiler, J., . . . Ziegler, M. (2021). InterCarb: A Community Effort to Improve Interlaboratory Standardization of the Carbonate Clumped Isotope Thermometer Using Carbonate Standards. Geochemistry Geophysics Geosystems. https://doi.org/10.1029/2020gc009588
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.