Explanation, imagination, and confidence in judgment.

Abstract

This article concerns a class of experimental manipulations that require people to generate explanations or imagine scenarios. A review of studies using such manipulations indicates that people who explain or imagine a possibility then express greater confidence in the truth of that possibility. It is argued that this effect results from the approach people take in the explanation or imagination task: They temporarily assume that the hypothesis is true and assess how plausibly it can account for the relevant evidence. From this view, any task that requires that a hypothesis be treated as if it were true is sufficient to increase confidence in the truth of that hypothesis. Such tasks cause increased confidence in the hypothesis at the expense of viable alternatives because of changes in problem representation, evidence evaluation, and information search that take place when the hypothesis is temporarily treated as if it were true.

Cites (11)

1. The Framing of Decisions and the Psychology of Choice
   Tversky, Amos, Kahneman, Daniel · 1981 · Science
2. Telling more than we can know: Verbal reports on mental processes.
   Nisbett, Richard E., Wilson, Timothy D. · 1977 · Psychological Review
3. Availability: A heuristic for judging frequency and probability
   Tversky, Amos, Kahneman, Daniel · 1973 · Cognitive Psychology
4. On the psychology of prediction.
   Kahneman, Daniel, Tversky, Amos · 1973 · Psychological Review
5. Self-perception: An alternative interpretation of cognitive dissonance phenomena.
   Bem, Daryl J. · 1967 · Psychological Review
6. Confirmation, disconfirmation, and information in hypothesis testing
   Klayman, Joshua, Ha, Young-won · 1987 · Psychological Review
7. Is memory schematic
   Alba, Joseph W., Hasher, Lynn · 1983 · Psychological Bulletin
8. Perseverance in self-perception and social perception: Biased attributional processes in the debriefing paradigm.
   Ross, Lee, Lepper, Mark R., Hubbard, Michael · 1975 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
9. Fault trees: sensitivity of estimated failure probabilities to problem representation
   Fischhoff, Baruch, Slovic, Paul, Lichtenstein, Sarah · 1978 · Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance
10. The dilution effect: Nondiagnostic information weakens the implications of diagnostic information
    Nisbett, Richard E., Zukier, Henry, Lemley, Ronald E. · 1981 · Cognitive Psychology
11. Training for calibration
    Lichtenstein, Sarah, Fischhoff, Baruch · 1980 · Organizational Behavior and Human Performance

Cited by (24)

1. Confirmation Bias: A Ubiquitous Phenomenon in Many Guises
   Nickerson, Raymond S. · 1998 · Review of General Psychology
2. Feedback and Self-Regulated Learning: A Theoretical Synthesis
   Butler, Deborah L., Winne, Philip H. · 1995 · Review of Educational Research
3. The future of memory: remembering, imagining, and the brain
   Schacter, Daniel L., Addis, Donna Rose, Hassabis, Demis, Martin, Victoria C., Spreng, R. Nathan, Szpunar, Karl K. · 2012 · Neuron
4. Support theory: a nonextensional representation of subjective probability
   Tversky, Amos, Koehler, Derek J. · 1994 · Psychological Review
5. Explainable machine learning for scientific insights and discoveries
   Roscher, Ribana, Bohn, Bastian, Duarte, Marco F., Garcke, Jochen · 2020 · IEEE Access
6. Mental imagery in emotion and emotional disorders
   Holmes, Emily A., Mathews, Andrew · 2010 · Clinical Psychology Review
7. Does the Whole Exceed its Parts? The Effect of AI Explanations on Complementary Team Performance
   Bansal, Gagan, Wu, Tongshuang, Zhou, Joyce, Fok, Raymond, Nushi, Besmira, Kamar, Ece, Ribeiro, Marco Tulio, Weld, Daniel · 2021 · Proceedings of the 2021 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems
8. Imagination inflation: Imagining a childhood event inflates confidence that it occurred
   Garry, Maryanne, Manning, Charles G., Loftus, Elizabeth F., Sherman, Steven J. · 1996 · Psychonomic Bulletin & Review
9. Overcoming the Inevitable Anchoring Effect: Considering the Opposite Compensates for Selective Accessibility
   Mussweiler, Thomas, Strack, Fritz, Pfeiffer, Tim · 2000 · Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin
10. Cognitive and Interpersonal Features of Intellectual Humility
    Leary, Mark R., Diebels, Kate J., Davisson, Erin K., Jongman-Sereno, Katrina P., Isherwood, Jennifer C., Raimi, Kaitlin T., Deffler, Samantha A., Hoyle, Rick H. · 2017 · Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin
11. How People Explain Behavior: A New Theoretical Framework
    Malle, Bertram F. · 1999 · Personality and Social Psychology Review
12. Adaptive constructive processes and the future of memory
    Schacter, Daniel L. · 2012 · American Psychologist
13. Measures for explainable AI: Explanation goodness, user satisfaction, mental models, curiosity, trust, and human-AI performance
    Hoffman, Robert R., Mueller, Shane T., Klein, Gary, Litman, Jordan · 2023 · Frontiers in Computer Science
14. The challenge of crafting intelligible intelligence
    Weld, Daniel S., Bansal, Gagan · 2019 · Communications of the ACM
15. Explanation and abductive inference
    Lombrozo, Tanya · 2012 · The Oxford Handbook of Thinking and Reasoning
16. Episodic future thinking and episodic counterfactual thinking: Intersections between memory and decisions
    Schacter, Daniel L., Benoit, Roland G., De Brigard, Felipe, Szpunar, Karl K. · 2015 · Neurobiology of Learning and Memory
17. Appropriate Reliance on AI Advice: Conceptualization and the Effect of Explanations
    Schemmer, Max, Kuehl, Niklas, Benz, Carina, Bartos, Andrea, Satzger, Gerhard · 2023 · Proceedings of the 28th International Conference on Intelligent User Interfaces
18. Evaluating the Evidence For and Against the Overdiagnosis of ADHD
    Sciutto, Mark J., Eisenberg, Miriam · 2007 · Journal of Attention Disorders
19. Predicting the phenomenology of episodic future thoughts
    D’Argembeau, Arnaud, Van der Linden, Martial · 2012 · Consciousness and Cognition
20. How Cognitive Biases Affect XAI-assisted Decision-making: A Systematic Review
    Bertrand, Astrid, Belloum, Rafik, Eagan, James R., Maxwell, Winston · 2022 · Proceedings of the 2022 AAAI/ACM Conference on AI, Ethics, and Society
21. The Instrumental Value of Explanations
    Lombrozo, Tania · 2011 · Philosophy Compass
22. It Could Have Been True: How Counterfactual Thoughts Reduce Condemnation of Falsehoods and Increase Political Polarization
    Effron, Daniel A. · 2018 · Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin
23. Cognitive Forcing for Better Decision-Making: Reducing Overreliance on AI Systems Through Partial Explanations
    de Jong, Sander, Paananen, Ville, Tag, Benjamin, van Berkel, Niels · 2025 · Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction
24. Should I Follow AI-based Advice? Measuring Appropriate Reliance in Human-AI Decision-Making
    Schemmer, Max, Hemmer, Patrick, Kühl, Niklas, Benz, Carina, Satzger, Gerhard · 2022 · arXiv