Comparing comprehension following silent and aloud reading across elementary and secondary students: implication for curriculum-based measurement
Open accessThe DOI matches its Crossref record; 41 of the 41 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Abstract
In the current study, 42 secondary students (10th, 11th, and 12th grade students) and 51 elementary students (4th and 5th grade students) read 400 word passages silently and aloud. During aloud reading, words correct per minute (WCPM) were recorded. After reading each passage, students answered 10 multiple-choice comprehension questions. Results showed comprehension was significantly higher when students read passages aloud, as opposed to silently. No interaction was found between comprehension and grade level (elementary versus secondary). Discussion is focused on theories of reading comprehension and applied implications for assessing comprehension following the administration of Curriculum-Based Measurement (CBM) reading probes. Keywords: Reading comprehension, silent reading, oral reading, words correct per minute, curriculumbased measurement ********** Reading skill deficit are prevalent, common in most student refereed for special education services, and can hinder learning, skill development, and success across vocational, academic, and daily living tasks (Daly, Chafouleas, & Skinner, 2005; Lentz, 1998; National Assessment of Educational Progress, 2005; Winn, Skinner, Oliver, Hale, & Ziegler, in press). Although a variety of theories and procedures have been developed to remedy reading skill deficits, our science has not developed to the point where we can be assured that any specific intervention will remedy reading skill deficits for specific students. Thus, researchers and educators have developed various procedures and systems that allow educators to quickly assess the effects of various reading interventions on students reading skill development (i.e., progress monitoring or measuring responsiveness to intervention, see Fletcher, Coulter, Reschly, & Vaughn, 2004). Words Correct per Minute There are several common characteristics with various reading skill development progress monitoring systems. One is that they employ brief and sensitive measures that allow for frequent assessment of skill development. With respect to reading skills, one measure that is included in most systems is words read correctly per minute (WCPM). This measure which Deno and Mirkin's (1977) described in their curriculum-based measurement (CBM) system for progress and performance monitoring, is also used in the Dynamic Indicators of Basic Early Literacy Skills (DIBELS, Good & Kaminski, 2002) and AIMSweb (AIMSweb Progress Monitoring and Response to Intervention System, 2006) systems. To collect WCPM data, students are asked to read aloud, often for 1 minute, as the examiner scores errors. After students have finished reading aloud the examiner calculates both words correct per minute (WCPM) and errors per minute (Deno & Mirkin, 1977; Shapiro, 2004). WCPM is a measure of oral or aloud reading fluency or speed of accurate aloud reading. Many researchers have investigated the psychometric properties of WCPM and found that it is a valid (concurrent, construct, and criterion related validity), reliable, and sensitive measure of general reading skill development (Deno, Mirkin, & Chiang, 1982; Espin & Foegen, 1996; Fuchs & Deno 1991; Fuchs, Fuchs, and Maxwell, 1988; Hintze, Shapiro, Conte, & Basile, 1997). Although, WCPM has been shown to positively correlate with standardized norm-referenced measures of reading comprehension, (Deno et al., 1982; Fuchs & Deno, 1992; Fuchs et al., 1988; Marston, 1989; Shinn et al., 1992), because WCPM does not directly assess reading comprehension educators and research have expressed concerns about the face validity of the measure (Potter & Wamre, 1990; Skinner, Neddenriep, Bradley-Klug, & Ziemann, 2002). This limitation may be important as the primary function, goal, or purpose of reading is comprehension (2) (Rowell, 1976; Salasoo, 1986; Sindelar & Stoddard, 1991; Skinner, 1998). Thus, some may be concerned that WC/M will not detect comprehension deficits in students who can read aloud accurately and rapidly, but fail to comprehend what they are reading (Marston, 1989). …
Overview
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
Claims other papers make about this one
Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?
In the citing paper
“Second, currently much evidence-based reading instruction emphasizes oral reading (pronouncing words on lists without context clues and oral reading of passages with context clues), but beginning in fourth grade and thereafter there is a transition to increasing silent reading”
From Computer instruction in handwriting, spelling, and composing for students with specific learning disabilities in grades 4–9 (2015) · cites this paper as Hale et al., 2007
Citations
Cites
Langenberg, D. N. (2000) · Cited by 4,305
Curriculum-based measurement: Assessing special children.
Shinn, M. R. (1989) · Guilford Press eBooks · Cited by 911
The Nation's Report Card: Reading, 2002.
Grigg, W. S., Daane, M. C., Jin, Y., & Campbell, J. R. (2003) · Cited by 695
The Validity of Informal Reading Comprehension Measures
Fuchs, L. S., Fuchs, D., & Maxwell, L. (1988) · Remedial and Special Education · doi:10.1177/074193258800900206 · Cited by 475 · cited 3×
“…found that it is a valid (concurrent, construct, and criterion related validity), reliable, and sensitive measure of general reading skill development (Deno, Mirkin, & Chiang, 1982; Espin & Foegen, 1996; Fuchs & Deno 1991; Fuchs, Fuchs, and Maxwell, 1988; Hintze, Shapiro, Conte, & Basile, 1997).”
BackgroundIdentifying Valid Measures of Reading
Deno, S. L., Mirkin, P. K., & Chiang, B. (1982) · Exceptional Children · doi:10.1177/001440298204900105 · Cited by 463 · cited 2×
“Although, WCPM has been shown to positively correlate with standardized norm-referenced measures of reading comprehension, (Deno et al., 1982; Fuchs & Deno, 1992; Fuchs et al., 1988; Marston, 1989; Shinn et al., 1992), because WCPM does not directly assess reading comprehension educators and research have expressed co…”
BackgroundResultFuchs, L. S., Deno, S. L., & Mirkin, P. K. (1984) · American Educational Research Journal · doi:10.2307/1162454 · Cited by 420
Paradigmatic Distinctions between Instructionally Relevant Measurement Models
Fuchs, L. S., & Deno, S. L. (1991) · Exceptional Children · doi:10.1177/001440299105700603 · Cited by 393 · cited 1×
“…found that it is a valid (concurrent, construct, and criterion related validity), reliable, and sensitive measure of general reading skill development (Deno, Mirkin, & Chiang, 1982; Espin & Foegen, 1996; Fuchs & Deno 1991; Fuchs, Fuchs, and Maxwell, 1988; Hintze, Shapiro, Conte, & Basile, 1997).”
BackgroundShinn, M. R., Knutson, N., Good, R. H., Tilly, W. D., & Collins, V. L. (1992) · School Psychology Review · doi:10.1080/02796015.1992.12085629 · Cited by 336
Fletcher, J. M., Coulter, W. A., Reschly, D. J., & Vaughn, S. (2004) · Annals of Dyslexia · doi:10.1007/s11881-004-0015-y · Cited by 263
Identifying a Measure for Monitoring Student Reading Progress
Fuchs, L. S., & Fuchs, D. (1992) · School Psychology Review · doi:10.1080/02796015.1992.12085594 · Cited by 235
Cited by
Denton, C. A., Barth, A. E., Fletcher, J. M., Wexler, J., Vaughn, S., Cirino, P. T., Romain, M., & Francis, D. J. (2011) · Scientific Studies of Reading · doi:10.1080/10888431003623546 · Cited by 140
“On the other hand, Hale et al. (2007) reported that students in Grades 4, 5, 10, 11, and 12 were better able to answer comprehension questions following oral reading than after reading silently and that this was equally true across grade levels.”
BackgroundBerninger, V. W., Nagy, W., Tanimoto, S., Thompson, R., & Abbott, R. D. (2015) · Computers & Education · doi:10.1016/j.compedu.2014.10.005 · Cited by 110
“…passages with context clues), but beginning in fourth grade and thereafter there is a transition to increasing silent reading (Denton et al., 2011; Hale et al., 2007; Hiebert, Samuels, & Rasinski, 2012; Rasinski, Samuels, Hiebert, Petscher, & Feller, 2011) and written composing (Berninger et al.,…”
BackgroundDenton, C. A., Enos, M., York, M. J., Francis, D. J., Barnes, M. A., Kulesz, P. A., Fletcher, J. M., & Carter, S. (2015) · Reading Research Quarterly · doi:10.1002/rrq.105 · Cited by 124
Underlying skills of oral and silent reading
van den Boer, M., van Bergen, E., & de Jong, P. F. (2014) · Journal of Experimental Child Psychology · doi:10.1016/j.jecp.2014.07.008 · Cited by 91
The Effects of Oral and Silent Reading on Reading Comprehension
Schimmel, N., & Ness, M. K. (2017) · Reading Psychology · doi:10.1080/02702711.2016.1278416 · Cited by 83
Assessing reading fluency in Kenya: Oral or silent assessment?
Piper, B., & Zuilkowski, S. S. (2015) · International Review of Education · doi:10.1007/s11159-015-9470-4 · Cited by 62
“The gap between oral and silent reading performance may be larger for less skilled readers (Georgiou et al. 2013; Kim et al. 2011; Kim et al. 2012; Kragler 1995; Miller and Smith 1985, 1990), although Hale et al. (2007) did not find such a relationship.”
BackgroundResultThe Impact of Context and Word Type on Students' Maze Task Accuracy
January, S. A., & Ardoin, S. P. (2012) · School Psychology Review · doi:10.1080/02796015.2012.12087508 · Cited by 60
“CBM-R might then explain greater variance in comprehension because (a) when reading aloud examiners are able to record students’ reading errors that are unknown when they read and complete the maze silently; (b) with CBM-R, examiners record exactly where students stop reading whereas with the maze, because only every…”
BackgroundConroy, M. A., Sutherland, K. S., Haydon, T. F., Stormont, M. A., & Harmon, J. (2008) · Psychology in the Schools · doi:10.1002/pits.20350 · Cited by 63
“Researchers have used CBM to monitor the effects of instructional practices on words read correctly per minute (Deno, Fuchs, Marston, & Shin, 2001; Hale et al., 2007; Sutherland & Snyder, 2007b).”
MethodRevisiting Key Assumptions of the Reading Level Framework
Halladay, J. L. (2012) · The Reading Teacher · doi:10.1002/trtr.01093 · Cited by 44
Is retell a valid measure of reading comprehension?
Cao, Y., & Kim, Y. G. (2020) · Educational Research Review · doi:10.1016/j.edurev.2020.100375 · Cited by 59
“Reading aloud forces students to pay attention to each word whereas silent reading permits students to skip words, especially for beginning readers (Allington & McGill-Franzen, 2010; Hale et al., 2007; Schimmel & Ness, 2017).”
BackgroundHale, A. D., Hawkins, R. O., Sheeley, W., Reynolds, J. R., Jenkins, S. L., Schmitt, A. J., & Martin, D. A. (2010) · Psychology in the Schools · doi:10.1002/pits.20543 · Cited by 49
Self-citationThe silent reading supported by adaptive learning technology: Influence in the children outcomes
Giacomo, D. D., Cofini, V., Mascio, T. D., Rosita, C. M., Fiorenzi, D., Gennari, R., & Vittorini, P. (2014) · Computers in Human Behavior · doi:10.1016/j.chb.2014.09.053 · Cited by 38
“…considering the traditional approach, which sees the child engaged in the activity of reading alone and the psychological evaluation performed through tests applied by an examiner (Hale et al., 2007); the weakness is the difficult control of the child’s performance during the silent reading.”
BackgroundNiedo, J., Lee, Y.-L., Breznitz, Z., & Berninger, V. W. (2013) · Learning Disability Quarterly · doi:10.1177/0731948713507263 · Cited by 35
“For example, Hale et al. (2007) found that oral reading accounted for only 27.66% of the variance in silent reading of elementary students and only 14.38% of the variance in silent reading in high school students.”
BackgroundInfluentialKrieber, M., Bartl-Pokorny, K. D., Pokorny, F. B., Zhang, D., Landerl, K., Körner, C., Pernkopf, F., Pock, T., Einspieler, C., & Marschik, P. B. (2017) · PLoS ONE · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0170986 · Cited by 44
Chen, X., Liang, L., Lu, M., Potměšíl, M., & Zhong, J. (2019) · Research in Developmental Disabilities · doi:10.1016/j.ridd.2019.05.003 · Cited by 23
How fast can we read in the mind? Developmental trajectories of silent reading fluency
Ciuffo, M., Myers, J., Ingrassia, M., Milanese, A., Venuti, M., Alquino, A., Baradello, A., Stella, G., & Gagliano, A. (2017) · Reading and Writing · doi:10.1007/s11145-017-9744-2 · Cited by 22
Robinson, M. F., Meisinger, E. B., & Joyner, R. E. (2018) · Learning Disability Quarterly · doi:10.1177/0731948718806665 · Cited by 34
Silent versus reading out loud modes: An eye-tracking study
Smyrnakis, I., Andreadakis, V., Andriani, R., Bοufachrentin, N., & Aslanides, I. M. (2021) · Journal of Eye Movement Research · doi:10.16910/jemr.14.2.1 · Cited by 25
Examining the Effects of Skill Level and Reading Modality on Reading Comprehension
Dickens, R. H., & Meisinger, E. B. (2015) · Reading Psychology · doi:10.1080/02702711.2015.1055869 · Cited by 28
“Hale et al. (2007) examined reading modality and comprehension with elementary and high school students.”
BackgroundResultInfluentialDickens, R. H., & Meisinger, E. B. (2016) · Reading Psychology · doi:10.1080/02702711.2016.1263701 · Cited by 26
“Hale et al. (2007) examined the influence of reading modality on comprehension with late elementary and high school students.”
BackgroundThe Influence of Testing Prompt and Condition on Middle School Students’ Retell Performance
Reed, D. K., & Petscher, Y. (2012) · Reading Psychology · doi:10.1080/02702711.2011.557333 · Cited by 15
“…students to read silently prior to answering questions (Paris, 2007), but research examining whether oral or silent reading is more efficacious for comprehension has been inconclusive (e.g., Hale et al., 2007; McCallum, Sharp, Bell, & George, 2004; Miller & Smith, 1990; Prior & Welling, 2001).”
BackgroundA Review of the Psychometric Properties of Retell Instruments
Reed, D. K. (2011) · Educational Assessment · doi:10.1080/10627197.2011.604238 · Cited by 16
Reading text aloud benefits memory but not comprehension
Roberts, B. R. T., Hu, Z. S., Curtis, E., Bodner, G. E., McLean, D., & MacLeod, C. M. (2023) · Memory & Cognition · doi:10.3758/s13421-023-01442-2 · Cited by 25
“Hale et al. (2007) reported that reading aloud as opposed to silently aided what they referred to as ‘comprehension’ in school-aged children.”
Making Sense of Reading Comprehension Assessments: Guidance for Evaluating Student Performance
Collins, A. A., & Lindström, E. R. (2021) · Intervention in School and Clinic · doi:10.1177/1053451221994806 · Cited by 13
“Mixed results in prior research studies suggest student performance may or may not differ between the two modes (McCallum et al., 2004), although some suggest higher comprehension scores may be measured when students read passages aloud (Hale et al., 2007).”
BackgroundResultGarcía-Rodicio, H., Melero, M. A., & Izquierdo, M.-B. (2017) · Journal for the Study of Education and Development Infancia y Aprendizaje · doi:10.1080/02103702.2017.1364038 · Cited by 12
“…podríamos interpretar que la ayuda que facilitan los investigadores para leer palabras difíciles en la lectura en voz alta podría explicar parciamente la superioridad de esta condición en experimentos previos (Carretti et al., 2012; Hale et al., 2007; Miller & Smith, 1990; Prior et al., 2011).”
BackgroundResultInfluentialBlonder, M., Skinner, C. H., Ciancio, D., Cazzell, S., Scott, K., Jaquett, C., Ruddy, J., & Thompson, K. (2018) · Contemporary School Psychology · doi:10.1007/s40688-017-0169-3 · Cited by 7
“Because aloud and silent reading differ (Hale et al. 2007; McCallum et al. 2004) and in a typical classroom, students often read silently when reading for comprehension (Skinner et al. 2002), additional studies are needed to determine if similar results would be obtained had students been…”
Self-citationPergams, O. R. W., Jake-Matthews, C. E., & Mohanty, L. M. (2018) · The journal of college science teaching · doi:10.2505/4/jcst18_047_05_10 · Cited by 6
Iacobelli, F., Dragon, G., Mazur, G., & Guitelman, J. (2021) · JMIR Formative Research · doi:10.2196/22809 · Cited by 5
“(2) Participant behavior: here, we recorded whether participants read aloud, whether dyads discussed or talked to each other, or whether there were durations of silence without action; behaviors such as these are mechanisms frequently used by beginner or nonproficient readers for memorization and comprehension [31,32].”
BackgroundChou, S. T. Y., Sutherland, R., & Mccabe, P. (2024) · International Journal of Speech-Language Pathology · doi:10.1080/17549507.2024.2363935 · Cited by 4
“…comprehension following oral reading is usually better than when following silent reading (e.g. Ciuffo et al., 2017; Dickens & Meisinger, 2016; Hale et al., 2007), meaning that we should proceed with caution in attempting to assess and understand the reading comprehension skills of children…”
García-Rodicio, H., Melero, M. A., & de Izquierdo, B. L. (2014) · INTED proceedings · Cited by 3
EFFECTS OF SILENT READING ON INTERMEDIATE STUDENTS' READING GROWTH
Rosseau, A. S. (2012) · Cited by 5
A comparison between reading aloud and silent reading among Iranian EFL learners
Jafari, M. A. (2013) · Eastern Mediterranean University Institutional Repository (Eastern Mediterranean University) · Cited by 9
The jingle fallacy in comprehension tests for reading
Lee, C. E., Godwin, H. J., & Drieghe, D. (2024) · PLoS ONE · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0306466 · Cited by 4
Subedi, R. (2022) · Kanakai Journal · doi:10.3126/kj.v2i1.47109 · Cited by 1
Aisiah, I. N., & Mahaputri, R. A. (2019) · Academic Journal Perspective Education Language and Literature · doi:10.33603/perspective.v7i1.1816 · Cited by 1
Mosleh, M. A., & Alshaboul, A. K. (2020) · Journal of Educational and Psychological Studies [JEPS] · doi:10.24200/jeps.vol14iss1pp108-127 · Cited by 1
Fluência e compreensão textual: uma revisão sistemática
Hickmann, G. M., Braz, E. D. H., & Guimarães, S. R. K. (2021) · EDUCA - Revista Multidisciplinar em Educação · doi:10.26568/2359-2087.2021.4777 · Cited by 1
Bridging the Gap between Accountability and Reading Comprehension.
Harvey-Woodall, A., & Richards, M. (2010) · Cited by 1
Smith, J. (2011) · ProQuest LLC eBooks
Nouvelle, R. C. (2010) · ScholarWorks (Walden University)
Reichenberg, J. L. (2014) · Digital Commons (Liberty University) · Cited by 5
En studie om elevers uppfattningar om sin egen och lärarens högläsning i årskurs 5
Olofsson, G., & Åhlén, S. (2012)
Park, S.-Y., & Jung, K. (2018) · Eon'eo cheong'gag jang'ae yeon'gu/Communication sciences & disorders · doi:10.12963/csd.18562
A Case Study on Two Korean EFL Middle School Students' Oral Reading Experiences
전채린 (2019) · Seoul National University Open Repository (Seoul National University)
Gürsoy, E., & ŞAHİN, O. (2019) · İnönü Üniversitesi Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi · doi:10.17679/inuefd.466367
“Moreover, readers have been claimed to use their cognitive capacity better while reading silently than reading aloud since their comprehension is hindered due to finite cognitive resources while reading aloud (Hale et al., 2007).”
BackgroundInput-based Instruction of English Personal Pronouns to Young Korean Learners
Kim, H. W., Sung, M.-C., & Kim, H. (2020) · The Journal of AsiaTEFL · doi:10.18823/asiatefl.2020.17.1.2.18
“Reading aloud in pairs was opted for as the main activity because hearing their own voice while reading helps learners to monitor their reading and to maintain an appropriate reading pace, leading to more active engagement in the task (Hale et al., 2007; Kragler, 1995; Levin, 1979).”
BackgroundConsciência fonológica, leitura e compreensão leitora no alemão como língua adicional
Konrad, J. T., & Lorandi, A. (2020) · Revista Linguagem & Ensino · doi:10.15210/rle.v23i2.17408
الغافرية, م. ب. ن. ب. ع., إمام, م. م., & عمارة, إ. م. ن. (2021) · Journal of Educational Sciences – Qatar University · doi:10.29117/jes.2021.0051
Iacobelli, F., Dragon, G., Mazur, G., & Guitelman, J. (2020) · doi:10.2196/preprints.18610
Pem, K., & Sukavatee, P. (2021) · Chula Digiverse · doi:10.58837/chula.the.2021.378
Development of Persian Reading Comprehension Test and determination of its psychometric properties
Hamdollahi, M. H., Mohamadi, R., Sadeghi, A., & Ahadi, H. (2024) · Applied Neuropsychology Child · doi:10.1080/21622965.2024.2429482 · Cited by 1
Using Read-Alouds to Reinforce Comprehension in Second Grade Students
Alessandra, M. (2012) · Fisher Digital Publications (St. John Fisher College)
Metadata
- Authors
- Hale, A. D., Skinner, C. H., Williams, J., Hawkins, R., Neddenriep, C. E., & Dizer, J.
- Affiliations
- Eastern Kentucky University (US)
- University of Tennessee at Knoxville (US)
- University of Cincinnati (US)
- University of Wisconsin–Whitewater (US)
- Venue
- The Behavior Analyst Today
- Published
- 2007
- Volume
- 8
- Issue
- 1
- Pages
- 9-23
- ISSN
- 1539-4352 (ISSN-L)
- OpenAlex
- W1982179833
- Cited by
- 53
- References
- 41
- Citations by year
- 2024: 3 · 2023: 1 · 2022: 1 · 2021: 6 · 2020: 5 · 2019: 4 · 2018: 4 · 2017: 4 · 2016: 2 · 2015: 3 · 2014: 5 · 2013: 2 · 2012: 6
- FWCI
- 2.24
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- hybrid
- doi.org
- Locations
- The Behavior Analyst Today (publishedVersion, other-oa)
- Topics
- Social Sciences › Psychology › Developmental and Educational Psychology › Reading and Literacy Development
- Social Sciences › Psychology › Developmental and Educational Psychology › Behavioral and Psychological Studies
- Social Sciences › Psychology › Developmental and Educational Psychology › Second Language Acquisition and Learning
- Keywords
- reading comprehension, silent reading, reading aloud, curriculum-based measurement, progress monitoring, elementary school students, high school students, grade level differences, DIBELS, Response to Intervention, special education, reading assessment, word recognition, fluency, phonological awareness, phonics, sight words
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.