Does Simulation-Based Medical Education With Deliberate Practice Yield Better Results Than Traditional Clinical Education? A Meta-Analytic Comparative Review of the Evidence
Open accessThe DOI matches its Crossref record; 46 of the 47 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Abstract
PURPOSE: This article presents a comparison of the effectiveness of traditional clinical education toward skill acquisition goals versus simulation-based medical education (SBME) with deliberate practice (DP). METHOD: This is a quantitative meta-analysis that spans 20 years, 1990 to 2010. A search strategy involving three literature databases, 12 search terms, and four inclusion criteria was used. Four authors independently retrieved and reviewed articles. Main outcome measures were extracted to calculate effect sizes. RESULTS: Of 3,742 articles identified, 14 met inclusion criteria. The overall effect size for the 14 studies evaluating the comparative effectiveness of SBME compared with traditional clinical medical education was 0.71 (95% confidence interval, 0.65-0.76; P < .001). CONCLUSIONS: Although the number of reports analyzed in this meta-analysis is small, these results show that SBME with DP is superior to traditional clinical medical education in achieving specific clinical skill acquisition goals. SBME is a complex educational intervention that should be introduced thoughtfully and evaluated rigorously at training sites. Further research on incorporating SBME with DP into medical education is needed to amplify its power, utility, and cost-effectiveness.
Overview
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Claims other papers make about this one
Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?
The source backs part of the claim, not all of it — or backs it for a different population, condition or comparison.
In the citing paper
“In medical and nursing education, simulation-based teaching has demonstrated superior effectiveness compared to didactic teaching [4,5]”
From Effectiveness of Virtual Simulations Versus Mannequins and Real Persons in Medical and Nursing Education: Meta-Analysis and Trial Sequential Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials (2024) · cites this paper as [4]
Experimental — accuracy not yet measuredIn the citing paper
“However, a persistent challenge in this field is the significant gap between theoretical learning acquired in academic settings and the practical skills required in real-world clinical environments—a phenomenon widely recognized as the “theory–practice gap” [2, 3].”
From The impact of clinical simulation on bridging the theory–practice gap in nursing education: a systematic review (2025) · cites this paper as [3]
Self-check
Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.
The self-check needs the paper’s full text.
Citations
Cites
Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences
(1990) · Computers, Environment and Urban Systems · doi:10.1016/0198-9715(90)90050-4 · Cited by 65,269
Meta-analysis of Observational Studies in Epidemiology<SUBTITLE>A Proposal for Reporting</SUBTITLE>
Stroup, D. F. (2000) · JAMA · doi:10.1001/jama.283.15.2008 · Cited by 20,623
Borenstein, M., Hedges, L. V., Higgins, J. P. T., & Rothstein, H. R. (2021) · doi:10.1002/9781119558378 · Cited by 9,799
Moher, D., Cook, D. J., Eastwood, S., Olkin, I., Rennie, D., & Stroup, D. F. (1999) · The Lancet · doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(99)04149-5 · Cited by 4,826
Barry Issenberg, S., Mcgaghie, W. C., Petrusa, E. R., Lee Gordon, D., & Scalese, R. J. (2005) · Medical Teacher · doi:10.1080/01421590500046924 · Cited by 3,966
Self-citationRealist review - a new method of systematic review designed for complex policy interventions
Pawson, R., Greenhalgh, T., Harvey, G., & Walshe, K. (2005) · Journal of Health Services Research & Policy · doi:10.1258/1355819054308530 · Cited by 3,190
The Cambridge Handbook of Expertise and Expert Performance
(2006) · Cambridge University Press eBooks · doi:10.1017/cbo9780511816796 · Cited by 3,158
Ericsson, K. A. (2004) · Academic Medicine · doi:10.1097/00001888-200410001-00022 · Cited by 2,988
Seymour, N. E., Gallagher, A. G., Roman, S. A., O’Brien, M. K., Bansal, V. K., Andersen, D. K., & Satava, R. M. (2002) · Annals of Surgery · doi:10.1097/00000658-200210000-00008 · Cited by 2,853
Clinical Epidemiology: The Essentials.
(1991) · Annals of Internal Medicine · doi:10.7326/0003-4819-114-9-825_10 · Cited by 1,835
A critical review of simulation‐based medical education research: 2003–2009
McGaghie, W. C., Issenberg, S. B., Petrusa, E. R., & Scalese, R. J. (2010) · Medical Education · doi:10.1111/j.1365-2923.2009.03547.x · Cited by 1,733
Self-citationEricsson, K. A. (2006) · The Cambridge Handbook of Expertise and Expert Performance · doi:10.1017/cbo9780511816796.038 · Cited by 1,629
Simulation Technology for Health Care Professional Skills Training and Assessment
Issenberg, S. B. (1999) · JAMA · doi:10.1001/jama.282.9.861 · Cited by 914
Self-citationAhlberg, G., Enochsson, L., Gallagher, A. G., Hedman, L., Hogman, C., McClusky, D. A., Ramel, S., Smith, C. D., & Arvidsson, D. (2007) · The American Journal of Surgery · doi:10.1016/j.amjsurg.2006.06.050 · Cited by 693
Wayne, D. B., Didwania, A., Feinglass, J., Fudala, M. J., Barsuk, J. H., & McGaghie, W. C. (2008) · Chest · doi:10.1378/chest.07-0131 · Cited by 677
Self-citationUse of Simulation-Based Education to Reduce Catheter-Related Bloodstream Infections
Barsuk, J. H., Cohen, E. R., Feinglass, J., McGaghie, W. C., & Wayne, D. B. (2009) · Archives of Internal Medicine · doi:10.1001/archinternmed.2009.215 · Cited by 567
Self-citationDoes training in obstetric emergencies improve neonatal outcome?
Draycott, T., Sibanda, T., Owen, L., Akande, V., Winter, C., Reading, S., & Whitelaw, A. (2006) · BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics & Gynaecology · doi:10.1111/j.1471-0528.2006.00800.x · Cited by 566
Improving Neonatal Outcome Through Practical Shoulder Dystocia Training
Draycott, T. J., Crofts, J. F., Ash, J. P., Wilson, L. V., Yard, E., Sibanda, T., & Whitelaw, A. (2008) · Obstetrics & Gynecology · doi:10.1097/aog.0b013e31817bbc61 · Cited by 528
Barsuk, J. H., McGaghie, W. C., Cohen, E. R., OʼLeary, K. J., & Wayne, D. B. (2009) · Critical Care Medicine · doi:10.1097/00003246-200910000-00003 · Cited by 486
Self-citationWayne, D. B., Butter, J., Siddall, V. J., Fudala, M. J., Wade, L. D., Feinglass, J., & McGaghie, W. C. (2006) · Journal of General Internal Medicine · doi:10.1111/j.1525-1497.2006.00341.x · Cited by 420
Self-citationKorndorffer, J. R., Dunne, J. B., Sierra, R., Stefanidis, D., Touchard, C. L., & Scott, D. J. (2005) · Journal of the American College of Surgeons · doi:10.1016/j.jamcollsurg.2005.02.021 · Cited by 420
QUOROM Group, Moher, D., Cook, D. J., Eastwood, S., Olkin, I., Rennie, D., & Stroup, D. F. (2000) · Journal of British Surgery · doi:10.1046/j.1365-2168.2000.01610.x · Cited by 416
Barsuk, J. H., McGaghie, W. C., Cohen, E. R., Balachandran, J. S., & Wayne, D. B. (2009) · Journal of Hospital Medicine · doi:10.1002/jhm.468 · Cited by 405
Self-citationCohen, E. R., Feinglass, J., Barsuk, J. H., Barnard, C., O'Donnell, A., McGaghie, W. C., & Wayne, D. B. (2010) · Simulation in Healthcare: The Journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare · doi:10.1097/sih.0b013e3181bc8304 · Cited by 376
Self-citationBland, K. I. (2006) · Yearbook of Surgery · doi:10.1016/s0090-3671(08)70537-8 · Cited by 367
Wayne, D. B., Butter, J., Siddall, V. J., Fudala, M. J., Linquist, L. A., Feinglass, J., Wade, L. D., & McGaghie, W. C. (2005) · Teaching and Learning in Medicine · doi:10.1207/s15328015tlm1703_3 · Cited by 347
Self-citationAndreatta, P. B., Woodrum, D. T., Birkmeyer, J. D., Yellamanchilli, R. K., Doherty, G. M., Gauger, P. G., & Minter, R. M. (2006) · Annals of Surgery · doi:10.1097/01.sla.0000219641.79092.e5 · Cited by 291
Wayne, D. B., Barsuk, J. H., O'Leary, K. J., Fudala, M. J., & McGaghie, W. C. (2008) · Journal of Hospital Medicine · doi:10.1002/jhm.268 · Cited by 282
Self-citationHalpenny, J. (1918) · Europe PMC (PubMed Central) · Cited by 256
Graphical displays for meta-analysis: An overview with suggestions for practice
Anzures‐Cabrera, J., & Higgins, J. P. T. (2010) · Research Synthesis Methods · doi:10.1002/jrsm.6 · Cited by 233
Blum, M. G., Powers, T. W., & Sundaresan, S. (2004) · The Annals of Thoracic Surgery · doi:10.1016/j.athoracsur.2003.11.058 · Cited by 172
Van Sickle, K. R., Ritter, M. E., Baghai, M., Goldenberg, A. E., Huang, I.-P., Gallagher, A. G., & Smith, D. C. (2008) · Journal of the American College of Surgeons · doi:10.1016/j.jamcollsurg.2008.05.007 · Cited by 170
Barsuk, J. H., Ahya, S. N., Cohen, E. R., McGaghie, W. C., & Wayne, D. B. (2009) · American Journal of Kidney Diseases · doi:10.1053/j.ajkd.2008.12.041 · Cited by 167
Self-citationMedical Education Research As Translational Science
McGaghie, W. C. (2010) · Science Translational Medicine · doi:10.1126/scitranslmed.3000679 · Cited by 161
Self-citationSimulation-based Mastery Learning Improves Cardiac Auscultation Skills in Medical Students
Butter, J., McGaghie, W. C., Cohen, E. R., Kaye, M., & Wayne, D. B. (2010) · Journal of General Internal Medicine · doi:10.1007/s11606-010-1309-x · Cited by 151
Self-citationIssenberg, S. B., McGaghie, W. C., Gordon, D. L., Symes, S., Petrusa, E. R., Hart, I. R., & Harden, R. M. (2002) · Teaching and Learning in Medicine · doi:10.1207/s15328015tlm1404_4 · Cited by 134
Self-citationImproving Neonatal Outcome Through Practical Shoulder Dystocia Training
Draycott, T. J., Crofts, J. F., Ash, J. P., Wilson, L. V., Yard, E., Sibanda, T., & Whitelaw, A. (2009) · Obstetric Anesthesia Digest · doi:10.1097/01.aoa.0000350630.57549.70 · Cited by 102
Development and transferability of a cost-effective laparoscopic camera navigation simulator
Korndorffer, J. R., Hayes, D., Dunne, J. B., Sierra, R. J., Touchard, C. L., Markert, R. J., & Scott, D. J. (2004) · Surgical Endoscopy · doi:10.1007/s00464-004-8901-2 · Cited by 87
Characteristics of Published Comparative Effectiveness Studies of Medications
Hochman, M. (2010) · JAMA · doi:10.1001/jama.2010.240 · Cited by 81
Quirk, M., Mazor, K., Haley, H.-L., Wellman, S., Keller, D., Hatem, D., & Keller, L. A. (2005) · Teaching and Learning in Medicine · doi:10.1207/s15328015tlm1703_2 · Cited by 77
Treatment Strength and Integrity: Models and Methods.
Cordray, D. S., & Pion, G. M. (2006) · American Psychological Association eBooks · doi:10.1037/11384-006 · Cited by 73
Stefanidis, D., Sierra, R. J., Korndorffer, J. R., Dunne, J. B., Markley, S., Touchard, C. L., & Scott, D. J. (2006) · The American Journal of Surgery · doi:10.1016/j.amjsurg.2005.06.046 · Cited by 52
Meta‐analysis of quasi‐experimental research: are systematic narrative reviews indicated?
Colliver, J. A., Kucera, K., & Verhulst, S. J. (2008) · Medical Education · doi:10.1111/j.1365-2923.2008.03144.x · Cited by 45
The value of paradoxical tensions in medical education research
Eva, K. W. (2009) · Medical Education · doi:10.1111/j.1365-2923.2009.03540.x · Cited by 33
Fincher, R.-M. E., White, C. B., Huang, G. C., & Schwartzstein, R. M. (2010) · Academic Medicine · doi:10.1097/acm.0b013e3181d73f9e · Cited by 28
(2009) · American Journal of Kidney Diseases · doi:10.1053/s0272-6386(09)00658-1 · Cited by 2
Research works printed but not linked: 3
- Ericsson KA, Charness N, Feltovich PJ, Hoffman RR. The Cambridge Handbook of Expertise and Expert Performance. New York: Cambridge University Press; 2006. [Google Scholar]
- Institute of Medicine. National Priorities for Comparative Effectiveness Research. Washington, DC: National Academies Press; 2009. [Google Scholar]
- Institute of Medicine (IOM) Knowing What Works in Health Care: A Roadmap for the Nation. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press; 2008. [Google Scholar]
Cited by
Global Surgery 2030: evidence and solutions for achieving health, welfare, and economic development
Meara, J. G., Leather, A. J. M., Hagander, L., Alkire, B. C., Alonso, N., Ameh, E. A., Bickler, S. W., Conteh, L., Dare, A. J., Davies, J., et al. (2015) · The Lancet · doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(15)60160-x · Cited by 3,851
Cook, D. A., Hatala, R., Brydges, R., Zendejas, B., Szostek, J. H., Wang, A. T., Erwin, P. J., & Hamstra, S. J. (2011) · JAMA · doi:10.1001/jama.2011.1234 · Cited by 2,170
Simulation in healthcare education: A best evidence practical guide. AMEE Guide No. 82
Motola, I., Devine, L. A., Chung, H. S., Sullivan, J. E., & Issenberg, S. B. (2013) · Medical Teacher · doi:10.3109/0142159x.2013.818632 · Cited by 1,180
Self-citationEppich, W., & Cheng, A. (2015) · Simulation in Healthcare: The Journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare · doi:10.1097/sih.0000000000000072 · Cited by 1,106
The impact of simulation-based training in medical education: A review
Elendu, C., Amaechi, D. C., Okatta, A. U., Amaechi, E. C., Elendu, T. C., Ezeh, C. P., & Elendu, I. D. (2024) · Medicine · doi:10.1097/md.0000000000038813 · Cited by 994
“[44] Such findings high-light the lasting impact of SBT on clinical competence.”
Background
Metadata
- Authors
- McGaghie, W. C., Issenberg, S. B., Cohen, E. R., Barsuk, J. H., & Wayne, D. B.
- Affiliations
- Northwestern University (US)
- Corresponding author
- McGaghie, William C.
- Venue
- Academic Medicine
- Publisher
- Oxford University Press (OUP)
- Published
- 2011-06
- Volume
- 86
- Issue
- 6
- Pages
- 706-711
- ISSN
- 1040-2446 (ISSN-L)
- PMC
- PMC3102783
- OpenAlex
- W1969241382
- Semantic Scholar
- acd6ea2dfcedd1f8cb2cbe1f21b02538a7e7250e
- Cited by
- 1,866
- References
- 47
- Citations by year
- 2026: 236 · 2025: 125 · 2024: 112 · 2023: 116 · 2022: 115 · 2021: 181 · 2020: 183 · 2019: 133 · 2018: 125 · 2017: 103 · 2016: 105 · 2015: 113 · 2014: 76 · 2013: 77 · 2012: 51
- FWCI
- 47.32
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- green
- www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- Locations
- Academic Medicine (publishedVersion)
- PubMed (publishedVersion)
- Europe PMC (PubMed Central) (acceptedVersion)
- PubMed Central (acceptedVersion)
- Funders
- National Center for Research Resources (UL1RR025741)
- Topics
- Social Sciences › Education › Simulation-Based Education in Healthcare
- Social Sciences › Education › Innovations in Medical Education
- Health Sciences › Medicine › Surgery › Surgical Simulation and Training
- Keywords
- simulation-based medical education, deliberate practice, comparative effectiveness
- MeSH terms
- Clinical Competence, Education, Medical, Humans, Manikins, Practice, Psychological, United States, Outcome Assessment, Health Care, Comparative Effectiveness Research
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.