A Randomized Clinical Trial of Three Options for N95 Respirators and Medical Masks in Health Workers
The DOI matches its Crossref record; 44 of the 44 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Abstract
Rationale We compared three policy options for the use of medical masks and N95 respirators in healthcare workers (HCWs). Objectives A cluster randomized clinical trial of 1,669 hospital-based HCWs in Beijing, China in the winter of 2009-2010. Methods Participants were randomized to medical masks, N95 respirators, or targeted use of N95 respirators while doing high-risk procedures or barrier nursing. Outcomes included clinical respiratory illness (CRI) and laboratory-confirmed respiratory pathogens in symptomatic subjects. Measurements and main results The rate of CRI was highest in the medical mask arm (98 of 572; 17%), followed by the targeted N95 arm (61 of 516; 11.8%), and the N95 arm (42 of 581; 7.2%) (P Conclusions Continuous use of N95 respirators was more efficacious against CRI than intermittent use of N95 or medical masks. Most policies for HCWs recommend use of medical masks alone or targeted N95 respirator use. Continuous use of N95s resulted in significantly lower rates of bacterial colonization, a novel finding that points to more research on the clinical significance of bacterial infection in symptomatic HCWs. This study provides further data to inform occupational policy options for HCWs. Clinical trial registered with Australian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry http://www.anzctr.org.au (ACTRN 12609000778280).
Overview
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
Claims other papers make about this one
Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?
In the citing paper
“In MacIntyre 2013, fewer participants using the N95 respirator reported problems (38% (195/512) versus 48% (274/571) of participants in the medical‐mask arm; P = 0.001).”
From Physical interventions to interrupt or reduce the spread of respiratory viruses (2023) · cites this paper as MacIntyre 2013
In the citing paper
“Pooling of three trials found an estimate of effect suggesting considerable uncertainty as to whether an N95/P2 respirator provides any benefit compared to medical/surgical masks for the outcome of clinical respiratory illness (RR 0.70, 95% CI 0.45 to 1.10; 7799 participants, very low‐certainty evidence; Analysis 2.1)”
From Physical interventions to interrupt or reduce the spread of respiratory viruses (2023) · cites this paper as MacIntyre 2013
In the citing paper
“Pooling of three trials found an estimate of effect suggesting considerable uncertainty as to whether an N95/P2 respirator provides any benefit compared to medical/surgical masks for the outcome of clinical respiratory illness (RR 0.70, 95% CI 0.45 to 1.10; 7799 participants, very low‐certainty evidence; Analysis 2.1)”
From Physical interventions to interrupt or reduce the spread of respiratory viruses (2023) · cites this paper as MacIntyre 2013
In the citing paper
“Pooling of two studies (MacIntyre 2011; MacIntyre 2013) also found an estimate of effect that favoured N95 respirators to medical/surgical masks for clinical respiratory infections (RR 0.47, 95% CI 0.36 to 0.62), but not for ILI, (RR 0.59, 95% CI 0.27 to 1.28) based on three studies (Loeb 2009: MacIntyre 2011; MacIntyre 2013).”
From Physical interventions to interrupt or reduce the spread of respiratory viruses (2023) · cites this paper as MacIntyre 2013
In the citing paper
“Our findings accord with those of a cluster randomised trial showing a potential benefit of continuous N95 respirator use over medical masks against seasonal viral infections.”
Citations
Cites
Consort 2010 statement: extension to cluster randomised trials
Campbell, M. K., Piaggio, G., Elbourne, D. R., Altman, D. G., & for the CONSORT Group (2012) · BMJ · doi:10.1136/bmj.e5661 · Cited by 3,510
CONSORT statement: extension to cluster randomised trials
Campbell, M. K., Elbourne, D. R., & Altman, D. G. (2004) · BMJ · doi:10.1136/bmj.328.7441.702 · Cited by 2,557
A Note on Robust Variance Estimation for Cluster‐Correlated Data
Williams, R. L. (2000) · Biometrics · doi:10.1111/j.0006-341x.2000.00645.x · Cited by 2,501
Pandemic Potential of a Strain of Influenza A (H1N1): Early Findings
Fraser, C., Donnelly, C. A., Cauchemez, S., Hanage, W. P., Van Kerkhove, M. D., Hollingsworth, T. D., Griffin, J., Baggaley, R. F., Jenkins, H. E., Lyons, E. J., et al. (2009) · Science · doi:10.1126/science.1176062 · Cited by 1,909 · cited 3×
“HCWs were excluded if they (1) were unable or refused to consent; (2) had beards, long moustaches, or long facial hair stubble; (3) had a current respiratory illness, rhinitis, and/or allergy; or (4) worked part-time or did not work in the aforementioned wards or departments.”
BackgroundMethod(2003) · RePEc: Research Papers in Economics · Cited by 1,844
Design and Analysis of Cluster Randomization Trials in Health Research
DONNER, A. P., & Klar, N. S. (2000) · Cited by 1,236
A role for Streptococcus pneumoniae in virus-associated pneumonia
Madhi, S. A., Klugman, K. P., & The Vaccine Trialist Group (2004) · Nature Medicine · doi:10.1038/nm1077 · Cited by 565
Cowling, B. J., Chan, K.-H., Fang, V. J., Cheng, C. K. Y., Fung, R. O. P., Wai, W., Sin, J., Seto, W. H., Yung, R., Chu, D. W. S., et al. (2009) · Annals of Internal Medicine · doi:10.7326/0003-4819-151-7-200910060-00142 · Cited by 533 · cited 1×
“In three trials, participants were randomized either to hand washing or to hand washing plus surgical masks (9, 11, 13), with no clear additional benefit of masks.”
BackgroundLouie, J. K., Jean, C., Chen, T. H., Park, S., Ueki, R., Harper, T. J., Chmara, E., Myers, J. E., Stoppacher, R., Catanese, C., et al. (2009) · MMWR Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report · Cited by 519
Loeb, M., Dafoe, N., Mahony, J., John, M., Sarabia, A., Glavin, V., Webby, R., Smieja, M., Earn, D. J. D., Chong, S., et al. (2009) · JAMA · doi:10.1001/jama.2009.1466 · Cited by 465 · cited 6×
“Importantly, the intervention studied in the Loeb trial was the use of medical masks and respirators only during care of identified febrile patients with ILI or having high-risk procedures, and where the unit of randomization was blocks of four HCW (15).”
BackgroundInfluentialFace mask use and control of respiratory virus transmission in households
MacIntyre, C. R., Cauchemez, S., Dwyer, D. E., Seale, H., Cheung, P., Browne, G., Fasher, M., Wood, J., Gao, Z., Booy, R., et al. (2009) · Emerging Infectious Diseases · doi:10.3201/eid1502.081166 · Cited by 461 · cited 7×
“Importantly, the intervention studied in the Loeb trial was the use of medical masks and respirators only during care of identified febrile patients with ILI or having high-risk procedures, and where the unit of randomization was blocks of four HCW (15).”
BackgroundMethodInfluentialSelf-citationInfluenza in the acute hospital setting
Salgado, C. D., Farr, B. M., Hall, K. K., & Hayden, F. G. (2002) · The Lancet Infectious Diseases · doi:10.1016/s1473-3099(02)00221-9 · Cited by 417 · cited 1×
“Indeed, the rate of “influenza” found in that study (z24%) is the same as rates of influenza documented in nosocomial outbreaks of influenza in HCWs without preventive interventions (22), and actually higher than rates described in other studies of influenza in unprotected HCWs (23), suggesting that the endpoint overe…”
ResultBałazy, A., Toivola, M., Adhikari, A., Sivasubramani, S. K., Reponen, T., & Grinshpun, S. A. (2006) · American Journal of Infection Control · doi:10.1016/j.ajic.2005.08.018 · Cited by 376 · cited 2×
“HCWs were excluded if they (1) were unable or refused to consent; (2) had beards, long moustaches, or long facial hair stubble; (3) had a current respiratory illness, rhinitis, and/or allergy; or (4) worked part-time or did not work in the aforementioned wards or departments.”
BackgroundMethodAiello, A. E., Murray, G. F., Perez, V., Coulborn, R. M., Davis, B. M., Uddin, M., Shay, D. K., Waterman, S. H., & Monto, A. S. (2010) · The Journal of Infectious Diseases · doi:10.1086/650396 · Cited by 354 · cited 1×
“In three trials, participants were randomized either to hand washing or to hand washing plus surgical masks (9, 11, 13), with no clear additional benefit of masks.”
BackgroundMacIntyre, C. R., Wang, Q., Cauchemez, S., Seale, H., Dwyer, D. E., Yang, P., Shi, W., Gao, Z., Pang, X., Zhang, Y., et al. (2011) · Influenza and Other Respiratory Viruses · doi:10.1111/j.1750-2659.2011.00198.x · Cited by 257
Self-citationElder, A. G., O'Donnell, B., McCruden, E. A. B., Symington, I. S., & Carman, W. F. (1996) · BMJ · doi:10.1136/bmj.313.7067.1241 · Cited by 228 · cited 1×
“Indeed, the rate of “influenza” found in that study (z24%) is the same as rates of influenza documented in nosocomial outbreaks of influenza in HCWs without preventive interventions (22), and actually higher than rates described in other studies of influenza in unprotected HCWs (23), suggesting that the endpoint overe…”
ResultHyman, C. L., Roblin, P. M., Gaydos, C. A., Quinn, T. C., Schachter, J., & Hammerschlag, M. R. (1995) · Clinical Infectious Diseases · doi:10.1093/clinids/20.5.1174 · Cited by 201 · cited 1×
“pneumoniae has been reported in HCWs (36, 37).”
BackgroundPostoperative wound infections and surgical face masks: A controlled study
Tunevall, T. G. (1991) · World Journal of Surgery · doi:10.1007/bf01658736 · Cited by 196
Cowling, B. J., Fung, R. O. P., Cheng, C. K. Y., Fang, V. J., Chan, K. H., Seto, W. H., Yung, R., Chiu, B., Lee, P., Uyeki, T. M., et al. (2008) · PLoS ONE · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0002101 · Cited by 186
Simmerman, J. M., Suntarattiwong, P., Levy, J., Jarman, R. G., Kaewchana, S., Gibbons, R. V., Cowling, B. J., Sanasuttipun, W., Maloney, S. A., Uyeki, T. M., et al. (2011) · Influenza and Other Respiratory Viruses · doi:10.1111/j.1750-2659.2011.00205.x · Cited by 177
USE OF PERTUSSIS VACCINE IN AN EPIDEMIC INVOLVING HOSPITAL STAFF
Linnemann, C. C., Perlstein, P. H., Ramundo, N., Minton, S. D., Englender, G. S., McCormick, J. B., & Hayes, P. S. (1975) · The Lancet · doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(75)90907-1 · Cited by 172
Pneumococcal pneumonia and influenza: A deadly combination
Klugman, K. P., Chien, Y., & Madhi, S. A. (2009) · Vaccine · doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2009.06.007 · Cited by 158
Impact of Non-Pharmaceutical Interventions on URIs and Influenza in Crowded, Urban Households
Larson, E. L., Ferng, Y.-H., Wong-McLoughlin, J., Wang, S., Haber, M., & Morse, S. S. (2010) · Public Health Reports® · doi:10.1177/003335491012500206 · Cited by 157
Aerosol penetration and leakae characteristics of masks used in the health care industry
Weber, A. M., Willeke, K., Marchloni, R., Myojo, T., McKay, R. T., Donnelly, J., & Liebhaber, F. B. (1993) · American Journal of Infection Control · doi:10.1016/0196-6553(93)90027-2 · Cited by 156
DONNER, A. P., & Klar, N. S. (2000) · Statistical Methods in Medical Research · doi:10.1191/096228000669355658 · Cited by 153
Spread of Pertussis by Hospital Staff
Kurt, T. L. (1972) · JAMA · doi:10.1001/jama.1972.03200160016004 · Cited by 130
Comparison of Performance of Three Different Types of Respiratory Protection Devices
Lawrence, R. B., Duling, M. G., Calvert, C. A., & Coffey, C. C. (2006) · Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene · doi:10.1080/15459620600829211 · Cited by 127 · cited 1×
“HCWs were excluded if they (1) were unable or refused to consent; (2) had beards, long moustaches, or long facial hair stubble; (3) had a current respiratory illness, rhinitis, and/or allergy; or (4) worked part-time or did not work in the aforementioned wards or departments.”
BackgroundCarrat, F., Sahler, C., Rogez, S., Leruez-Ville, M., Freymuth, F., Le Gales, C., Bungener, M., Housset, B., Nicolas, M., & Rouzioux, C. (2002) · Archives of Internal Medicine · doi:10.1001/archinte.162.16.1842 · Cited by 125 · cited 1×
“CRI, defined as two or more respiratory symptoms or one respiratory symptom and a systemic symptom (16, 17).”
BackgroundUdasin, I. G. (2000) · Primary Care Clinics in Office Practice · doi:10.1016/s0095-4543(05)70190-1 · Cited by 106
Is a mask necessary in the operating theatre?
Orr, N. W. M. (1981) · PubMed · Cited by 100
Sherertz, R. J., Bassetti, S., & Bassetti-Wyss, B. A. (2001) · Emerging infectious diseases · doi:10.3201/eid0702.010218 · Cited by 99 · cited 1×
“pneumoniae are absent, possibly because it is not an outbreakassociated disease (30).”
BackgroundChristie, C. D. C., Glover, A.-M., Willke, M. J., Marx, M. L., Reising, S. F., & Hutchinson, N. (1995) · Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology · doi:10.1086/647008 · Cited by 94
Surgical face masks in modern operating rooms—a costly and unnecessary ritual?
Mitchell, N. J., & Hunt, S. (1991) · Journal of Hospital Infection · doi:10.1016/0195-6701(91)90148-2 · Cited by 91
A Pertussis Outbreak in a Wisconsin Nursing Home
Addiss, D. G., Davis, J. P., Meade, B. D., Burstyn, D. G., Meissner, M., Zastrow, J. A., Berg, J. L., Drinka, P., & Phillips, R. (1991) · Journal of Infectious Diseases · doi:10.1093/infdis/164.4.704 · Cited by 86
Kao, T., Huang, K.-C., Huang, Y., Tsai, T., Hsieh, B.-S., & Wu, M. (2004) · PubMed · Cited by 67
Barriers to Mask Wearing for Influenza‐like Illnesses Among Urban Hispanic Households
Ferng, Y., Wong‐McLoughlin, J., Barrett, A. E., Currie, L. M., & Larson, E. (2010) · Public Health Nursing · doi:10.1111/j.1525-1446.2010.00918.x · Cited by 56 · cited 1×
“Acceptability of face mask use in developed country settings is lower than in Asian countries (39), and this limits the translation of the findings.”
BackgroundInvasive Pneumococcal Pneumonia and Respiratory Virus Co-infections
Zhou, H., Haber, M., Ray, S. M., Farley, M. M., Panozzo, C. A., & Klugman, K. P. (2012) · Emerging infectious diseases · doi:10.3201/eid1802.102025 · Cited by 50
Novel H1N1 Influenza and Respiratory Protection for Health Care Workers
Shine, K. I., Rogers, B., & Goldfrank, L. R. (2009) · New England Journal of Medicine · doi:10.1056/nejmp0908437 · Cited by 46 · cited 3×
“HCWs were excluded if they (1) were unable or refused to consent; (2) had beards, long moustaches, or long facial hair stubble; (3) had a current respiratory illness, rhinitis, and/or allergy; or (4) worked part-time or did not work in the aforementioned wards or departments.”
BackgroundMethodInfluenza and Bacterial Pathogen Coinfections in the 20th Century
Wang, X.-Y., Kilgore, P. E., Lim, K. A., Wang, S.-M., Lee, J., Deng, W., Mo, M.-Q., Nyambat, B., Ma, J.-C., Favorov, M. O., et al. (2011) · Interdisciplinary Perspectives on Infectious Diseases · doi:10.1155/2011/146376 · Cited by 37 · cited 7×
“Importantly, the intervention studied in the Loeb trial was the use of medical masks and respirators only during care of identified febrile patients with ILI or having high-risk procedures, and where the unit of randomization was blocks of four HCW (15).”
BackgroundInfluentialSelf-citationKleemola, M., & Jokinen, C. (1992) · Journal of Hospital Infection · doi:10.1016/0195-6701(92)90078-z · Cited by 24 · cited 1×
“pneumoniae has been reported in HCWs (36, 37).”
BackgroundSeale, H., Corbett, S. J., Dwyer, D. E., & MacIntyre, C. R. (2009) · Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology · doi:10.1086/599254 · Cited by 21
Self-citationUsefulness of Pulsed-Field Gel Electrophoresis in Assessing Nosocomial Transmission of Pertussis
Nouvellon, M., Gehanno, J.-F., Pestel‐Caron, M., Weber, C., Lemeland, J., & Guiso, N. (1999) · Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology · doi:10.1086/501579 · Cited by 19
Alternative Epidemic of Different Types of Influenza in 2009–2010 Influenza Season, China
Yang, P., Qian, H.-K., Peng, X., Liang, H., Huang, F., & Wang, Q. (2010) · Clinical Infectious Diseases · doi:10.1086/655766 · Cited by 6 · cited 1×
“During our study, A(H1N1)pdm09 activity in Beijing was waning (38).”
BackgroundSelf-citationDensity of carriage - Can it predict pneumonia?
Klugman, K. P. (2012) · International Journal of Infectious Diseases · doi:10.1016/j.ijid.2012.05.081 · Cited by 1 · cited 1×
“Bacterial carriage density may be a predictor of invasive disease and of viral-bacterial coinfection (24).”
Background
Cited by
Chu, D. K., Akl, E. A., Duda, S., Solo, K., Yaacoub, S., Schünemann, H. J., Chu, D. K., Akl, E. A., El-harakeh, A., Bognanni, A., et al. (2020) · The Lancet · doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(20)31142-9 · Cited by 3,843
Self-citationAlhazzani, W., Møller, M. H., Arabi, Y. M., Loeb, M., Gong, M. N., Fan, E., Oczkowski, S., Levy, M. M., Derde, L., Dzierba, A., et al. (2020) · Intensive Care Medicine · doi:10.1007/s00134-020-06022-5 · Cited by 2,105
“Overall, 4 RCTs (5549 individuals) randomized healthcare workers to N95 res-pirators or medical masks [21–25].”
Alhazzani, W., Møller, M. H., Arabi, Y. M., Loeb, M., Gong, M. N., Fan, E., Oczkowski, S., Levy, M. M., Derde, L., Dzierba, A., et al. (2020) · Critical Care Medicine · doi:10.1097/ccm.0000000000004363 · Cited by 1,565
Particle Sizes of Infectious Aerosols: Implications for Infection Control
Fennelly, K. P. (2020) · The Lancet Respiratory Medicine · doi:10.1016/s2213-2600(20)30323-4 · Cited by 621
Airborne or Droplet Precautions for Health Workers Treating Coronavirus Disease 2019?
Bahl, P., Doolan, C., de Silva, C., Chughtai, A. A., Bourouiba, L., & MacIntyre, C. R. (2022) · The Journal of Infectious Diseases · doi:10.1093/infdis/jiaa189 · Cited by 513
“We have previously shown that masks do not have clinical efficacy against respiratory infections [43, 44], and that intermittent use of respirators (which depends on HCWs to assess their own risk and use the device Table 2.”
Self-citation
Metadata
- Authors
- MacIntyre, C. R., Wang, Q., Seale, H., Yang, P., Shi, W., Gao, Z., Rahman, B., Zhang, Y., Wang, X., Newall, A. T., Heywood, A., & Dwyer, D. E.
- Affiliations
- UNSW Sydney (AU)
- Beijing Center for Disease Prevention and Control (CN)
- Westmead Hospital (AU)
- Corresponding author
- MacIntyre, C. Raina
- ORCID
- Venue
- American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine
- Publisher
- Oxford University Press (OUP)
- Published
- 2013-05-01
- Volume
- 187
- Issue
- 9
- Pages
- 960-966
- ISSN
- 1073-449X (ISSN-L)
- 1535-4970
- OpenAlex
- W2106589588
- Cited by
- 189
- References
- 44
- Citations by year
- 2026: 3 · 2025: 3 · 2024: 15 · 2023: 17 · 2022: 17 · 2021: 28 · 2020: 59 · 2019: 5 · 2018: 2 · 2017: 6 · 2016: 8 · 2015: 10 · 2014: 11 · 2013: 5
- FWCI
- 9.21
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- closed
- Locations
- American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine (publishedVersion)
- PubMed (publishedVersion)
- Topics
- Health Sciences › Medicine › Pulmonary and Respiratory Medicine › Infection Control and Ventilation
- Health Sciences › Medicine › Infectious Diseases › Infection Control in Healthcare
- Health Sciences › Medicine › Critical Care and Intensive Care Medicine › Nosocomial Infections in ICU
- Keywords
- N95 respirators, surgical masks, healthcare workers, respiratory diseases, occupational respiratory protection, barrier nursing, 2009 H1N1 pandemic, occupational health policy
- MeSH terms
- Adult, China, Female, Health Personnel, Humans, Male, Masks, Middle Aged, Respiratory Protective Devices, Respiratory Tract Infections, Cluster Analysis, Proportional Hazards Models, Occupational Exposure, Infection Control, Kaplan-Meier Estimate, Tertiary Care Centers
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.