Student or educator? Sign up with your school email and get 6 months of Pro free.
CoChat

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 82 of the 82 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

Comparative analyses of CTCF and BORIS occupancies uncover two distinct classes of CTCF binding genomic regions

Open access

Abstract

BACKGROUND: CTCF and BORIS (CTCFL), two paralogous mammalian proteins sharing nearly identical DNA binding domains, are thought to function in a mutually exclusive manner in DNA binding and transcriptional regulation. RESULTS: Here we show that these two proteins co-occupy a specific subset of regulatory elements consisting of clustered CTCF binding motifs (termed 2xCTSes). BORIS occupancy at 2xCTSes is largely invariant in BORIS-positive cancer cells, with the genomic pattern recapitulating the germline-specific BORIS binding to chromatin. In contrast to the single-motif CTCF target sites (1xCTSes), the 2xCTS elements are preferentially found at active promoters and enhancers, both in cancer and germ cells. 2xCTSes are also enriched in genomic regions that escape histone to protamine replacement in human and mouse sperm. Depletion of the BORIS gene leads to altered transcription of a large number of genes and the differentiation of K562 cells, while the ectopic expression of this CTCF paralog leads to specific changes in transcription in MCF7 cells. CONCLUSIONS: We discover two functionally and structurally different classes of CTCF binding regions, 2xCTSes and 1xCTSes, revealed by their predisposition to bind BORIS. We propose that 2xCTSes play key roles in the transcriptional program of cancer and germ cells.

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1186/s13059-015-0736-8

Cites

82 of 82 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Figures

Fig. 1 Genomic profiling of CTCF and BORIS occupancy in human cancer cells. a Schematic representation of CTCF and BORIS zinc fingers (ZF) shows the four essential amino acids involved in DNA recognition for each ZF. The amino acids of BORIS that differ from CTCF are highlighted in red. The numbers between ZFs show linker length. b Electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA) with increasing amount of full-length BORIS protein (left panel) and unprogrammed TNT (right panel) on the background of a constant level of full-length CTCF protein. The fourth CTCF binding site out of seven mapped in the H19-IGF2 imprinting control region (ICR) was used as the labeled probe. c, d Gene tracks show the distribution of CTCF (red) and BORIS (blue) bound regions in the K562 cell line (c) and in cell lines K562, Delta47, OVCAR8, and normal human dermal fibroblasts (NHDFs) (d). The molecules against which antibodies were directed and cell lines used in ChIP-seq are shown on the left. The number of tags per one million of mapped reads is indicated. The gray frames and arrows show CTCF-only, CTCF&BORIS and BORIS-only bound regions. e–h Heatmaps depict CTCF (red) and BORIS (blue) occupancy in NHDFs (e), K562 (f), OVCAR8 (g) and Delta47 (h) cells. e Heatmap shows the absence of BORIS occupancy at CTCF bound regions mapped in BORIS-negative NHDFs. f The genome-wide overlapping of CTCF- and BORIS-bound regions mapped in K562 cells is shown on the left side of the heatmap. The overlapping of CTCF and BORIS occupancy was done independently for each cell type. The tag density of CTCF and BORIS ChIP-seq data was collected within a 10-kb window around the summit of CTCF (CTCF&BORIS and CTCF-only) and BORIS peaks (BORIS-only). The collected data were subjected to k-means clustering using linear normalization based on similar tag density profiles. The molecules against which antibodies were directed in ChIP-seq are listed on top of the heat map. i Heatmap shows the enrichment of ChIP-Re-ChIP tag density at CTCF&BORIS-bound regions. ChIP-Re-ChIP occupancy (purple) is presented in comparison with CTCF (red) and BORIS (blue) ChIP-seq data for Delta47 cells. The tag density was subjected to k-means ranked clustering with two clusters expected
Fig. 1 Genomic profiling of CTCF and BORIS occupancy in human cancer cells. a Schematic representation of CTCF and BORIS zinc fingers (ZF) shows the four essential amino acids involved in DNA recognition for each ZF. The amino acids of BORIS that differ from CTCF are highlighted in red. The numbers between ZFs show linker length. b Electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA) with increasing amount of full-length BORIS protein (left panel) and unprogrammed TNT (right panel) on the background of a constant level of full-length CTCF protein. The fourth CTCF binding site out of seven mapped in the H19-IGF2 imprinting control region (ICR) was used as the labeled probe. c, d Gene tracks show the distribution of CTCF (red) and BORIS (blue) bound regions in the K562 cell line (c) and in cell lines K562, Delta47, OVCAR8, and normal human dermal fibroblasts (NHDFs) (d). The molecules against which antibodies were directed and cell lines used in ChIP-seq are shown on the left. The number of tags per one million of mapped reads is indicated. The gray frames and arrows show CTCF-only, CTCF&BORIS and BORIS-only bound regions. e–h Heatmaps depict CTCF (red) and BORIS (blue) occupancy in NHDFs (e), K562 (f), OVCAR8 (g) and Delta47 (h) cells. e Heatmap shows the absence of BORIS occupancy at CTCF bound regions mapped in BORIS-negative NHDFs. f The genome-wide overlapping of CTCF- and BORIS-bound regions mapped in K562 cells is shown on the left side of the heatmap. The overlapping of CTCF and BORIS occupancy was done independently for each cell type. The tag density of CTCF and BORIS ChIP-seq data was collected within a 10-kb window around the summit of CTCF (CTCF&BORIS and CTCF-only) and BORIS peaks (BORIS-only). The collected data were subjected to k-means clustering using linear normalization based on similar tag density profiles. The molecules against which antibodies were directed in ChIP-seq are listed on top of the heat map. i Heatmap shows the enrichment of ChIP-Re-ChIP tag density at CTCF&BORIS-bound regions. ChIP-Re-ChIP occupancy (purple) is presented in comparison with CTCF (red) and BORIS (blue) ChIP-seq data for Delta47 cells. The tag density was subjected to k-means ranked clustering with two clusters expectedCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 2 CTCF&BORIS bound regions enclose at least two closely located CTCF binding sites. a Upper panel: gene track represents CTCF (red) and BORIS (blue) binding at the TSP50 (PRSS50) promoter in K562 cells. Lower panel: the alignment of human and mouse sequences under the summit of CTCF (red nucleotide) and BORIS (blue nucleotide) peaks mapped by ChIP-seq at the TSP50 promoter. Two CTCF core motifs (shown on the top of the alignment) coincide with two CTCF binding sites (site1 and site2) previously identified by EMSA and methylation interference assay (MIA) [32] in both mouse and human TSP50 promoters (labeled and underlined at the bottom of the alignment). Asterisks denote the contact guanines mapped by MIA. The space between the two CTCF binding motifs in human and mouse TSP50 promoters varies from 33 bp to 58 bp (shown by brackets). The phastCons conservation track shows the high conservation of two CTCF sites in the TSP50 promoter among 100 vertebrates. The black arrow shows the beginning of TSP50 transcription. b The percentage of CTCF-only, CTCF&BORIS and BORIS-only peaks with two or more CTCF motifs. The top 1000 CTCF-only, CTCF&BORIS and BORIS-only binding regions (invariant in three cancer cell lines) were selected for analysis. The presence of a CTCF motif was calculated by FIMO (MEME suite) in the sequence extended 100 bp upstream and downstream of the summit of either CTCF (CTCF-only and CTCF&BORIS) or BORIS (BORIS-only) peaks. Each CTCF motif occurrence has a p value < 0.0001. c Upper panel: EMSA with five CTCF&BORIS (blue bracket) and four CTCF-only (red bracket) binding regions. The ~200-bp 32P-labeled probes were incubated with either in vitro translated luciferase (−) or with the 11 ZF domain of CTCF (+). The slower (shown by arrow with two red dots) and faster (arrow with one red dot) migrating shifted bands correspond to CTCF binding to two CTCF sites at once or to one CTCF site, respectively (double and single occupancy). Lower panel: genome browser view of CTCF and BORIS occupancy in K562 and Delta47 cells at nine DNA sequences used in the EMSA. The brackets show the connection between upper and lower panels. ChIP-seq data are shown in combination with ChIP-Re-ChIP-seq data for K562 and Delta47 cells. ChIP-seq tracks are labeled with the molecule against which antibodies were directed and the cell line used. d First row: individual examples of 1xCTS and 2xCTS, differentially occupied by CTCF and BORIS in BORIS-positive (K562) and BORIS-negative (NHDF) cells. CTCF and BORIS ChIP-seq data are combined with digital genomic footprinting (DGF, ENCODE data) and phastCons46 conservation scores. The core 20-bp CTCF motif is marked by a grey box. Second row: heatmaps show DNaseI cleavage density at thousands of 1xCTSes (single CTCF motif on plus strand) and at hundreds of 2xCTSes (two CTCF motifs separated by a 30–40-bp linker, both on the minus strand). The tag density data were collected within a 300-bp window around the first (left) 20-bp CTCF core motifs (0) under a single CTCF ChIP-seq peak. Third row: average phastCons46 conservation score at 1xCTSes and 2xCTSes, the same genomic regions as in the second row. Fourth row: model of CTCF and BORIS differential occupancy in NHDF and K562 cells. 1xCTSes are occupied by CTCF monomer in both BORIS-positive and BORIS-negative cells, while 2xCTSes are co-occupied by CTCF and BORIS in BORIS-positive cells or by CTCF homodimer in BORIS-negative cells
Fig. 2 CTCF&BORIS bound regions enclose at least two closely located CTCF binding sites. a Upper panel: gene track represents CTCF (red) and BORIS (blue) binding at the TSP50 (PRSS50) promoter in K562 cells. Lower panel: the alignment of human and mouse sequences under the summit of CTCF (red nucleotide) and BORIS (blue nucleotide) peaks mapped by ChIP-seq at the TSP50 promoter. Two CTCF core motifs (shown on the top of the alignment) coincide with two CTCF binding sites (site1 and site2) previously identified by EMSA and methylation interference assay (MIA) [32] in both mouse and human TSP50 promoters (labeled and underlined at the bottom of the alignment). Asterisks denote the contact guanines mapped by MIA. The space between the two CTCF binding motifs in human and mouse TSP50 promoters varies from 33 bp to 58 bp (shown by brackets). The phastCons conservation track shows the high conservation of two CTCF sites in the TSP50 promoter among 100 vertebrates. The black arrow shows the beginning of TSP50 transcription. b The percentage of CTCF-only, CTCF&BORIS and BORIS-only peaks with two or more CTCF motifs. The top 1000 CTCF-only, CTCF&BORIS and BORIS-only binding regions (invariant in three cancer cell lines) were selected for analysis. The presence of a CTCF motif was calculated by FIMO (MEME suite) in the sequence extended 100 bp upstream and downstream of the summit of either CTCF (CTCF-only and CTCF&BORIS) or BORIS (BORIS-only) peaks. Each CTCF motif occurrence has a p value < 0.0001. c Upper panel: EMSA with five CTCF&BORIS (blue bracket) and four CTCF-only (red bracket) binding regions. The ~200-bp 32P-labeled probes were incubated with either in vitro translated luciferase (−) or with the 11 ZF domain of CTCF (+). The slower (shown by arrow with two red dots) and faster (arrow with one red dot) migrating shifted bands correspond to CTCF binding to two CTCF sites at once or to one CTCF site, respectively (double and single occupancy). Lower panel: genome browser view of CTCF and BORIS occupancy in K562 and Delta47 cells at nine DNA sequences used in the EMSA. The brackets show the connection between upper and lower panels. ChIP-seq data are shown in combination with ChIP-Re-ChIP-seq data for K562 and Delta47 cells. ChIP-seq tracks are labeled with the molecule against which antibodies were directed and the cell line used. d First row: individual examples of 1xCTS and 2xCTS, differentially occupied by CTCF and BORIS in BORIS-positive (K562) and BORIS-negative (NHDF) cells. CTCF and BORIS ChIP-seq data are combined with digital genomic footprinting (DGF, ENCODE data) and phastCons46 conservation scores. The core 20-bp CTCF motif is marked by a grey box. Second row: heatmaps show DNaseI cleavage density at thousands of 1xCTSes (single CTCF motif on plus strand) and at hundreds of 2xCTSes (two CTCF motifs separated by a 30–40-bp linker, both on the minus strand). The tag density data were collected within a 300-bp window around the first (left) 20-bp CTCF core motifs (0) under a single CTCF ChIP-seq peak. Third row: average phastCons46 conservation score at 1xCTSes and 2xCTSes, the same genomic regions as in the second row. Fourth row: model of CTCF and BORIS differential occupancy in NHDF and K562 cells. 1xCTSes are occupied by CTCF monomer in both BORIS-positive and BORIS-negative cells, while 2xCTSes are co-occupied by CTCF and BORIS in BORIS-positive cells or by CTCF homodimer in BORIS-negative cellsCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 3 CTCF and BORIS interact at CTCF&BORIS bound regions. a ChIP-seq does not resolve the two closely spaced CTCF binding sites at CTCF&BORIS bound regions: no enrichment of reads between two CTCF binding sites (black dots) in the middle panel compared with the right panel with two CTCF binding regions resolved by ChIP-seq. b Western blot demonstrates co-immunoprecipitation of CTCF and BORIS complexes: K562 nuclear lysates were immunoprecipitated with IgG, anti-CTCF and anti-BORIS antibodies. Precipitated complexes were probed with CTCF antibodies. The lysates were either untreated (−) or treated (+) with ethidium bromide (EtBr) before co-immunoprecipitation. c, d In situ proximity ligation assay (ISPLA) shows the close proximity between CTCF and BORIS proteins in BORIS-positive cells: ovarian cancer cells (OVCAR8) (c) and human testis tissue (d). e A 200-bp 32P-labeled probe representing human TP53 promoter (2xCTS, the palindromic orientation of CTCF motifs shown by arrows) was incubated with increasing concentrations of the 11 ZF domain of CTCF (11ZFs, left and middle panels) or Pichia recombinant full-length CTCF (FL CTCF, right panel). The 2xCTS was used in EMSA either as wild type with two CTCF binding sites (grey boxes) or as the mutant type with one CTCF mutated site (red cross). The model of 11 ZFs and full-length CTCF occupancies are shown by arrows and red dots (CTCF molecules). f A 200-bp 32P-labeled probe representing IRF2BP1 3’ untranslated region (UTR) was incubated with nuclear extracts (n.e.) from either K562 or NHDF cells. All lanes contain the indicated nuclear extract, except the first lane for K562, where only free probe is present. Nuclear extracts and probe were also incubated with either control mouse IgG (−), antibodies against CTCF or BORIS. The red and blue arrows point to the super-shifted bands corresponding to CTCF–DNA and BORIS–DNA complexes, respectively. NHDF nuclear extract did not produce a super-shift band with anti-BORIS antibodies. g Gene tracks show that exogenous BORIS expression in MCF7 cells (MCF7 + BORIS) recapitulates endogenous BORIS occupancy in OVCAR8 cells. The name of the molecules against which antibodies were directed and the cell lines used in ChIP-seq are shown in the tracks. h Heatmap of BORIS (blue) occupancy at 50,000 CTCF peaks invariantly mapped in both OVCAR8 and MCF7 + BORIS cells. The tag density was subjected to k-means ranked clustering with two clusters expected. i ISPLA in BORIS-negative MCF7 cells stably transfected with either empty vector (MCF7+EV) or BORIS (MCF7+BORIS). The specific positive ISPLA signal (red) is present only in MCF7 cells transfected with BORIS-expressing vector
Fig. 3 CTCF and BORIS interact at CTCF&BORIS bound regions. a ChIP-seq does not resolve the two closely spaced CTCF binding sites at CTCF&BORIS bound regions: no enrichment of reads between two CTCF binding sites (black dots) in the middle panel compared with the right panel with two CTCF binding regions resolved by ChIP-seq. b Western blot demonstrates co-immunoprecipitation of CTCF and BORIS complexes: K562 nuclear lysates were immunoprecipitated with IgG, anti-CTCF and anti-BORIS antibodies. Precipitated complexes were probed with CTCF antibodies. The lysates were either untreated (−) or treated (+) with ethidium bromide (EtBr) before co-immunoprecipitation. c, d In situ proximity ligation assay (ISPLA) shows the close proximity between CTCF and BORIS proteins in BORIS-positive cells: ovarian cancer cells (OVCAR8) (c) and human testis tissue (d). e A 200-bp 32P-labeled probe representing human TP53 promoter (2xCTS, the palindromic orientation of CTCF motifs shown by arrows) was incubated with increasing concentrations of the 11 ZF domain of CTCF (11ZFs, left and middle panels) or Pichia recombinant full-length CTCF (FL CTCF, right panel). The 2xCTS was used in EMSA either as wild type with two CTCF binding sites (grey boxes) or as the mutant type with one CTCF mutated site (red cross). The model of 11 ZFs and full-length CTCF occupancies are shown by arrows and red dots (CTCF molecules). f A 200-bp 32P-labeled probe representing IRF2BP1 3’ untranslated region (UTR) was incubated with nuclear extracts (n.e.) from either K562 or NHDF cells. All lanes contain the indicated nuclear extract, except the first lane for K562, where only free probe is present. Nuclear extracts and probe were also incubated with either control mouse IgG (−), antibodies against CTCF or BORIS. The red and blue arrows point to the super-shifted bands corresponding to CTCF–DNA and BORIS–DNA complexes, respectively. NHDF nuclear extract did not produce a super-shift band with anti-BORIS antibodies. g Gene tracks show that exogenous BORIS expression in MCF7 cells (MCF7 + BORIS) recapitulates endogenous BORIS occupancy in OVCAR8 cells. The name of the molecules against which antibodies were directed and the cell lines used in ChIP-seq are shown in the tracks. h Heatmap of BORIS (blue) occupancy at 50,000 CTCF peaks invariantly mapped in both OVCAR8 and MCF7 + BORIS cells. The tag density was subjected to k-means ranked clustering with two clusters expected. i ISPLA in BORIS-negative MCF7 cells stably transfected with either empty vector (MCF7+EV) or BORIS (MCF7+BORIS). The specific positive ISPLA signal (red) is present only in MCF7 cells transfected with BORIS-expressing vectorCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 4 1xCTSes and 2xCTSes are associated with different epigenetic landscapes in both BORIS-positive (K562) and BORIS-negative (GM12878) cells. a Gene tracks show the association of CTCF and BORIS bound regions in K562 cells with multiple ENCODE ChIP-seq data. The tracks are labeled with the names of molecules against which antibodies were directed for ChIP-seq. The gray frames highlight CTCF-only, CTCF&BORIS and BORIS-only bound regions. b Average tag density (tags/10 million) of multiple factors mapped by ChIP-seq in K562 cells (ENCODE data) across BORIS-only (blue), CTCF-only (red) and CTCF&BORIS (purple) bound regions mapped in K562 cells. The data were normalized to the number of mapped reads and binding regions. The names of factors used in ChIP-seq are labeled on the top of each plot. RNAPII RNA polymerase II. c Heatmap demonstrates the difference between 1xCTSes and 2xCTSes with respect to the enrichment of RNAPII, CAGEs, H3K4me3, H2AZ, H3K27ac, ZNF143, and SMC3 ChIP-seq tag density at two types of CTCF binding classes in BORIS-negative cells (GM12878)
Fig. 4 1xCTSes and 2xCTSes are associated with different epigenetic landscapes in both BORIS-positive (K562) and BORIS-negative (GM12878) cells. a Gene tracks show the association of CTCF and BORIS bound regions in K562 cells with multiple ENCODE ChIP-seq data. The tracks are labeled with the names of molecules against which antibodies were directed for ChIP-seq. The gray frames highlight CTCF-only, CTCF&BORIS and BORIS-only bound regions. b Average tag density (tags/10 million) of multiple factors mapped by ChIP-seq in K562 cells (ENCODE data) across BORIS-only (blue), CTCF-only (red) and CTCF&BORIS (purple) bound regions mapped in K562 cells. The data were normalized to the number of mapped reads and binding regions. The names of factors used in ChIP-seq are labeled on the top of each plot. RNAPII RNA polymerase II. c Heatmap demonstrates the difference between 1xCTSes and 2xCTSes with respect to the enrichment of RNAPII, CAGEs, H3K4me3, H2AZ, H3K27ac, ZNF143, and SMC3 ChIP-seq tag density at two types of CTCF binding classes in BORIS-negative cells (GM12878)CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 5 Genomic profiling of CTCF and BORIS occupancy in mouse germ cells. a Overlapping of CTCF (red) and BORIS (blue) genomic occupancy in mouse round spermatids. b Histogram indicates the percentage of conserved mouse CTCF and BORIS bound regions in the human genome. c Average tag density of CTCF (red) and BORIS (blue) occupancy in K562 cells across the conserved mouse binding regions from (b). d Gene tracks of CTCF and BORIS occupancy at the Tsp50/TSP50 (Prss50/PRSS50) gene in mouse (round spermatids) and human (K562) cells. e Average tag density (tags/10 million) of RNAPII, H3K4me3, and H3K27ac mapped by ChIP-seq in mouse testis (ENCODE data) across BORIS-only (blue), CTCF-only (red) and CTCF&BORIS (purple) bound regions mapped in mouse round spermatids. The data were normalized to the number of mapped reads and binding regions
Fig. 5 Genomic profiling of CTCF and BORIS occupancy in mouse germ cells. a Overlapping of CTCF (red) and BORIS (blue) genomic occupancy in mouse round spermatids. b Histogram indicates the percentage of conserved mouse CTCF and BORIS bound regions in the human genome. c Average tag density of CTCF (red) and BORIS (blue) occupancy in K562 cells across the conserved mouse binding regions from (b). d Gene tracks of CTCF and BORIS occupancy at the Tsp50/TSP50 (Prss50/PRSS50) gene in mouse (round spermatids) and human (K562) cells. e Average tag density (tags/10 million) of RNAPII, H3K4me3, and H3K27ac mapped by ChIP-seq in mouse testis (ENCODE data) across BORIS-only (blue), CTCF-only (red) and CTCF&BORIS (purple) bound regions mapped in mouse round spermatids. The data were normalized to the number of mapped reads and binding regionsCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 6 CTCF and BORIS interactions are essential for transcriptional regulation in cancers. a Two models are used in the study: K562 cells (BORIS+/+) treated with zinc finger nuclease (ZFN) to knockout/downregulate the BORIS gene (BORIS+/−) and MCF7 cells with stably transfected empty vector (MCF7+EV) or BORIS-expressing vector (MCF7+BORIS). Upon stable change of BORIS expression (western blot) both types of cells showed phenotypic changes. b Western blot analysis of K562 cells (mass culture) upon BORIS depletion by ZFN (before ZFN (wt), 48 h, and two weeks after ZFN). c Number of K562 single-cell clones growing in soft agar after ZFN transfection (ZFN) compared with untransfected cells (Control). d Expression of megakaryocytic lineage markers in three independent single-cell K562 clones after ZFN treatment compared with wild type (wt). e, f Fold changes (log2) in gene expression in response to BORIS depletion in K562 cells (e) and BORIS induction in MCF7 cells (f). Two independent single-cell clones of MCF7 cells with stably expressed BORIS were analyzed (f). Top associated diseases and bio functions (p < 0.0001) are shown for upregulated (red) and downregulated (green) genes on the right (Ingenuity Pathway Analysis). The genes that change expression in a similar way in both independent MCF7 clones with stably transfected BORIS are shown on the heat map (f). g Heat map showing the comparison of genes that changed expression upon BORIS depletion (K562 cells) and BORIS induction (MCF7 cells, clone1) in respect to diseases and bio functions (activation z-score). h Genome browser view of six CTCF&BORIS target genes. The tracks are labeled with the names of molecules against which antibodies were directed and the cell lines used in ChIP-seq, respectively. The red arrows show the beginning and direction of transcription. The schematic occupancy of promoters with either CTCF (red) and BORIS (blue) heterodimers or CTCF homodimer is shown on the right. i Expression of six CTCF&BORIS targets from panel (h) was analyzed by quantitative PCR in cells with upregulated (MCF7+BORIS) and downregulated BORIS (BORIS small interference RNA (si) treatment of K562 cells, mass culture) expression. Asterisk (*) represents p-value <0.05 and double-asterisk (**) represents p-value <0.01 between treated and untreated cells (c, i). Error bars represent standard deviation of the average of triplicate measurements (c, d, i). TSS transcription start site
Fig. 6 CTCF and BORIS interactions are essential for transcriptional regulation in cancers. a Two models are used in the study: K562 cells (BORIS+/+) treated with zinc finger nuclease (ZFN) to knockout/downregulate the BORIS gene (BORIS+/−) and MCF7 cells with stably transfected empty vector (MCF7+EV) or BORIS-expressing vector (MCF7+BORIS). Upon stable change of BORIS expression (western blot) both types of cells showed phenotypic changes. b Western blot analysis of K562 cells (mass culture) upon BORIS depletion by ZFN (before ZFN (wt), 48 h, and two weeks after ZFN). c Number of K562 single-cell clones growing in soft agar after ZFN transfection (ZFN) compared with untransfected cells (Control). d Expression of megakaryocytic lineage markers in three independent single-cell K562 clones after ZFN treatment compared with wild type (wt). e, f Fold changes (log2) in gene expression in response to BORIS depletion in K562 cells (e) and BORIS induction in MCF7 cells (f). Two independent single-cell clones of MCF7 cells with stably expressed BORIS were analyzed (f). Top associated diseases and bio functions (p < 0.0001) are shown for upregulated (red) and downregulated (green) genes on the right (Ingenuity Pathway Analysis). The genes that change expression in a similar way in both independent MCF7 clones with stably transfected BORIS are shown on the heat map (f). g Heat map showing the comparison of genes that changed expression upon BORIS depletion (K562 cells) and BORIS induction (MCF7 cells, clone1) in respect to diseases and bio functions (activation z-score). h Genome browser view of six CTCF&BORIS target genes. The tracks are labeled with the names of molecules against which antibodies were directed and the cell lines used in ChIP-seq, respectively. The red arrows show the beginning and direction of transcription. The schematic occupancy of promoters with either CTCF (red) and BORIS (blue) heterodimers or CTCF homodimer is shown on the right. i Expression of six CTCF&BORIS targets from panel (h) was analyzed by quantitative PCR in cells with upregulated (MCF7+BORIS) and downregulated BORIS (BORIS small interference RNA (si) treatment of K562 cells, mass culture) expression. Asterisk (*) represents p-value <0.05 and double-asterisk (**) represents p-value <0.01 between treated and untreated cells (c, i). Error bars represent standard deviation of the average of triplicate measurements (c, d, i). TSS transcription start siteCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 7 BORIS bound regions correlate with histone retention in human and mouse sperm. a Gene tracks show the distribution of histones retained in human sperm in association with CTCF and BORIS bound regions, mapped in K562, Delta47 and OVCAR8 cell lines. The name of the molecules against which antibodies were directed and the cell lines used in ChIP-seq are shown on the left. b Heatmap indicates the enrichment of histones retained in human sperm at 2xCTS regions (invariant BORIS binding in K562, OVCAR8, and Delta47). c, d Average tag density (tags/10 million) of histones retained in human (c) and mouse (d) sperm across BORIS-only (blue), CTCF-only (red) and CTCF&BORIS (purple) bound regions mapped in K562 cells (c) and mouse round spermatids (d). The data were normalized to the number of mapped reads and binding regions
Fig. 7 BORIS bound regions correlate with histone retention in human and mouse sperm. a Gene tracks show the distribution of histones retained in human sperm in association with CTCF and BORIS bound regions, mapped in K562, Delta47 and OVCAR8 cell lines. The name of the molecules against which antibodies were directed and the cell lines used in ChIP-seq are shown on the left. b Heatmap indicates the enrichment of histones retained in human sperm at 2xCTS regions (invariant BORIS binding in K562, OVCAR8, and Delta47). c, d Average tag density (tags/10 million) of histones retained in human (c) and mouse (d) sperm across BORIS-only (blue), CTCF-only (red) and CTCF&BORIS (purple) bound regions mapped in K562 cells (c) and mouse round spermatids (d). The data were normalized to the number of mapped reads and binding regionsCC BY · PubMed Central

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Claims other papers make about this one

Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Citations

Cites

Show all 82 references

Cited by

See all 110

Metadata

Authors
Pugacheva, E. M., Rivero-Hinojosa, S., Espinoza, C. A., Méndez-Catalá, C. F., Kang, S., Suzuki, T., Kosaka-Suzuki, N., Robinson, S., Nagarajan, V., Ye, Z., Boukaba, A., Rasko, J. E. J., Strunnikov, A. V., Loukinov, D., Ren, B., & Lobanenkov, V. V.
Affiliations
  • National Institutes of Health (US)
  • University of California San Diego (US)
  • Ludwig Cancer Research (US)
  • Guangzhou Institutes of Biomedicine and Health (CN)
  • The University of Sydney (AU)
  • Ludwig Cancer Research (BE)
Corresponding author
  • Ren, Bing
  • Lobanenkov, Victor V.
Venue
Genome biology
Published
2015-08-14
Volume
16
Issue
1
Pages
161-161
ISSN
  • 1465-6906 (ISSN-L)
  • 1474-760X
OpenAlex
W2163068365
Cited by
110
References
82
Citations by year
2026: 5 · 2025: 9 · 2024: 6 · 2023: 9 · 2022: 10 · 2021: 14 · 2020: 17 · 2019: 10 · 2018: 10 · 2017: 11 · 2016: 6 · 2015: 3
FWCI
4.34
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Licence
Locations
  • Genome biology (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • Europe PMC (PubMed Central) (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
  • eScholarship (California Digital Library) (submittedVersion)
  • eScholarship (California Digital Library) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
Funders
  • Division of Intramural Research, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (ᅟ)
  • Ludwig Institute for Cancer Research, California Institute of Regenerative Medicine (RN2-00905)
  • National Institutes of Health (P50 GM085764-03 and U01 ES017166)
  • Cancer Council NSW (RG11-12; RG14-05; RG14-09)
Topics
  • Life Sciences › Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology › Molecular Biology › Genomics and Chromatin Dynamics
  • Life Sciences › Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology › Molecular Biology › Epigenetics and DNA Methylation
  • Life Sciences › Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology › Molecular Biology › Chromatin Remodeling and Cancer
Keywords
CTCF, BORIS, CTCFL, CTCF binding motifs, transcriptional regulation, enhancers, promoter, sperm chromatin, germ cells, cancer cells, MCF-7 cells
MeSH terms
CCCTC-Binding Factor, Animals, Binding Sites, Cell Line, Chromatin, DNA, DNA-Binding Proteins, Enhancer Elements, Genetic, Humans, Male, Neoplasms, Promoter Regions, Genetic, Protein Binding, Repressor Proteins, Spermatids, Spermatozoa, Transcription, Genetic, Genome, K562 Cells, Mice, Nucleotide Motifs

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Comparative analyses of CTCF and BORIS occupancies uncover two distinct classes of CTCF binding genomic regions. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1186/s13059-015-0736-8
The paper
Pugacheva, E. M., Rivero-Hinojosa, S., Espinoza, C. A., Méndez-Catalá, C. F., Kang, S., Suzuki, T., Kosaka-Suzuki, N., Robinson, S., Nagarajan, V., Ye, Z., Boukaba, A., Rasko, J. E. J., Strunnikov, A. V., Loukinov, D., Ren, B., & Lobanenkov, V. V. (2015). Comparative analyses of CTCF and BORIS occupancies uncover two distinct classes of CTCF binding genomic regions. Genome biology. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13059-015-0736-8

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.