Systematic review and meta-analysis of bifrontal electroconvulsive therapy versus bilateral and unilateral electroconvulsive therapy in depression
The DOI matches its Crossref record; 13 of the 13 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Our aim was to perform a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials comparing efficacy and side effects of bifrontal (BF) ECT to bitemporal (BT) or unilateral (RUL) ECT in depression. METHODS: We performed a systematic review of randomized controlled trials comparing BF ECT with RUL or BT ECT in depression. Eight trials (n=617) reported some cognitive outcome. Efficacy was measured by reduction in Hamilton Depression Rating Scale score. Cognitive outcomes were limited to Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) in seven studies, with two studies measuring each of: Complex-figure delayed recall, Trail-making tests and verbal learning. RESULTS: Efficacy was equal between BF and BT ECT (Hedges's g=0.102, P=0.345, confidence interval (CI): -0.110, 0.313) and BF and RUL ECT (standardized mean difference=-0.12, P=0.365, CI: -0.378, 0.139). Post-treatment MMSE score decline was less for BF than BT ECT (g=0.89, CI: 0.054, 1.724) but not RUL ECT. RUL ECT impaired Complex figure recall more than BF ECT (g=0.76, CI :0.487, 1.035), but BF ECT impaired word recall more than RUL ECT (g=-1.45, CI: -2.75, -0.15). CONCLUSIONS: Bifrontal ECT is not more effective than BT or RUL ECT but may have modest short-term benefits for specific memory domains. BF ECT has potential advantages, but given longer experience with BT and RUL, bifrontal ECT requires better characterization.
Overview
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Self-check
Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.
The self-check needs the paper’s full text.
Citations
Cites
Estimating the mean and variance from the median, range, and the size of a sample
Hozo, S. P., Djulbegovic, B., & Hozo, I. (2005) · BMC Medical Research Methodology · doi:10.1186/1471-2288-5-13 · Cited by 9,062
Distribution Theory for Glass's Estimator of Effect Size and Related Estimators
Hedges, L. V. (1981) · Journal of Educational Statistics · doi:10.2307/1164588 · Cited by 5,695 · cited 1×
“Reported effect sizes for effi cacy and cognitive outcomes were converted to “ Hedges ’ s g ” where possible in order to meaningfully compare the magnitude of effects across differing versions of the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HDRS) (Hamilton 1960; Hedges 1981).”
MethodLopez, A. D., Mathers, C. D., Ezzati, M., Jamison, D. T., & Murray, C. J. (2006) · The Lancet · doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(06)68770-9 · Cited by 5,630
The Handbook of Research Synthesis and Meta-Analysis
(2019) · doi:10.7758/9781610448864 · Cited by 4,553
(2003) · The Lancet · doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(03)12705-5 · Cited by 1,706
A brief cognitive test battery to differentiate Alzheimer's disease and frontotemporal dementia
Mathuranath, P. S., Nestor, P. J., Berrios, G. E., Rakowicz, W., & Hodges, J. R. (2000) · Neurology · doi:10.1212/01.wnl.0000434309.85312.19 · Cited by 1,029 · cited 1×
“This test is not particularly sensitive to frontal-executive decline in dementing patients (Mathuranath et al. 2000) and provides only an overall score which cannot localize function to particular cognitive domains.”
BackgroundSackeim, H. A., Prudic, J., Nobler, M. S., Fitzsimons, L., Lisanby, S. H., Payne, N., Berman, R. M., Brakemeier, E.-L., Perera, T., & Devanand, D. P. (2008) · Brain Stimulation · doi:10.1016/j.brs.2008.03.001 · Cited by 542
Electroconvulsive Therapy for Depression
Lisanby, S. H. (2007) · New England Journal of Medicine · doi:10.1056/nejmct075234 · Cited by 503
Bifrontal, bitemporal and right unilateral electrode placement in ECT: randomised trial
Kellner, C. H., Knapp, R., Husain, M. M., Rasmussen, K., Sampson, S., Cullum, M., McClintock, S. M., Tobias, K. G., Martino, C., Mueller, M., et al. (2010) · British Journal of Psychiatry · doi:10.1192/bjp.bp.109.066183 · Cited by 432 · cited 22×
“However, whereas both of these studies measured phonemic fl uency – the ability to generate words beginning with the same letter – only one (Kellner et al. 2010) tested category fl uency (Fleischmann and Oswald 1986; Benton et al. 1994).”
BackgroundMethodResultInfluentialEranti, S., Mogg, A., Pluck, G., Landau, S., Purvis, R., Brown, R. G., Howard, R., Knapp, M., Philpot, M., Rabe-Hesketh, S., et al. (2007) · American Journal of Psychiatry · doi:10.1176/ajp.2007.164.1.73 · Cited by 188
Self-citationHiremani, R. M., Thirthalli, J., Tharayil, B. S., & Gangadhar, B. N. (2008) · Bipolar Disorders · doi:10.1111/j.1399-5618.2008.00608.x · Cited by 79 · cited 1×
“Our search revealed only two trials evaluating bifrontal ECT in mania (Barekatain et al. 2008; Hiremani et al. 2008).”
BackgroundBorroni, B., Agosti, C., Premi, E., Cerini, C., Cosseddu, M., Paghera, B., Bellelli, G., & Padovani, A. (2010) · European Journal of Neurology · doi:10.1111/j.1468-1331.2009.02911.x · Cited by 65 · cited 1×
“However, we failed to fi nd a signifi cant effect of bifrontal ECT over right unilateral ECT in Trailmaking or verbal fl uency tasks sensitive to frontalexecutive dysfunction (Borroni et al. 2010).”
Bifrontal Versus Bitemporal Electroconvulsive Therapy in Severe Manic Patients
Barekatain, M., Jahangard, L., Haghighi, M., & Ranjkesh, F. (2008) · The Journal of ECT · doi:10.1097/yct.0b013e3181624b5d · Cited by 54 · cited 1×
“Our search revealed only two trials evaluating bifrontal ECT in mania (Barekatain et al. 2008; Hiremani et al. 2008).”
Background
Research works printed but not linked: 48
- Amiri S, 2009, Iranian J Psychiatry, 4, 13
- Bailine SH, 2000, Am J Psychiatry, 157, 121, 10.1176/ajp.157.1.121 · DOI · Paper page
- Benton AL, 1994, Multilingual Aphasia Examination
- Crowley K, 2008, J ECT, 24, 268, 10.1097/YCT.0b013e318168e72c · DOI
- Curran S, 1995, Br J Psychiatry, 167, 821, 10.1192/bjp.167.6.821b · doi:10.1192/bjp.167.6.821b
- d'Elia G, 1970, Acta Psychiatr Scand Suppl, 215, 1
- Eranti SV, 2003, Br J Psychiatry, 182, 8, 10.1192/bjp.182.1.8 · DOI
- Eranti SV, 2009, J Affect Disord, 113, 165, 10.1016/j.jad.2008.03.004 · DOI
- Eschweiler GW, 2007, J Affect Disord, 101, 149, 10.1016/j.jad.2006.11.012 · DOI
- Fleischmann U, 1986, Nürnberger-Alters-Inventar (NAI)-Kurzmanual: Testbeschreibung, Testkriterien, Normwerte
- Folstein MF, 1975, J Psychiatr Res, 12, 189, 10.1016/0022-3956(75)90026-6 · DOI · Paper page
- Gleser LJ, 2009, The handbook of research synthesis and meta-analysis, 358
- Greenhalgh J, 2005, Health Technol Assess, 9, 1, 10.3310/hta9090 · DOI · Paper page
- Hamilton M, 1960, J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry, 23, 56, 10.1136/jnnp.23.1.56 · DOI · Paper page
- Hedges LV, 1981, J Educ Behav Stat, 6, 107, 10.3102/10769986006002107 · doi:10.3102/10769986006002107 · Paper page
- Heikman P, 2002, Right unilateral and bifrontal electroconvulsive therapy in the treatment of depression with special reference to neurophysiological and clinical aspects [Thesis]
- Heikman P, 2002, J ECT, 18, 26, 10.1097/00124509-200203000-00009 · DOI · Paper page
- Higgins JP, 2002, Stat Med, 21, 1539, 10.1002/sim.1186 · DOI · Paper page
- Husain MM, 2004, J Clin Psychiatry, 65, 485, 10.4088/JCP.v65n0406 · DOI · Paper page
- Inglis J, 1970, Br J Psychiatry, 117, 143, 10.1192/S0007125000192827 · DOI
- Ingram F, 1997, Neuropsychiatry Neuropsychol Behav Neurol, 10, 144
- Johnstone EC, 1980, Lancet, 316, 1317, 10.1016/S0140-6736(80)92393-4 · DOI · Paper page
- 10.1001/jama.289.23.3095 · DOI · Paper page
- Knowles FW, 1973, Br J Psychiatry, 123, 376, 10.1192/bjp.123.3.376-a · doi:10.1192/bjp.123.3.376-a
- 10.1080/01688638908400928 · DOI · Paper page
- Kriss A, 1978, J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry, 41, 1135, 10.1136/jnnp.41.12.1135 · DOI · Paper page
- Lambourn J, 1978, Br J Psychiatry, 133, 514, 10.1192/bjp.133.6.514 · DOI · Paper page
- Lancaster NP, 1958, J Ment Sci, 104, 221, 10.1192/bjp.104.434.221 · DOI · Paper page
- Lawson JS, 1990, Psychol Med, 20, 335, 10.1017/S0033291700017645 · DOI · Paper page
- Letemendia FJ, 1993, Psychol Med, 23, 349, 10.1017/S0033291700028452 · DOI · Paper page
- Lezak MD, 2004, Neuropsychological assessment
- Lisanby SH, 2000, Arch Gen Psychiatry, 57, 581, 10.1001/archpsyc.57.6.581 · DOI · Paper page
- McCall WV, 2002, J ECT, 18, 126, 10.1097/00124509-200209000-00003 · DOI · Paper page
- Owen GS, 2008, Br Med J, 337, 448, 10.1136/bmj.39580.546597.BE · DOI · Paper page
- Plakiotis C, 2009, Curr Psychiatry Rev, 5, 202, 10.2174/157340009788971092 · DOI
- Ranjkesh F, 2005, J ECT, 21, 207, 10.1097/01.yct.0000187041.79087.59 · DOI · Paper page
- Reitan RM, 1958, Percept Motor Skills, 8, 271, 10.2466/PMS.8.7.271-276 · DOI
- Rey A, 1964, L'examen clinique en psychologie
- Sackeim HA, 1987, Am J Psychiatry, 144, 1449, 10.1176/ajp.144.11.1449 · DOI · Paper page
- Sackeim HA, 1993, New Engl J Med, 328, 839, 10.1056/NEJM199303253281204 · DOI · Paper page
- Sackeim HA, 2000, Arch Gen Psychiatry, 57, 425, 10.1001/archpsyc.57.5.425 · DOI · Paper page
- Schlotter W, 2005, Short-term antidepressant and cognitive effects of bifrontal versus right unilateral electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) in depressive patients [Thesis]
- Semkovska M, 2010, Biol Psychiatry 68, 568, 577
- Semkovska M, 2011, J Psychiatr Res 45, 770, 80
- Sienaert P, 2009, J Affect Disord, 116, 106, 10.1016/j.jad.2008.11.001 · DOI · Paper page
- Sienaert P, 2010, J Affect Disord, 122, 60, 10.1016/j.jad.2009.06.011 · DOI
- Tharyan P, 2005, Cochrane Database Syst Rev
- 10.1007/s11920-007-0061-3 · DOI · Paper page
Cited by
Galletly, C., Castle, D., Dark, F., Humberstone, V., Jablensky, A., Killackey, E., Kulkarni, J., McGorry, P., Nielssen, O., & Tran, N. (2016) · Australian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry · doi:10.1177/0004867416641195 · Cited by 877
Malhi, G. S., Bassett, D., Boyce, P., Bryant, R., Fitzgerald, P. B., Fritz, K., Hopwood, M., Lyndon, B., Mulder, R., Murray, G., et al. (2015) · Australian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry · doi:10.1177/0004867415617657 · Cited by 842
“Data from early studies (Bailine et al., 2000; Dunne and McLoughlin, 2012; Ranjkesh et al., 2005) and pooled analyses of data from studies comparing bifrontal with unilateral and bitemporal ECT show fewer cognitive side effects for bifrontal ECT compared with bitemporal ECT (Plakiotis and O’Connor, 2009).”
Milev, R. V., Giacobbe, P., Kennedy, S. H., Blumberger, D. M., Daskalakis, Z. J., Downar, J., Modirrousta, M., Patry, S., Vila-Rodriguez, F., Lam, R. W., et al. (2016) · The Canadian Journal of Psychiatry · doi:10.1177/0706743716660033 · Cited by 586
“A meta-analysis (8 trials, N1⁄4 617) found that BT, BF, and RUL have the same efficacy but may adversely affect specific cognitive domains differently.(53) Both BF and RUL ECT are first-line recommendations, but BT is recommended as second line because of higher rates of short-term cognitive adverse effects.”
Parikh, S. V., Quilty, L. C., Ravitz, P., Rosenbluth, M., Pavlova, B., Grigoriadis, S., Velyvis, V., Kennedy, S. H., Lam, R. W., MacQueen, G. M., et al. (2016) · The Canadian Journal of Psychiatry · doi:10.1177/0706743716659418 · Cited by 562
Relapse Following Successful Electroconvulsive Therapy for Major Depression: A Meta-Analysis
Jelovac, A., Kolshus, E., & McLoughlin, D. M. (2013) · Neuropsychopharmacology · doi:10.1038/npp.2013.149 · Cited by 287
Self-citation
Metadata
- Authors
- Dunne, R. A., & McLoughlin, D. M.
- Venue
- The World Journal of Biological Psychiatry
- Publisher
- Informa UK Limited
- Published
- 2011-11-18
- Volume
- 13
- Issue
- 4
- Pages
- 248-258
- ISSN
- 1562-2975 (ISSN-L)
- 1814-1412
- OpenAlex
- W2039528415
- Cited by
- 117
- References
- 13
- FWCI
- 0.64
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- closed
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.