Systematic review and economic modelling of the clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of art therapy among people with non-psychotic mental health disorders
Open accessThe DOI matches its Crossref record; 19 of the 19 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Abstract
Background: Mental health problems account for almost half of all ill health in people under 65 years. The majority are non-psychotic (e.g. depression, anxiety and phobias). For some people, art therapy may provide more profound and long-lasting healing than more standard forms of treatment, perhaps because it can provide an alternative means of expression and release from trauma. As yet, no formal evaluation of art therapy for non-psychotic mental health disorders has been conducted. Aim: This review aimed to evaluate evidence for the clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of art therapy for non-psychotic mental health disorders. Methods: Comprehensive literature searches for studies examining art therapy in populations with non-psychotic mental health disorders were performed in major health-related and social science bibliographic databases including MEDLINE, EMBASE, The Cochrane Library, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL), PsycINFO, Allied and Complementary Medicine Database (AMED) and Applied Social Sciences Index and Abstracts (ASSIA) from inception up to May 2013. A quantitative systematic review of clinical effectiveness, a qualitative review to explore the acceptability, relative benefits and potential harms, and a cost–utility analysis of studies evaluating cost-effectiveness of art therapy were conducted. Results: In the quantitative review, 15 randomised controlled trials (RCTs) were included (n = 777). Meta-analysis was not possible because of clinical heterogeneity and insufficient comparable data on outcome measures across studies. A narrative synthesis reports that art therapy was associated with significant positive changes relative to the control group in mental health symptoms in 10 out of the 15 studies. The control groups varied between studies but included wait-list/no treatment, attention placebo controls and psychological therapy comparators. Four studies reported improvement from baseline but no significant difference between groups. One study reported that outcomes were more favourable in the control group. The quality of included RCTs was generally low. In the qualitative review, 12 cohort studies were included (n = 188 service users;n = 16 service providers). Themes relating to benefits of art therapy for service users included the relationship with the therapist, personal achievement and distraction. Areas of potential harms were related to the activation of emotions that were then unresolved, lack of skill of the art therapist and sudden termination of art therapy. The quality of included qualitative studies was generally low to moderate. In the cost-effectiveness review, a de novo model was constructed and populated with data identified from the clinical review. Scenario analyses were conducted allowing comparisons of group art therapy with wait-list control, group art therapy with group verbal therapy, and individual art therapy versus control. Art therapy appeared cost-effective compared with wait-list control with high certainty, although generalisability to the target population was unclear. Verbal therapy appeared more cost-effective than art therapy but there was considerable uncertainty and a sizeable probability that art therapy was more clinically effective. The cost-effectiveness of individual art therapy was uncertain and dependent on assumptions regarding clinical benefit and duration of benefit. Conclusions: From the limited available evidence, art therapy was associated with positive effects when compared with a control in a number of studies in patients with different clinical profiles, and it was reported to be an acceptable treatment and was associated with a number of benefits. Art therapy appeared to be cost-effective compared with wait-list but further studies are needed to confirm this finding as well as evidence to inform future cost-effective analyses of art therapy versus other treatments. Study registration: The study is registered as PROSPERO CRD42013003957. Funding: The National Institute for Health Research Health Technology Assessment programme.
Overview
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Self-check
Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.
The self-check needs the paper’s full text.
Citations
Cites
Methods for the thematic synthesis of qualitative research in systematic reviews
Thomas, J., & Harden, A. (2008) · BMC Medical Research Methodology · doi:10.1186/1471-2288-8-45 · Cited by 9,312
Depression, chronic diseases, and decrements in health: results from the World Health Surveys
Moussavi, S., Chatterji, S., Verdes, E., Tandon, A., Patel, V., & Ustun, B. (2007) · The Lancet · doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(07)61415-9 · Cited by 4,070
Recovery from mental illness: the guiding vision of the mental health service system in the 1990s
Anthony, W. A. (1993) · Psychosocial Rehabilitation Journal · doi:10.1037/h0095655 · Cited by 3,700 · cited 1×
“The term ‘recovery’ accommodates the concept that the journey of transitioning from a negative mental health state may be non-linear and may include setbacks as well as progress.(21,35) Essential elements of the recovery approach are reported to be those that facilitate the rebuilding of a meaningful life despite the…”
BackgroundEvaluating non-randomised intervention studies
Deeks, J., Dinnes, J., D'Amico, R., Sowden, A., Sakarovitch, C., Song, F., Petticrew, M., & Altman, D. (2003) · Health Technology Assessment · doi:10.3310/hta7270 · Cited by 2,907 · cited 1×
“The consequence of including data from non-randomised studies into the review is that the resulting data are biased and therefore not robust or sufficient to inform and contribute to the evidence base.(41,42) The inclusion and exclusion criteria for the quantitative review are shown in Figure 2.”
BackgroundMcHugh, R. K., Whitton, S. W., Peckham, A. D., Welge, J. A., & Otto, M. W. (2013) · The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry · doi:10.4088/jcp.12r07757 · Cited by 800 · cited 1×
“In addition, recent evidence suggests that psychological treatment may be a preferred treatment option over pharmacological treatment for many who are undergoing treatment for a psychiatric disorder.(12,13) Moreover, patient preference for treatment may impact on adherence and treatment outcome.”
BackgroundHopewell, S., Clarke, M., Moher, D., Wager, E., Middleton, P., Altman, D. G., Schulz, K. F., & and the CONSORT Group (2008) · PLoS Medicine · doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0050020 · Cited by 674 · cited 1×
“Conference proceedings without a corresponding final report (published or unpublished) would not qualify for inclusion, as they are unlikely to contain sufficient information to permit quality assessment and can often be different to results published in the final report.(39,40)”
BackgroundBarkham, M., Margison, F., Leach, C., Lucock, M., Mellor-Clark, J., Evans, C., Benson, L., Connell, J., Audin, K., & McGrath, G. (2001) · Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology · doi:10.1037/0022-006x.69.2.184 · Cited by 532
Glenton, C., Colvin, C., Carlsen, B., Swartz, A., Lewin, S., Noyes, J., & Rashidian, A. (2013) · Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews · doi:10.1002/14651858.cd010414.pub2 · Cited by 454
Merlin, T., Weston, A., & Tooher, R. (2009) · BMC Medical Research Methodology · doi:10.1186/1471-2288-9-34 · Cited by 435
Patients' preferences in the treatment of depressive disorder in primary care
van Schaik, D. J. F., Klijn, A. F. J., van Hout, H. P. J., van Marwijk, H. W. J., Beekman, A. T. F., de Haan, M., & van Dyck, R. (2004) · General Hospital Psychiatry · doi:10.1016/j.genhosppsych.2003.12.001 · Cited by 428 · cited 1×
“In addition, recent evidence suggests that psychological treatment may be a preferred treatment option over pharmacological treatment for many who are undergoing treatment for a psychiatric disorder.(12,13) Moreover, patient preference for treatment may impact on adherence and treatment outcome.”
BackgroundA randomized, controlled trial of mindfulness‐based art therapy (MBAT) for women with cancer
Monti, D. A., Peterson, C., Kunkel, E. J. S., Hauck, W. W., Pequignot, E., Rhodes, L., & Brainard, G. C. (2006) · Psycho-Oncology · doi:10.1002/pon.988 · Cited by 378
Designing Randomised Trials in Health, Education and the Social Sciences
Torgerson, D. J., & Torgerson, C. J. (2008) · doi:10.1057/9780230583993 · Cited by 366
The influence of patient preference on depression treatment in primary care
Lin, P., Campbell, D. G., Chaney, E. F., Liu, C.-F., Heagerty, P., Felker, B. L., & Hedrick, S. C. (2005) · Annals of Behavioral Medicine · doi:10.1207/s15324796abm3002_9 · Cited by 192 · cited 2×
“A small number of participants also reported that they did not want to take part in art therapy, which reiterates the importance of considering patient preference in choice of treatment.(14,15)”
BackgroundArt therapy improves coping resources: A randomized, controlled study among women with breast cancer
ÖSTER, I., SVENSK, A.-C., MAGNUSSON, E., THYME, K. E., SJÕDIN, M., ÅSTRÖM, S., & LINDH, J. (2006) · Palliative and Supportive Care · doi:10.1017/s147895150606007x · Cited by 173 · cited 1×
“2009;(63) Oster et al.(64) Computer generated and stratified according to receipt of chemotherapy to ensure equal numbers treated with cytostatics between groups”
MethodRusted, J., Sheppard, L., & Waller, D. (2006) · Group Analysis · doi:10.1177/0533316406071447 · Cited by 162
Hattori, H., Hattori, C., Hokao, C., Mizushima, K., & Mase, T. (2011) · Geriatrics & Gerontology International · doi:10.1111/j.1447-0594.2011.00698.x · Cited by 126 · cited 9×
“Hattori et al.(51) Monti and Peterson 2004;(60) Monti et al.”
BackgroundMethodResultInfluentialSportel, B. E., de Hullu, E., de Jong, P. J., & Nauta, M. H. (2013) · PLoS ONE · doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0064355 · Cited by 119 · cited 1×
“More recent data provided in Sportel et al.(94) (table 3) indicate that when Cognitive Bias Modification and Cognitive Behavioural Group Training provided larger decreases in an outcome measure (the Spielberger Test Anxiety Inventory(95)), the effect had not entirely waned at 12-month follow-up.”
ResultA randomized trial to test the effectiveness of art therapy for children with asthma
Beebe, A., Gelfand, E. W., & Bender, B. (2010) · Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology · doi:10.1016/j.jaci.2010.03.019 · Cited by 111 · cited 10×
“Anxiety Among the seven studies examining anxiety, art therapy resulted in significant reduction of anxiety in six studies.(52,54,55,58,61,62) In these six studies, art therapy was significantly more effective than the control.”
BackgroundInfluentialMonti, D. A., Kash, K. M., Kunkel, E. J. S., Brainard, G., Wintering, N., Moss, A. S., Rao, H., Zhu, S., & Newberg, A. B. (2012) · Stress and Health · doi:10.1002/smi.2470 · Cited by 80 · cited 3×
“As can be seen from Table 17, there were only four studies in which all participants completed the trial.(52,54,55,58) While several studies reported substantial numbers of dropouts, only one study reported to be sized with reference to effect size.”
BackgroundResult
Cited by
Art therapy as an adjuvant treatment for depression in elderly women: a randomized controlled trial
Ciasca, E. C., Ferreira, R. C., Santana, C. L. A., Forlenza, O. V., dos Santos, G. D., Brum, P. S., & Nunes, P. V. (2018) · Revista Brasileira de Psiquiatria · doi:10.1590/1516-4446-2017-2250 · Cited by 123
A systematic literature review of the impact of art therapy upon post-traumatic stress disorder
Schnitzer, G., Holttum, S., & Huet, V. (2021) · International Journal of Art Therapy · doi:10.1080/17454832.2021.1910719 · Cited by 75
The Effectiveness of Art Therapy for Anxiety in Adult Women: A Randomized Controlled Trial
Abbing, A., Baars, E. W., de Sonneville, L., Ponstein, A. S., & Swaab, H. (2019) · Frontiers in Psychology · doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2019.01203 · Cited by 73
“, 2018), or prefer not to take medication, or prefer non-verbal therapy (Uttley et al., 2015).”
BackgroundMoula, Z. (2020) · International Journal of Art Therapy · doi:10.1080/17454832.2020.1751219 · Cited by 72
Czamanski-Cohen, J., Wiley, J., & Weihs, K. (2020) · BMJ Open · doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2020-037521 · Cited by 19
Metadata
- Authors
- Uttley, L., Scope, A., Stevenson, M., Rawdin, A., Taylor Buck, E., Sutton, A., Stevens, J., Kaltenthaler, E., Dent-Brown, K., & Wood, C.
- Venue
- Health Technology Assessment
- Published
- 2015-03
- Volume
- 19
- Issue
- 18
- Pages
- 1-120
- ISSN
- 1366-5278 (ISSN-L)
- 2046-4924
- OpenAlex
- W2085013935
- Cited by
- 134
- References
- 19
- FWCI
- 25.52
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- diamond
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.