CoChat

Tracing the Influence of Ming-Qing Buddhism in Early Modern Japan: Yunqi Zhuhong’s Tract on Refraining from Killing and on Releasing Life and Ritual Animal Releases

Open access
Ambros, Barbara R. · 2021 · Religions

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 14 of the 14 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; none of the 53 sources its claims cite is checked for support yet.

Abstract

This essay traces the Japanese reception of Zhuhong’s Tract on Refraining from Killing and on Releasing Life in the early modern period. Ritual animal releases have a long history in Japan beginning in the seventh century, approximately two centuries after such rituals arose in China. From the mid-eighth century, the releases became large-scale state rites conducted at Hachiman shrines, which have been most widely studied and documented. By contrast, a different strand of life releases that emerged in the Edo period owing to the influence of late Ming Buddhism has received comparatively little scholarly attention despite the significance for the period. Not only may the publication of a Sino–Japanese edition of Zhuhong’s Tract in 1661 have been an impetus for Shogun Tokugawa Tsunayoshi’s Laws of Compassion in the late-seventeenth century, but also approximately thirty Japanese Buddhist texts inspired by Zhuhong’s Tract appeared over the next two and a half centuries. As Zhuhong’s ethic of refraining from killing and releasing life was assimilated over the course of the Edo and into the Meiji period, life releases became primarily associated with generating merit for the posthumous repose of the ancestors although they were also said to have a variety of vital benefits for the devotees and their families, such as health, longevity, prosperity, and descendants.

Overview

CoChat Summary

TL;DR

Barbara R. Ambros traces how Yunqi Zhuhong’s 1584 *Tract on Refraining from Killing and on Releasing Life* was transmitted, adapted, and assimilated in early modern Japan from the 1661 Sino-Japanese edition through approximately thirty Japanese Buddhist texts over the next two and a half centuries. The essay argues that this Ming-Qing Buddhist ethic had trans-sectarian and lay appeal, may have influenced Tokugawa Tsunayoshi’s Laws of Compassion, and eventually became primarily associated with merit for ancestors while also promising vital benefits to the living.

Key findings

  • The 1661 Sino-Japanese edition of Zhuhong’s *Tract* may have been an impetus for Shogun Tokugawa Tsunayoshi’s Laws of Compassion, though the paper notes there are no extant records that Tsunayoshi had direct access to the *Tract* and the evidence is circumstantial.
  • Approximately thirty Japanese Buddhist texts inspired by Zhuhong’s *Tract* appeared over the next two and a half centuries, from Asai Ryōi’s *Kaisetsu hōjō monogatari* (1664) to Taikyo’s *Hōjō meikan roku* (1898).
  • The texts were compiled by clerics from Jōdo, Jōdo Shin, Sōtō, Shingon, and Tendai schools, suggesting trans-sectarian appeal; as the ethic was assimilated, life releases became primarily associated with generating merit for ancestors, while also promising health, longevity, prosperity, and descendants.
  • Table 1 reports the number of tales from Zhuhong’s *Tract on Releasing Life* included in Japanese texts: Asai Ryōi 14; Enkyō 28; Dokuan 28; Zenseki 28; Jishū 20; Tainin 3/14; Kanjun 5; Zaizen 9; Junshō 11/7; Tendai ācārya 3; Taikyo 2.

Methods

  • Historical and textual study of the Japanese reception of Zhuhong’s *Tract*, examining Sino-Japanese editions, vernacular translations, commentaries, anthologies, and later didactic tracts from the mid-seventeenth through the late nineteenth century.
  • Primary sources include the 1661 Sino-Japanese edition, Asai Ryōi’s 1664 vernacular adaptation, Enkyō’s 1682 commentary, Dokuan’s 1692 anthology, Zenseki’s 1744 translation, Jishū’s 1783 compendium, Tainin’s 1784 guide, Junshō’s 1812/1816 jottings, Kanjun’s 1803 clarification, the Tendai ācārya’s 1836 tract, and Taikyo’s 1898 record.
  • Analysis compares source borrowings, abridgements, and adaptations, including a table counting tales from Zhuhong’s *Tract* in each Japanese text.

Limitations

  • The paper states that it is difficult to accurately assess the societal influence of Zhuhong’s *Tract* (citing Araki Kengo), and that there are no extant records showing Tsunayoshi had direct access to the *Tract*; the influence on the Laws of Compassion is presented as circumstantial.
  • The paper notes uncertainty about authorship and provenance: Asai Ryōi’s authorship of the *Tale* cannot be certified with absolute certainty, little is known about Zenseki, and relatively little is known about the anonymous Tendai ācārya, Kanjun, and Taikyo or the production of their tracts.
  • Evident from the text: the study focuses on textual reception and selected printed sources, often relying on the author’s collection and available editions, so it does not claim exhaustive coverage of all Japanese life-release materials or popular practice.

Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.3390/rel12100889

Cites

14 of 14 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Nothing to recompute.

Figures

Figure 1 The opening page of the Sino-Japanese edition of Zhuhong's Tract on Refraining from Killing and on Releasing Life (1661). Zhuhong's text is reproduced in Chinese with Japanese reading guides. (Original in author's collection.). Figure 1. The opening page of the Sino-Japanese edition of Zhuhong's Tract on Refraining from Killing and on Releasing Life (1661). Zhuhong's text is reproduced in Chinese with Japanese reading guides. (Original in author's collection.)
Figure 1 The opening page of the Sino-Japanese edition of Zhuhong's Tract on Refraining from Killing and on Releasing Life (1661). Zhuhong's text is reproduced in Chinese with Japanese reading guides. (Original in author's collection.). Figure 1. The opening page of the Sino-Japanese edition of Zhuhong's Tract on Refraining from Killing and on Releasing Life (1661). Zhuhong's text is reproduced in Chinese with Japanese reading guides. (Original in author's collection.)CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 2 An illustration from Illustrated Record of Self-Knowledge in Japanese Script depicting people performing a variety of good deeds, such as releasing birds and turtles on a bridge and fish from baskets on the riverside. The caption on the top of the left page explains: 'Rescuing animals counts as ten merits for one life; small animals such as sparrows and fish count as one merit for one life.' (Original in author's collection.). Figure 2. An illustration from Illustrated Record of Self-Knowledge in Japanese Script depicting people performing a variety of good deeds, such as releasing birds and turtles on a bridge and fish from baskets on the riverside. The caption on the top of the left page explains: 'Rescuing animals counts as ten merits for one life; small animals such as sparrows and fish count as one merit for one life.' (Original in author's collection.)
Figure 2 An illustration from Illustrated Record of Self-Knowledge in Japanese Script depicting people performing a variety of good deeds, such as releasing birds and turtles on a bridge and fish from baskets on the riverside. The caption on the top of the left page explains: 'Rescuing animals counts as ten merits for one life; small animals such as sparrows and fish count as one merit for one life.' (Original in author's collection.). Figure 2. An illustration from Illustrated Record of Self-Knowledge in Japanese Script depicting people performing a variety of good deeds, such as releasing birds and turtles on a bridge and fish from baskets on the riverside. The caption on the top of the left page explains: 'Rescuing animals counts as ten merits for one life; small animals such as sparrows and fish count as one merit for one life.' (Original in author's collection.)CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 3 The title page and table of contents of the first volume of a Jish ū 's Compendium on the Merit of Life Releases reprinted under the new title, Must-Read Compendium for Sermonizing on Karma . The original title was replaced with the reprint's; otherwise, the printing blocks are identical with the original's. (Original in author's collection.). Figure 3. The title page and table of contents of the first volume of a Jish¯ u's Compendium on the Merit of Life Releases reprinted under the new title, Must-Read Compendium for Sermonizing on Karma . The original title was replaced with the reprint's; otherwise, the printing blocks are identical with the original's. (Original in author's collection.)
Figure 3 The title page and table of contents of the first volume of a Jish ū 's Compendium on the Merit of Life Releases reprinted under the new title, Must-Read Compendium for Sermonizing on Karma . The original title was replaced with the reprint's; otherwise, the printing blocks are identical with the original's. (Original in author's collection.). Figure 3. The title page and table of contents of the first volume of a Jish¯ u's Compendium on the Merit of Life Releases reprinted under the new title, Must-Read Compendium for Sermonizing on Karma . The original title was replaced with the reprint's; otherwise, the printing blocks are identical with the original's. (Original in author's collection.)CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 4 Colophon of the Tendai ā c ā rya's Tract on Admonishing against Killing and Releasing Life describing the provenance and purpose of the text. It states that the text contains twenty entries from Jish ū 's Compendium and that the text was written by an anonymous ā c ā rya from Mt. Kurama. (Original in author's collection.). Figure 4. Colophon of the Tendai ¯ ac¯ arya's Tract on Admonishing against Killing and Releasing Life describing the provenance and purpose of the text. It states that the text contains twenty entries from Jish¯ u's Compendium and that the text was written by an anonymous ¯ ac¯ arya from Mt. Kurama. (Original in author's collection.) , x FOR PEER REVIEW 19 of 32
Figure 4 Colophon of the Tendai ā c ā rya's Tract on Admonishing against Killing and Releasing Life describing the provenance and purpose of the text. It states that the text contains twenty entries from Jish ū 's Compendium and that the text was written by an anonymous ā c ā rya from Mt. Kurama. (Original in author's collection.). Figure 4. Colophon of the Tendai ¯ ac¯ arya's Tract on Admonishing against Killing and Releasing Life describing the provenance and purpose of the text. It states that the text contains twenty entries from Jish¯ u's Compendium and that the text was written by an anonymous ¯ ac¯ arya from Mt. Kurama. (Original in author's collection.) , x FOR PEER REVIEW 19 of 32CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 5 This page from volume 4 of Kanjun's Clarification of Life Releases in the Three Teachings mentions Zhuhong's Tract on Refraining from Killing and on Releasing Life and Jish ū 's Compendium on the Merit of Life Releases as good resources on life releases and Yuan Liaofan's Record of Hidden Recompense as a good resource on secret merit. (Original in author's collection.). Figure 5. This page from volume 4 of Kanjun's Clarification of Life Releases in the Three Teachings mentions Zhuhong's Tract on Refraining from Killing and on Releasing Life and Jish¯ u's Compendium on the Merit of Life Releases as good resources on life releases and Yuan Liaofan's Record of Hidden Recompense as a good resource on secret merit. (Original in author's collection.)
Figure 5 This page from volume 4 of Kanjun's Clarification of Life Releases in the Three Teachings mentions Zhuhong's Tract on Refraining from Killing and on Releasing Life and Jish ū 's Compendium on the Merit of Life Releases as good resources on life releases and Yuan Liaofan's Record of Hidden Recompense as a good resource on secret merit. (Original in author's collection.). Figure 5. This page from volume 4 of Kanjun's Clarification of Life Releases in the Three Teachings mentions Zhuhong's Tract on Refraining from Killing and on Releasing Life and Jish¯ u's Compendium on the Merit of Life Releases as good resources on life releases and Yuan Liaofan's Record of Hidden Recompense as a good resource on secret merit. (Original in author's collection.)CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 6 The colophons of the main text ( a ) and the appendix ( b ) of the 1812 edition of Junsh ō 's Jottings on the Joys of Life Releases . The printing of the main text was sponsored by a devout layman (J. ubasoku ) from Ō tsu, who may be identical to the layman Tetsu ō who inspired the publication. The merit of the printing of the main text and the appendix was dedicated to the salvation of the sponsors' relatives. The colophon of main text wished that a layman, K ō un Jiden Zenj ō mon, and a laywoman, Kangetsu My ō rin Zenj ō ni, will attain posthumous merit, while the colophon of the appendix expressed the wish that a layman, Shunh ō Ry ō en Koji, and ancestors of the sponsor would achieve rebirth in Amit ā bha's pure land. The three beneficiaries mentioned by their posthumous names were likely very close family members of the sponsors. In addition, the printing was also dedicated to the sponsors' six relations by blood and marriage (parents, siblings, spouses, and children) and all living beings. The printing was dated the fifteenth day of the eighth month of Bunka 9. The day was associated with life releases because the annual release at the Iwashimizu Hachiman Shrine. (Original in author's collection.). Figure 6. The colophons of the main text ( a ) and the appendix ( b ) of the 1812 edition of Junsh¯ o's Jottings on the Joys of Life Releases . The printing of the main text was sponsored by a devout layman (J. ubasoku ) from ¯ Otsu, who may be identical to the layman Tetsu¯ o who inspired the publication. The merit of the printing of the main text and the appendix was dedicated to the salvation of the sponsors' relatives. The colophon of main text wished that a layman, K¯ oun Jiden Zenj¯ omon, and a laywoman, Kangetsu My¯ orin Zenj¯ oni, will attain posthumous merit, while the colophon of the appendix expressed the wish that a layman, Shunh¯ o Ry¯ oen Koji, and ancestors of the sponsor would achieve rebirth in Amit¯ abha's pure land. The three beneficiaries mentioned by their posthumous names were likely very close family members of the sponsors. In addition, the printing was also dedicated to the sponsors' six relations by blood and marriage (parents, siblings, spouses, and children) and all living beings. The printing was dated the fifteenth day of the eighth month of Bunka 9. The day was associated with life releases because the annual release at the Iwashimizu Hachiman Shrine. (Original in author's collection.)
Figure 6 The colophons of the main text ( a ) and the appendix ( b ) of the 1812 edition of Junsh ō 's Jottings on the Joys of Life Releases . The printing of the main text was sponsored by a devout layman (J. ubasoku ) from Ō tsu, who may be identical to the layman Tetsu ō who inspired the publication. The merit of the printing of the main text and the appendix was dedicated to the salvation of the sponsors' relatives. The colophon of main text wished that a layman, K ō un Jiden Zenj ō mon, and a laywoman, Kangetsu My ō rin Zenj ō ni, will attain posthumous merit, while the colophon of the appendix expressed the wish that a layman, Shunh ō Ry ō en Koji, and ancestors of the sponsor would achieve rebirth in Amit ā bha's pure land. The three beneficiaries mentioned by their posthumous names were likely very close family members of the sponsors. In addition, the printing was also dedicated to the sponsors' six relations by blood and marriage (parents, siblings, spouses, and children) and all living beings. The printing was dated the fifteenth day of the eighth month of Bunka 9. The day was associated with life releases because the annual release at the Iwashimizu Hachiman Shrine. (Original in author's collection.). Figure 6. The colophons of the main text ( a ) and the appendix ( b ) of the 1812 edition of Junsh¯ o's Jottings on the Joys of Life Releases . The printing of the main text was sponsored by a devout layman (J. ubasoku ) from ¯ Otsu, who may be identical to the layman Tetsu¯ o who inspired the publication. The merit of the printing of the main text and the appendix was dedicated to the salvation of the sponsors' relatives. The colophon of main text wished that a layman, K¯ oun Jiden Zenj¯ omon, and a laywoman, Kangetsu My¯ orin Zenj¯ oni, will attain posthumous merit, while the colophon of the appendix expressed the wish that a layman, Shunh¯ o Ry¯ oen Koji, and ancestors of the sponsor would achieve rebirth in Amit¯ abha's pure land. The three beneficiaries mentioned by their posthumous names were likely very close family members of the sponsors. In addition, the printing was also dedicated to the sponsors' six relations by blood and marriage (parents, siblings, spouses, and children) and all living beings. The printing was dated the fifteenth day of the eighth month of Bunka 9. The day was associated with life releases because the annual release at the Iwashimizu Hachiman Shrine. (Original in author's collection.)CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 7 Illustration of the karmic benefits of life releases in Junsh ō 's Jottings on the Joys of Life Releases (1816). (Original in author's collection.). Figure 7. Illustration of the karmic benefits of life releases in Junsh¯ o's Jottings on the Joys of Life Releases (1816). (Original in author's collection.)
Figure 7 Illustration of the karmic benefits of life releases in Junsh ō 's Jottings on the Joys of Life Releases (1816). (Original in author's collection.). Figure 7. Illustration of the karmic benefits of life releases in Junsh¯ o's Jottings on the Joys of Life Releases (1816). (Original in author's collection.)CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 8 Illustration of the karmic retribution for killing living beings in Junsh ō 's Jottings on the Joys of Life Releases (1816). (Original in author's collection.). Figure 8. Illustration of the karmic retribution for killing living beings in Junsh¯ o's Jottings on the Joys of Life Releases (1816). (Original in author's collection.)
Figure 8 Illustration of the karmic retribution for killing living beings in Junsh ō 's Jottings on the Joys of Life Releases (1816). (Original in author's collection.). Figure 8. Illustration of the karmic retribution for killing living beings in Junsh¯ o's Jottings on the Joys of Life Releases (1816). (Original in author's collection.)CC-BY · From the PDF

Verification

Claims the paper makes

0 Valid · 5 Not valid · 59 Not checked · 133 Own results and interpretations

66 more claims

Create a free account to see all 197 claims and every source verdict.

See all claims — free account
  • It may state two separate claims as one. 89
  • Probably not a substantial claim. 70
  • The quote only partly states this claim. 3

Create a free account to see these claims.

Citations

Cites

Show all 14 references

Research works printed but not linked: 22

  1. Singer, Robert T., and Masatomo, Kawai (2019). Cultivating Compassion and Accruing Merit: Animal Releases during the Edo Period. The Life of Animals in Japanese Art, Princeton University Press.
  2. Baskind, James Matthew (2006). Ming Buddhism in Edo Japan: The Chinese Founding Masters of the Japanese Obaku School. [Ph.D. Dissertation, Yale University].
  3. Dong, 2018a, Asai Ryōi ni okeru Chūgoku minmatsu zensho bunka no shuyō: Yan Maoyou cho Diji lu o chūshin ni. 浅井了意における中国明末善書文化の受容―顔茂猷著『廸吉録』を中心に, Ilbon Munhwa Hakbo 日本文化學報, 79, 109
  4. Dong, 2018b, Kagami gusa ni okeru Diji lu kara shakuyō mondai: Ryōha no hikaku kentō o chūushin ni.『鑑草』における『廸吉録』からの借用問題―両者の比較検討を中心に, Seikei Jinbun Kenkyū 成蹊人文研究, 26, 19
  5. 1973, Asai Ryōi ikaden narabi ni shukke kō. 浅井了意訛伝並びに出家考, Tōkai Gakuen Joshi Tanki Daigaku Kiyō 東海学園女子短期大学紀要, 8, 158
  6. Ishiguro, 2006, Sesshōtan no henbō (1): Chūsei kara kinsei e 殺生譚の変貌(1)中世説話から近世説話へ, Senshū Bungaku 専修国文, 79, 21
  7. Ishiguro, 2007, Sesshōtan no henbō (2): Chūsei kara kinsei e 殺生譚の変貌(2)中世説話から近世説話へ, Senshū Bungaku 専修国文, 81, 33
  8. Ishiguro, 2008, Sesshōtan no henbō (3): Chūsei kara kinsei e 殺生譚の変貌(3)中世説話から近世説話へ, Senshū Bungaku 専修国文, 82, 41
  9. Kawaguchi, 1989, Tainin risshi to Zen sō to no kōryū. 諦忍律師と禅僧との交流, Indogaku Bukkyōgaku Kenkyū 印度学仏教学研究, 38, 181
  10. Kawaguchi, 1994, Tainin risshi no shi to deshi. 諦忍律師の師と弟子, Zen Kenyūsho Kiyō 禅研究所紀要, 23, 19
  11. Kimura, 2018, Asai Ryōi saku Kaisetsu monogatari, hōjō monogatari ni tsuite: Chūugoku jōdokyō shisō to no kankei ni chūmoku shite. 浅井了意作『戒殺物語・放生物語』について―中国浄土教思想との関係に注目 して, Kokubungaku Kenkyū 国文学研究, 186, 71
  12. Legge, James (1885). The Sacred Books of China—The Texts of Confucianism, vol. 28: The Li Ki, Clarendon Press.
  13. Nakazawa, 2000, Sesshō to shinsei: Shuryō to nikushoku o meguru bakufu no tuzurafuji. 殺生と新制―狩猟と肉食をめぐる幕府の葛藤, Tōhokugaku 東北学, 3, 247
  14. Nishimura, 2012, Fusesshō to hōjōe 不殺生と放生会, Eco-Philosophy Kenkyū エコ・フィロソフィ研究, 6, 47
  15. Nishimura, 2014, Nihon ni okeru fusesshō shisō: Unsei Shukō no shuyō to eikyō. 日本近世における不殺生思想―雲棲袾宏の受容と影響, Indogaku Bukkyōgaku Kenkyū 印度學佛教學研究, 62, 753
  16. Nishimura, 2016, Kinsei ni okeru fusesshō shisō no hatten: Sankyō hōjō benwaku ni tsuite. 日本近世における不殺生思想の展開: 『三教放生辨惑』について, Shūkyō Kenkyū 宗教研究, 89, 323
  17. Nogawa, 2016b, Riben 17 shiji yihou de jiesha husheng sixiang: Yi Tokugawa Tsunayoshi wei zhongxin 日本17世紀以降的戒殺護生思想―以德川綱吉為中心, Yuanguang Foxue Xuebao 圓光佛學學報, 27, 107
  18. Ogawa, 1975, Asai Ryōi no nicho ni tsukite: Kaisetsu hōjō mon kana to Deki saikyō miyage. 浅井了意の二著につきてー戒殺放生仮名と出来斎京土産, Kinsei Bungei Kenkyū to Hyōron 近世文芸研究と評論, 8, 23
  19. Haruhiko, 1993, Asai Ryōi Kaisetsu monogatari hōjō monogatari to Shukō Kaisetsu hōjō mon. 浅井了意『戒殺物語放生物語』と袾宏『戒殺放生文』, Kanazōshi Shūsei. 假名草子集成, 4, 421
  20. Lopez, Donald (2004a). Against Animal Sacrifice. Buddhist Scriptures, Penguin.
  21. Lopez, Donald (2004b). Freeing Birds and Fish from Bondage. Buddhist Scriptures, Penguin.
  22. Yanagida, 2015, Tokugawa Tsunayoshi jukyōteki tōji to Chūgoku zensho no shuyō ni tsuite. 徳川綱吉の儒教的統治と中国善書の受容について, Gengo Bunka Shakai 言語・文化・社会, 13, 1

Metadata

Authors
Ambros, B. R.
Affiliations
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (US)
Corresponding author
Ambros, Barbara R.
Venue
Religions
Publisher
MDPI AG
Published
2021-10-15
Volume
12
Issue
10
Pages
889
ISSN
2077-1444 (ISSN-L)
OpenAlex
W3206290321
Cited by
3
References
13
Citations by year
2026: 1 · 2025: 2
FWCI
0.00
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Locations
  • Religions (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) (submittedVersion, cc-by-sa)
Topics
  • Social Sciences › Arts and Humanities › Religious studies › Indian and Buddhist Studies
  • Social Sciences › Cultural Studies › Japanese History and Culture
  • Social Sciences › Arts and Humanities › History › Chinese history and philosophy
Keywords
Edo period Buddhism, ancestor veneration, merit-making, early modern Japan

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-10-05, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).

A second model labelled each claim on 2026-10-05 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Tracing the Influence of Ming-Qing Buddhism in Early Modern Japan: Yunqi Zhuhong’s Tract on Refraining from Killing and on Releasing Life and Ritual Animal Releases. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.3390/rel12100889
The paper
Ambros, B. R. (2021). Tracing the Influence of Ming-Qing Buddhism in Early Modern Japan: Yunqi Zhuhong’s Tract on Refraining from Killing and on Releasing Life and Ritual Animal Releases. Religions. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel12100889

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.