CoChat

Evaluating Stream Restoration Projects: What Do We Learn from Monitoring?

Open access
Rubin, Zan, Kondolf, G., Rios-Touma, Blanca · 2017 · Water
Cited by 86

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 4 of the 4 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

Abstract

Two decades since calls for stream restoration projects to be scientifically assessed, most projects are still unevaluated, and conducted evaluations yield ambiguous results. Even after these decades of investigation, do we know how to define and measure success? We systematically reviewed 26 studies of stream restoration projects that used macroinvertebrate indicators to assess the success of habitat heterogeneity restoration projects. All 26 studies were previously included in two meta-analyses that sought to assess whether restoration programs were succeeding. By contrast, our review focuses on the evaluations themselves, and asks what exactly we are measuring and learning from these evaluations. All 26 studies used taxonomic diversity, richness, or abundance of invertebrates as biological measures of success, but none presented explicit arguments why those metrics were relevant measures of success for the restoration projects. Although changes in biodiversity may reflect overall ecological condition at the regional or global scale, in the context of reach-scale habitat restoration, more abundance and diversity may not necessarily be better. While all 26 studies sought to evaluate the biotic response to habitat heterogeneity enhancement projects, about half of the studies (46%) explicitly measured habitat alteration, and 31% used visual estimates of grain size or subjectively judged ‘habitat quality’ from protocols ill-suited for the purpose. Although the goal of all 26 projects was to increase habitat heterogeneity, 31% of the studies either sampled only riffles or did not specify the habitats sampled. One-third of the studies (35%) used reference ecosystems to define target conditions. After 20 years of stream restoration evaluation, more work remains for the restoration community to identify appropriate measures of success and to coordinate monitoring so that evaluations are at a scale capable of detecting ecosystem change.

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.3390/w9030174

Cites

4 of 4 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Citations

Cites

Research works printed but not linked: 85

  1. National Research Council (U.S.), Committee on Restoration of Aquatic Ecosystems—Science, Technology, and Public Policy, Commission on Geosciences, Environment, and Resources (1992). Restoration of Aquatic Ecosystems: Science, Technology, and Public Policy, Haworth Press.
  2. Kondolf, 1995, Evaluating stream restoration projects, Environ. Manag., 19, 1, 10.1007/BF02471999 · DOI · Paper page
  3. Kondolf, 1995, Five elements for effective evaluation of stream restoration, Restor. Ecol., 3, 133, 10.1111/j.1526-100X.1995.tb00086.x · DOI · Paper page
  4. Kondolf, G.M. (1994, January 16–18). Learning from stream restoration projects. Proceedings of the Fifth Biennial Watershed Management Conference, Ashland, OR, USA.
  5. Downs, 2002, Post-project appraisals in adaptive management of river channel restoration, Environ. Manag., 29, 477, 10.1007/s00267-001-0035-X · DOI · Paper page
  6. Woolsey, 2007, A strategy to assess river restoration success, Freshw. Biol., 52, 752, 10.1111/j.1365-2427.2007.01740.x · DOI · Paper page
  7. Rutherfurd, 2004, Evaluating stream rehabilitation projects: Reasons not to, and approaches if you have to, Aust. J. Water Resour., 8, 57
  8. Convertino, 2013, Multi-criteria decision analysis to select metrics for design and monitoring of sustainable ecosystem restorations, Ecol. Indic., 26, 76, 10.1016/j.ecolind.2012.10.005 · DOI
  9. Krebs, 1991, The experimental paradigm and long-term population studies, Ibis, 133, 3, 10.1111/j.1474-919X.1991.tb07663.x · DOI
  10. Palmer, 2010, River restoration, habitat heterogeneity and biodiversity: A failure of theory or practice?, Freshw. Biol., 55, 205, 10.1111/j.1365-2427.2009.02372.x · DOI · Paper page
  11. Miller, 2010, Quantifying Macroinvertebrate Responses to In-Stream Habitat Restoration: Applications of Meta-Analysis to River Restoration, Restor. Ecol., 18, 8, 10.1111/j.1526-100X.2009.00605.x · DOI · Paper page
  12. Wohl, 2005, River restoration, Water Resour. Res., 41, W10301, 10.1029/2005WR003985 · DOI · Paper page
  13. Reynoldson, T.B., Norris, R.H., Resh, V.H., Day, K.E., and Rosenberg, D.M. (1997). The reference condition: A comparison of multimetric and multivariate approaches to assess water-quality impairment using benthic macroinvertebrates. J. N. Am. Benthol. Soc., 833–852. · DOI · Paper page
  14. Biggs, 1998, Restoration of the rivers Brede, Cole and Skerne: A joint Danish and British EU-LIFE demonstration project, V—Short-term impacts on the conservation value of aquatic macroinvertebrate and macrophyte assemblages, Aquat. Conserv. Mar. Freshw. Ecosyst., 8, 241, 10.1002/(SICI)1099-0755(199801/02)8:1<241::AID-AQC269>3.0.CO;2-9 · DOI · Paper page
  15. Ebrahimnezhad, 1997, The biological effectiveness of artificial riffles in river rehabilitation, Aquat. Conserv. Mar. Freshw. Ecosyst., 7, 187, 10.1002/(SICI)1099-0755(199709)7:3<187::AID-AQC219>3.0.CO;2-B · doi:10.1002/(sici)1099-0755(199709)7:3<187::aid-aqc219>3.0.co;2-b
  16. Edwards, 1984, Mitigating effects of artificial riffles and pools on the fauna of a channelized warmwater stream, N. Am. J. Fish. Manag., 4, 194, 10.1577/1548-8659(1984)4<194:MEOARA>2.0.CO;2 · doi:10.1577/1548-8659(1984)4<194:meoara>2.0.co;2
  17. Friberg, 1998, Long-term, habitat-specific response of a macroinvertebrate community to river restoration, Aquat. Conserv. Mar. Freshw. Ecosyst., 8, 87, 10.1002/(SICI)1099-0755(199801/02)8:1<87::AID-AQC249>3.0.CO;2-L · doi:10.1002/(sici)1099-0755(199801/02)8:1<87::aid-aqc249>3.0.co;2-l
  18. Gerhard, 2000, Restoration of Streams with Large Wood: Effects of Accumulated and Built-in Wood on Channel Morphology, Habitat Diversity and Aquatic Fauna, Int. Rev. Hydrobiol., 85, 123, 10.1002/(SICI)1522-2632(200003)85:1<123::AID-IROH123>3.0.CO;2-T · doi:10.1002/(sici)1522-2632(200003)85:1<123::aid-iroh123>3.0.co;2-t
  19. 1998, Effects of stream restoration on the macroinvertebrate community in the River Esrom, Denmark, Aquat. Conserv. Mar. Freshw. Ecosyst., 8, 115, 10.1002/(SICI)1099-0755(199801/02)8:1<115::AID-AQC263>3.0.CO;2-L · doi:10.1002/(sici)1099-0755(199801/02)8:1<115::aid-aqc263>3.0.co;2-l
  20. Harrison, 2004, The effect of instream rehabilitation structures on macroinvertebrates in lowland rivers, J. Appl. Ecol., 41, 1140, 10.1111/j.0021-8901.2004.00958.x · DOI · Paper page
  21. Lorenz, 2008, Substrate-specific macroinvertebrate diversity patterns following stream restoration, Aquat. Sci., 70, 292, 10.1007/s00027-008-8042-0 · DOI
  22. Lorenz, 2009, Restoration effort, habitat mosaics, and macroinvertebrates—Does channel form determine community composition?, Aquat. Conserv. Mar. Freshw. Ecosyst., 19, 157, 10.1002/aqc.976 · DOI · Paper page
  23. Lorenz, 2008, Hydromorphological parameters indicating differences between single-and multiple-channel mountain rivers in Germany, in relation to their modification and recovery, Aquat. Conserv. Mar. Freshw. Ecosyst., 18, 1200, 10.1002/aqc.875 · DOI
  24. Jungwirth, 1993, Effects of river bed restructuring on fish and benthos of a fifth order stream, Melk, Austria, Regul. Rivers Res. Manag., 8, 195, 10.1002/rrr.3450080122 · DOI · Paper page
  25. Laasonen, 1998, Recovery of macroinvertebrate communities from stream habitat restoration, Aquat. Conserv. Mar. Freshw. Ecosyst., 8, 101, 10.1002/(SICI)1099-0755(199801/02)8:1<101::AID-AQC251>3.0.CO;2-4 · DOI
  26. Larson, 2001, Effectiveness of large woody debris in stream rehabilitation projects in urban basins, Ecol. Eng., 18, 211, 10.1016/S0925-8574(01)00079-9 · DOI
  27. Lemly, 2000, Influence of large woody debris on stream insect communities and benthic detritus, Hydrobiologia, 421, 179, 10.1023/A:1003904130002 · DOI
  28. Lepori, 2005, Does restoration of structural heterogeneity in streams enhance fish and macroinvertebrate diversity?, Ecol. Appl., 15, 2060, 10.1890/04-1372 · DOI · Paper page
  29. Lester, 2007, Does adding wood to agricultural streams enhance biodiversity? An experimental approach, Mar. Freshw. Res., 58, 687, 10.1071/MF06198 · DOI
  30. Moerke, 2004, Restoration of an Indiana, USA, stream: Bridging the gap between basic and applied lotic ecology, J. N. Am. Benthol. Soc., 23, 647, 10.1899/0887-3593(2004)023<0647:ROAIUS>2.0.CO;2 · doi:10.1899/0887-3593(2004)023<0647:roaius>2.0.co;2
  31. Muotka, 2002, Ecosystem recovery in restored headwater streams: The role of enhanced leaf retention, J. Appl. Ecol., 39, 145, 10.1046/j.1365-2664.2002.00698.x · DOI · Paper page
  32. Muotka, 2002, Long-term recovery of stream habitat structure and benthic invertebrate communities from in-stream restoration, Biol. Conserv., 105, 243, 10.1016/S0006-3207(01)00202-6 · DOI · Paper page
  33. Nakano, 2006, Responses of macroinvertebrate communities to river restoration in a channelized segment of the Shibetsu River, Northern Japan, River Res. Appl., 22, 681, 10.1002/rra.928 · DOI
  34. Negishi, 2003, Responses of organic matter and macroinvertebrates to placements of boulder clusters in a small stream of southwestern British Columbia, Canada, Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 60, 247, 10.1139/f03-013 · DOI
  35. Pedersen, 2007, Restoration of Skjern River and its valley—Short-term effects on river habitats, macrophytes and macroinvertebrates, Ecol. Eng., 30, 145, 10.1016/j.ecoleng.2006.08.009 · DOI
  36. Roni, 2006, Rehabilitation of bedrock stream channels: The effects of boulder weir placement on aquatic habitat and biota, River Res. Appl., 22, 967, 10.1002/rra.954 · DOI
  37. Moerke, 2006, Ecological responses to trout habitat rehabilitation in a Northern Michigan stream, Environ. Manag., 38, 99, 10.1007/s00267-005-0177-3 · DOI
  38. Sarriquet, 2007, Effects of bottom sediment restoration on interstitial habitat characteristics and benthic macroinvertebrate assemblages in a headwater stream, River Res. Appl., 23, 815, 10.1002/rra.1013 · DOI
  39. Tullos, 2009, Analysis of functional traits in reconfigured channels: Implications for the bioassessment and disturbance of river restoration, J. N. Am. Benthol. Soc., 28, 80, 10.1899/07-122.1 · DOI
  40. Walther, 2008, Macroinvertebrate responses to constructed riffles in the Cache River, Illinois, USA, Environ. Manag., 41, 516, 10.1007/s00267-007-9058-2 · DOI
  41. Laub, 2012, Range of variability of channel complexity in urban, restored and forested reference streams, Freshw. Biol., 57, 1076, 10.1111/j.1365-2427.2012.02763.x · DOI
  42. Rosgen, D.L. (2001, January 25–29). A practical method of computing streambank erosion rate. Proceedings of the Seventh Federal Interagency Sedimentation Conference, Reno, NV, USA.
  43. Wolman, 1954, A method of sampling coarse river-bed material, EOS Trans. Am. Geophys. Union, 35, 951, 10.1029/TR035i006p00951 · DOI · Paper page
  44. Kondolf, 1997, Application of the pebble count: Notes on purpose, method, and variants, J. Am. Water Resour. Assoc., 33, 79, 10.1111/j.1752-1688.1997.tb04084.x · DOI
  45. Kondolf, 1992, The pebble count technique for quantifying surface bed material size in instream flow studies, Rivers, 3, 80
  46. Whitacre, H.W., Roper, B.B., and Kershner, J.L. (2007). A Comparison of Protocols and Observer Precision for Measuring Physical Stream Attributes1, Wiley Online Library. · DOI
  47. Lisle, 2015, Can rapid assessment protocols be used to judge sediment impairment in gravel-bed streams? A commentary, JAWRA J. Am. Water Resour. Assoc., 51, 373, 10.1111/jawr.12255 · DOI
  48. Shields, 2010, The stream channel incision syndrome and water quality, Ecol. Eng., 36, 78, 10.1016/j.ecoleng.2009.09.014 · DOI
  49. Bennett, S.J., Simon, A., Castro, J.M., Atkinson, J.F., Bronner, C.E., Blersch, S.S., and Rabideau, A.J. (2013). Stream Restoration in Dynamic Fluvial Systems, Wiley Online Library.
  50. Cuaz, 1997, Bank erosion management based on geomorphological, ecological and economic criteria on the Galaure River, France, Regul. Rivers Res. Manag., 13, 433, 10.1002/(SICI)1099-1646(199709/10)13:5<433::AID-RRR467>3.0.CO;2-L · doi:10.1002/(sici)1099-1646(199709/10)13:5<433::aid-rrr467>3.0.co;2-l
  51. Florsheim, 2008, Bank erosion as a desirable attribute of rivers, Bioscience, 58, 519, 10.1641/B580608 · DOI · Paper page
  52. Gardali, 2006, Abundance patterns of landbirds in restored and remnant riparian forests on the Sacramento River, California, USA, Restor. Ecol., 14, 391, 10.1111/j.1526-100X.2006.00147.x · DOI
  53. Golet, G.H., Brown, D.L., Carlson, M., Gardali, T., Henderson, A., Holl, K.D., Howell, C.A., Holyoak, M., Hunt, J.W., and Kondolf, G.M. (2013). Successes, failures and suggested future directions for ecosystem restoration of the middle Sacramento River, California. San Franc. Estuary Watershed Sci., 11. · DOI
  54. Brudvig, 2011, The restoration of biodiversity: Where has research been and where does it need to go?, Am. J. Bot., 98, 549, 10.3732/ajb.1000285 · DOI · Paper page
  55. 2005, Restoration success: How is it being measured?, Restor. Ecol., 13, 569, 10.1111/j.1526-100X.2005.00072.x · DOI · Paper page
  56. Bonada, 2006, Developments in aquatic insect biomonitoring: A comparative analysis of recent approaches, Annu. Rev. Entomol., 51, 495, 10.1146/annurev.ento.51.110104.151124 · DOI · Paper page
  57. Resh, 2008, Which group is best? Attributes of different biological assemblages used in freshwater biomonitoring programs, Environ. Monit. Assess., 138, 131, 10.1007/s10661-007-9749-4 · DOI · Paper page
  58. Kerans, 1994, A benthic index of biotic integrity (B-IBI) for rivers of the Tennessee Valley, Ecol. Appl., 4, 768, 10.2307/1942007 · DOI · Paper page
  59. Leps, 2016, Time is no healer: Increasing restoration age does not lead to improved benthic invertebrate communities in restored river reaches, Sci. Total Environ., 557–558, 722, 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.03.120 · DOI
  60. Connell, 1978, Diversity in tropical rain forests and coral reefs, Science, 199, 1302, 10.1126/science.199.4335.1302 · DOI · Paper page
  61. Petts, G.E., and Amoros, C. (1996). The Fluvial Hydrosystem, Springer. · DOI
  62. Vannote, 1980, The river continuum concept, Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 37, 130, 10.1139/f80-017 · DOI · Paper page
  63. Ward, 1983, The serial discontinuity concept of lotic ecosystems, Dyn. Lotic Ecosyst., 10, 29
  64. Waters, 2001, Late Quaternary arroyo formation and climate change in the American Southwest, Geology, 29, 399, 10.1130/0091-7613(2001)029<0399:LQAFAC>2.0.CO;2 · DOI
  65. Montgomery, D.R. (1999). Process Domains and the River Continuum, Wiley Online Library.
  66. Polvi, 2011, Geomorphic and process domain controls on riparian zones in the Colorado Front Range, Geomorphology, 125, 504, 10.1016/j.geomorph.2010.10.012 · DOI
  67. Wohl, E. (2013). Mountain Rivers Revisited, John Wiley & Sons.
  68. Simpson, 1949, Measurement of diversity, Nature, 163, 688, 10.1038/163688a0 · DOI · Paper page
  69. MacArthur, R.H., and Wilson, E.O. (2015). Theory of Island Biogeography. (MPB-1), Princeton University Press.
  70. Ricklefs, R.E., and Schluter, D. (1993). Species Diversity in Ecological Communities, University of Chicago Press.
  71. Warfe, 2008, Quantifying habitat structure: Surface convolution and living space for species in complex environments, Oikos, 117, 1764, 10.1111/j.1600-0706.2008.16836.x · DOI
  72. Belll, S., McCoy, E.D., and Mushinsky, H.R. (2012). Habitat Structure: The Physical Arrangement of Objects in Space, Springer Science & Business Media.
  73. Feminella, 1996, Comparison of benthic macroinvertebrate assemblages in small streams along a gradient of flow permanence, J. N. Am. Benthol. Soc., 15, 651, 10.2307/1467814 · DOI · Paper page
  74. Jacobsen, 2012, Biodiversity under threat in glacier-fed river systems, Nat. Clim. Chang., 2, 361, 10.1038/nclimate1435 · DOI · Paper page
  75. Hernandez, 2005, Benthic invertebrate community structure is influenced by forest succession after clearcut logging in southeastern Alaska, Hydrobiologia, 533, 45, 10.1007/s10750-004-2105-6 · DOI
  76. Power, M.E., Parker, M.S., and Wootton, J.T. (1996). Food Webs, Springer.
  77. Flecker, 1996, Ecosystem engineering by a dominant detritivore in a diverse tropical stream, Ecology, 77, 1845, 10.2307/2265788 · DOI · Paper page
  78. Taylor, 2006, Loss of a harvested fish species disrupts carbon flow in a diverse tropical river, Science, 313, 833, 10.1126/science.1128223 · DOI · Paper page
  79. Rice, 2001, Tributaries, sediment sources, and the longitudinal organisation of macroinvertebrate fauna along river systems, Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 58, 824, 10.1139/f01-022 · doi:10.1139/f01-022 · Paper page
  80. White, 1997, Approximating nature’s variation: Selecting and using reference information in restoration ecology, Restor. Ecol., 5, 338, 10.1046/j.1526-100X.1997.00547.x · DOI · Paper page
  81. Whittier, 2007, Selecting reference sites for stream biological assessments: Best professional judgment or objective criteria, J. N. Am. Benthol. Soc., 26, 349, 10.1899/0887-3593(2007)26[349:SRSFSB]2.0.CO;2 · DOI
  82. Gilvear, D., and Bryant, R. (2016). Tools in Fluvial Geomorphology, John Wiley & Sons. [2nd ed.].
  83. Reid, 1981, Application of sediment budget studies to the evaluation of logging road impact, J. Hydrol., 20, 49
  84. Keppeler, E.T. (2011, January 21–23). Sediment production in a coastal watershed: Legacy, land use, recovery, and rehabilitation. Proceedings of the Coast Redwood Forests in a Changing California: A Symposium for Scientists and Managers, Santa Cruz, CA, USA. Gen. Tech. Rep. PSW-GTR-238.
  85. Rood, 2003, Flows for floodplain forests: A successful riparian restoration, BioScience, 53, 647, 10.1641/0006-3568(2003)053[0647:FFFFAS]2.0.CO;2 · DOI · Paper page

Cited by

See all 86

Metadata

Authors
Rubin, Z., Kondolf, G., & Rios-Touma, B.
Venue
Water
Publisher
MDPI AG
Published
2017-02-28
Volume
9
Issue
3
Pages
174
ISSN
2073-4441 (ISSN-L)
OpenAlex
W2591648519
Cited by
86
References
4
FWCI
5.41
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
gold
Funders
  • Ecuadorian National Secretariat of Higher Education (20120122)
  • Beatrix Farrand Fund of the Department of Landscape Architecture and Environmental Planning, Univeristy of California Berkeley (N/A)

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.