Instructional animations can be superior to statics when learning human motor skills

Wong, Anna, Marcus, Nadine, Ayres, Paul, Smith, Lee, Cooper, Graham A., Paas, Fred, Sweller, John·2009·Computers in Human Behavior
DOI 10.1016/j.chb.2008.12.012

Cited by (192)

Items 101–192 of 192

  1. Cognitive and visual processing of 3D enhanced disaster risk communication video
    Agata Kopacz, Grzegorz Banerski, Cezary Biele · 2022 · International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction
  2. Exploring the effect of realism at the cognitive stage of complex motor skill learning
    Terry Lucas · 2019 · E-Learning and Digital Media
  3. Toward Literacy-Neutral Spinal Cord Injury Information and Training
    Manon Maitland Schladen, Alexander Libin, Inger H. Ljungberg, Brenda W. Tsai, Suzanne L. Groah · 2010 · Topics in Spinal Cord Injury Rehabilitation
  4. Origami folding: Taxing resources necessary for the acquisition of sequential skills
    Fang Zhao, Robert Gaschler, Anneli Kneschke, Simon Rädler, Melanie Gausmann, Christina Duttine, Hilde Haider · 2020 · PLoS ONE
  5. Controlling Presentation Speed, Labels, and Tooltips in Interactive Animations
    Günter Daniel Rey, Stephan Diehl · 2010 · Journal of Media Psychology Theories Methods and Applications
  6. Strategies to reduce the negative effects of spoken explanatory text on integrated tasks
    Anne‐Marie Singh, Nadine Marcus, Paul Ayres · 2016 · Instructional Science
  7. The Effect of Augmented Reality Application toward Student’s Learning Performance in PC Assembly
    Safiani Osman · 2020 · International Journal of Advanced Trends in Computer Science and Engineering
  8. Realism in Dynamic, Static-Sequential, and Static-Simultaneous Visualizations during Knowledge Acquisition on Locomotion Patterns
    Birgit Imhof, Katharina Scheiter, Peter H. Gerjets · 2009 · eScholarship (California Digital Library)
  9. Watching videos of a drawing hand improves students’ understanding of the normal probability distribution
    Icy Zhang, Xiaohan Guo, Ji Yun Son, Idan Blank, James W. Stigler · 2024 · Memory & Cognition
  10. Effects of using cueing in instructional animations on learning and cognitive load level of elementary students in science education
    Rabia Meryem Yılmaz · 2020 · Interactive Learning Environments
  11. Utilising multimedia ESP programme in enhancing flight attendants' safety knowledge and problem solving skills
    Zakaria A. Bani-Salameh, Muhammad Kamarul Kabilan, Lina Bani-Salalmeh · 2010 · British Journal of Educational Technology
  12. Some do's and don'ts of Educational Videos
    Paul Ayres, Kevin Ackermans · 2025 · Learning and Instruction
  13. Reducing Cognitive Overload Among Students of Different Anxiety Levels Using Segmented Animation
    Soon Fook Fong, Lee Pei Lin Lily, Fei Ping Por · 2012 · Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences
  14. Effectiveness of a Program Based on Action-Observation Training (AOT) on Motor, Functional and Cognitive Aspects in Patients with Cognitive Impairment: A Non-Randomized Controlled Trial
    Cecilia Estrada-Barranco, Maria de los Ángeles Martinez-Javaloyes, Isabel Rodríguez‐Costa, Ismael Sanz-Esteban, Alberto Bermejo-Franco, Araceli Aranda-Ruiperez, Maria de los Ángeles Gallegos-Martínez · 2023 · Healthcare
  15. Effect of Interface Dynamism on Learning Procedural Motor Skills
    Olurotimi Richard Akinlofa, Patrik O’Brian Holt, Eyad Elyan · 2013 · Interacting with Computers
  16. Task-appropriate visualizations: Can the very same visualization format either promote or hinder learning depending on the task requirements?
    Alexander Soemer, Stephan Schwan · 2016 · Journal of Educational Psychology
  17. Learning anaesthesia and mirror neurons
    Jhon Bautista, José Ricardo Navarro · 2011 · Revista de la Facultad de Medicina
  18. To Trace or Not to Trace? Mimicry in Timed Multimedia Lessons with Pointing and Tracing
    Stoo Sepp, Shirley Agostinho, Sharon Tindall‐Ford, FRED G. W. C. PAAS · 2023 · Educational Psychology Review
  19. Using iconic hand gestures in teaching a year 8 science lesson
    Brendan Bentley, Kylie Walters, Gregory C. R. Yates · 2023 · Applied Cognitive Psychology
  20. Capturing Movement: A Tablet App, Geometry Touch, for Recording Onscreen Finger-Based Gesture Data
    Stoo Sepp, Sharon Tindall‐Ford, Shirley Agostinho, FRED G. W. C. PAAS · 2023 · IEEE Transactions on Learning Technologies
  21. Domain expertise and the effectiveness of dynamic simulator interfaces in the acquisition of procedural motor skills
    Olurotimi Richard Akinlofa, Patrik O’Brian Holt, Eyad Elyan · 2012 · British Journal of Educational Technology
  22. Effects of observing real, animated and combined model on learning cognitive and motor levels of basketball jump shot in children
    Akbar Ghavami, Hossein Samadi, Amir Dana, Saeed Ghorbani · 2021 · Biomedical Human Kinetics
  23. Emerging Themes in Cognitive Load Theory: The Transient Information and the Collective Working Memory Effects
    John Sweller, Paul Ayres, Slava Kalyuga · 2011 · Springer eBooks
  24. To move or not to move? The effect of active versus passive pre‐training on cognitive load and in‐game performance in an AR game
    Michaela Arztmann, Jessica Lizeth Domínguez Alfaro, Lisette Hornstra, Jacqueline Wong, Johan T. Jeuring, Liesbeth Kester A · 2025 · British Journal of Educational Technology
  25. Does a Drama-Inspired ‘Mirroring’ Exercise Enhance Mathematical Learning?
    Eleni Smyrnis, Paul Ginns · 2016 · The Educational and Developmental Psychologist
  26. The moderating effect of knowledge type on search result modality preferences in web search scenarios
    Georg Pardi, Steffen Gottschling, Peter H. Gerjets, Yvonne Kammerer · 2023 · Computers and Education Open
  27. Interactivity to enhance perception
    Paweł Orzechowski, Douglas Atkinson, Stefano Padilla, Thomas S. Methven, Sharon L. Baurley, Mike J. Chantler · 2011 · International Conference on Human-Computer Interaction with Mobile Devices and Services (MobileHCI)
  28. Generative processing of animated partial depictions fosters fish identification skills: eye tracking evidence
    Jean‐Michel Boucheix, Richard Lowe · 2018 · Le travail humain
  29. Segmentation of Animations
    Spanjers · 2012 · Research Publications (Maastricht University)
  30. Learning computer algorithms through dynamic visualizations: Benefits of ‘ AlgoRythmics ’ videos
    Zoltán Kátai, Erika Osztián · 2023 · Journal of Computer Assisted Learning
  31. Instructional Animations: More Complex to Learn from Than at First Sight?
    Anna Wong, Nadine Marcus, John Sweller · 2011 · Lecture notes in computer science
  32. Investigating the impact of gender-differences and spatial ability on learning from instructional animations
    Ruchi Gupta, Nadine Marcus, Paul Ayres · 2022 · L’Année psychologique
  33. Static vs. Dynamic Representations and the Mediating Role of Behavioral Affect on E-Learning Outcomes
    Yuzhi Sun, David A. Nembhard · 2022 · International Journal of Human-Computer Interaction
  34. The Use of Gesturing to Facilitate Older Adults’ Learning from Computer-Based Dynamic Visualizations
    Kim Ouwehand, Tamara van Gog, FRED G. W. C. PAAS · 2012 · IGI Global eBooks
  35. Measuring cognitive load: a meta-analysis of load measurement sensitivity
    Hodson, Jeffrey L · 2016 · J. Willard Marriott Library
  36. Animation‐guided family empowerment program on perioperative care after neurosurgery: A randomized controlled trial for preventing respiratory complications
    Yunfen Lv, Ziwei Zhao, Xinyi Wu, Yao Wang, Shanshan Qiu · 2024 · Health care science
  37. The Effect of Visual Cueing in 3D Animations for Learning Procedural-manipulative Tasks
    Seyoung Park, Jae-Gil Lee, So-Jeong Kim, Donghee Shin · 2016 · International Conference on Internet of Things, Data and Cloud Computing (ICC)
  38. A Cognitive Load Perspective to Instructional Design for Online Learning
    Onur Dönmez · 2021 · Advances in mobile and distance learning book series
  39. Interactive video module and simulated model for uterine manipulation during laparoscopic hysterectomy
    Anousheh Shafa, Adela G. Cope, Tatnai L. Burnett, Kristopher P. Kolish, Kristin C. Mara, Michelle A. Wyatt, Isabel C. Green · 2022 · Surgical Endoscopy
  40. Multimedia Instructional Message (MIM) and Simulation-Aided Learning: A Conceptual Framework
    Politeknik Seberang Perai, Jalan Permatang Pauh, 13500 Seberang Perai, Pulau Pinang, Malaysia, Mohd Syahrizad Elias, Ahmad Zamzuri Mohamad Ali · 2015 · International Journal of Information and Education Technology
  41. The effect of using visual information aids on learning performance during larger scale procedural task
    Ding‐Hau Huang, Wen‐Ko Chiou · 2010 · Conference on Human System Interactions
  42. La neurodidáctica como elemento primordial en la formación inclusiva docente
    Roberto Figueroa Molina, Mirna Patricia Bernal Martínez, Roberto Thorné Torné · 2021 · Revista Boletín Redipe
  43. Comparing Real and Imitative Practice with No Practice during Observational Learning of Hand Motor Skills from Animations
    Maliha Naushad Mian, Hannah Beder, Nadine Marcus, Paul Ayres · 2024 · Education Sciences
  44. Effects of language fluency and graphic animation on modality choices by adults when following online explanatory demonstrations
    P. Wright, Anthony Soroka, S. Belt, Stefan Dimov, H. Petrie, David De Roure · 2009 · IEEE International Professional Communication Conference (ProComm)
  45. Multimedia Instructions for Motor Control Exercises in Patients With Chronic Nonspecific Low Back Pain
    Utku Berberoğlu, Özlem Ülger · 2023 · Journal of Sport Rehabilitation
  46. A Comparison of Text-Annotated vs. Purely Visio-Spatial Instructions for Video Game Input Sequences
    David Whittinghill, Donald Herring · 2017 · Computers in entertainment
  47. Learning from different multimedia representation formats: effects of prior knowledge
    Chih‐Yi Hsu, Tzu‐Chien Liu, Yi-Chun Lin, Chung-Yuan Hsu, FRED G. W. C. PAAS · 2023 · Journal of Research on Technology in Education
  48. Effects of videos with whole-body movements on young children’s geography learning
    Myrto Foteini Mavilidi, FRED G. W. C. PAAS, Liye Zou, David Revalds Lubans, Leila Mokhtari, Mirko Schmidt, Juan Cristobal Castro-Alonso, Rebecca Ng, Sue Bennett · 2026 · npj Science of Learning
  49. Self-avatar-supported observational learning: Designing and evaluating VR-based physical exercise tutorial systems for older adults
    Ruitong Che, Jiaan Li, Chi DENG, Qian Mao, Jeffrey C. F. Ho, Fiona Nah, Calvin Kalun Or, Hailiang Wang · 2026 · International Journal of Human-Computer Studies
  50. Perspectives on learning with multimodal technology
    Karin Harman James, James C. Lester, Dan Schwartz, Katherine M. Cheng, Sharon L. Oviatt · 2017 · ACM eBooks
  51. The effects of simulation aided learning with various multimedia instructional message strategies on polytechnic Malaysia students' achievement
    Mohd Syahrizad Elias, Ahmad Zamzuri Mohamad Ali · 2017 · International Conference on Science in Information Technology
  52. Application and Research of Basketball Tactics Teaching Assisted by Computer Multimedia Technology
    Lei Yu, Dong Li, Dong Chen, Wenbin Li · 2020 · Advances in intelligent systems and computing
  53. Intersubject synchrony of viewers during naturalistic observational self-learning of a complex bimanual task
    Kathrin Kostorz, Virginia L. Flanagin, Stefan Glasauer · 2022 · Neuroimage Reports
  54. The impact of observing lecturer hand motor actions on the learning of cognitive skills in higher education
    Katharina Rahnert, Gretha Steenkamp, Niklas Jakobsson, Juan Mendelsohn Ontong · 2024 · Acta Psychologica
  55. Dynamic Automated Graphics and Dynamic Interactive Graphics: Tools for Training on Tablet Devices
    Matthew D. Marraffino, John P. Killilea, Michael J. Singer · 2012 · Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting
  56. The Cognitive Benefit of Dynamic Representations on Procedural Skill Acquisition: A Computational Modeling Approach
    Olurotimi Richard Akinlofa, Patrik O’Brian Holt, Eyad Elyan · 2013 · International Journal of Human-Computer Interaction
  57. Γνωστικό φορτίο και πολυμορφικό διδακτικό υλικό στην εξ αποστάσεως εκπαίδευση.
    Ροδάνθη Τσώνη · 2017 · Διεθνές Συνέδριο για την Ανοικτή & εξ Αποστάσεως Εκπαίδευση
  58. Using Interactive E-Books in Elementary School Origami Activities: Analysis of Learning Effect, Learning Motivation, and Cognitive Load
    Wen-Jung Chu, Hong-Ren Chen · 2018 · IEEE Annual International Computer Software and Applications Conference (COMPSAC)
  59. Difficultés rencontrées par les étudiants dans la recherche en ligne et l’utilisation de documents audio-visuels dans des travaux évalués
    Emmanuelle Papinot · 2021 · Revue internationale des technologies en pédagogie universitaire
  60. The Virtual Breadboard: Helping Students to Learn Electrical Engineering at a Distance
    Lori L. Scarlatos, Ahmad Pratama, Tatiana Tchoubar · 2018
  61. Engaging Students with Multiple Representations of Mathematical Models
    Pradip Peter Dey · 2024 · ASEE Pacific Southwest Section Meeting
  62. Effects of observing and producing deictic gestures on memory and learning in different age groups
    Kim Ouwehand · 2016 · EUR Research Repository (Erasmus University Rotterdam)
  63. Guidelines for Psychomotor Skill Instruction for Athletic Performance: A Design and Development Study
    Allison Victoria Randall · 2018 · VTechWorks (Virginia Tech)
  64. L’apprentissage de procédures médicales par vidéo : effets de la segmentation et du contrôle du rythme par l’apprenant
    Nicolas Biard · 2019 · theses.fr (ABES)
  65. The Role of Dynamic Visualizations and Spatial Layout of Static Visualizations for Learning How to Classify Locomotion Patterns
    Birgit Imhof, Katharina Scheiter, Peter H. Gerjets, Jörg Edelmann · 2010 · eScholarship (California Digital Library)
  66. Mental Rotation and Learning Procedural Motor Tasks from Instructional Media
    Theodore B. Garland · 2012
  67. Some Motion Models of Artificial Animals and Momentarily Continously Switching of the Models
    Guo Wei Yang, Wei Liu · 2011 · Key engineering materials
  68. Motion Models of Artificial Animals and Momentarily Continously Switching of the Models
    Guo Wei Yang, Yang Yang · 2010 · Applied Mechanics and Materials
  69. The Scrollbar and Learner-control of Instructional Animations: Some Exploratory Studies
    George Hatsidimitris · 2010 · E-Learn: World Conference on E-Learning in Corporate, Government, Healthcare, and Higher Education
  70. An investigation into the effects of presentation modality and visual representation on recall and cognitive load: learning aspects of electroencephalogram (EEG) net application
    Lewis Barber · 2011 · e-space (Manchester Metropolitan University)
  71. Characterizing Virtual Prototype Constructability Programming for the Pictographic Instruction of Procedure
    Brendan Ashley Johnston · 2012 · VTechWorks (Virginia Tech)
  72. Rethinking e-learning strategy 2.0 in the digital age : case study of the future school project in the Kingdom of Bahrain
    Ahmed A. Mohammed · 2015
  73. Effectiveness of virtual experiential learning for cognitive load reduction on traffic rules education
    Sirilak Borirug · 2016 · Murdoch University Research Portal
  74. Examining the Effects of Interactive Dynamic Multimedia and Direct Touch Input on Performance of a Procedural Motor Task
    Matthew D. Marraffino · 2014 · Journal of International Crisis and Risk Communication Research
  75. Investigating the Effects of Pre-Laboratory Videos with Associated Questions on the Performance and Overall Laboratory Experience of Organic Chemistry Students
    Shareef Gamal Mohamed Kotb · 2017
  76. Effects of animation on students’ understanding of a novel
    Elvin Selvadasan Kanapathy · 2013
  77. The Role of Gesture Observation and Imitation in Learning (Artificial) Grammar Rules From Dynamic Visualizations
    Lysanne S. Post · 2019 · RePub (Erasmus University Rotterdam)
  78. Designing Animated (and Interactive) Infographics for Remote Learning
    Shalin Hai-Jew · 2020 · Advances in educational technologies and instructional design book series
  79. Development of Fundamental Nursing Instructional Teaching Media for Nursing Student of Suratthani Rajabhat University, Thailand
    Nittaya Srisuk · 2020 · International Journal of Nursing Education
  80. Meaningful Hand Gestures for Learning with Touch-based I.C.T.
    Stoo Sepp · 2019 · Research Online (University of Wollongong)
  81. Principles Based on Social and Affective Features of Multimedia Learning
    Richard E. Mayer, Logan Fiorella · 2021 · Cambridge University Press eBooks
  82. References
    Ruth Colvin Clark, Richard E. Mayer · 2011 · Wiley eBooks
  83. References
    Ruth Colvin Clark, Richard E. Mayer · 2016 · Wiley eBooks
  84. Incorporation of Virtual Learning Environments for Online STEM Activities
    Stefan Kleinke, Brian Sanders, Mark Miller · 2020 · ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition
  85. Examining the holistic course delivery in an integrated system administration course
    Patrick Duane Dunston · 2023 · Digital Repository Service (Northeastern University)
  86. Augmented and Mixed Reality Procedural Task Training Effectiveness and User Experience
    Emily Rickel, Barbara S. Chaparro · 2025 · Lecture notes in computer science
  87. User Preferences for Multimedia in Collaborative Processes for Complex Manual Tasks in Mixed-Reality Environments
    Ruoyan Wang, Chengqi Xue · 2025 · International Conference on Control, Automation and Robotics (ICCAR)
  88. Recherche de vidéos académiques dans les collections en ligne : approche ergonomique
    Emmanuelle Papinot · 2018 · theses.fr (ABES)
  89. Ergonomie cognitive des manuels scolaires numériques
    Ikram Malti · 2018
  90. Approche psycho-ergonomique de l'usage de la simulation en e-learning pour l'apprentissage de procédures : le cas du point de suture
    Leslie Jannin · 2020 · theses.fr (ABES)
  91. AgentHands: Generating Interactive Hand Gestures for Spatially Grounded Agent Conversations in XR
    Ziyi Liu, David Li, Zhongyi Zhou, David Kim, Ruofei Du, Xun Qian · 2026 · CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems
  92. How Do Inhibitory Control Abilities Influence the Effects of Animations Combined With the Presence of Seductive Details on Primary School Children's Performance?
    Tiphaine Colliot, Guillaume de Pereyra, Jean‐Michel Boucheix · 2026 · Applied Cognitive Psychology