CoChat

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 104 of the 104 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; 9 of the 47 sources its claims cite were checked for support.

Descending networks transform command signals into population motor control

Open access
Braun, Jonas, Hurtak, Femke, Wang-Chen, Sibo, Ramdya, Pavan · 2024 · Nature

Published version of a preprint

Abstract

To convert intentions into actions, movement instructions must pass from the brain to downstream motor circuits through descending neurons (DNs). These include small sets of command-like neurons that are sufficient to drive behaviours 1 —the circuit mechanisms for which remain unclear. Here we show that command-like DNs in Drosophila directly recruit networks of additional DNs to orchestrate behaviours that require the active control of numerous body parts. Specifically, we found that command-like DNs previously thought to drive behaviours alone 2–4 in fact co-activate larger populations of DNs. Connectome analyses and experimental manipulations revealed that this functional recruitment can be explained by direct excitatory connections between command-like DNs and networks of interconnected DNs in the brain. Descending population recruitment is necessary for behavioural control: DNs with many downstream descending partners require network co-activation to drive complete behaviours and drive only simple stereotyped movements in their absence. These DN networks reside within behaviour-specific clusters that inhibit one another. These results support a mechanism for command-like descending control in which behaviours are generated through the recruitment of increasingly large DN networks that compose behaviours by combining multiple motor subroutines.

Overview

CoChat Summary

TL;DR

Command-like descending neurons (comDNs) in *Drosophila* recruit additional descending neuron (DN) populations through direct excitatory brain connections, rather than acting alone. The size of a comDN’s downstream DN network predicts whether that recruitment is necessary to produce a complete behaviour.

Key findings

  • Optogenetic activation of DNp09, aDN2 and MDN recruited GNG DN populations significantly more than controls: P = 0.018 (DNp09), P = 0.040 (aDN2) and P = 0.008 (MDN). Recruitment strength followed DNp09 > aDN2 > MDN.
  • Connectome analysis found monosynaptic downstream DN partners numbering 32 for DNp09, 23 for aDN2 and 14 for MDN, mirroring the functional recruitment gradient. Across all DNs, median connected DNs were 4; MDN 9, aDN2 15 and DNp09 23; 567 DNs (44%) targeted two or fewer DNs.
  • Decapitation showed network necessity: MDN still drove backwards walking in headless flies (P = 0.265 versus intact), whereas DNp09-driven forwards walking and aDN2-driven antennal grooming were lost (P = 0.006 each). Headless DNp09 and aDN2 flies still showed stereotyped abdomen contraction (P = 0.006) and front leg approach (P = 0.030), respectively.
  • DN networks formed behaviour-related clusters: Louvain clustering found 12 clusters in the real network versus 34 smaller clusters in a shuffled network; modularity was 0.27 for the original network and 0.12 for the shuffled network. Within clusters connectivity was predominantly excitatory, while between-cluster connectivity was dominated by inhibition.

Methods

  • All-optical experiments in female adult *Drosophila*: comDNs were optogenetically activated with CsChrimson while GNG DN axons in the thoracic cervical connective were imaged with two-photon calcium imaging using Dfd-LexA > GCaMP6s; behaviour was tracked on spherical or cylindrical treadmills, including intact, headless and VNC-resected preparations.
  • Connectome analyses used the female adult fly brain (FAFB/FlyWire) dataset and the male adult nerve cord (MANC) dataset; connectivity was counted at ≥5 synapses, neurotransmitter identity was classified, and DN–DN networks were analysed with Louvain clustering and shuffled-network controls.
  • Behavioural and neural comparisons used two-sided Mann–Whitney U-tests, with trial averaging and biological replicates as the unit for statistical comparison.

Limitations

  • Stated: the Dfd driver excludes Scr-positive GNG DNs, so the study probably under-reports the number of recruited GNG DNs; Scr-based imaging was difficult because Scr expression extends into the neck and anterior VNC.
  • Stated: the aDN2-spGAL4 line contains off-target neurons, and DNp09 stimulation produced variable phenotypes across studies and expression levels; GCaMP6s fluorescence does not reliably reflect inhibition, so reduced fluorescence was not interpreted as inhibition.
  • Stated/evident: optogenetic stimulation may be non-ethological, and comparisons with natural behaviour showed differences for DNp09 and, to a lesser extent, aDN2; connectome analyses also rely on female brain and male VNC datasets, while functional experiments used female flies.

Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1038/s41586-024-07523-9

Cites

104 of 104 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Nothing to recompute.

Figures

Fig. 1 Optical approach to probe the relationship between comDNs and popDNs in behaving animals. a, Schematic of the Drosophila nervous system showing a pair of DNs that project from the brain to motor circuits in the VNC (left). Activation of small sets of comDNs (green) can drive complete behaviours. Thus, comDNs are thought to send simple, high-level control signals to the VNC, where they are transformed into complex, multi-joint movements. However, larger popDNs (orange) are also known to become active during natural behaviours (right). Therefore, in another model, individual DNs contribute to complex behaviours by sending low-level signals that control the fine-grained movements of individual or sparse sets of joints. b, We stimulated three sets of comDNs to elicit three distinct behaviours: forwards walking (DNp09, green)3,14, antennal grooming (aDN2, red)4 and backwards walking (MDN, cyan) (left)2. DN cell body locations are schematized. Two coarse subdivisions of the adult Drosophila brain are the cerebral ganglia (CRG; previously known as the supraoesophageal ganglion) and the GNG (also known as the suboesophageal ganglion) (right)59. We recorded from DNs within the GNG, which houses most DNs14. c, We recorded neural activity in the axons of GNG DN populations (orange) during optogenetic stimulation of different sets of comDNs (green). The grey dashed line denotes a coronal section region of interest in the thoracic cervical connective illustrating DN axon cross-sections (orange ellipses). d, A system for recording behaviour, GNG DN neural activity29 and optogenetically stimulating comDN axons in the neck connective (schema not to scale). The inset shows a camera image of a fly with focused laser light on its neck. Superimposed on the camera image are pose estimation key points (light blue).
Fig. 1 Optical approach to probe the relationship between comDNs and popDNs in behaving animals. a, Schematic of the Drosophila nervous system showing a pair of DNs that project from the brain to motor circuits in the VNC (left). Activation of small sets of comDNs (green) can drive complete behaviours. Thus, comDNs are thought to send simple, high-level control signals to the VNC, where they are transformed into complex, multi-joint movements. However, larger popDNs (orange) are also known to become active during natural behaviours (right). Therefore, in another model, individual DNs contribute to complex behaviours by sending low-level signals that control the fine-grained movements of individual or sparse sets of joints. b, We stimulated three sets of comDNs to elicit three distinct behaviours: forwards walking (DNp09, green)3,14, antennal grooming (aDN2, red)4 and backwards walking (MDN, cyan) (left)2. DN cell body locations are schematized. Two coarse subdivisions of the adult Drosophila brain are the cerebral ganglia (CRG; previously known as the supraoesophageal ganglion) and the GNG (also known as the suboesophageal ganglion) (right)59. We recorded from DNs within the GNG, which houses most DNs14. c, We recorded neural activity in the axons of GNG DN populations (orange) during optogenetic stimulation of different sets of comDNs (green). The grey dashed line denotes a coronal section region of interest in the thoracic cervical connective illustrating DN axon cross-sections (orange ellipses). d, A system for recording behaviour, GNG DN neural activity29 and optogenetically stimulating comDN axons in the neck connective (schema not to scale). The inset shows a camera image of a fly with focused laser light on its neck. Superimposed on the camera image are pose estimation key points (light blue).CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 2 Activation of comDNs recruits larger, distinct DN populations. Optogenetic stimulation of comDNs: DNp09 (forwards walking, n = 5 flies, 120 stimulation trials), aDN2 (antennal grooming, n = 3 flies, 34 trials) and MDN (backwards walking, n = 9 flies, 271 trials). Control: no DN expression (n = 3 flies, 47 trials). a, Forwards walking velocities (top) and the probability of classified behaviours (bottom) during optogenetic stimulation (grey bar). b, Images illustrating GNG DN population activity upon comDN stimulation. For each, one representative animal is shown (as in Supplementary Video 1; n = 33, 10, 97 and 10 trials for DNp09, aDN2, MDN and control flies, respectively). The same flies are shown in panels c,d. c, Single-neuron responses to DN stimulation. Circles are scaled or colour coded to represent the maximum change in fluorescence (normalized ΔF/F) of one detected DN axon or region of interest (ROI). The small white dots indicate responses smaller than the 95% CI of the trial mean. d, Trial-averaged single ROI responses across time, ordered by response magnitude. Response magnitude is colour coded or white if smaller than the 95% CI. The red dashed line indicates the number of activated ROIs (that is, positive response larger than the 95% CI). e,f, A registered overlay (e) or density visualization (f) of the data from multiple flies analysed as in c. The number of flies or trials is identical to a. g–i, Statistical comparison of the number of activated ROIs (that is, red dashed line in d) (g), the fraction of activated ROIs (that is, divided by the number of visible ROIs) (h) and the strength of activation (that is, the sum of the normalized ΔF/F for positively activated neurons) (i) using two-sided Mann–Whitney U-tests (n as in a; P values for each comparison to control: DNp09 = 0.018, aDN2 = 0.040 and MDN = 0.008). The shaded areas in a and the error bars in g–i represent 95% CI of the mean. ***P < 0.001, *P < 0.05. Source Data
Fig. 2 Activation of comDNs recruits larger, distinct DN populations. Optogenetic stimulation of comDNs: DNp09 (forwards walking, n = 5 flies, 120 stimulation trials), aDN2 (antennal grooming, n = 3 flies, 34 trials) and MDN (backwards walking, n = 9 flies, 271 trials). Control: no DN expression (n = 3 flies, 47 trials). a, Forwards walking velocities (top) and the probability of classified behaviours (bottom) during optogenetic stimulation (grey bar). b, Images illustrating GNG DN population activity upon comDN stimulation. For each, one representative animal is shown (as in Supplementary Video 1; n = 33, 10, 97 and 10 trials for DNp09, aDN2, MDN and control flies, respectively). The same flies are shown in panels c,d. c, Single-neuron responses to DN stimulation. Circles are scaled or colour coded to represent the maximum change in fluorescence (normalized ΔF/F) of one detected DN axon or region of interest (ROI). The small white dots indicate responses smaller than the 95% CI of the trial mean. d, Trial-averaged single ROI responses across time, ordered by response magnitude. Response magnitude is colour coded or white if smaller than the 95% CI. The red dashed line indicates the number of activated ROIs (that is, positive response larger than the 95% CI). e,f, A registered overlay (e) or density visualization (f) of the data from multiple flies analysed as in c. The number of flies or trials is identical to a. g–i, Statistical comparison of the number of activated ROIs (that is, red dashed line in d) (g), the fraction of activated ROIs (that is, divided by the number of visible ROIs) (h) and the strength of activation (that is, the sum of the normalized ΔF/F for positively activated neurons) (i) using two-sided Mann–Whitney U-tests (n as in a; P values for each comparison to control: DNp09 = 0.018, aDN2 = 0.040 and MDN = 0.008). The shaded areas in a and the error bars in g–i represent 95% CI of the mean. ***P < 0.001, *P < 0.05. Source DataCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 3 ComDNs connect to other DNs, forming larger DN networks. a, The neuronal morphologies of three sets of comDNs in the female adult fly brain connectome: DNp09 (left), aDN2 (middle) and MDN (right)7. b, The location and morphologies of DNs directly (monosynaptically) targeted by comDNs. DNs are colour coded based on their cell body localization in the GNG (orange) or CRG (purple). Command-like neurons are colour coded as in a. c, ComDNs form monosynaptic excitatory connections to downstream DN targets. Edge weights reflect the number of synapses as shown in d, with consistent scaling across all plots. Edge colours denote whether synapses are excitatory (red), inhibitory (blue) or glutamatergic (pink), which can be excitatory or inhibitory depending on the receptor type60. DNs are colour coded as in b. d, Network connectivity among downstream DNs shows strong recurrence and minimal feedback to comDNs (only in aDN2). e, The cumulative number of downstream DNs that three sets of command-like neurons—DNp09 (green lines; 2 DNs), aDN2 (red lines; 2 DNs), MDN (cyan lines; 4 DNs)—connect to across an increasing number of DN–DN synapses or ‘hops’. This is compared with the number of DNs accessible over an increasing number of hops for all DNs (grey lines) and the median of all DNs (black line). Many DNs do not connect to any other DN, and 455 DNs only receive inputs from maximally one other DN, limiting the maximum number of recruited DNs to approximately 800.
Fig. 3 ComDNs connect to other DNs, forming larger DN networks. a, The neuronal morphologies of three sets of comDNs in the female adult fly brain connectome: DNp09 (left), aDN2 (middle) and MDN (right)7. b, The location and morphologies of DNs directly (monosynaptically) targeted by comDNs. DNs are colour coded based on their cell body localization in the GNG (orange) or CRG (purple). Command-like neurons are colour coded as in a. c, ComDNs form monosynaptic excitatory connections to downstream DN targets. Edge weights reflect the number of synapses as shown in d, with consistent scaling across all plots. Edge colours denote whether synapses are excitatory (red), inhibitory (blue) or glutamatergic (pink), which can be excitatory or inhibitory depending on the receptor type60. DNs are colour coded as in b. d, Network connectivity among downstream DNs shows strong recurrence and minimal feedback to comDNs (only in aDN2). e, The cumulative number of downstream DNs that three sets of command-like neurons—DNp09 (green lines; 2 DNs), aDN2 (red lines; 2 DNs), MDN (cyan lines; 4 DNs)—connect to across an increasing number of DN–DN synapses or ‘hops’. This is compared with the number of DNs accessible over an increasing number of hops for all DNs (grey lines) and the median of all DNs (black line). Many DNs do not connect to any other DN, and 455 DNs only receive inputs from maximally one other DN, limiting the maximum number of recruited DNs to approximately 800.CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 4 Recruited DN networks are required for forwards walking and grooming, but not for backwards walking. a, In intact animals (left), activation of a comDN (green) recruits other DNs (orange) and leads to the execution of a complete behaviour. In headless animals (right), the axons of comDNs (green) can still be activated in the VNC. However, other DN axons (orange) cannot be recruited in the brain and remain silent. This comparison between intact and headless animals allows one to isolate the necessity of downstream DN networks to generate complete behaviours. b–e, Forwards walking velocities and behaviour probabilities for DNp09 (b), aDN2 (c), MDN (d) or control (e) flies. Mann–Whitney U-tests compare the difference between the means of the first 2.5 s of optogenetic stimulation across intact (black traces) versus headless (blue traces) animals. f, DNp09 stimulation in both intact and headless animals leads to abdominal contraction (change in Euclidian distance between the anal plate and the ventral side of the most posterior stripe). Mann–Whitney U-test compares the mean of the first 2.5 s of stimulation (blue bars) for headless DNp09 versus headless control animals (blue traces). g, aDN2 stimulation in both intact and headless animals leads to front leg approach (change in Euclidian distance between the front leg tibia–tarsus joint and the neck). Mann–Whitney U-test compares the first 2.5 s of stimulation (blue bars) between headless aDN2 and headless control animals (blue traces). All plots in b–g show data from n = 5 flies with 10 trials each (trial mean and 95% CI (shaded area)). Two-sided Mann–Whitney U-tests compare the trial mean across different flies. ***P < 0.001, **P < 0.01, *P < 0.05 and not significant (NS) P > 0.05. For exact P values, see Supplementary Table 5. Source Data
Fig. 4 Recruited DN networks are required for forwards walking and grooming, but not for backwards walking. a, In intact animals (left), activation of a comDN (green) recruits other DNs (orange) and leads to the execution of a complete behaviour. In headless animals (right), the axons of comDNs (green) can still be activated in the VNC. However, other DN axons (orange) cannot be recruited in the brain and remain silent. This comparison between intact and headless animals allows one to isolate the necessity of downstream DN networks to generate complete behaviours. b–e, Forwards walking velocities and behaviour probabilities for DNp09 (b), aDN2 (c), MDN (d) or control (e) flies. Mann–Whitney U-tests compare the difference between the means of the first 2.5 s of optogenetic stimulation across intact (black traces) versus headless (blue traces) animals. f, DNp09 stimulation in both intact and headless animals leads to abdominal contraction (change in Euclidian distance between the anal plate and the ventral side of the most posterior stripe). Mann–Whitney U-test compares the mean of the first 2.5 s of stimulation (blue bars) for headless DNp09 versus headless control animals (blue traces). g, aDN2 stimulation in both intact and headless animals leads to front leg approach (change in Euclidian distance between the front leg tibia–tarsus joint and the neck). Mann–Whitney U-test compares the first 2.5 s of stimulation (blue bars) between headless aDN2 and headless control animals (blue traces). All plots in b–g show data from n = 5 flies with 10 trials each (trial mean and 95% CI (shaded area)). Two-sided Mann–Whitney U-tests compare the trial mean across different flies. ***P < 0.001, **P < 0.01, *P < 0.05 and not significant (NS) P > 0.05. For exact P values, see Supplementary Table 5. Source DataCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 5 Network connectivity accurately predicts the necessity for downstream DNs to drive behaviour. a, For the comDNs investigated, three important properties covary in a continuum that spans from broadcaster DNs to standalone DNs. Schematized along this continuum are our three comDNs, giant fibre (GF) neurons and nine additional tested neurons: DNp42, aDN1, DNa01, DNb02, DNa02, oviDN, DNg11, Mute and DNg14. b, For each Drosophila DN, the total (grey) or GNG-based (orange) number of monosynaptically downstream DNs. ComDNs are colour coded. The inset shows median and 25% and 75% quantiles (left violin plot, n = 1,303) comparing all DNs to DNp09, aDN2 and MDN. c, The number of DNs directly downstream of nine additional sets of DNs (colour-coded circles as in a) for which connectome-based experimental predictions are made. All DNs (grey) shown are as in b. d, The morphology of two sets of DNs (DNb02 and DNg14) in the female adult fly brain connectome. e, Monosynaptic connectivity for two tested DNs (DNb02 and DNg14). Edge weights denote the number of glutamatergic synapses (pink). f, Absolute, undirected turn velocity for DNb02 (top) and control (bottom) animals upon laser stimulation. g, Abdomen dipping for DNg14 (top) and control (bottom) animals upon laser stimulation (change in anal plate vertical position). In f,g, data are shown for intact (black traces) and headless (blue traces) animals. The number of animals is indicated for each condition. Each fly was optogenetically stimulated ten times. Traces show the average and 95% CI across n × 10 trials. Two-sided Mann–Whitney U-tests comparing the trial mean of intact and headless animals (black bars) or comparing headless experimental with headless control flies (blue bars, between top and bottom plots). **P < 0.01, *P < 0.05 and NS P > 0.05. For exact P values, see Supplementary Table 5. Source Data
Fig. 5 Network connectivity accurately predicts the necessity for downstream DNs to drive behaviour. a, For the comDNs investigated, three important properties covary in a continuum that spans from broadcaster DNs to standalone DNs. Schematized along this continuum are our three comDNs, giant fibre (GF) neurons and nine additional tested neurons: DNp42, aDN1, DNa01, DNb02, DNa02, oviDN, DNg11, Mute and DNg14. b, For each Drosophila DN, the total (grey) or GNG-based (orange) number of monosynaptically downstream DNs. ComDNs are colour coded. The inset shows median and 25% and 75% quantiles (left violin plot, n = 1,303) comparing all DNs to DNp09, aDN2 and MDN. c, The number of DNs directly downstream of nine additional sets of DNs (colour-coded circles as in a) for which connectome-based experimental predictions are made. All DNs (grey) shown are as in b. d, The morphology of two sets of DNs (DNb02 and DNg14) in the female adult fly brain connectome. e, Monosynaptic connectivity for two tested DNs (DNb02 and DNg14). Edge weights denote the number of glutamatergic synapses (pink). f, Absolute, undirected turn velocity for DNb02 (top) and control (bottom) animals upon laser stimulation. g, Abdomen dipping for DNg14 (top) and control (bottom) animals upon laser stimulation (change in anal plate vertical position). In f,g, data are shown for intact (black traces) and headless (blue traces) animals. The number of animals is indicated for each condition. Each fly was optogenetically stimulated ten times. Traces show the average and 95% CI across n × 10 trials. Two-sided Mann–Whitney U-tests comparing the trial mean of intact and headless animals (black bars) or comparing headless experimental with headless control flies (blue bars, between top and bottom plots). **P < 0.01, *P < 0.05 and NS P > 0.05. For exact P values, see Supplementary Table 5. Source DataCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 6 Networks of DNs for similar behaviours excite one another and inhibit those for other behaviours. a, The connectivity distribution of the DN–DN network (black), the same data after shuffling individual connections (red), the best exponential fit (green) or the best power law fit (blue). b, DN–DN connectivity clusters (grey squares) indicating excitatory (red) and inhibitory (blue) connectivity between presynaptic DNs (rows) and postsynaptic DNs (columns). The numbers on the right side indicate cluster numbers in d,f–i. c, As in b, but for a network with shuffled DN–DN connectivity. d, The number of synapses (excitatory minus inhibitory) between any two clusters normalized by the number of DNs in the postsynaptic cluster. e, As in d, but for the shuffled network in c. f, Fraction of known DNs within each cluster projecting to different VNC neuropil regions. Anm, abdominal neuromere; HTct, haltere tectulum; IntTct, intermediate tectulum; LTct, lower tectulum; mVAC, medial ventral association centre; NTct, neck tectulum; Ov, ovoid; T1–T3, leg neuropils; WTct, wing tectulum. Data are from ref. 13. g, Fraction of known DNs within each cluster associated with distinct behaviours. Data are taken from the literature (Supplementary Table 8). Open squares indicate clusters containing fewer than five known DNs (f,g). h, The distribution of experimentally investigated DNs across DN clusters. i, A network visualization of clusters in d with associated behaviours from g. There are predominantly excitatory (red) connections within each DN cluster and inhibitory (blue) connections between clusters.
Fig. 6 Networks of DNs for similar behaviours excite one another and inhibit those for other behaviours. a, The connectivity distribution of the DN–DN network (black), the same data after shuffling individual connections (red), the best exponential fit (green) or the best power law fit (blue). b, DN–DN connectivity clusters (grey squares) indicating excitatory (red) and inhibitory (blue) connectivity between presynaptic DNs (rows) and postsynaptic DNs (columns). The numbers on the right side indicate cluster numbers in d,f–i. c, As in b, but for a network with shuffled DN–DN connectivity. d, The number of synapses (excitatory minus inhibitory) between any two clusters normalized by the number of DNs in the postsynaptic cluster. e, As in d, but for the shuffled network in c. f, Fraction of known DNs within each cluster projecting to different VNC neuropil regions. Anm, abdominal neuromere; HTct, haltere tectulum; IntTct, intermediate tectulum; LTct, lower tectulum; mVAC, medial ventral association centre; NTct, neck tectulum; Ov, ovoid; T1–T3, leg neuropils; WTct, wing tectulum. Data are from ref. 13. g, Fraction of known DNs within each cluster associated with distinct behaviours. Data are taken from the literature (Supplementary Table 8). Open squares indicate clusters containing fewer than five known DNs (f,g). h, The distribution of experimentally investigated DNs across DN clusters. i, A network visualization of clusters in d with associated behaviours from g. There are predominantly excitatory (red) connections within each DN cluster and inhibitory (blue) connections between clusters.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 1 DN driver lines and optogenetic stimulation strategy. (a) Z-projected confocal images of the brain (top) and VNC (bottom) show the expression of UAS-CsChrimson.mVenus (green) in command-like DNs, membrane-bound tdTomato in the Dfd driver line (red), and neuropil (‘nc82’, blue). The location of command-like DN cell bodies is indicated (white arrowheads). Scalebars are 100 μm. (b) Z-projected confocal image of Dfd driver line expression of soma-targeted mCherry. Only brain neurons in the GNG are labeled. Scalebar is 100 μm. (c) Confocal image of the posterior GNG with Dfd driver line expression of soma-targeted mCherry and aDN2 expression of UAS-CsChrimson.mVenus (green). The two GNG-DNs in the aDN2 driver line are not targeted by the Dfd driver line. Scalebar is 20 μm. Immunohistochemistry and confocal imaging experiments in (a-c) were performed once due to the reliability of these methods. (d) Behavioral responses to optogenetic stimulation of the neck connective at different laser intensities for DNp09 (left; 4 flies, total 49 trials per condition), aDN2 (left-middle; 4 flies, total 60 trials per condition), MDN (right-middle; 4 flies, total 50 trials per condition), and no DN control (right; 3 flies, total 60 trials per condition) animals. Flies reliably (i) walk forward upon DNp09 stimulation for stimuli ≥ 21 μW, (ii) groom upon aDN2 stimulation only for the highest stimulation power (41.6 μW) but rest at 21 μW, and (iii) walk backward upon MDN stimulation for stimuli ≥ 10.5 μW. For all stimulation intensities, control flies walk more and rest less. Thus, we selected 21 μW as our default laser stimulation power and 41.6 μW for aDN2 stimulation specifically. (e) MDN stimulation with focused laser light elicits backward walking when illuminating the anterior dorsal thorax (left, as in Figs. 4 and 5), the neck (middle, as in Fig. 2) or the head (right). 3 flies, total 30 stimulation trials per condition. (f) Stimulation of a brain-specific neuron (‘Bolt protocerebral neurons’ or BPN) known to drive forward walking3 with focused laser light elicits forward walking when illuminating the head (right), but not the thorax (left). Laser light focused on the neck (middle) can only elicit weak forward walking at 41.6 μW. 4 flies, total 40 stimulation trials per condition. (g) Silencing GNG neurons (Dfd-LexA > LexAop-GtACR1) with focused 561 nm laser light elicits anterior grooming when illuminating the head (right), neck (middle), or thorax (left). 3 flies, total of 30 stimulation trials per condition. All velocity traces in (d,e,f) show mean ± 95% confidence interval of the mean across stimulation trials.
Extended Data Fig. 1 DN driver lines and optogenetic stimulation strategy. (a) Z-projected confocal images of the brain (top) and VNC (bottom) show the expression of UAS-CsChrimson.mVenus (green) in command-like DNs, membrane-bound tdTomato in the Dfd driver line (red), and neuropil (‘nc82’, blue). The location of command-like DN cell bodies is indicated (white arrowheads). Scalebars are 100 μm. (b) Z-projected confocal image of Dfd driver line expression of soma-targeted mCherry. Only brain neurons in the GNG are labeled. Scalebar is 100 μm. (c) Confocal image of the posterior GNG with Dfd driver line expression of soma-targeted mCherry and aDN2 expression of UAS-CsChrimson.mVenus (green). The two GNG-DNs in the aDN2 driver line are not targeted by the Dfd driver line. Scalebar is 20 μm. Immunohistochemistry and confocal imaging experiments in (a-c) were performed once due to the reliability of these methods. (d) Behavioral responses to optogenetic stimulation of the neck connective at different laser intensities for DNp09 (left; 4 flies, total 49 trials per condition), aDN2 (left-middle; 4 flies, total 60 trials per condition), MDN (right-middle; 4 flies, total 50 trials per condition), and no DN control (right; 3 flies, total 60 trials per condition) animals. Flies reliably (i) walk forward upon DNp09 stimulation for stimuli ≥ 21 μW, (ii) groom upon aDN2 stimulation only for the highest stimulation power (41.6 μW) but rest at 21 μW, and (iii) walk backward upon MDN stimulation for stimuli ≥ 10.5 μW. For all stimulation intensities, control flies walk more and rest less. Thus, we selected 21 μW as our default laser stimulation power and 41.6 μW for aDN2 stimulation specifically. (e) MDN stimulation with focused laser light elicits backward walking when illuminating the anterior dorsal thorax (left, as in Figs. 4 and 5), the neck (middle, as in Fig. 2) or the head (right). 3 flies, total 30 stimulation trials per condition. (f) Stimulation of a brain-specific neuron (‘Bolt protocerebral neurons’ or BPN) known to drive forward walking3 with focused laser light elicits forward walking when illuminating the head (right), but not the thorax (left). Laser light focused on the neck (middle) can only elicit weak forward walking at 41.6 μW. 4 flies, total 40 stimulation trials per condition. (g) Silencing GNG neurons (Dfd-LexA > LexAop-GtACR1) with focused 561 nm laser light elicits anterior grooming when illuminating the head (right), neck (middle), or thorax (left). 3 flies, total of 30 stimulation trials per condition. All velocity traces in (d,e,f) show mean ± 95% confidence interval of the mean across stimulation trials.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 2 Comparison of GNG-DN population neural activity during optogenetic stimulation versus corresponding natural behaviors. (a-c) For (a) DNp09 and forward walking, (b) aDN2 and anterior grooming, or (c) MDN and backward walking: (left) behavioral responses to optogenetic stimulation of command-like DNs (black) versus natural occurrences of the behavior in question (color); (middle left) single neuron/ROI responses (analyzed as in Fig. 2c). Here the left half-circle reflects the response to optogenetic activation and the right half-circle the activity during natural behavior; (middle) single neuron average responses as in Fig. 2d; (middle right) Comparing the activity of individual neurons between optogenetic stimulation (black) and natural behavior (color). Neurons/ROIs are sorted by the magnitude of their responses to optogenetic activation. Shaded areas indicate 95% confidence interval of the mean across trials. Pearson correlation between optogenetic and spontaneous response and significance of test against null-hypothesis (the two variables are uncorrelated, see Methods) are shown; (right) Confusion matrix comparing the number of active neurons/ROIs that were more active (+), similar (~), or less active (−) upon optogenetic stimulation versus during natural behavior. (a) DNp09: for one fly n=23 optogenetic stimulation trials (not forward walking before stimulus) and 28 instances of spontaneous forward walking in which the fly was not walking forward for at least 1 s and then walking forward for at least 1 s (correlation: ρ = − 0.022, p = 0.356, N = 66 neurons, two-sided test, see Methods). (b) aDN2: for one fly, n = 20 optogenetic stimulation trials (pre-stimulus behavior not restricted) and 16 instances of anterior grooming elicited by a 5 s humidified air puff (correlation: ρ = 0.277, p = 0.022, N = 68 neurons, two-sided test, see Methods). Indicated are central neurons/ROIs with strong activation during aDN2 stimulation of the neck cervical connective as in Fig. 2f. (c) MDN: for one fly, n = 80 optogenetic stimulation trials (pre-stimulus behavior not restricted) and 21 instances of spontaneous backward walking on a cylindrical treadmill in which the fly was not walking backward for 1 s and then walked backward for at least 1 s (correlation: ρ = 0.746, p < 0.001, N = 60 neurons, two-sided test, see Methods). (d) Density visualisation (as in Fig. 2f) of neural responses to DNp09 stimulation and spontaneous forward walking across three animals. The difference in responses is primarily localized to the medial but not lateral regions of the connective. To maximize comparability, only trials where the fly was not walking forward before stimulus onset were selected. (e) Same plot as in a, middle right but for three animals with DNp09 stimulation and forward walking. Indicated are the correlation values when including (ρ = − 0.083, p = 0.564, n = 172 neurons across three flies, two-sided test, see Methods) or excluding (ρ = 0.564, p < 0.001, n = 142 neurons across three flies, two-sided test, see Methods) the ten neurons most activated by optogenetic stimulation (orange region). (f) The locations of ten neurons indicated in e within the connective of three flies (top) and their single neuron responses to optogenetic stimulation (bottom, black traces) or during natural backward walking (bottom, green traces).
Extended Data Fig. 2 Comparison of GNG-DN population neural activity during optogenetic stimulation versus corresponding natural behaviors. (a-c) For (a) DNp09 and forward walking, (b) aDN2 and anterior grooming, or (c) MDN and backward walking: (left) behavioral responses to optogenetic stimulation of command-like DNs (black) versus natural occurrences of the behavior in question (color); (middle left) single neuron/ROI responses (analyzed as in Fig. 2c). Here the left half-circle reflects the response to optogenetic activation and the right half-circle the activity during natural behavior; (middle) single neuron average responses as in Fig. 2d; (middle right) Comparing the activity of individual neurons between optogenetic stimulation (black) and natural behavior (color). Neurons/ROIs are sorted by the magnitude of their responses to optogenetic activation. Shaded areas indicate 95% confidence interval of the mean across trials. Pearson correlation between optogenetic and spontaneous response and significance of test against null-hypothesis (the two variables are uncorrelated, see Methods) are shown; (right) Confusion matrix comparing the number of active neurons/ROIs that were more active (+), similar (~), or less active (−) upon optogenetic stimulation versus during natural behavior. (a) DNp09: for one fly n=23 optogenetic stimulation trials (not forward walking before stimulus) and 28 instances of spontaneous forward walking in which the fly was not walking forward for at least 1 s and then walking forward for at least 1 s (correlation: ρ = − 0.022, p = 0.356, N = 66 neurons, two-sided test, see Methods). (b) aDN2: for one fly, n = 20 optogenetic stimulation trials (pre-stimulus behavior not restricted) and 16 instances of anterior grooming elicited by a 5 s humidified air puff (correlation: ρ = 0.277, p = 0.022, N = 68 neurons, two-sided test, see Methods). Indicated are central neurons/ROIs with strong activation during aDN2 stimulation of the neck cervical connective as in Fig. 2f. (c) MDN: for one fly, n = 80 optogenetic stimulation trials (pre-stimulus behavior not restricted) and 21 instances of spontaneous backward walking on a cylindrical treadmill in which the fly was not walking backward for 1 s and then walked backward for at least 1 s (correlation: ρ = 0.746, p < 0.001, N = 60 neurons, two-sided test, see Methods). (d) Density visualisation (as in Fig. 2f) of neural responses to DNp09 stimulation and spontaneous forward walking across three animals. The difference in responses is primarily localized to the medial but not lateral regions of the connective. To maximize comparability, only trials where the fly was not walking forward before stimulus onset were selected. (e) Same plot as in a, middle right but for three animals with DNp09 stimulation and forward walking. Indicated are the correlation values when including (ρ = − 0.083, p = 0.564, n = 172 neurons across three flies, two-sided test, see Methods) or excluding (ρ = 0.564, p < 0.001, n = 142 neurons across three flies, two-sided test, see Methods) the ten neurons most activated by optogenetic stimulation (orange region). (f) The locations of ten neurons indicated in e within the connective of three flies (top) and their single neuron responses to optogenetic stimulation (bottom, black traces) or during natural backward walking (bottom, green traces).CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 3 GNG-DNs are recruited by command-like DNs despite resection of ascending axons from the VNC. Experimental data (three flies each) showing anatomy and functional responses of GNG-DNs upon optogenetic stimulation of (a-e) DNp09 > CsChrimson or (f-j) control flies. (a,f) Horizontal (top) and side (bottom) projections of the cervical connective and VNC for three flies after resecting the VNC T1 neuropil. Arrowheads indicate the locations of cuts. Scale bars are 50 μm. (b,g) Single neuron/region-of-interest (ROI) response magnitude during laser light illumination. Each circle is scaled and color-coded to represent the maximum change in fluorescence (normalized ΔF/F) of one detected DN axon/ROI relative to the level of activity 1 s prior to illumination. Small white dots are shown if the response magnitude is smaller than the 95% confidence interval of the mean across trials. The background image is a standard-deviation projection across time of raw fluorescence microscopy data. (c,h) Trial-averaged single neuron/ROI responses across time, aligned to illumination onset and ordered by response magnitude. Data are color-coded according to the magnitude of activity, or white if the response is smaller than the 95% confidence interval of the mean. Indicated are the number of neurons/ROIs with a positive response magnitude larger than the 95% confidence interval of the mean across trials (horizontal red line). (d,i) A registered overlay of the data from all three flies shown in panel b,g. (e,j) A density visualization of the data from all three flies shown in panel b,g.
Extended Data Fig. 3 GNG-DNs are recruited by command-like DNs despite resection of ascending axons from the VNC. Experimental data (three flies each) showing anatomy and functional responses of GNG-DNs upon optogenetic stimulation of (a-e) DNp09 > CsChrimson or (f-j) control flies. (a,f) Horizontal (top) and side (bottom) projections of the cervical connective and VNC for three flies after resecting the VNC T1 neuropil. Arrowheads indicate the locations of cuts. Scale bars are 50 μm. (b,g) Single neuron/region-of-interest (ROI) response magnitude during laser light illumination. Each circle is scaled and color-coded to represent the maximum change in fluorescence (normalized ΔF/F) of one detected DN axon/ROI relative to the level of activity 1 s prior to illumination. Small white dots are shown if the response magnitude is smaller than the 95% confidence interval of the mean across trials. The background image is a standard-deviation projection across time of raw fluorescence microscopy data. (c,h) Trial-averaged single neuron/ROI responses across time, aligned to illumination onset and ordered by response magnitude. Data are color-coded according to the magnitude of activity, or white if the response is smaller than the 95% confidence interval of the mean. Indicated are the number of neurons/ROIs with a positive response magnitude larger than the 95% confidence interval of the mean across trials (horizontal red line). (d,i) A registered overlay of the data from all three flies shown in panel b,g. (e,j) A density visualization of the data from all three flies shown in panel b,g.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 4 DN-DN connectivity statistics when also including interneurons in the underlying connectome network. (a) The number of DNs monosynaptically (directly) downstream of every DN, taking into account both excitatory and inhibitory synapses. Data are identical to those in figure 5. (b) The number of DNs disynaptically downstream of each DN, allowing for at most one additional intervening DN. Sorting of the x axis identical to panel (a). Correlation coefficient compares the distributions of panels (a) and (b). (c) The number of DNs disynaptically downstream of each DN, allowing for at most one additional intervening interneuron of any type. Sorting of the x axis identical to panel (a). Correlation coefficient compares the distributions of panels (a) and (c). (d-f) Identical to panels (a-c) but restricted only to excitatory connections between individual neurons. Sorting of the x axis identical in panels (d-f). (g-i) Identical to panels (a-c) but restricted only to inhibitory connections between individual neurons. Sorting of the x axis identical in panels (g-i).
Extended Data Fig. 4 DN-DN connectivity statistics when also including interneurons in the underlying connectome network. (a) The number of DNs monosynaptically (directly) downstream of every DN, taking into account both excitatory and inhibitory synapses. Data are identical to those in figure 5. (b) The number of DNs disynaptically downstream of each DN, allowing for at most one additional intervening DN. Sorting of the x axis identical to panel (a). Correlation coefficient compares the distributions of panels (a) and (b). (c) The number of DNs disynaptically downstream of each DN, allowing for at most one additional intervening interneuron of any type. Sorting of the x axis identical to panel (a). Correlation coefficient compares the distributions of panels (a) and (c). (d-f) Identical to panels (a-c) but restricted only to excitatory connections between individual neurons. Sorting of the x axis identical in panels (d-f). (g-i) Identical to panels (a-c) but restricted only to inhibitory connections between individual neurons. Sorting of the x axis identical in panels (g-i).CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 5 Testing the connectome-based prediction for broadcaster DNs that behaviors depend strongly on downstream DNs. (a-e)(first column) The morphology of tested DNs in the adult female brain connectome. DNs are color-coded based on their somata localization within the cerebral ganglia (purple) or gnathal ganglia (orange). The number of DNs is indicated. (second column) A network schematic of direct connections from tested to downstream DNs. Edge widths reflect the number of synapses and is consistent across plots. Edge colors denote excitatory (red), inhibitory (blue), or glutamatergic (pink) which can be excitatory or inhibitory depending on receptor type60. (third column) Quantitative analyses of optogenetically-driven behaviors and movements in intact (black traces) and headless animals (blue traces). The number of flies for each condition are indicated. Each fly is optogenetically stimulated ten times. Thus, the average and 95% confidence interval of the mean for a total of n*10 trials is shown. (fourth column) Identical behavioral analysis for control flies without DN opsin expression. Note that controls for different parameters include the same five animals. Two-sided Mann-Whitney U tests comparing the trial mean of intact and headless animals (black bars, above each plot) and comparing headless experimental with headless control flies (blue, in between experimental and control plots) are shown (*** means p < 0.001, ** means p < 0.01, * means p < 0.05, n.s. means p≥0.05; for exact p-values see Supplementary Table 5). (fifth column) An illustration of the behavioral parameter(s) being quantified. (a) DNp42 has monosyaptic connections to 29 other DNs and triggers backing up in intact animals64. This behavior is not observed in headless flies, as quantified by fictive forward walking velocity. (b) aDN1 has monosynaptic connections to 26 other DNs and triggers grooming in intact animals. By contrast, headless animals produce mostly uncoordinated front leg movements. These occur more slowly at a lower frequency (top) with a smaller change in femur-tibia angle (middle). The ‘front leg approach’ to the head—the change in Euclidean distance between the neck and tibia-tarsus joint relative to 1 s before stimulus onset—is similar between intact and headless animals (bottom). (c) DNa01 has monosynaptic connections to 25 other DNs and triggers in place turning. This is quantified as an increase in turn velocity. This behavior is lost in headless animals. (d) DNb02 has monosynaptic connections to 20 other DNs and weakly triggers turning. This is quantified as an increase in turning velocity (top), a phenotype that is lost in headless animals. Instead, a flexion of the front legs can be observed in headless animals. This is quantified as a short spike in forward velocity (bottom). These data partially overlap with those in Fig. 5d–g. (e) DNa02 has monosynaptic connections to 18 other DNs and weakly triggers turning. This is quantified as an increase in turning velocity. This behavior is lost in headless animals.
Extended Data Fig. 5 Testing the connectome-based prediction for broadcaster DNs that behaviors depend strongly on downstream DNs. (a-e)(first column) The morphology of tested DNs in the adult female brain connectome. DNs are color-coded based on their somata localization within the cerebral ganglia (purple) or gnathal ganglia (orange). The number of DNs is indicated. (second column) A network schematic of direct connections from tested to downstream DNs. Edge widths reflect the number of synapses and is consistent across plots. Edge colors denote excitatory (red), inhibitory (blue), or glutamatergic (pink) which can be excitatory or inhibitory depending on receptor type60. (third column) Quantitative analyses of optogenetically-driven behaviors and movements in intact (black traces) and headless animals (blue traces). The number of flies for each condition are indicated. Each fly is optogenetically stimulated ten times. Thus, the average and 95% confidence interval of the mean for a total of n*10 trials is shown. (fourth column) Identical behavioral analysis for control flies without DN opsin expression. Note that controls for different parameters include the same five animals. Two-sided Mann-Whitney U tests comparing the trial mean of intact and headless animals (black bars, above each plot) and comparing headless experimental with headless control flies (blue, in between experimental and control plots) are shown (*** means p < 0.001, ** means p < 0.01, * means p < 0.05, n.s. means p≥0.05; for exact p-values see Supplementary Table 5). (fifth column) An illustration of the behavioral parameter(s) being quantified. (a) DNp42 has monosyaptic connections to 29 other DNs and triggers backing up in intact animals64. This behavior is not observed in headless flies, as quantified by fictive forward walking velocity. (b) aDN1 has monosynaptic connections to 26 other DNs and triggers grooming in intact animals. By contrast, headless animals produce mostly uncoordinated front leg movements. These occur more slowly at a lower frequency (top) with a smaller change in femur-tibia angle (middle). The ‘front leg approach’ to the head—the change in Euclidean distance between the neck and tibia-tarsus joint relative to 1 s before stimulus onset—is similar between intact and headless animals (bottom). (c) DNa01 has monosynaptic connections to 25 other DNs and triggers in place turning. This is quantified as an increase in turn velocity. This behavior is lost in headless animals. (d) DNb02 has monosynaptic connections to 20 other DNs and weakly triggers turning. This is quantified as an increase in turning velocity (top), a phenotype that is lost in headless animals. Instead, a flexion of the front legs can be observed in headless animals. This is quantified as a short spike in forward velocity (bottom). These data partially overlap with those in Fig. 5d–g. (e) DNa02 has monosynaptic connections to 18 other DNs and weakly triggers turning. This is quantified as an increase in turning velocity. This behavior is lost in headless animals.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 6 Testing the connectome-based prediction for stand-alone DNs that behaviors depend weakly on downstream DNs. (a-d)(first column) The morphology of tested DNs in the adult female brain connectome. DNs are color-coded based on their somata localization within the cerebral ganglia (purple) or gnathal ganglia (orange). The number of DNs is indicated. (second column) A network schematic of direct connections from tested to downstream DNs. Edge widths reflect the number of synapses and is consistent across plots. Edge colors denote excitatory (red), inhibitory (blue), or glutamatergic (pink) which can be excitatory or inhibitory depending on receptor type60. (third column) Quantitative analyses of optogenetically-driven behaviors and movements in intact (black traces) and headless animals (blue traces). The number of flies for each condition are indicated. Each fly is optogenetically stimulated ten times. Thus, the average and 95% confidence interval of the mean for a total of n*10 trials is shown. (fourth column) Identical behavioral analysis for control flies without DN opsin expression. Note that controls for different parameters include the same five animals. Two-sided Mann-Whitney U tests comparing the trial mean of intact and headless animals (black bars, above each plot) and comparing headless experimental with headless control flies (blue, in between experimental and control plots) are shown (*** means p < 0.001, ** means p < 0.01, * means p < 0.05, n.s. means p≥0.05; for exact p-values see Supplementary Table 5). (fifth column) An illustration of the behavioral parameter(s) being quantified. (a) oviDNs have four direct downstream partners and trigger curling of the abdomen in both intact and headless animals. This movement is quantified as a change in the vertical positioning of the ovum during optogenetic stimulation. (b) All together, six DNg11 neurons have four downstream partners and trigger foreleg rubbing21. This movement is quantified by the angle drawn by the axis between the coxa and front legs’ tibia-tarsus joint, and the coxa-neck axis. This metric allows to compare positions across flies. (c) The DN ‘Mute’ has no monosynaptic connections to other DNs and triggers ovipositor extension in both intact and headless animals. This movement is quantified as a change in the horizontal position of the ovipositor relative to the 1 s prior to stimulus onset. (d) DNg14 has no monosynaptic connections to other DNs and triggers abdominal dipping and vibration in both intact and headless animals. This movement is quantified as a change in the vertical position of the anal plate relative to 1 s before stimulus onset. These are the same data as in Fig. 5d–f).
Extended Data Fig. 6 Testing the connectome-based prediction for stand-alone DNs that behaviors depend weakly on downstream DNs. (a-d)(first column) The morphology of tested DNs in the adult female brain connectome. DNs are color-coded based on their somata localization within the cerebral ganglia (purple) or gnathal ganglia (orange). The number of DNs is indicated. (second column) A network schematic of direct connections from tested to downstream DNs. Edge widths reflect the number of synapses and is consistent across plots. Edge colors denote excitatory (red), inhibitory (blue), or glutamatergic (pink) which can be excitatory or inhibitory depending on receptor type60. (third column) Quantitative analyses of optogenetically-driven behaviors and movements in intact (black traces) and headless animals (blue traces). The number of flies for each condition are indicated. Each fly is optogenetically stimulated ten times. Thus, the average and 95% confidence interval of the mean for a total of n*10 trials is shown. (fourth column) Identical behavioral analysis for control flies without DN opsin expression. Note that controls for different parameters include the same five animals. Two-sided Mann-Whitney U tests comparing the trial mean of intact and headless animals (black bars, above each plot) and comparing headless experimental with headless control flies (blue, in between experimental and control plots) are shown (*** means p < 0.001, ** means p < 0.01, * means p < 0.05, n.s. means p≥0.05; for exact p-values see Supplementary Table 5). (fifth column) An illustration of the behavioral parameter(s) being quantified. (a) oviDNs have four direct downstream partners and trigger curling of the abdomen in both intact and headless animals. This movement is quantified as a change in the vertical positioning of the ovum during optogenetic stimulation. (b) All together, six DNg11 neurons have four downstream partners and trigger foreleg rubbing21. This movement is quantified by the angle drawn by the axis between the coxa and front legs’ tibia-tarsus joint, and the coxa-neck axis. This metric allows to compare positions across flies. (c) The DN ‘Mute’ has no monosynaptic connections to other DNs and triggers ovipositor extension in both intact and headless animals. This movement is quantified as a change in the horizontal position of the ovipositor relative to the 1 s prior to stimulus onset. (d) DNg14 has no monosynaptic connections to other DNs and triggers abdominal dipping and vibration in both intact and headless animals. This movement is quantified as a change in the vertical position of the anal plate relative to 1 s before stimulus onset. These are the same data as in Fig. 5d–f).CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 7 Inputs to clusters by brain region. Fraction of DN input synapses from different brain neuropils within each cluster. Although there is largely no clear link between the source of DN inputs in the brain and DN clusters, there is one exception: Among ‘walking’ or ‘steering’ clusters 3 & 9 we find a bias with neurons in the right hemisphere being assigned mainly to cluster 3 and those in the left hemisphere being assigned to cluster 9. This was due to differences in connectivity between the two brain hemispheres, both in terms of bilateral symmetry in the brain as well as a left-right imbalance of inputs from the inferior posterior slope (IPS), superior posterior slope (SPS) and the lateral accessory lobe (LAL) (white asterisks). Neuropil names are listed in Supplementary Table 7.
Extended Data Fig. 7 Inputs to clusters by brain region. Fraction of DN input synapses from different brain neuropils within each cluster. Although there is largely no clear link between the source of DN inputs in the brain and DN clusters, there is one exception: Among ‘walking’ or ‘steering’ clusters 3 & 9 we find a bias with neurons in the right hemisphere being assigned mainly to cluster 3 and those in the left hemisphere being assigned to cluster 9. This was due to differences in connectivity between the two brain hemispheres, both in terms of bilateral symmetry in the brain as well as a left-right imbalance of inputs from the inferior posterior slope (IPS), superior posterior slope (SPS) and the lateral accessory lobe (LAL) (white asterisks). Neuropil names are listed in Supplementary Table 7.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 8 DN-DN connectivity for multiple DNs driving similar behaviors. (a-d) DNs used to test predictions and that are directly downstream of our studied command-like DNs (DNp09, aDN2 and MDN). (a) Schematic illustrating that command-like DNs can recruit other command-like DNs involved in related behaviors. (b) Downstream partners of DNp09 include DNa02 and DNb02 neurons. (c) Downstream partners of aDN2 include aDN1 neurons. (d) Downstream of MDN is one DNa01 neuron. (e,i) Command-like DNs whose artificial stimulation are known to evoke (e) forward walking (DNp093, BDN249, and oDN149), or (i) antennal grooming (aDN1 and aDN24) are all well-connected to other DNs. (f-h, j,k) Direct connectivity diagrams showing downstream partners of (f) DNp09, (g) BDN2, (h) oDN1, (j) aDN1, and (k) aDN2. Command-like DNs are shown at the center of each plot. Edge widths indicate the strength of the synaptic connections. Peripheral neurons highlighted in (f-h) green or (j-k) red are the interconnected DNs evoking forward locomotion or antennal grooming, respectively. Dashed circles in (g) represent internal connections among BDN2 neurons, grouped in the center through self loops.
Extended Data Fig. 8 DN-DN connectivity for multiple DNs driving similar behaviors. (a-d) DNs used to test predictions and that are directly downstream of our studied command-like DNs (DNp09, aDN2 and MDN). (a) Schematic illustrating that command-like DNs can recruit other command-like DNs involved in related behaviors. (b) Downstream partners of DNp09 include DNa02 and DNb02 neurons. (c) Downstream partners of aDN2 include aDN1 neurons. (d) Downstream of MDN is one DNa01 neuron. (e,i) Command-like DNs whose artificial stimulation are known to evoke (e) forward walking (DNp093, BDN249, and oDN149), or (i) antennal grooming (aDN1 and aDN24) are all well-connected to other DNs. (f-h, j,k) Direct connectivity diagrams showing downstream partners of (f) DNp09, (g) BDN2, (h) oDN1, (j) aDN1, and (k) aDN2. Command-like DNs are shown at the center of each plot. Edge widths indicate the strength of the synaptic connections. Peripheral neurons highlighted in (f-h) green or (j-k) red are the interconnected DNs evoking forward locomotion or antennal grooming, respectively. Dashed circles in (g) represent internal connections among BDN2 neurons, grouped in the center through self loops.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 9 Node-wise connectivity between two clusters controlling walking versus take-off and landing. (a-b) Excitatory connections between (a) all or only (b) experimentally studied (prior to37) nodes from cluster 2 implicated in take-off and landing (purple) or cluster 3 implicated in walking (green). Synapse counts are indicated by edge weights. Each cluster is organized such that DNs with outputs only within the cluster are on the inner ring, DNs with both inputs and outputs to the same cluster are on the middle ring, and remaining cluster DNs are on the outer ring. Most excitatory connections are within a given cluster. (c-d) As in panels a-d but including only inhibitory connections. Most connections project across clusters 2 and 3. In panel d, four Web DNs15 are indicated (black asterisks). These neurons receive strong excitatory input from within their cluster 2 (panel b) and inhibit many DNs in cluster 3.
Extended Data Fig. 9 Node-wise connectivity between two clusters controlling walking versus take-off and landing. (a-b) Excitatory connections between (a) all or only (b) experimentally studied (prior to37) nodes from cluster 2 implicated in take-off and landing (purple) or cluster 3 implicated in walking (green). Synapse counts are indicated by edge weights. Each cluster is organized such that DNs with outputs only within the cluster are on the inner ring, DNs with both inputs and outputs to the same cluster are on the middle ring, and remaining cluster DNs are on the outer ring. Most excitatory connections are within a given cluster. (c-d) As in panels a-d but including only inhibitory connections. Most connections project across clusters 2 and 3. In panel d, four Web DNs15 are indicated (black asterisks). These neurons receive strong excitatory input from within their cluster 2 (panel b) and inhibit many DNs in cluster 3.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 10 Backward locomotion depends on the active actuation of fewer appendages than forward locomotion. (a) Illustration of the hypothesis that behavioral complexity/compositionality correlates with underlying DN network size. (b-e, top row) Cartoon schema illustrating legs that were bilaterally amputated at the level of the tibia-tarsus joint. Indicated are optogenetically activated DNs. Shown below is the cumulative fictive forward displacement for tethered flies before, after, and during optogenetic stimulation (gray region) for either optogenetic stimulation of (b-e, middle row) the DN in question, or (b-e, bottom row) a control animal with no GAL4 driver. Data are shown for traces for both amputated (blue) and intact control (black traces) flies. Flies were optogenetically stimulated 10 times. Shaded areas represent the 95% confidence interval of the mean. Shown are two-sided Mann-Whitney U tests comparing the trial-wise mean of intact versus leg amputated animals (black asterisks and ‘n.s.’) as well as the leg amputated DN > GAL4 versus leg amputated control flies (blue asterisks and ‘n.s.’). *** Indicates p < 0.001, ** indicates p < 0.01, * indicates p < 0.05, n.s. indicates p ≥ 0.05; for exact p-values see Supplementary Table 6. (b) Amputation of the hind legs is sufficient to prevent flies from walking backward upon MDN optogenetic stimulation. Residual backward displacement results from struggle-associated noise and is not statistically distinguishable from control animal backward displacement. (c-e) Amputation of either the hind-, mid- or forelegs does not prevent forward walking but only reduces forward walking velocity.
Extended Data Fig. 10 Backward locomotion depends on the active actuation of fewer appendages than forward locomotion. (a) Illustration of the hypothesis that behavioral complexity/compositionality correlates with underlying DN network size. (b-e, top row) Cartoon schema illustrating legs that were bilaterally amputated at the level of the tibia-tarsus joint. Indicated are optogenetically activated DNs. Shown below is the cumulative fictive forward displacement for tethered flies before, after, and during optogenetic stimulation (gray region) for either optogenetic stimulation of (b-e, middle row) the DN in question, or (b-e, bottom row) a control animal with no GAL4 driver. Data are shown for traces for both amputated (blue) and intact control (black traces) flies. Flies were optogenetically stimulated 10 times. Shaded areas represent the 95% confidence interval of the mean. Shown are two-sided Mann-Whitney U tests comparing the trial-wise mean of intact versus leg amputated animals (black asterisks and ‘n.s.’) as well as the leg amputated DN > GAL4 versus leg amputated control flies (blue asterisks and ‘n.s.’). *** Indicates p < 0.001, ** indicates p < 0.01, * indicates p < 0.05, n.s. indicates p ≥ 0.05; for exact p-values see Supplementary Table 6. (b) Amputation of the hind legs is sufficient to prevent flies from walking backward upon MDN optogenetic stimulation. Residual backward displacement results from struggle-associated noise and is not statistically distinguishable from control animal backward displacement. (c-e) Amputation of either the hind-, mid- or forelegs does not prevent forward walking but only reduces forward walking velocity.CC BY · PubMed Central

Verification

Claims the paper makes

6 Valid · 2 Not valid · 22 Not checked · 148 Own results and interpretations

90 more claims

Create a free account to see all 178 claims and to verify the 38 references still open.

See all claims — free account
  • Probably not a substantial claim. 44
  • It may state two separate claims as one. 49
  • The quote only partly states this claim. 3

Create a free account to see these claims.

Claims other papers make about this one

Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?

3 more claims about this paper

Create a free account to see every claim other papers make about this one.

See all claims — free account

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

Each contradiction between two passages listed here was confirmed by an independent check.

1 of 1

Citations

Cites

Show all 98 references

Cited by

See all 53

Metadata

Authors
Braun, J., Hurtak, F., Wang-Chen, S., & Ramdya, P.
Affiliations
École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (CH)
Corresponding author
Ramdya, Pavan
Venue
Nature
Published
2024-06-05
Volume
630
Issue
8017
Pages
686-694
ISSN
  • 0028-0836 (ISSN-L)
  • 1476-4687
OpenAlex
W4399366694
Cited by
51
References
98
Citations by year
2026: 13 · 2025: 22 · 2024: 13
FWCI
8.33
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Licence
Locations
  • Nature (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory) (acceptedVersion, cc-by-nc-nd)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
  • RePEc: Research Papers in Economics (submittedVersion)
  • Infoscience (Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne) (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc-nd)
Funders
  • Wellcome Trust (220343/Z/20/Z, 203261/Z/16/Z)
  • Boehringer Ingelheim Fonds
  • Schweizerischer Nationalfonds zur Förderung der Wissenschaftlichen Forschung (175667, 181239)
  • National Institute of Mental Health (RF1MH117815, RF1MH120679)
  • National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke (U24NS126935)
Topics
  • Life Sciences › Neuroscience › Cellular and Molecular Neuroscience › Neurobiology and Insect Physiology Research
  • Life Sciences › Neuroscience › Cognitive Neuroscience › Motor Control and Adaptation
  • Life Sciences › Neuroscience › Cellular and Molecular Neuroscience › Neuroscience and Neuropharmacology Research
Keywords
descending neurons, motor control, Drosophila, connectome, excitatory connections, behavioral control
MeSH terms
Animals, Behavior, Animal, Brain, Drosophila melanogaster, Female, Motor Neurons, Movement, Nerve Net, Connectome

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

The claim verdicts this report counts are experimental: their accuracy is not yet measured.

A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-10-07, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).

A second model labelled each claim on 2026-10-07 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).

Cited sources are checked with a language model’s help (qwen3.8-omni-flash and gpt-6-sol).

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Descending networks transform command signals into population motor control. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1038/s41586-024-07523-9
The paper
Braun, J., Hurtak, F., Wang-Chen, S., & Ramdya, P. (2024). Descending networks transform command signals into population motor control. Nature. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-024-07523-9

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.