The DOI matches its Crossref record; 55 of the 59 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; 24 of the 55 sources its claims cite were checked for support.
Infertility-related distress and clinical targets for psychotherapy: a qualitative study
Open accessAbstract
Objectives An estimated 30%-40% of women attending infertility tertiary care facilities experience clinically significant depression and anxiety. However, current psychological interventions for infertility are only modestly effective in this population. In this study, we aimed to identify the specific psychological components of infertility-related distress to assist in the development of a more targeted and effective therapeutic intervention. To our knowledge, this study is the first of its kind to include the views and opinions of mental health professionals who specialise in the field of infertility and the first to explore therapies currently used by mental health professionals. Design A qualitative approach using semistructured individual interviews and focus group interviews with women who have experience with infertility and also mental health professionals specialising in the field of infertility. Thematic analysis was used to identify patterns and themes emerging from the data. Participants Twenty-one women (aged 25-41 years) struggling to conceive for ≥12 months and 14 mental health professionals participated in semistructured interviews about the psychological challenges related to infertility. Results Five themes, each divided into subthemes, emerged from the data and these were developed into a model of infertility-related distress. These five themes are: (1) anxiety, (2) mood disturbance, (3) threat to self-esteem, identity and purpose, (4) deterioration of the couple and (5) weakened support network. In addition, therapeutic techniques used by mental health professionals were identified. Conclusions The results of this study suggest specific clinical targets that future interventions treating infertility-related distress should address. © 2021 BMJ Publishing Group. All rights reserved.
Overview
CoChat Summary
## TL;DR
This qualitative study interviewed 21 women with infertility and 14 infertility-specialist mental health professionals to map the components of infertility-related distress and identify psychotherapy targets. It produced a five-theme model of distress and highlighted a mix of commonly used therapies—especially CBT, DBT, and mindfulness—but noted that current interventions remain only modestly effective.
## Key findings
- Five themes of infertility-related distress emerged: (1) anxiety, (2) mood disturbance, (3) threat to self-esteem, identity and purpose, (4) deterioration of the couple, and (5) weakened support network.
- Anxiety was “perhaps the most highly endorsed” aspect of distress; reported subthemes included anxious rumination, avoidance of fertility reminders, narrowed focus on fertility-related activities, and excessive information seeking.
- Mood disturbance included emotional lability, helplessness, and emotional exhaustion; one participant reported becoming suicidal, and the paper notes that a smaller subset of women developed what “sounds like clinical depression.”
- Mental health professionals reported using an eclectic mix of therapies, with CBT, DBT, and mindfulness-based approaches standing out as the most used, though always in combination with others.
## Methods
- Design: Qualitative study using semistructured individual interviews and focus group interviews; thematic analysis was used to identify patterns and themes.
- Sample/data: 21 women aged 25–41 years who had been trying to conceive for ≥12 months, plus 14 mental health professionals specializing in infertility; women were recruited purposively and by snowball sampling, and professionals were recruited via internet search and email.
- Analysis: Interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed, and analyzed separately for women and professionals before comparing themes; preliminary analysis occurred concurrently with data collection, and saturation determined when to stop recruiting.
## Limitations
- The paper states that the sample was “relatively homogeneous,” largely Caucasian and of high socioeconomic status, which may limit generalisability.
- The paper states that all participants were in heterosexual relationships, which may have prevented themes specific to same-sex couples from emerging.
- Evident from the text: the study is qualitative and based on a small, non-random sample from Canada and the USA, so its findings are descriptive and not intended to estimate prevalence or causal effects.
Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Figures
Verification
Claims the paper makes
16 Valid · 3 Not valid · 17 Not checked · 112 Own results and interpretations
The cited sources support only part of this claim — read each source’s verdict below.
In the paper
“Anxiety emerged as one of the most prominent features of infertility-related distress, consistent with previous findings from other studies in which anxious rumination was reported to be a common feature of infertility.22 23”
§ Infertility-related distress and clinical targets for psychotherapy: a qualitative study > Discussion The purpose of the current study was to gain a deeper understanding of infertility-related distress as well as gather information about which psychotherapeutic approaches were being used by mental health professionals for the treatment of infertility-related distress. The ultimate aim was to inform the development of an intervention better tailored to infertility and more effective than currently available ones. While some of the identified themes and subthemes are common to mood and anxiety disorders unrelated to infertility, the results of the current study also highlighted several challenges that are clearly unique to infertility. Women’s reports, corroborated by the accounts of mental health professionals specialising in infertility-related distress, paint a picture of infertility-related distress in which one is highly preoccupied and emotionally invested in the day-to-day occurrences of the menstrual/treatment cycle, leading to high anxiety and fluctuating mood. As they are preoccupied with their current efforts and wish to avoid having to explain themselves to others or to submit themselves to others’ pregnancies and children, they become more reclusive and spend less time engaged in activities that previously enriched their lives. They worry about who they will be and what their lives will look like if they never conceive. At the same time, at home, women are struggling to connect with their partner as they do not always find themselves to be on the same page with regard to various reproductive events and/or decisions to be made. In a subset of women, these emotional struggles contribute to clinical mental health problems over time and, in some, the complete dissolution of their relationship. Below, we review each of the identified themes in greater detail and compare our findings with those of other studies. Anxiety emerged as one of the most prominent features of infertility-related distress, consistent with previous findings from other studies in which anxious rumination was reported to be a common feature of infertility.22 23 A few studies have also reported on women’s narrowed focus on infertility to the exclusion of other activities, as well as excessive information seeking as behavioural features of anxiety.24–26 In this study, these subthemes were more prominent, and we suspect that the inclusion of mental health professionals, providing an outsider’s perspective, was a unique feature in the current study that may have facilitated the identification of these subthemes. With regard to the second theme, mood disturbance, other researchers have also reported on the ‘emotional rollercoaster’ of infertility, as well as the loss of control that women frequently experience.6 22 27 28 Emotional exhaustion and burnout have also been reported as a common feature of infertility, resulting from the chronic exposure to the emotional ups and downs of infertility.26 29 This finding is consistent with the high rate of clinical depression seen among women struggling with infertility.7 9 10 The third theme—threat to self-esteem, identity and purpose—is somewhat similar to previous reports that women’s view of themselves and their future identities are challenged by infertility, leading to feelings of role loss or role failure and the development of a negative self-perception.6 26 27 Pedro and Andipatin30 also reported on women’s tendency to blame themselves for their infertility. Finally, the broad themes of deterioration of the couple,22 23 28 and of weakened social support systems27 28 have been previously identified. However, the identification of specific subthemes within these broader issues is unique to the current study and helps to inform the identification and development of more effective psychotherapies directly targeting infertility-related distress. The subtheme relating to negative interactions with healthcare providers adds to the findings of previous studies31 32 and highlights the need for increased awareness and education among healthcare providers in addressing the emotional aspect of infertility with sensitivity and compassion. Mental health professionals reported using an array of techniques borrowed from a range of psychotherapy approaches, some more evidence based than others, to address the unique challenges associated with infertility-related distress. CBT, arguably the psychotherapeutic approach most supported by research evidence for the treatment of depression and anxiety unrelated to infertility,33 was met with disdain by some and cautious acknowledgement of its potential benefits by others. Specific concerns about CBT related to its focus on ‘cognitive distortions’ as being invalidating of the very natural emotions resulting from infertility. Approaches incorporating mindfulness, commonly termed ‘third-wave’ psychotherapy approaches, were mentioned numerous times as being helpful, including ACT, DBT and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy, all of which are supported by growing bodies of research evidence for distress unrelated to infertility.33 34 Other therapy approaches mentioned, such as EFT, upside down therapy and existential therapy, have modest to no research support as of yet.35 36 These findings, in combination with recent meta-analytical evidence suggesting that the efficacy of current psychotherapeutic approaches to infertility is modest,15 perhaps reflect a need for a new psychotherapeutic approach that combines techniques from various approaches to create a more tailored intervention that addresses the unique psychological challenges identified here. While cognitive restructuring, progressive muscle relaxation, and mindfulness meditation are the most-used and tested approaches to date for the treatment of infertility-related distress, their efficacy in this population is limited.15 Several other approaches mentioned by the mental health professionals may better target the unique aspects of infertility-related distress. For example, some of the techniques used in DBT aimed at improving distress tolerance34 may help women cope with intense distress during medical procedures or after very upsetting news. The interpersonal effectiveness skills taught in DBT may also help individuals appropriately interact with the people in their lives who say unhelpful or upsetting things related to their infertility. ACT, mentioned by several mental health professionals in our study, may be useful in addressing the avoidance of infertility reminders, which emerged as one of the subthemes of infertility-related anxiety, as ACT encourages women to engage in activities that align with their values, in spite of the distress that doing so may cause.37 For example, a woman who highly values being a supportive sister will be encouraged to work up to going to her sister’s baby shower. Importantly, cognitive strategies and mindfulness exercises are first introduced to equip clients with the tools needed to cope with the distress they encounter through the process of exposure. To date, studies conducted in the Middle East have applied ACT to infertility-related distress with promising results,38–40 though it has yet to be tested in North America. Several of the mental health professionals highlighted the use of mindfulness-based approaches. Although mindfulness approaches have proven to be of limited efficacy for infertility-related distress, one mindfulness-based approach that has yet to be applied to infertility is loving-kindness meditation (LKM),41 which seems to map on well to both shame/self-blame and severed relationships with others. LKM is a Buddhist practice aimed at increasing compassion towards self and others. As a first step, one meditates while focusing on statements that promote self-love and self-compassion (eg, ‘May I be free from mental suffering or distress’), while attempting to let go of any self-judgement or self-hatred. Next, thoughts and statements centre around an elderly loved one, then a close loved one, next a neutral person, and, finally, someone with whom you have a difficult relationship or feel bitterness towards. Mounting research42 suggests that LKM increases both positive self-regard as well as positive feelings towards others. In infertility, it may therefore be used to reduce feelings of shame related to the diagnosis while also improving relationships with others who fail to provide the emotional support that was expected or hoped for. IPT, which was also mentioned by several mental health professionals, may also be an effective approach to improving a woman’s interpersonal relationships within the context of infertility. IPT is a time-limited, evidence-based therapy that uses techniques such as communication analysis and role-playing to address four main interpersonal issues: interpersonal disputes, role transitions, grief and interpersonal deficits.43 44 Within the context of infertility, interpersonal disputes may include disagreements with one’s partner about next steps to take in fertility treatments or negative interactions with loved ones who inadvertently make unhelpful comments. ‘Role transitions’ may also be relevant for women contemplating stopping treatments and who are trying to make peace with living a child-free life. Finally, ‘grief’ is clearly applicable to negative pregnancy test outcome or miscarriage. To our knowledge, a single pilot study has tested IPT for infertility-related distress, with promising results.45 Though CBT has been applied to infertility in a number of studies, with limited results, there are a number of CBT-based techniques that have yet to be used but that may address some of the specific infertility-related psychological challenges raised in this study. Specifically, given the prominence of anxious rumination and excessive information seeking, the incorporation of ‘worry time’ may be warranted. ‘Worry time’ is a technique that is commonly used in CBT for generalised anxiety disorder and involves having the client set aside a certain amount of time daily (eg, 30 min once or twice daily) to devote to their ongoing worries.33 46 In the context of infertility, this time could be used to research potential treatments, budget for fertility treatments or simply contemplate what life might be like without children. Whenever an infertility-related worry pops up outside of ‘worry time’, women would be encouraged to jot down their concerns on a notepad, to be considered further during the next worry time. While this technique may seem counterintuitive, research has found it to be effective in reducing the amount of time spent ruminating overall.33 46 A few limitations are worth mentioning. Our sample was relatively homogeneous, being largely Caucasian and of high socioeconomic status, potentially limiting the generalisability of our findings to the larger population. All participants were also in heterosexual relationships, perhaps preventing the discovery of themes specific to same-sex couples. Despite these limitations, our study is strengthened by its patient-oriented approach and its inclusion of mental health professionals specialising in infertility.
What the sources say
- Partly supportedcites [22] Born, 2016, The fertility Invetory and Infertility-related stress: a case study, Qual Rep sourceExperimental — accuracy not yet measured
The Avoidance section reports that all participants described infertility-related preoccupation, including rumination and obsessive thinking. That supports the claim about rumination, but the paper does not identify anxiety as one of the most prominent features of infertility-related distress; it emphasizes identity and coping instead. The indexed passages provide no page numbers. (LLM, conf=0.81)
- Supportedcites [23] Donkor, 2017, "I am anxious and desperate": psychological experiences of women with infertility in The Greater Accra Region, Ghana, Fertil Res Pract source
The Discussion identifies anxiety and depression as the notable psychological problems reported by the women in this study. The Results also list anxiety among the emotional difficulties they experienced, supporting the paraphrase in the study’s context. (LLM, conf=0.90)
plain- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Partly supported
The sources with a verdict support this claim; the rest weren’t checked yet, have no full text we could read, or their verdicts aren’t rated yet.
In the paper
“This finding is consistent with the high rate of clinical depression seen among women struggling with infertility.7 9 10”
§ Infertility-related distress and clinical targets for psychotherapy: a qualitative study > Discussion The purpose of the current study was to gain a deeper understanding of infertility-related distress as well as gather information about which psychotherapeutic approaches were being used by mental health professionals for the treatment of infertility-related distress. The ultimate aim was to inform the development of an intervention better tailored to infertility and more effective than currently available ones. While some of the identified themes and subthemes are common to mood and anxiety disorders unrelated to infertility, the results of the current study also highlighted several challenges that are clearly unique to infertility. Women’s reports, corroborated by the accounts of mental health professionals specialising in infertility-related distress, paint a picture of infertility-related distress in which one is highly preoccupied and emotionally invested in the day-to-day occurrences of the menstrual/treatment cycle, leading to high anxiety and fluctuating mood. As they are preoccupied with their current efforts and wish to avoid having to explain themselves to others or to submit themselves to others’ pregnancies and children, they become more reclusive and spend less time engaged in activities that previously enriched their lives. They worry about who they will be and what their lives will look like if they never conceive. At the same time, at home, women are struggling to connect with their partner as they do not always find themselves to be on the same page with regard to various reproductive events and/or decisions to be made. In a subset of women, these emotional struggles contribute to clinical mental health problems over time and, in some, the complete dissolution of their relationship. Below, we review each of the identified themes in greater detail and compare our findings with those of other studies. Anxiety emerged as one of the most prominent features of infertility-related distress, consistent with previous findings from other studies in which anxious rumination was reported to be a common feature of infertility.22 23 A few studies have also reported on women’s narrowed focus on infertility to the exclusion of other activities, as well as excessive information seeking as behavioural features of anxiety.24–26 In this study, these subthemes were more prominent, and we suspect that the inclusion of mental health professionals, providing an outsider’s perspective, was a unique feature in the current study that may have facilitated the identification of these subthemes. With regard to the second theme, mood disturbance, other researchers have also reported on the ‘emotional rollercoaster’ of infertility, as well as the loss of control that women frequently experience.6 22 27 28 Emotional exhaustion and burnout have also been reported as a common feature of infertility, resulting from the chronic exposure to the emotional ups and downs of infertility.26 29 This finding is consistent with the high rate of clinical depression seen among women struggling with infertility.7 9 10 The third theme—threat to self-esteem, identity and purpose—is somewhat similar to previous reports that women’s view of themselves and their future identities are challenged by infertility, leading to feelings of role loss or role failure and the development of a negative self-perception.6 26 27 Pedro and Andipatin30 also reported on women’s tendency to blame themselves for their infertility. Finally, the broad themes of deterioration of the couple,22 23 28 and of weakened social support systems27 28 have been previously identified. However, the identification of specific subthemes within these broader issues is unique to the current study and helps to inform the identification and development of more effective psychotherapies directly targeting infertility-related distress. The subtheme relating to negative interactions with healthcare providers adds to the findings of previous studies31 32 and highlights the need for increased awareness and education among healthcare providers in addressing the emotional aspect of infertility with sensitivity and compassion. Mental health professionals reported using an array of techniques borrowed from a range of psychotherapy approaches, some more evidence based than others, to address the unique challenges associated with infertility-related distress. CBT, arguably the psychotherapeutic approach most supported by research evidence for the treatment of depression and anxiety unrelated to infertility,33 was met with disdain by some and cautious acknowledgement of its potential benefits by others. Specific concerns about CBT related to its focus on ‘cognitive distortions’ as being invalidating of the very natural emotions resulting from infertility. Approaches incorporating mindfulness, commonly termed ‘third-wave’ psychotherapy approaches, were mentioned numerous times as being helpful, including ACT, DBT and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy, all of which are supported by growing bodies of research evidence for distress unrelated to infertility.33 34 Other therapy approaches mentioned, such as EFT, upside down therapy and existential therapy, have modest to no research support as of yet.35 36 These findings, in combination with recent meta-analytical evidence suggesting that the efficacy of current psychotherapeutic approaches to infertility is modest,15 perhaps reflect a need for a new psychotherapeutic approach that combines techniques from various approaches to create a more tailored intervention that addresses the unique psychological challenges identified here. While cognitive restructuring, progressive muscle relaxation, and mindfulness meditation are the most-used and tested approaches to date for the treatment of infertility-related distress, their efficacy in this population is limited.15 Several other approaches mentioned by the mental health professionals may better target the unique aspects of infertility-related distress. For example, some of the techniques used in DBT aimed at improving distress tolerance34 may help women cope with intense distress during medical procedures or after very upsetting news. The interpersonal effectiveness skills taught in DBT may also help individuals appropriately interact with the people in their lives who say unhelpful or upsetting things related to their infertility. ACT, mentioned by several mental health professionals in our study, may be useful in addressing the avoidance of infertility reminders, which emerged as one of the subthemes of infertility-related anxiety, as ACT encourages women to engage in activities that align with their values, in spite of the distress that doing so may cause.37 For example, a woman who highly values being a supportive sister will be encouraged to work up to going to her sister’s baby shower. Importantly, cognitive strategies and mindfulness exercises are first introduced to equip clients with the tools needed to cope with the distress they encounter through the process of exposure. To date, studies conducted in the Middle East have applied ACT to infertility-related distress with promising results,38–40 though it has yet to be tested in North America. Several of the mental health professionals highlighted the use of mindfulness-based approaches. Although mindfulness approaches have proven to be of limited efficacy for infertility-related distress, one mindfulness-based approach that has yet to be applied to infertility is loving-kindness meditation (LKM),41 which seems to map on well to both shame/self-blame and severed relationships with others. LKM is a Buddhist practice aimed at increasing compassion towards self and others. As a first step, one meditates while focusing on statements that promote self-love and self-compassion (eg, ‘May I be free from mental suffering or distress’), while attempting to let go of any self-judgement or self-hatred. Next, thoughts and statements centre around an elderly loved one, then a close loved one, next a neutral person, and, finally, someone with whom you have a difficult relationship or feel bitterness towards. Mounting research42 suggests that LKM increases both positive self-regard as well as positive feelings towards others. In infertility, it may therefore be used to reduce feelings of shame related to the diagnosis while also improving relationships with others who fail to provide the emotional support that was expected or hoped for. IPT, which was also mentioned by several mental health professionals, may also be an effective approach to improving a woman’s interpersonal relationships within the context of infertility. IPT is a time-limited, evidence-based therapy that uses techniques such as communication analysis and role-playing to address four main interpersonal issues: interpersonal disputes, role transitions, grief and interpersonal deficits.43 44 Within the context of infertility, interpersonal disputes may include disagreements with one’s partner about next steps to take in fertility treatments or negative interactions with loved ones who inadvertently make unhelpful comments. ‘Role transitions’ may also be relevant for women contemplating stopping treatments and who are trying to make peace with living a child-free life. Finally, ‘grief’ is clearly applicable to negative pregnancy test outcome or miscarriage. To our knowledge, a single pilot study has tested IPT for infertility-related distress, with promising results.45 Though CBT has been applied to infertility in a number of studies, with limited results, there are a number of CBT-based techniques that have yet to be used but that may address some of the specific infertility-related psychological challenges raised in this study. Specifically, given the prominence of anxious rumination and excessive information seeking, the incorporation of ‘worry time’ may be warranted. ‘Worry time’ is a technique that is commonly used in CBT for generalised anxiety disorder and involves having the client set aside a certain amount of time daily (eg, 30 min once or twice daily) to devote to their ongoing worries.33 46 In the context of infertility, this time could be used to research potential treatments, budget for fertility treatments or simply contemplate what life might be like without children. Whenever an infertility-related worry pops up outside of ‘worry time’, women would be encouraged to jot down their concerns on a notepad, to be considered further during the next worry time. While this technique may seem counterintuitive, research has found it to be effective in reducing the amount of time spent ruminating overall.33 46 A few limitations are worth mentioning. Our sample was relatively homogeneous, being largely Caucasian and of high socioeconomic status, potentially limiting the generalisability of our findings to the larger population. All participants were also in heterosexual relationships, perhaps preventing the discovery of themes specific to same-sex couples. Despite these limitations, our study is strengthened by its patient-oriented approach and its inclusion of mental health professionals specialising in infertility.
What the sources say
- Not checked — no full text of the sourcecites [7] source
- Not checked — no full text of the sourcecites [9] source
- Supportedcites [10] source
The Discussion (page not available in our copy) concludes that major depression is common among infertile women undergoing IVF treatment. This supports the cited statement about a high rate of clinical depression, although the study population was women receiving IVF rather than all women experiencing infertility. (LLM, conf=0.90)
plainstates an association- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: unclear — It is unclear whether the paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
Every source the paper cites for this claim was checked and supports it.
In the paper
“To date, studies conducted in the Middle East have applied ACT to infertility-related distress with promising results,38–40 though it has yet to be tested in North America.”
§ Infertility-related distress and clinical targets for psychotherapy: a qualitative study > Discussion The purpose of the current study was to gain a deeper understanding of infertility-related distress as well as gather information about which psychotherapeutic approaches were being used by mental health professionals for the treatment of infertility-related distress. The ultimate aim was to inform the development of an intervention better tailored to infertility and more effective than currently available ones. While some of the identified themes and subthemes are common to mood and anxiety disorders unrelated to infertility, the results of the current study also highlighted several challenges that are clearly unique to infertility. Women’s reports, corroborated by the accounts of mental health professionals specialising in infertility-related distress, paint a picture of infertility-related distress in which one is highly preoccupied and emotionally invested in the day-to-day occurrences of the menstrual/treatment cycle, leading to high anxiety and fluctuating mood. As they are preoccupied with their current efforts and wish to avoid having to explain themselves to others or to submit themselves to others’ pregnancies and children, they become more reclusive and spend less time engaged in activities that previously enriched their lives. They worry about who they will be and what their lives will look like if they never conceive. At the same time, at home, women are struggling to connect with their partner as they do not always find themselves to be on the same page with regard to various reproductive events and/or decisions to be made. In a subset of women, these emotional struggles contribute to clinical mental health problems over time and, in some, the complete dissolution of their relationship. Below, we review each of the identified themes in greater detail and compare our findings with those of other studies. Anxiety emerged as one of the most prominent features of infertility-related distress, consistent with previous findings from other studies in which anxious rumination was reported to be a common feature of infertility.22 23 A few studies have also reported on women’s narrowed focus on infertility to the exclusion of other activities, as well as excessive information seeking as behavioural features of anxiety.24–26 In this study, these subthemes were more prominent, and we suspect that the inclusion of mental health professionals, providing an outsider’s perspective, was a unique feature in the current study that may have facilitated the identification of these subthemes. With regard to the second theme, mood disturbance, other researchers have also reported on the ‘emotional rollercoaster’ of infertility, as well as the loss of control that women frequently experience.6 22 27 28 Emotional exhaustion and burnout have also been reported as a common feature of infertility, resulting from the chronic exposure to the emotional ups and downs of infertility.26 29 This finding is consistent with the high rate of clinical depression seen among women struggling with infertility.7 9 10 The third theme—threat to self-esteem, identity and purpose—is somewhat similar to previous reports that women’s view of themselves and their future identities are challenged by infertility, leading to feelings of role loss or role failure and the development of a negative self-perception.6 26 27 Pedro and Andipatin30 also reported on women’s tendency to blame themselves for their infertility. Finally, the broad themes of deterioration of the couple,22 23 28 and of weakened social support systems27 28 have been previously identified. However, the identification of specific subthemes within these broader issues is unique to the current study and helps to inform the identification and development of more effective psychotherapies directly targeting infertility-related distress. The subtheme relating to negative interactions with healthcare providers adds to the findings of previous studies31 32 and highlights the need for increased awareness and education among healthcare providers in addressing the emotional aspect of infertility with sensitivity and compassion. Mental health professionals reported using an array of techniques borrowed from a range of psychotherapy approaches, some more evidence based than others, to address the unique challenges associated with infertility-related distress. CBT, arguably the psychotherapeutic approach most supported by research evidence for the treatment of depression and anxiety unrelated to infertility,33 was met with disdain by some and cautious acknowledgement of its potential benefits by others. Specific concerns about CBT related to its focus on ‘cognitive distortions’ as being invalidating of the very natural emotions resulting from infertility. Approaches incorporating mindfulness, commonly termed ‘third-wave’ psychotherapy approaches, were mentioned numerous times as being helpful, including ACT, DBT and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy, all of which are supported by growing bodies of research evidence for distress unrelated to infertility.33 34 Other therapy approaches mentioned, such as EFT, upside down therapy and existential therapy, have modest to no research support as of yet.35 36 These findings, in combination with recent meta-analytical evidence suggesting that the efficacy of current psychotherapeutic approaches to infertility is modest,15 perhaps reflect a need for a new psychotherapeutic approach that combines techniques from various approaches to create a more tailored intervention that addresses the unique psychological challenges identified here. While cognitive restructuring, progressive muscle relaxation, and mindfulness meditation are the most-used and tested approaches to date for the treatment of infertility-related distress, their efficacy in this population is limited.15 Several other approaches mentioned by the mental health professionals may better target the unique aspects of infertility-related distress. For example, some of the techniques used in DBT aimed at improving distress tolerance34 may help women cope with intense distress during medical procedures or after very upsetting news. The interpersonal effectiveness skills taught in DBT may also help individuals appropriately interact with the people in their lives who say unhelpful or upsetting things related to their infertility. ACT, mentioned by several mental health professionals in our study, may be useful in addressing the avoidance of infertility reminders, which emerged as one of the subthemes of infertility-related anxiety, as ACT encourages women to engage in activities that align with their values, in spite of the distress that doing so may cause.37 For example, a woman who highly values being a supportive sister will be encouraged to work up to going to her sister’s baby shower. Importantly, cognitive strategies and mindfulness exercises are first introduced to equip clients with the tools needed to cope with the distress they encounter through the process of exposure. To date, studies conducted in the Middle East have applied ACT to infertility-related distress with promising results,38–40 though it has yet to be tested in North America. Several of the mental health professionals highlighted the use of mindfulness-based approaches. Although mindfulness approaches have proven to be of limited efficacy for infertility-related distress, one mindfulness-based approach that has yet to be applied to infertility is loving-kindness meditation (LKM),41 which seems to map on well to both shame/self-blame and severed relationships with others. LKM is a Buddhist practice aimed at increasing compassion towards self and others. As a first step, one meditates while focusing on statements that promote self-love and self-compassion (eg, ‘May I be free from mental suffering or distress’), while attempting to let go of any self-judgement or self-hatred. Next, thoughts and statements centre around an elderly loved one, then a close loved one, next a neutral person, and, finally, someone with whom you have a difficult relationship or feel bitterness towards. Mounting research42 suggests that LKM increases both positive self-regard as well as positive feelings towards others. In infertility, it may therefore be used to reduce feelings of shame related to the diagnosis while also improving relationships with others who fail to provide the emotional support that was expected or hoped for. IPT, which was also mentioned by several mental health professionals, may also be an effective approach to improving a woman’s interpersonal relationships within the context of infertility. IPT is a time-limited, evidence-based therapy that uses techniques such as communication analysis and role-playing to address four main interpersonal issues: interpersonal disputes, role transitions, grief and interpersonal deficits.43 44 Within the context of infertility, interpersonal disputes may include disagreements with one’s partner about next steps to take in fertility treatments or negative interactions with loved ones who inadvertently make unhelpful comments. ‘Role transitions’ may also be relevant for women contemplating stopping treatments and who are trying to make peace with living a child-free life. Finally, ‘grief’ is clearly applicable to negative pregnancy test outcome or miscarriage. To our knowledge, a single pilot study has tested IPT for infertility-related distress, with promising results.45 Though CBT has been applied to infertility in a number of studies, with limited results, there are a number of CBT-based techniques that have yet to be used but that may address some of the specific infertility-related psychological challenges raised in this study. Specifically, given the prominence of anxious rumination and excessive information seeking, the incorporation of ‘worry time’ may be warranted. ‘Worry time’ is a technique that is commonly used in CBT for generalised anxiety disorder and involves having the client set aside a certain amount of time daily (eg, 30 min once or twice daily) to devote to their ongoing worries.33 46 In the context of infertility, this time could be used to research potential treatments, budget for fertility treatments or simply contemplate what life might be like without children. Whenever an infertility-related worry pops up outside of ‘worry time’, women would be encouraged to jot down their concerns on a notepad, to be considered further during the next worry time. While this technique may seem counterintuitive, research has found it to be effective in reducing the amount of time spent ruminating overall.33 46 A few limitations are worth mentioning. Our sample was relatively homogeneous, being largely Caucasian and of high socioeconomic status, potentially limiting the generalisability of our findings to the larger population. All participants were also in heterosexual relationships, perhaps preventing the discovery of themes specific to same-sex couples. Despite these limitations, our study is strengthened by its patient-oriented approach and its inclusion of mental health professionals specialising in infertility.
What the sources say
- Supportedcites [38] Hosseinpanahi, 2020, The effect of counseling based on acceptance and commitment therapy on mental health and quality of life among infertile couples: a randomized controlled trial, J Educ Health Promot source
The Methods describe an ACT trial with infertile couples in Sanandaj, Iran. The Conclusion reports improved mental health and quality of life, and the Discussion also describes an Iranian ACT trial that reduced infertility stress. These passages support the cited claim of promising results in the Middle East. (LLM, conf=0.92)
- Supportedcites [39] Rahimi, 2019, Effect of acceptance and commitment therapy on the quality of life in infertile women during treatment: a randomized control trial, International Journal of Women's Health and Reproduction Sciences source
The Materials and Methods section places this ACT trial among infertile women in Iran. The Results summarized in the Abstract report improved quality of life compared with controls, and the Discussion reports improvement in its mental-health dimension. These are promising results for an infertility-related outcome in the Middle East. (LLM, conf=0.90)
- Supportedcites [40] Haji-Adineh, 2019, The effectiveness of acceptance and commitment therapy on optimism about life and psychological well-being in infertile women, Int J Body Mind Culture doi:10.22122/ijbmc.v6i4.178
The methods passage describes an ACT intervention for infertile women at treatment centers in Tehran, Iran. The concluding passage reports increased optimism and psychological well-being and recommends ACT to reduce their suffering, supporting the characterization of the results as promising. The separate statement about testing in North America is not attributed to this source. (LLM, conf=0.90)
plainstates a cause- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: unclear — It is unclear whether the paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Supported
The cited sources that could be checked couldn’t confirm or dispute this claim.
In the paper
“Although mindfulness approaches have proven to be of limited efficacy for infertility-related distress, one mindfulness-based approach that has yet to be applied to infertility is loving-kindness meditation (LKM),41 which seems to map on well to both shame/self-blame and severed relationships with others.”
§ Infertility-related distress and clinical targets for psychotherapy: a qualitative study > Discussion The purpose of the current study was to gain a deeper understanding of infertility-related distress as well as gather information about which psychotherapeutic approaches were being used by mental health professionals for the treatment of infertility-related distress. The ultimate aim was to inform the development of an intervention better tailored to infertility and more effective than currently available ones. While some of the identified themes and subthemes are common to mood and anxiety disorders unrelated to infertility, the results of the current study also highlighted several challenges that are clearly unique to infertility. Women’s reports, corroborated by the accounts of mental health professionals specialising in infertility-related distress, paint a picture of infertility-related distress in which one is highly preoccupied and emotionally invested in the day-to-day occurrences of the menstrual/treatment cycle, leading to high anxiety and fluctuating mood. As they are preoccupied with their current efforts and wish to avoid having to explain themselves to others or to submit themselves to others’ pregnancies and children, they become more reclusive and spend less time engaged in activities that previously enriched their lives. They worry about who they will be and what their lives will look like if they never conceive. At the same time, at home, women are struggling to connect with their partner as they do not always find themselves to be on the same page with regard to various reproductive events and/or decisions to be made. In a subset of women, these emotional struggles contribute to clinical mental health problems over time and, in some, the complete dissolution of their relationship. Below, we review each of the identified themes in greater detail and compare our findings with those of other studies. Anxiety emerged as one of the most prominent features of infertility-related distress, consistent with previous findings from other studies in which anxious rumination was reported to be a common feature of infertility.22 23 A few studies have also reported on women’s narrowed focus on infertility to the exclusion of other activities, as well as excessive information seeking as behavioural features of anxiety.24–26 In this study, these subthemes were more prominent, and we suspect that the inclusion of mental health professionals, providing an outsider’s perspective, was a unique feature in the current study that may have facilitated the identification of these subthemes. With regard to the second theme, mood disturbance, other researchers have also reported on the ‘emotional rollercoaster’ of infertility, as well as the loss of control that women frequently experience.6 22 27 28 Emotional exhaustion and burnout have also been reported as a common feature of infertility, resulting from the chronic exposure to the emotional ups and downs of infertility.26 29 This finding is consistent with the high rate of clinical depression seen among women struggling with infertility.7 9 10 The third theme—threat to self-esteem, identity and purpose—is somewhat similar to previous reports that women’s view of themselves and their future identities are challenged by infertility, leading to feelings of role loss or role failure and the development of a negative self-perception.6 26 27 Pedro and Andipatin30 also reported on women’s tendency to blame themselves for their infertility. Finally, the broad themes of deterioration of the couple,22 23 28 and of weakened social support systems27 28 have been previously identified. However, the identification of specific subthemes within these broader issues is unique to the current study and helps to inform the identification and development of more effective psychotherapies directly targeting infertility-related distress. The subtheme relating to negative interactions with healthcare providers adds to the findings of previous studies31 32 and highlights the need for increased awareness and education among healthcare providers in addressing the emotional aspect of infertility with sensitivity and compassion. Mental health professionals reported using an array of techniques borrowed from a range of psychotherapy approaches, some more evidence based than others, to address the unique challenges associated with infertility-related distress. CBT, arguably the psychotherapeutic approach most supported by research evidence for the treatment of depression and anxiety unrelated to infertility,33 was met with disdain by some and cautious acknowledgement of its potential benefits by others. Specific concerns about CBT related to its focus on ‘cognitive distortions’ as being invalidating of the very natural emotions resulting from infertility. Approaches incorporating mindfulness, commonly termed ‘third-wave’ psychotherapy approaches, were mentioned numerous times as being helpful, including ACT, DBT and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy, all of which are supported by growing bodies of research evidence for distress unrelated to infertility.33 34 Other therapy approaches mentioned, such as EFT, upside down therapy and existential therapy, have modest to no research support as of yet.35 36 These findings, in combination with recent meta-analytical evidence suggesting that the efficacy of current psychotherapeutic approaches to infertility is modest,15 perhaps reflect a need for a new psychotherapeutic approach that combines techniques from various approaches to create a more tailored intervention that addresses the unique psychological challenges identified here. While cognitive restructuring, progressive muscle relaxation, and mindfulness meditation are the most-used and tested approaches to date for the treatment of infertility-related distress, their efficacy in this population is limited.15 Several other approaches mentioned by the mental health professionals may better target the unique aspects of infertility-related distress. For example, some of the techniques used in DBT aimed at improving distress tolerance34 may help women cope with intense distress during medical procedures or after very upsetting news. The interpersonal effectiveness skills taught in DBT may also help individuals appropriately interact with the people in their lives who say unhelpful or upsetting things related to their infertility. ACT, mentioned by several mental health professionals in our study, may be useful in addressing the avoidance of infertility reminders, which emerged as one of the subthemes of infertility-related anxiety, as ACT encourages women to engage in activities that align with their values, in spite of the distress that doing so may cause.37 For example, a woman who highly values being a supportive sister will be encouraged to work up to going to her sister’s baby shower. Importantly, cognitive strategies and mindfulness exercises are first introduced to equip clients with the tools needed to cope with the distress they encounter through the process of exposure. To date, studies conducted in the Middle East have applied ACT to infertility-related distress with promising results,38–40 though it has yet to be tested in North America. Several of the mental health professionals highlighted the use of mindfulness-based approaches. Although mindfulness approaches have proven to be of limited efficacy for infertility-related distress, one mindfulness-based approach that has yet to be applied to infertility is loving-kindness meditation (LKM),41 which seems to map on well to both shame/self-blame and severed relationships with others. LKM is a Buddhist practice aimed at increasing compassion towards self and others. As a first step, one meditates while focusing on statements that promote self-love and self-compassion (eg, ‘May I be free from mental suffering or distress’), while attempting to let go of any self-judgement or self-hatred. Next, thoughts and statements centre around an elderly loved one, then a close loved one, next a neutral person, and, finally, someone with whom you have a difficult relationship or feel bitterness towards. Mounting research42 suggests that LKM increases both positive self-regard as well as positive feelings towards others. In infertility, it may therefore be used to reduce feelings of shame related to the diagnosis while also improving relationships with others who fail to provide the emotional support that was expected or hoped for. IPT, which was also mentioned by several mental health professionals, may also be an effective approach to improving a woman’s interpersonal relationships within the context of infertility. IPT is a time-limited, evidence-based therapy that uses techniques such as communication analysis and role-playing to address four main interpersonal issues: interpersonal disputes, role transitions, grief and interpersonal deficits.43 44 Within the context of infertility, interpersonal disputes may include disagreements with one’s partner about next steps to take in fertility treatments or negative interactions with loved ones who inadvertently make unhelpful comments. ‘Role transitions’ may also be relevant for women contemplating stopping treatments and who are trying to make peace with living a child-free life. Finally, ‘grief’ is clearly applicable to negative pregnancy test outcome or miscarriage. To our knowledge, a single pilot study has tested IPT for infertility-related distress, with promising results.45 Though CBT has been applied to infertility in a number of studies, with limited results, there are a number of CBT-based techniques that have yet to be used but that may address some of the specific infertility-related psychological challenges raised in this study. Specifically, given the prominence of anxious rumination and excessive information seeking, the incorporation of ‘worry time’ may be warranted. ‘Worry time’ is a technique that is commonly used in CBT for generalised anxiety disorder and involves having the client set aside a certain amount of time daily (eg, 30 min once or twice daily) to devote to their ongoing worries.33 46 In the context of infertility, this time could be used to research potential treatments, budget for fertility treatments or simply contemplate what life might be like without children. Whenever an infertility-related worry pops up outside of ‘worry time’, women would be encouraged to jot down their concerns on a notepad, to be considered further during the next worry time. While this technique may seem counterintuitive, research has found it to be effective in reducing the amount of time spent ruminating overall.33 46 A few limitations are worth mentioning. Our sample was relatively homogeneous, being largely Caucasian and of high socioeconomic status, potentially limiting the generalisability of our findings to the larger population. All participants were also in heterosexual relationships, perhaps preventing the discovery of themes specific to same-sex couples. Despite these limitations, our study is strengthened by its patient-oriented approach and its inclusion of mental health professionals specialising in infertility.
What the sources say
- Could not verifycites [41] sourceExperimental — accuracy not yet measured
The Discussion and Treatment Studies sections describe applications of LKM, but neither states whether it has been applied to infertility. Searches for infertility and related fertility terms found no passage addressing that point; its absence from the studies reviewed does not establish that it had never been applied. (LLM, conf=0.72)
plain- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Could not verify
The cited sources support only part of this claim — read each source’s verdict below.
In the paper
“Though CBT has been applied to infertility in a number of studies, with limited results, there are a number of CBT-based techniques that have yet to be used but that may address some of the specific infertility-related psychological challenges raised in this study.”
§ Infertility-related distress and clinical targets for psychotherapy: a qualitative study > Discussion The purpose of the current study was to gain a deeper understanding of infertility-related distress as well as gather information about which psychotherapeutic approaches were being used by mental health professionals for the treatment of infertility-related distress. The ultimate aim was to inform the development of an intervention better tailored to infertility and more effective than currently available ones. While some of the identified themes and subthemes are common to mood and anxiety disorders unrelated to infertility, the results of the current study also highlighted several challenges that are clearly unique to infertility. Women’s reports, corroborated by the accounts of mental health professionals specialising in infertility-related distress, paint a picture of infertility-related distress in which one is highly preoccupied and emotionally invested in the day-to-day occurrences of the menstrual/treatment cycle, leading to high anxiety and fluctuating mood. As they are preoccupied with their current efforts and wish to avoid having to explain themselves to others or to submit themselves to others’ pregnancies and children, they become more reclusive and spend less time engaged in activities that previously enriched their lives. They worry about who they will be and what their lives will look like if they never conceive. At the same time, at home, women are struggling to connect with their partner as they do not always find themselves to be on the same page with regard to various reproductive events and/or decisions to be made. In a subset of women, these emotional struggles contribute to clinical mental health problems over time and, in some, the complete dissolution of their relationship. Below, we review each of the identified themes in greater detail and compare our findings with those of other studies. Anxiety emerged as one of the most prominent features of infertility-related distress, consistent with previous findings from other studies in which anxious rumination was reported to be a common feature of infertility.22 23 A few studies have also reported on women’s narrowed focus on infertility to the exclusion of other activities, as well as excessive information seeking as behavioural features of anxiety.24–26 In this study, these subthemes were more prominent, and we suspect that the inclusion of mental health professionals, providing an outsider’s perspective, was a unique feature in the current study that may have facilitated the identification of these subthemes. With regard to the second theme, mood disturbance, other researchers have also reported on the ‘emotional rollercoaster’ of infertility, as well as the loss of control that women frequently experience.6 22 27 28 Emotional exhaustion and burnout have also been reported as a common feature of infertility, resulting from the chronic exposure to the emotional ups and downs of infertility.26 29 This finding is consistent with the high rate of clinical depression seen among women struggling with infertility.7 9 10 The third theme—threat to self-esteem, identity and purpose—is somewhat similar to previous reports that women’s view of themselves and their future identities are challenged by infertility, leading to feelings of role loss or role failure and the development of a negative self-perception.6 26 27 Pedro and Andipatin30 also reported on women’s tendency to blame themselves for their infertility. Finally, the broad themes of deterioration of the couple,22 23 28 and of weakened social support systems27 28 have been previously identified. However, the identification of specific subthemes within these broader issues is unique to the current study and helps to inform the identification and development of more effective psychotherapies directly targeting infertility-related distress. The subtheme relating to negative interactions with healthcare providers adds to the findings of previous studies31 32 and highlights the need for increased awareness and education among healthcare providers in addressing the emotional aspect of infertility with sensitivity and compassion. Mental health professionals reported using an array of techniques borrowed from a range of psychotherapy approaches, some more evidence based than others, to address the unique challenges associated with infertility-related distress. CBT, arguably the psychotherapeutic approach most supported by research evidence for the treatment of depression and anxiety unrelated to infertility,33 was met with disdain by some and cautious acknowledgement of its potential benefits by others. Specific concerns about CBT related to its focus on ‘cognitive distortions’ as being invalidating of the very natural emotions resulting from infertility. Approaches incorporating mindfulness, commonly termed ‘third-wave’ psychotherapy approaches, were mentioned numerous times as being helpful, including ACT, DBT and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy, all of which are supported by growing bodies of research evidence for distress unrelated to infertility.33 34 Other therapy approaches mentioned, such as EFT, upside down therapy and existential therapy, have modest to no research support as of yet.35 36 These findings, in combination with recent meta-analytical evidence suggesting that the efficacy of current psychotherapeutic approaches to infertility is modest,15 perhaps reflect a need for a new psychotherapeutic approach that combines techniques from various approaches to create a more tailored intervention that addresses the unique psychological challenges identified here. While cognitive restructuring, progressive muscle relaxation, and mindfulness meditation are the most-used and tested approaches to date for the treatment of infertility-related distress, their efficacy in this population is limited.15 Several other approaches mentioned by the mental health professionals may better target the unique aspects of infertility-related distress. For example, some of the techniques used in DBT aimed at improving distress tolerance34 may help women cope with intense distress during medical procedures or after very upsetting news. The interpersonal effectiveness skills taught in DBT may also help individuals appropriately interact with the people in their lives who say unhelpful or upsetting things related to their infertility. ACT, mentioned by several mental health professionals in our study, may be useful in addressing the avoidance of infertility reminders, which emerged as one of the subthemes of infertility-related anxiety, as ACT encourages women to engage in activities that align with their values, in spite of the distress that doing so may cause.37 For example, a woman who highly values being a supportive sister will be encouraged to work up to going to her sister’s baby shower. Importantly, cognitive strategies and mindfulness exercises are first introduced to equip clients with the tools needed to cope with the distress they encounter through the process of exposure. To date, studies conducted in the Middle East have applied ACT to infertility-related distress with promising results,38–40 though it has yet to be tested in North America. Several of the mental health professionals highlighted the use of mindfulness-based approaches. Although mindfulness approaches have proven to be of limited efficacy for infertility-related distress, one mindfulness-based approach that has yet to be applied to infertility is loving-kindness meditation (LKM),41 which seems to map on well to both shame/self-blame and severed relationships with others. LKM is a Buddhist practice aimed at increasing compassion towards self and others. As a first step, one meditates while focusing on statements that promote self-love and self-compassion (eg, ‘May I be free from mental suffering or distress’), while attempting to let go of any self-judgement or self-hatred. Next, thoughts and statements centre around an elderly loved one, then a close loved one, next a neutral person, and, finally, someone with whom you have a difficult relationship or feel bitterness towards. Mounting research42 suggests that LKM increases both positive self-regard as well as positive feelings towards others. In infertility, it may therefore be used to reduce feelings of shame related to the diagnosis while also improving relationships with others who fail to provide the emotional support that was expected or hoped for. IPT, which was also mentioned by several mental health professionals, may also be an effective approach to improving a woman’s interpersonal relationships within the context of infertility. IPT is a time-limited, evidence-based therapy that uses techniques such as communication analysis and role-playing to address four main interpersonal issues: interpersonal disputes, role transitions, grief and interpersonal deficits.43 44 Within the context of infertility, interpersonal disputes may include disagreements with one’s partner about next steps to take in fertility treatments or negative interactions with loved ones who inadvertently make unhelpful comments. ‘Role transitions’ may also be relevant for women contemplating stopping treatments and who are trying to make peace with living a child-free life. Finally, ‘grief’ is clearly applicable to negative pregnancy test outcome or miscarriage. To our knowledge, a single pilot study has tested IPT for infertility-related distress, with promising results.45 Though CBT has been applied to infertility in a number of studies, with limited results, there are a number of CBT-based techniques that have yet to be used but that may address some of the specific infertility-related psychological challenges raised in this study. Specifically, given the prominence of anxious rumination and excessive information seeking, the incorporation of ‘worry time’ may be warranted. ‘Worry time’ is a technique that is commonly used in CBT for generalised anxiety disorder and involves having the client set aside a certain amount of time daily (eg, 30 min once or twice daily) to devote to their ongoing worries.33 46 In the context of infertility, this time could be used to research potential treatments, budget for fertility treatments or simply contemplate what life might be like without children. Whenever an infertility-related worry pops up outside of ‘worry time’, women would be encouraged to jot down their concerns on a notepad, to be considered further during the next worry time. While this technique may seem counterintuitive, research has found it to be effective in reducing the amount of time spent ruminating overall.33 46 A few limitations are worth mentioning. Our sample was relatively homogeneous, being largely Caucasian and of high socioeconomic status, potentially limiting the generalisability of our findings to the larger population. All participants were also in heterosexual relationships, perhaps preventing the discovery of themes specific to same-sex couples. Despite these limitations, our study is strengthened by its patient-oriented approach and its inclusion of mental health professionals specialising in infertility.
What the sources say
- Partly supportedcites [15] sourceExperimental — accuracy not yet measured
The Results (Study characteristics; page unavailable) identify eight CBT studies, supporting that CBT has been applied to infertility. The Results (Possible moderators; page unavailable) report a significant effect on psychological outcomes before adjustment for publication bias, but a smaller effect afterward; the adjusted CBT estimate was not statistically significant. Calling the results simply “limited” omits the paper’s conclusion that CBT could be beneficial. (LLM, conf=0.84)
plain- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Partly supported
66 more claims · 1 with their cited sources checked
Create a free account to see all 148 claims and to verify the 1 reference still open.
- It may state two separate claims as one. 45
- Probably not a substantial claim. 46
- Borderline: one of the tests for a substantial claim is unclear. 1
- The quote only partly states this claim. 2
Citations
Cites
Tong, A., Sainsbury, P., & Craig, J. (2007) · International Journal for Quality in Health Care · doi:10.1093/intqhc/mzm042 · Cited by 42,509
(2017) · Cited by 16,036
Evidence-based practice in psychology.
American Psychological Association (2006) · American Psychologist · doi:10.1037/0003-066x.61.4.271 · Cited by 2,478
A unique view on male infertility around the globe
Agarwal, A., Mulgund, A., Hamada, A., & Chyatte, M. R. (2015) · Reproductive Biology and Endocrinology · doi:10.1186/s12958-015-0032-1 · Cited by 2,399
(2011) · Cited by 2,032
Theme development in qualitative content analysis and thematic analysis
Vaismoradi, M., Jones, J., Turunen, H., & Snelgrove, S. (2016) · Journal of Nursing Education and Practice · doi:10.5430/jnep.v6n5p100 · Cited by 1,994
Creswell, J. D. (2017) · Annual Review of Psychology · doi:10.1146/annurev-psych-042716-051139 · Cited by 1,702
Freeman, A. M. (2001) · The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry · doi:10.4088/jcp.v62n1112 · Cited by 1,666
(2014) · Cited by 1,541
Loving-Kindness and Compassion Meditation: Potential for Psychological Interventions
Hofmann, S. G., Grossman, P., & Hinton, D. E. (2011) · Clinical Psychology Review · doi:10.1016/j.cpr.2011.07.003 · Cited by 960
Research works printed but not linked: 2
- Born, 2016, The fertility Invetory and Infertility-related stress: a case study, Qual Rep, 21, 497
- McLeod J . An introduction to counselling. 3 ed. Berkshire: Open University Press, 2003.
Cited by
Jiang, L., Zeng, T., Wu, M., Yang, L., Zhao, M., Yuan, M., Zhu, Z., & Lang, X. (2024) · Journal of Clinical Nursing · doi:10.1111/jocn.17195 · Cited by 40
Mauricio, R., Sharma, G. V., Lewey, J., Tompkins, R. O., Plowden, T. C., Rexrode, K. M., Canobbio, M. M., Skowronski, J. N., Hameed, A. B., Silversides, C. K., et al. (2025) · Circulation · doi:10.1161/cir.0000000000001292 · Cited by 33
“82,83 Some who have experienced infertility continue to have negative psychological effects even after conceiving and delivering a child.”
Foti, F.-L., Karner‐Huțuleac, A., & Maftei, A. (2023) · Frontiers in Public Health · doi:10.3389/fpubh.2023.1024438 · Cited by 27
“, about the effectiveness of treatments, causes of infertility, efforts to find ways to avoid explanations to family/friends, uncertainty about the future – who they would be and how would their life will look like if they cannot conceive; (76)] becomes a common coping strategy in infertile couples (77).”
BackgroundSambasivam, I., & Jennifer, H. G. (2023) · Journal of Education and Health Promotion · doi:10.4103/jehp.jehp_1600_22 · Cited by 15
“[8] Many communities have a strong social stigma against infertility, which causes many social issues among infertile couples.”
BackgroundSupporting the treatment of infertility using psychological methods
Humeniuk, E., Pucek, W., Wdowiak, A., Filip, M., Bojar, I., & Wdowiak, A. (2023) · Annals of Agricultural and Environmental Medicine · doi:10.26444/aaem/171874 · Cited by 15
“Since not every person struggling with infertility requires suwch help, it is important that medical staff be equipped with standardized methods of assessing the mental condition of patients and take appropriate action if necessary [10].”
Background
Metadata
- Authors
- Dube, L., Nkosi-Mafutha, N., Balsom, A. A., & Gordon, J. L.
- Affiliations
- University of Regina (CA)
- Department of Nursing Education, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg-Braamfontein, South Africa
- Corresponding author
- Gordon, Jennifer L
- Venue
- BMJ Open
- Publisher
- BMJ
- Published
- 2021-11
- Volume
- 11
- Issue
- 11
- Pages
- e050373
- ISSN
- 2044-6055 (ISSN-L)
- PMC
- PMC8578979
- OpenAlex
- W3212170362
- Cited by
- 54
- References
- 59
- Citations by year
- 2026: 17 · 2025: 16 · 2024: 12 · 2023: 7 · 2022: 1 · 2021: 1
- FWCI
- 4.52
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- gold
- doi.org
- Licence
- Locations
- BMJ Open (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc)
- PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc)
- PubMed (publishedVersion)
- DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) (submittedVersion, cc-by-sa)
- Funders
- Saskatchewan Health Research Foundation (4577)
- Canadian Institutes of Health Research Tier II Canada Research Chair
- Topics
- Health Sciences › Medicine › Reproductive Medicine › Reproductive Health and Technologies
- Health Sciences › Medicine › Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health › Maternal Mental Health During Pregnancy and Postpartum
- Social Sciences › Psychology › Social Psychology › Attachment and Relationship Dynamics
- Keywords
- infertility, depression, anxiety, psychotherapy, mental health professionals, self-esteem, identity, couple relationships, social support, therapeutic target
- MeSH terms
- Anxiety, Female, Humans, Infertility, Psychotherapy, Qualitative Research
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
The claim verdicts this report counts are experimental: their accuracy is not yet measured.
A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-10-11, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).
A second model labelled each claim on 2026-10-11 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).
Cited sources are checked with a language model’s help (gpt-6-sol).
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
How to cite
Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.
- This page
- CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Infertility-related distress and clinical targets for psychotherapy: a qualitative study. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1136/bmjopen-2021-050373
- The paper
- Dube, L., Nkosi-Mafutha, N., Balsom, A. A., & Gordon, J. L. (2021). Infertility-related distress and clinical targets for psychotherapy: a qualitative study. BMJ Open. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2021-050373
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.
