Student or educator? Sign up with your school email and get 6 months of Pro free.
Cited by 2,799

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 41 of the 41 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

Why the “Haves” Come Out Ahead: Speculations on the Limits of Legal Change

Galanter, Marc · 1974 · Law & Society Review

Abstract

This essay attempts to discern some of the general features of a legal system like the American by drawing on (and rearranging) commonplaces and less than systematic gleanings from the literature. The speculative and tentative nature of the assertions here will be apparent and is acknowledged here wholesale to spare myself and the reader repeated disclaimers. I would like to try to put forward some conjectures about the way in which the basic architecture of the legal system creates and limits the possibilities of using the system ;as a means of redistributive (that is, systemically equalizing) change. Our question, specifically, is, under what conditions can Iitigation be redistributive, taking litigation in the broadest sense of the presentation of claims to be decided by courts (or court-like agencies) and the whole penumbra of threats, feints, and so forth, surrounding such presentation.

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Run the check — free, no account needed. It reads the open-access text and checks the sources it cites.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.2307/3053023

Cites

41 of 41 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Run the check — free, no account needed. It reads the open-access text and checks the sources it cites.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Citations

Cites

Research works printed but not linked: 192

  1. HORSKY, 1952, The Washington Lawyer
  2. LOEBER, 1965, Law in the Soviet Society
  3. HAZARD, 1965, The Courts, the Public and the Law Explosion
  4. MACAULAY, 1966, Law and the Balance of Power: The Automobile Manufacturers and Their Dealers
  5. MARSHALL, 1932, The Divorce Court: Volume One—Maryland
  6. ENNIS, 1967, Criminal Victimization in the United States: A Report of a National Survey. (President's Commission on Law Enforcement and Administration of Justice, Field Survey II)
  7. SHUCHMAN, 1969, Profit on Default: an archival study of automobile repossession and resale, Stanford Law Review, 20
  8. STUMPF, 1971, The Legal Profession and Legal Services: Explorations in Local Bar Politics, Law and Society Review, 47
  9. COONS, 1964, Approaches to Court-Imposed Compromise—The Uses of Doubt and Reason, Northwestern University Law Review, 750
  10. DOO, 1973, Dispute Settlement in Chinese-American Communities, American Journal of Comparative Law, 627
  11. COHEN, 1958, Parental Authority: The Community and the Law
  12. FRIEDMAN, 1967, Contract Law and Contract Teaching: Past, Present, and Future, Wisconsin Law Review, 805
  13. BABCOCK, 1969, The Zoning Game: Municipal Practices and Policies
  14. LOWRY, 1973, Lord Mansfield and the Law Merchant, Journal of Economic Issues, 605
  15. EHRLICH, 1936, Fundamental Principles of the Sociology of Law
  16. MAYHEW, Leon H. (1973) “Institutions of Representation.” A paper prepared for delivery at the Conference on the Delivery and Distribution of Legal Services, State University of New York at Buffalo, October 12, 1973.
  17. ARNOLD, 1962, The Symbols of Government
  18. REICH, 1964a, The New Property, Yale Law Journal, 733
  19. RABINOWITZ, 1968, Law and the Social Process in Japan, Transactions of the Asiatic Society of Japan
  20. ROTHSTEIN, 1974, The Myth of Sisyphus: Legal Services Efforts on Behalf of the Poor, University of Michigan Journal of Law Reform, 493
  21. ATLESON, 1971, Disciplinary Discharges, Arbitration and NLRB Deference, Buffalo Law Review, 355
  22. GIFFORD, 1971, Communication of Legal Standards, Policy Development and Effective Conduct Regulation, Cornell Law Review, 409
  23. GOLDSTEIN, 1971, The Management of Air Quality: Legal Structures and Official Behavior, Buffalo Law Review, 1
  24. BONN, 1972b, The Predictability of Nonlegalistic Adjudication, Law and Society Review, 563
  25. 10.4159/harvard.9780674491694 · doi:10.4159/harvard.9780674491694
  26. GOLDING, 1969, Law, Reason and Justice
  27. SHUCHMAN, 1971, The Fraud Exception in Consumer Bankruptcy, Stanford Law Review, 735
  28. HANDLER, 1967, The Lawyer and his Community: The Practicing Bar in a Middlesized City
  29. BRUFF, 1973, Arizona's Inferior Courts, Law and the Social Order, 1
  30. HOLLINGSWORTH, 1974, The Ohio Small Claims Court: An Empirical Study, University of Cincinnati Law Review, 469
  31. SHUCHMAN, 1968, Ethics and Legal Ethics: The Propriety of the Canons as a Group Moral Code, George Washington Law Review, 244
  32. TANNER, 1970, Disputing and the Genesis of Legal Principles: Examples from Minangkabau, Southwestern Journal of Anthropology, 375
  33. HUNTIN, 1962, Who Sues in New York City? A Study of Automobile Accident Claims
  34. MENTSCHIKOFF, 1961, Commercial Arbitration, Columbia Law Review, 846
  35. VIRTUE, 1956, Family Cases in Court: A Group of Four Court Studies Dealing with Judicial Administration
  36. VOSE, 1967, Caucasions Only: The Supreme Court, the NAACP, and the Restrictive Covenant Cases
  37. YNGVESSON, 1973, Responses to Grievance Behavior: Extended Cases in a Fishing Community, Choice-Making in the Law.
  38. RANKIN, 1964, The Effect of Pretrial Detention, N.Y.U. Law Review, 641
  39. LARGE, 1972, Is Anybody Listening? The Problem of Access in Environmental Litigation, Wisconsin Law Review, 62
  40. KALVEN, 1958, The Jury, the Law and the Personal Injury Damage Award, Ohio State Law Journal, 158
  41. MAYHEW, 1971, Stability and Social Change
  42. SIMKIN, 1971, Mediation and the Dynamics of Collective Bargaining
  43. HAHM, 1969, Comparative Judicial Behavior: Cross-Cultural Studies of Political Decision-Making in the East and West
  44. 1953, Settlement of Personal Injury Cases in the Chicago Area, Northwestern University Law Review, 895
  45. HOMBERGER, 1974, Private Suits in the Public Interest in the United States of America, Buffalo Law Review, 343
  46. BLUMBERG, 1967a, Criminal Justice
  47. BLACK, 1973, The Mobilization of Law, Journal of Legal Studies, 125
  48. 10.4159/harvard.9780674429840 · doi:10.4159/harvard.9780674429840
  49. O'CONNELL, 1971, The Injury Industry and the Remedy of No-Fault Insurance
  50. BURGHARDT, 1972, Tenants and the Urban Housing Crisis
  51. FRANK, 1930, Law and the Modern Mind
  52. BURNLEY, 1973, Comment, Solicitation by the Second Oldest Profession: Attorneys and Advertising, Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review, 77
  53. WANNER, 1974a, The Public Ordering of Private Relations: Part I: Initiating Civil Cases in Urban Trial Courts, Law and Society Review, 421
  54. CHRISTIANSON, 1970, Lawyers for People of Moderate Means: Some Problems of Availability of Legal Services
  55. WEXLER, 1973, Practicing Law for Poor People, Yale Law Journal, 1049
  56. ASPIN, Leslie (1966) A Study of Reinstatement Under the National Labor Relations Act. Unpublished dissertation, Mass. Inst. of Tech., Dept. of Economics.
  57. HAKMAN, 1969, Frontiers of Judicial Research
  58. BORKIN, 1950, The Patent Infringement Suit—Ordeal by Trial, University of Chicago Law Review, 634
  59. JACOB, 1969, Debtors in Court: The Consumption of Government Services
  60. SHRIVER, 1966, America's Religious Heretics: Formal and Informal Trials in American Protestantism
  61. REPPETTO, 1970, The Millet System in the Ottoman and American Empires, Public Policy, 629
  62. LEPAULLE, 1950, Law Practice in France, Columbia Law Review, 945
  63. GROSSMAN, 1970, The Supreme Court and Social Change: A Preliminary Inquiry, American Behavioral Scientist, 535
  64. AGNEW, 1972, What's Wrong with the Legal Services Program, A.B.A. Journal, 930
  65. ANDERSON, 1969, Ombudsman Papers: American Experience and Proposals, With a Comparative Analysis of Ombudsmen Offices by Kent M. Weeks
  66. KIDDER, 1973, Courts and Conflict in an Indian City: A Study in Legal Impact, Journal of Commonwealth Political Studies, 121
  67. OWEN, Harold J. Jr. (1971) The Role of Trial Courts in the Local Political System: A Comparison of Two Georgia Counties. Unpublished dissertation, Department of Political Science, University of Georgia.
  68. 1974, Large Grievances About Small Causes: New York City's Small Claims Court—Proposals for Improving the Collection of Judgments
  69. RAWLS, 1958, Justice as Fairness, The Philosophical Review, 80
  70. SAARI, 1967, Open Doors to Justice—An Overview of Financing Justice in America, Journal of the American Judicature Society, 296
  71. ABEL-SMITH, 1967, Lawyers and the Courts: A Sociological Study of the English Legal System, 1750-1965
  72. PAGTER, 1964, The California Small Claims Court, California Law Review, 876
  73. SIMON, 1972, Class Actions—Useful Tool or Engine of Destruction, Federal Rules Decisions, 375
  74. KIDDER, 1974, Formal Litigation and Professional Insecurity: Legal Entrepreneurship in South India, Law and Society Review, 11
  75. ROSS, 1970, Settled Out of Court: The Social Process of Insurance Claims Adjustment
  76. SCIGLIANO, 1971, The Supreme Court and the Presidency
  77. ROTHWAX, 1969, Justice and the Law in the Mobilization for Youth Experience
  78. NONET, 1969, Administrative Justice: Advocacy and Change in a Government Agency
  79. BRILL, 1973, The Uses and Abuses of Legal Assistance, The Public Interest, 38
  80. DAHL, 1958, Decision-making in a Democracy: The Supreme Court as a National Policy-maker, Journal of Public Law, 279
  81. BLACK, 1967b, The Practice of Law as a Confidence Game, Law and Society Review, 15
  82. CAMERON, 1964, The Booster and the Snitch: Department Shoplifting
  83. KENNEDY, 1973, Legal Formality, Journal of Legal Studies, 351
  84. MacCALLUM, 1967, Law and Warfare
  85. HOWARD, 1969, Adjudication Considered as a Process of Conflict Resolution: A Variation on Separation of Powers, Journal of Public Law, 339
  86. FRIEDMAN, 1973, A History of American Law
  87. MURRAY, 1969, Unconscionability: Unconscionability, University of Pittsburgh Law Review, 1
  88. HART, 1958, The Legal Process: Basic Problems in the Making and Application of Law
  89. McPHERSON, 1972, In My Father's House There are Many Mansions, and I'm Going to Get Me Some of Them, Too! The Story of the Contract Buyers League, Atlantic Monthly, 51
  90. AUBERT, 1963, Competition and Dissensus: Two Types of Conflict Resolution, Journal of Conflict Resolution, 26
  91. ROSENTHAL, 1971, Negotiability—Who Needs It?, Columbia Law Review, 375
  92. LEFF, 1970a, Injury, Ignorance, and Spite—The Dynamics of Coercive Collection, Yale Law Journal, 1
  93. SEYMOUR, 1974, Frontier Justice: A Run-In With the Law, The New York Times
  94. 1971, Roman Catholic Ecclesiastical Courts and the Law of Marriage, Columbia Journal of Law and Social Problems, 204
  95. 1973, Newsletter
  96. ORBELL, 1972, A Theory of Neighborhood Problem Solving: Political Action vs. Residential Mobility, American Political Science Review, 471
  97. REICHSTEIN, 1965, Ambulance Chasing: A Case Study of Deviation Within the Legal Profession, Social Problems, 3
  98. 1970, Product Safety Law and Administration: Federal, State, Local and Common Law
  99. SKOLNICK, 1966, Justice Without Trial: Law Enforcement in a Democratic Society
  100. VAUGHAN, 1968, The Landlord-Tenant Relationship in a Low-Income Area, Social Problems, 208
  101. MOSIER, 1973, Modern Legislation, Metropolitan Court, Miniscule Results: A Study of Detroit's Landlord-Tenant Court, University of Michigan Journal of Law Reform, 6
  102. tenBROEK, 1964-65, California's Dual System of Family Law: Its Origin, Development and Present Status, Stanford Law Review
  103. FULLER, 1969, The Morality of Law
  104. WALD, 1964, Foreward: Pretrial Detention and Ultimate Freedom, N.Y.U. Law Review, 631
  105. 1970, Rabbinical Courts: Modern Day Solomons, Columbia Journal of Law and Social Problems, 49
  106. COHN, 1959, Some Notes on Law and Change in North India, Economic Development and Cultural Change, 79
  107. GALANTER, 1968, The Displacement of Traditional Law in Modern India, Journal of Social Issues, 65
  108. McINTYRE, 1968, A Study of Judicial Dominance of the Charging Process, Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science, 463
  109. WEBER, 1954, Max Weber on Law in Economy and Society
  110. DERRETT, 1959, Sir Henry Maine and Law in India, Juridical Review, 40
  111. SKOLNICK, 1967, Social Control in the Adversary Process, Journal of Conflict Resolution, 52
  112. RAWLS, 1964b, Individual Rights and Social Welfare: The Emerging Legal Issues, Yale Law Journal, 1245
  113. DAVIS, 1967, Tenant Unions: An Experiment in Private Law Making, Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review, 237
  114. CRESSEY, 1969, Theft of the Nation: The Structure and Operations of Organized Crime in America
  115. SMITH, Regan G. (1970) The Small Claims Court: a Sociological Interpretation. Unpublished dissertation, Department of Sociology, University of Illinois.
  116. 1970, Justice Out of Reach: A Case for Small Claims Courts
  117. FRIEDMAN, 1967, Social Change and the Law of Industrial Accidents, Columbia Law Review, 50
  118. KIDDER, Robert L. (1971) The Dynamics of Litigation: A Study of Civil Litigation in South Indian Courts. Unpublished Dissertation, Northwestern University.
  119. FORD, 1970, The American Legal System
  120. POWELL, 1968, on Real Property. One Volume Ed
  121. SCHRAG, 1969, Bleak House 1968: A Report on Consumer Test Litigation, N.Y.U. Law Review, 115
  122. CASPER, 1970, Lawyers Before the Supreme Court: Civil Liberties and Civil Rights, 1957-66, Stanford Law Review, 487
  123. SHKLAR, 1964, Legalism
  124. HALLAUER, 1972, Low Income Laborers as Legal Clients: Use Patterns and Attitudes Toward Lawyers, Denver Law Journal, 169
  125. LADINSKY, 1963, Careers of Lawyers, Law Practice and Legal Institutions, American Sociological Review, 47
  126. BATTLE, 1971, In Search of the Adversary System—The Cooperative Practices of Private Criminal Defense Attorneys, Texas Law Review, 60
  127. FOOTE, 1956, Vagrancy-type Law and Its Administration, University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 603
  128. HAZARD, 1970, Law Reforming in the Anti-Poverty Effort, University of Chicago Law Review, 242
  129. HURST, 1950, The Growth of American Law: The Law Makers
  130. 10.2307/1338271 · doi:10.2307/1338271
  131. LOCKARD, 1968, Toward Equal Opportunity: A Study of State and Local Antidiscrimination Laws
  132. RANDALL, 1968, Censorship of the Movies: Social and Political Control of a Mass Medium
  133. SCHELLING, 1963, The Strategy of Conflict
  134. VOSE, 1972, Constitutional Change: Amendment Politics and Supreme Court Litigation Since 1900
  135. SMALL CLAIMS STUDY GROUP (1972) “Little Injustices: Small Claims Courts and the American Consumer.” A preliminary report to The Center for Auto Safety, Cambridge, Mass.
  136. DOLBEARE, 1967, Trial Courts in Urban Politics: State Court Policy Impact and Function in a Local Political System
  137. DOLBEARE, 1971, The School Prayer Decisions: From Court Policy to Local Practice
  138. BLANKENBURG, 1972, Tatsachen Forschung in der Justiz
  139. AUBERT, 1967, Courts and Conflict Resolution, Journal of Conflict Resolution, 40
  140. LEFF, 1970b, Unconscionability and the Crow-Consumers and the Common-Law Tradition, University of Pittsburgh Law Review, 349
  141. LORTIE, 1959, Laymen to Lawmen: Law School, Careers, and Professional Socialization, Harvard Educational Review, 352
  142. ENGLE, C. Donald (1971) Criminal Justice in the City. Unpublished dissertation, Department of Political Science, Temple University.
  143. ROSENTHAL, Douglas E. (1970) Client Participation in Professional Decision: the Lawyer-Client Relationship in Personal Injury Cases. Unpublished dissertation, Yale University.
  144. HANDLER, 1966, The Law of the Poor
  145. FINKLESTEIN, 1954, The Composer and the Public Interest—Regulation of Performing Rights Societies, Law and Contemporary Problems, 275
  146. JOHNSTONE, 1967, Lawyers and Their Work: An Analysis of the Legal Profession in the United States and England
  147. FRIEDMAN, 1967, Legal Rules and the Process of Social Change, Stanford Law Review, 786
  148. LIPSKY, 1970, Protest in City Politics: Rent Strikes, Housing, and the Power of the Poor
  149. TRUBEK, 1972, Toward a Social Theory of Law: An Essay on the Study of Law and Development, Yale Law Journal, 1
  150. HOMBERGER, 1970, Functions of Orality in Austrian and American Civil Procedure, Buffalo Law Review, 9
  151. KAWASHIMA, 1963, Law in Japan: The Legal Order in a Changing Society
  152. HOMBERGER, 1971, State Class Actions and the Federal Rule, Columbia Law Review, 609
  153. SUMMERS, 1960, Individual Rights in Collective Agreements: A Preliminary Analysis, Buffalo Law Review, 239
  154. CARLIN, 1965, Legal Representation and Class Justice, U.C.L.A. Law Review, 381
  155. DOLBEARE, 1969, Frontiers of Judicial Research
  156. FRIEDMAN, 1969, Legal Culture and Social Development, Law and Society Review, 29
  157. LEVINE, 1970, Community Resource Orientation Among Low Income Groups, Wisconsin Law Review, 80
  158. MORRISON, 1974, Clerks and Clients: Paraprofessional Roles and Cultural Identities in Indian Litigation, Law and Society Review, 39
  159. CONRAD, 1964, Automobile Accident Costs and Payments: Studies in the Economics of Injury Reparation
  160. BOHANNON, 1965, The Differing Realms of the Law in The Ethnography of Law, The Ethnography of Law (=Part 2 of American Anthropologist,, 67
  161. BURGER, 1970, The State of the Judiciary—1970, A.B.A. Journal, 929
  162. MORGAN, 1968, The Politics of Religious Conflict: Church and State in America
  163. SMIGEL, 1969, The Wall Street Lawyer: Professional Organization Man?
  164. 10.2307/3053082 · doi:10.2307/3053082
  165. McINTYRE, 1970, Prosecutors and Early Disposition of Felony Cases, A.B.A. Journal, 1154
  166. GALANTER, 1968-69, Introduction: The Study of the Indian Legal Profession, Law and Society Review, 201
  167. HENDERSON, 1968, Political Development in Modern Japan
  168. IANNI, 1972, A Family Business: Kinship and Control in Organized Crime
  169. TULLOCK, 1971, Logic of the Law
  170. 1970, The New Public Interest Lawyers, Yale Law Journal, 1069
  171. HANDLER, 1971a, The Shift from Substantive to Procedural Innovations in Antitrust Suits, Record of N.Y.C. Bar Association, 124
  172. OHLHAUSEN, 1936, Rich and Poor in Civil Procedure, Science and Society, 275
  173. HAKMAN, 1966, Lobbying the Supreme Court—An Appraisal of Political Science Folklore, Fordham Law Review, 15
  174. MOULTON, 1969, The Persecution and Intimidation of the Low-Income Litigant as Performed by the Small Claims Court in California, Stanford Law Review, 1657
  175. CAHN, 1970, Power to the People or the Profession?—The Public Interest in Public Interest Law, Yale Law Journal, 1005
  176. MATZA, 1964, Delinquency and Drift
  177. BEUTEL, 1957, Some Potentialities of Experimental Jurisprudence as a New Branch of Social Science
  178. VOSE, 1966, Interest Groups, Judicial Review, and Local Government, Western Political Quarterly, 85
  179. WOLL, 1960, Informal Administrative Adjudication: Summary of Findings, U.C.L.A. Law Review, 436
  180. SHOVER, 1966, Cornbelt Rebellion: The Farmers' Holiday Association
  181. LAUFER, 1970, Embattled Victims of the Uninsured: In Court with New York's MVAIC, 1959-69, Buffalo Law Review, 471
  182. DIBBLE, 1973, What Is, and What Ought to Be: A Comparison of Certain Formal Characteristics of the Ideological and Legal Styles of Thought, American Journal of Sociology, 511
  183. GRACE, 1970, Justice, Chinese Style, Case and Comment, 50
  184. KATZ, 1969, Mr. Lin's Accident Case: A Working Hypothesis on the Oriental Meaning of Face in International Relations on the Grand Scheme, Yale Law Journal, 1491
  185. HANDLER, 1971b, Twenty-Fourth Annual Antitrust Review, Record of N.Y.C. Bar Association, 753
  186. ATLESON, 1967, A Union Member's Right of Free Speech and Assembly: Institutional Interests and Individual Rights, Minnesota Law Review, 403
  187. BONN, 1972a, Arbitration: An Alternative System for Handling Contract Related Disputes, Administrative Sciences Quarterly, 254
  188. LOBENTHAL, 1970, Power and Put-On: The Law in America
  189. NADER, 1965, The Anthropological Study of Law, The Ethnography of Law (= Part 2 of American Anthropologist, Volume 67
  190. WHITFORD, 1968, Law and the Consumer Transaction: A case study of the automobile warranty, Wisconsin Law Review, 1006
  191. ZEISEL, 1959, Delay in the Court
  192. MURPHY, 1959, Lower Court Checks on Supreme Court Power, American Political Science Review, 1017

Cited by

See all 2,799

Metadata

Authors
Galanter, M.
Venue
Law & Society Review
Published
1974
Volume
9
Issue
1
Pages
95-160
ISSN
  • 0023-9216 (ISSN-L)
  • 1540-5893
OpenAlex
W2736643333
Cited by
2,799
References
41
FWCI
46.13
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
closed

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.