The DOI matches its Crossref record; 36 of the 36 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; 13 of the 73 sources its claims cite were checked for support.
Role of Sensory Evaluation in Consumer Acceptance of Plant-Based Meat Analogs and Meat Extenders: A Scoping Review
Open accessAbstract
Scoping review on how sensory evaluation methods support consumer acceptance studies.
Overview
CoChat Summary
# TL;DR
This scoping review summarizes 14 papers on sensory evaluation of plant-based meat analogs and meat extenders, showing that hedonic testing and descriptive analysis are both useful for linking formulation and processing choices to consumer acceptance. Across the reviewed studies, ingredients and processing methods could improve color, flavor, and texture, but the authors emphasize that control choice, standardized methods, and combining sensory with instrumental measures are critical.
# Key findings
- The review identified 14 articles: 11 used hedonic testing and 3 used sensory descriptive analysis.
- Of the 14 papers, 11 evaluated 100% plant-based meat analogs and 3 evaluated extended meat products; 12 studied ingredient addition and 2 studied processing/cooking methods.
- In the reviewed studies, 0.3–0.6% kappa-carrageenan or 0.6% konjac mannan gave the highest consumer acceptability for a soy protein isolate sausage, and 1.5% iota-carrageenan was the optimal level for hedonic texture ratings in one soy meat analog study.
- In one hybrid beef patty study, substituting beef with textured soy protein up to 30% still produced acceptable liking scores, and in another hybrid meatball study, 15% TSP + nutritional yeast gave the highest liking scores for flavor and overall acceptance.
# Methods
- This is a narrative/scoping review of original research on sensory evaluation of meat analogs and meat extenders.
- The authors searched Web of Science and Google Scholar for papers from 2000 to 2020, then excluded products made with insects, mycoproteins, algae, and in vitro meat, and required at least 30% plant-protein replacement for meat extenders; the final set was 14 articles.
- The review synthesizes studies using consumer acceptability/hedonic tests and descriptive sensory analysis, sometimes paired with instrumental measures such as texture analysis and color analysis.
# Limitations
- The paper notes that some included studies had methodological issues, such as using a trained panel for hedonic responses, which it says is not standard for consumer acceptability and should be interpreted with caution.
- The paper states that some consumer groups were small, making it inappropriate to generalize hedonic responses in those cases.
- Evident from the text: this is a narrative review, so it does not report a formal meta-analysis or pooled effect estimates.
Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
12 Valid · 3 Not valid · 59 Not checked · 68 Own results and interpretations
The cited sources support only part of this claim — read each source’s verdict below.
In the paper
“While there are many different processing methods to prepare meat analogs, one top-down strategy is high-moisture wet extrusion, which is highly successful in achieving a desirable structure, most resembling animal proteins [13].”
§ Role of Sensory Evaluation in Consumer Acceptance of Plant-Based Meat Analogs and Meat Extenders: A Scoping Review > 1. Introduction > 1.1. Background: The Need for Sustainable Alternatives to Meat
What the sources say
- Partly supportedcites [13] Dekkers, 2018, Structuring processes for meat analogues, Trends Food Sci. Technol. sourceExperimental — accuracy not yet measured
Section 2.2.1 describes high-moisture extrusion as producing fibrous products and says extrusion is the most widely applied technology for meat analogues. But Section 3 and the Conclusions say bottom-up methods have the potential to mimic meat’s structure most closely; they do not support describing high-moisture extrusion as the method that most resembles animal proteins. (LLM, conf=0.88)
boostedstates a cause- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: unclear — It is unclear whether the paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Partly supported
Every source the paper cites for this claim was checked and supports it.
In the paper
“Results from the hedonic test showed that addition of 15% TSP and nutritional yeast resulted in the highest liking scores for flavor and overall acceptance.”
§ Role of Sensory Evaluation in Consumer Acceptance of Plant-Based Meat Analogs and Meat Extenders: A Scoping Review > 3. Literature Review > 3.2. Taste, Flavor, Aroma A common disadvantage of using plant proteins in meat analogs is the generation of volatile compounds from the lipid oxidation of unsaturated fatty acids that contribute to the formation of unappealing odors and flavors [41]. To overcome this problem, food scientists develop recipes that include flavoring mixtures with seasonings, spices, and enhancers that can both replicate the typical flavor of smoked meat as well as mask the beany, grassy, or green aroma of pulses. To assess consumer acceptability of meat analogs in terms of taste, flavor, and aroma, the sample is presented in a way so that it resembles the equivalent meat product. In a study performed by Rehrah et al. [30], three formulations of peanut-based minced product were evaluated against a commercial soy-based minced product in a seasoned puff pastry application. The peanut-based meat analog was made by fortifying defatted peanut flour with peanut protein concentrate. The mixture was extruded, ground into a beef-like mince, and stuffed into a rolled puff pastry to provide a more realistic version of a commercial snack. All three formulations of textured peanut protein concentrate (PPC) were seasoned with beef flavor and soy sauce as a flavor enhancer. In addition, the first sample contained tomato powder, the second sample contained crushed red pepper, and the third sample had no modifications. A sensory panel of 60 participants rated the peanut-based sample along with the commercial soy-based control in terms of beefy flavor, off-flavor, and spiciness on a 9-point hedonic scale. Participants were also asked to determine spiciness on a just-right scale with three intensities (too little, just right, too much). Of the three formulations of peanut-based meat analog, the one containing crushed red peppers had the most acceptable meaty flavor, the least dislike of off-flavor, and the most adequate spiciness level. These results suggest that the addition of flavors, enhancers, and spices can positively affect consumer acceptance of taste of a meat analog. However, while PPC performed better than soy-based formulations in a puff pastry application, the study did not include comparisons against a traditional meat formulation, suggesting that the choice of the control is a significant variable to be considered. On one hand, if the reference and test samples consist of different plant proteins, hedonic responses may be affected by the additional spices, with the most seasoned formulation resulting in higher acceptance scores. Alternatively, using a full-meat sample as a control would help to best determine how a meat analog compares to the desirable sensory properties of a traditional animal product. Comparing plant-based meat analogs to their meat equivalent can be adopted as a strategy during evaluation of extended meat products. Wong and colleagues [31] developed three formulations of hybrid beef patties by substituting 10%, 20%, and 30% ground beef with hydrated textured soy protein (TSP). A first hedonic test with 55 consumers showed no significant difference in overall liking scores for all formulations compared to the all-beef control. In a second hedonic test, 56 consumers evaluated the sensory properties of a hybrid beef patty with 20% TSP substitution and all-beef patty both with reduced sodium level. Liking scores for flavor were slightly lower in both the 20% TSP patty and the all-beef patty with reduced sodium compared to the all-beef control with regular sodium level. This suggests that substitution of beef with plant protein up to 30% can lead to acceptable liking scores as long as the sodium content remains unchanged. These findings reveal that maintaining a high sodium level in meat analogs is important for consumer acceptance in terms of flavor, although this may lower the nutritional quality of the final product. In another study, Grasso et al. [37] developed four types of hybrid meatballs by substituting 15% and 30% of beef with TSP in duplicates, with or without nutritional yeast, which was used as a flavor enhancer for its strong umami flavor. Sixty participants evaluated the four samples and an all-beef control by assessing degree of liking on a 9-point scale in terms of flavor, texture, and overall acceptance. In addition, participant used the check-all-that-apply (CATA) method by selecting the most appropriate terms to describe the samples. This method provides a complete description of the sensory characteristics of the samples. A list of 24 terms was chosen from the available literature on meat products. The CATA terms related to flavor were “tasty’’, ‘‘bland’’, ‘‘cheesy’’, ‘‘weak meaty’’, ‘‘strong meaty’’, ‘‘wheat-cereal like’’, ‘‘unusual’’, and ‘‘characteristic’’. Results from the hedonic test showed that addition of 15% TSP and nutritional yeast resulted in the highest liking scores for flavor and overall acceptance. Results from CATA analysis revealed that this sample was most associated with the term “tasty” and less associated with “bland”, while the 30% TSP without yeast was most associated with “wheat-cereal like”, suggesting that the absence of flavor enhancers in a sample with a high percentage of soy content may lead to the detection of strong off-flavors. Interestingly, the all-beef control was most frequently associated with the term “bland”. This suggests that the selection of control is important in understanding and interpreting consumer acceptance of hybrid products. It is important to select a control that is liked by consumers and is a good representation of the target product, as a low-quality control product could lead to misinterpreting results. Partial replacement of animal protein with plant protein provides the opportunity to improve the sustainability of meat products while also improving the nutritional profile of processed meat. However, addition of plant proteins might affect the overall product quality. The addition of up to 15% vegetable protein is appropriate to improve healthfulness of meat products without reducing the quality of sensory attributes. When the objective of the study is to test how different concentrations of a flavoring agent affect the sensory attributes of the final product, the sample without the added ingredient is used as a control, as opposed to using a full-meat product or a commercial meat substitute. Chiang et al. [32] added Maillard-reacted beef bone hydrolysate (MRP) at four concentrations to a meat analog made with soy protein concentrate and wheat gluten to improve its sensory attributes. Beef-bone extract, a by-product of meat processing, can be used as a flavor-enhancing agent by undergoing enzymatic hydrolysis to increase the proportion of free amino acids, followed by Maillard reaction through addition of reducing sugars to produce heterocyclic compounds. These molecules contribute to the typical flavor and aroma of smoked meat when this is cooked on the grill. Sensory evaluation by a group of 55 consumers revealed that 20% MRP was the optimal level for acceptance, resulting in the highest sensory scores for meaty aroma and meaty taste. By contrast, addition of 40% MRP received the lowest scores in all attributes due to bitter taste and a burnt appearance, while 0% MRP (the control) resulted in a weaker meaty taste and an undesirable pale brown color. The addition of MRP, under a certain concentration, helps to increase desirable “meat” flavors and increases acceptance compared to unflavored meat analog. It is not known if the addition of MRP would compare to a full-meat control. However, this product includes meat extracts, making it inappropriate for vegans and vegetarians; yet, it demonstrates the use of hydrolyzed protein materials can enhance desirable flavor attributes, which is important in increasing overall acceptance of meat analogs. Katayama and Wilson [25] used a similar approach in their study. The aim was to determine the most acceptable concentration of vegetable-based “chicken” and “shrimp” flavors added to textured soy meat analogs prepared in four different shapes (narrow strip, wide strip, shred, and bit) and with two cooking methods (fried and baked). The use of vegetable-based flavors provides an acceptable alternative to meat-by products like beef-bone extract, which may represent a barrier for vegan consumers. In the study, “chicken” flavor was added in either powder or liquid form at 3% and 4% to all four shapes of extrudates, which were fried, while two types of “shrimp” flavor, one oyster-like, the other a combination of oyster and crab-like, were added to shred-shaped extrudates, which were baked. A trained sensory panel of 14 participants generated a list of descriptive terms based on chicken and shrimp flavors to evaluate the samples. All formulations were rated on an analog scale using unflavored samples as controls. Results showed that the presence of 4% flavoring enhanced the overall saltiness and meatiness. The size of the product sample appeared to significantly impact the “chicken” flavor in powder form as the narrow strip-shape was more intense in the oily flavor compared to the wide strip sample. This was attributed to the formation of air pockets in the former, responsible for encapsulating flavor molecules during frying. Following descriptive analysis, researchers conducted a consumer preference test with 125 volunteers for evaluating the “chicken” flavored product. Consumer results revealed that the chicken-flavored sample was most accepted when fried rather than baked. However, chemical analysis showed that the fried samples had more than 3 times higher fat content than the baked samples, suggesting that the higher fat content may increase liking. Moreover, this cooking method can negatively impact the nutritional quality of the product. In this study, researchers first used a descriptive sensory analysis to determine the best product formulation based on variables, such as type and concentration of the flavoring agent as well as shape and cooking method of the sample. Then, a consumer preference test was performed to evaluate the product based on a single variable. Performing a consumer test following descriptive analysis is a common strategy to efficiently assess consumer acceptance by combining both quantitative and qualitative data on the sensory profile of meat analogs in order to collect more specific information that can be used to apply changes in the recipe or processing method. The formation of unappealing odors and flavors during processing of plant proteins represents a barrier to acceptance of meat analogs. Addition of spices, seasonings, and flavor enhancers is an appropriate strategy to mask the beany and grassy aroma, specifically in pulses. The nature of the added ingredient may need to comply with vegetarian and/or vegan consumers’ dietary restrictions. Meat by-products such as beef bone hydrolysate can provide a “meaty” flavor to meat analogs in order to increase acceptance among non-vegetarian consumers. Yet, vegetable-based mixtures have been successful in recreating the flavor of poultry or seafood products. Use of spices, such as red pepper flakes, can increase spiciness to overcome off-flavors, while nutritional yeast can be used as an enhancer to provide a “meaty” umami taste. Sensory evaluation methods aimed at identifying acceptable flavoring ingredients can be influenced by the selection of the control product. Comparing two different kinds of plant proteins as opposed to using a full-meat control can impact conclusions drawn regarding product liking. Further research should focus on evaluating the taste and flavor of meat analogs in a meal context, as additional foods in the dish can alter the perception of oral sensation of meat analogs.
What the sources say
- Supportedcites [37] Grasso, 2019, Effect of texturised soy protein and yeast on the instrumental and sensory quality of hybrid beef meatballs, J. Food Sci. Technol. source
The Abstract states that meatballs with 15% TSP and yeast received the highest flavour and overall acceptability scores. The Sensory evaluation section confirms that this formulation scored significantly higher than the control, though not significantly higher than the other TSP-containing samples. (LLM, conf=0.94)
plainstates a causen = 4- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: unclear — It is unclear whether the paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Supported
Every source the paper cites for this claim was checked and supports it.
In the paper
“Interestingly, the all-beef control was most frequently associated with the term “bland”.”
§ Role of Sensory Evaluation in Consumer Acceptance of Plant-Based Meat Analogs and Meat Extenders: A Scoping Review > 3. Literature Review > 3.2. Taste, Flavor, Aroma A common disadvantage of using plant proteins in meat analogs is the generation of volatile compounds from the lipid oxidation of unsaturated fatty acids that contribute to the formation of unappealing odors and flavors [41]. To overcome this problem, food scientists develop recipes that include flavoring mixtures with seasonings, spices, and enhancers that can both replicate the typical flavor of smoked meat as well as mask the beany, grassy, or green aroma of pulses. To assess consumer acceptability of meat analogs in terms of taste, flavor, and aroma, the sample is presented in a way so that it resembles the equivalent meat product. In a study performed by Rehrah et al. [30], three formulations of peanut-based minced product were evaluated against a commercial soy-based minced product in a seasoned puff pastry application. The peanut-based meat analog was made by fortifying defatted peanut flour with peanut protein concentrate. The mixture was extruded, ground into a beef-like mince, and stuffed into a rolled puff pastry to provide a more realistic version of a commercial snack. All three formulations of textured peanut protein concentrate (PPC) were seasoned with beef flavor and soy sauce as a flavor enhancer. In addition, the first sample contained tomato powder, the second sample contained crushed red pepper, and the third sample had no modifications. A sensory panel of 60 participants rated the peanut-based sample along with the commercial soy-based control in terms of beefy flavor, off-flavor, and spiciness on a 9-point hedonic scale. Participants were also asked to determine spiciness on a just-right scale with three intensities (too little, just right, too much). Of the three formulations of peanut-based meat analog, the one containing crushed red peppers had the most acceptable meaty flavor, the least dislike of off-flavor, and the most adequate spiciness level. These results suggest that the addition of flavors, enhancers, and spices can positively affect consumer acceptance of taste of a meat analog. However, while PPC performed better than soy-based formulations in a puff pastry application, the study did not include comparisons against a traditional meat formulation, suggesting that the choice of the control is a significant variable to be considered. On one hand, if the reference and test samples consist of different plant proteins, hedonic responses may be affected by the additional spices, with the most seasoned formulation resulting in higher acceptance scores. Alternatively, using a full-meat sample as a control would help to best determine how a meat analog compares to the desirable sensory properties of a traditional animal product. Comparing plant-based meat analogs to their meat equivalent can be adopted as a strategy during evaluation of extended meat products. Wong and colleagues [31] developed three formulations of hybrid beef patties by substituting 10%, 20%, and 30% ground beef with hydrated textured soy protein (TSP). A first hedonic test with 55 consumers showed no significant difference in overall liking scores for all formulations compared to the all-beef control. In a second hedonic test, 56 consumers evaluated the sensory properties of a hybrid beef patty with 20% TSP substitution and all-beef patty both with reduced sodium level. Liking scores for flavor were slightly lower in both the 20% TSP patty and the all-beef patty with reduced sodium compared to the all-beef control with regular sodium level. This suggests that substitution of beef with plant protein up to 30% can lead to acceptable liking scores as long as the sodium content remains unchanged. These findings reveal that maintaining a high sodium level in meat analogs is important for consumer acceptance in terms of flavor, although this may lower the nutritional quality of the final product. In another study, Grasso et al. [37] developed four types of hybrid meatballs by substituting 15% and 30% of beef with TSP in duplicates, with or without nutritional yeast, which was used as a flavor enhancer for its strong umami flavor. Sixty participants evaluated the four samples and an all-beef control by assessing degree of liking on a 9-point scale in terms of flavor, texture, and overall acceptance. In addition, participant used the check-all-that-apply (CATA) method by selecting the most appropriate terms to describe the samples. This method provides a complete description of the sensory characteristics of the samples. A list of 24 terms was chosen from the available literature on meat products. The CATA terms related to flavor were “tasty’’, ‘‘bland’’, ‘‘cheesy’’, ‘‘weak meaty’’, ‘‘strong meaty’’, ‘‘wheat-cereal like’’, ‘‘unusual’’, and ‘‘characteristic’’. Results from the hedonic test showed that addition of 15% TSP and nutritional yeast resulted in the highest liking scores for flavor and overall acceptance. Results from CATA analysis revealed that this sample was most associated with the term “tasty” and less associated with “bland”, while the 30% TSP without yeast was most associated with “wheat-cereal like”, suggesting that the absence of flavor enhancers in a sample with a high percentage of soy content may lead to the detection of strong off-flavors. Interestingly, the all-beef control was most frequently associated with the term “bland”. This suggests that the selection of control is important in understanding and interpreting consumer acceptance of hybrid products. It is important to select a control that is liked by consumers and is a good representation of the target product, as a low-quality control product could lead to misinterpreting results. Partial replacement of animal protein with plant protein provides the opportunity to improve the sustainability of meat products while also improving the nutritional profile of processed meat. However, addition of plant proteins might affect the overall product quality. The addition of up to 15% vegetable protein is appropriate to improve healthfulness of meat products without reducing the quality of sensory attributes. When the objective of the study is to test how different concentrations of a flavoring agent affect the sensory attributes of the final product, the sample without the added ingredient is used as a control, as opposed to using a full-meat product or a commercial meat substitute. Chiang et al. [32] added Maillard-reacted beef bone hydrolysate (MRP) at four concentrations to a meat analog made with soy protein concentrate and wheat gluten to improve its sensory attributes. Beef-bone extract, a by-product of meat processing, can be used as a flavor-enhancing agent by undergoing enzymatic hydrolysis to increase the proportion of free amino acids, followed by Maillard reaction through addition of reducing sugars to produce heterocyclic compounds. These molecules contribute to the typical flavor and aroma of smoked meat when this is cooked on the grill. Sensory evaluation by a group of 55 consumers revealed that 20% MRP was the optimal level for acceptance, resulting in the highest sensory scores for meaty aroma and meaty taste. By contrast, addition of 40% MRP received the lowest scores in all attributes due to bitter taste and a burnt appearance, while 0% MRP (the control) resulted in a weaker meaty taste and an undesirable pale brown color. The addition of MRP, under a certain concentration, helps to increase desirable “meat” flavors and increases acceptance compared to unflavored meat analog. It is not known if the addition of MRP would compare to a full-meat control. However, this product includes meat extracts, making it inappropriate for vegans and vegetarians; yet, it demonstrates the use of hydrolyzed protein materials can enhance desirable flavor attributes, which is important in increasing overall acceptance of meat analogs. Katayama and Wilson [25] used a similar approach in their study. The aim was to determine the most acceptable concentration of vegetable-based “chicken” and “shrimp” flavors added to textured soy meat analogs prepared in four different shapes (narrow strip, wide strip, shred, and bit) and with two cooking methods (fried and baked). The use of vegetable-based flavors provides an acceptable alternative to meat-by products like beef-bone extract, which may represent a barrier for vegan consumers. In the study, “chicken” flavor was added in either powder or liquid form at 3% and 4% to all four shapes of extrudates, which were fried, while two types of “shrimp” flavor, one oyster-like, the other a combination of oyster and crab-like, were added to shred-shaped extrudates, which were baked. A trained sensory panel of 14 participants generated a list of descriptive terms based on chicken and shrimp flavors to evaluate the samples. All formulations were rated on an analog scale using unflavored samples as controls. Results showed that the presence of 4% flavoring enhanced the overall saltiness and meatiness. The size of the product sample appeared to significantly impact the “chicken” flavor in powder form as the narrow strip-shape was more intense in the oily flavor compared to the wide strip sample. This was attributed to the formation of air pockets in the former, responsible for encapsulating flavor molecules during frying. Following descriptive analysis, researchers conducted a consumer preference test with 125 volunteers for evaluating the “chicken” flavored product. Consumer results revealed that the chicken-flavored sample was most accepted when fried rather than baked. However, chemical analysis showed that the fried samples had more than 3 times higher fat content than the baked samples, suggesting that the higher fat content may increase liking. Moreover, this cooking method can negatively impact the nutritional quality of the product. In this study, researchers first used a descriptive sensory analysis to determine the best product formulation based on variables, such as type and concentration of the flavoring agent as well as shape and cooking method of the sample. Then, a consumer preference test was performed to evaluate the product based on a single variable. Performing a consumer test following descriptive analysis is a common strategy to efficiently assess consumer acceptance by combining both quantitative and qualitative data on the sensory profile of meat analogs in order to collect more specific information that can be used to apply changes in the recipe or processing method. The formation of unappealing odors and flavors during processing of plant proteins represents a barrier to acceptance of meat analogs. Addition of spices, seasonings, and flavor enhancers is an appropriate strategy to mask the beany and grassy aroma, specifically in pulses. The nature of the added ingredient may need to comply with vegetarian and/or vegan consumers’ dietary restrictions. Meat by-products such as beef bone hydrolysate can provide a “meaty” flavor to meat analogs in order to increase acceptance among non-vegetarian consumers. Yet, vegetable-based mixtures have been successful in recreating the flavor of poultry or seafood products. Use of spices, such as red pepper flakes, can increase spiciness to overcome off-flavors, while nutritional yeast can be used as an enhancer to provide a “meaty” umami taste. Sensory evaluation methods aimed at identifying acceptable flavoring ingredients can be influenced by the selection of the control product. Comparing two different kinds of plant proteins as opposed to using a full-meat control can impact conclusions drawn regarding product liking. Further research should focus on evaluating the taste and flavor of meat analogs in a meal context, as additional foods in the dish can alter the perception of oral sensation of meat analogs.
What the sources say
- Supportedcites [37] Grasso, 2019, Effect of texturised soy protein and yeast on the instrumental and sensory quality of hybrid beef meatballs, J. Food Sci. Technol. source
The Meatball preparation section identifies the control as the treatment with no soy substitution. Table 4 in Sensory evaluation records “bland” for the control 28 times, more than for any of the four other recipes. The table does not indicate a significant difference between the control and TSP15, but the claim is about frequency, not statistical significance. (LLM, conf=0.94)
plainstates an associationn = 4- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Supported
Every source the paper cites for this claim was checked and supports it.
In the paper
“This suggests that the selection of control is important in understanding and interpreting consumer acceptance of hybrid products.”
§ Role of Sensory Evaluation in Consumer Acceptance of Plant-Based Meat Analogs and Meat Extenders: A Scoping Review > 3. Literature Review > 3.2. Taste, Flavor, Aroma A common disadvantage of using plant proteins in meat analogs is the generation of volatile compounds from the lipid oxidation of unsaturated fatty acids that contribute to the formation of unappealing odors and flavors [41]. To overcome this problem, food scientists develop recipes that include flavoring mixtures with seasonings, spices, and enhancers that can both replicate the typical flavor of smoked meat as well as mask the beany, grassy, or green aroma of pulses. To assess consumer acceptability of meat analogs in terms of taste, flavor, and aroma, the sample is presented in a way so that it resembles the equivalent meat product. In a study performed by Rehrah et al. [30], three formulations of peanut-based minced product were evaluated against a commercial soy-based minced product in a seasoned puff pastry application. The peanut-based meat analog was made by fortifying defatted peanut flour with peanut protein concentrate. The mixture was extruded, ground into a beef-like mince, and stuffed into a rolled puff pastry to provide a more realistic version of a commercial snack. All three formulations of textured peanut protein concentrate (PPC) were seasoned with beef flavor and soy sauce as a flavor enhancer. In addition, the first sample contained tomato powder, the second sample contained crushed red pepper, and the third sample had no modifications. A sensory panel of 60 participants rated the peanut-based sample along with the commercial soy-based control in terms of beefy flavor, off-flavor, and spiciness on a 9-point hedonic scale. Participants were also asked to determine spiciness on a just-right scale with three intensities (too little, just right, too much). Of the three formulations of peanut-based meat analog, the one containing crushed red peppers had the most acceptable meaty flavor, the least dislike of off-flavor, and the most adequate spiciness level. These results suggest that the addition of flavors, enhancers, and spices can positively affect consumer acceptance of taste of a meat analog. However, while PPC performed better than soy-based formulations in a puff pastry application, the study did not include comparisons against a traditional meat formulation, suggesting that the choice of the control is a significant variable to be considered. On one hand, if the reference and test samples consist of different plant proteins, hedonic responses may be affected by the additional spices, with the most seasoned formulation resulting in higher acceptance scores. Alternatively, using a full-meat sample as a control would help to best determine how a meat analog compares to the desirable sensory properties of a traditional animal product. Comparing plant-based meat analogs to their meat equivalent can be adopted as a strategy during evaluation of extended meat products. Wong and colleagues [31] developed three formulations of hybrid beef patties by substituting 10%, 20%, and 30% ground beef with hydrated textured soy protein (TSP). A first hedonic test with 55 consumers showed no significant difference in overall liking scores for all formulations compared to the all-beef control. In a second hedonic test, 56 consumers evaluated the sensory properties of a hybrid beef patty with 20% TSP substitution and all-beef patty both with reduced sodium level. Liking scores for flavor were slightly lower in both the 20% TSP patty and the all-beef patty with reduced sodium compared to the all-beef control with regular sodium level. This suggests that substitution of beef with plant protein up to 30% can lead to acceptable liking scores as long as the sodium content remains unchanged. These findings reveal that maintaining a high sodium level in meat analogs is important for consumer acceptance in terms of flavor, although this may lower the nutritional quality of the final product. In another study, Grasso et al. [37] developed four types of hybrid meatballs by substituting 15% and 30% of beef with TSP in duplicates, with or without nutritional yeast, which was used as a flavor enhancer for its strong umami flavor. Sixty participants evaluated the four samples and an all-beef control by assessing degree of liking on a 9-point scale in terms of flavor, texture, and overall acceptance. In addition, participant used the check-all-that-apply (CATA) method by selecting the most appropriate terms to describe the samples. This method provides a complete description of the sensory characteristics of the samples. A list of 24 terms was chosen from the available literature on meat products. The CATA terms related to flavor were “tasty’’, ‘‘bland’’, ‘‘cheesy’’, ‘‘weak meaty’’, ‘‘strong meaty’’, ‘‘wheat-cereal like’’, ‘‘unusual’’, and ‘‘characteristic’’. Results from the hedonic test showed that addition of 15% TSP and nutritional yeast resulted in the highest liking scores for flavor and overall acceptance. Results from CATA analysis revealed that this sample was most associated with the term “tasty” and less associated with “bland”, while the 30% TSP without yeast was most associated with “wheat-cereal like”, suggesting that the absence of flavor enhancers in a sample with a high percentage of soy content may lead to the detection of strong off-flavors. Interestingly, the all-beef control was most frequently associated with the term “bland”. This suggests that the selection of control is important in understanding and interpreting consumer acceptance of hybrid products. It is important to select a control that is liked by consumers and is a good representation of the target product, as a low-quality control product could lead to misinterpreting results. Partial replacement of animal protein with plant protein provides the opportunity to improve the sustainability of meat products while also improving the nutritional profile of processed meat. However, addition of plant proteins might affect the overall product quality. The addition of up to 15% vegetable protein is appropriate to improve healthfulness of meat products without reducing the quality of sensory attributes. When the objective of the study is to test how different concentrations of a flavoring agent affect the sensory attributes of the final product, the sample without the added ingredient is used as a control, as opposed to using a full-meat product or a commercial meat substitute. Chiang et al. [32] added Maillard-reacted beef bone hydrolysate (MRP) at four concentrations to a meat analog made with soy protein concentrate and wheat gluten to improve its sensory attributes. Beef-bone extract, a by-product of meat processing, can be used as a flavor-enhancing agent by undergoing enzymatic hydrolysis to increase the proportion of free amino acids, followed by Maillard reaction through addition of reducing sugars to produce heterocyclic compounds. These molecules contribute to the typical flavor and aroma of smoked meat when this is cooked on the grill. Sensory evaluation by a group of 55 consumers revealed that 20% MRP was the optimal level for acceptance, resulting in the highest sensory scores for meaty aroma and meaty taste. By contrast, addition of 40% MRP received the lowest scores in all attributes due to bitter taste and a burnt appearance, while 0% MRP (the control) resulted in a weaker meaty taste and an undesirable pale brown color. The addition of MRP, under a certain concentration, helps to increase desirable “meat” flavors and increases acceptance compared to unflavored meat analog. It is not known if the addition of MRP would compare to a full-meat control. However, this product includes meat extracts, making it inappropriate for vegans and vegetarians; yet, it demonstrates the use of hydrolyzed protein materials can enhance desirable flavor attributes, which is important in increasing overall acceptance of meat analogs. Katayama and Wilson [25] used a similar approach in their study. The aim was to determine the most acceptable concentration of vegetable-based “chicken” and “shrimp” flavors added to textured soy meat analogs prepared in four different shapes (narrow strip, wide strip, shred, and bit) and with two cooking methods (fried and baked). The use of vegetable-based flavors provides an acceptable alternative to meat-by products like beef-bone extract, which may represent a barrier for vegan consumers. In the study, “chicken” flavor was added in either powder or liquid form at 3% and 4% to all four shapes of extrudates, which were fried, while two types of “shrimp” flavor, one oyster-like, the other a combination of oyster and crab-like, were added to shred-shaped extrudates, which were baked. A trained sensory panel of 14 participants generated a list of descriptive terms based on chicken and shrimp flavors to evaluate the samples. All formulations were rated on an analog scale using unflavored samples as controls. Results showed that the presence of 4% flavoring enhanced the overall saltiness and meatiness. The size of the product sample appeared to significantly impact the “chicken” flavor in powder form as the narrow strip-shape was more intense in the oily flavor compared to the wide strip sample. This was attributed to the formation of air pockets in the former, responsible for encapsulating flavor molecules during frying. Following descriptive analysis, researchers conducted a consumer preference test with 125 volunteers for evaluating the “chicken” flavored product. Consumer results revealed that the chicken-flavored sample was most accepted when fried rather than baked. However, chemical analysis showed that the fried samples had more than 3 times higher fat content than the baked samples, suggesting that the higher fat content may increase liking. Moreover, this cooking method can negatively impact the nutritional quality of the product. In this study, researchers first used a descriptive sensory analysis to determine the best product formulation based on variables, such as type and concentration of the flavoring agent as well as shape and cooking method of the sample. Then, a consumer preference test was performed to evaluate the product based on a single variable. Performing a consumer test following descriptive analysis is a common strategy to efficiently assess consumer acceptance by combining both quantitative and qualitative data on the sensory profile of meat analogs in order to collect more specific information that can be used to apply changes in the recipe or processing method. The formation of unappealing odors and flavors during processing of plant proteins represents a barrier to acceptance of meat analogs. Addition of spices, seasonings, and flavor enhancers is an appropriate strategy to mask the beany and grassy aroma, specifically in pulses. The nature of the added ingredient may need to comply with vegetarian and/or vegan consumers’ dietary restrictions. Meat by-products such as beef bone hydrolysate can provide a “meaty” flavor to meat analogs in order to increase acceptance among non-vegetarian consumers. Yet, vegetable-based mixtures have been successful in recreating the flavor of poultry or seafood products. Use of spices, such as red pepper flakes, can increase spiciness to overcome off-flavors, while nutritional yeast can be used as an enhancer to provide a “meaty” umami taste. Sensory evaluation methods aimed at identifying acceptable flavoring ingredients can be influenced by the selection of the control product. Comparing two different kinds of plant proteins as opposed to using a full-meat control can impact conclusions drawn regarding product liking. Further research should focus on evaluating the taste and flavor of meat analogs in a meal context, as additional foods in the dish can alter the perception of oral sensation of meat analogs.
What the sources say
- Supportedcites [37] Grasso, 2019, Effect of texturised soy protein and yeast on the instrumental and sensory quality of hybrid beef meatballs, J. Food Sci. Technol. source
In Results and discussion > Sensory evaluation (page unavailable), the control meatballs scored significantly lower on texture acceptability than every hybrid recipe, and one hybrid scored higher on overall acceptability. The paper also contrasts its findings with studies reporting lower acceptability for hybrids than for controls. Those comparisons support the hedged inference that the choice of control matters when interpreting acceptance results. (LLM, conf=0.85)
hedgedstates an associationn = 4- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Supported
Every source the paper cites for this claim was checked and supports it.
In the paper
“A first hedonic test with 55 consumers showed no significant difference in overall liking scores for all formulations compared to the all-beef control.”
§ Role of Sensory Evaluation in Consumer Acceptance of Plant-Based Meat Analogs and Meat Extenders: A Scoping Review > 3. Literature Review > 3.2. Taste, Flavor, Aroma A common disadvantage of using plant proteins in meat analogs is the generation of volatile compounds from the lipid oxidation of unsaturated fatty acids that contribute to the formation of unappealing odors and flavors [41]. To overcome this problem, food scientists develop recipes that include flavoring mixtures with seasonings, spices, and enhancers that can both replicate the typical flavor of smoked meat as well as mask the beany, grassy, or green aroma of pulses. To assess consumer acceptability of meat analogs in terms of taste, flavor, and aroma, the sample is presented in a way so that it resembles the equivalent meat product. In a study performed by Rehrah et al. [30], three formulations of peanut-based minced product were evaluated against a commercial soy-based minced product in a seasoned puff pastry application. The peanut-based meat analog was made by fortifying defatted peanut flour with peanut protein concentrate. The mixture was extruded, ground into a beef-like mince, and stuffed into a rolled puff pastry to provide a more realistic version of a commercial snack. All three formulations of textured peanut protein concentrate (PPC) were seasoned with beef flavor and soy sauce as a flavor enhancer. In addition, the first sample contained tomato powder, the second sample contained crushed red pepper, and the third sample had no modifications. A sensory panel of 60 participants rated the peanut-based sample along with the commercial soy-based control in terms of beefy flavor, off-flavor, and spiciness on a 9-point hedonic scale. Participants were also asked to determine spiciness on a just-right scale with three intensities (too little, just right, too much). Of the three formulations of peanut-based meat analog, the one containing crushed red peppers had the most acceptable meaty flavor, the least dislike of off-flavor, and the most adequate spiciness level. These results suggest that the addition of flavors, enhancers, and spices can positively affect consumer acceptance of taste of a meat analog. However, while PPC performed better than soy-based formulations in a puff pastry application, the study did not include comparisons against a traditional meat formulation, suggesting that the choice of the control is a significant variable to be considered. On one hand, if the reference and test samples consist of different plant proteins, hedonic responses may be affected by the additional spices, with the most seasoned formulation resulting in higher acceptance scores. Alternatively, using a full-meat sample as a control would help to best determine how a meat analog compares to the desirable sensory properties of a traditional animal product. Comparing plant-based meat analogs to their meat equivalent can be adopted as a strategy during evaluation of extended meat products. Wong and colleagues [31] developed three formulations of hybrid beef patties by substituting 10%, 20%, and 30% ground beef with hydrated textured soy protein (TSP). A first hedonic test with 55 consumers showed no significant difference in overall liking scores for all formulations compared to the all-beef control. In a second hedonic test, 56 consumers evaluated the sensory properties of a hybrid beef patty with 20% TSP substitution and all-beef patty both with reduced sodium level. Liking scores for flavor were slightly lower in both the 20% TSP patty and the all-beef patty with reduced sodium compared to the all-beef control with regular sodium level. This suggests that substitution of beef with plant protein up to 30% can lead to acceptable liking scores as long as the sodium content remains unchanged. These findings reveal that maintaining a high sodium level in meat analogs is important for consumer acceptance in terms of flavor, although this may lower the nutritional quality of the final product. In another study, Grasso et al. [37] developed four types of hybrid meatballs by substituting 15% and 30% of beef with TSP in duplicates, with or without nutritional yeast, which was used as a flavor enhancer for its strong umami flavor. Sixty participants evaluated the four samples and an all-beef control by assessing degree of liking on a 9-point scale in terms of flavor, texture, and overall acceptance. In addition, participant used the check-all-that-apply (CATA) method by selecting the most appropriate terms to describe the samples. This method provides a complete description of the sensory characteristics of the samples. A list of 24 terms was chosen from the available literature on meat products. The CATA terms related to flavor were “tasty’’, ‘‘bland’’, ‘‘cheesy’’, ‘‘weak meaty’’, ‘‘strong meaty’’, ‘‘wheat-cereal like’’, ‘‘unusual’’, and ‘‘characteristic’’. Results from the hedonic test showed that addition of 15% TSP and nutritional yeast resulted in the highest liking scores for flavor and overall acceptance. Results from CATA analysis revealed that this sample was most associated with the term “tasty” and less associated with “bland”, while the 30% TSP without yeast was most associated with “wheat-cereal like”, suggesting that the absence of flavor enhancers in a sample with a high percentage of soy content may lead to the detection of strong off-flavors. Interestingly, the all-beef control was most frequently associated with the term “bland”. This suggests that the selection of control is important in understanding and interpreting consumer acceptance of hybrid products. It is important to select a control that is liked by consumers and is a good representation of the target product, as a low-quality control product could lead to misinterpreting results. Partial replacement of animal protein with plant protein provides the opportunity to improve the sustainability of meat products while also improving the nutritional profile of processed meat. However, addition of plant proteins might affect the overall product quality. The addition of up to 15% vegetable protein is appropriate to improve healthfulness of meat products without reducing the quality of sensory attributes. When the objective of the study is to test how different concentrations of a flavoring agent affect the sensory attributes of the final product, the sample without the added ingredient is used as a control, as opposed to using a full-meat product or a commercial meat substitute. Chiang et al. [32] added Maillard-reacted beef bone hydrolysate (MRP) at four concentrations to a meat analog made with soy protein concentrate and wheat gluten to improve its sensory attributes. Beef-bone extract, a by-product of meat processing, can be used as a flavor-enhancing agent by undergoing enzymatic hydrolysis to increase the proportion of free amino acids, followed by Maillard reaction through addition of reducing sugars to produce heterocyclic compounds. These molecules contribute to the typical flavor and aroma of smoked meat when this is cooked on the grill. Sensory evaluation by a group of 55 consumers revealed that 20% MRP was the optimal level for acceptance, resulting in the highest sensory scores for meaty aroma and meaty taste. By contrast, addition of 40% MRP received the lowest scores in all attributes due to bitter taste and a burnt appearance, while 0% MRP (the control) resulted in a weaker meaty taste and an undesirable pale brown color. The addition of MRP, under a certain concentration, helps to increase desirable “meat” flavors and increases acceptance compared to unflavored meat analog. It is not known if the addition of MRP would compare to a full-meat control. However, this product includes meat extracts, making it inappropriate for vegans and vegetarians; yet, it demonstrates the use of hydrolyzed protein materials can enhance desirable flavor attributes, which is important in increasing overall acceptance of meat analogs. Katayama and Wilson [25] used a similar approach in their study. The aim was to determine the most acceptable concentration of vegetable-based “chicken” and “shrimp” flavors added to textured soy meat analogs prepared in four different shapes (narrow strip, wide strip, shred, and bit) and with two cooking methods (fried and baked). The use of vegetable-based flavors provides an acceptable alternative to meat-by products like beef-bone extract, which may represent a barrier for vegan consumers. In the study, “chicken” flavor was added in either powder or liquid form at 3% and 4% to all four shapes of extrudates, which were fried, while two types of “shrimp” flavor, one oyster-like, the other a combination of oyster and crab-like, were added to shred-shaped extrudates, which were baked. A trained sensory panel of 14 participants generated a list of descriptive terms based on chicken and shrimp flavors to evaluate the samples. All formulations were rated on an analog scale using unflavored samples as controls. Results showed that the presence of 4% flavoring enhanced the overall saltiness and meatiness. The size of the product sample appeared to significantly impact the “chicken” flavor in powder form as the narrow strip-shape was more intense in the oily flavor compared to the wide strip sample. This was attributed to the formation of air pockets in the former, responsible for encapsulating flavor molecules during frying. Following descriptive analysis, researchers conducted a consumer preference test with 125 volunteers for evaluating the “chicken” flavored product. Consumer results revealed that the chicken-flavored sample was most accepted when fried rather than baked. However, chemical analysis showed that the fried samples had more than 3 times higher fat content than the baked samples, suggesting that the higher fat content may increase liking. Moreover, this cooking method can negatively impact the nutritional quality of the product. In this study, researchers first used a descriptive sensory analysis to determine the best product formulation based on variables, such as type and concentration of the flavoring agent as well as shape and cooking method of the sample. Then, a consumer preference test was performed to evaluate the product based on a single variable. Performing a consumer test following descriptive analysis is a common strategy to efficiently assess consumer acceptance by combining both quantitative and qualitative data on the sensory profile of meat analogs in order to collect more specific information that can be used to apply changes in the recipe or processing method. The formation of unappealing odors and flavors during processing of plant proteins represents a barrier to acceptance of meat analogs. Addition of spices, seasonings, and flavor enhancers is an appropriate strategy to mask the beany and grassy aroma, specifically in pulses. The nature of the added ingredient may need to comply with vegetarian and/or vegan consumers’ dietary restrictions. Meat by-products such as beef bone hydrolysate can provide a “meaty” flavor to meat analogs in order to increase acceptance among non-vegetarian consumers. Yet, vegetable-based mixtures have been successful in recreating the flavor of poultry or seafood products. Use of spices, such as red pepper flakes, can increase spiciness to overcome off-flavors, while nutritional yeast can be used as an enhancer to provide a “meaty” umami taste. Sensory evaluation methods aimed at identifying acceptable flavoring ingredients can be influenced by the selection of the control product. Comparing two different kinds of plant proteins as opposed to using a full-meat control can impact conclusions drawn regarding product liking. Further research should focus on evaluating the taste and flavor of meat analogs in a meal context, as additional foods in the dish can alter the perception of oral sensation of meat analogs.
What the sources say
- Supportedcites [31] Wong, 2019, Sodium reduction strategies through use of meat extenders (white button mushrooms vs. textured soy) in beef patties, Food Sci. Nutr. source
In Results and Discussion, the Hedonic Test #1 section reports that 55 consumers rated the variant formulations’ overall liking statistically similarly to the all-meat control. The same section states that up to 30% textured soy protein showed no statistical difference from the all-beef control. (LLM, conf=0.94)
plain- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Supported
68 more claims · 4 with their cited sources checked
Create a free account to see all 142 claims and to verify the 19 references still open.
- It may state two separate claims as one. 37
- Probably not a substantial claim. 43
Citations
Cites
Sensory Evaluation of Food: Principles and Practices
Lawless, H. T., & Heymann, H. (2010) · Food Science Text Series · doi:10.1007/978-1-4419-6488-5 · Cited by 4,815
Deaths: Leading Causes for 2017.
Heron, M. P. (2019) · PubMed · Cited by 2,108
World Population Prospects 2019: Highlights
Nations, U. (2019) · Statistical Papers - United Nations (Ser. A), Population and Vital Statistics Report · doi:10.18356/13bf5476-en · Cited by 1,854
Piqueras-Fiszman, B., & Spence, C. (2015) · Food Quality and Preference · doi:10.1016/j.foodqual.2014.09.013 · Cited by 855 · cited 1×
“More specifically, the unfamiliarity with novel foods can alter expectations that may negatively impact sensory perception and overall liking [17].”
BackgroundHoek, A. C., Luning, P. A., Weijzen, P., Engels, W., Kok, F. J., & de Graaf, C. (2011) · Appetite · doi:10.1016/j.appet.2011.02.001 · Cited by 757 · cited 2×
“However, such products are not as popular among meat-eaters and flexitarians due to their low sensory appeal [11].”
BackgroundStructuring processes for meat analogues
Dekkers, B. L., Boom, R. M., & van der Goot, A. J. (2018) · Trends in Food Science & Technology · doi:10.1016/j.tifs.2018.08.011 · Cited by 751 · cited 1×
“While there are many different processing methods to prepare meat analogs, one top-down strategy is high-moisture wet extrusion, which is highly successful in achieving a desirable structure, most resembling animal proteins [13].”
MethodSchösler, H., Boer, J. D., & Boersema, J. J. (2012) · Appetite · doi:10.1016/j.appet.2011.09.009 · Cited by 590 · cited 1×
“Replacing meat with sustainable alternative proteins is one promising strategy to reduce meat consumption [7].”
BackgroundThe impact of perceptual interactions on perceived flavor
Delwiche, J. (2004) · Food Quality and Preference · doi:10.1016/s0950-3293(03)00041-7 · Cited by 563 · cited 1×
“A disconfirmation of expectations occurs when the perceived liking after consumption is below the expected liking, which may occur when the visual cues misrepresent the taste, odor, and flavor of the product [39].”
BackgroundBiodiversity conservation: The key is reducing meat consumption
Machovina, B., Feeley, K. J., & Ripple, W. J. (2015) · Science of The Total Environment · doi:10.1016/j.scitotenv.2015.07.022 · Cited by 527 · cited 1×
“This presents an alarming threat to our planet, as meat production is an intensive and unsustainable process, causing environmental problems such as deforestation, pollution, damage to hydrogeological reserves, and loss of biodiversity [3].”
BackgroundFunctional and edible uses of soy protein products
Singh, P., Kumar, R., Sabapathy, S. N., & Bawa, A. S. (2008) · Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety · doi:10.1111/j.1541-4337.2007.00025.x · Cited by 506 · cited 1×
“This is a common practice adopted by the food industry to improve the economical, functional, sustainability, and nutritional profile of processed meats [14].”
Background
Research works printed but not linked: 2
- Wild, 2014, The evolution of a plant-based alternative to meat, Agro Food Ind. Hi-Tech, 25, 45
- Hassan, 2018, Physicochemical properties and consumer preference of imitation chicken nuggets produced from chickpea flour and textured vegetable protein, Int. Food Res. J., 25, 1016
Cited by
Functionality of Ingredients and Additives in Plant-Based Meat Analogues
Kyriakopoulou, K., Keppler, J. K., & van der Goot, A. J. (2021) · Foods · doi:10.3390/foods10030600 · Cited by 630
“Even though the added ingredient does not comply with a vegetarian and/or vegan diet, the produced flavour can increase the acceptance of meat analogues among consumers that enjoy eating conventional meat [257].”
BackgroundFunctional Performance of Plant Proteins
Ma, K. K., Greis, M., Lu, J., Nolden, A. A., McClements, D. J., & Kinchla, A. J. (2022) · Foods · doi:10.3390/foods11040594 · Cited by 420
Self-citationAndreani, G., Sogari, G., Marti, A., Froldi, F., Dagevos, H., & Martini, D. (2023) · Nutrients · doi:10.3390/nu15020452 · Cited by 296
“For instance, the color of plant-based products may diminish due to light or oxygen exposure, or the taste could be affected by lipid oxidation and cause undesirable characteristics [52].”
BackgroundFlavor challenges in extruded plant‐based meat alternatives: A review
Wang, Y., Tuccillo, F., Lampi, A., Knaapila, A., Pulkkinen, M., Kariluoto, S., Coda, R., Edelmann, M., Jouppila, K., Sandell, M., et al. (2022) · Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety · doi:10.1111/1541-4337.12964 · Cited by 281
Giacalone, D., Clausen, M. P., & Jaeger, S. R. (2022) · Current Opinion in Food Science · doi:10.1016/j.cofs.2022.100919 · Cited by 256
Metadata
- Authors
- Fiorentini, M., Kinchla, A. J., & Nolden, A. A.
- Affiliations
- University of Massachusetts Amherst (US)
- Corresponding author
- Nolden, Alissa A.
- Venue
- Foods
- Publisher
- MDPI AG
- Published
- 2020-09-22
- Volume
- 9
- Issue
- 9
- Pages
- 1334
- ISSN
- 2304-8158 (ISSN-L)
- PMC
- PMC7555205
- OpenAlex
- W3087456866
- Cited by
- 398
- References
- 36
- Citations by year
- 2026: 68 · 2025: 69 · 2024: 103 · 2023: 81 · 2022: 60 · 2021: 16 · 2020: 1
- FWCI
- 3.34
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- gold
- doi.org
- Licence
- Locations
- Foods (publishedVersion, cc-by)
- PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
- PubMed (publishedVersion)
- ScholarWorks@UMassAmherst (University of Massachusetts Amherst) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
- DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) (submittedVersion, cc-by-sa)
- Topics
- Life Sciences › Agricultural and Biological Sciences › Food Science › Sensory Analysis and Statistical Methods
- Life Sciences › Agricultural and Biological Sciences › Animal Science and Zoology › Meat and Animal Product Quality
- Physical Sciences › Environmental Science › Ecology › Agriculture Sustainability and Environmental Impact
- Keywords
- plant-based meat analogs, meat extender, sensory evaluation, consumer acceptance, hedonic test, descriptive analysis, sensory properties, meat color, sustainable food, product development, flexitarians
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
The claim verdicts this report counts are experimental: their accuracy is not yet measured.
A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-10-10, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).
A second model labelled each claim on 2026-10-10 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).
Cited sources are checked with a language model’s help (gpt-6-sol).
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
How to cite
Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.
- This page
- CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Role of Sensory Evaluation in Consumer Acceptance of Plant-Based Meat Analogs and Meat Extenders: A Scoping Review. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.3390/foods9091334
- The paper
- Fiorentini, M., Kinchla, A. J., & Nolden, A. A. (2020). Role of Sensory Evaluation in Consumer Acceptance of Plant-Based Meat Analogs and Meat Extenders: A Scoping Review. Foods. https://doi.org/10.3390/foods9091334
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.