Student or educator? Sign up with your school email and get 6 months of Pro free.
CoChat

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 84 of the 94 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; 24 of the 74 sources its claims cite were checked for support.

First Sagittarius A* Event Horizon Telescope Results. IV. Variability, Morphology, and Black Hole Mass

Open access
Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration, Akiyama, Kazunori, Alberdi, Antxon, Alef, Walter, Algaba, Juan Carlos, Anantua, Richard, Asada, Keiichi, Azulay, Rebecca, Bach, Uwe, Baczko, Anne-Kathrin, Ball, David, Baloković, Mislav, Barrett, John, Bauböck, Michi, Benson, Bradford A., Bintley, Dan, Blackburn, Lindy, Blundell, Raymond, Bouman, Katherine L., Bower, Geoffrey C., Boyce, Hope, Bremer, Michael, Brinkerink, Christiaan D., Brissenden, Roger, Britzen, Silke, Broderick, Avery E., Broguiere, Dominique, Bronzwaer, Thomas, Bustamante, Sandra, Byun, Do-Young, Carlstrom, John E., Ceccobello, Chiara, Chael, Andrew, Chan, Chi-kwan, Chatterjee, Koushik, Chatterjee, Shami, Chen, Ming-Tang, Chen 陈, Yongjun 永军, Cheng, Xiaopeng, Cho, Ilje, Christian, Pierre, Conroy, Nicholas S., Conway, John E., Cordes, James M., Crawford, Thomas M., Crew, Geoffrey B., Cruz-Osorio, Alejandro, Cui 崔, Yuzhu 玉竹, Davelaar, Jordy, Laurentis, Mariafelicia De, Deane, Roger, Dempsey, Jessica, Desvignes, Gregory, Dexter, Jason, Dhruv, Vedant, Doeleman, Sheperd S., Dougal, Sean, Dzib, Sergio A., Eatough, Ralph P., Emami, Razieh, Falcke, Heino, Farah, Joseph, Fish, Vincent L., Fomalont, Ed, Ford, H. Alyson, Fraga-Encinas, Raquel, Freeman, William T., Friberg, Per, Fromm, Christian M., Fuentes, Antonio, Galison, Peter, Gammie, Charles F., García, Roberto, Gentaz, Olivier, Georgiev, Boris, Goddi, Ciriaco, Gold, Roman, Gómez-Ruiz, Arturo I., Gómez, José L., Gu 顾, Minfeng 敏峰, Gurwell, Mark, Hada, Kazuhiro, Haggard, Daryl, Haworth, Kari, Hecht, Michael H., Hesper, Ronald, Heumann, Dirk, Ho 何, Luis C. 子山, Ho, Paul, Honma, Mareki, Huang, Chih-Wei L., Huang 黄, Lei 磊, Hughes, David H., Ikeda, Shiro, Impellizzeri, C. M. Violette, Inoue, Makoto, Issaoun, Sara, James, David J., Jannuzi, Buell T., Janssen, Michael, Jeter, Britton, Jiang 江, Wu 悟, Jiménez-Rosales, Alejandra, Johnson, Michael D., Jorstad, Svetlana, Joshi, Abhishek V., Jung, Taehyun, Karami, Mansour, Karuppusamy, Ramesh, Kawashima, Tomohisa, Keating, Garrett K., Kettenis, Mark, Kim, Dong-Jin, Kim, Jae-Young, Kim, Jongsoo, Kim, Junhan, Kino, Motoki, Koay, Jun Yi, Kocherlakota, Prashant, Kofuji, Yutaro, Koch, Patrick M., Koyama, Shoko, Kramer, Carsten, Kramer, Michael, Krichbaum, Thomas P., Kuo, Cheng-Yu, Bella, Noemi La, Lauer, Tod R., Lee, Daeyoung, Lee, Sang-Sung, Leung, Po Kin, Levis, Aviad, Li 李, Zhiyuan 志远, Lico, Rocco, Lindahl, Greg, Lindqvist, Michael, Lisakov, Mikhail, Liu 刘, Jun 俊, Liu, Kuo, Liuzzo, Elisabetta, Lo, Wen-Ping, Lobanov, Andrei P., Loinard, Laurent, Lonsdale, Colin J., Lu 路, Ru-Sen 如森, Mao 毛, Jirong 基荣, Marchili, Nicola, Markoff, Sera, Marrone, Daniel P., Marscher, Alan P., Martí-Vidal, Iván, Matsushita, Satoki, Matthews, Lynn D., Medeiros, Lia, Menten, Karl M., Michalik, Daniel, Mizuno, Izumi, Mizuno, Yosuke, Moran, James M., Moriyama, Kotaro, Moscibrodzka, Monika, Müller, Cornelia, Mus, Alejandro, Musoke, Gibwa, Myserlis, Ioannis, Nadolski, Andrew, Nagai, Hiroshi, Nagar, Neil M., Nakamura, Masanori, Narayan, Ramesh, Narayanan, Gopal, Natarajan, Iniyan, Nathanail, Antonios, Fuentes, Santiago Navarro, Neilsen, Joey, Neri, Roberto, Ni, Chunchong, Noutsos, Aristeidis, Nowak, Michael A., Oh, Junghwan, Okino, Hiroki, Olivares, Héctor, Ortiz-León, Gisela N., Oyama, Tomoaki, Palumbo, Daniel C. M., Paraschos, Georgios Filippos, Park, Jongho, Parsons, Harriet, Patel, Nimesh, Pen, Ue-Li, Pesce, Dominic W., Piétu, Vincent, Plambeck, Richard, PopStefanija, Aleksandar, Porth, Oliver, Pötzl, Felix M., Prather, Cora, Preciado-López, Jorge A., Pu, Hung-Yi, Ramakrishnan, Venkatessh, Rao, Ramprasad, Rawlings, Mark G., Raymond, Alexander W., Rezzolla, Luciano, Ricarte, Angelo, Ripperda, Bart, Roelofs, Freek, Rogers, Alan, Ros, Eduardo, Romero-Cañizales, Cristina, Roshanineshat, Arash, Rottmann, Helge, Roy, Alan L., Ruiz, Ignacio, Ruszczyk, Chet, Rygl, Kazi L. J., Sánchez, Salvador, Sánchez-Argüelles, David, Sánchez-Portal, Miguel, Sasada, Mahito, Satapathy, Kaushik, Savolainen, Tuomas, Schloerb, F. Peter, Schonfeld, Jonathan, Schuster, Karl-Friedrich, Shao, Lijing, Shen 沈, Zhiqiang 志强, Small, Des, Sohn, Bong Won, SooHoo, Jason, Souccar, Kamal, Sun 孙, He 赫, Tazaki, Fumie, Tetarenko, Alexandra J., Tiede, Paul, Tilanus, Remo P. J., Titus, Michael, Torne, Pablo, Traianou, Efthalia, Trent, Tyler, Trippe, Sascha, Turk, Matthew, van Bemmel, Ilse, van Langevelde, Huib Jan, van Rossum, Daniel R., Vos, Jesse, Wagner, Jan, Ward-Thompson, Derek, Wardle, John, Weintroub, Jonathan, Wex, Norbert, Wharton, Robert, Wielgus, Maciek, Wiik, Kaj, Witzel, Gunther, Wondrak, Michael F., Wong, George N., Wu 吴, Qingwen 庆文, Yamaguchi, Paul, Yoon, Doosoo, Young, André, Young, Ken, Younsi, Ziri, Yuan 袁, Feng 峰, Yuan 袁, Ye-Fei 业飞, Zensus, J. Anton, Zhang, Shuo, Zhao, Guang-Yao, Zhao 赵, Shan-Shan 杉杉, Chang, Dominic O. · 2022 · The Astrophysical Journal Letters

Abstract

In this paper we quantify the temporal variability and image morphology of the horizon-scale emission from Sgr A*, as observed by the EHT in 2017 April at a wavelength of 1.3 mm. We find that the Sgr A* data exhibit variability that exceeds what can be explained by the uncertainties in the data or by the effects of interstellar scattering. The magnitude of this variability can be a substantial fraction of the correlated flux density, reaching ∼100% on some baselines. Through an exploration of simple geometric source models, we demonstrate that ring-like morphologies provide better fits to the Sgr A* data than do other morphologies with comparable complexity. We develop two strategies for fitting static geometric ring models to the time-variable Sgr A* data; one strategy fits models to short segments of data over which the source is static and averages these independent fits, while the other fits models to the full data set using a parametric model for the structural variability power spectrum around the average source structure. Both geometric modeling and image-domain feature extraction techniques determine the ring diameter to be 51.8 ± 2.3 μ as (68% credible intervals), with the ring thickness constrained to have an FWHM between ∼30% and 50% of the ring diameter. To bring the diameter measurements to a common physical scale, we calibrate them using synthetic data generated from GRMHD simulations. This calibration constrains the angular size of the gravitational radius to be 4.8 − 0.7 + 1.4 μ as, which we combine with an independent distance measurement from maser parallaxes to determine the mass of Sgr A* to be 4.0 − 0.6 + 1.1 × 10 6 M ⊙ .

Overview

CoChat Summary

TL;DR

The EHT’s 2017 1.3 mm observations of Sgr A* show strong intraday structural variability that complicates static imaging, but the data prefer ring-like morphology. Joint geometric modeling and image-domain feature extraction give a ring diameter of 51.8 ± 2.3 μas, which calibrates to θ_g = 4.8^{+0.7}_{-1.4} μas and a black hole mass of 4.0^{+0.6}_{-1.1} × 10^6 M_⊙.

Key findings

  • Sgr A* exhibits variability exceeding thermal noise, station gains, and refractive scattering; on some baselines the variability can reach ∼100% of the correlated flux density. On intermediate baselines (2.5–6 Gλ), excess noise falls from a peak rms of ∼5% of total flux density (∼120 mJy) near 2.5 Gλ to ∼1% (∼25 mJy) near 6 Gλ, with fitted amplitude at 4 Gλ of 1.90% ± 0.2% and long-baseline power-law index 2.4 ± 0.8.
  • Ring-like morphologies provide better fits than other morphologies of comparable complexity. The joint geometric modeling and IDFE constraint on ring diameter is 51.8 ± 2.3 μas (68% credible intervals).
  • Ring thickness is constrained to an FWHM between ∼30% and 50% of the ring diameter; geometric modeling gives 35% ± 5%, while IDFE gives 53% ± 10%.
  • Calibrating ring diameters with GRMHD synthetic data gives θ_g = 4.8^{+0.7}_{-1.4} μas; combined with the maser parallax distance D = 8.15 ± 0.15 kpc, this yields M = 4.0^{+0.6}_{-1.1} × 10^6 M_⊙.

Methods

  • The paper analyzes EHT 2017 April observations of Sgr A* at 1.3 mm, primarily the April 6 and April 7 data sets, across two frequency bands and two calibration pipelines; April 11 is excluded from most analyses because of strong variability.
  • Two static ring-modeling strategies are developed: “snapshot” geometric modeling fits an mG-ring model to 120 s data segments and combines them hierarchically, while “full-track” geometric modeling fits the entire data set with a parameterized broken-power-law variability noise model.
  • Ring morphology is also measured via image-domain feature extraction (REx and VIDA) on Paper III image reconstructions, and diameter measurements are calibrated to θ_g using 90 GRMHD synthetic data sets plus 10 validation sets.

Limitations

  • The paper states that Sgr A*’s rapid structural variability violates the static-source assumption; the full-track variability noise model assumes uncorrelated fluctuations, but subhour correlations are present and make the model misspecified, especially for single-day analyses.
  • The paper states that ring asymmetry, position angle, and central brightness depression are poorly constrained and method-dependent; ring thickness is also method-dependent, so no analysis-agnostic thickness is produced.
  • The paper states that the θ_g calibration assumes the GRMHD library reliably represents Sgr A* emission; the calibration suite contains diverse morphologies not resembling Sgr A*, producing heavy tails in α and larger θ_g uncertainty. Evident from the text: variability constraints are unavailable below 2.5 Gλ and not statistically significant above 6 Gλ, and the mass uncertainty remains dominated by θ_g.

Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.3847/2041-8213/ac6736

Cites

84 of 84 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Nothing to recompute.

Figures

Figure 1 The amount of excess variance in the visibility amplitudes expected for a GRMHD simulation ( red lines, s var 2 ) , after subtraction of the average image and normalization of the fl ux density by the light curve. Shown also are the typical thermal noise ( black dashed line ) and a 1% fractional systematic noise ( green band ) proportional to the mean image visibility amplitudes. The expected degree of refractive scattering is shown by the purple bands, with purple lines evaluated for a Gaussian source at the projected location of EHT data ( see Paper III ) . The variability is shown about a mean image constructed on different observationally relevant timescales. The fractional systematic and variability noises have been averaged over azimuth and over the position angle of the diffractive screen.
Figure 1 The amount of excess variance in the visibility amplitudes expected for a GRMHD simulation ( red lines, s var 2 ) , after subtraction of the average image and normalization of the fl ux density by the light curve. Shown also are the typical thermal noise ( black dashed line ) and a 1% fractional systematic noise ( green band ) proportional to the mean image visibility amplitudes. The expected degree of refractive scattering is shown by the purple bands, with purple lines evaluated for a Gaussian source at the projected location of EHT data ( see Paper III ) . The variability is shown about a mean image constructed on different observationally relevant timescales. The fractional systematic and variability noises have been averaged over azimuth and over the position angle of the diffractive screen.From the PDF
Figure 2 Location and detrended visibility amplitudes for crossing and following tracks from the Sgr A * observations on April 5, 6, 7, and 10. Left: the locations of all data points in the ( u , v ) -plane. Individual baselines correspond to the curving tracks seen in this plot, and we have highlighted the crossing and following tracks using colored points. For reference, circles of constant baseline length are shown by the dashed gray lines. The central time stamps for the highlighted tracks are labeled in the corresponding colors. Right: linearly detrended and light-curve-normalized visibility amplitudes for the crossing and following baselines highlighted in the left panel, shown in corresponding point colors. For crossing tracks ( bottom panels ) , the points within 1 G λ of the crossing point are shown. Error bars show the thermal errors. For following tracks ( top panels ) all points for which the baselines overlap are shown. All highlighted points are employed in the linear detrending for each panel. The associated estimates of the mean and standard deviation are shown by the gray dashed line and horizontal band in each panel. The April 7 visibility amplitudes are indicated by open circles.
Figure 2 Location and detrended visibility amplitudes for crossing and following tracks from the Sgr A * observations on April 5, 6, 7, and 10. Left: the locations of all data points in the ( u , v ) -plane. Individual baselines correspond to the curving tracks seen in this plot, and we have highlighted the crossing and following tracks using colored points. For reference, circles of constant baseline length are shown by the dashed gray lines. The central time stamps for the highlighted tracks are labeled in the corresponding colors. Right: linearly detrended and light-curve-normalized visibility amplitudes for the crossing and following baselines highlighted in the left panel, shown in corresponding point colors. For crossing tracks ( bottom panels ) , the points within 1 G λ of the crossing point are shown. Error bars show the thermal errors. For following tracks ( top panels ) all points for which the baselines overlap are shown. All highlighted points are employed in the linear detrending for each panel. The associated estimates of the mean and standard deviation are shown by the gray dashed line and horizontal band in each panel. The April 7 visibility amplitudes are indicated by open circles.From the PDF
Figure 3 Illustration of detrended visibility amplitudes and associated variance estimate. Top: scan-averaged tracks in ( u , v ) -coordinates with a circular region of diameter 1 G λ superposed ( red disk ) , centered at ( -2.1 G λ , 4.7 G λ ) . Scans within the region are dark red, while those outside are blue. Middle: lightcurve-normalized visibility amplitudes as a function of u , projected in v ( limited to points within the top panel ) . Bottom: light-curve-normalized visibility amplitudes after detrending with a linear model de fi ned by the scans within the 1 G λ circular region. The estimated mean and standard deviation are shown by the orange dashed line and horizontal band.
Figure 3 Illustration of detrended visibility amplitudes and associated variance estimate. Top: scan-averaged tracks in ( u , v ) -coordinates with a circular region of diameter 1 G λ superposed ( red disk ) , centered at ( -2.1 G λ , 4.7 G λ ) . Scans within the region are dark red, while those outside are blue. Middle: lightcurve-normalized visibility amplitudes as a function of u , projected in v ( limited to points within the top panel ) . Bottom: light-curve-normalized visibility amplitudes after detrending with a linear model de fi ned by the scans within the 1 G λ circular region. The estimated mean and standard deviation are shown by the orange dashed line and horizontal band.From the PDF
Figure 4 Model-agnostic estimate of the azimuthally averaged excess variance of the visibility amplitudes, after subtracting the variance from the reported statistical errors, as a function of baseline length. Nonparametric estimates ( fi lled and open black circles ) are obtained across April 5, 6, 7, and 10 and using both high- and low-band data. The fi lled black circles indicate signi fi cant detections of source variability, while the open black circles indicate variance measurements that are dominated by the other sources of uncertainty; only the former are used in the parametric fi tting. Uncertainties associated with the thermal errors, uncertain station gains, and polarization leakage are indicated by the error bars. Azimuthally averaged thermal errors are shown by the gray triangles and provide an approximate lower limit on the range of accurate variance estimates. For comparison, the magnitudes of the variance induced by refractive scattering are shown in purple along the minor ( top ) and major ( bottom ) axes of the diffractive scattering kernel ( see Section 4 of Paper III ) ; the variance along individual tracks on April 7, as well as a ∼ 10 mJy fl oor ( assuming a fi xed 2.5 Jy total fl ux ) , is shown by the solid and dashed purple lines, respectively. The orange band indicates the 95th-percentile range of fi ts to the fi lled variance estimates shown by fi lled points by the broken power law of the form in Equation ( 8 ) , with a handful of speci fi c examples shown explicitly.
Figure 4 Model-agnostic estimate of the azimuthally averaged excess variance of the visibility amplitudes, after subtracting the variance from the reported statistical errors, as a function of baseline length. Nonparametric estimates ( fi lled and open black circles ) are obtained across April 5, 6, 7, and 10 and using both high- and low-band data. The fi lled black circles indicate signi fi cant detections of source variability, while the open black circles indicate variance measurements that are dominated by the other sources of uncertainty; only the former are used in the parametric fi tting. Uncertainties associated with the thermal errors, uncertain station gains, and polarization leakage are indicated by the error bars. Azimuthally averaged thermal errors are shown by the gray triangles and provide an approximate lower limit on the range of accurate variance estimates. For comparison, the magnitudes of the variance induced by refractive scattering are shown in purple along the minor ( top ) and major ( bottom ) axes of the diffractive scattering kernel ( see Section 4 of Paper III ) ; the variance along individual tracks on April 7, as well as a ∼ 10 mJy fl oor ( assuming a fi xed 2.5 Jy total fl ux ) , is shown by the solid and dashed purple lines, respectively. The orange band indicates the 95th-percentile range of fi ts to the fi lled variance estimates shown by fi lled points by the broken power law of the form in Equation ( 8 ) , with a handful of speci fi c examples shown explicitly.From the PDF
Figure 5 Joint posteriors of the constrained parameters after fi tting a broken power law to the model-agnostic normalized variances estimates. Because the amplitude is well constrained within the range of baseline lengths for which good estimates of the variability exist, we set the normalization at | u | = 4 G λ , denoted as a 4. Contours show the enclosed 50th, 90th, and 99th percentiles. The purple bands indicate the ranges used as priors during the full-track modeling, associated with the interquartile ranges.
Figure 5 Joint posteriors of the constrained parameters after fi tting a broken power law to the model-agnostic normalized variances estimates. Because the amplitude is well constrained within the range of baseline lengths for which good estimates of the variability exist, we set the normalization at | u | = 4 G λ , denoted as a 4. Contours show the enclosed 50th, 90th, and 99th percentiles. The purple bands indicate the ranges used as priors during the full-track modeling, associated with the interquartile ranges.From the PDF
Figure 6 Comparison of the relative Bayesian evidence, D ln  , for a series of increasingly complex geometric models fi tted using closure amplitudes and closure phases within the snapshot modeling formalism described in detail in Section 6. The fi ts have been carried out using eht-imaging on the HOPS April 7 Sgr A * data, and each point in the fi gure is colored according to the number of free parameters in the model; the number of free parameters in each model is also indicated in the horizontal axis labels. The panel on the right shows a zoom-in to the highest-evidence region of the left panel. Ring-like models are indicated with circles, and nonring models are indicated with crosses. All Bayesian evidence values are quoted relative to the highest value attained across all models. The parameter counts re fl ect the fact that all models are normalized to have unit total fl ux density and are centered at the image origin. The crescent model consists of a smaller disk subtracted from an offset larger disk. In the crescent +fl oor model, the smaller disk may have a nonzero fl ux density. The m-ring and mG-ring models are de fi ned in Section 4.3. The maximum value of ln  among the models explored in this fi gure is obtained for an m = 2 mG-ring model, in agreement with the DPI analysis described in Section 6.
Figure 6 Comparison of the relative Bayesian evidence, D ln  , for a series of increasingly complex geometric models fi tted using closure amplitudes and closure phases within the snapshot modeling formalism described in detail in Section 6. The fi ts have been carried out using eht-imaging on the HOPS April 7 Sgr A * data, and each point in the fi gure is colored according to the number of free parameters in the model; the number of free parameters in each model is also indicated in the horizontal axis labels. The panel on the right shows a zoom-in to the highest-evidence region of the left panel. Ring-like models are indicated with circles, and nonring models are indicated with crosses. All Bayesian evidence values are quoted relative to the highest value attained across all models. The parameter counts re fl ect the fact that all models are normalized to have unit total fl ux density and are centered at the image origin. The crescent model consists of a smaller disk subtracted from an offset larger disk. In the crescent +fl oor model, the smaller disk may have a nonzero fl ux density. The m-ring and mG-ring models are de fi ned in Section 4.3. The maximum value of ln  among the models explored in this fi gure is obtained for an m = 2 mG-ring model, in agreement with the DPI analysis described in Section 6.From the PDF
Figure 7 An illustration of how the observed visibilities constrain the source structure, within the context of a simple geometric model ( see Section 4.2 ) . The left panel shows the debiased visibility amplitudes from April 7 ( black points ) after normalizing by the light curve, averaging in time across scans, and deconvolving the diffractive scattering kernel. Only data points with a signal-to-noise ratio greater than 3 are shown. The ranges of baseline lengths corresponding to the locations of the fi rst and second visibility minima are highlighted in cyan and purple, respectively. The locations of these minima constrain the diameter of an emitting ring, as shown in the top right panel. Similarly, the ranges of normalized amplitudes corresponding to the fi rst and second visibility maxima are highlighted in red and orange, respectively. Both the absolute fractional amplitudes and their relative values ( shown in green ) constrain a combination of the fractional ring width and the fractional central fl ux. The ' best- fi t ' model visibility amplitudes are shown by the gray curve in the left panel, with the corresponding parameters marked by the gray line in the top right panel and the gray cross in the bottom right panel. The image structure corresponding to this model is shown in the upper right corner of the left panel, with a 20 μ as scale bar shown in white.
Figure 7 An illustration of how the observed visibilities constrain the source structure, within the context of a simple geometric model ( see Section 4.2 ) . The left panel shows the debiased visibility amplitudes from April 7 ( black points ) after normalizing by the light curve, averaging in time across scans, and deconvolving the diffractive scattering kernel. Only data points with a signal-to-noise ratio greater than 3 are shown. The ranges of baseline lengths corresponding to the locations of the fi rst and second visibility minima are highlighted in cyan and purple, respectively. The locations of these minima constrain the diameter of an emitting ring, as shown in the top right panel. Similarly, the ranges of normalized amplitudes corresponding to the fi rst and second visibility maxima are highlighted in red and orange, respectively. Both the absolute fractional amplitudes and their relative values ( shown in green ) constrain a combination of the fractional ring width and the fractional central fl ux. The ' best- fi t ' model visibility amplitudes are shown by the gray curve in the left panel, with the corresponding parameters marked by the gray line in the top right panel and the gray cross in the bottom right panel. The image structure corresponding to this model is shown in the upper right corner of the left panel, with a 20 μ as scale bar shown in white.From the PDF
Figure 8 Example mG-ring model. The model consists of an m-ring of diameter d , with azimuthal variations determined by Fourier coef fi cients β m and with thickness determined by convolution with a circular Gaussian of FWHM W . The mG-ring model also includes a circular Gaussian of FWHM W Gauss and fractional relative fl ux density f Gauss ( Equation ( 20 )) . The position angle η of the ring is determined by the phase of the m = 1 mode ( Equation ( 23 )) , while the magnitude of its asymmetry A is determined by the amplitude of the m = 1 mode ( Equation ( 24 )) . The red curve in the middle panel shows a radial pro fi le in the horizontal direction; the orange curve in the bottom panel shows the azimuthal pro fi le and its decomposition into its three modes. The plotted model has w = 0.3, f Gauss = 0.2, W Gauss / d = 0.8, β 1 = -0.3 i , and β 2 = 0.1 + 0.1 i .
Figure 8 Example mG-ring model. The model consists of an m-ring of diameter d , with azimuthal variations determined by Fourier coef fi cients β m and with thickness determined by convolution with a circular Gaussian of FWHM W . The mG-ring model also includes a circular Gaussian of FWHM W Gauss and fractional relative fl ux density f Gauss ( Equation ( 20 )) . The position angle η of the ring is determined by the phase of the m = 1 mode ( Equation ( 23 )) , while the magnitude of its asymmetry A is determined by the amplitude of the m = 1 mode ( Equation ( 24 )) . The red curve in the middle panel shows a radial pro fi le in the horizontal direction; the orange curve in the bottom panel shows the azimuthal pro fi le and its decomposition into its three modes. The plotted model has w = 0.3, f Gauss = 0.2, W Gauss / d = 0.8, β 1 = -0.3 i , and β 2 = 0.1 + 0.1 i .From the PDF
Figure 9 Representative examples of imaging results for each of the four imaging pipelines used in Paper III; DIFMAP is shown in the top left panel, eht-imaging in the top right panel, SMILI in the bottom left panel, and THEMIS in the bottom right panel. The top section of each panel shows the light-curve-normalized complex visibility data ( in blue ) as a function of baseline length; the light-curve-normalized visibilities are denoted as ˆ V . The real parts of the complex visibilities are plotted as fi lled markers, and the imaginary parts of the complex visibilities are plotted as open markers; the corresponding model visibilities are overplotted as red points. The plotted data have been through the pre-analysis and pre-imaging calibration procedures described in M87 * Paper III, Paper II, and Paper III. The bottom section of each panel shows the normalized residuals -i.e., the difference between the model and data visibilities, normalized by the data uncertainties -as a function of baseline length. The solid red horizontal line marks zero residual, and the two dotted horizontal red lines mark ± one standard deviation. The blue histogram on the right side of each bottom panel shows the distribution of normalized residuals, with the solid red curve showing a unit-variance normal distribution and the dotted green curve showing a normal distribution with variance equal to that of the normalized residuals. We note that the visibilities for the DIFMAP , eht-imaging , and SMILI pipelines have been ' descattered ' and so have somewhat larger typical amplitudes than the visibilities for the THEMIS pipeline ( for which the scattering is incorporated as part of the forward model; see Equation ( 5.1 ) and Paper III ) . We also note that the different imaging pipelines make different choices about data averaging: DIFMAP and eht-imaging average the data over 60 s intervals, SMILI averages over 120 s intervals, and THEMIS averages over scans. Detailed descriptions of each of the imaging methods are provided in Paper III.
Figure 9 Representative examples of imaging results for each of the four imaging pipelines used in Paper III; DIFMAP is shown in the top left panel, eht-imaging in the top right panel, SMILI in the bottom left panel, and THEMIS in the bottom right panel. The top section of each panel shows the light-curve-normalized complex visibility data ( in blue ) as a function of baseline length; the light-curve-normalized visibilities are denoted as ˆ V . The real parts of the complex visibilities are plotted as fi lled markers, and the imaginary parts of the complex visibilities are plotted as open markers; the corresponding model visibilities are overplotted as red points. The plotted data have been through the pre-analysis and pre-imaging calibration procedures described in M87 * Paper III, Paper II, and Paper III. The bottom section of each panel shows the normalized residuals -i.e., the difference between the model and data visibilities, normalized by the data uncertainties -as a function of baseline length. The solid red horizontal line marks zero residual, and the two dotted horizontal red lines mark ± one standard deviation. The blue histogram on the right side of each bottom panel shows the distribution of normalized residuals, with the solid red curve showing a unit-variance normal distribution and the dotted green curve showing a normal distribution with variance equal to that of the normalized residuals. We note that the visibilities for the DIFMAP , eht-imaging , and SMILI pipelines have been ' descattered ' and so have somewhat larger typical amplitudes than the visibilities for the THEMIS pipeline ( for which the scattering is incorporated as part of the forward model; see Equation ( 5.1 ) and Paper III ) . We also note that the different imaging pipelines make different choices about data averaging: DIFMAP and eht-imaging average the data over 60 s intervals, SMILI averages over 120 s intervals, and THEMIS averages over scans. Detailed descriptions of each of the imaging methods are provided in Paper III.From the PDF
Figure 10 Morphological parameter distributions from IDFE analyses, applied to the descattered Sgr A * top-set and posterior images corresponding to the combined LO + HI band data from the HOPS calibration pipeline. The distributions shown correspond to combined April 6 + 7 results for posterior imaging and April 7 data for top-set imaging. No metronization -based fi ltering has been applied.
Figure 10 Morphological parameter distributions from IDFE analyses, applied to the descattered Sgr A * top-set and posterior images corresponding to the combined LO + HI band data from the HOPS calibration pipeline. The distributions shown correspond to combined April 6 + 7 results for posterior imaging and April 7 data for top-set imaging. No metronization -based fi ltering has been applied.From the PDF
Figure 11 Comparison of two ring classi fi cation procedures. Each panel shows a mean Sgr A * ring and nonring image for a single imaging pipeline, with the top row showing how the images are classi fi ed by metronization in the ' permissive ' mode and the bottom row showing the classi fi cation determined by the clustering analysis from Paper III. All of the images have been produced using descattered Sgr A * data from the HOPS calibration pipeline. The results correspond to combined April 6 and 7 data for posterior imaging and April 7 data for top-set imaging. All of the images share a common brightness color scale; the absolute brightness scale is arbitrary because each image has been normalized to have unit total fl ux density.
Figure 11 Comparison of two ring classi fi cation procedures. Each panel shows a mean Sgr A * ring and nonring image for a single imaging pipeline, with the top row showing how the images are classi fi ed by metronization in the ' permissive ' mode and the bottom row showing the classi fi cation determined by the clustering analysis from Paper III. All of the images have been produced using descattered Sgr A * data from the HOPS calibration pipeline. The results correspond to combined April 6 and 7 data for posterior imaging and April 7 data for top-set imaging. All of the images share a common brightness color scale; the absolute brightness scale is arbitrary because each image has been normalized to have unit total fl ux density.From the PDF
Figure 12 Diameter distributions determined by REx and VIDA for all descattered Sgr A * images from the HOPS pipeline, organized by metronization mode. Each panel shows the fraction of images found to possess topological ring structure. For posterior imaging we use the combined April 6 + 7 results, and for top-set imaging we use the April 7 results.
Figure 12 Diameter distributions determined by REx and VIDA for all descattered Sgr A * images from the HOPS pipeline, organized by metronization mode. Each panel shows the fraction of images found to possess topological ring structure. For posterior imaging we use the combined April 6 + 7 results, and for top-set imaging we use the April 7 results.From the PDF
Figure 13 Example snapshot modeling results and averaging scheme applied to the Sgr A * April 6 and 7 low-band HOPS data sets. The blue fi lled regions show the posterior distribution of the mG-ring diameter parameter for an m = 4 model fi t to each 120 s snapshot. We fi nd the tightest diameter posteriors from 12.5 to 14 UTC, which corresponds to the best time region from Paper III. For visual clarity we only show the distributions for every second snapshot. The black curves at the top show the diameter distribution corresponding to 100 random draws from the hypermodel posterior ( Equation ( 36 )) .
Figure 13 Example snapshot modeling results and averaging scheme applied to the Sgr A * April 6 and 7 low-band HOPS data sets. The blue fi lled regions show the posterior distribution of the mG-ring diameter parameter for an m = 4 model fi t to each 120 s snapshot. We fi nd the tightest diameter posteriors from 12.5 to 14 UTC, which corresponds to the best time region from Paper III. For visual clarity we only show the distributions for every second snapshot. The black curves at the top show the diameter distribution corresponding to 100 random draws from the hypermodel posterior ( Equation ( 36 )) .From the PDF
Figure 14 Relative Bayesian evidence and best- fi t mG-ring model diameter vs. m -order, from the snapshot + averaging geometric modeling from the Comrade pipeline applied to the Sgr A * data. Because the absolute values of ln  can be substantially different for each data set ( i.e., each combination of observing day, frequency band, and calibration pipeline ) , and because only the relative values carry information about model speci fi cation preferences, we reference all ln  values to the maximum value attained at any m for that data set.
Figure 14 Relative Bayesian evidence and best- fi t mG-ring model diameter vs. m -order, from the snapshot + averaging geometric modeling from the Comrade pipeline applied to the Sgr A * data. Because the absolute values of ln  can be substantially different for each data set ( i.e., each combination of observing day, frequency band, and calibration pipeline ) , and because only the relative values carry information about model speci fi cation preferences, we reference all ln  values to the maximum value attained at any m for that data set.From the PDF
Figure 15 Representative examples of snapshot modeling results for both the Comrade ( top row ) and DPI ( bottom row ) pipelines. The top row of panels shows results from fi tting an m = 4 mG-ring with Comrade to the HOPS low-band Sgr A * data on both April 6 and 7, while the bottom row of panels shows results from fi tting an m = 2 mG-ring with DPI to the same data set. Each panel is arranged analogously to the individual panels of Figure 9, though the plotted data products are different. For the Comrade results, the visibility amplitudes and closure phases are used during fi tting, so these are the data products shown in the top left and top right panels, respectively. For the DPI results, the log closure amplitudes and closure phases are used during fi tting, so these are the data products shown in the bottom left and bottom right panels, respectively. All closure quantities are plotted as a function of the perimeter of the relevant polygon ( i.e., triangles for closure phases, quadrangles for log closure amplitudes ) ; the evident zero-valued closure phases and log closure amplitudes primarily correspond to so-called ' trivial ' polygons, i.e., those with near-zero area ( M87 * Paper III; Paper II ) . We note that the data- fl agging procedures differ slightly between the two pipelines ( see Sections 6.4.1 and 6.4.3 ) , resulting in small differences in the fi tted data sets.
Figure 15 Representative examples of snapshot modeling results for both the Comrade ( top row ) and DPI ( bottom row ) pipelines. The top row of panels shows results from fi tting an m = 4 mG-ring with Comrade to the HOPS low-band Sgr A * data on both April 6 and 7, while the bottom row of panels shows results from fi tting an m = 2 mG-ring with DPI to the same data set. Each panel is arranged analogously to the individual panels of Figure 9, though the plotted data products are different. For the Comrade results, the visibility amplitudes and closure phases are used during fi tting, so these are the data products shown in the top left and top right panels, respectively. For the DPI results, the log closure amplitudes and closure phases are used during fi tting, so these are the data products shown in the bottom left and bottom right panels, respectively. All closure quantities are plotted as a function of the perimeter of the relevant polygon ( i.e., triangles for closure phases, quadrangles for log closure amplitudes ) ; the evident zero-valued closure phases and log closure amplitudes primarily correspond to so-called ' trivial ' polygons, i.e., those with near-zero area ( M87 * Paper III; Paper II ) . We note that the data- fl agging procedures differ slightly between the two pipelines ( see Sections 6.4.1 and 6.4.3 ) , resulting in small differences in the fi tted data sets.From the PDF
Figure 16 Relative Bayesian evidence and median posterior mG-ring model diameter vs. m -order, from the full-track geometric modeling applied to the Sgr A * data; error bars on the diameter measurements show 1 σ credible intervals. Because the absolute values of ln  can be substantially different for each data set ( i.e., each combination of frequency band and calibration pipeline ) , and because only the relative values carry information about model speci fi cation preferences, we reference all ln  values to the maximum value attained at any m for that data set.
Figure 16 Relative Bayesian evidence and median posterior mG-ring model diameter vs. m -order, from the full-track geometric modeling applied to the Sgr A * data; error bars on the diameter measurements show 1 σ credible intervals. Because the absolute values of ln  can be substantially different for each data set ( i.e., each combination of frequency band and calibration pipeline ) , and because only the relative values carry information about model speci fi cation preferences, we reference all ln  values to the maximum value attained at any m for that data set.From the PDF
Figure 17 Results of full-track modeling using an m = 4 mG-ring fi t to the Sgr A * HOPS low-band data on April 6 and 7, arranged analogously to the individual panels of Figure 9. As in Figure 9, ˆ V denotes light-curve-normalized complex visibilities.
Figure 17 Results of full-track modeling using an m = 4 mG-ring fi t to the Sgr A * HOPS low-band data on April 6 and 7, arranged analogously to the individual panels of Figure 9. As in Figure 9, ˆ V denotes light-curve-normalized complex visibilities.From the PDF
Figure 18 Similar to Figure 4, but after the direct visibility estimates have been debiased to account for the short-time temporal correlations as described in Broderick et al. ( 2022 ) . These estimates are directly comparable to the power spectra implied by GRMHD simulations ( Georgiev et al. 2022 ) . A single example and the range associated with the library presented in Paper V are shown by the red line and band, respectively.
Figure 18 Similar to Figure 4, but after the direct visibility estimates have been debiased to account for the short-time temporal correlations as described in Broderick et al. ( 2022 ) . These estimates are directly comparable to the power spectra implied by GRMHD simulations ( Georgiev et al. 2022 ) . A single example and the range associated with the library presented in Paper V are shown by the red line and band, respectively.From the PDF
Figure 19 Joint posteriors of the constrained parameters after fi tting a broken power law to the debiased model-agnostic normalized variance estimates, speci fi cally the normalization at | u | = 4 G λ , denoted by a 4, the break location u 0, and the long-baseline power-law index b . Contours enclose 50%, 90%, and 99% probability.
Figure 19 Joint posteriors of the constrained parameters after fi tting a broken power law to the debiased model-agnostic normalized variance estimates, speci fi cally the normalization at | u | = 4 G λ , denoted by a 4, the break location u 0, and the long-baseline power-law index b . Contours enclose 50%, 90%, and 99% probability.From the PDF
Figure 20 Mean images for each geometric modeling and image reconstruction pipelines applied to the Sgr A * data, showing both low band and high band separately for the geometric modeling and the combined bands for image reconstruction ( from Paper III ) . The geometric modeling and THEMIS imaging pipelines have been applied to the combined April 6 and 7 data, while the DIFMAP , eht-imaging , and SMILI imaging pipelines have been applied to the April 7 descattered data; Figures 28 and 29 show single-day results for all pipelines on April 6 and 7, respectively. The upper group of images have been produced from the HOPS calibration pipeline Sgr A * data, while the bottom group of images correspond to the CASA calibration pipeline. All of the images share a common brightness color scale; the absolute brightness scale is arbitrary because each image has been normalized to have unit total fl ux density.
Figure 20 Mean images for each geometric modeling and image reconstruction pipelines applied to the Sgr A * data, showing both low band and high band separately for the geometric modeling and the combined bands for image reconstruction ( from Paper III ) . The geometric modeling and THEMIS imaging pipelines have been applied to the combined April 6 and 7 data, while the DIFMAP , eht-imaging , and SMILI imaging pipelines have been applied to the April 7 descattered data; Figures 28 and 29 show single-day results for all pipelines on April 6 and 7, respectively. The upper group of images have been produced from the HOPS calibration pipeline Sgr A * data, while the bottom group of images correspond to the CASA calibration pipeline. All of the images share a common brightness color scale; the absolute brightness scale is arbitrary because each image has been normalized to have unit total fl ux density.From the PDF
Figure 21 Morphological parameters measured from Sgr A * data using the geometric modeling ( left columns ) , posterior imaging IDFE ( middle column ) , and top-set imaging IDFE ( right columns ) analyses; each marker denotes a median value, and the error bars indicate 68% credible intervals. For geometric and posterior imaging we show the combined April 6 and 7 results, while for top-set imaging we show just descattered April 7. Each row of panels shows the results for a single morphological parameter, with the markers colored according to the method used to make the measurement ( per the legend on the right ) . Measurements made using Sgr A * data from both calibration pipelines are shown using circular and square markers for HOPS and CASA, respectively. IDFE measurements made using REx and VIDA are indicated by fi lled and open markers, respectively; no metronization cuts have been applied to either top-set or posterior images. The IDFE analyses have been applied to images reconstructed using both frequency bands simultaneously ( LO + HI ) , while the geometric modeling analyses have been applied to each frequency band separately ( LO and HI ) .
Figure 21 Morphological parameters measured from Sgr A * data using the geometric modeling ( left columns ) , posterior imaging IDFE ( middle column ) , and top-set imaging IDFE ( right columns ) analyses; each marker denotes a median value, and the error bars indicate 68% credible intervals. For geometric and posterior imaging we show the combined April 6 and 7 results, while for top-set imaging we show just descattered April 7. Each row of panels shows the results for a single morphological parameter, with the markers colored according to the method used to make the measurement ( per the legend on the right ) . Measurements made using Sgr A * data from both calibration pipelines are shown using circular and square markers for HOPS and CASA, respectively. IDFE measurements made using REx and VIDA are indicated by fi lled and open markers, respectively; no metronization cuts have been applied to either top-set or posterior images. The IDFE analyses have been applied to images reconstructed using both frequency bands simultaneously ( LO + HI ) , while the geometric modeling analyses have been applied to each frequency band separately ( LO and HI ) .From the PDF
Figure 22 Sgr A * θ g distributions for all of the analyses in this paper. The solid color curves show the fi tted generalized lambda distribution. The transparent curves show the kernel density estimate for the distribution. The plotted results have been obtained using the HOPS calibration pipeline. For reference, we overlay the θ g constraints measured from stellar orbits with the Keck ( Do et al. 2019 ) and Very Large Telescope ( VLT; Gravity Collaboration et al. 2019, 2020 ) facilities.
Figure 22 Sgr A * θ g distributions for all of the analyses in this paper. The solid color curves show the fi tted generalized lambda distribution. The transparent curves show the kernel density estimate for the distribution. The plotted results have been obtained using the HOPS calibration pipeline. For reference, we overlay the θ g constraints measured from stellar orbits with the Keck ( Do et al. 2019 ) and Very Large Telescope ( VLT; Gravity Collaboration et al. 2019, 2020 ) facilities.From the PDF
Figure 23 Estimate of the variance of the visibility amplitudes from the 2013 1.3 mm VLBI observations reported in Johnson et al. ( 2015 ) , indicated by the red open circles. The associated statistical errors are shown by the red triangles. For comparison, all of the elements of Figure 4 are reproduced as shown there, including the 2017 EHT variance estimates ( fi lled and open black circles ) .
Figure 23 Estimate of the variance of the visibility amplitudes from the 2013 1.3 mm VLBI observations reported in Johnson et al. ( 2015 ) , indicated by the red open circles. The associated statistical errors are shown by the red triangles. For comparison, all of the elements of Figure 4 are reproduced as shown there, including the 2017 EHT variance estimates ( fi lled and open black circles ) .From the PDF
Image 24
From the PDF
Figure 25 Visibility amplitudes from the HOPS low-band GRMHD validation synthetic data set ( data set 092 in Table 7 ) , averaged coherently over 120 s segments, on April 10 ( red ) , April 7 ( blue ) , and April 5 and 10 ( gray ) on the Chile-LMT baselines as functions of baseline length ( left ) and observing time ( right ) . Error bars indicate the error implied by the mean noise model and are intended to account for fl uctuations due to variability in addition to statistical and known systematic error components. Vertical dotted green lines indicate the positions at which frames are shown in Figure 26.
Figure 25 Visibility amplitudes from the HOPS low-band GRMHD validation synthetic data set ( data set 092 in Table 7 ) , averaged coherently over 120 s segments, on April 10 ( red ) , April 7 ( blue ) , and April 5 and 10 ( gray ) on the Chile-LMT baselines as functions of baseline length ( left ) and observing time ( right ) . Error bars indicate the error implied by the mean noise model and are intended to account for fl uctuations due to variability in addition to statistical and known systematic error components. Vertical dotted green lines indicate the positions at which frames are shown in Figure 26.From the PDF
Figure 26 Average ( left ) and snapshot ( right ) images from the GRMHD simulation used to generate the validation synthetic data set shown in Figure 25. Three frames from the portion of the simulation used to generate the April 10 ( top, outlined in red ) and April 7 ( bottom, outlined in blue ) synthetic data sets are shown at the GMST times speci fi ed ( corresponding to the times indicated by the vertical dotted green lines in Figure 25 ) . All of the images share a common brightness color scale; the absolute brightness scale is arbitrary because each image has been normalized to have unit total fl ux density, and a modest amount of saturation has been permitted in the brightest regions to enhance the visibility of low-brightness features.
Figure 26 Average ( left ) and snapshot ( right ) images from the GRMHD simulation used to generate the validation synthetic data set shown in Figure 25. Three frames from the portion of the simulation used to generate the April 10 ( top, outlined in red ) and April 7 ( bottom, outlined in blue ) synthetic data sets are shown at the GMST times speci fi ed ( corresponding to the times indicated by the vertical dotted green lines in Figure 25 ) . All of the images share a common brightness color scale; the absolute brightness scale is arbitrary because each image has been normalized to have unit total fl ux density, and a modest amount of saturation has been permitted in the brightest regions to enhance the visibility of low-brightness features.From the PDF
Figure 27 Comparison of the results from THEMIS imaging ( top row ) , full-track geometric modeling ( middle row ) , and snapshot modeling ( bottom row ) across different combinations of April 6 and 7 data sets. The fi rst column shows results from fi tting to the April 6 data, the second column shows results from fi tting to the April 6 data after fl agging baselines between Chile and LMT, the third column shows results from fi tting to the April 7 data, and the fourth column shows results from fi tting to the combined April 6 and 7 data. In all panels, we show an image corresponding to the posterior mean; for the THEMIS imaging results, each sample image has been shifted during averaging so as to maximize the normalized cross-correlation computed with respect to a reference sample. The full-track and snapshot modeling results show fi ts to the HOPS pipeline low-band data, while the imaging results show fi ts to the HOPS pipeline combined low- and high-band data. All of the images share a common brightness color scale; the absolute brightness scale is arbitrary because each image has been normalized to have unit total fl ux density, and a modest amount of saturation has been permitted in the brightest regions to enhance the visibility of low-brightness features.
Figure 27 Comparison of the results from THEMIS imaging ( top row ) , full-track geometric modeling ( middle row ) , and snapshot modeling ( bottom row ) across different combinations of April 6 and 7 data sets. The fi rst column shows results from fi tting to the April 6 data, the second column shows results from fi tting to the April 6 data after fl agging baselines between Chile and LMT, the third column shows results from fi tting to the April 7 data, and the fourth column shows results from fi tting to the combined April 6 and 7 data. In all panels, we show an image corresponding to the posterior mean; for the THEMIS imaging results, each sample image has been shifted during averaging so as to maximize the normalized cross-correlation computed with respect to a reference sample. The full-track and snapshot modeling results show fi ts to the HOPS pipeline low-band data, while the imaging results show fi ts to the HOPS pipeline combined low- and high-band data. All of the images share a common brightness color scale; the absolute brightness scale is arbitrary because each image has been normalized to have unit total fl ux density, and a modest amount of saturation has been permitted in the brightest regions to enhance the visibility of low-brightness features.From the PDF
Figure 29 Same as Figure 20, but showing results obtained from using only the April 7 data.
Figure 29 Same as Figure 20, but showing results obtained from using only the April 7 data.From the PDF
Figure 30 Similar to Figure 21, but showing results obtained from fi tting to the April 6 and 7 data sets separately. Each column from Figure 21 has now been split into a pair of columns showing April 6 results on the left and April 7 results on the right.
Figure 30 Similar to Figure 21, but showing results obtained from fi tting to the April 6 and 7 data sets separately. Each column from Figure 21 has now been split into a pair of columns showing April 6 results on the left and April 7 results on the right.From the PDF
Figure 31 Example average images from some of the GRMHD movies selected for synthetic data generation; each movie has been light-curve-normalized prior to averaging. The data set indices are labeled in the upper left corner of each panel, and the corresponding GRMHD parameters are listed in Table 7. All of the images share a common brightness color scale; the absolute brightness scale is arbitrary because each image has been normalized to have unit total fl ux density, and a modest amount of saturation has been permitted in the brightest regions to enhance the visibility of low-brightness features. We note that these average images tend to have much smoother structure than the individual frames of the movies that were averaged to produce them ( see, e.g., Figure 26 for several example frames from one movie ) ; the synthetic data sets themselves are produced from the movies and not from the average images.
Figure 31 Example average images from some of the GRMHD movies selected for synthetic data generation; each movie has been light-curve-normalized prior to averaging. The data set indices are labeled in the upper left corner of each panel, and the corresponding GRMHD parameters are listed in Table 7. All of the images share a common brightness color scale; the absolute brightness scale is arbitrary because each image has been normalized to have unit total fl ux density, and a modest amount of saturation has been permitted in the brightest regions to enhance the visibility of low-brightness features. We note that these average images tend to have much smoother structure than the individual frames of the movies that were averaged to produce them ( see, e.g., Figure 26 for several example frames from one movie ) ; the synthetic data sets themselves are produced from the movies and not from the average images.From the PDF
Figure 32 Illustration of the centralizing bias induced by specifying both the snapshot priors and hypermodel priors separately, using the diameter parameter as an example. The orange curve shows the diameter prior speci fi ed during mG-ring model fi tting of an individual snapshot, and the blue curve shows the effective prior on this parameter after snapshots are combined via the procedure speci fi ed in Section 6.3.
Figure 32 Illustration of the centralizing bias induced by specifying both the snapshot priors and hypermodel priors separately, using the diameter parameter as an example. The orange curve shows the diameter prior speci fi ed during mG-ring model fi tting of an individual snapshot, and the blue curve shows the effective prior on this parameter after snapshots are combined via the procedure speci fi ed in Section 6.3.From the PDF
Figure 33 Comparison of the 2D joint posterior distributions obtained from fi tting an mG-ring model to a 120 s snapshot starting at 12.65 hr UT in the Sgr A * April 7 HOPS low-band data set. The left plot compares the results from Comrade ( blue ) and eht-imaging ( orange ) , fi tting to visibility amplitudes ( including gains ) and closure phases with an m = 3 mG-ring. The right triangle plot shows the results from Comrade ( blue ) , eht-imaging ( orange ) , and DPI ( green ) , fi tting to closure amplitudes and closure phases for an m = 2 mG-ring. In both cases we only show the results for the diameter, width, and fractional Gaussian component fl ux parameters. Since DPI fi ts the diameter of the blurred m-ring ¢ d ( Equation ( 42 )) , the DPI diameter was debiased so that it corresponds to the in fi nitesimally thin m-ring diameter that is fi t by eht-imaging and Comrade ( see also M87 * Paper VI ) . The contours show 1 σ , 2 σ , and 3 σ levels of the posterior distributions.
Figure 33 Comparison of the 2D joint posterior distributions obtained from fi tting an mG-ring model to a 120 s snapshot starting at 12.65 hr UT in the Sgr A * April 7 HOPS low-band data set. The left plot compares the results from Comrade ( blue ) and eht-imaging ( orange ) , fi tting to visibility amplitudes ( including gains ) and closure phases with an m = 3 mG-ring. The right triangle plot shows the results from Comrade ( blue ) , eht-imaging ( orange ) , and DPI ( green ) , fi tting to closure amplitudes and closure phases for an m = 2 mG-ring. In both cases we only show the results for the diameter, width, and fractional Gaussian component fl ux parameters. Since DPI fi ts the diameter of the blurred m-ring ¢ d ( Equation ( 42 )) , the DPI diameter was debiased so that it corresponds to the in fi nitesimally thin m-ring diameter that is fi t by eht-imaging and Comrade ( see also M87 * Paper VI ) . The contours show 1 σ , 2 σ , and 3 σ levels of the posterior distributions.From the PDF
Image 33
From the PDF
Figure 35 Time-averaged images for GRMHD simulations that produce anomalously small ( left ) and typical ( right ) α calibrations for each geometric modeling and IDFE method used to estimate the mass of Sgr A * . Left: shown are the GMRHD simulations within the calibration set that result in the fi ve smallest median α values ( computed across the applicable posterior or top set ) . Above each collection of images, the number of calibration data sets that fi nd α < 7.5 is listed, in comparison to the total number of calibration experiments ( HI / LO band, REx / VIDA ring radius measurements ) . Right: fi ve GRMHD simulations randomly chosen from within the peak of the distribution of α values. Above each collection of images, the number of calibration data sets within one standard deviation of the mean α across the calibration set is listed. In each panel, the corresponding simulation index in Table 7 and the median α across the relevant posterior or top set are given in the upper left and right, respectively.
Figure 35 Time-averaged images for GRMHD simulations that produce anomalously small ( left ) and typical ( right ) α calibrations for each geometric modeling and IDFE method used to estimate the mass of Sgr A * . Left: shown are the GMRHD simulations within the calibration set that result in the fi ve smallest median α values ( computed across the applicable posterior or top set ) . Above each collection of images, the number of calibration data sets that fi nd α < 7.5 is listed, in comparison to the total number of calibration experiments ( HI / LO band, REx / VIDA ring radius measurements ) . Right: fi ve GRMHD simulations randomly chosen from within the peak of the distribution of α values. Above each collection of images, the number of calibration data sets within one standard deviation of the mean α across the calibration set is listed. In each panel, the corresponding simulation index in Table 7 and the median α across the relevant posterior or top set are given in the upper left and right, respectively.From the PDF

Verification

Claims the paper makes

18 Valid · 3 Not valid · 36 Not checked · 204 Own results and interpretations

170 more claims · 7 with their cited sources checked

Create a free account to see all 261 claims and to verify the 2 references still open.

See all claims — free account
  • It may state two separate claims as one. 56
  • Probably not a substantial claim. 31
  • The quote only partly states this claim. 2

Create a free account to see these claims.

Citations

Cites

Show all 94 references

Research works printed but not linked: 5

  1. Luminet, 1979, A&A, 75, 228
  2. Morozov, 2017, Dionysus 2, Library for Computing Persistent Homology
  3. Paszke, 2017, NIPS 2017 Workshop on Autodiff
  4. Pedregosa, 2011, J. Mach. Learn. Res., 12, 2825
  5. Twiss, 1960, Obs, 80, 153

Cited by

See all 369

Metadata

Authors
Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration, Akiyama, K., Alberdi, A., Alef, W., Algaba, J. C., Anantua, R., Asada, K., Azulay, R., Bach, U., Baczko, A.-K., Ball, D., Baloković, M., Barrett, J., Bauböck, M., Benson, B. A., Bintley, D., Blackburn, L., Blundell, R., Bouman, K. L., Bower, G. C., Boyce, H., Bremer, M., Brinkerink, C. D., Brissenden, R., Britzen, S., Broderick, A. E., Broguiere, D., Bronzwaer, T., Bustamante, S., Byun, D.-Y., Carlstrom, J. E., Ceccobello, C., Chael, A., Chan, C.-K., Chatterjee, K., Chatterjee, S., Chen, M.-T., Chen 陈, Y. 永., Cheng, X., Cho, I., Christian, P., Conroy, N. S., Conway, J. E., Cordes, J. M., Crawford, T. M., Crew, G. B., Cruz-Osorio, A., Cui 崔, Y. 玉., Davelaar, J., Laurentis, M. D., Deane, R., Dempsey, J., Desvignes, G., Dexter, J., Dhruv, V., Doeleman, S. S., Dougal, S., Dzib, S. A., Eatough, R. P., Emami, R., Falcke, H., Farah, J., Fish, V. L., Fomalont, E., Ford, H. A., Fraga-Encinas, R., Freeman, W. T., Friberg, P., Fromm, C. M., Fuentes, A., Galison, P., Gammie, C. F., García, R., Gentaz, O., Georgiev, B., Goddi, C., Gold, R., Gómez-Ruiz, A. I., Gómez, J. L., Gu 顾, M. 敏., Gurwell, M., Hada, K., Haggard, D., Haworth, K., Hecht, M. H., Hesper, R., Heumann, D., Ho 何, L. C. 子., Ho, P., Honma, M., Huang, C.-W. L., Huang 黄, L. 磊., Hughes, D. H., Ikeda, S., Impellizzeri, C. M. V., Inoue, M., Issaoun, S., James, D. J., Jannuzi, B. T., Janssen, M., Jeter, B., Jiang 江, W. 悟., Jiménez-Rosales, A., Johnson, M. D., Jorstad, S., Joshi, A. V., Jung, T., Karami, M., Karuppusamy, R., Kawashima, T., Keating, G. K., Kettenis, M., Kim, D.-J., Kim, J.-Y., Kim, J., Kim, J., Kino, M., Koay, J. Y., Kocherlakota, P., Kofuji, Y., Koch, P. M., Koyama, S., Kramer, C., Kramer, M., Krichbaum, T. P., Kuo, C.-Y., Bella, N. L., Lauer, T. R., Lee, D., Lee, S.-S., Leung, P. K., Levis, A., Li 李, Z. 志., Lico, R., Lindahl, G., Lindqvist, M., Lisakov, M., Liu 刘, J. 俊., Liu, K., Liuzzo, E., Lo, W.-P., Lobanov, A. P., Loinard, L., Lonsdale, C. J., Lu 路, R.-S. 如., Mao 毛, J. 基., Marchili, N., Markoff, S., Marrone, D. P., Marscher, A. P., Martí-Vidal, I., Matsushita, S., Matthews, L. D., Medeiros, L., Menten, K. M., Michalik, D., Mizuno, I., Mizuno, Y., Moran, J. M., Moriyama, K., Moscibrodzka, M., Müller, C., Mus, A., Musoke, G., Myserlis, I., Nadolski, A., Nagai, H., Nagar, N. M., Nakamura, M., Narayan, R., Narayanan, G., Natarajan, I., Nathanail, A., Fuentes, S. N., Neilsen, J., Neri, R., Ni, C., Noutsos, A., Nowak, M. A., Oh, J., Okino, H., Olivares, H., Ortiz-León, G. N., Oyama, T., Palumbo, D. C. M., Paraschos, G. F., Park, J., Parsons, H., Patel, N., Pen, U.-L., Pesce, D. W., Piétu, V., Plambeck, R., PopStefanija, A., Porth, O., Pötzl, F. M., Prather, C., Preciado-López, J. A., Pu, H.-Y., Ramakrishnan, V., Rao, R., Rawlings, M. G., Raymond, A. W., Rezzolla, L., Ricarte, A., Ripperda, B., Roelofs, F., Rogers, A., Ros, E., Romero-Cañizales, C., Roshanineshat, A., Rottmann, H., Roy, A. L., Ruiz, I., Ruszczyk, C., Rygl, K. L. J., Sánchez, S., Sánchez-Argüelles, D., Sánchez-Portal, M., Sasada, M., Satapathy, K., Savolainen, T., Schloerb, F. P., Schonfeld, J., Schuster, K.-F., Shao, L., Shen 沈, Z. 志., Small, D., Sohn, B. W., SooHoo, J., Souccar, K., Sun 孙, H. 赫., Tazaki, F., Tetarenko, A. J., Tiede, P., Tilanus, R. P. J., Titus, M., Torne, P., Traianou, E., Trent, T., Trippe, S., Turk, M., van Bemmel, I., van Langevelde, H. J., van Rossum, D. R., Vos, J., Wagner, J., Ward-Thompson, D., Wardle, J., Weintroub, J., Wex, N., Wharton, R., Wielgus, M., Wiik, K., Witzel, G., Wondrak, M. F., Wong, G. N., Wu 吴, Q. 庆., Yamaguchi, P., Yoon, D., Young, A., Young, K., Younsi, Z., Yuan 袁, F. 峰., Yuan 袁, Y.-F. 业., Zensus, J. A., Zhang, S., Zhao, G.-Y., Zhao 赵, S.-S. 杉., & Chang, D. O.
Affiliations
  • Harvard University (US)
  • Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas (ES)
  • Max Planck Institute for Radio Astronomy (DE)
  • University of Malaya (MY)
  • Institute of Astronomy and Astrophysics, Academia Sinica (TW)
  • Universitat de València (ES)
  • University of Arizona (US)
  • Yale University (US)
  • University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign (US)
  • Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory (US)
  • California Institute of Technology (US)
  • University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa (US)
  • Institut de Radioastronomie Millimétrique (FR)
  • Radboud University Nijmegen (NL)
  • University of Waterloo (CA)
  • Institut de Radioastronomie Millimétrique (IRAM)
  • University of Massachusetts Amherst (US)
  • Korea Astronomy and Space Science Institute (KR)
  • University of Chicago (US)
  • Princeton University (US)
  • Chinese Academy of Sciences
  • Chinese Academy of Sciences (CN)
  • Fairfield University (US)
  • Cornell University (US)
  • Goethe University Frankfurt (DE)
  • Shanghai Jiao Tong University
  • University of the Witwatersrand (ZA)
  • Université Paris Cité (FR)
  • Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (FR)
  • Joint Institute for Laboratory Astrophysics (US)
  • Las Cumbres Observatory Global Telescope Network (US)
  • National Radio Astronomy Observatory
  • Google (United States) (US)
  • The Graduate University for Advanced Studies, SOKENDAI (JP)
  • Center for Astrophysics Harvard & Smithsonian (US)
  • University of Groningen (NL)
  • Peking University
  • Leiden University (NL)
  • Max-Planck-Institut für Radioastronomie
  • Boston University (US)
  • Kogakuin University (JP)
  • Chinese University of Hong Kong (HK)
  • Nanjing University
  • Istituto di Radioastronomia di Bologna (IT)
  • Massachusetts Institute of Technology (US)
  • European Space Agency (FR)
  • Radboud University
  • University of Concepción (CL)
  • Instituto de Radioastronomía Milimétrica (ES)
  • Washington University in St. Louis (US)
  • Sejong University (KR)
  • East Asian Observatory (US)
  • Canadian Institute for Advanced Research (CA)
  • University of California System (US)
  • University of California, Berkeley (US)
  • University of Illinois
  • University of Turku (FI)
  • Consejo Nacional de Ciencia y Tecnología (GT)
  • National Institute of Astrophysics, Optics and Electronics (MX)
  • Hiroshima University (JP)
  • Peking University (CN)
  • Yonsei University (KR)
  • Massachusetts Institute of Technology Haystack Observatory
  • California Institute of Technology
  • Texas Tech University (US)
  • Seoul National University (KR)
  • Joint Institute for VLBI ERIC (JIVE)
  • University of Lancashire (GB)
  • Huazhong University of Science and Technology
  • East Asian Observatory
  • University of Science and Technology of China (CN)
  • Bard College (US)
Corresponding author
Honma, Mareki
ORCID
Venue
The Astrophysical Journal Letters
Published
2022-05-01
Volume
930
Issue
2
Pages
L15
ISSN
  • 2041-8205 (ISSN-L)
  • 2041-8213
OpenAlex
W4280648529
Cited by
369
References
94
Citations by year
2026: 36 · 2025: 114 · 2024: 102 · 2023: 78 · 2022: 39
FWCI
32.81
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Licence
Locations
  • The Astrophysical Journal Letters (publishedVersion, other-oa)
  • OpenBU (Boston University) (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • CLOK (University of Central Lancashire) (acceptedVersion)
  • arXiv (Cornell University) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • Leiden Repository (Leiden University) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • OSTI OAI (U.S. Department of Energy Office of Scientific and Technical Information) (submittedVersion)
  • Chalmers Research (Chalmers University of Technology) (submittedVersion)
  • UTUPub (University of Turku) (submittedVersion)
  • CaltechAUTHORS (California Institute of Technology) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • Data Archiving and Networked Services (DANS) (submittedVersion, other-oa)
  • HAL (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • Aaltodoc (Aalto University) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • UvA-DARE (University of Amsterdam) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • DIGITAL.CSIC (Spanish National Research Council (CSIC)) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) (submittedVersion)
  • UCL Discovery (University College London) (submittedVersion)
  • UNICA IRIS Institutional Research Information System (University of Cagliari) (submittedVersion, other-oa)
  • Publication Server of Goethe University Frankfurt am Main (Goethe University Frankfurt) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • University of Groningen research database (University of Groningen / Centre for Information Technology) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • Radboud Repository (Radboud University) (submittedVersion)
  • UpSpace Institutional Repository (University of Pretoria) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • University of Southern Denmark Research Portal (University of Southern Denmark) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • UTUPub (University of Turku) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • Radboud Repository (Radboud University) (submittedVersion, other-oa)
  • arXiv (Cornell University) (cc-by)
Funders
  • National Science Foundation (1207704, 12192223, 1144085, 11933007, SEV-2017-0709, 1265383, JPMXP1020200109, 1140030, 1818253, 1743442, 11991053, DEAC05- 00OR22725, HST-HF2-51431.001-A, 1440254, 18KK0090, 884631, 1221421, 1248097, 1310896, 1715061, ACI-1 548 562, 0096454, 0705062, 1548562, 0905844, 00OR22725, 1207730, 1614868, 11991052, 11721303, JP18K13594, 0521233, 1615796, 1743747, TG-AST080026N, 1935980, 1228509, 0735191, 0922984, 11650110427, 1716536, 10625314, 89233218CNA000001, 2034306, 610058, 1126433, 11725312, 1816420, AST-1555365, FR 4069/2-1, ZDBS-LY-SLH011, 0352953, 1716327, 1852617, 12192220, 1207752, 1903847)
  • Smithsonian Institution
  • U.S. Department of Energy (#89233218CNA000001, AC05-00OR22725, 51431, DE--AC05--00OR22725, DE-AC05?, Contract No. DE-AC05-00OR22725, 1548562, Contract 89233218CNA000001, ACI-1548562, No. DE-AC05-00OR22725, 00OR22725)
  • National Aeronautics and Space Administration (AST-1935980, 89233218CNA000001, AST-1816420, ACI-1548562, AC05-00OR22725, DE-AC05-00OR22725, 80NSSC20K0645, OISE-1743747, 2016YFA0400702, AST-2034306, AST-1716536, NAS 526555, 80NSSC20K0527, 80NSSC20K1567, HST-HF2-51431.001-A)
  • Simons Foundation (001-001)
  • John Templeton Foundation (AST20023, OISE-1743747)
  • Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation (IN112820, 263356, 1221421, AST-2034306, AST-1935980, AST-1440254, Fondecyt 1221421)
  • University of Chicago
  • University of Arizona (1228509)
  • National Center for Theoretical Sciences
  • Compute Canada
  • Netherlands eScience Center
  • Space Telescope Science Institute (AST-1440254, AST-1614868, NAS5- 26555, AST-2034306, 26555, HST-HF2-51431.001-A, AST-1935980)
  • Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovación y Universidades (PID2020-117404GB-C21, SEV-2017-0709, PID2019, PGC 2018, PID2020, AYA2016-80889-P, PGC2018-098915-B-C21, PID2019-108995GB-C22)
  • National Radio Astronomy Observatory
  • Associated Universities
  • International Max Planck Research School for Environmental, Cellular and Molecular Microbiology
  • Joint Institute for Computational Fundamental Science (AST-2034306, AST-1440254, JPMXP1020200109, JP18K13594, AST-1614868)
  • Flatiron Health
  • Government of Canada (DE-AC05-00OR22725)
  • Leverhulme Trust
  • European Commission (AST-2034306, DE-AC05-00OR22725, HORIZON2020, AST-1935980, 610058, SEV-2017-0709, 101018682, 312496, 246083, 730562, 275201)
  • National Research Foundation (77948, NRF-2015H1D3A1066561, NRF-2015H1A2A1033752)
  • University of Pretoria
  • Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (AST-1935980, AST-1716536, OISE-1743747, 884631, SEV-2017-0709, AST-2034306, 610058, AST-1816420, FR 4069/2-1, DE-AC05-00OR22725)
  • Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology (JP18K13594, AST-2034306, 25120007, 18H01245, AST-1614868, AST-1440254, JPMXP1020200109, JP17J08829)
  • Universiteit Leiden
  • National Natural Science Foundation of China (ACI-1548562, DE-AC05-00OR22725, 11650110427, 12 192 220, 12192223, AST-2034306, AST-1935980, (11721303, 11991052, 0 and, 11873028, 11725312, ZDBS-LY-SLH011, 2016YFA0400704, 18KK0090, 11991053, 2017YFA0402703, 2016YFA0400702, 11933007)
  • Universiteit van Amsterdam
  • Radboud Universiteit
  • Academia Sinica
  • Academy of Finland (274477, 312496, 284495, 315721)
  • Chinese Academy of Sciences (QYZDJ-SSW-SLH057, 2016YFA0400702, JCYJ-SHFY2021-013, 2017YFA0402700, 18KK0090, QYZDJ-SSW-SYS008, AST-2034306, 11991052, 11721303, ZDBS-LY-SLH011, 11933007, AST-1935980)
  • China Postdoctoral Science Foundation (11991052, 2020M671266, 11721303)
  • Consejo Nacional de Ciencia y Tecnología (U0004-246083, 279006, U0004-259839, F0003-281692, M0037-279006, 263356, 104497, 281692, 275201, F0003-272050)
  • Nederlandse Organisatie voor Wetenschappelijk Onderzoek (DE-AC05-00OR22725, 639.043.513, OCENW.KLEIN.113)
  • Generalitat Valenciana (APOSTD/2018, APOSTD/2018/177, CIDEGENT/2018/021)
  • Universitat de València
  • Nuclear Safety and Security Commission
  • Korea Astronomy and Space Science Institute
  • National Research Foundation of Korea (2015H1D3A1066561, 2021R1A6A3A01086420, 2022R1C1C1005255, NRF-2015H1D3A1066561, 2019H1D3A1A01102564, NRF-2015H1A2A1033752, 2019R1F1A1059721, ACI-1548562, DE-AC05-00OR22725, 2015H1A2A1033752)
  • Max-Planck-Gesellschaft (2017YFA0402700)
  • Vetenskapsrådet (01154, 2017-00648)
  • Ministry of Education, India
  • China Scholarship Council (2016YFA0400702, DE-AC05-00OR22725)
  • European Southern Observatory
  • Ministry of Science and Technology, Taiwan (MOST106-2112-M001-011, MOST107-2119-M001-017, MOST106-2119-M001-027, MOST105-2119-M001-042, MOST106-2923-M001-005, MOST107-2119-M001-041, MOST107-2119-M110-005, MOST106-2119-M001-013, MOST107-2119-M001-020, MOST107-2923-M001-009)
  • Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique
  • Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación (AYA2016-80889-P, SEV2017-0709, PID2019, PID2019-108995GB-C22, PGC2018, PGC2018-098915-B-C21, PID2019-108995GB-C21, PID2020, PID2020-117404GB-C21)
  • Shanghai Jiao Tong University
  • Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México (IN112417, IN112820, SEV-2017-0709)
  • National Astronomical Observatory of Japan
  • Recruitment Program of Global Experts
  • Junta de Andalucía (SEV-2017-0709, P18-FR-1769)
  • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare
  • Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía (SEV‐2017‐0709)
  • Agencia Nacional de Investigación y Desarrollo (NCN19-058, Fondecyt 1221421, 1221421, DE-AC05-00OR22725)
  • Institut Périmètre de physique théorique
  • East Asian Core Observatories Association
  • Toray Science Foundation
  • Office of Science (DEAC05- 00OR22725, 89233218CNA000001, No. DE-AC05-00OR22725, Contract 89233218CNA000001, ACI-1548562, AC05-00OR22725)
  • National Nuclear Security Administration (89233218C-NA000001, #DE-AC05-00OR22725)
  • Physics Division, National Center for Theoretical Sciences
  • Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (DE-AC05-00OR22725)
  • Science and Technology Facilities Council (ST/V000268/1)
  • Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (17J08829, AST-1440254, AST-1935980, DE-AC05-00OR22725, 610058, 19KK0081, 21H01137, 89233218CNA000001, AST-1614868, 19K14761, ZDBS-LY-SLH011, AST-2034306, 18H03721, 1548562, 18KK0090, 11933007, 18K03709, 275201, 18K13594, 25120007, 246083, JPMXP1020200109, 18H01245)
  • Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas (AYA2016-80889-P, 2019AEP112, SEV-2017-0709)
  • Dirección General de Asuntos del Personal Académico, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México (IN112820, IN112417, 263356)
  • National Institutes of Natural Sciences
  • National Key Research and Development Program of China (2016YFA0400704, 2016YFA0400702, 2017YFA0402700, 2017YFA0402703)
  • Office of International Science and Engineering (17-43747)
  • Astrophysics Division (NAS5-26555)
  • Oak Ridge National Laboratory (AC05-00OR22725, Contract No. DE-AC05-00OR22725, DE-AC05-00OR22725)
  • Los Alamos National Laboratory (89233218CNA 000001, DE-AC05-00OR22725, Contract 89233218CNA000001)
  • Compute Ontario
Topics
  • Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Astronomy and Astrophysics › Astrophysical Phenomena and Observations
  • Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Astronomy and Astrophysics › Pulsars and Gravitational Waves Research
  • Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Nuclear and High Energy Physics › Astrophysics and Cosmic Phenomena
Keywords
Sgr A*, supermassive black holes, black hole mass, event horizon imaging, temporal variation, image morphology, interstellar scattering, gravitational radius, GRMHD simulations

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

The claim verdicts this report counts are experimental: their accuracy is not yet measured.

A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-10-12, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).

A second model labelled each claim on 2026-10-12 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).

Cited sources are checked with a language model’s help (gpt-6-sol).

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: First Sagittarius A* Event Horizon Telescope Results. IV. Variability, Morphology, and Black Hole Mass. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.3847/2041-8213/ac6736
The paper
Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration, Akiyama, K., Alberdi, A., Alef, W., Algaba, J. C., Anantua, R., Asada, K., Azulay, R., Bach, U., Baczko, A.-K., Ball, D., Baloković, M., Barrett, J., Bauböck, M., Benson, B. A., Bintley, D., Blackburn, L., Blundell, R., Bouman, K. L., . . . Chang, D. O. (2022). First Sagittarius A* Event Horizon Telescope Results. IV. Variability, Morphology, and Black Hole Mass. The Astrophysical Journal Letters. https://doi.org/10.3847/2041-8213/ac6736

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.