The DOI matches its Crossref record; 72 of the 72 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Legacy, Rather Than Adequacy, Drives the Selection of Hydrological Models
Open accessAbstract
The findings of hydrological modeling studies depend on which model was used. Although hydrological model selection is a crucial step, experience suggests that hydrologists tend to stick to the model they have experience with, and rarely switch to competing models, although these models might be more adequate given the study objectives. To gain quantitative insights into model selection, we explored the use of seven rainfall‐runoff models based on the abstract of 1,529 peer‐reviewed papers published between 1991 and 2018. The models selected were the Hydrologiska Byråns Vattenbalansavdelning model (HBV), the Variable Infiltration Capacity model (VIC), the mesoscale Hydrological model (mHM), the TOPography‐based hydrologic model (TOPMODEL), the Precipitation Runoff Modelling System (PRMS), the Génie Rural model à 4 paramètres Journaliers (GR4J), and the Sacramento soil moisture accounting model. We provide quantitative evidence of regional preferences in model use across the world and demonstrate that specific models are consistently preferred by certain institutes. Model attachment is particularly strong. In ~74% of the studies, the model selected can be predicted solely based on the affiliation of the first author. The influence of adequacy on the model selection process is less clear. Our data reveal that each model is used across a wide range of purposes, landscapes, and temporal and spatial scales (i.e., as a model of everything and everywhere). Model intercomparisons can provide guidance for model selection and improve model adequacy, but they are still rare (because each model must usually be setup individually) and the insights they provide are currently limited (because they are rarely controlled experiments). We suggest that moving from fixed‐structure models to modular modeling frameworks (master templates for model generation) can overcome these issues, enable a more collaborative and responsive model development environment, and result in improved model adequacy.
Overview
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Self-check
Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.
The self-check needs the paper’s full text.
Citations
Cites
River flow forecasting through conceptual models part I — A discussion of principles
Nash, J. E., & Sutcliffe, J. V. (1970) · Journal of Hydrology · doi:10.1016/0022-1694(70)90255-6 · Cited by 23,674
bibliometrix: An R-tool for comprehensive science mapping analysis
Aria, M., & Cuccurullo, C. (2017) · Journal of Informetrics · doi:10.1016/j.joi.2017.08.007 · Cited by 16,064
THE STRUCTURE OF SCIENTIFIC REVOLUTIONS
MCGUIRE, J. E. (1963) · Philosophical Books · doi:10.1111/j.1468-0149.1963.tb00813.x · Cited by 8,424
Laboratory Life: The Construction of Scientific Facts
Latour, B. (1986) · DigitalGeorgetown (Georgetown University Library) · Cited by 7,491
BEVEN, K. J., & KIRKBY, M. J. (1979) · Hydrological Sciences Bulletin · doi:10.1080/02626667909491834 · Cited by 6,670
Liang, X., Lettenmaier, D. P., Wood, E. F., & Burges, S. J. (1994) · Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres · doi:10.1029/94jd00483 · Cited by 4,051
Niu, G.-Y., Yang, Z.-L., Mitchell, K. E., Chen, F., Ek, M. B., Barlage, M., Kumar, A., Manning, K., Niyogi, D., Rosero, E., et al. (2011) · Journal of Geophysical Research · doi:10.1029/2010jd015139 · Cited by 2,954
Rainfall‐Runoff Modelling: The Primer
Beven, K. (2012) · Wiley eBooks · doi:10.1002/9781119951001 · Cited by 2,051
Improvement of a parsimonious model for streamflow simulation
Perrin, C., Michel, C., & Andréassian, V. (2003) · Journal of Hydrology · doi:10.1016/s0022-1694(03)00225-7 · Cited by 1,821
The Manufacture of Knowledge: An Essay on the Constructivist and Contextual Nature of Science.
Mayrl, W. W., Knorr-Cetina, K. D., & Newton-Smith, W. H. (1982) · Contemporary Sociology · doi:10.2307/2068552 · Cited by 1,303
Ten iterative steps in development and evaluation of environmental models
Jakeman, A. J., Letcher, R. A., & Norton, J. P. (2006) · Environmental Modelling & Software · doi:10.1016/j.envsoft.2006.01.004 · Cited by 1,111
Hartmann, A., Goldscheider, N., Wagener, T., Lange, J., & Weiler, M. (2014) · Reviews of Geophysics · doi:10.1002/2013rg000443 · Cited by 1,068
Putting Science in Its Place: Geographies of Scientific Knowledge
Livingstone, D. N. (2003) · doi:10.7208/chicago/9780226487243.001.0001 · Cited by 953
Mathematical Modeling of Watershed Hydrology
Singh, V. P., & Woolhiser, D. A. (2002) · Journal of Hydrologic Engineering · doi:10.1061/(asce)1084-0699(2002)7:4(270 · Cited by 843
Multiscale parameter regionalization of a grid‐based hydrologic model at the mesoscale
Samaniego, L., Kumar, R., & Attinger, S. (2010) · Water Resources Research · doi:10.1029/2008wr007327 · Cited by 836
Clark, M. P., Slater, A. G., Rupp, D. E., Woods, R. A., Vrugt, J. A., Gupta, H. V., Wagener, T., & Hay, L. E. (2008) · Water Resources Research · doi:10.1029/2007wr006735 · Cited by 638
Precipitation-runoff modeling system; user's manual
(1983) · doi:10.3133/wri834238 · Cited by 632
Teaching hydrological modeling with a user-friendly catchment-runoff-model software package
(2012) · doi:10.5194/hess-16-3315-2012 · Cited by 616
Pursuing the method of multiple working hypotheses for hydrological modeling
Clark, M. P., Kavetski, D., & Fenicia, F. (2011) · Water Resources Research · doi:10.1029/2010wr009827 · Cited by 594
Operational Validation and Intercomparison of Different Types of Hydrological Models
Refsgaard, J. C., & Knudsen, J. (1996) · Water Resources Research · doi:10.1029/96wr00896 · Cited by 591
A unified approach for process‐based hydrologic modeling: 1. Modeling concept
Clark, M. P., Nijssen, B., Lundquist, J. D., Kavetski, D., Rupp, D. E., Woods, R. A., Freer, J. E., Gutmann, E. D., Wood, A. W., Brekke, L. D., et al. (2015) · Water Resources Research · doi:10.1002/2015wr017198 · Cited by 582
Coron, L., Andréassian, V., Perrin, C., Lerat, J., Vaze, J., Bourqui, M., & Hendrickx, F. (2012) · Water Resources Research · doi:10.1029/2011wr011721 · Cited by 461
The Philosophical Basis of Peer Review and the Suppression of Innovation
Horrobin, D. F. (1990) · JAMA: The Journal of the American Medical Association · doi:10.1001/jama.1990.03440100162024 · Cited by 436
The Role of Expert Opinion in Environmental Modelling
Krueger, T., Page, T., Hubacek, K., Smith, L., & Hiscock, K. (2012) · Environmental Modelling & Software · doi:10.1016/j.envsoft.2012.01.011 · Cited by 413
The Method of Multiple Working Hypotheses
Chamberlin, T. C. (1890) · Science · doi:10.1126/science.ns-15.366.92 · Cited by 367
Beven, K., & Freer, J. (2001) · Hydrological Processes · doi:10.1002/hyp.252 · Cited by 365
The Representation of Snow in Land Surface Schemes: Results from PILPS 2(d)
Slater, A. G., Schlosser, C. A., Desborough, C. E., Pitman, A. J., Henderson-Sellers, A., Robock, A., Vinnikov, K. Y., Entin, J., Mitchell, K., Chen, F., et al. (2001) · Journal of Hydrometeorology · doi:10.1175/1525-7541(2001)002<0007:trosil>2.0.co;2 · Cited by 347
A Comparison of Rainfall‐Runoff Modeling Techniques on Small Upland Catchments
Loague, K., & Freeze, R. A. (1985) · Water Resources Research · doi:10.1029/wr021i002p00229 · Cited by 336
Hamman, J. J., Nijssen, B., Bohn, T. J., Gergel, D. R., & Mao, Y. (2018) · Geoscientific Model Development · doi:10.5194/gmd-11-3481-2018 · Cited by 322
A global water resources ensemble of hydrological models: the eartH2Observe Tier-1 dataset
Schellekens, J., Dutra, E., Martínez-de la Torre, A., Balsamo, G., van Dijk, A., Sperna Weiland, F., Minvielle, M., Calvet, J.-C., Decharme, B., Eisner, S., et al. (2017) · Earth System Science Data · doi:10.5194/essd-9-389-2017 · Cited by 319
The Plumbing of Land Surface Models: Benchmarking Model Performance
Best, M. J., Abramowitz, G., Johnson, H. R., Pitman, A. J., Balsamo, G., Boone, A., Cuntz, M., Decharme, B., Dirmeyer, P. A., Dong, J., et al. (2015) · Journal of Hydrometeorology · doi:10.1175/jhm-d-14-0158.1 · Cited by 296
PRMS-IV, the precipitation-runoff modeling system, version 4
Markstrom, S. L., Regan, R. S., Hay, L. E., Viger, R. J., Webb, R. M., Payn, R. A., & LaFontaine, J. H. (2015) · Techniques and Methods · doi:10.3133/tm6b7 · Cited by 277
Kauffeldt, A., Wetterhall, F., Pappenberger, F., Salamon, P., & Thielen, J. (2016) · Environmental Modelling & Software · doi:10.1016/j.envsoft.2015.09.009 · Cited by 277
Handbook of Ecosystem Theories and Management
Müller, F. (2000) · CRC Press eBooks · doi:10.1201/9781482278606 · Cited by 273
ESM-SnowMIP: assessing snow models and quantifying snow-related climate feedbacks
Krinner, G., Derksen, C., Essery, R., Flanner, M., Hagemann, S., Clark, M., Hall, A., Rott, H., Brutel-Vuilmet, C., Kim, H., et al. (2018) · Geoscientific Model Development · doi:10.5194/gmd-11-5027-2018 · Cited by 262
On the need for catchment classification
McDonnell, J. J., & Woods, R. A. (2004) · Journal of Hydrology · doi:10.1016/j.jhydrol.2004.09.003 · Cited by 254
Hobley, D. E. J., Adams, J. M., Nudurupati, S. S., Hutton, E. W. H., Gasparini, N. M., Istanbulluoglu, E., & Tucker, G. E. (2017) · Earth Surface Dynamics · doi:10.5194/esurf-5-21-2017 · Cited by 253
HESS Opinions "Topography driven conceptual modelling (FLEX-Topo)"
Savenije, H. H. G. (2010) · Hydrology and Earth System Sciences · doi:10.5194/hess-14-2681-2010 · Cited by 252
Robust changes and sources of uncertainty in the projected hydrological regimes of Swiss catchments
Addor, N., Rössler, O., Köplin, N., Huss, M., Weingartner, R., & Seibert, J. (2014) · Water Resources Research · doi:10.1002/2014wr015549 · Cited by 242
Self-citationEpistemic geographies of climate change: Science, space and politics
Mahony, M., & Hulme, M. (2018) · Progress in Human Geography · doi:10.1177/0309132516681485 · Cited by 199
Multiscale and Multivariate Evaluation of Water Fluxes and States over European River Basins
Rakovec, O., Kumar, R., Mai, J., Cuntz, M., Thober, S., Zink, M., Attinger, S., Schäfer, D., Schrön, M., & Samaniego, L. (2016) · Journal of Hydrometeorology · doi:10.1175/jhm-d-15-0054.1 · Cited by 196
Changing the Atmosphere: Expert Knowledge and Environmental Governance
(2001) · The MIT Press eBooks · doi:10.7551/mitpress/1789.001.0001 · Cited by 186
Whither field hydrology? The need for discovery science and outrageous hydrological hypotheses
Burt, T. P., & McDonnell, J. J. (2015) · Water Resources Research · doi:10.1002/2014wr016839 · Cited by 185
Catchment properties, function, and conceptual model representation: is there a correspondence?
Fenicia, F., Kavetski, D., Savenije, H. H. G., Clark, M. P., Schoups, G., Pfister, L., & Freer, J. (2014) · Hydrological Processes · doi:10.1002/hyp.9726 · Cited by 178
Accelerating advances in continental domain hydrologic modeling
Archfield, S. A., Clark, M., Arheimer, B., Hay, L. E., McMillan, H., Kiang, J. E., Seibert, J., Hakala, K., Bock, A., Wagener, T., et al. (2015) · Water Resources Research · doi:10.1002/2015wr017498 · Cited by 177
Kollet, S., Sulis, M., Maxwell, R. M., Paniconi, C., Putti, M., Bertoldi, G., Coon, E. T., Cordano, E., Endrizzi, S., Kikinzon, E., et al. (2017) · Water Resources Research · doi:10.1002/2016wr019191 · Cited by 174
Upper and lower benchmarks in hydrological modelling
Seibert, J., Vis, M. J. P., Lewis, E., & van Meerveld, H. J. (2018) · Hydrological Processes · doi:10.1002/hyp.11476 · Cited by 170
Gharari, S., Hrachowitz, M., Fenicia, F., Gao, H., & Savenije, H. H. G. (2014) · Hydrology and Earth System Sciences · doi:10.5194/hess-18-4839-2014 · Cited by 169
Krysanova, V., Vetter, T., Eisner, S., Huang, S., Pechlivanidis, I., Strauch, M., Gelfan, A., Kumar, R., Aich, V., Arheimer, B., et al. (2017) · Environmental Research Letters · doi:10.1088/1748-9326/aa8359 · Cited by 163
Hydrological field data from a modeller's perspective: Part 1. Diagnostic tests for model structure
McMillan, H., Clark, M., Bowden, W. B., Duncan, M. J., & Woods, R. A. (2010) · Hydrological Processes · doi:10.1002/hyp.7841 · Cited by 141
Improving the theoretical underpinnings of process‐based hydrologic models
Clark, M., Schaefli, B., Schymanski, S. J., Samaniego, L., Luce, C. H., Jackson, B., Freer, J. E., Arnold, J. R., Moore, R. D., İstanbulluoğlu, E., et al. (2016) · Water Resources Research · doi:10.1002/2015wr017910 · Cited by 141
Bibliometric review of ecological network analysis: 2010–2016
Borrett, S. R., Sheble, L., Moody, J. W., & Anway, E. C. (2018) · Ecological Modelling · doi:10.1016/j.ecolmodel.2018.04.020 · Cited by 140
Kavetski, D., & Fenicia, F. (2011) · Water Resources Research · doi:10.1029/2011wr010748 · Cited by 139
The museum of errors/horrors in Scopus
Franceschini, F., Maisano, D. A., & Mastrogiacomo, L. (2016) · Journal of Informetrics · doi:10.1016/j.joi.2015.11.006 · Cited by 130
Clark, M., McMillan, H., Collins, D. B. G., Kavetski, D., & Woods, R. A. (2010) · Hydrological Processes · doi:10.1002/hyp.7902 · Cited by 125
Comparison of hydrological model structures based on recession and low flow simulations
Staudinger, M., Stahl, K., Seibert, J., Clark, M., & Tallaksen, L. M. (2011) · Hydrology and earth system sciences · doi:10.5194/hess-15-3447-2011 · Cited by 123
Comparative predictions of discharge from an artificial catchment (Chicken Creek) using sparse data
Holländer, H. M., Blume, T., Bormann, H., Buytaert, W., Chirico, G. B., Exbrayat, J., Gustafsson, D., Hölzel, H., Kraft, P., Stamm, C., et al. (2009) · Hydrology and earth system sciences · doi:10.5194/hess-13-2069-2009 · Cited by 114
Mapping (dis)agreement in hydrologic projections
Melsen, L. A., Addor, N., Mizukami, N., Newman, A. J., Torfs, P. J. J. F., Clark, M., Uijlenhoet, R., & Teuling, A. J. (2018) · Hydrology and earth system sciences · doi:10.5194/hess-22-1775-2018 · Cited by 112
Self-citationHow do hydrologic modeling decisions affect the portrayal of climate change impacts?
Mendoza, P. A., Clark, M., Mizukami, N., Gutmann, E. D., Arnold, J. R., Brekke, L. D., & Rajagopalan, B. (2015) · Hydrological Processes · doi:10.1002/hyp.10684 · Cited by 104
Coxon, G., Freer, J. E., Wagener, T., Odoni, N. A., & Clark, M. (2013) · Hydrological Processes · doi:10.1002/hyp.10096 · Cited by 100
Methods and Model Dependency of Extreme Event Attribution: The 2015 European Drought
Hauser, M., Gudmundsson, L., Orth, R., Jézéquel, A., Haustein, K., Vautard, R., van Oldenborgh, G. J., Wilcox, L. J., & Seneviratne, S. I. (2017) · Earth s Future · doi:10.1002/2017ef000612 · Cited by 94
Dynamic TOPMODEL: A new implementation in R and its sensitivity to time and space steps
Metcalfe, P., Beven, K. J., & Freer, J. E. (2015) · Environmental Modelling & Software · doi:10.1016/j.envsoft.2015.06.010 · Cited by 89
Smith, M. B., Koren, V., Reed, S. M., Zhang, Z., Zhang, Y., Moreda, F. G., Cui, Z., Mizukami, N., Anderson, E. A., & Cosgrove, B. A. (2011) · Journal of Hydrology · doi:10.1016/j.jhydrol.2011.08.055 · Cited by 89
de Boer‐Euser, T., Bouaziz, L. J. E., Niel, J. D., Brauer, C., Dewals, B., Drogue, G., Fenicia, F., Grelier, B., Nossent, J., Pereira, F., et al. (2017) · Hydrology and earth system sciences · doi:10.5194/hess-21-423-2017 · Cited by 73
The nature of ecological complexity: A protocol for building the narrative
Zellmer, A. J., Allen, T. F. H., & Kesseboehmer, K. (2006) · Ecological Complexity · doi:10.1016/j.ecocom.2006.06.002 · Cited by 64
Guillaume, J. H. A., Helgeson, C., Elsawah, S., Jakeman, A. J., & Kummu, M. (2017) · Water Resources Research · doi:10.1002/2017wr020609 · Cited by 49
Why discrepancies in searching the conservation biology literature matter
Calver, M., Goldman, B. D., HUTCHINGS, P. A., & Kingsford, R. T. (2017) · Biological Conservation · doi:10.1016/j.biocon.2017.06.028 · Cited by 41
Influence of Omitted Citations on the Bibliometric Statistics of the Major Manufacturing Journals
Franceschini, F., Maisano, D., & Mastrogiacomo, L. (2015) · Scientometrics · doi:10.1007/s11192-015-1583-9 · Cited by 34
The hermeneutics of ecological simulation
Peck, S. L. (2008) · Biology & Philosophy · doi:10.1007/s10539-008-9109-y · Cited by 29
The citation impact of hydrology journals
Clark, M., & Hanson, B. (2017) · Water Resources Research · doi:10.1002/2017wr021125 · Cited by 21
Science studies in physical geography: An idea whose time has come?
Wainwright, S. P. (2012) · Progress in Physical Geography Earth and Environment · doi:10.1177/0309133312450997 · Cited by 19
Please don't aim for a highly cited paper
Calver, M. (2015) · Murdoch University Research Portal · Cited by 10
Cited by
Conducting systematic literature reviews and bibliometric analyses
Linnenluecke, M. K., Marrone, M., & Singh, A. K. (2020) · Australian Journal of Management · doi:10.1177/0312896219877678 · Cited by 1,649
What Role Does Hydrological Science Play in the Age of Machine Learning?
Nearing, G. S., Kratzert, F., Sampson, A. K., Pelissier, C. S., Klotz, D., Frame, J. M., Prieto, C., & Gupta, H. V. (2021) · Water Resources Research · doi:10.1029/2020wr028091 · Cited by 894
The Future of Sensitivity Analysis: An essential discipline for systems modeling and policy support
Razavi, S., Jakeman, A., Saltelli, A., Prieur, C., Iooss, B., Borgonovo, E., Plischke, E., Lo Piano, S., Iwanaga, T., Becker, W., et al. (2021) · Environmental Modelling & Software · doi:10.1016/j.envsoft.2020.104954 · Cited by 628
Differentiable modelling to unify machine learning and physical models for geosciences
Shen, C., Appling, A. P., Gentine, P., Bandai, T., Gupta, H., Tartakovsky, A., Baity-Jesi, M., Fenicia, F., Kifer, D., Li, L., et al. (2023) · Nature Reviews Earth & Environment · doi:10.1038/s43017-023-00450-9 · Cited by 468
Irrigation in the Earth system
McDermid, S., Nocco, M., Lawston-Parker, P., Keune, J., Pokhrel, Y., Jain, M., Jägermeyr, J., Brocca, L., Massari, C., Jones, A. D., et al. (2023) · Nature Reviews Earth & Environment · doi:10.1038/s43017-023-00438-5 · Cited by 360
Metadata
- Authors
- Addor, N., & Melsen, L. A.
- Venue
- Water Resources Research
- Publisher
- American Geophysical Union (AGU)
- Published
- 2019-01
- Volume
- 55
- Issue
- 1
- Pages
- 378-390
- ISSN
- 0043-1397 (ISSN-L)
- 1944-7973
- OpenAlex
- W2902237058
- Cited by
- 286
- References
- 72
- FWCI
- 11.56
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- bronze
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.