Learning Through Case Comparisons: A Meta-Analytic Review
The DOI matches its Crossref record; 86 of the 86 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Abstract
Over the past 20 years, there has been much research on how people learn from case comparisons. This work has implemented comparison activities in a variety of different ways across a wide range of laboratory and classroom contexts. In an effort to assess the overall effectiveness of case comparisons across this diversity of implementation and contexts and to explore what variables might moderate learning outcomes, we conducted a meta-analysis of 57 experiments with 336 tests. Random effects analyses of the 336 tests revealed that case comparison activities commonly led to greater learning outcomes than other forms of case study including sequential, single case, and nonanalogous, as well as traditional instruction and control (d = .50), 95% CI [.44, .56]. Of 15 potential moderators, four variables were found to reliably moderate the effectiveness of case comparisons: the objective of the comparison, the presentation of a principle, the content, and the lag between the comparison and testing. Asking learners to find similarities between cases, providing principles after the comparisons, using perceptual content, and testing learners immediately are all associated with greater learning. We conclude with a discussion of the theoretical and practical implications of these results for cognitive theory and classroom practice.
Overview
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Self-check
Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.
The self-check needs the paper’s full text.
Citations
Cites
Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences
(1990) · Computers, Environment and Urban Systems · doi:10.1016/0198-9715(90)90050-4 · Cited by 65,269
Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences (2nd ed.).
Lachenbruch, P. A., & Cohen, J. (1989) · Journal of the American Statistical Association · doi:10.2307/2290095 · Cited by 37,395
James, W. (1913) · Henry Holt and Company eBooks · doi:10.1037/11059-000 · Cited by 25,226
The principles of psychology, Vol I.
James, W. (1890) · doi:10.1037/10538-000 · Cited by 4,514
Assessing heterogeneity in meta-analysis: Q statistic or I² index?
Huedo-Medina, T. B., Sánchez-Meca, J., Marín-Martínez, F., & Botella, J. (2006) · Psychological Methods · doi:10.1037/1082-989x.11.2.193 · Cited by 4,256
Cognitive Load Theory and Instructional Design: Recent Developments
Paas, F., Renkl, A., & Sweller, J. (2003) · Educational Psychologist · doi:10.1207/s15326985ep3801_1 · Cited by 3,041
Schema induction and analogical transfer
Gick, M. L., & Holyoak, K. J. (1983) · Cognitive Psychology · doi:10.1016/0010-0285(83)90002-6 · Cited by 3,010 · cited 8×
“…help students focus on the key features of new information (e.g., Christie & Gentner, 2010; Cummins, 1992; Gentner, Loewenstein, & Thompson, 2003; Gick & Holyoak, 1983; Mason, 2004; Mundy, Honey, & Dwyer, 2009) and generate appropriate inferences for that content Correspondence should be…”
BackgroundInfluentialMemory: A Contribution to Experimental Psychology
Ebbinghaus, H. (2013) · Annals of Neurosciences · doi:10.5214/ans.0972.7531.200408 · Cited by 2,827
(2000) · Cited by 2,779
Gick, M. L., & Holyoak, K. J. (1980) · Cognitive Psychology · doi:10.1016/0010-0285(80)90013-4 · Cited by 2,552 · cited 1×
“…situations that share the same underlying structure but differ in the specific features (Chen & Daehler, 1989; Gentner et al., 2003; Gerjets, Scheiter, & Schuh, 2008; Gick & Holyoak, 1980, 1983; Loewenstein, Thompson, & Gentner, 2003; Richland & McDonough, 2010; Schuh, Gerjets, & Scheiter, 2005).”
Bransford, J. D. (2000) · Medical Entomology and Zoology · Cited by 2,530
Structure mapping in analogy and similarity.
Gentner, D., & Markman, A. B. (1997) · American Psychologist · doi:10.1037//0003-066x.52.1.45 · Cited by 1,816
Self‐Explanations: How Students Study and Use Examples in Learning to Solve Problems
Chi, M. T. H., Bassok, M., Lewis, M. W., Reimann, P., & Glaser, R. (1989) · Cognitive Science · doi:10.1207/s15516709cog1302_1 · Cited by 1,714
Memory: A contribution to experimental psychology.
Ebbinghaus, H. (1913) · doi:10.1037/10011-000 · Cited by 1,645
Active‐Constructive‐Interactive: A Conceptual Framework for Differentiating Learning Activities
Chi, M. T. H. (2009) · Topics in Cognitive Science · doi:10.1111/j.1756-8765.2008.01005.x · Cited by 1,597
Schwartz, D. L., & Bransford, J. D. (1998) · Cognition and Instruction · doi:10.1207/s1532690xci1604_4 · Cited by 1,037
On the role of analogies and metaphors in learning science
Duit, R. (1991) · Science Education · doi:10.1002/sce.3730750606 · Cited by 921
Distributed representations of structure: A theory of analogical access and mapping.
Hummel, J. E., & Holyoak, K. J. (1997) · Psychological Review · doi:10.1037/0033-295x.104.3.427 · Cited by 910
Chapter 3: Rethinking Transfer: A Simple Proposal With Multiple Implications
BRANSFORD, J. D., & SCHWARTZ, D. L. (1999) · Review of Research in Education · doi:10.3102/0091732x024001061 · Cited by 881 · cited 4×
“In such instances, the comparison could be considered a preparation for future learning (Bransford & Schwartz, 1999).”
BackgroundInfluentialLearning and transfer: A general role for analogical encoding.
Gentner, D., Loewenstein, J., & Thompson, L. (2003) · Journal of Educational Psychology · doi:10.1037/0022-0663.95.2.393 · Cited by 865
Structure-mapping: A theoretical framework for analogy
GENTNER, D. (1983) · Cognitive Science · doi:10.1016/s0364-0213(83)80009-3 · Cited by 816 · cited 1×
“Schemas are cognitive representations of the structures or relational systems shared by cases/exemplars as have been highlighted through structural alignments (Gentner, 1983, 2010; Gick & Holyoak, 1983; Markman & Gentner, 1993; Namy & Gentner, 2002).”
Structural Alignment during Similarity Comparisons
Markman, A. B., & Gentner, D. (1993) · Cognitive Psychology · doi:10.1006/cogp.1993.1011 · Cited by 809
The Oxford Handbook of Thinking and Reasoning
(2012) · Oxford University Press eBooks · doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199734689.001.0001 · Cited by 697
Holyoak, K. J., & Thagard, P. (1997) · American Psychologist · doi:10.1037//0003-066x.52.1.35 · Cited by 629
The effects of statistical training on thinking about everyday problems
Fong, G. T., Krantz, D. H., & Nisbett, R. E. (1986) · Cognitive Psychology · doi:10.1016/0010-0285(86)90001-0 · Cited by 597
Overcoming contextual limitations on problem-solving transfer.
Catrambone, R., & Holyoak, K. J. (1989) · Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition · doi:10.1037//0278-7393.15.6.1147 · Cited by 570
A symbolic-connectionist theory of relational inference and generalization.
Hummel, J. E., & Holyoak, K. J. (2003) · Psychological Review · doi:10.1037/0033-295x.110.2.220 · Cited by 567 · cited 1×
“Prior work has shown that analogy making across multiple cases affords the opportunity of acquiring a schematic representation that includes the common features of the cases but does not include features unique to each given case (Gick & Holyoak, 1983; Hummel & Holyoak, 1997, 2003).”
BackgroundRittle-Johnson, B., & Star, J. R. (2007) · Journal of Educational Psychology · doi:10.1037/0022-0663.99.3.561 · Cited by 536
Bootstrapping the Mind: Analogical Processes and Symbol Systems
Gentner, D. (2010) · Cognitive Science · doi:10.1111/j.1551-6709.2010.01114.x · Cited by 519
DSTAT : software for the meta-analytic review of research literatures
Johnson, B. T. (1989) · Medical Entomology and Zoology · Cited by 489
Reuniting perception and conception
Goldstone, R. L., & Barsalou, L. W. (1998) · Cognition · doi:10.1016/s0010-0277(97)00047-4 · Cited by 459
Comparison and Categorization in the Development of Relational Similarity
Kotovsky, L., & Gentner, D. (1996) · Child Development · doi:10.1111/j.1467-8624.1996.tb01889.x · Cited by 457
Supporting coherence formation in learning from multiple representations
Seufert, T. (2003) · Learning and Instruction · doi:10.1016/s0959-4752(02)00022-1 · Cited by 407
Comparison in the Development of Categories
Gentner, D., & Namy, L. L. (1999) · Cognitive Development · doi:10.1016/s0885-2014(99)00016-7 · Cited by 399
Analogy and Relational Reasoning
Holyoak, K. J. (2012) · The Oxford Handbook of Thinking and Reasoning · doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199734689.013.0013 · Cited by 394
Making a silk purse out of two sow's ears: Young children's use of comparison in category learning.
Namy, L. L., & Gentner, D. (2002) · Journal of Experimental Psychology General · doi:10.1037//0096-3445.131.1.5 · Cited by 387
Systematicity as a selection constraint in analogical mapping
CLEMENT, C., & GENTNER, D. (1991) · Cognitive Science · doi:10.1016/0364-0213(91)80014-v · Cited by 305
Analogical encoding facilitates knowledge transfer in negotiation
Loewenstein, J., Thompson, L., & Gentner, D. (1999) · Psychonomic Bulletin & Review · doi:10.3758/bf03212967 · Cited by 293
Cognitive Supports for Analogies in the Mathematics Classroom
Richland, L. E., Zur, O., & Holyoak, K. J. (2007) · Science · doi:10.1126/science.1142103 · Cited by 285
Those confounded moderators in meta-analysis: good, bad, and ugly
Lipsey, M. W. (2003) · The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science · doi:10.1177/0002716202250791 · Cited by 283 · cited 1×
“As Lipsey (2003) pointed out, a great risk within metaanalysis is not to recognize when variables are confounded.”
BackgroundLearning by Analogical Bootstrapping
Kurtz, K. J., Miao, C.-H., & Gentner, D. (2001) · Journal of the Learning Sciences · doi:10.1207/s15327809jls1004new_2 · Cited by 264
Rittle-Johnson, B., Star, J. R., & Durkin, K. (2009) · Journal of Educational Psychology · doi:10.1037/a0016026 · Cited by 245
Thompson, L., Gentner, D., & Loewenstein, J. (2000) · Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes · doi:10.1006/obhd.2000.2887 · Cited by 243
Where Hypotheses Come From: Learning New Relations by Structural Alignment
Christie, S., & Gentner, D. (2010) · Journal of Cognition and Development · doi:10.1080/15248371003700015 · Cited by 240
Seeing Deep Structure From the Interactions of Surface Features
Chi, M. T. H., & VanLehn, K. A. (2012) · Educational Psychologist · doi:10.1080/00461520.2012.695709 · Cited by 225
Reviving Inert Knowledge: Analogical Abstraction Supports Relational Retrieval of Past Events
Gentner, D., Loewenstein, J., Thompson, L., & Forbus, K. D. (2009) · Cognitive Science · doi:10.1111/j.1551-6709.2009.01070.x · Cited by 218
Spatial Mapping in Preschoolers: Close Comparisons Facilitate Far Mappings
Loewenstein, J., & Gentner, D. (2001) · Journal of Cognition and Development · doi:10.1207/s15327647jcd0202_4 · Cited by 212
Motivation and Transfer: The Role of Mastery-Approach Goals in Preparation for Future Learning
Belenky, D. M., & Nokes-Malach, T. J. (2012) · Journal of the Learning Sciences · doi:10.1080/10508406.2011.651232 · Cited by 195
Self-citationScience teachers’ use of analogies: observations from classroom practice
Treagust, D. F., Duit, R. H., Joslin, P., & Lindauer, I. E. (1992) · International Journal of Science Education · doi:10.1080/0950069920140404 · Cited by 182
Analogical Learning in Negotiation Teams: Comparing Cases Promotes Learning and Transfer
Loewenstein, J., Thompson, L., & Gentner, D. (2003) · Academy of Management Learning & Education · doi:10.5465/amle.2003.9901663 · Cited by 180
Learning by analogy: Discriminating between potential analogs
Richland, L. E., & McDonough, I. M. (2009) · Contemporary Educational Psychology · doi:10.1016/j.cedpsych.2009.09.001 · Cited by 163
Context-dependent effects on analogical transfer
Spencer, R. M., & Weisberg, R. W. (1986) · Memory & Cognition · doi:10.3758/bf03197019 · Cited by 159
It pays to compare: An experimental study on computational estimation
Star, J. R., & Rittle-Johnson, B. (2009) · Journal of Experimental Child Psychology · doi:10.1016/j.jecp.2008.11.004 · Cited by 158
Rittle‐Johnson, B., & Star, J. R. (2011) · The Psychology of learning and motivation/The psychology of learning and motivation · doi:10.1016/b978-0-12-387691-1.00007-7 · Cited by 143
Role of analogical reasoning in the induction of problem categories.
Cummins, D. D. (1992) · Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition · doi:10.1037/0278-7393.18.5.1103 · Cited by 136
Kurtz, K. J., & Loewenstein, J. (2007) · Memory & Cognition · doi:10.3758/bf03193454 · Cited by 134
Effects of analogy to prior knowledge on memory for new information
Schustack, M. W., & Anderson, J. R. (1979) · Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior · doi:10.1016/s0022-5371(79)90314-1 · Cited by 114
Immediate and delayed transfer of training effects in statistical reasoning.
Fong, G. T., & Nisbett, R. E. (1991) · Journal of Experimental Psychology: General · doi:10.1037//0096-3445.120.1.34 · Cited by 113
Memory connections between thematically similar episodes.
Seifert, C. M., McKoon, G., Abelson, R. P., & Ratcliff, R. (1986) · Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition · doi:10.1037//0278-7393.12.2.220 · Cited by 113
How analogies foster learning from science texts
Iding, M. K. (1997) · Instructional Science · doi:10.1023/a:1002987126719 · Cited by 94
Developing Effective Fractions Instruction for Kindergarten Through 8th Grade
Siegler, R. S., Carpenter, T. P., Fennell, F. M., Geary, D., Lewis, J., Okamoto, Y., Thompson, L., & Wray, J. A. (2018) · KiltHub Repository · doi:10.1184/r1/6614288 · Cited by 91
The role of comparison in preschoolers’ novel object categorization
Graham, S. A., Namy, L. L., Dedre Gentner, C., & Meagher, K. (2010) · Journal of Experimental Child Psychology · doi:10.1016/j.jecp.2010.04.017 · Cited by 90
Distributed representations of structure: A theory of analogical access and mapping.
Hummel, J. E., & Holyoak, K. J. (1997) · Psychological Review · doi:10.1037//0033-295x.104.3.427 · Cited by 90
Positive and negative transfer in analogical problem solving by 6-year-old children
Chen, Z., & Daehler, M. W. (1989) · Cognitive Development · doi:10.1016/s0885-2014(89)90031-2 · Cited by 87
Proceedings of the Twenty-Eighth Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society
Hsiao, J. H., & Shillcock, R. C. (2006) · Cited by 86
Gerjets, P. H., Scheiter, K., & Schuh, J. (2007) · Educational Technology Research and Development · doi:10.1007/s11423-007-9068-z · Cited by 72
Coordinating principles and examples through analogy and self-explanation
Nokes‐Malach, T. J., VanLehn, K. A., Belenky, D. M., Lichtenstein, M., & Cox, G. E. (2012) · European Journal of Psychology of Education · doi:10.1007/s10212-012-0164-z · Cited by 71
Self-citationPublication bias in psychological science: Comment on Ferguson and Brannick (2012).
Rothstein, H. R., & Bushman, B. J. (2012) · Psychological Methods · doi:10.1037/a0027128 · Cited by 68
Short Article: Superior Discrimination between Similar Stimuli after Simultaneous Exposure
Mundy, M. E., Honey, R. C., & Dwyer, D. M. (2008) · Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology · doi:10.1080/17470210802240614 · Cited by 60
Comparison and the development of knowledge
Boroditsky, L. (2007) · Cognition · doi:10.1016/j.cognition.2002.08.001 · Cited by 50
Loewenstein, J., & Thompson, L. (2000) · Negotiation Journal · doi:10.1111/j.1571-9979.2000.tb00767.x · Cited by 49
The transition form theory to therapy: Test of two instructional methods
Michael, A. L., Klee, T., Bransford, J. D., & Warren, S. F. (1993) · Applied Cognitive Psychology · doi:10.1002/acp.2350070206 · Cited by 40
Fostering Understanding by Structural Alignment as a Route to Analogical Learning
Masón, L. (2004) · Instructional Science · doi:10.1023/b:truc.0000026512.88700.32 · Cited by 35
The role of analogy in teaching science
Weller, C. M. (1970) · Journal of Research in Science Teaching · doi:10.1002/tea.3660070207 · Cited by 34
Analogies and Their Limitations
Webb, M. J. (1985) · School Science and Mathematics · doi:10.1111/j.1949-8594.1985.tb09677.x · Cited by 34
Models as a pedagogical tool: can we learn from Maxwell?
Gee, B. (1978) · Physics Education · doi:10.1088/0031-9120/13/5/004 · Cited by 32
Goldstone, R. L., Day, S., & Son, J. Y. (2009) · On thinking · doi:10.1007/978-3-642-03129-8_7 · Cited by 32
The impact of example comparisons on schema acquisition: do learners really need multiple examples?
Scheiter, K., Gerjets, P. H., & Schuh, J. (2004) · International Conference of Learning Sciences · Cited by 19
How close is too close? Alignment and perceptual similarity in children's categorization
Namy, L. L., Dedre Gentner, C., & Clepper, L. E. (2007) · Cited by 18
Scaffolding learning from contrasting video cases
Nagarajan, A., & Hmelo‐Silver, C. E. (2006) · International Conference of Learning Sciences · Cited by 14
Does "Different" Imply a Difference? A Comparison of Two Tasks
Gentner, D., & Sagi, E. (2006) · Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of the Cognitive Science Society · Cited by 14
Analogies in teaching freshman chemistry
Lewis, J. R. (1933) · Journal of Chemical Education · doi:10.1021/ed010p627 · Cited by 12
Analogical Scaffolding in Collaborative Learning
Gadgil, S., & Nokes, T. J. (2009) · eScholarship (California Digital Library) · Cited by 12
Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Analogy
Pease, A., Guhe, M., & Smaill, A. (2009) · Cited by 11
Gerjets, P. H., Scheiter, K., & Schuh, J. (2005) · eScholarship (California Digital Library) · Cited by 8
Cited by
The power of internal feedback: Exploiting natural comparison processes
Nicol, D. (2021) · Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education · doi:10.1080/02602938.2020.1823314 · Cited by 402
“While comparison researchers offer some suggestions about instructions, these are quite limited and only relate to analogical comparisons (e.g. Alfieri, Nokes-Malach, and Schunn 2013).”
BackgroundInfluentialZepeda, C. D., Richey, J. E., Ronevich, P., & Nokes-Malach, T. J. (2015) · Journal of Educational Psychology · doi:10.1037/edu0000022 · Cited by 167
Self-citationMaking Sense of Generative Learning
Fiorella, L. (2023) · Educational Psychology Review · doi:10.1007/s10648-023-09769-7 · Cited by 135
Chow, J. C., & Ekholm, E. (2018) · Educational Psychology Review · doi:10.1007/s10648-018-9437-7 · Cited by 80
Individual preparation for collaborative learning: Systematic review and synthesis
Mende, S., Proske, A., & Narciss, S. (2021) · Educational Psychologist · doi:10.1080/00461520.2020.1828086 · Cited by 47
Metadata
- Authors
- Alfieri, L., Nokes-Malach, T. J., & Schunn, C. D.
- Venue
- Educational Psychologist
- Publisher
- Informa UK Limited
- Published
- 2013-04
- Volume
- 48
- Issue
- 2
- Pages
- 87-113
- ISSN
- 0046-1520 (ISSN-L)
- 1532-6985
- OpenAlex
- W2124645092
- Cited by
- 318
- References
- 86
- FWCI
- 23.19
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- closed
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.