Student or educator? Sign up with your school email and get 6 months of Pro free.
CoChat

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 50 of the 50 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; 19 of the 79 sources its claims cite were checked for support.

The varved succession of Crawford Lake, Milton, Ontario, Canada as a candidate Global boundary Stratotype Section and Point for the Anthropocene series

Open access

Abstract

An annually laminated succession in Crawford Lake, Ontario, Canada is proposed for the Global boundary Stratotype Section and Point (GSSP) to define the Anthropocene as a series/epoch with a base dated at 1950 CE. Varve couplets of organic matter capped by calcite precipitated each summer in alkaline surface waters reflect environmental change at global to local scales. Spheroidal carbonaceous particles and nitrogen isotopes record an increase in fossil fuel combustion in the early 1950s, coinciding with early fallout from nuclear and thermonuclear testing – 239+240 Pu and 14 C: 12 C, the latter more than compensating for the effects of old carbon in this dolomitic basin. Rapid industrial expansion in the North American Great Lakes region led to enhanced leaching of terrigenous elements by acid precipitation during the Great Acceleration, and calcite precipitation was reduced, producing thin calcite laminae around the GSSP that is marked by a sharp decline in elm pollen (Dutch Elm disease). The lack of bioturbation in well-oxygenated bottom waters, supported by the absence of fossil pigments from obligately anaerobic purple sulfur bacteria, is attributed to elevated salinities and high alkalinity below the chemocline. This aerobic depositional environment, highly unusual in a meromictic lake, inhibits the mobilization of Pu, the proposed primary stratigraphic guide for the Anthropocene.

Overview

CoChat Summary

TL;DR

The paper proposes the annually laminated (varved) succession of Crawford Lake, Ontario, Canada as a candidate Global boundary Stratotype Section and Point (GSSP) for the Anthropocene series/epoch, with a base dated to 1950 CE. It argues that the varves preserve a high-fidelity, annually resolved record of mid-20th-century global markers, especially plutonium fallout, fossil-fuel combustion particles, and radiocarbon from nuclear testing.

Key findings

  • The proposed GSSP is placed at the base of the calcite lamina deposited in summer 1950 CE in freeze core CRA22-1FR-3, at a depth of 15.6 cm; the associated stage and age name “Crawfordian” is proposed.
  • A sharp rise in 239+240Pu begins between 1948–1951 and 1950–1953 CE, continues to a peak in 1964–1967 CE, and reaches a Nuclear Age plateau by 1982–1985 CE; 240Pu/239Pu ratios from the mid-1950s–1980s range between 0.15 and 0.19, consistent with global weapons fallout.
  • Spheroidal carbonaceous particles (SCPs) rise from ~3800 g/DM in 1950–1952 to a peak of ~17,000 g/DM in 1954 CE, then decline to ~8000 g/DM by 1967 and stabilize between ~1000 and 2000 g/DM after 1980 CE; δ15N declines to a minimum in 1964–1965 CE.
  • The varves are undisturbed by bioturbation despite a well-oxygenated monimolimnion: dissolved oxygen remained above the hypoxic limit (2 mg/L) throughout the water column, with mean DO = 8.2 mg/L (range 4.6–11.4 mg/L, n = 78), and okenone from obligately anaerobic purple sulfur bacteria is absent after ~1500 CE. This oxygenated, slightly saline/alkaline bottom water is argued to inhibit Pu mobilization.

Methods

  • Freeze cores and gravity cores were collected from the deep basin of Crawford Lake in 2011, 2019, and 2022; the proposed GSSP core CRA22-1FR-3 is archived at the National Biodiversity Cryobank of Canada, and parastratotype CRA22-1FR-1 at the Royal Ontario Museum.
  • Varve chronology was anchored to the thickest white calcite lamina, assigned to 1935 CE, because core tops were not always fully recovered; analyses included AMS radiocarbon, 210Pb/137Cs gamma spectrometry, plutonium alpha spectrometry and MC-ICP-MS, SCP counting, µXRF elemental analysis, stable isotopes, fossil pigments, pollen/non-pollen palynomorphs, and siliceous microfossils.
  • Sampling followed varve boundaries in freeze cores where possible, but multiple varve years were amalgamated for some analyses depending on sample-size requirements; gravity core CL-19 was subsampled at 1 cm intervals.

Limitations

  • The paper states that core tops were not always fully recovered, so varve years were counted relative to marker laminae rather than from the top; it also notes that bulk sediment radiocarbon from core CL-2011 may retain old dolomitic carbon, attenuating the bomb pulse, and that a macrofossil measurement is probably more accurate.
  • The paper states that gravity core CL-19 cannot be discriminated at annual precision and that 1-cm subsampling mutes the mid-20th-century signature; PCBs did not exceed background, suggesting the small rural lake is not a useful repository for local persistent organic pollutants.
  • Evident from the text: the paper presents a candidate GSSP rather than a ratified boundary, and the chronology depends on the assumption that the thickest white lamina corresponds to 1935 CE.

Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1177/20530196221149281

Cites

50 of 50 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Nothing to recompute.

Figures

Figure 1. Diatoms and the rotifers that consume them were abundant in Crawford Lake during intervals of human impact (shading), recorded by the pollen of cultigens (e.g., Zea – maize and Helianthus – sunflower) and spores of their pathogens (e.g., Ustilago maydis – corn smut), and nonarboreal pollen (e.g., ragweed – Ambrosia). ×10 = ten times exaggeration of rare but significant elements in palynological preparations. Palynomorph data from Turton and McAndrews (2006), diatom data modified from Ekdahl et al. (2004) with updated taxonomic nomenclature – Lindavia intermedia = Cyclotella bodanica lemanica and Lindavia michiganiana = Cyclotella michiganiana. Diatoms identified as Synedra nana by Ekdahl et al. (2004) are likely to have been various large Fragilariaspp., including the common Fragilaria andreseniana (compare Figure 16). Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 1. Diatoms and the rotifers that consume them were abundant in Crawford Lake during intervals of human impact (shading), recorded by the pollen of cultigens (e.g., Zea – maize and Helianthus – sunflower) and spores of their pathogens (e.g., Ustilago maydis – corn smut), and nonarboreal pollen (e.g., ragweed – Ambrosia). ×10 = ten times exaggeration of rare but significant elements in palynological preparations. Palynomorph data from Turton and McAndrews (2006), diatom data modified from Ekdahl et al. (2004) with updated taxonomic nomenclature – Lindavia intermedia = Cyclotella bodanica lemanica and Lindavia michiganiana = Cyclotella michiganiana. Diatoms identified as Synedra nana by Ekdahl et al. (2004) are likely to have been various large Fragilariaspp., including the common Fragilaria andreseniana (compare Figure 16). Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 2. (a) Crawford Lake is in the Lower Great Lakes region of North America. (b) Location of the study site relative to the Niagara Escarpment and Milton Outlier (darker brown highlighting higher elevation), northeast of the industrial city of Hamilton. (c) Groundwater infiltrates hydraulically conductive units in the Silurian bedrock that transect the karstic basin of Crawford Lake at Nassagaweya Canyon (see Supplemental Figure S3). Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 2. (a) Crawford Lake is in the Lower Great Lakes region of North America. (b) Location of the study site relative to the Niagara Escarpment and Milton Outlier (darker brown highlighting higher elevation), northeast of the industrial city of Hamilton. (c) Groundwater infiltrates hydraulically conductive units in the Silurian bedrock that transect the karstic basin of Crawford Lake at Nassagaweya Canyon (see Supplemental Figure S3). Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 3. Bathymetry (from Boyko, 1973) and physical limnology of Crawford Lake. (a) The 15m isobath identifies the area below which seasonally laminated sediments accumulate and cross-sections (b, c) illustrate the small volume of the monimolimnion (darkest shading; see Figure S4 for water mass key). Measured physicochemical variables demark the water column zonation, with a permanent chemocline (~15.5 m) isolating the dense, electrically conductive monimolimnion (d) from the overlying mixolimnion. (e) Dissolved oxygen concentrations were highest in the metalimnion (lightest grey) but always exceeded the 2mg/L threshold for hypoxia in freshwater ecosystems (vertical line). Modified from Llew-Williams (2022). Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 3. Bathymetry (from Boyko, 1973) and physical limnology of Crawford Lake. (a) The 15m isobath identifies the area below which seasonally laminated sediments accumulate and cross-sections (b, c) illustrate the small volume of the monimolimnion (darkest shading; see Figure S4 for water mass key). Measured physicochemical variables demark the water column zonation, with a permanent chemocline (~15.5 m) isolating the dense, electrically conductive monimolimnion (d) from the overlying mixolimnion. (e) Dissolved oxygen concentrations were highest in the metalimnion (lightest grey) but always exceeded the 2mg/L threshold for hypoxia in freshwater ecosystems (vertical line). Modified from Llew-Williams (2022). Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 4. (a) Range of water temperature and pH required for calcite to precipitate in Crawford Lake, based on analysis of sediment traps and Langelier Saturation Index calculations. (b, c) These conditions were only met during summer and early fall in the upper 6 m of the water column. Crystals grow when they encounter Ca2+ and CO32- saturated water along the chemocline where the density contrast slows their descent until they become large enough to overcome Stokes’ Law and sink through the dense and slightly acidic monimolimnion to form the light-coloured summer varve couplet. Modified from Llew-Williams (2022). Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 4. (a) Range of water temperature and pH required for calcite to precipitate in Crawford Lake, based on analysis of sediment traps and Langelier Saturation Index calculations. (b, c) These conditions were only met during summer and early fall in the upper 6 m of the water column. Crystals grow when they encounter Ca2+ and CO32- saturated water along the chemocline where the density contrast slows their descent until they become large enough to overcome Stokes’ Law and sink through the dense and slightly acidic monimolimnion to form the light-coloured summer varve couplet. Modified from Llew-Williams (2022). Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 5. Freeze cores CRA19-2FT-1FR-A and CRA19-2FT-B2 collected from the deep basin of Crawford Lake in February 2019; see Supplemental Figure S6 for logs and images of cores CRA19-2FT-B1 and CRA19-2FT-D1. Dashed lines illustrate the ease with which varve-dated couplets can be correlated across freeze cores and the thin calcite lamina deposited in the summer of 1950 CE is indicated by the white arrow. Note that the loose sediments at the top of the cores were not recovered due to the short residence time of freeze corers in the substrate during the 2019 expedition, so varve ages were not determined by counting from the top but always with reference to the thickest white lamina assigned to 1935 CE, the warmest and driest year of the Dust Bowl interval; see Supplemental Table S1, Figure 7, and Supplemental Information for details of varve counting using high-resolution varve imaging (Supplemental Figure S9). Photo credit: K. Lafond. Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 5. Freeze cores CRA19-2FT-1FR-A and CRA19-2FT-B2 collected from the deep basin of Crawford Lake in February 2019; see Supplemental Figure S6 for logs and images of cores CRA19-2FT-B1 and CRA19-2FT-D1. Dashed lines illustrate the ease with which varve-dated couplets can be correlated across freeze cores and the thin calcite lamina deposited in the summer of 1950 CE is indicated by the white arrow. Note that the loose sediments at the top of the cores were not recovered due to the short residence time of freeze corers in the substrate during the 2019 expedition, so varve ages were not determined by counting from the top but always with reference to the thickest white lamina assigned to 1935 CE, the warmest and driest year of the Dust Bowl interval; see Supplemental Table S1, Figure 7, and Supplemental Information for details of varve counting using high-resolution varve imaging (Supplemental Figure S9). Photo credit: K. Lafond. Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 6. Composite image of a section (side-view) along core CRA19-2FT-B2 through the Canadian Zone (post-1867 CE); note curvature of horizontal varves as sediments froze onto the sampler as it sank slowly into the lakebed. The age model assumes that the thickest white lamina formed during the exceptionally warm, dry summer of 1935 CE (Lafond et al., 2022, Table S1). At this resolution, transition to and from the white “summer” layer includes substantial organic matter, whereas the center of the white layer consists almost entirely of calcite crystals. The first calcite lamina deposited during the proposed Anthropocene (1950 CE) is near the base of the lowermost of two dark intervals separated by a distinct triplet of varves dated to 1956, 1957, and 1958 CE (see Figure S9). Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 6. Composite image of a section (side-view) along core CRA19-2FT-B2 through the Canadian Zone (post-1867 CE); note curvature of horizontal varves as sediments froze onto the sampler as it sank slowly into the lakebed. The age model assumes that the thickest white lamina formed during the exceptionally warm, dry summer of 1935 CE (Lafond et al., 2022, Table S1). At this resolution, transition to and from the white “summer” layer includes substantial organic matter, whereas the center of the white layer consists almost entirely of calcite crystals. The first calcite lamina deposited during the proposed Anthropocene (1950 CE) is near the base of the lowermost of two dark intervals separated by a distinct triplet of varves dated to 1956, 1957, and 1958 CE (see Figure S9). Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 7. Composite image (side-view) of sections along the entire length of core CRA22-1FR-3, showing the position of the proposed GSSP. The uppermost enlargement allows the faint white lamina capping the 1950 CE varve year, at the base of the dark layer with almost imperceptible calcite laminae below the distinct triplet (varve ages 1956, 1957, and 1958 CE). The middle image shows the transition from reddish brown to very dark brown organic matter in the mid-19th century, when logging began. The lower enlargement illustrates the most prominent calcite laminae, deposited when an agricultural settlement was established during the Medieval Warm Interval (Llew-Williams et al., in revision). Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 7. Composite image (side-view) of sections along the entire length of core CRA22-1FR-3, showing the position of the proposed GSSP. The uppermost enlargement allows the faint white lamina capping the 1950 CE varve year, at the base of the dark layer with almost imperceptible calcite laminae below the distinct triplet (varve ages 1956, 1957, and 1958 CE). The middle image shows the transition from reddish brown to very dark brown organic matter in the mid-19th century, when logging began. The lower enlargement illustrates the most prominent calcite laminae, deposited when an agricultural settlement was established during the Medieval Warm Interval (Llew-Williams et al., in revision). Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 8. Section of core CL-2011, photographed during subsampling for radiocarbon analysis in 2018. This core was analyzed using micro-XRF and for additional palynological information including SCPs in “pollen slides,” with age model based on varve imagery (see Supplemental Information). Photo credit: F. McCarthy. Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 8. Section of core CL-2011, photographed during subsampling for radiocarbon analysis in 2018. This core was analyzed using micro-XRF and for additional palynological information including SCPs in “pollen slides,” with age model based on varve imagery (see Supplemental Information). Photo credit: F. McCarthy. Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 9. Activities of total 210Pb and 137Cs and associated counting error measured approximately every 1 cm from the CL-19 gravity core measured by gamma spectroscopy (Supplemental Table S2). The modelled ages are based on a constant rate of supply model on the estimated unsupported 210Pb activity constrained to a tie point at 23 cm (the Ambrosia rise, that was set at 1830 CE ± 20 years). Background (supported) 210Pb activities were estimated from the mean of the bottommost 7 samples for total 210Pb activities in the CL-19 core (14.8 Bq/Kg ± 3.2) which was similar to the tail of the total 210Pb activity in this core (10.8 Bq/Kg ± 10.7, n=7). The correspondence of the 137Cs peak in the early 1960s CE supports the age estimates of the CRS model (Supplemental Table S3). Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 9. Activities of total 210Pb and 137Cs and associated counting error measured approximately every 1 cm from the CL-19 gravity core measured by gamma spectroscopy (Supplemental Table S2). The modelled ages are based on a constant rate of supply model on the estimated unsupported 210Pb activity constrained to a tie point at 23 cm (the Ambrosia rise, that was set at 1830 CE ± 20 years). Background (supported) 210Pb activities were estimated from the mean of the bottommost 7 samples for total 210Pb activities in the CL-19 core (14.8 Bq/Kg ± 3.2) which was similar to the tail of the total 210Pb activity in this core (10.8 Bq/Kg ± 10.7, n=7). The correspondence of the 137Cs peak in the early 1960s CE supports the age estimates of the CRS model (Supplemental Table S3). Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 10. The rapid decline in Ulmus, marking the effects of Dutch elm disease, regionally identifies the base of the proposed Anthropocene series/ epoch (compare with varve-age dated pollen spectra over the last millennium, Supplemental Figure S11). The pollen zonation reveals the much lower rates of sediment accumulation between the intervals of human impact on the Crawford Lake catchment indicated by stippling. An anomalous peak in pine pollen (Pinus) followed by a peak in early successional taxa such as birch (Betula) suggests disturbance during the Little Ice Age, probably by fire. This anomaly was also identified in a freeze core record by McAndrews and Turton (2010) in sediments dating to the early 18th century. Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 10. The rapid decline in Ulmus, marking the effects of Dutch elm disease, regionally identifies the base of the proposed Anthropocene series/ epoch (compare with varve-age dated pollen spectra over the last millennium, Supplemental Figure S11). The pollen zonation reveals the much lower rates of sediment accumulation between the intervals of human impact on the Crawford Lake catchment indicated by stippling. An anomalous peak in pine pollen (Pinus) followed by a peak in early successional taxa such as birch (Betula) suggests disturbance during the Little Ice Age, probably by fire. This anomaly was also identified in a freeze core record by McAndrews and Turton (2010) in sediments dating to the early 18th century. Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 11. Anthropogenic radiogenic signatures in varved sediments from Crawford Lake, calendar year using varve chronology (Table S1, Figure S9) with horizontal line identifying 1950 CE. (a) Values of F14C in bulk sediment from core CRA19-2FT-1FR-A and macrofossils from core CL-2011 (Table 2) compare well with atmospheric 14C concentration (Hua et al., 2022). In addition to old carbon found in DOC and POC throughout the water column (Table S5), bulk sediment samples from core CL-2011 probably retain some dolomitic old carbon because of incomplete digestion. Nonetheless, values of F14C > 1 were measured through the post-bomb era, identifying the “bomb pulse” of artificially created radiocarbon. (b) Activity of 239+240Pu (with counting error) in sediments subsampled by varve age from core CRA19-2FT-D1, supplemented by Pu material from core CRA19-2FT-B2 mirrors the global signature of atmospheric deposition of plutonium from above-ground nuclear testing (United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation (UNSCEAR), 2000). Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 11. Anthropogenic radiogenic signatures in varved sediments from Crawford Lake, calendar year using varve chronology (Table S1, Figure S9) with horizontal line identifying 1950 CE. (a) Values of F14C in bulk sediment from core CRA19-2FT-1FR-A and macrofossils from core CL-2011 (Table 2) compare well with atmospheric 14C concentration (Hua et al., 2022). In addition to old carbon found in DOC and POC throughout the water column (Table S5), bulk sediment samples from core CL-2011 probably retain some dolomitic old carbon because of incomplete digestion. Nonetheless, values of F14C > 1 were measured through the post-bomb era, identifying the “bomb pulse” of artificially created radiocarbon. (b) Activity of 239+240Pu (with counting error) in sediments subsampled by varve age from core CRA19-2FT-D1, supplemented by Pu material from core CRA19-2FT-B2 mirrors the global signature of atmospheric deposition of plutonium from above-ground nuclear testing (United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation (UNSCEAR), 2000). Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 12. SCPs in core CRA19-2FT-B2. (a) Concentrations increase sharply between 1948 and 1954 CE. (b) Particles larger than 10 µm occur throughout, while smaller particles gradually increase in abundance after 1945 CE. The decline in SCPs larger than 25 µm coincides with closure of the lumber mill at Crawford Lake in 1900 CE. The proposed base of the Anthropocene is shown at 1950 as a solid horizontal line. Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 12. SCPs in core CRA19-2FT-B2. (a) Concentrations increase sharply between 1948 and 1954 CE. (b) Particles larger than 10 µm occur throughout, while smaller particles gradually increase in abundance after 1945 CE. The decline in SCPs larger than 25 µm coincides with closure of the lumber mill at Crawford Lake in 1900 CE. The proposed base of the Anthropocene is shown at 1950 as a solid horizontal line. Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 13. Organic proxies in sediments subsampled by varve age from core CRA19-2FT-D1, supplemented by material from core CRA19-2FT-B2. Sharply depleted values of δ15N mark the proposed base of the Anthropocene epoch (1950 – horizontal line). High values of TN and TOC are in dark calcite-poor sediments that characterise the 1950s and 1960s (see Figures 5, 14), attributed to acidic precipitation. Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 13. Organic proxies in sediments subsampled by varve age from core CRA19-2FT-D1, supplemented by material from core CRA19-2FT-B2. Sharply depleted values of δ15N mark the proposed base of the Anthropocene epoch (1950 – horizontal line). High values of TN and TOC are in dark calcite-poor sediments that characterise the 1950s and 1960s (see Figures 5, 14), attributed to acidic precipitation. Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 14. Laminae visible in the original core photo (Figure 6) superimposed on the ITRAX-generated RBG scan allow sediment geochemistry determined using µXRF analysis of freeze core CL-2011 to be related directly to the varved sediments. Peaks in activity attributed to Cu and Pb peak around the proposed base of the Anthropocene where SPCs rich in these metals are abundant (see Figure 12). Peaks in activity attributed to Ca align with prominent light-coloured laminae (with prominent laminae deposited during the summers of 1956, 1957 and 1958 CE identified across the diagram by dashed lines) whereas peaks in terrigenous elements, such as Fe, K and Ti in dark layers record enhanced leaching of the catchment. Compare the µXRF record in the upper 20 cm of gravity core CL-19 (Figure S21). Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 14. Laminae visible in the original core photo (Figure 6) superimposed on the ITRAX-generated RBG scan allow sediment geochemistry determined using µXRF analysis of freeze core CL-2011 to be related directly to the varved sediments. Peaks in activity attributed to Cu and Pb peak around the proposed base of the Anthropocene where SPCs rich in these metals are abundant (see Figure 12). Peaks in activity attributed to Ca align with prominent light-coloured laminae (with prominent laminae deposited during the summers of 1956, 1957 and 1958 CE identified across the diagram by dashed lines) whereas peaks in terrigenous elements, such as Fe, K and Ti in dark layers record enhanced leaching of the catchment. Compare the µXRF record in the upper 20 cm of gravity core CL-19 (Figure S21). Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 15. Summary fossil pigment concentrations in core CL-19 – note the absence of okenone above 38 cm, recording the unusual absence of anoxia in this meromictic lake since the early 16th century. The ratio of chlorophyll a (not plotted individually) to pheophytin a (Chla : pheoa ratio) suggests poor preservation in the sample from 35 cm where an anomalous peak in resistant and readily transported pine pollen was identified (see Figure 10). Gray shading identifies intervals of human impact, Indigenous and colonial-Canadian. Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 15. Summary fossil pigment concentrations in core CL-19 – note the absence of okenone above 38 cm, recording the unusual absence of anoxia in this meromictic lake since the early 16th century. The ratio of chlorophyll a (not plotted individually) to pheophytin a (Chla : pheoa ratio) suggests poor preservation in the sample from 35 cm where an anomalous peak in resistant and readily transported pine pollen was identified (see Figure 10). Gray shading identifies intervals of human impact, Indigenous and colonial-Canadian. Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 16. Summary of analysis of siliceous microfossils at annual resolution from core CRA19-2FT-D1. Stratigraphically constrained cluster analysis identified three zones, with Zone B defined by a decline in the planktonic diatoms Lindavia michiganiana and Fragilaria crotonensis that dominated Zone C and sharp increases in non-planktonic taxa such as Achnanthidium spp. Significant dissimilarity was also noted around 1950 CE (solid line), primarily in the scaled chrysophyte record, with several species of Synura dominating assemblages in the upper part of zone B. Modified from Marshall et al. (2023). Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 16. Summary of analysis of siliceous microfossils at annual resolution from core CRA19-2FT-D1. Stratigraphically constrained cluster analysis identified three zones, with Zone B defined by a decline in the planktonic diatoms Lindavia michiganiana and Fragilaria crotonensis that dominated Zone C and sharp increases in non-planktonic taxa such as Achnanthidium spp. Significant dissimilarity was also noted around 1950 CE (solid line), primarily in the scaled chrysophyte record, with several species of Synura dominating assemblages in the upper part of zone B. Modified from Marshall et al. (2023). Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 17. Summary of key Anthropocene markers and the synchronous ecosystem response recorded by siliceous microfossils around 1950 CE in varve-age dated samples from freeze cores from the deep basin of Crawford Lake. Abundant SCPs and depleted δ15N values record increased fossil fuel combustion following the Second World War, when plutonium fallout first appears in varved sediment. The increase in non-planktonic diatoms and the scaled chrysophyte genus Synura across the proposed Anthropocene GSSP (marked by horizontal line) begins in the 1940s and declines through the 1970s, as do the physical Anthropocene markers. Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 17. Summary of key Anthropocene markers and the synchronous ecosystem response recorded by siliceous microfossils around 1950 CE in varve-age dated samples from freeze cores from the deep basin of Crawford Lake. Abundant SCPs and depleted δ15N values record increased fossil fuel combustion following the Second World War, when plutonium fallout first appears in varved sediment. The increase in non-planktonic diatoms and the scaled chrysophyte genus Synura across the proposed Anthropocene GSSP (marked by horizontal line) begins in the 1940s and declines through the 1970s, as do the physical Anthropocene markers. Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 18. Summary of key Anthropocene markers in freeze core CL-2011. The proposed base of the Anthropocene (1950 CE, shown by horizontal line) is marked by high XRF activity attributed to terrigenous elements (e.g., titanium) in calcite-poor sediments and a sharp increase in concentration of SCPs in palynological preparations. The radiocarbon ‘bomb pulse’ coincides with the sharp decline in Ulmus pollen resulting from Dutch elm disease. Reforestation also helps identify the late 20th century, as do several non-pollen palynomorphs, such as loricae of the chrysophyte Dinobryon divergens and the rotifer Keratella quadrata, almost unknown from earlier sediments from Crawford Lake. Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 18. Summary of key Anthropocene markers in freeze core CL-2011. The proposed base of the Anthropocene (1950 CE, shown by horizontal line) is marked by high XRF activity attributed to terrigenous elements (e.g., titanium) in calcite-poor sediments and a sharp increase in concentration of SCPs in palynological preparations. The radiocarbon ‘bomb pulse’ coincides with the sharp decline in Ulmus pollen resulting from Dutch elm disease. Reforestation also helps identify the late 20th century, as do several non-pollen palynomorphs, such as loricae of the chrysophyte Dinobryon divergens and the rotifer Keratella quadrata, almost unknown from earlier sediments from Crawford Lake. Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central
Figure 19. Summary of key Anthropocene markers plotted against depth in gravity core CL-19. a) Increases in terrigenous elements and non-arboreal pollen (NAP) identify two distinct intervals of human impact on Crawford Lake, highlighted by stippling. The decline in elm pollen (Ulmus) and increase in 137Cs activity identify the mid-20th century, when increased fossil fuel combustion produced a sharp increase in SCP concentration in palynological preparations. b) Fossil pigments and algal palynomorphs record an increase in green algae and the chrysophyte Dinobryon divergenssince the mid-20th century, recording a slight increase in overall primary productivity. The absence of the fossil pigment okenone confirms the well-oxygenated water column in this unusual meromictic lake since the early 16th century. Reproduced in color in online version.
Figure 19. Summary of key Anthropocene markers plotted against depth in gravity core CL-19. a) Increases in terrigenous elements and non-arboreal pollen (NAP) identify two distinct intervals of human impact on Crawford Lake, highlighted by stippling. The decline in elm pollen (Ulmus) and increase in 137Cs activity identify the mid-20th century, when increased fossil fuel combustion produced a sharp increase in SCP concentration in palynological preparations. b) Fossil pigments and algal palynomorphs record an increase in green algae and the chrysophyte Dinobryon divergenssince the mid-20th century, recording a slight increase in overall primary productivity. The absence of the fossil pigment okenone confirms the well-oxygenated water column in this unusual meromictic lake since the early 16th century. Reproduced in color in online version.CC BY-NC · PubMed Central

Verification

Claims the paper makes

16 Valid · 2 Not valid · 49 Not checked · 121 Own results and interpretations

90 more claims · 1 with their cited sources checked

Create a free account to see all 188 claims and to verify the 3 references still open.

See all claims — free account
  • It may state two separate claims as one. 68
  • Probably not a substantial claim. 34

Create a free account to see these claims.

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

Each contradiction between two passages listed here was confirmed by an independent check.

3 of 3

Citations

Cites

Show all 48 references

Research works printed but not linked: 11

  1. Battarbee RW, 2001, Tracking Environmental Change Using Lake Sediments, Vol. 3: Terrestrial, Algal, and Siliceous Indicators, 55
  2. Boyko-Diakonow M, 1979, Moraines and Varves, 303
  3. Boyko M, 1973, European impact on the vegetation around Crawford Lake in Southern Ontario
  4. Byrne R, 1998, Iroquoian Peoples of the Land of Rocks and Water A.D. 1000–1650: A Study in Settlement Archaeology, 94
  5. Finlayson WD, 1973, Bulletin (Canadian Archaeological Association), 5, 134
  6. Karrow PF, 1987, Ontario Geological Survey Report, 255, 94
  7. Llew-Williams B, 2022, The hydrological and limnological characterization of two Canadian water catchments sensitive to anthropogenic influences: Crawford Lake, Ontario and Old Crow Flats, Yukon
  8. Llew-Williams BM, McCarthy FMG, Krueger AM, et al. (in revision) Varve formation in meromictic Crawford Lake, Ontario, Canada: Important process for characterizing the Anthropocene epoch. In revision to Journal of Paleolimnology
  9. McAndrews JH, 1994, Great Lakes Archaeology and Paleoecology: Exploring Interdisciplinary Initiatives for the Nineties, 179
  10. McAndrews JH, 1989, Quaternary Geology of Canada and Greenland, Geology of Canada, 1, 528
  11. McCarthy FMG, 2021, TMS Special Publication SP511, Applications of Non-pollen Palynomorphs from Palaeoenvironmental Reconstructions to Biostratigraphy

Cited by

See all 160

Metadata

Authors
McCarthy, F. M., Patterson, R. T., Head, M. J., Riddick, N. L., Cumming, B. F., Hamilton, P. B., Pisaric, M. F., Gushulak, A. C., Leavitt, P. R., Lafond, K. M., Llew-Williams, B., Marshall, M., Heyde, A., Pilkington, P. M., Moraal, J., Boyce, J. I., Nasser, N. A., Walsh, C., Garvie, M., Roberts, S., Rose, N. L., Cundy, A. B., Gaca, P., Milton, A., Hajdas, I., Crann, C. A., Boom, A., Finkelstein, S. A., & McAndrews, J. H.
Affiliations
  • Brock University (CA)
  • Carleton University (CA)
  • Queen's University (CA)
  • Canadian Museum of Nature (CA)
  • University of Regina, Canada
  • University of Regina (CA)
  • McMaster University (CA)
  • University College London (GB)
  • University of Southampton, UK
  • University of Southampton (GB)
  • ETH Zurich (CH)
  • University of Ottawa (CA)
  • University of Leicester (GB)
  • University of Toronto (CA)
Corresponding author
McCarthy, Francine MG
Venue
The Anthropocene Review
Published
2023-02-16
Volume
10
Issue
1
Pages
146-176
ISSN
  • 2053-0196 (ISSN-L)
  • 2053-020X
OpenAlex
W4321095461
Cited by
160
References
48
Citations by year
2026: 24 · 2025: 75 · 2024: 40 · 2023: 21
FWCI
17.63
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Locations
  • The Anthropocene Review (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by-nc)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
  • ePrints Soton (University of Southampton) (submittedVersion)
  • UCL Discovery (University College London) (submittedVersion)
  • Figshare (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc)
Funders
  • Kulturveranstaltungen des Bundes in Berlin
  • Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada
Topics
  • Physical Sciences › Earth and Planetary Sciences › Atmospheric Science › Geology and Paleoclimatology Research
  • Physical Sciences › Earth and Planetary Sciences › Paleontology › Paleontology and Stratigraphy of Fossils
  • Life Sciences › Agricultural and Biological Sciences › Soil Science › Soil and Environmental Studies
Keywords
Anthropocene, GSSP, Crawford Lake, varved lake sediments, annually laminated sediments, Great Acceleration, fossil fuel combustion, plutonium-239,240, radioactive fallout, carbon-14, nitrogen isotopes, spheroidal carbonaceous particles, acid rain, Dutch elm disease, purple sulfur bacteria, bioturbation, meromictic lakes, Great Lakes, calcite precipitation

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

The claim verdicts this report counts are experimental: their accuracy is not yet measured.

A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-10-10, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).

A second model labelled each claim on 2026-10-10 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).

Cited sources are checked with a language model’s help (gpt-6-sol).

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: The varved succession of Crawford Lake, Milton, Ontario, Canada as a candidate Global boundary Stratotype Section and Point for the Anthropocene series. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1177/20530196221149281
The paper
McCarthy, F. M., Patterson, R. T., Head, M. J., Riddick, N. L., Cumming, B. F., Hamilton, P. B., Pisaric, M. F., Gushulak, A. C., Leavitt, P. R., Lafond, K. M., Llew-Williams, B., Marshall, M., Heyde, A., Pilkington, P. M., Moraal, J., Boyce, J. I., Nasser, N. A., Walsh, C., Garvie, M., . . . McAndrews, J. H. (2023). The varved succession of Crawford Lake, Milton, Ontario, Canada as a candidate Global boundary Stratotype Section and Point for the Anthropocene series. The Anthropocene Review. https://doi.org/10.1177/20530196221149281

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.