Student or educator? Sign up with your school email and get 6 months of Pro free.

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 122 of the 123 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; 29 of the 75 sources its claims cite were checked for support.

Nitrogen and phosphorus stress as a tool to induce lipid production in microalgae

Open access
Maltsev, Yevhen, Kulikovskiy, Maxim, Maltseva, Svetlana · 2023 · Microbial Cell Factories

Abstract

Review/meta-analysis of nitrogen and phosphorus restriction experiments to increase lipid productivity in microalgae.

Overview

CoChat Summary

TL;DR

This review/systematic analysis compiles 301 experiments to assess how nitrogen and phosphorus restriction affects lipid content and productivity across microalgal taxonomic and ecological groups. It proposes standardized N and P supply ranges and concludes that responses are highly group-, species-, and strain-specific, complicating direct comparison across studies.

Key findings

  • Across nutrient media and modifications, nitrogen ranged from 0 to 0.494 g L−1, phosphorus from 0.0003 to 0.227 g L−1, and N:P from 0.12:1 to 823.33:1; the paper proposes categories: replete -N >0.4, moderate -N 0.4–0.2, moderate N-limitation 0.19–0.1, strong N-limitation <0.1, without nitrogen 0; replete -P >0.2, moderate -P 0.2–0.02, moderate P-limitation 0.019–0.01, strong P-limitation <0.01, without phosphorus 0.
  • PCA showed different relationships among lipid content/productivity, N, P, N:P, light, and cultivation time for Cyanobacteria, Heterokontophyta/Ochrophyta, Chlorophyta, Dinophyta, Haptophyta, and marine vs freshwater/terrestrial groups; some species increased lipids under N/P deprivation while others decreased or showed no change.
  • In *Chlorella vulgaris*, 38 experiments showed lipid content from 5.9 to 67.1% DW and lipid productivity from 5.0 to 204.9 mg L−1 day−1, with a general trend of decreasing lipid content as nitrogen increased, but different strains did not show identical lipid amounts or productivity at the same nitrogen concentration.
  • Promising biodiesel candidates listed include *Ankistrodesmus falcatus*, *Ankistrodesmus fusiformis*, *Chlorella sorokiniana*, *Chlorella vulgaris*, *Cylindrotheca fusiformis*, *Diacronema lutheri*, *Ettlia oleoabundans*, *Microchloropsis salina*, *Microcystis aeruginosa*, *Nannochloropsis granulata*, *Nannochloropsis oceanica*, *Nannochloropsis oculata*, *Phaeodactylum tricornutum*, *Prymnesium parvum*, *Rebecca salina*, *Tetradesmus deserticola*, *Tetradesmus obliquus*, *Tetraselmis suecica*, *Vischeria magna*, and *Vischeria vischeri*.

Methods

  • Data were collected from publications on batch cultures of microalgae grown with varying nitrogen and phosphorus, recording taxonomy, culture conditions, light intensity, medium, N/P source and concentration, growth rate, and experiment duration; 301 experiments were included.
  • Principal component analysis (PCA) was used to examine relationships among lipid content, lipid productivity, N, P, N:P ratio, cultivation time, and light intensity, with calculations and plotting in Statistica ver.12.0.
  • A separate PCA and trend analysis was performed for *Chlorella vulgaris* using 38 experiments with nitrogen concentrations from 0 to 0.494 g L−1.

Limitations

  • The paper states that no single approach is used to determine experimental N and P concentrations, preventing correct interpretation and potentially leading to erroneous conclusions; terminology for N/P deficiency also differs across publications.
  • The paper notes scarce data for Rhodophyta and Cryptophyta, limited information for heterocytic Cyanobacteria, and that growth-rate information was not always available for species accumulating lipids over 50% DW.
  • Evident from the text: this is a synthesis of heterogeneous published experiments rather than a controlled new experiment, PCA identifies associations but not causation, and incomplete records were excluded from some analyses.

Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1186/s12934-023-02244-6

Cites

122 of 122 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Nothing to recompute.

Figures

Fig. 1 Projection of the studied variables and observations onto the factorial plane PC 1 and PC 2 for Cyanobacteria. Indicators (variables): light intensity (µmol photons m− 2 s− 1); cultivation time (days); lipid content (% DW); lipid productivity (mg L− 1 day− 1); total nitrogen (g L− 1); total phosphorus (g L− 1); N:P (unit). Observations: species or strain numbers (circles): Arthrospira platensis (1–4); Arthrospira platensis NIOF17/003 (5); Microcystis aeruginosa (6, 16, 17); Microcystis aeruginosa CACIAM08 (7–13); Microcystis aeruginosa NPCD-1 (14, 15); Oscillatoria sp. PBGA3 (18); Synechococcus elongatus PCC7942 (19); Synechocystis sp. CACIAM05 (20–26); Synechocystis sp. MH01 (27); Tolypothrix sp. PBGA1 (28); Tolypothrix sp. PBGA2 (29); Trichormus sp. CENA77 (30). Group A: species and strains representing filamentous Cyanobacteria (Arthrospira, Oscillatoria, Tolypothrix). Group B: species and strains representing coccoid Cyanobacteria (Microcystis, Synechococcus, Synechocystis). Red circles (here and further) unite species and strains of microalgae, which are characterised by general patterns (groups A, B) in the coordinate space specified by PC 1 and PC 2
Fig. 1 Projection of the studied variables and observations onto the factorial plane PC 1 and PC 2 for Cyanobacteria. Indicators (variables): light intensity (µmol photons m− 2 s− 1); cultivation time (days); lipid content (% DW); lipid productivity (mg L− 1 day− 1); total nitrogen (g L− 1); total phosphorus (g L− 1); N:P (unit). Observations: species or strain numbers (circles): Arthrospira platensis (1–4); Arthrospira platensis NIOF17/003 (5); Microcystis aeruginosa (6, 16, 17); Microcystis aeruginosa CACIAM08 (7–13); Microcystis aeruginosa NPCD-1 (14, 15); Oscillatoria sp. PBGA3 (18); Synechococcus elongatus PCC7942 (19); Synechocystis sp. CACIAM05 (20–26); Synechocystis sp. MH01 (27); Tolypothrix sp. PBGA1 (28); Tolypothrix sp. PBGA2 (29); Trichormus sp. CENA77 (30). Group A: species and strains representing filamentous Cyanobacteria (Arthrospira, Oscillatoria, Tolypothrix). Group B: species and strains representing coccoid Cyanobacteria (Microcystis, Synechococcus, Synechocystis). Red circles (here and further) unite species and strains of microalgae, which are characterised by general patterns (groups A, B) in the coordinate space specified by PC 1 and PC 2CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 2 Projection of the studied variables and observations onto the factorial plane PC 1 and PC 2 for Heterokontophyta/Ochrophyta. Indicators (variables): light intensity (µmol photons m− 2 s− 1); cultivation time (days); lipid content (% DW); lipid productivity (mg L− 1 day− 1); total nitrogen (g L− 1); total phosphorus (g L− 1); N:P (unit). Observations: species or strain numbers (circles): Chaetoceros muelleri (1); Chaetoceros calcitrans (2); Cylindrotheca fusiformis (3, 4); Phaeodactylum tricornutum (5–7); Phaeodactylum tricornutum CCMP 2561 (8); Skeletonema costatum (9); Skeletonema sp. (10); Thalassiosira pseudonana (11); Vischeria magna (12); Vischeria vischeri (13–16); Vischeria cf. polyphem (17–24); Monodopsis subterranea UTEX 151 (25); Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M26 (26); Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M28 (27); Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M29 (28); Microchloropsis gaditana CCMP527 (29); Nannochloropsis granulata CCMP525 (30); Nannochloropsis limnetica CCMP505 (31); Nannochloropsis oceanica 805 (32); Nannochloropsis oceanica CCMP1779 (33); Nannochloropsis oceanica CCMP531 (34); Nannochloropsis oceanica IMET1 (35); Nannochloropsis oculata (36–38); Nannochloropsis oculata CCMP529 (39); Microchloropsis salina CCMP1176 (40); Microchloropsis salina CCMP537 (41); Nannochloropsis sp. (42–44); Nannochloropsis sp. CS 246 (45); Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M24 (46); Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M27 (47); Ellipsoidion sp. (48). Group A: Vischeria species. Group B: Eustigmatophyceae, Xanthophyceae and Bacillariophyceae species
Fig. 2 Projection of the studied variables and observations onto the factorial plane PC 1 and PC 2 for Heterokontophyta/Ochrophyta. Indicators (variables): light intensity (µmol photons m− 2 s− 1); cultivation time (days); lipid content (% DW); lipid productivity (mg L− 1 day− 1); total nitrogen (g L− 1); total phosphorus (g L− 1); N:P (unit). Observations: species or strain numbers (circles): Chaetoceros muelleri (1); Chaetoceros calcitrans (2); Cylindrotheca fusiformis (3, 4); Phaeodactylum tricornutum (5–7); Phaeodactylum tricornutum CCMP 2561 (8); Skeletonema costatum (9); Skeletonema sp. (10); Thalassiosira pseudonana (11); Vischeria magna (12); Vischeria vischeri (13–16); Vischeria cf. polyphem (17–24); Monodopsis subterranea UTEX 151 (25); Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M26 (26); Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M28 (27); Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M29 (28); Microchloropsis gaditana CCMP527 (29); Nannochloropsis granulata CCMP525 (30); Nannochloropsis limnetica CCMP505 (31); Nannochloropsis oceanica 805 (32); Nannochloropsis oceanica CCMP1779 (33); Nannochloropsis oceanica CCMP531 (34); Nannochloropsis oceanica IMET1 (35); Nannochloropsis oculata (36–38); Nannochloropsis oculata CCMP529 (39); Microchloropsis salina CCMP1176 (40); Microchloropsis salina CCMP537 (41); Nannochloropsis sp. (42–44); Nannochloropsis sp. CS 246 (45); Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M24 (46); Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M27 (47); Ellipsoidion sp. (48). Group A: Vischeria species. Group B: Eustigmatophyceae, Xanthophyceae and Bacillariophyceae speciesCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 3 Projection of the studied variables and observations onto the factorial plane PC 1 and PC 2 for Chlorophyta. Indicators (variables): light intensity (µmol photons m− 2 s− 1); cultivation time (days); lipid content (% DW); lipid productivity (mg L− 1 day− 1); total nitrogen (g L− 1); total phosphorus (g L− 1); N:P (unit). Observations: species or strain numbers (circles): Tetradesmus dissociatus (1); Ankistrodesmus fusiformis (2); Ankistrodesmus falcatus (3–5); Chlamydocapsa bacillus (6); Chlamydomonadales sp. TGA3 (7); Chlamydomonadales sp. TGA5 (8); Chlamydomonas sp. (9); Mychonastes homosphaera (10–11); Chlorella sorokiniana (12); Chlorella sp. (13); Chlorella sp. MRA-1 (14); Chlorella sp. PGA2 (15); Chlorella sp. TGA2 (16); Chlorella sp. TGA4 (17); Chlorella vulgaris (18–22); Chlorella vulgaris CCAP 211/11B (23); Chlorella vulgaris F&M-M49 (24); Chlorella vulgaris AG10032 (25); Chlorella vulgaris CCAP 211 (26–28); Chlorella vulgaris UTEX 395 (29, 30); Chlorella vulgaris CCAP 211/11B (31–35); Chlorococcum sp. (36); Chromochloris zofingiensis (37, 38); Coelastrum microporum (39); Desmodesmus brasiliensis (40); Hindakia tetrachotoma ME03 (41); Hindakia tetrachotoma PGA1 (42); Kirchneriella lunaris (43); Micractinium sp. ME05(44); Ettlia oleoabundans (45, 46); Ettlia oleoabundans REF2 (47); Raphidocelis subcapitata (48); Tetradesmus obliquus (49–53); Desmodesmus communis (54, 55); Scenedesmus sp. (56–58); Scenedesmus sp. DM (59); Scenedesmus sp. ME02 (60); Tetraselmis chuii (61); Tetraselmis gracilis (62); Tetraselmis sp. (63); Tetraselmis striata BBRR1 (64); Tetraselmis suecica (65–67); Tetraselmis suecica F&M-M33 (68); Tetraselmis suecica F&M-M35 (69); Tetraselmis tetrathele (70)
Fig. 3 Projection of the studied variables and observations onto the factorial plane PC 1 and PC 2 for Chlorophyta. Indicators (variables): light intensity (µmol photons m− 2 s− 1); cultivation time (days); lipid content (% DW); lipid productivity (mg L− 1 day− 1); total nitrogen (g L− 1); total phosphorus (g L− 1); N:P (unit). Observations: species or strain numbers (circles): Tetradesmus dissociatus (1); Ankistrodesmus fusiformis (2); Ankistrodesmus falcatus (3–5); Chlamydocapsa bacillus (6); Chlamydomonadales sp. TGA3 (7); Chlamydomonadales sp. TGA5 (8); Chlamydomonas sp. (9); Mychonastes homosphaera (10–11); Chlorella sorokiniana (12); Chlorella sp. (13); Chlorella sp. MRA-1 (14); Chlorella sp. PGA2 (15); Chlorella sp. TGA2 (16); Chlorella sp. TGA4 (17); Chlorella vulgaris (18–22); Chlorella vulgaris CCAP 211/11B (23); Chlorella vulgaris F&M-M49 (24); Chlorella vulgaris AG10032 (25); Chlorella vulgaris CCAP 211 (26–28); Chlorella vulgaris UTEX 395 (29, 30); Chlorella vulgaris CCAP 211/11B (31–35); Chlorococcum sp. (36); Chromochloris zofingiensis (37, 38); Coelastrum microporum (39); Desmodesmus brasiliensis (40); Hindakia tetrachotoma ME03 (41); Hindakia tetrachotoma PGA1 (42); Kirchneriella lunaris (43); Micractinium sp. ME05(44); Ettlia oleoabundans (45, 46); Ettlia oleoabundans REF2 (47); Raphidocelis subcapitata (48); Tetradesmus obliquus (49–53); Desmodesmus communis (54, 55); Scenedesmus sp. (56–58); Scenedesmus sp. DM (59); Scenedesmus sp. ME02 (60); Tetraselmis chuii (61); Tetraselmis gracilis (62); Tetraselmis sp. (63); Tetraselmis striata BBRR1 (64); Tetraselmis suecica (65–67); Tetraselmis suecica F&M-M33 (68); Tetraselmis suecica F&M-M35 (69); Tetraselmis tetrathele (70)CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 4 Projection of the studied variables and observations onto the factorial plane PC 1 and PC 2 for Dinophyta and Haptophyta. Indicators (variables): light intensity (µmol photons m− 2 s− 1); cultivation time (days); lipid content (% DW); lipid productivity (mg L− 1 day− 1); total nitrogen (g L− 1); total phosphorus (g L− 1); N:P (unit). Observations: species or strain numbers (circles): Akashiwo sanguinea (1); Alexandrium affine (2); Polykrikos geminatum (3); Prorocentrum minimum strain a (4); Prorocentrum minimum strain b (5); Prorocentrum triestinum strain a (6); Prorocentrum triestinum strain b (7); Scrippsiella rotunda (8); Isochrysis aff. galbana clone T-Iso CCAP 927/14 (9); Isochrysis galbana (10); Isochrysis sp. (11–13); Isochrysis sp. (T-ISO) CS 177 (14); Isochrysis sp. F&M-M37 (15); Diacronema lutheri CS 182 (16); Rebecca salina CS 49 (17); Pavlova sp. (18, 19)
Fig. 4 Projection of the studied variables and observations onto the factorial plane PC 1 and PC 2 for Dinophyta and Haptophyta. Indicators (variables): light intensity (µmol photons m− 2 s− 1); cultivation time (days); lipid content (% DW); lipid productivity (mg L− 1 day− 1); total nitrogen (g L− 1); total phosphorus (g L− 1); N:P (unit). Observations: species or strain numbers (circles): Akashiwo sanguinea (1); Alexandrium affine (2); Polykrikos geminatum (3); Prorocentrum minimum strain a (4); Prorocentrum minimum strain b (5); Prorocentrum triestinum strain a (6); Prorocentrum triestinum strain b (7); Scrippsiella rotunda (8); Isochrysis aff. galbana clone T-Iso CCAP 927/14 (9); Isochrysis galbana (10); Isochrysis sp. (11–13); Isochrysis sp. (T-ISO) CS 177 (14); Isochrysis sp. F&M-M37 (15); Diacronema lutheri CS 182 (16); Rebecca salina CS 49 (17); Pavlova sp. (18, 19)CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 5 Projection of the studied variables and observations onto the factorial plane PC 1 and PC 2 for marine microalgae. Indicators (variables): light intensity (µmol photons m− 2 s− 1); cultivation time (days); lipid content (% DW); lipid productivity (mg L− 1 day− 1); total nitrogen (g L− 1); total phosphorus (g L− 1); N:P (unit). Group A: Porphyridium purpureum; Akashiwo sanguinea; Alexandrium affine; Polykrikos geminatum; Prorocentrum cordatum (strains a, b); Prorocentrum triestinum (strains a, b); Scrippsiella rotunda; Isochrysis aff. galbana clone T-Iso CCAP 927/14; Isochrysis galbana; Isochrysis sp.; Isochrysis sp. (T-ISO) CS 177; Isochrysis sp. F&M-M37; Diacronema lutheri CS 182; Rebecca salina CS 49; Chaetoceros muelleri; Chaetoceros calcitrans; Phaeodactylum tricornutum; Phaeodactylum tricornutum CCMP 2561; Skeletonema costatum; Skeletonema sp.; Thalassiosira pseudonana; Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M26; Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M28; Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M29; Nannochloropsis oceanica CCMP1779; Nannochloropsis oculate; Nannochloropsis sp. CS 246; Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M24; Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M27; Ellipsoidion sp.; Tetraselmis chuii; Tetraselmis gracilis; Tetraselmis sp.; Tetraselmis striata BBRR1; Tetraselmis suecica; Tetraselmis suecica F&M-M33; Tetraselmis suecica F&M-M35; Tetraselmis tetrathele. Group B: Microchloropsis gaditana CCMP527; Nannochloropsis granulata CCMP525; Nannochloropsis oceanica 805; Nannochloropsis oceanica CCMP1779; Nannochloropsis oceanica CCMP531; Nannochloropsis oceanica IMET1; Nannochloropsis oculate; Nannochloropsis oculata CCMP529; Microchloropsis salina CCMP1176; Microchloropsis salina CCMP537. Group C: Arthrospira platensis; Arthrospira platensis NIOF17/003; Isochrysis sp.; Pavlova sp.; Cylindrotheca fusiformis; Phaeodactylum tricornutum; Nannochloropsis sp.; Tetraselmis suecica
Fig. 5 Projection of the studied variables and observations onto the factorial plane PC 1 and PC 2 for marine microalgae. Indicators (variables): light intensity (µmol photons m− 2 s− 1); cultivation time (days); lipid content (% DW); lipid productivity (mg L− 1 day− 1); total nitrogen (g L− 1); total phosphorus (g L− 1); N:P (unit). Group A: Porphyridium purpureum; Akashiwo sanguinea; Alexandrium affine; Polykrikos geminatum; Prorocentrum cordatum (strains a, b); Prorocentrum triestinum (strains a, b); Scrippsiella rotunda; Isochrysis aff. galbana clone T-Iso CCAP 927/14; Isochrysis galbana; Isochrysis sp.; Isochrysis sp. (T-ISO) CS 177; Isochrysis sp. F&M-M37; Diacronema lutheri CS 182; Rebecca salina CS 49; Chaetoceros muelleri; Chaetoceros calcitrans; Phaeodactylum tricornutum; Phaeodactylum tricornutum CCMP 2561; Skeletonema costatum; Skeletonema sp.; Thalassiosira pseudonana; Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M26; Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M28; Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M29; Nannochloropsis oceanica CCMP1779; Nannochloropsis oculate; Nannochloropsis sp. CS 246; Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M24; Nannochloropsis sp. F&M-M27; Ellipsoidion sp.; Tetraselmis chuii; Tetraselmis gracilis; Tetraselmis sp.; Tetraselmis striata BBRR1; Tetraselmis suecica; Tetraselmis suecica F&M-M33; Tetraselmis suecica F&M-M35; Tetraselmis tetrathele. Group B: Microchloropsis gaditana CCMP527; Nannochloropsis granulata CCMP525; Nannochloropsis oceanica 805; Nannochloropsis oceanica CCMP1779; Nannochloropsis oceanica CCMP531; Nannochloropsis oceanica IMET1; Nannochloropsis oculate; Nannochloropsis oculata CCMP529; Microchloropsis salina CCMP1176; Microchloropsis salina CCMP537. Group C: Arthrospira platensis; Arthrospira platensis NIOF17/003; Isochrysis sp.; Pavlova sp.; Cylindrotheca fusiformis; Phaeodactylum tricornutum; Nannochloropsis sp.; Tetraselmis suecicaCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 6 Projection of the studied variables and observations onto the factorial plane PC 1 and 2 for freshwater (and terrestrial) microalgae. Indicators (variables): light intensity (µmol photons m− 2 s− 1); cultivation time (days); lipid content (% DW); lipid productivity (mg L− 1 day− 1); total nitrogen (g L− 1); total phosphorus (g L− 1); N:P (unit). Group A: Microcystis aeruginosa CACIAM08; Synechocystis sp. CACIAM05; Trichormus sp. CENA77; Ankistrodesmus fusiformis; Ankistrodesmus falcatus; Chlamydocapsa bacillus; Chlamydomonadales sp. TGA3; Chlamydomonas sp.; Mychonastes homosphaera; Chlorella sorokiniana; Chlorella sp. TGA2; Chlorella sp. TGA4; Chlorella vulgaris; Chlorella vulgaris CCAP 211/11B; Chlorella vulgaris CCAP 211; Chlorella vulgaris UTEX 395; Chlorella vulgaris CCAP 211/11B; Chromochloris zofingiensis; Coelastrum microporum; Desmodesmus brasiliensis; Ettlia oleoabundans; Ettlia oleoabundans REF2; Hindakia tetrachotoma PGA1; Kirchneriella lunaris; Raphidocelis subcapitata; Scenedesmus sp.; Tetradesmus obliquus. Group B: Vischeria magna; Vischeria vischeri; Vischeria cf. polyphem. Group C: Microcystis aeruginosa; Microcystis aeruginosa NPCD-1; Oscillatoria sp. PBGA3; Synechococcus elongatus PCC7942; Synechocystis sp. MH01; Tolypothrix sp. PBGA1, Tolypothrix sp. PBGA2; Monodopsis subterranea UTEX 151; Nannochloropsis limnetica CCMP505; Chlorella sp.; Chlorella sp. MRA-1; Chlorella sp. PGA2; Chlorella vulgaris; Chlorella vulgaris F&M-M49; Chlorella vulgaris AG10032; Chlorococcum sp.; Desmodesmus communis; Hindakia tetrachotoma ME03; Micractinium sp. ME05; Scenedesmus sp. DM; Scenedesmus sp. ME02; Tetradesmus dissociates; Tetradesmus obliquus
Fig. 6 Projection of the studied variables and observations onto the factorial plane PC 1 and 2 for freshwater (and terrestrial) microalgae. Indicators (variables): light intensity (µmol photons m− 2 s− 1); cultivation time (days); lipid content (% DW); lipid productivity (mg L− 1 day− 1); total nitrogen (g L− 1); total phosphorus (g L− 1); N:P (unit). Group A: Microcystis aeruginosa CACIAM08; Synechocystis sp. CACIAM05; Trichormus sp. CENA77; Ankistrodesmus fusiformis; Ankistrodesmus falcatus; Chlamydocapsa bacillus; Chlamydomonadales sp. TGA3; Chlamydomonas sp.; Mychonastes homosphaera; Chlorella sorokiniana; Chlorella sp. TGA2; Chlorella sp. TGA4; Chlorella vulgaris; Chlorella vulgaris CCAP 211/11B; Chlorella vulgaris CCAP 211; Chlorella vulgaris UTEX 395; Chlorella vulgaris CCAP 211/11B; Chromochloris zofingiensis; Coelastrum microporum; Desmodesmus brasiliensis; Ettlia oleoabundans; Ettlia oleoabundans REF2; Hindakia tetrachotoma PGA1; Kirchneriella lunaris; Raphidocelis subcapitata; Scenedesmus sp.; Tetradesmus obliquus. Group B: Vischeria magna; Vischeria vischeri; Vischeria cf. polyphem. Group C: Microcystis aeruginosa; Microcystis aeruginosa NPCD-1; Oscillatoria sp. PBGA3; Synechococcus elongatus PCC7942; Synechocystis sp. MH01; Tolypothrix sp. PBGA1, Tolypothrix sp. PBGA2; Monodopsis subterranea UTEX 151; Nannochloropsis limnetica CCMP505; Chlorella sp.; Chlorella sp. MRA-1; Chlorella sp. PGA2; Chlorella vulgaris; Chlorella vulgaris F&M-M49; Chlorella vulgaris AG10032; Chlorococcum sp.; Desmodesmus communis; Hindakia tetrachotoma ME03; Micractinium sp. ME05; Scenedesmus sp. DM; Scenedesmus sp. ME02; Tetradesmus dissociates; Tetradesmus obliquusCC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 7 The amount of lipids in different strains of Chlorella vulgaris when cultivated in media with different nitrogen content. The nitrogen content was calculated as NO3-N g L− 1. For known strains, their original names were used; the rest were divided into two groups: NS, natural strains; LS, laboratory strains of personal collections. NS and LS strains from the same work have the same number. Slash numbering was used to distinguish between different experiments with these strains. List of strains and sources: NS 1/1, NS 1/2, NS 1/3, NS 1/4 [104]; NS 2/1, NS 2/2 [34]; NS 3/1, NS 3/2, NS 3/3, NS 3/4, NS 3/5, NS 3/6 [99]; LS 1/1, LS 1/2, LS 1/3, LS 71/4, LS 1/5 [105]; LS 2/1, LS 2/2, LS 2/3 [106]; LS 3 [82]; UTEX 395 [93]; NS 4 [107]; CCAP 211/11B [68]; LS 4 [108]; CCAP 211 [109]; LS 5 [110]; NS 5 [111]; CCAP 211/11B [103]; F&M-M49 [103]; AG10032 [112]
Fig. 7 The amount of lipids in different strains of Chlorella vulgaris when cultivated in media with different nitrogen content. The nitrogen content was calculated as NO3-N g L− 1. For known strains, their original names were used; the rest were divided into two groups: NS, natural strains; LS, laboratory strains of personal collections. NS and LS strains from the same work have the same number. Slash numbering was used to distinguish between different experiments with these strains. List of strains and sources: NS 1/1, NS 1/2, NS 1/3, NS 1/4 [104]; NS 2/1, NS 2/2 [34]; NS 3/1, NS 3/2, NS 3/3, NS 3/4, NS 3/5, NS 3/6 [99]; LS 1/1, LS 1/2, LS 1/3, LS 71/4, LS 1/5 [105]; LS 2/1, LS 2/2, LS 2/3 [106]; LS 3 [82]; UTEX 395 [93]; NS 4 [107]; CCAP 211/11B [68]; LS 4 [108]; CCAP 211 [109]; LS 5 [110]; NS 5 [111]; CCAP 211/11B [103]; F&M-M49 [103]; AG10032 [112]CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 8 Productivity of lipids of different strains of Chlorella vulgaris during cultivation in media with different nitrogen content. Compiled from Converti et al. [109], Rodolfi et al. [103], Griffiths et al. [93], Mujtaba et al. [112], Abdo et al. [111], Hamedi et al. [110], Sonkar & Mallick [34], Wong et al. [68]. Nitrogen content calculated as NO3-N g L− 1
Fig. 8 Productivity of lipids of different strains of Chlorella vulgaris during cultivation in media with different nitrogen content. Compiled from Converti et al. [109], Rodolfi et al. [103], Griffiths et al. [93], Mujtaba et al. [112], Abdo et al. [111], Hamedi et al. [110], Sonkar & Mallick [34], Wong et al. [68]. Nitrogen content calculated as NO3-N g L− 1CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 9 Projection of the studied variables and observations onto the factorial plane PC 1 and PC 2 for strains of Chlorella vulgaris. Indicators (variables): light intensity (µmol photons m− 2 s− 1); cultivation time (days); lipid content (% DW); lipid productivity (mg L− 1 day− 1); total nitrogen (g L− 1); total phosphorus (g L− 1); N:P (unit). Observations: species or strain numbers: Chlorella vulgaris (5); Group A: Chlorella vulgaris CCAP 211 (9–11); Chlorella vulgaris CCAP 211/11B (14–18); Group B: Chlorella vulgaris (1, 2); Chlorella vulgaris UTEX 395 (12, 13); Group C: Chlorella vulgaris (3, 4); Chlorella vulgaris CCAP 211/11B (6); Chlorella vulgaris F&M-M49 (7); Chlorella vulgaris AG10032 (8)
Fig. 9 Projection of the studied variables and observations onto the factorial plane PC 1 and PC 2 for strains of Chlorella vulgaris. Indicators (variables): light intensity (µmol photons m− 2 s− 1); cultivation time (days); lipid content (% DW); lipid productivity (mg L− 1 day− 1); total nitrogen (g L− 1); total phosphorus (g L− 1); N:P (unit). Observations: species or strain numbers: Chlorella vulgaris (5); Group A: Chlorella vulgaris CCAP 211 (9–11); Chlorella vulgaris CCAP 211/11B (14–18); Group B: Chlorella vulgaris (1, 2); Chlorella vulgaris UTEX 395 (12, 13); Group C: Chlorella vulgaris (3, 4); Chlorella vulgaris CCAP 211/11B (6); Chlorella vulgaris F&M-M49 (7); Chlorella vulgaris AG10032 (8)CC BY · PubMed Central

Verification

Claims the paper makes

16 Valid · 6 Not valid · 16 Not checked · 127 Own results and interpretations

91 more claims · 3 with their cited sources checked

Create a free account to see all 165 claims and to verify the 5 references still open.

See all claims — free account
  • It may state two separate claims as one. 52
  • Probably not a substantial claim. 18
  • The quote only partly states this claim. 2

Create a free account to see these claims.

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

Each contradiction between two passages listed here was confirmed by an independent check.

4 of 4

Cited works that were retracted

Works this paper cites that were later retracted, from the retraction notices publishers deposit. Major when the notice came out before this paper was published.

1 of 1

Citations

Cites

1 retracted

Show all 123 references

Research works printed but not linked: 12

  1. Sen S, Satpati GG. CRISPR mediated lipid enhancement in microalgae. Res J Biotechnol. 2021;16(1):213–9.
  2. Saseendran SK, Saramma AV. Optimization and effect of culture medium and concentration on the growth and biochemical composition of marine microalga- Nannochloropsis salina. Int J Curr Res Life Sci. 2018;7:2013–9.
  3. Kamyab H, Lee CT, Din MFM, Mohamad SEP, Khudhair AB, Maslahaiti Roudi A. Biodiesel production from microalgae – Chlorella sorokoniana. Aust J Basic & Appl Sci. 2014;8(3):140–5.
  4. Kadhim DAH, Abbood HAN, Al-Essawi AY, Mardan AJ, Kadhim HF. Estimation of lipids content for some algal species isolated from different regions in Al-Najaf city under different conditions. Plant Arch. 2020;20(2):4035–42.
  5. He S-S, Gao B-Y, Huang L-D, LI A-F, Zhang C-W. Growth and oil-production characteristics of Eustigmatos vischeri Hibberd under different cultivation modes. Plant Sci J. 2016;34(2):289–98. https://doi.org/10.11913/PSJ.2095-0837.2016.20289. · doi:10.11913/psj.2095-0837.2016.20289
  6. Battah M, El-Ayoty Y, Abomohra AE-F, El-Ghany SA, Esmael A. Optimization of growth and lipid production of the chlorophyte microalga Chlorella vulgaris as a feedstock for biodiesel production. World Appl Scien J. 2013;28(11):1536–43. https://doi.org/10.5829/idosi.wasj.2013.28.11.1918. · doi:10.5829/idosi.wasj.2013.28.11.1918
  7. Abdo SM, Ahmed E, El-Enin SA, El Din RS, Diwani GE, Ali G. Growth rate and fatty acids profile of 19 microalgal strains isolated from River Nile for biodiesel production. J Algal Biomass Utln. 2013;4(4):51–9.
  8. Kassim TI, Al-Saadi HA, Al-Lami AA, Alwan YA. Spatial and seasonal variation at phytoplankton in Qadisia Lake, Iraq. IAEC Sci J. 1999;1:99–111.
  9. Bischoff HW, Bold HC. Some soil algae from Enchanted Rock and related algal species. In: Bischoff HW, Bold HC, editors. Phycological studies IV. Austoin: University of Texas Publication; 1963. p. 6318.
  10. Walne PR. Studies on the food value of nineteen genera of algae to juvenile bivalves of the genera Ostrea, Crassostrea, Mercenaria, and Mytilus. Fish Invest. 1970;26:1–62.
  11. Zarrouk C. Contribution à l’étude d’une cyanophycée.Influence de divers facteurs physiques et chimiques sur lacroissance et photosynthèse de Spirulina maxima Geitler. University of Paris: Ph.D. Thesis;1966.
  12. Zolotaryova OK, Shnyukova EI, Sivash OO, Mykhaylenko NF. Perspectives use of microalgae in biotechnology. Kyiv: Alterpress; 2008.

Cited by

See all 174

Metadata

Authors
Maltsev, Y., Kulikovskiy, M., & Maltseva, S.
Affiliations
Timiryazev Institute of Plant Physiology (RU)
Corresponding author
Maltsev, Yevhen
Venue
Microbial Cell Factories
Published
2023-11-20
Volume
22
Issue
1
Pages
239-239
ISSN
1475-2859 (ISSN-L)
OpenAlex
W4388815796
Cited by
174
References
123
Citations by year
2026: 88 · 2025: 57 · 2024: 28 · 2023: 1
FWCI
2.66
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Licence
Locations
  • Microbial Cell Factories (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
  • DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) (submittedVersion, cc-by-sa)
Funders
  • Russian Science Foundation (23-74-10081)
  • Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Russian Federation (122042700045-3)
Topics
  • Physical Sciences › Energy › Renewable Energy, Sustainability and the Environment › Algal biology and biofuel production
  • Physical Sciences › Environmental Science › Environmental Chemistry › Aquatic Ecosystems and Phytoplankton Dynamics
  • Life Sciences › Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology › Molecular Biology › Microbial Metabolic Engineering and Bioproduction
Keywords
microalgae, lipid production, nitrogen limitation, phosphorus limitation, nutritional stress, N:P ratio, lipid productivity, biodiesel feedstock, phosphorus supply, cyanobacteria, dinoflagellates, red algae, green algae, light intensity, phosphorus sources
MeSH terms
Lipids, Nitrogen, Phosphorus, Biomass, Biofuels, Stramenopiles, Microalgae

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

The claim verdicts this report counts are experimental: their accuracy is not yet measured.

A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-10-10, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).

A second model labelled each claim on 2026-10-10 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).

Cited sources are checked with a language model’s help (gpt-6-sol).

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Nitrogen and phosphorus stress as a tool to induce lipid production in microalgae. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1186/s12934-023-02244-6
The paper
Maltsev, Y., Kulikovskiy, M., & Maltseva, S. (2023). Nitrogen and phosphorus stress as a tool to induce lipid production in microalgae. Microbial Cell Factories. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12934-023-02244-6

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.