Mapping Differentiation under Mixed Culture Conditions Reveals a Tunable Continuum of T Cell Fates
Open accessThe DOI matches its Crossref record; 56 of the 56 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Abstract
Cell differentiation is typically directed by external signals that drive opposing regulatory pathways. Studying differentiation under polarizing conditions, with only one input signal provided, is limited in its ability to resolve the logic of interactions between opposing pathways. Dissection of this logic can be facilitated by mapping the system's response to mixtures of input signals, which are expected to occur in vivo, where cells are simultaneously exposed to various signals with potentially opposing effects. Here, we systematically map the response of naïve T cells to mixtures of signals driving differentiation into the Th1 and Th2 lineages. We characterize cell state at the single cell level by measuring levels of the two lineage-specific transcription factors (T-bet and GATA3) and two lineage characteristic cytokines (IFN-γ and IL-4) that are driven by these transcription regulators. We find a continuum of mixed phenotypes in which individual cells co-express the two lineage-specific master regulators at levels that gradually depend on levels of the two input signals. Using mathematical modeling we show that such tunable mixed phenotype arises if autoregulatory positive feedback loops in the gene network regulating this process are gradual and dominant over cross-pathway inhibition. We also find that expression of the lineage-specific cytokines follows two independent stochastic processes that are biased by expression levels of the master regulators. Thus, cytokine expression is highly heterogeneous under mixed conditions, with subpopulations of cells expressing only IFN-γ, only IL-4, both cytokines, or neither. The fraction of cells in each of these subpopulations changes gradually with input conditions, reproducing the continuous internal state at the cell population level. These results suggest a differentiation scheme in which cells reflect uncertainty through a continuously tuneable mixed phenotype combined with a biased stochastic decision rather than a binary phenotype with a deterministic decision.
Overview
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Figures






Verification
Claims the paper makes
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Claims other papers make about this one
Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?
The cited source says what the claim attributes to it.
In the citing paper
“These factors may not only be the discrete categories that are often assumed when classifying cells into major types4,30,94 but may also represent a continuous spectrum1, or a combination of discrete and continuous categories36,95–97,227.”
From Revealing the vectors of cellular identity with single-cell genomics (2016) · cites this paper as [97]
The check wasn’t confident either way, so it gives no verdict — never disputed.
In the citing paper
“Several studies inferred the cell cycle phase of individual cells from single-cell RNA-seq data30,35,97,99, relying on transcriptional signatures of discrete phases from earlier bulk profiling experiments146.”
From Revealing the vectors of cellular identity with single-cell genomics (2016) · cites this paper as [97]
Experimental — accuracy not yet measuredIn the citing paper
“In pathological settings, especially cancer97,130,131, such hybrid states may reflect either transitions (below) or the intrinsic abnormal mixture of different functional modules (N.Y., A.R. and colleagues130).”
From Revealing the vectors of cellular identity with single-cell genomics (2016) · cites this paper as [97]
In the citing paper
“even when a cell population partitions into discrete types, hybrid cells—single cells that are a mix of two or more types—may be observed95,97”
From Revealing the vectors of cellular identity with single-cell genomics (2016) · cites this paper as [97]
In the citing paper
“single-cell profiles provide a near-continuous sampling and show high conservation across cell types and species30,97,99”
From Revealing the vectors of cellular identity with single-cell genomics (2016) · cites this paper as [97]
2 more claims about this paper
Create a free account to see every claim other papers make about this one.
Self-check
Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.
The self-check needs the paper’s full text.
Citations
Cites
Fuzzy Logic with Engineering Applications
Ross, T. J. (2010) · Wiley eBooks · doi:10.1002/9781119994374 · Cited by 6,597
Differentiation of Effector CD4 T Cell Populations
Zhu, J., Yamane, H., & Paul, W. E. (2010) · Annual Review of Immunology · doi:10.1146/annurev-immunol-030409-101212 · Cited by 3,452
Bendall, S. C., Simonds, E. F., Qiu, P., Amir, E.-A. D., Krutzik, P. O., Finck, R., Bruggner, R. V., Melamed, R., Trejo, A., Ornatsky, O. I., et al. (2011) · Science · doi:10.1126/science.1198704 · Cited by 2,279
Self-citationPlasticity of CD4+ T Cell Lineage Differentiation
Zhou, L., Chong, M. M. W., & Littman, D. R. (2009) · Immunity · doi:10.1016/j.immuni.2009.05.001 · Cited by 1,551
Induction and effector functions of TH17 cells
Bettelli, E., Korn, T., Oukka, M., & Kuchroo, V. K. (2008) · Nature · doi:10.1038/nature07036 · Cited by 1,216
Kattman, S. J., Witty, A. D., Gagliardi, M., Dubois, N. C., Niapour, M., Hotta, A., Ellis, J., & Keller, G. (2011) · Cell Stem Cell · doi:10.1016/j.stem.2010.12.008 · Cited by 1,159
Wei, G., Wei, L., Zhu, J., Zang, C., Hu-Li, J., Yao, Z., Cui, K., Kanno, Y., Roh, T.-Y., Watford, W. T., et al. (2009) · Immunity · doi:10.1016/j.immuni.2008.12.009 · Cited by 1,152
Transcriptome-wide noise controls lineage choice in mammalian progenitor cells
Chang, H. H., Hemberg, M., Barahona, M., Ingber, D. E., & Huang, S. (2008) · Nature · doi:10.1038/nature06965 · Cited by 1,092
Th17 and regulatory T cells in mediating and restraining inflammation
Littman, D. R., & Rudensky, A. Y. (2010) · Cell · doi:10.1016/j.cell.2010.02.021 · Cited by 1,039
Multistability in the lactose utilization network of Escherichia coli
Ozbudak, E. M., Thattai, M., Lim, H. N., Shraiman, B. I., & van Oudenaarden, A. (2004) · Nature · doi:10.1038/nature02298 · Cited by 1,030 · cited 1×
“Finally, multistability is expected to result in either a multimodal population at transition points, or increased levels of noise in intermediate expression levels [34,35].”
BackgroundAn extracellular matrix microarray for probing cellular differentiation
Flaim, C. J., Chien, S., & Bhatia, S. N. (2005) · Nature Methods · doi:10.1038/nmeth736 · Cited by 803
Linking Stochastic Dynamics to Population Distribution: An Analytical Framework of Gene Expression
Friedman, N., Cai, L., & Xie, X. S. (2006) · Physical Review Letters · doi:10.1103/physrevlett.97.168302 · Cited by 700 · cited 1×
“Finally, multistability is expected to result in either a multimodal population at transition points, or increased levels of noise in intermediate expression levels [34,35].”
BackgroundSelf-citationGene function in mouse embryogenesis: get set for gastrulation
Tam, P. P. L., & Loebel, D. A. F. (2007) · Nature Reviews Genetics · doi:10.1038/nrg2084 · Cited by 602
Diversification of haematopoietic stem cells to specific lineages
Orkin, S. H. (2000) · Nature Reviews Genetics · doi:10.1038/35049577 · Cited by 565
Bifurcation dynamics in lineage-commitment in bipotent progenitor cells
Huang, S., Guo, Y.-P., May, G., & Enver, T. (2007) · Developmental Biology · doi:10.1016/j.ydbio.2007.02.036 · Cited by 560
Newell, E. W., Sigal, N., Bendall, S. C., Nolan, G. P., & Davis, M. M. (2012) · Immunity · doi:10.1016/j.immuni.2012.01.002 · Cited by 555
Th1 and Th2 subsets: paradigms lost?
Kelso, A. (1995) · Immunology Today · doi:10.1016/0167-5699(95)80004-2 · Cited by 472
Hegazy, A. N., Peine, M., Helmstetter, C., Panse, I., Fröhlich, A., Bergthaler, A., Flatz, L., Pinschewer, D. D., Radbruch, A., & Löhning, M. (2010) · Immunity · doi:10.1016/j.immuni.2009.12.004 · Cited by 340
Stem Cell States, Fates, and the Rules of Attraction
Enver, T., Pera, M., Peterson, C., & Andrews, P. W. (2009) · Cell Stem Cell · doi:10.1016/j.stem.2009.04.011 · Cited by 323
Heterogeneity of Embryonic and Adult Stem Cells
Graf, T., & Stadtfeld, M. (2008) · Cell Stem Cell · doi:10.1016/j.stem.2008.10.007 · Cited by 302
RNA sequencing reveals two major classes of gene expression levels in metazoan cells
Hebenstreit, D., Fang, M., Gu, M., Charoensawan, V., van Oudenaarden, A., & Teichmann, S. A. (2011) · Molecular Systems Biology · doi:10.1038/msb.2011.28 · Cited by 289
Schulz, E. G., Mariani, L., Radbruch, A., & Höfer, T. (2009) · Immunity · doi:10.1016/j.immuni.2009.03.013 · Cited by 279
Yagi, R., Zhu, J., & Paul, W. E. (2011) · International Immunology · doi:10.1093/intimm/dxr029 · Cited by 250
Soen, Y., Mori, A., Palmer, T. D., & Brown, P. O. (2006) · Molecular Systems Biology · doi:10.1038/msb4100076 · Cited by 224
Drug interactions modulate the potential for evolution of resistance
Michel, J.-B., Yeh, P. J., Chait, R., Moellering, R. C., & Kishony, R. (2008) · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences · doi:10.1073/pnas.0800944105 · Cited by 215
Hume, D. A. (2000) · Blood · doi:10.1182/blood.v96.7.2323 · Cited by 210
Combinatorial Signaling Microenvironments for Studying Stem Cell Fate
Flaim, C. J., Teng, D., Chien, S., & Bhatia, S. N. (2008) · Stem Cells and Development · doi:10.1089/scd.2007.0085 · Cited by 195
Hematopoietic development: a balancing act
Cantor, A. B., & Orkin, S. H. (2001) · Current Opinion in Genetics & Development · doi:10.1016/s0959-437x(00)00226-4 · Cited by 191
Understanding gene circuits at cell-fate branch points for rational cell reprogramming
Zhou, J. X., & Huang, S. (2011) · Trends in Genetics · doi:10.1016/j.tig.2010.11.002 · Cited by 186
A network model for the control of the differentiation process in Th cells
Mendoza, L. (2006) · Biosystems · doi:10.1016/j.biosystems.2005.10.004 · Cited by 174
Elson, L. H., Nutman, T. B., Metcalfe, D. D., & Prussin, C. (1995) · The Journal of Immunology · doi:10.4049/jimmunol.154.9.4294 · Cited by 167
The lineage commitment of haemopoietic progenitor cells
Cross, M. A., & Enver, T. (1997) · Current Opinion in Genetics & Development · doi:10.1016/s0959-437x(97)80007-x · Cited by 166
Heterogeneity of single cell cytokine gene expression in clonal T cell populations.
Bucy, R. P., Panoskaltsis-Mortari, A., Huang, G. Q., Li, J., Karr, L., Ross, M., Russell, J. H., Murphy, K. M., & Weaver, C. T. (1994) · The Journal of experimental medicine · doi:10.1084/jem.180.4.1251 · Cited by 166
Regulation of IL-4 Expression by Activation of Individual Alleles
Rivière, I., Sunshine, M. J., & Littman, D. R. (1998) · Immunity · doi:10.1016/s1074-7613(00)80604-4 · Cited by 164
Cross-talk and decision making in MAP kinase pathways
McClean, M. N., Mody, A., Broach, J. R., & Ramanathan, S. (2007) · Nature Genetics · doi:10.1038/ng1957 · Cited by 159
Diverse Two-Dimensional Input Functions Control Bacterial Sugar Genes
Kaplan, S., Bren, A., Zaslaver, A., Dekel, E., & Alon, U. S. (2008) · Molecular Cell · doi:10.1016/j.molcel.2008.01.021 · Cited by 155
Peine, M., Rausch, S., Helmstetter, C., Fröhlich, A., Hegazy, A. N., Kühl, A. A., Grevelding, C. G., Höfer, T., Hartmann, S., & Löhning, M. (2013) · PLoS Biology · doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.1001633 · Cited by 151
Yates, A. J., Callard, R. E., & Stark, J. (2004) · Journal of Theoretical Biology · doi:10.1016/j.jtbi.2004.06.013 · Cited by 147
Roeder, I., & Glauche, I. (2006) · Journal of Theoretical Biology · doi:10.1016/j.jtbi.2006.01.021 · Cited by 142
Chickarmane, V. S., Enver, T., & Peterson, C. (2009) · PLoS Computational Biology · doi:10.1371/journal.pcbi.1000268 · Cited by 127
Sustained signaling by canonical helper T cell cytokines throughout the reactive lymph node
Perona‐Wright, G., Mohrs, K., & Mohrs, M. (2010) · Nature Immunology · doi:10.1038/ni.1866 · Cited by 114
Kelso, A., Groves, P., Troutt, A. B., & Francis, K. G. (1995) · European Journal of Immunology · doi:10.1002/eji.1830250506 · Cited by 92
Hong, T., Xing, J., Li, L., & Tyson, J. J. (2011) · PLoS Computational Biology · doi:10.1371/journal.pcbi.1002122 · Cited by 89
Generation, Persistence, and Modulation of Th0 Effector Cells: Role of Autocrine IL-4 and IFN-γ
Miner, K. T., & Croft, M. (1998) · The Journal of Immunology · doi:10.4049/jimmunol.160.11.5280 · Cited by 85
Mariani, L., Schulz, E. G., Lexberg, M. H., Helmstetter, C., Radbruch, A., Löhning, M., & Höfer, T. (2010) · Molecular Systems Biology · doi:10.1038/msb.2010.13 · Cited by 83
Probabilistic Regulation of IL-4 Production in Th2 Cells
Guo, L., Hu‐Li, J., & Paul, W. E. (2004) · Immunity · doi:10.1016/s1074-7613(04)00025-1 · Cited by 80
Transcriptional control networks of cell differentiation: insights from helper T lymphocytes
Mariani, L., Löhning, M., Radbruch, A., & Höfer, T. (2004) · Progress in Biophysics and Molecular Biology · doi:10.1016/j.pbiomolbio.2004.02.007 · Cited by 79
Generation, persistence, and modulation of Th0 effector cells: role of autocrine IL-4 and IFN-gamma.
Miner, K. T., & Croft, M. (1998) · PubMed · Cited by 68
Huang, S. (2010) · PLoS Biology · doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.1000380 · Cited by 67
Stochastic Cytokine Expression Induces Mixed T Helper Cell States
Fang, M., Xie, H., Dougan, S. K., Ploegh, H., & van Oudenaarden, A. (2013) · PLoS Biology · doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.1001618 · Cited by 56
From the two-dimensional Th1 and Th2 phenotypes to high-dimensional models for gene regulation
van den Ham, H., & de Boer, R. J. (2008) · International Immunology · doi:10.1093/intimm/dxn093 · Cited by 39
Mathematical modelling of stem cell differentiation: the PU.1–GATA-1 interaction
Duff, C., Smith‐Miles, K., Lopes, L., & Tian, T. (2011) · Journal of Mathematical Biology · doi:10.1007/s00285-011-0419-3 · Cited by 35
Decision‐making by the immune response
Callard, R. E. (2007) · Immunology and Cell Biology · doi:10.1038/sj.icb.7100060 · Cited by 33
Bokes, P., King, J. R., & Loose, M. (2009) · Mathematical Medicine and Biology A Journal of the IMA · doi:10.1093/imammb/dqn026 · Cited by 20
A probabilistic view of immunology: Drawing parallels with physics
Hodgkin, P. D. (2007) · Immunology and Cell Biology · doi:10.1038/sj.icb.7100061 · Cited by 18
Audet, J. (2010) · Biotechnology and Bioengineering · doi:10.1002/bit.22708 · Cited by 14
Cited by
Regev, A., Teichmann, S. A., Lander, E. S., Amit, I., Benoist, C., Birney, E., Bodenmiller, B., Campbell, P., Carninci, P., Clatworthy, M., et al. (2017) · eLife · doi:10.7554/elife.27041 · Cited by 2,232
Self-citationRegev, A., Teichmann, S. A., Lander, E. S., Amit, I., Benoist, C. O., Birney, E., Bodenmiller, B., & Campbell, P. J. (2017) · Zurich Open Repository and Archive (University of Zurich) · doi:10.5167/uzh-162597 · Cited by 1,399
Palantir characterizes cell fate continuities in human hematopoiesis
Setty, M., Kiseliovas, V., Levine, J., Gayoso, A., Mazutis, L., & Pe’er, D. (2018) · doi:10.1101/385328 · Cited by 836
Self-citationCharacterization of cell fate probabilities in single-cell data with Palantir
Setty, M., Kiseliovas, V., Levine, J., Gayoso, A., Mazutis, L., & Pe’er, D. (2019) · Nature Biotechnology · doi:10.1038/s41587-019-0068-4 · Cited by 833
Self-citationRevealing the vectors of cellular identity with single-cell genomics
Wagner, A., Regev, A., & Yosef, N. (2016) · Nature Biotechnology · doi:10.1038/nbt.3711 · Cited by 632
Metadata
- Authors
- Antebi, Y. E., Reich-Zeliger, S., Hart, Y., Mayo, A., Eizenberg, I., Rimer, J., Putheti, P., Pe'er, D., & Friedman, N.
- Affiliations
- Weizmann Institute of Science (IL)
- Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center (US)
- Corresponding author
- Friedman, Nir
- Venue
- PLoS Biology
- Publisher
- Public Library of Science (PLoS)
- Published
- 2013-07-30
- Volume
- 11
- Issue
- 7
- Pages
- e1001616
- ISSN
- 1544-9173 (ISSN-L)
- 1545-7885
- PMC
- PMC3728017
- OpenAlex
- W2137224137
- Semantic Scholar
- 4a8fcf5effeb3bfe69edebc7b3494ef7956ceb2a
- Cited by
- 100
- References
- 56
- Citations by year
- 2026: 1 · 2025: 2 · 2024: 7 · 2023: 3 · 2022: 6 · 2021: 2 · 2020: 9 · 2019: 9 · 2018: 8 · 2017: 11 · 2016: 13 · 2015: 11 · 2014: 10 · 2013: 5
- FWCI
- 7.18
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- gold
- doi.org
- Locations
- PLoS Biology (publishedVersion, cc-by)
- Europe PMC (PubMed Central) (publishedVersion, cc-by)
- PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
- PubMed (publishedVersion)
- CaltechAUTHORS (California Institute of Technology) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
- Digital Access to Scholarship at Harvard (DASH) (Harvard University) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
- DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) (submittedVersion)
- Figshare (submittedVersion, cc-by)
- Columbia Academic Commons (Columbia University)
- Funders
- Israel Science Foundation (1254/11)
- Topics
- Life Sciences › Immunology and Microbiology › Immunology › T-cell and B-cell Immunology
- Life Sciences › Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology › Molecular Biology › Gene Regulatory Network Analysis
- Life Sciences › Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology › Molecular Biology › Developmental Biology and Gene Regulation
- Keywords
- T cell differentiation, mixed signals, naive T cells, T-bet, GATA3, interferon-gamma, IL-4, transcriptional regulatory networks, positive feedback loop, stochastic gene expression, single-cell gene expression
- MeSH terms
- T-bet Transcription Factor, Animals, Cell Differentiation, Cell Separation, Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay, Female, Flow Cytometry, Interferon-gamma, Mice, Inbred C57BL, T-Lymphocytes, CD4-Positive T-Lymphocytes, Interleukin-4, T-Box Domain Proteins, GATA3 Transcription Factor, Mice, Real-Time Polymerase Chain Reaction
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.