The DOI matches its Crossref record; 63 of the 65 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; 31 of the 88 sources its claims cite were checked for support.
Self-Reported Trait Mindfulness and Affective Reactivity: A Motivational Approach Using Multiple Psychophysiological Measures
Open accessAbstract
As a form of attention, mindfulness is qualitatively receptive and non-reactive, and is thought to facilitate adaptive emotional responding. One suggestedmechanism is that mindfulness facilitates disengagement from an affective stimulus and thereby decreases affective reactivity. However, mindfulness has been conceptualized as a state, intervention, and trait. Because evidence is mixed as to whether self-reported trait mindfulness decreases affective reactivity, we used a multi-method approach to study the relationship between individual differences in self-reported traitmindfulness and electrocortical, electrodermal, electromyographic, and self-reported responses to emotional pictures. Specifically, while participants (N = 51) passively viewed pleasant, neutral, and unpleasant IAPS pictures, we recorded high-density (128 channels) electrocortical, electrodermal, and electromyographic data to the pictures as well as to acoustic startle probes presented during the pictures. Afterwards, participants rated their subjective valence and arousal while viewing the pictures again. If trait mindfulness spontaneously reduces general emotional reactivity, then for individuals reporting high rather than lowmindfulness, response differences between emotional and neutral pictures would show relatively decreased early posterior negativity (EPN) and late positive potential (LPP) amplitudes, decreased skin conductance responses, and decreased subjective ratings for valence and arousal. Highmindfulness would also be associated with decreased emotional modulation of startle eyeblink and P3 amplitudes. Although results showed clear effects of emotion on the dependent measures, in general,mindfulness did not moderate these effects. For most measures, effect sizes were small with rather narrow confidence intervals. These data do not support the hypothesis that individual differences in self-reported trait mindfulness are related to spontaneous emotional responses during picture viewing. © 2015 Cosme, Wiens.
Overview
CoChat Summary
TL;DR
In this passive picture-viewing study with 51 participants, self-reported trait mindfulness did not meaningfully moderate affective reactivity across multiple psychophysiological and self-report measures. The authors found clear valence/arousal effects for most outcomes, but mindfulness effects were generally null or negligible.
Key findings
- Across participants, the expected emotion effects were observed for most measures: pleasant vs. unpleasant valence ratings differed by about 4 points on a 9-point scale (95% CI: 3.60 to 4.30), and arousing (pleasant + unpleasant) vs. neutral pictures differed by nearly 2 points in arousal ratings (95% CI: 1.58 to 2.22).
- Valence effects were present for self-reported valence ratings and startle eyeblink EMG; arousal effects were present for self-reported arousal, skin conductance response (SCR), EPN, and LPP.
- Trait mindfulness generally did not moderate these effects for the MAAS or FFMQ facets; the authors report point estimates “close to zero” and “rather narrow” confidence intervals, suggesting negligible effects.
- The one reported direct mindfulness effect was on startle P3 amplitudes: FFMQ-NR showed a main effect on P3, F(2, 98) = 4.8, p = .033, ηp2 = .089, with higher mindfulness associated with generally decreased P3 amplitudes, but no Emotion × Mindfulness interaction was significant.
Methods
- Convenience sample of 56 students/professionals from Stockholm University and an online recruitment website; after exclusions, 51 participants remained (25 women, 26 men), aged 19–51 (M = 25, SD = 6.8).
- Participants passively viewed 72 IAPS pictures (24 pleasant, 24 unpleasant, 24 neutral) while EEG (128 channels), facial EMG, and skin conductance were recorded; startle probes occurred 1500, 4500, or 7500 ms after picture onset.
- Trait mindfulness was measured with the MAAS and FFMQ; analyses used repeated-measures ANCOVAs with mindfulness as a continuous centered covariate, and the FFMQ-NR facet was emphasized as theoretically most relevant.
Limitations
- The paper states that results are limited to mindfulness as a self-reported trait and may not generalize to mindfulness as a state, process, or intervention.
- The paper states that findings were obtained with emotional pictures and “do not necessarily generalize” to other emotional stimuli, and that passive viewing may not capture effects seen in active tasks with specific instructions.
- Evident from the text: the sample was a convenience sample of mostly young Swedish students/professionals, so broader generalizability is limited; the paper also notes a relatively small sample size (N = 51) and that the startle P3 outcome showed no emotion effect across subjects, making conclusions about that measure cautious.
Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Figures




Verification
Claims the paper makes
29 Valid · 0 Not valid · 40 Not checked · 64 Own results and interpretations
The cited sources support only part of this claim — read each source’s verdict below.
In the paper
“Because evidence is mixed as to whether self-reported trait mindfulness decreases affective reactivity, we used a multi-method approach to study the relationship between individual differences in self-reported trait mindfulness and electrocortical, electrodermal, electromyographic, and self-reported responses to emotional pictures.”
- Also stated in: § Introduction Scientific interest in mindfulness and mindfulness-based therapies to alleviate psychological distress and promote well-being has increased exponentially over the past 15 years. Mindfulness is a form of attention that is rooted in the present moment and is qualitatively receptive and non-reactive, and as such it is thought to facilitate emotion regulation [1]. In line with this, randomized controlled trials using the mindfulness-based intervention Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) [2] found that MBSR reduced symptoms of psychological distress, such as self-reported anxiety, depression, and stress, and improved self-reported positive affect, self-compassion, and satisfaction with life (for a review, see [3]). MBSR has also been associated with positive outcomes of emotion regulatory processes, such as reduced rumination [4] and decreased activation in brain regions implicated in self-referential processing and elaboration [5]. In addition, experienced meditators have reported lower levels of rumination and fewer difficulties in emotion regulation, compared to non-meditators [6]. Similarly, self-reported mindfulness has been positively correlated with self-reported use of adaptive emotion regulation strategies [7] and negatively correlated with self-reported difficulty in emotion regulation [8]. Together these findings support the notion that mindfulness is related to adaptive emotional responding, but the underlying mechanisms are not clearly understood. One suggested mechanism is that mindfulness facilitates disengagement from the affect-relevant stimulus and thereby decreases affective reactivity (i.e., one’s reaction in response to affect-relevant events) [9]. An affective response is characterized by several physiological components, including: threshold for reactivity, peak amplitude of response, rise time to peak, and recovery time [10]. Paying attention mindfully is proposed to facilitate disengagement from an emotion-provoking stimulus by attenuating the peak amplitude and speeding up recovery, thereby decreasing the overall emotional response [9]. This is in contrast to continued engagement with the stimulus, which may promote elaborative self-referential processing and rumination, processes which are associated with psychological distress [11]. Despite the proposed link between mindfulness and affective reactivity, mindfulness is a rich concept originating in ancient Buddhist traditions that is difficult to succinctly and adequately operationalize [12]. Within the context of Western science, mindfulness is often defined as the awareness generated through “paying attention in a particular way: on purpose, in the present moment, and non-judgmentally” (p. 4) [13]. Within the psychological literature, it is described as consisting of two components: self-regulation of attention, and orientation to one’s current experience with an attitude of curiosity, acceptance, and openness [14]. These two components are thought to work synergistically to facilitate disengagement from affect-relevant stimuli, leading to decreased reactivity [14]. Self-regulation of attention helps practitioners to focus in the present moment and to observe their current experience, including thoughts, feelings, perceptions, and bodily sensations. As attentional resources are limited, focusing attention on the current experience inhibits elaboration, rumination, and other self-referential processes [14]. That is not to say that experiences (thoughts, feelings, perceptions) are suppressed, but rather they are merely noted as mental events and not elaborated on further, keeping attention on current experience. This focus of attention in the present moment might also facilitate disengagement by increasing awareness of one's initial reactivity to a stimulus, allowing one to let go and return to the present moment [15]. The second component of mindfulness describes a particular orientation of curiosity, openness, and non-judgmentalness to all experiences. This attitude of acceptance of current experience, regardless of valence or desirability, is thought to reduce avoidant behaviors and facilitate decoupling of stimulus-response reactivity through exposure, such as in exposure therapy [15]. In addition, open observation of one’s experience can create space between the observer and their thoughts, feelings, and perceptions. Rather than seeing them as accurate judgments or reflections of self, they may be observed as transitory mental events that do not have to be identified with [14]. This distance during exposure is likely to facilitate disengagement as it weakens the typical, spontaneous emotional response tendencies to affect-relevant stimuli. In sum, being mindful may facilitate disengagement by maintaining attention in the present moment, thereby inhibiting elaborative processes, and by maintaining an attitude of acceptance, thereby creating distance between the stimulus and response that weakens habitual emotional response tendencies. Thus, mindfulness is thought to facilitate the development of dispositional nonreactivity [9]. Several studies have investigated effects of mindful states or mindfulness interventions on responses to emotional pictures. Results have supported the link between mindfulness and decreased reactivity to emotional pictures [16–18]. Arch and Craske [16] employed a 15-minute focused breathing induction and found that, compared to inductions of worry or unfocused attention, focused breathing was associated with decreased self-reported negative affect after passively viewing aversive pictures and greater willingness to engage with unpleasant pictures in a subsequent task. Ortner and colleagues [17] investigated effects of a 7-week mindfulness intervention on emotional responding. Participants were shown pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral pictures and performed two tasks. The first task was an emotional interference task (categorizing tones as high or low while viewing emotional and neutral pictures), and the second was a passive viewing task. Skin conductance responses and self-reported emotional intensity were collected as measures of affective reactivity. Mindfulness training was associated with decreased (post-intervention vs. pre-intervention) emotional interference while viewing unpleasant pictures, decreased self-reported emotional intensity while viewing pleasant and unpleasant pictures, and decreased skin conductance responses to pleasant and unpleasant pictures. Lastly, Taylor and colleagues [18] investigated mindful attention versus uninstructed attention to pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral pictures in novice and experienced meditators, and used self-reported ratings of emotional intensity after each picture as a measure of affective reactivity. For both novice and experienced meditators, mindful attention decreased self-reported emotional intensity to pleasant, neutral, and unpleasant pictures. Together, these findings support the hypothesis that mindfulness, when operationalized as a state or intervention, decreases affective reactivity while viewing emotional pictures. However, in the field of psychology, the term mindfulness is currently used in three ways: to describe a state, as in a mode of awareness entered during mindfulness meditation, an intervention, in which participants learn mindfulness meditation, and a trait, implying a stable quality that differs between individuals. Effects for mindfulness may differ depending on how it is conceptualized. The studies reviewed above [16–18] provide evidence of the relationship between mindfulness treated as a state or intervention and decreased affective reactivity to emotional pictures. In contrast, there is mixed evidence from studies on affective reactivity during passive picture viewing when mindfulness is treated a self-reported trait [19–21]. Ostafin and colleagues [19] found evidence supporting the relationship between self-reported trait mindfulness and reduced self-reported and behavioral measures of affective reactivity. Self-reported trait mindfulness was measured with the Acting with awareness and Non-judging of inner experience facets of the Five Facet Mindfulness Questionnaire (FFMQ) [22]. High self-reported trait mindfulness was associated with lower self-reported negative affect and accessibility of aversive words after a negative emotion induction using unpleasant pictures. In contrast, Sauer and colleagues [20] used a large sample (N = 247) and found no relationship between self-reported trait mindfulness and ratings of unpleasant and neutral pictures, or word ratings after aversive evaluative conditioning. Brown and colleagues [21] used evoked brain potentials (the late positive potential; LPP) as a measure of affective reactivity. They found that high self-reported trait mindfulness on the Mindful Attention Awareness Scale (MAAS) [23] was associated with low LPP amplitudes while viewing unpleasant pictures. Although this finding supports the idea that self-reported trait mindfulness reduces affective reactivity, other research employed similar designs but compared meditators and non-meditators directly rather than using self-reported trait mindfulness as an independent measure and did not replicate this finding [24, 25]. Because experienced meditators should ostensibly be more mindful than non-meditators, one would expect to find clear differences in LPP responses as a function of meditation experience. However, the available evidence is inconclusive. On the one hand, Sobolewski and colleagues [25] found experienced Buddhist meditators to have attenuated LPP amplitudes for unpleasant pictures, but the effect was found at left and right frontal electrodes rather than at centro-parietal sites where it is generally reported [26]. On the other hand, using a group of yogic meditators practicing in the Sudarshan Kriya tradition, Gootjes and colleagues [24] found no difference in LPP amplitudes to emotional pictures between meditators and non-meditators during a passive viewing task. While there are no obvious reasons for these inconclusive results for LPP in active meditators, it is nonetheless important to replicate findings by Brown et al. [21] and to even extend them, if possible. If it can be shown that trait mindfulness is associated with reduced LPP responses to emotional pictures versus neutral pictures (rather than just to unpleasant pictures per se), then these results would provide convincing evidence for a specific effect of trait mindfulness on affective reactivity. In sum, the current evidence that self-reported trait mindfulness is associated with decreased affective reactivity to emotional pictures is rather limited and mixed. The aim of the present study was to further investigate the relationship between self-reported trait mindfulness and affective reactivity to emotional pictures during passive picture viewing using multiple measures that comprehensively characterize affective reactivity. Participants rated trait mindfulness using two commonly used self-report scales, the MAAS [23] and FFMQ [22]. We used both scales as they are thought to measure different aspects of mindfulness and thus, they allowed us to separate the components thought to be related to self-regulation of attention (MAAS and the Acting with awareness subscale on the FFMQ) and attitude of acceptance (the subscales of Non-judging of inner experience and of Nonreactivity to inner experience on the FFMQ). In the study, participants completed a passive viewing task, looking at pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral pictures while electroencephalography (EEG), electromyography (EMG), and electrodermal measures were recorded. Participants heard sporadic loud bursts of white noise to evoke a startle response. Self-reported ratings of valence and arousal were collected while participants viewed the pictures a second time. In the present study, emotion was characterized in terms of valence and arousal. Emotion can be conceptualized in terms of discrete categories (e.g., fear, disgust, etc.) or in term of the motivational dimensions of valence and arousal [27]. According to the motivational model, unpleasant and pleasant pictures differ in their valence, and both unpleasant and pleasant pictures differ from neutral pictures in their arousal level. Because research has demonstrated clear effects of valence and arousal on different physiological and self-report measures [27], the present study adopted a motivational perspective on emotion. Further, because various dependent measures differ in their sensitivity to either valence or arousal [27], the predictions and data analyses were focused on either the valence effect (i.e., pleasant vs. unpleasant) or the arousal effect (i.e., pleasant + unpleasant combined vs. neutral) of emotion. To index valence effects, we measured self-reported valence ratings to the pictures and startle eyeblink responses during the pictures. The startle response is characterized in humans by muscular contractions in the torso and face, and indexes the activation of the defensive system [28]. Startle response amplitude is modulated by one’s affective state and can be conveniently recorded by measuring the amplitude of the eyeblink response to the startle probe [29]. The eyeblink amplitude, which is potentiated during negative affective states and attenuated during positive affective states, has been shown to be modulated particularly while viewing highly arousing emotional pictures [27]. Therefore, an effect of picture valence was predicted such that pleasant pictures would elicit more pleasant self-reported valence ratings than unpleasant pictures, whereas unpleasant pictures would elicit greater startle responses than pleasant pictures. Self-reported trait mindfulness was expected to moderate these effects with higher mindfulness being associated with smaller differences in arousal effects on valence ratings and startle responses. To index arousal effects (i.e., pleasant + unpleasant combined vs. neutral), we measured self-reported arousal to the pictures, skin conductance responses to picture onset, and three event-related potentials derived from the EEG: the early posterior negativity (EPN) and the late positive potential (LPP) to picture onset, and the P3 to startle onset. The skin conductance response (SCR) is regulated by the autonomic nervous system with sympathetic innervation of the sweat glands producing the skin conductance response [30]. As such, SCR can serve as a measure of sympathetic arousal [31]. The EPN is a relative negativity over occipito-temporal electrodes to arousing versus neutral pictures about 200 ms after picture onset. It appears to reflect a call for attentional resources [32]. The LPP is a positive deflection of the ERP waveform occurring at centro-parietal sites approximately 400 ms after picture onset. Although it may already be observed to neutral pictures per se, arousal effects on the LPP are apparent in the difference ERP waveforms to arousing versus neutral pictures [33]. This relative LPP is thought to index greater attention allocation to arousing pictures than to neutral pictures [34]. As such, EPN and LPP were used to measure the call, as well as the actual allocation, of attention to arousing versus neutral pictures. Lastly, the P3 component, which is a centro-parietal positivity approximately 300 ms after stimulus onset, indexes attention allocation and has been used in affect-modulated startle response paradigms to assess the relative allocation of attention to the startle probes versus pictures [35]. Specifically, the P3 to startle probes is reduced during viewing of arousing (unpleasant or pleasant) pictures versus neutral pictures [36, 37]. This is consistent with the idea that more attentional resources are drawn to arousing pictures than to neutral pictures and thus, that fewer attentional resources are available to process the additional startle probe during arousing than neutral pictures. Therefore, across participants, we expected to find a general effect of picture arousal on P3 amplitudes, with smaller P3 amplitudes to startle probes presented on trials in which arousing pictures were shown than when neutral pictures were shown. In sum, as a consequence of arousal effects, responses were expected to be greater for arousing than neutral pictures for self-reported arousal, skin conductance responses, and LPP. In contrast, responses were expected to be lower (i.e., less positive) for arousing than neutral pictures for the EPN and P3. Self-reported trait mindfulness was predicted to moderate these response differences with higher mindfulness being associated with relatively smaller response differences, indicating decreased affective reactivity. · plain
“In contrast, there is mixed evidence from studies on affective reactivity during passive picture viewing when mindfulness is treated a self-reported trait [19–21].”
§ Self-Reported Trait Mindfulness and Affective Reactivity: A Motivational Approach Using Multiple Psychophysiological Measures > Abstract As a form of attention, mindfulness is qualitatively receptive and non-reactive, and is thought to facilitate adaptive emotional responding. One suggested mechanism is that mindfulness facilitates disengagement from an affective stimulus and thereby decreases affective reactivity. However, mindfulness has been conceptualized as a state, intervention, and trait. Because evidence is mixed as to whether self-reported trait mindfulness decreases affective reactivity, we used a multi-method approach to study the relationship between individual differences in self-reported trait mindfulness and electrocortical, electrodermal, electromyographic, and self-reported responses to emotional pictures. Specifically, while participants (N = 51) passively viewed pleasant, neutral, and unpleasant IAPS pictures, we recorded high-density (128 channels) electrocortical, electrodermal, and electromyographic data to the pictures as well as to acoustic startle probes presented during the pictures. Afterwards, participants rated their subjective valence and arousal while viewing the pictures again. If trait mindfulness spontaneously reduces general emotional reactivity, then for individuals reporting high rather than low mindfulness, response differences between emotional and neutral pictures would show relatively decreased early posterior negativity (EPN) and late positive potential (LPP) amplitudes, decreased skin conductance responses, and decreased subjective ratings for valence and arousal. High mindfulness would also be associated with decreased emotional modulation of startle eyeblink and P3 amplitudes. Although results showed clear effects of emotion on the dependent measures, in general, mindfulness did not moderate these effects. For most measures, effect sizes were small with rather narrow confidence intervals. These data do not support the hypothesis that individual differences in self-reported trait mindfulness are related to spontaneous emotional responses during picture viewing.
What the sources say
- Not checked — no full text of the sourcecites [19] Ostafin BD, Brooks JJ, Laitem M. Affective reactivity mediates an inverse relation between mindfulness and anxiety. Mindfulness. 2013:1–9. doi: 10.1007/s12671-013-0206-x. source
- Not checked — no full text of the sourcecites [20] S Sauer, 2011, Implicit and explicit emotional behavior and mindfulness, Conscious Cogn source
- Partly supportedcites [21] KW Brown, 2013, Dispositional mindfulness and the attenuation of neural responses to emotional stimuli, Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci sourceExperimental — accuracy not yet measured
The Introduction reports evidence linking dispositional mindfulness to less neural reactivity to affective stimuli, and the study reports lower responses to high-arousal unpleasant images among people scoring higher on self-reported mindfulness scales. But the paper does not characterize the evidence as mixed, and its limitations caution that the observed association does not establish that mindfulness causes a decrease in reactivity. (LLM, conf=0.82)
plainn = 51- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Also stated in: § Introduction Scientific interest in mindfulness and mindfulness-based therapies to alleviate psychological distress and promote well-being has increased exponentially over the past 15 years. Mindfulness is a form of attention that is rooted in the present moment and is qualitatively receptive and non-reactive, and as such it is thought to facilitate emotion regulation [1]. In line with this, randomized controlled trials using the mindfulness-based intervention Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) [2] found that MBSR reduced symptoms of psychological distress, such as self-reported anxiety, depression, and stress, and improved self-reported positive affect, self-compassion, and satisfaction with life (for a review, see [3]). MBSR has also been associated with positive outcomes of emotion regulatory processes, such as reduced rumination [4] and decreased activation in brain regions implicated in self-referential processing and elaboration [5]. In addition, experienced meditators have reported lower levels of rumination and fewer difficulties in emotion regulation, compared to non-meditators [6]. Similarly, self-reported mindfulness has been positively correlated with self-reported use of adaptive emotion regulation strategies [7] and negatively correlated with self-reported difficulty in emotion regulation [8]. Together these findings support the notion that mindfulness is related to adaptive emotional responding, but the underlying mechanisms are not clearly understood. One suggested mechanism is that mindfulness facilitates disengagement from the affect-relevant stimulus and thereby decreases affective reactivity (i.e., one’s reaction in response to affect-relevant events) [9]. An affective response is characterized by several physiological components, including: threshold for reactivity, peak amplitude of response, rise time to peak, and recovery time [10]. Paying attention mindfully is proposed to facilitate disengagement from an emotion-provoking stimulus by attenuating the peak amplitude and speeding up recovery, thereby decreasing the overall emotional response [9]. This is in contrast to continued engagement with the stimulus, which may promote elaborative self-referential processing and rumination, processes which are associated with psychological distress [11]. Despite the proposed link between mindfulness and affective reactivity, mindfulness is a rich concept originating in ancient Buddhist traditions that is difficult to succinctly and adequately operationalize [12]. Within the context of Western science, mindfulness is often defined as the awareness generated through “paying attention in a particular way: on purpose, in the present moment, and non-judgmentally” (p. 4) [13]. Within the psychological literature, it is described as consisting of two components: self-regulation of attention, and orientation to one’s current experience with an attitude of curiosity, acceptance, and openness [14]. These two components are thought to work synergistically to facilitate disengagement from affect-relevant stimuli, leading to decreased reactivity [14]. Self-regulation of attention helps practitioners to focus in the present moment and to observe their current experience, including thoughts, feelings, perceptions, and bodily sensations. As attentional resources are limited, focusing attention on the current experience inhibits elaboration, rumination, and other self-referential processes [14]. That is not to say that experiences (thoughts, feelings, perceptions) are suppressed, but rather they are merely noted as mental events and not elaborated on further, keeping attention on current experience. This focus of attention in the present moment might also facilitate disengagement by increasing awareness of one's initial reactivity to a stimulus, allowing one to let go and return to the present moment [15]. The second component of mindfulness describes a particular orientation of curiosity, openness, and non-judgmentalness to all experiences. This attitude of acceptance of current experience, regardless of valence or desirability, is thought to reduce avoidant behaviors and facilitate decoupling of stimulus-response reactivity through exposure, such as in exposure therapy [15]. In addition, open observation of one’s experience can create space between the observer and their thoughts, feelings, and perceptions. Rather than seeing them as accurate judgments or reflections of self, they may be observed as transitory mental events that do not have to be identified with [14]. This distance during exposure is likely to facilitate disengagement as it weakens the typical, spontaneous emotional response tendencies to affect-relevant stimuli. In sum, being mindful may facilitate disengagement by maintaining attention in the present moment, thereby inhibiting elaborative processes, and by maintaining an attitude of acceptance, thereby creating distance between the stimulus and response that weakens habitual emotional response tendencies. Thus, mindfulness is thought to facilitate the development of dispositional nonreactivity [9]. Several studies have investigated effects of mindful states or mindfulness interventions on responses to emotional pictures. Results have supported the link between mindfulness and decreased reactivity to emotional pictures [16–18]. Arch and Craske [16] employed a 15-minute focused breathing induction and found that, compared to inductions of worry or unfocused attention, focused breathing was associated with decreased self-reported negative affect after passively viewing aversive pictures and greater willingness to engage with unpleasant pictures in a subsequent task. Ortner and colleagues [17] investigated effects of a 7-week mindfulness intervention on emotional responding. Participants were shown pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral pictures and performed two tasks. The first task was an emotional interference task (categorizing tones as high or low while viewing emotional and neutral pictures), and the second was a passive viewing task. Skin conductance responses and self-reported emotional intensity were collected as measures of affective reactivity. Mindfulness training was associated with decreased (post-intervention vs. pre-intervention) emotional interference while viewing unpleasant pictures, decreased self-reported emotional intensity while viewing pleasant and unpleasant pictures, and decreased skin conductance responses to pleasant and unpleasant pictures. Lastly, Taylor and colleagues [18] investigated mindful attention versus uninstructed attention to pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral pictures in novice and experienced meditators, and used self-reported ratings of emotional intensity after each picture as a measure of affective reactivity. For both novice and experienced meditators, mindful attention decreased self-reported emotional intensity to pleasant, neutral, and unpleasant pictures. Together, these findings support the hypothesis that mindfulness, when operationalized as a state or intervention, decreases affective reactivity while viewing emotional pictures. However, in the field of psychology, the term mindfulness is currently used in three ways: to describe a state, as in a mode of awareness entered during mindfulness meditation, an intervention, in which participants learn mindfulness meditation, and a trait, implying a stable quality that differs between individuals. Effects for mindfulness may differ depending on how it is conceptualized. The studies reviewed above [16–18] provide evidence of the relationship between mindfulness treated as a state or intervention and decreased affective reactivity to emotional pictures. In contrast, there is mixed evidence from studies on affective reactivity during passive picture viewing when mindfulness is treated a self-reported trait [19–21]. Ostafin and colleagues [19] found evidence supporting the relationship between self-reported trait mindfulness and reduced self-reported and behavioral measures of affective reactivity. Self-reported trait mindfulness was measured with the Acting with awareness and Non-judging of inner experience facets of the Five Facet Mindfulness Questionnaire (FFMQ) [22]. High self-reported trait mindfulness was associated with lower self-reported negative affect and accessibility of aversive words after a negative emotion induction using unpleasant pictures. In contrast, Sauer and colleagues [20] used a large sample (N = 247) and found no relationship between self-reported trait mindfulness and ratings of unpleasant and neutral pictures, or word ratings after aversive evaluative conditioning. Brown and colleagues [21] used evoked brain potentials (the late positive potential; LPP) as a measure of affective reactivity. They found that high self-reported trait mindfulness on the Mindful Attention Awareness Scale (MAAS) [23] was associated with low LPP amplitudes while viewing unpleasant pictures. Although this finding supports the idea that self-reported trait mindfulness reduces affective reactivity, other research employed similar designs but compared meditators and non-meditators directly rather than using self-reported trait mindfulness as an independent measure and did not replicate this finding [24, 25]. Because experienced meditators should ostensibly be more mindful than non-meditators, one would expect to find clear differences in LPP responses as a function of meditation experience. However, the available evidence is inconclusive. On the one hand, Sobolewski and colleagues [25] found experienced Buddhist meditators to have attenuated LPP amplitudes for unpleasant pictures, but the effect was found at left and right frontal electrodes rather than at centro-parietal sites where it is generally reported [26]. On the other hand, using a group of yogic meditators practicing in the Sudarshan Kriya tradition, Gootjes and colleagues [24] found no difference in LPP amplitudes to emotional pictures between meditators and non-meditators during a passive viewing task. While there are no obvious reasons for these inconclusive results for LPP in active meditators, it is nonetheless important to replicate findings by Brown et al. [21] and to even extend them, if possible. If it can be shown that trait mindfulness is associated with reduced LPP responses to emotional pictures versus neutral pictures (rather than just to unpleasant pictures per se), then these results would provide convincing evidence for a specific effect of trait mindfulness on affective reactivity. In sum, the current evidence that self-reported trait mindfulness is associated with decreased affective reactivity to emotional pictures is rather limited and mixed. The aim of the present study was to further investigate the relationship between self-reported trait mindfulness and affective reactivity to emotional pictures during passive picture viewing using multiple measures that comprehensively characterize affective reactivity. Participants rated trait mindfulness using two commonly used self-report scales, the MAAS [23] and FFMQ [22]. We used both scales as they are thought to measure different aspects of mindfulness and thus, they allowed us to separate the components thought to be related to self-regulation of attention (MAAS and the Acting with awareness subscale on the FFMQ) and attitude of acceptance (the subscales of Non-judging of inner experience and of Nonreactivity to inner experience on the FFMQ). In the study, participants completed a passive viewing task, looking at pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral pictures while electroencephalography (EEG), electromyography (EMG), and electrodermal measures were recorded. Participants heard sporadic loud bursts of white noise to evoke a startle response. Self-reported ratings of valence and arousal were collected while participants viewed the pictures a second time. In the present study, emotion was characterized in terms of valence and arousal. Emotion can be conceptualized in terms of discrete categories (e.g., fear, disgust, etc.) or in term of the motivational dimensions of valence and arousal [27]. According to the motivational model, unpleasant and pleasant pictures differ in their valence, and both unpleasant and pleasant pictures differ from neutral pictures in their arousal level. Because research has demonstrated clear effects of valence and arousal on different physiological and self-report measures [27], the present study adopted a motivational perspective on emotion. Further, because various dependent measures differ in their sensitivity to either valence or arousal [27], the predictions and data analyses were focused on either the valence effect (i.e., pleasant vs. unpleasant) or the arousal effect (i.e., pleasant + unpleasant combined vs. neutral) of emotion. To index valence effects, we measured self-reported valence ratings to the pictures and startle eyeblink responses during the pictures. The startle response is characterized in humans by muscular contractions in the torso and face, and indexes the activation of the defensive system [28]. Startle response amplitude is modulated by one’s affective state and can be conveniently recorded by measuring the amplitude of the eyeblink response to the startle probe [29]. The eyeblink amplitude, which is potentiated during negative affective states and attenuated during positive affective states, has been shown to be modulated particularly while viewing highly arousing emotional pictures [27]. Therefore, an effect of picture valence was predicted such that pleasant pictures would elicit more pleasant self-reported valence ratings than unpleasant pictures, whereas unpleasant pictures would elicit greater startle responses than pleasant pictures. Self-reported trait mindfulness was expected to moderate these effects with higher mindfulness being associated with smaller differences in arousal effects on valence ratings and startle responses. To index arousal effects (i.e., pleasant + unpleasant combined vs. neutral), we measured self-reported arousal to the pictures, skin conductance responses to picture onset, and three event-related potentials derived from the EEG: the early posterior negativity (EPN) and the late positive potential (LPP) to picture onset, and the P3 to startle onset. The skin conductance response (SCR) is regulated by the autonomic nervous system with sympathetic innervation of the sweat glands producing the skin conductance response [30]. As such, SCR can serve as a measure of sympathetic arousal [31]. The EPN is a relative negativity over occipito-temporal electrodes to arousing versus neutral pictures about 200 ms after picture onset. It appears to reflect a call for attentional resources [32]. The LPP is a positive deflection of the ERP waveform occurring at centro-parietal sites approximately 400 ms after picture onset. Although it may already be observed to neutral pictures per se, arousal effects on the LPP are apparent in the difference ERP waveforms to arousing versus neutral pictures [33]. This relative LPP is thought to index greater attention allocation to arousing pictures than to neutral pictures [34]. As such, EPN and LPP were used to measure the call, as well as the actual allocation, of attention to arousing versus neutral pictures. Lastly, the P3 component, which is a centro-parietal positivity approximately 300 ms after stimulus onset, indexes attention allocation and has been used in affect-modulated startle response paradigms to assess the relative allocation of attention to the startle probes versus pictures [35]. Specifically, the P3 to startle probes is reduced during viewing of arousing (unpleasant or pleasant) pictures versus neutral pictures [36, 37]. This is consistent with the idea that more attentional resources are drawn to arousing pictures than to neutral pictures and thus, that fewer attentional resources are available to process the additional startle probe during arousing than neutral pictures. Therefore, across participants, we expected to find a general effect of picture arousal on P3 amplitudes, with smaller P3 amplitudes to startle probes presented on trials in which arousing pictures were shown than when neutral pictures were shown. In sum, as a consequence of arousal effects, responses were expected to be greater for arousing than neutral pictures for self-reported arousal, skin conductance responses, and LPP. In contrast, responses were expected to be lower (i.e., less positive) for arousing than neutral pictures for the EPN and P3. Self-reported trait mindfulness was predicted to moderate these response differences with higher mindfulness being associated with relatively smaller response differences, indicating decreased affective reactivity. · plain
The sources with a verdict support this claim; the rest weren’t checked yet, have no full text we could read, or their verdicts aren’t rated yet.
In the paper
“Results have supported the link between mindfulness and decreased reactivity to emotional pictures [16–18].”
§ Self-Reported Trait Mindfulness and Affective Reactivity: A Motivational Approach Using Multiple Psychophysiological Measures > Introduction Scientific interest in mindfulness and mindfulness-based therapies to alleviate psychological distress and promote well-being has increased exponentially over the past 15 years. Mindfulness is a form of attention that is rooted in the present moment and is qualitatively receptive and non-reactive, and as such it is thought to facilitate emotion regulation [1]. In line with this, randomized controlled trials using the mindfulness-based intervention Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) [2] found that MBSR reduced symptoms of psychological distress, such as self-reported anxiety, depression, and stress, and improved self-reported positive affect, self-compassion, and satisfaction with life (for a review, see [3]). MBSR has also been associated with positive outcomes of emotion regulatory processes, such as reduced rumination [4] and decreased activation in brain regions implicated in self-referential processing and elaboration [5]. In addition, experienced meditators have reported lower levels of rumination and fewer difficulties in emotion regulation, compared to non-meditators [6]. Similarly, self-reported mindfulness has been positively correlated with self-reported use of adaptive emotion regulation strategies [7] and negatively correlated with self-reported difficulty in emotion regulation [8]. Together these findings support the notion that mindfulness is related to adaptive emotional responding, but the underlying mechanisms are not clearly understood. One suggested mechanism is that mindfulness facilitates disengagement from the affect-relevant stimulus and thereby decreases affective reactivity (i.e., one’s reaction in response to affect-relevant events) [9]. An affective response is characterized by several physiological components, including: threshold for reactivity, peak amplitude of response, rise time to peak, and recovery time [10]. Paying attention mindfully is proposed to facilitate disengagement from an emotion-provoking stimulus by attenuating the peak amplitude and speeding up recovery, thereby decreasing the overall emotional response [9]. This is in contrast to continued engagement with the stimulus, which may promote elaborative self-referential processing and rumination, processes which are associated with psychological distress [11]. Despite the proposed link between mindfulness and affective reactivity, mindfulness is a rich concept originating in ancient Buddhist traditions that is difficult to succinctly and adequately operationalize [12]. Within the context of Western science, mindfulness is often defined as the awareness generated through “paying attention in a particular way: on purpose, in the present moment, and non-judgmentally” (p. 4) [13]. Within the psychological literature, it is described as consisting of two components: self-regulation of attention, and orientation to one’s current experience with an attitude of curiosity, acceptance, and openness [14]. These two components are thought to work synergistically to facilitate disengagement from affect-relevant stimuli, leading to decreased reactivity [14]. Self-regulation of attention helps practitioners to focus in the present moment and to observe their current experience, including thoughts, feelings, perceptions, and bodily sensations. As attentional resources are limited, focusing attention on the current experience inhibits elaboration, rumination, and other self-referential processes [14]. That is not to say that experiences (thoughts, feelings, perceptions) are suppressed, but rather they are merely noted as mental events and not elaborated on further, keeping attention on current experience. This focus of attention in the present moment might also facilitate disengagement by increasing awareness of one's initial reactivity to a stimulus, allowing one to let go and return to the present moment [15]. The second component of mindfulness describes a particular orientation of curiosity, openness, and non-judgmentalness to all experiences. This attitude of acceptance of current experience, regardless of valence or desirability, is thought to reduce avoidant behaviors and facilitate decoupling of stimulus-response reactivity through exposure, such as in exposure therapy [15]. In addition, open observation of one’s experience can create space between the observer and their thoughts, feelings, and perceptions. Rather than seeing them as accurate judgments or reflections of self, they may be observed as transitory mental events that do not have to be identified with [14]. This distance during exposure is likely to facilitate disengagement as it weakens the typical, spontaneous emotional response tendencies to affect-relevant stimuli. In sum, being mindful may facilitate disengagement by maintaining attention in the present moment, thereby inhibiting elaborative processes, and by maintaining an attitude of acceptance, thereby creating distance between the stimulus and response that weakens habitual emotional response tendencies. Thus, mindfulness is thought to facilitate the development of dispositional nonreactivity [9]. Several studies have investigated effects of mindful states or mindfulness interventions on responses to emotional pictures. Results have supported the link between mindfulness and decreased reactivity to emotional pictures [16–18]. Arch and Craske [16] employed a 15-minute focused breathing induction and found that, compared to inductions of worry or unfocused attention, focused breathing was associated with decreased self-reported negative affect after passively viewing aversive pictures and greater willingness to engage with unpleasant pictures in a subsequent task. Ortner and colleagues [17] investigated effects of a 7-week mindfulness intervention on emotional responding. Participants were shown pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral pictures and performed two tasks. The first task was an emotional interference task (categorizing tones as high or low while viewing emotional and neutral pictures), and the second was a passive viewing task. Skin conductance responses and self-reported emotional intensity were collected as measures of affective reactivity. Mindfulness training was associated with decreased (post-intervention vs. pre-intervention) emotional interference while viewing unpleasant pictures, decreased self-reported emotional intensity while viewing pleasant and unpleasant pictures, and decreased skin conductance responses to pleasant and unpleasant pictures. Lastly, Taylor and colleagues [18] investigated mindful attention versus uninstructed attention to pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral pictures in novice and experienced meditators, and used self-reported ratings of emotional intensity after each picture as a measure of affective reactivity. For both novice and experienced meditators, mindful attention decreased self-reported emotional intensity to pleasant, neutral, and unpleasant pictures. Together, these findings support the hypothesis that mindfulness, when operationalized as a state or intervention, decreases affective reactivity while viewing emotional pictures. However, in the field of psychology, the term mindfulness is currently used in three ways: to describe a state, as in a mode of awareness entered during mindfulness meditation, an intervention, in which participants learn mindfulness meditation, and a trait, implying a stable quality that differs between individuals. Effects for mindfulness may differ depending on how it is conceptualized. The studies reviewed above [16–18] provide evidence of the relationship between mindfulness treated as a state or intervention and decreased affective reactivity to emotional pictures. In contrast, there is mixed evidence from studies on affective reactivity during passive picture viewing when mindfulness is treated a self-reported trait [19–21]. Ostafin and colleagues [19] found evidence supporting the relationship between self-reported trait mindfulness and reduced self-reported and behavioral measures of affective reactivity. Self-reported trait mindfulness was measured with the Acting with awareness and Non-judging of inner experience facets of the Five Facet Mindfulness Questionnaire (FFMQ) [22]. High self-reported trait mindfulness was associated with lower self-reported negative affect and accessibility of aversive words after a negative emotion induction using unpleasant pictures. In contrast, Sauer and colleagues [20] used a large sample (N = 247) and found no relationship between self-reported trait mindfulness and ratings of unpleasant and neutral pictures, or word ratings after aversive evaluative conditioning. Brown and colleagues [21] used evoked brain potentials (the late positive potential; LPP) as a measure of affective reactivity. They found that high self-reported trait mindfulness on the Mindful Attention Awareness Scale (MAAS) [23] was associated with low LPP amplitudes while viewing unpleasant pictures. Although this finding supports the idea that self-reported trait mindfulness reduces affective reactivity, other research employed similar designs but compared meditators and non-meditators directly rather than using self-reported trait mindfulness as an independent measure and did not replicate this finding [24, 25]. Because experienced meditators should ostensibly be more mindful than non-meditators, one would expect to find clear differences in LPP responses as a function of meditation experience. However, the available evidence is inconclusive. On the one hand, Sobolewski and colleagues [25] found experienced Buddhist meditators to have attenuated LPP amplitudes for unpleasant pictures, but the effect was found at left and right frontal electrodes rather than at centro-parietal sites where it is generally reported [26]. On the other hand, using a group of yogic meditators practicing in the Sudarshan Kriya tradition, Gootjes and colleagues [24] found no difference in LPP amplitudes to emotional pictures between meditators and non-meditators during a passive viewing task. While there are no obvious reasons for these inconclusive results for LPP in active meditators, it is nonetheless important to replicate findings by Brown et al. [21] and to even extend them, if possible. If it can be shown that trait mindfulness is associated with reduced LPP responses to emotional pictures versus neutral pictures (rather than just to unpleasant pictures per se), then these results would provide convincing evidence for a specific effect of trait mindfulness on affective reactivity. In sum, the current evidence that self-reported trait mindfulness is associated with decreased affective reactivity to emotional pictures is rather limited and mixed. The aim of the present study was to further investigate the relationship between self-reported trait mindfulness and affective reactivity to emotional pictures during passive picture viewing using multiple measures that comprehensively characterize affective reactivity. Participants rated trait mindfulness using two commonly used self-report scales, the MAAS [23] and FFMQ [22]. We used both scales as they are thought to measure different aspects of mindfulness and thus, they allowed us to separate the components thought to be related to self-regulation of attention (MAAS and the Acting with awareness subscale on the FFMQ) and attitude of acceptance (the subscales of Non-judging of inner experience and of Nonreactivity to inner experience on the FFMQ). In the study, participants completed a passive viewing task, looking at pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral pictures while electroencephalography (EEG), electromyography (EMG), and electrodermal measures were recorded. Participants heard sporadic loud bursts of white noise to evoke a startle response. Self-reported ratings of valence and arousal were collected while participants viewed the pictures a second time. In the present study, emotion was characterized in terms of valence and arousal. Emotion can be conceptualized in terms of discrete categories (e.g., fear, disgust, etc.) or in term of the motivational dimensions of valence and arousal [27]. According to the motivational model, unpleasant and pleasant pictures differ in their valence, and both unpleasant and pleasant pictures differ from neutral pictures in their arousal level. Because research has demonstrated clear effects of valence and arousal on different physiological and self-report measures [27], the present study adopted a motivational perspective on emotion. Further, because various dependent measures differ in their sensitivity to either valence or arousal [27], the predictions and data analyses were focused on either the valence effect (i.e., pleasant vs. unpleasant) or the arousal effect (i.e., pleasant + unpleasant combined vs. neutral) of emotion. To index valence effects, we measured self-reported valence ratings to the pictures and startle eyeblink responses during the pictures. The startle response is characterized in humans by muscular contractions in the torso and face, and indexes the activation of the defensive system [28]. Startle response amplitude is modulated by one’s affective state and can be conveniently recorded by measuring the amplitude of the eyeblink response to the startle probe [29]. The eyeblink amplitude, which is potentiated during negative affective states and attenuated during positive affective states, has been shown to be modulated particularly while viewing highly arousing emotional pictures [27]. Therefore, an effect of picture valence was predicted such that pleasant pictures would elicit more pleasant self-reported valence ratings than unpleasant pictures, whereas unpleasant pictures would elicit greater startle responses than pleasant pictures. Self-reported trait mindfulness was expected to moderate these effects with higher mindfulness being associated with smaller differences in arousal effects on valence ratings and startle responses. To index arousal effects (i.e., pleasant + unpleasant combined vs. neutral), we measured self-reported arousal to the pictures, skin conductance responses to picture onset, and three event-related potentials derived from the EEG: the early posterior negativity (EPN) and the late positive potential (LPP) to picture onset, and the P3 to startle onset. The skin conductance response (SCR) is regulated by the autonomic nervous system with sympathetic innervation of the sweat glands producing the skin conductance response [30]. As such, SCR can serve as a measure of sympathetic arousal [31]. The EPN is a relative negativity over occipito-temporal electrodes to arousing versus neutral pictures about 200 ms after picture onset. It appears to reflect a call for attentional resources [32]. The LPP is a positive deflection of the ERP waveform occurring at centro-parietal sites approximately 400 ms after picture onset. Although it may already be observed to neutral pictures per se, arousal effects on the LPP are apparent in the difference ERP waveforms to arousing versus neutral pictures [33]. This relative LPP is thought to index greater attention allocation to arousing pictures than to neutral pictures [34]. As such, EPN and LPP were used to measure the call, as well as the actual allocation, of attention to arousing versus neutral pictures. Lastly, the P3 component, which is a centro-parietal positivity approximately 300 ms after stimulus onset, indexes attention allocation and has been used in affect-modulated startle response paradigms to assess the relative allocation of attention to the startle probes versus pictures [35]. Specifically, the P3 to startle probes is reduced during viewing of arousing (unpleasant or pleasant) pictures versus neutral pictures [36, 37]. This is consistent with the idea that more attentional resources are drawn to arousing pictures than to neutral pictures and thus, that fewer attentional resources are available to process the additional startle probe during arousing than neutral pictures. Therefore, across participants, we expected to find a general effect of picture arousal on P3 amplitudes, with smaller P3 amplitudes to startle probes presented on trials in which arousing pictures were shown than when neutral pictures were shown. In sum, as a consequence of arousal effects, responses were expected to be greater for arousing than neutral pictures for self-reported arousal, skin conductance responses, and LPP. In contrast, responses were expected to be lower (i.e., less positive) for arousing than neutral pictures for the EPN and P3. Self-reported trait mindfulness was predicted to moderate these response differences with higher mindfulness being associated with relatively smaller response differences, indicating decreased affective reactivity.
What the sources say
- Not checked — no full text of the sourcecites [16] JJ Arch, 2006, Mechanisms of mindfulness: Emotion regulation following a focused breathing induction, Behav Res Ther source
- Not checked — no full text of the sourcecites [17] CNM Ortner, 2007, Mindfulness meditation and reduced emotional interference on a cognitive task, Motiv Emot source
- Supportedcites [18] VA Taylor, 2011, Impact of mindfulness on the neural responses to emotional pictures in experienced and beginner meditators, Neuroimage source
The Discussion reports that mindfulness attenuated the emotional intensity participants perceived from pictures across all valence categories. This supports decreased subjective reactivity to emotional pictures; the paper notes that neural responses differed between experienced and beginner meditators. (LLM, conf=0.91)
boostedstates an association- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
The sources with a verdict support this claim; the rest weren’t checked yet, have no full text we could read, or their verdicts aren’t rated yet.
In the paper
“Specifically, the P3 to startle probes is reduced during viewing of arousing (unpleasant or pleasant) pictures versus neutral pictures [36, 37].”
§ Self-Reported Trait Mindfulness and Affective Reactivity: A Motivational Approach Using Multiple Psychophysiological Measures > Introduction Scientific interest in mindfulness and mindfulness-based therapies to alleviate psychological distress and promote well-being has increased exponentially over the past 15 years. Mindfulness is a form of attention that is rooted in the present moment and is qualitatively receptive and non-reactive, and as such it is thought to facilitate emotion regulation [1]. In line with this, randomized controlled trials using the mindfulness-based intervention Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) [2] found that MBSR reduced symptoms of psychological distress, such as self-reported anxiety, depression, and stress, and improved self-reported positive affect, self-compassion, and satisfaction with life (for a review, see [3]). MBSR has also been associated with positive outcomes of emotion regulatory processes, such as reduced rumination [4] and decreased activation in brain regions implicated in self-referential processing and elaboration [5]. In addition, experienced meditators have reported lower levels of rumination and fewer difficulties in emotion regulation, compared to non-meditators [6]. Similarly, self-reported mindfulness has been positively correlated with self-reported use of adaptive emotion regulation strategies [7] and negatively correlated with self-reported difficulty in emotion regulation [8]. Together these findings support the notion that mindfulness is related to adaptive emotional responding, but the underlying mechanisms are not clearly understood. One suggested mechanism is that mindfulness facilitates disengagement from the affect-relevant stimulus and thereby decreases affective reactivity (i.e., one’s reaction in response to affect-relevant events) [9]. An affective response is characterized by several physiological components, including: threshold for reactivity, peak amplitude of response, rise time to peak, and recovery time [10]. Paying attention mindfully is proposed to facilitate disengagement from an emotion-provoking stimulus by attenuating the peak amplitude and speeding up recovery, thereby decreasing the overall emotional response [9]. This is in contrast to continued engagement with the stimulus, which may promote elaborative self-referential processing and rumination, processes which are associated with psychological distress [11]. Despite the proposed link between mindfulness and affective reactivity, mindfulness is a rich concept originating in ancient Buddhist traditions that is difficult to succinctly and adequately operationalize [12]. Within the context of Western science, mindfulness is often defined as the awareness generated through “paying attention in a particular way: on purpose, in the present moment, and non-judgmentally” (p. 4) [13]. Within the psychological literature, it is described as consisting of two components: self-regulation of attention, and orientation to one’s current experience with an attitude of curiosity, acceptance, and openness [14]. These two components are thought to work synergistically to facilitate disengagement from affect-relevant stimuli, leading to decreased reactivity [14]. Self-regulation of attention helps practitioners to focus in the present moment and to observe their current experience, including thoughts, feelings, perceptions, and bodily sensations. As attentional resources are limited, focusing attention on the current experience inhibits elaboration, rumination, and other self-referential processes [14]. That is not to say that experiences (thoughts, feelings, perceptions) are suppressed, but rather they are merely noted as mental events and not elaborated on further, keeping attention on current experience. This focus of attention in the present moment might also facilitate disengagement by increasing awareness of one's initial reactivity to a stimulus, allowing one to let go and return to the present moment [15]. The second component of mindfulness describes a particular orientation of curiosity, openness, and non-judgmentalness to all experiences. This attitude of acceptance of current experience, regardless of valence or desirability, is thought to reduce avoidant behaviors and facilitate decoupling of stimulus-response reactivity through exposure, such as in exposure therapy [15]. In addition, open observation of one’s experience can create space between the observer and their thoughts, feelings, and perceptions. Rather than seeing them as accurate judgments or reflections of self, they may be observed as transitory mental events that do not have to be identified with [14]. This distance during exposure is likely to facilitate disengagement as it weakens the typical, spontaneous emotional response tendencies to affect-relevant stimuli. In sum, being mindful may facilitate disengagement by maintaining attention in the present moment, thereby inhibiting elaborative processes, and by maintaining an attitude of acceptance, thereby creating distance between the stimulus and response that weakens habitual emotional response tendencies. Thus, mindfulness is thought to facilitate the development of dispositional nonreactivity [9]. Several studies have investigated effects of mindful states or mindfulness interventions on responses to emotional pictures. Results have supported the link between mindfulness and decreased reactivity to emotional pictures [16–18]. Arch and Craske [16] employed a 15-minute focused breathing induction and found that, compared to inductions of worry or unfocused attention, focused breathing was associated with decreased self-reported negative affect after passively viewing aversive pictures and greater willingness to engage with unpleasant pictures in a subsequent task. Ortner and colleagues [17] investigated effects of a 7-week mindfulness intervention on emotional responding. Participants were shown pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral pictures and performed two tasks. The first task was an emotional interference task (categorizing tones as high or low while viewing emotional and neutral pictures), and the second was a passive viewing task. Skin conductance responses and self-reported emotional intensity were collected as measures of affective reactivity. Mindfulness training was associated with decreased (post-intervention vs. pre-intervention) emotional interference while viewing unpleasant pictures, decreased self-reported emotional intensity while viewing pleasant and unpleasant pictures, and decreased skin conductance responses to pleasant and unpleasant pictures. Lastly, Taylor and colleagues [18] investigated mindful attention versus uninstructed attention to pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral pictures in novice and experienced meditators, and used self-reported ratings of emotional intensity after each picture as a measure of affective reactivity. For both novice and experienced meditators, mindful attention decreased self-reported emotional intensity to pleasant, neutral, and unpleasant pictures. Together, these findings support the hypothesis that mindfulness, when operationalized as a state or intervention, decreases affective reactivity while viewing emotional pictures. However, in the field of psychology, the term mindfulness is currently used in three ways: to describe a state, as in a mode of awareness entered during mindfulness meditation, an intervention, in which participants learn mindfulness meditation, and a trait, implying a stable quality that differs between individuals. Effects for mindfulness may differ depending on how it is conceptualized. The studies reviewed above [16–18] provide evidence of the relationship between mindfulness treated as a state or intervention and decreased affective reactivity to emotional pictures. In contrast, there is mixed evidence from studies on affective reactivity during passive picture viewing when mindfulness is treated a self-reported trait [19–21]. Ostafin and colleagues [19] found evidence supporting the relationship between self-reported trait mindfulness and reduced self-reported and behavioral measures of affective reactivity. Self-reported trait mindfulness was measured with the Acting with awareness and Non-judging of inner experience facets of the Five Facet Mindfulness Questionnaire (FFMQ) [22]. High self-reported trait mindfulness was associated with lower self-reported negative affect and accessibility of aversive words after a negative emotion induction using unpleasant pictures. In contrast, Sauer and colleagues [20] used a large sample (N = 247) and found no relationship between self-reported trait mindfulness and ratings of unpleasant and neutral pictures, or word ratings after aversive evaluative conditioning. Brown and colleagues [21] used evoked brain potentials (the late positive potential; LPP) as a measure of affective reactivity. They found that high self-reported trait mindfulness on the Mindful Attention Awareness Scale (MAAS) [23] was associated with low LPP amplitudes while viewing unpleasant pictures. Although this finding supports the idea that self-reported trait mindfulness reduces affective reactivity, other research employed similar designs but compared meditators and non-meditators directly rather than using self-reported trait mindfulness as an independent measure and did not replicate this finding [24, 25]. Because experienced meditators should ostensibly be more mindful than non-meditators, one would expect to find clear differences in LPP responses as a function of meditation experience. However, the available evidence is inconclusive. On the one hand, Sobolewski and colleagues [25] found experienced Buddhist meditators to have attenuated LPP amplitudes for unpleasant pictures, but the effect was found at left and right frontal electrodes rather than at centro-parietal sites where it is generally reported [26]. On the other hand, using a group of yogic meditators practicing in the Sudarshan Kriya tradition, Gootjes and colleagues [24] found no difference in LPP amplitudes to emotional pictures between meditators and non-meditators during a passive viewing task. While there are no obvious reasons for these inconclusive results for LPP in active meditators, it is nonetheless important to replicate findings by Brown et al. [21] and to even extend them, if possible. If it can be shown that trait mindfulness is associated with reduced LPP responses to emotional pictures versus neutral pictures (rather than just to unpleasant pictures per se), then these results would provide convincing evidence for a specific effect of trait mindfulness on affective reactivity. In sum, the current evidence that self-reported trait mindfulness is associated with decreased affective reactivity to emotional pictures is rather limited and mixed. The aim of the present study was to further investigate the relationship between self-reported trait mindfulness and affective reactivity to emotional pictures during passive picture viewing using multiple measures that comprehensively characterize affective reactivity. Participants rated trait mindfulness using two commonly used self-report scales, the MAAS [23] and FFMQ [22]. We used both scales as they are thought to measure different aspects of mindfulness and thus, they allowed us to separate the components thought to be related to self-regulation of attention (MAAS and the Acting with awareness subscale on the FFMQ) and attitude of acceptance (the subscales of Non-judging of inner experience and of Nonreactivity to inner experience on the FFMQ). In the study, participants completed a passive viewing task, looking at pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral pictures while electroencephalography (EEG), electromyography (EMG), and electrodermal measures were recorded. Participants heard sporadic loud bursts of white noise to evoke a startle response. Self-reported ratings of valence and arousal were collected while participants viewed the pictures a second time. In the present study, emotion was characterized in terms of valence and arousal. Emotion can be conceptualized in terms of discrete categories (e.g., fear, disgust, etc.) or in term of the motivational dimensions of valence and arousal [27]. According to the motivational model, unpleasant and pleasant pictures differ in their valence, and both unpleasant and pleasant pictures differ from neutral pictures in their arousal level. Because research has demonstrated clear effects of valence and arousal on different physiological and self-report measures [27], the present study adopted a motivational perspective on emotion. Further, because various dependent measures differ in their sensitivity to either valence or arousal [27], the predictions and data analyses were focused on either the valence effect (i.e., pleasant vs. unpleasant) or the arousal effect (i.e., pleasant + unpleasant combined vs. neutral) of emotion. To index valence effects, we measured self-reported valence ratings to the pictures and startle eyeblink responses during the pictures. The startle response is characterized in humans by muscular contractions in the torso and face, and indexes the activation of the defensive system [28]. Startle response amplitude is modulated by one’s affective state and can be conveniently recorded by measuring the amplitude of the eyeblink response to the startle probe [29]. The eyeblink amplitude, which is potentiated during negative affective states and attenuated during positive affective states, has been shown to be modulated particularly while viewing highly arousing emotional pictures [27]. Therefore, an effect of picture valence was predicted such that pleasant pictures would elicit more pleasant self-reported valence ratings than unpleasant pictures, whereas unpleasant pictures would elicit greater startle responses than pleasant pictures. Self-reported trait mindfulness was expected to moderate these effects with higher mindfulness being associated with smaller differences in arousal effects on valence ratings and startle responses. To index arousal effects (i.e., pleasant + unpleasant combined vs. neutral), we measured self-reported arousal to the pictures, skin conductance responses to picture onset, and three event-related potentials derived from the EEG: the early posterior negativity (EPN) and the late positive potential (LPP) to picture onset, and the P3 to startle onset. The skin conductance response (SCR) is regulated by the autonomic nervous system with sympathetic innervation of the sweat glands producing the skin conductance response [30]. As such, SCR can serve as a measure of sympathetic arousal [31]. The EPN is a relative negativity over occipito-temporal electrodes to arousing versus neutral pictures about 200 ms after picture onset. It appears to reflect a call for attentional resources [32]. The LPP is a positive deflection of the ERP waveform occurring at centro-parietal sites approximately 400 ms after picture onset. Although it may already be observed to neutral pictures per se, arousal effects on the LPP are apparent in the difference ERP waveforms to arousing versus neutral pictures [33]. This relative LPP is thought to index greater attention allocation to arousing pictures than to neutral pictures [34]. As such, EPN and LPP were used to measure the call, as well as the actual allocation, of attention to arousing versus neutral pictures. Lastly, the P3 component, which is a centro-parietal positivity approximately 300 ms after stimulus onset, indexes attention allocation and has been used in affect-modulated startle response paradigms to assess the relative allocation of attention to the startle probes versus pictures [35]. Specifically, the P3 to startle probes is reduced during viewing of arousing (unpleasant or pleasant) pictures versus neutral pictures [36, 37]. This is consistent with the idea that more attentional resources are drawn to arousing pictures than to neutral pictures and thus, that fewer attentional resources are available to process the additional startle probe during arousing than neutral pictures. Therefore, across participants, we expected to find a general effect of picture arousal on P3 amplitudes, with smaller P3 amplitudes to startle probes presented on trials in which arousing pictures were shown than when neutral pictures were shown. In sum, as a consequence of arousal effects, responses were expected to be greater for arousing than neutral pictures for self-reported arousal, skin conductance responses, and LPP. In contrast, responses were expected to be lower (i.e., less positive) for arousing than neutral pictures for the EPN and P3. Self-reported trait mindfulness was predicted to moderate these response differences with higher mindfulness being associated with relatively smaller response differences, indicating decreased affective reactivity.
What the sources say
- Supportedcites [36] A Keil, 2007, Cross-modal attention capture by affective stimuli: Evidence from event-related potentials, Cogn Affect Behav Neurosci source
The Abstract states that startle-probe P3 amplitude is reduced while participants view either pleasant or unpleasant pictures, compared with neutral pictures. The Stimuli and Design section identifies both pleasant and unpleasant pictures as more arousing than neutral pictures. (LLM, conf=0.95)
- Not checked — no full text of the sourcecites [37] MM Bradley, 2006, A multi-process account of startle modulation during affective perception, Psychophysiology source
plainstates a cause- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Supported
Every source the paper cites for this claim was checked and supports it.
In the paper
“Because research has demonstrated clear effects of valence and arousal on different physiological and self-report measures [27], the present study adopted a motivational perspective on emotion.”
§ Self-Reported Trait Mindfulness and Affective Reactivity: A Motivational Approach Using Multiple Psychophysiological Measures > Introduction Scientific interest in mindfulness and mindfulness-based therapies to alleviate psychological distress and promote well-being has increased exponentially over the past 15 years. Mindfulness is a form of attention that is rooted in the present moment and is qualitatively receptive and non-reactive, and as such it is thought to facilitate emotion regulation [1]. In line with this, randomized controlled trials using the mindfulness-based intervention Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) [2] found that MBSR reduced symptoms of psychological distress, such as self-reported anxiety, depression, and stress, and improved self-reported positive affect, self-compassion, and satisfaction with life (for a review, see [3]). MBSR has also been associated with positive outcomes of emotion regulatory processes, such as reduced rumination [4] and decreased activation in brain regions implicated in self-referential processing and elaboration [5]. In addition, experienced meditators have reported lower levels of rumination and fewer difficulties in emotion regulation, compared to non-meditators [6]. Similarly, self-reported mindfulness has been positively correlated with self-reported use of adaptive emotion regulation strategies [7] and negatively correlated with self-reported difficulty in emotion regulation [8]. Together these findings support the notion that mindfulness is related to adaptive emotional responding, but the underlying mechanisms are not clearly understood. One suggested mechanism is that mindfulness facilitates disengagement from the affect-relevant stimulus and thereby decreases affective reactivity (i.e., one’s reaction in response to affect-relevant events) [9]. An affective response is characterized by several physiological components, including: threshold for reactivity, peak amplitude of response, rise time to peak, and recovery time [10]. Paying attention mindfully is proposed to facilitate disengagement from an emotion-provoking stimulus by attenuating the peak amplitude and speeding up recovery, thereby decreasing the overall emotional response [9]. This is in contrast to continued engagement with the stimulus, which may promote elaborative self-referential processing and rumination, processes which are associated with psychological distress [11]. Despite the proposed link between mindfulness and affective reactivity, mindfulness is a rich concept originating in ancient Buddhist traditions that is difficult to succinctly and adequately operationalize [12]. Within the context of Western science, mindfulness is often defined as the awareness generated through “paying attention in a particular way: on purpose, in the present moment, and non-judgmentally” (p. 4) [13]. Within the psychological literature, it is described as consisting of two components: self-regulation of attention, and orientation to one’s current experience with an attitude of curiosity, acceptance, and openness [14]. These two components are thought to work synergistically to facilitate disengagement from affect-relevant stimuli, leading to decreased reactivity [14]. Self-regulation of attention helps practitioners to focus in the present moment and to observe their current experience, including thoughts, feelings, perceptions, and bodily sensations. As attentional resources are limited, focusing attention on the current experience inhibits elaboration, rumination, and other self-referential processes [14]. That is not to say that experiences (thoughts, feelings, perceptions) are suppressed, but rather they are merely noted as mental events and not elaborated on further, keeping attention on current experience. This focus of attention in the present moment might also facilitate disengagement by increasing awareness of one's initial reactivity to a stimulus, allowing one to let go and return to the present moment [15]. The second component of mindfulness describes a particular orientation of curiosity, openness, and non-judgmentalness to all experiences. This attitude of acceptance of current experience, regardless of valence or desirability, is thought to reduce avoidant behaviors and facilitate decoupling of stimulus-response reactivity through exposure, such as in exposure therapy [15]. In addition, open observation of one’s experience can create space between the observer and their thoughts, feelings, and perceptions. Rather than seeing them as accurate judgments or reflections of self, they may be observed as transitory mental events that do not have to be identified with [14]. This distance during exposure is likely to facilitate disengagement as it weakens the typical, spontaneous emotional response tendencies to affect-relevant stimuli. In sum, being mindful may facilitate disengagement by maintaining attention in the present moment, thereby inhibiting elaborative processes, and by maintaining an attitude of acceptance, thereby creating distance between the stimulus and response that weakens habitual emotional response tendencies. Thus, mindfulness is thought to facilitate the development of dispositional nonreactivity [9]. Several studies have investigated effects of mindful states or mindfulness interventions on responses to emotional pictures. Results have supported the link between mindfulness and decreased reactivity to emotional pictures [16–18]. Arch and Craske [16] employed a 15-minute focused breathing induction and found that, compared to inductions of worry or unfocused attention, focused breathing was associated with decreased self-reported negative affect after passively viewing aversive pictures and greater willingness to engage with unpleasant pictures in a subsequent task. Ortner and colleagues [17] investigated effects of a 7-week mindfulness intervention on emotional responding. Participants were shown pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral pictures and performed two tasks. The first task was an emotional interference task (categorizing tones as high or low while viewing emotional and neutral pictures), and the second was a passive viewing task. Skin conductance responses and self-reported emotional intensity were collected as measures of affective reactivity. Mindfulness training was associated with decreased (post-intervention vs. pre-intervention) emotional interference while viewing unpleasant pictures, decreased self-reported emotional intensity while viewing pleasant and unpleasant pictures, and decreased skin conductance responses to pleasant and unpleasant pictures. Lastly, Taylor and colleagues [18] investigated mindful attention versus uninstructed attention to pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral pictures in novice and experienced meditators, and used self-reported ratings of emotional intensity after each picture as a measure of affective reactivity. For both novice and experienced meditators, mindful attention decreased self-reported emotional intensity to pleasant, neutral, and unpleasant pictures. Together, these findings support the hypothesis that mindfulness, when operationalized as a state or intervention, decreases affective reactivity while viewing emotional pictures. However, in the field of psychology, the term mindfulness is currently used in three ways: to describe a state, as in a mode of awareness entered during mindfulness meditation, an intervention, in which participants learn mindfulness meditation, and a trait, implying a stable quality that differs between individuals. Effects for mindfulness may differ depending on how it is conceptualized. The studies reviewed above [16–18] provide evidence of the relationship between mindfulness treated as a state or intervention and decreased affective reactivity to emotional pictures. In contrast, there is mixed evidence from studies on affective reactivity during passive picture viewing when mindfulness is treated a self-reported trait [19–21]. Ostafin and colleagues [19] found evidence supporting the relationship between self-reported trait mindfulness and reduced self-reported and behavioral measures of affective reactivity. Self-reported trait mindfulness was measured with the Acting with awareness and Non-judging of inner experience facets of the Five Facet Mindfulness Questionnaire (FFMQ) [22]. High self-reported trait mindfulness was associated with lower self-reported negative affect and accessibility of aversive words after a negative emotion induction using unpleasant pictures. In contrast, Sauer and colleagues [20] used a large sample (N = 247) and found no relationship between self-reported trait mindfulness and ratings of unpleasant and neutral pictures, or word ratings after aversive evaluative conditioning. Brown and colleagues [21] used evoked brain potentials (the late positive potential; LPP) as a measure of affective reactivity. They found that high self-reported trait mindfulness on the Mindful Attention Awareness Scale (MAAS) [23] was associated with low LPP amplitudes while viewing unpleasant pictures. Although this finding supports the idea that self-reported trait mindfulness reduces affective reactivity, other research employed similar designs but compared meditators and non-meditators directly rather than using self-reported trait mindfulness as an independent measure and did not replicate this finding [24, 25]. Because experienced meditators should ostensibly be more mindful than non-meditators, one would expect to find clear differences in LPP responses as a function of meditation experience. However, the available evidence is inconclusive. On the one hand, Sobolewski and colleagues [25] found experienced Buddhist meditators to have attenuated LPP amplitudes for unpleasant pictures, but the effect was found at left and right frontal electrodes rather than at centro-parietal sites where it is generally reported [26]. On the other hand, using a group of yogic meditators practicing in the Sudarshan Kriya tradition, Gootjes and colleagues [24] found no difference in LPP amplitudes to emotional pictures between meditators and non-meditators during a passive viewing task. While there are no obvious reasons for these inconclusive results for LPP in active meditators, it is nonetheless important to replicate findings by Brown et al. [21] and to even extend them, if possible. If it can be shown that trait mindfulness is associated with reduced LPP responses to emotional pictures versus neutral pictures (rather than just to unpleasant pictures per se), then these results would provide convincing evidence for a specific effect of trait mindfulness on affective reactivity. In sum, the current evidence that self-reported trait mindfulness is associated with decreased affective reactivity to emotional pictures is rather limited and mixed. The aim of the present study was to further investigate the relationship between self-reported trait mindfulness and affective reactivity to emotional pictures during passive picture viewing using multiple measures that comprehensively characterize affective reactivity. Participants rated trait mindfulness using two commonly used self-report scales, the MAAS [23] and FFMQ [22]. We used both scales as they are thought to measure different aspects of mindfulness and thus, they allowed us to separate the components thought to be related to self-regulation of attention (MAAS and the Acting with awareness subscale on the FFMQ) and attitude of acceptance (the subscales of Non-judging of inner experience and of Nonreactivity to inner experience on the FFMQ). In the study, participants completed a passive viewing task, looking at pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral pictures while electroencephalography (EEG), electromyography (EMG), and electrodermal measures were recorded. Participants heard sporadic loud bursts of white noise to evoke a startle response. Self-reported ratings of valence and arousal were collected while participants viewed the pictures a second time. In the present study, emotion was characterized in terms of valence and arousal. Emotion can be conceptualized in terms of discrete categories (e.g., fear, disgust, etc.) or in term of the motivational dimensions of valence and arousal [27]. According to the motivational model, unpleasant and pleasant pictures differ in their valence, and both unpleasant and pleasant pictures differ from neutral pictures in their arousal level. Because research has demonstrated clear effects of valence and arousal on different physiological and self-report measures [27], the present study adopted a motivational perspective on emotion. Further, because various dependent measures differ in their sensitivity to either valence or arousal [27], the predictions and data analyses were focused on either the valence effect (i.e., pleasant vs. unpleasant) or the arousal effect (i.e., pleasant + unpleasant combined vs. neutral) of emotion. To index valence effects, we measured self-reported valence ratings to the pictures and startle eyeblink responses during the pictures. The startle response is characterized in humans by muscular contractions in the torso and face, and indexes the activation of the defensive system [28]. Startle response amplitude is modulated by one’s affective state and can be conveniently recorded by measuring the amplitude of the eyeblink response to the startle probe [29]. The eyeblink amplitude, which is potentiated during negative affective states and attenuated during positive affective states, has been shown to be modulated particularly while viewing highly arousing emotional pictures [27]. Therefore, an effect of picture valence was predicted such that pleasant pictures would elicit more pleasant self-reported valence ratings than unpleasant pictures, whereas unpleasant pictures would elicit greater startle responses than pleasant pictures. Self-reported trait mindfulness was expected to moderate these effects with higher mindfulness being associated with smaller differences in arousal effects on valence ratings and startle responses. To index arousal effects (i.e., pleasant + unpleasant combined vs. neutral), we measured self-reported arousal to the pictures, skin conductance responses to picture onset, and three event-related potentials derived from the EEG: the early posterior negativity (EPN) and the late positive potential (LPP) to picture onset, and the P3 to startle onset. The skin conductance response (SCR) is regulated by the autonomic nervous system with sympathetic innervation of the sweat glands producing the skin conductance response [30]. As such, SCR can serve as a measure of sympathetic arousal [31]. The EPN is a relative negativity over occipito-temporal electrodes to arousing versus neutral pictures about 200 ms after picture onset. It appears to reflect a call for attentional resources [32]. The LPP is a positive deflection of the ERP waveform occurring at centro-parietal sites approximately 400 ms after picture onset. Although it may already be observed to neutral pictures per se, arousal effects on the LPP are apparent in the difference ERP waveforms to arousing versus neutral pictures [33]. This relative LPP is thought to index greater attention allocation to arousing pictures than to neutral pictures [34]. As such, EPN and LPP were used to measure the call, as well as the actual allocation, of attention to arousing versus neutral pictures. Lastly, the P3 component, which is a centro-parietal positivity approximately 300 ms after stimulus onset, indexes attention allocation and has been used in affect-modulated startle response paradigms to assess the relative allocation of attention to the startle probes versus pictures [35]. Specifically, the P3 to startle probes is reduced during viewing of arousing (unpleasant or pleasant) pictures versus neutral pictures [36, 37]. This is consistent with the idea that more attentional resources are drawn to arousing pictures than to neutral pictures and thus, that fewer attentional resources are available to process the additional startle probe during arousing than neutral pictures. Therefore, across participants, we expected to find a general effect of picture arousal on P3 amplitudes, with smaller P3 amplitudes to startle probes presented on trials in which arousing pictures were shown than when neutral pictures were shown. In sum, as a consequence of arousal effects, responses were expected to be greater for arousing than neutral pictures for self-reported arousal, skin conductance responses, and LPP. In contrast, responses were expected to be lower (i.e., less positive) for arousing than neutral pictures for the EPN and P3. Self-reported trait mindfulness was predicted to moderate these response differences with higher mindfulness being associated with relatively smaller response differences, indicating decreased affective reactivity.
What the sources say
- Supportedcites [27] PJ Lang, 2010, Emotion and the motivational brain, Biol Psychol source
The Abstract (page not provided) identifies valence and arousal as the main factors in affective language. “Looking at pictures” (page not provided) reports that physiological responses differ between pleasant and unpleasant cues, while other responses increase as pictures are rated more arousing. Together, these passages support the claim about physiological and self-report measures. (LLM, conf=0.90)
boostedstates a cause- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Supported
Every source the paper cites for this claim was checked and supports it.
In the paper
“Although it may already be observed to neutral pictures per se, arousal effects on the LPP are apparent in the difference ERP waveforms to arousing versus neutral pictures [33].”
§ Self-Reported Trait Mindfulness and Affective Reactivity: A Motivational Approach Using Multiple Psychophysiological Measures > Introduction Scientific interest in mindfulness and mindfulness-based therapies to alleviate psychological distress and promote well-being has increased exponentially over the past 15 years. Mindfulness is a form of attention that is rooted in the present moment and is qualitatively receptive and non-reactive, and as such it is thought to facilitate emotion regulation [1]. In line with this, randomized controlled trials using the mindfulness-based intervention Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) [2] found that MBSR reduced symptoms of psychological distress, such as self-reported anxiety, depression, and stress, and improved self-reported positive affect, self-compassion, and satisfaction with life (for a review, see [3]). MBSR has also been associated with positive outcomes of emotion regulatory processes, such as reduced rumination [4] and decreased activation in brain regions implicated in self-referential processing and elaboration [5]. In addition, experienced meditators have reported lower levels of rumination and fewer difficulties in emotion regulation, compared to non-meditators [6]. Similarly, self-reported mindfulness has been positively correlated with self-reported use of adaptive emotion regulation strategies [7] and negatively correlated with self-reported difficulty in emotion regulation [8]. Together these findings support the notion that mindfulness is related to adaptive emotional responding, but the underlying mechanisms are not clearly understood. One suggested mechanism is that mindfulness facilitates disengagement from the affect-relevant stimulus and thereby decreases affective reactivity (i.e., one’s reaction in response to affect-relevant events) [9]. An affective response is characterized by several physiological components, including: threshold for reactivity, peak amplitude of response, rise time to peak, and recovery time [10]. Paying attention mindfully is proposed to facilitate disengagement from an emotion-provoking stimulus by attenuating the peak amplitude and speeding up recovery, thereby decreasing the overall emotional response [9]. This is in contrast to continued engagement with the stimulus, which may promote elaborative self-referential processing and rumination, processes which are associated with psychological distress [11]. Despite the proposed link between mindfulness and affective reactivity, mindfulness is a rich concept originating in ancient Buddhist traditions that is difficult to succinctly and adequately operationalize [12]. Within the context of Western science, mindfulness is often defined as the awareness generated through “paying attention in a particular way: on purpose, in the present moment, and non-judgmentally” (p. 4) [13]. Within the psychological literature, it is described as consisting of two components: self-regulation of attention, and orientation to one’s current experience with an attitude of curiosity, acceptance, and openness [14]. These two components are thought to work synergistically to facilitate disengagement from affect-relevant stimuli, leading to decreased reactivity [14]. Self-regulation of attention helps practitioners to focus in the present moment and to observe their current experience, including thoughts, feelings, perceptions, and bodily sensations. As attentional resources are limited, focusing attention on the current experience inhibits elaboration, rumination, and other self-referential processes [14]. That is not to say that experiences (thoughts, feelings, perceptions) are suppressed, but rather they are merely noted as mental events and not elaborated on further, keeping attention on current experience. This focus of attention in the present moment might also facilitate disengagement by increasing awareness of one's initial reactivity to a stimulus, allowing one to let go and return to the present moment [15]. The second component of mindfulness describes a particular orientation of curiosity, openness, and non-judgmentalness to all experiences. This attitude of acceptance of current experience, regardless of valence or desirability, is thought to reduce avoidant behaviors and facilitate decoupling of stimulus-response reactivity through exposure, such as in exposure therapy [15]. In addition, open observation of one’s experience can create space between the observer and their thoughts, feelings, and perceptions. Rather than seeing them as accurate judgments or reflections of self, they may be observed as transitory mental events that do not have to be identified with [14]. This distance during exposure is likely to facilitate disengagement as it weakens the typical, spontaneous emotional response tendencies to affect-relevant stimuli. In sum, being mindful may facilitate disengagement by maintaining attention in the present moment, thereby inhibiting elaborative processes, and by maintaining an attitude of acceptance, thereby creating distance between the stimulus and response that weakens habitual emotional response tendencies. Thus, mindfulness is thought to facilitate the development of dispositional nonreactivity [9]. Several studies have investigated effects of mindful states or mindfulness interventions on responses to emotional pictures. Results have supported the link between mindfulness and decreased reactivity to emotional pictures [16–18]. Arch and Craske [16] employed a 15-minute focused breathing induction and found that, compared to inductions of worry or unfocused attention, focused breathing was associated with decreased self-reported negative affect after passively viewing aversive pictures and greater willingness to engage with unpleasant pictures in a subsequent task. Ortner and colleagues [17] investigated effects of a 7-week mindfulness intervention on emotional responding. Participants were shown pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral pictures and performed two tasks. The first task was an emotional interference task (categorizing tones as high or low while viewing emotional and neutral pictures), and the second was a passive viewing task. Skin conductance responses and self-reported emotional intensity were collected as measures of affective reactivity. Mindfulness training was associated with decreased (post-intervention vs. pre-intervention) emotional interference while viewing unpleasant pictures, decreased self-reported emotional intensity while viewing pleasant and unpleasant pictures, and decreased skin conductance responses to pleasant and unpleasant pictures. Lastly, Taylor and colleagues [18] investigated mindful attention versus uninstructed attention to pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral pictures in novice and experienced meditators, and used self-reported ratings of emotional intensity after each picture as a measure of affective reactivity. For both novice and experienced meditators, mindful attention decreased self-reported emotional intensity to pleasant, neutral, and unpleasant pictures. Together, these findings support the hypothesis that mindfulness, when operationalized as a state or intervention, decreases affective reactivity while viewing emotional pictures. However, in the field of psychology, the term mindfulness is currently used in three ways: to describe a state, as in a mode of awareness entered during mindfulness meditation, an intervention, in which participants learn mindfulness meditation, and a trait, implying a stable quality that differs between individuals. Effects for mindfulness may differ depending on how it is conceptualized. The studies reviewed above [16–18] provide evidence of the relationship between mindfulness treated as a state or intervention and decreased affective reactivity to emotional pictures. In contrast, there is mixed evidence from studies on affective reactivity during passive picture viewing when mindfulness is treated a self-reported trait [19–21]. Ostafin and colleagues [19] found evidence supporting the relationship between self-reported trait mindfulness and reduced self-reported and behavioral measures of affective reactivity. Self-reported trait mindfulness was measured with the Acting with awareness and Non-judging of inner experience facets of the Five Facet Mindfulness Questionnaire (FFMQ) [22]. High self-reported trait mindfulness was associated with lower self-reported negative affect and accessibility of aversive words after a negative emotion induction using unpleasant pictures. In contrast, Sauer and colleagues [20] used a large sample (N = 247) and found no relationship between self-reported trait mindfulness and ratings of unpleasant and neutral pictures, or word ratings after aversive evaluative conditioning. Brown and colleagues [21] used evoked brain potentials (the late positive potential; LPP) as a measure of affective reactivity. They found that high self-reported trait mindfulness on the Mindful Attention Awareness Scale (MAAS) [23] was associated with low LPP amplitudes while viewing unpleasant pictures. Although this finding supports the idea that self-reported trait mindfulness reduces affective reactivity, other research employed similar designs but compared meditators and non-meditators directly rather than using self-reported trait mindfulness as an independent measure and did not replicate this finding [24, 25]. Because experienced meditators should ostensibly be more mindful than non-meditators, one would expect to find clear differences in LPP responses as a function of meditation experience. However, the available evidence is inconclusive. On the one hand, Sobolewski and colleagues [25] found experienced Buddhist meditators to have attenuated LPP amplitudes for unpleasant pictures, but the effect was found at left and right frontal electrodes rather than at centro-parietal sites where it is generally reported [26]. On the other hand, using a group of yogic meditators practicing in the Sudarshan Kriya tradition, Gootjes and colleagues [24] found no difference in LPP amplitudes to emotional pictures between meditators and non-meditators during a passive viewing task. While there are no obvious reasons for these inconclusive results for LPP in active meditators, it is nonetheless important to replicate findings by Brown et al. [21] and to even extend them, if possible. If it can be shown that trait mindfulness is associated with reduced LPP responses to emotional pictures versus neutral pictures (rather than just to unpleasant pictures per se), then these results would provide convincing evidence for a specific effect of trait mindfulness on affective reactivity. In sum, the current evidence that self-reported trait mindfulness is associated with decreased affective reactivity to emotional pictures is rather limited and mixed. The aim of the present study was to further investigate the relationship between self-reported trait mindfulness and affective reactivity to emotional pictures during passive picture viewing using multiple measures that comprehensively characterize affective reactivity. Participants rated trait mindfulness using two commonly used self-report scales, the MAAS [23] and FFMQ [22]. We used both scales as they are thought to measure different aspects of mindfulness and thus, they allowed us to separate the components thought to be related to self-regulation of attention (MAAS and the Acting with awareness subscale on the FFMQ) and attitude of acceptance (the subscales of Non-judging of inner experience and of Nonreactivity to inner experience on the FFMQ). In the study, participants completed a passive viewing task, looking at pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral pictures while electroencephalography (EEG), electromyography (EMG), and electrodermal measures were recorded. Participants heard sporadic loud bursts of white noise to evoke a startle response. Self-reported ratings of valence and arousal were collected while participants viewed the pictures a second time. In the present study, emotion was characterized in terms of valence and arousal. Emotion can be conceptualized in terms of discrete categories (e.g., fear, disgust, etc.) or in term of the motivational dimensions of valence and arousal [27]. According to the motivational model, unpleasant and pleasant pictures differ in their valence, and both unpleasant and pleasant pictures differ from neutral pictures in their arousal level. Because research has demonstrated clear effects of valence and arousal on different physiological and self-report measures [27], the present study adopted a motivational perspective on emotion. Further, because various dependent measures differ in their sensitivity to either valence or arousal [27], the predictions and data analyses were focused on either the valence effect (i.e., pleasant vs. unpleasant) or the arousal effect (i.e., pleasant + unpleasant combined vs. neutral) of emotion. To index valence effects, we measured self-reported valence ratings to the pictures and startle eyeblink responses during the pictures. The startle response is characterized in humans by muscular contractions in the torso and face, and indexes the activation of the defensive system [28]. Startle response amplitude is modulated by one’s affective state and can be conveniently recorded by measuring the amplitude of the eyeblink response to the startle probe [29]. The eyeblink amplitude, which is potentiated during negative affective states and attenuated during positive affective states, has been shown to be modulated particularly while viewing highly arousing emotional pictures [27]. Therefore, an effect of picture valence was predicted such that pleasant pictures would elicit more pleasant self-reported valence ratings than unpleasant pictures, whereas unpleasant pictures would elicit greater startle responses than pleasant pictures. Self-reported trait mindfulness was expected to moderate these effects with higher mindfulness being associated with smaller differences in arousal effects on valence ratings and startle responses. To index arousal effects (i.e., pleasant + unpleasant combined vs. neutral), we measured self-reported arousal to the pictures, skin conductance responses to picture onset, and three event-related potentials derived from the EEG: the early posterior negativity (EPN) and the late positive potential (LPP) to picture onset, and the P3 to startle onset. The skin conductance response (SCR) is regulated by the autonomic nervous system with sympathetic innervation of the sweat glands producing the skin conductance response [30]. As such, SCR can serve as a measure of sympathetic arousal [31]. The EPN is a relative negativity over occipito-temporal electrodes to arousing versus neutral pictures about 200 ms after picture onset. It appears to reflect a call for attentional resources [32]. The LPP is a positive deflection of the ERP waveform occurring at centro-parietal sites approximately 400 ms after picture onset. Although it may already be observed to neutral pictures per se, arousal effects on the LPP are apparent in the difference ERP waveforms to arousing versus neutral pictures [33]. This relative LPP is thought to index greater attention allocation to arousing pictures than to neutral pictures [34]. As such, EPN and LPP were used to measure the call, as well as the actual allocation, of attention to arousing versus neutral pictures. Lastly, the P3 component, which is a centro-parietal positivity approximately 300 ms after stimulus onset, indexes attention allocation and has been used in affect-modulated startle response paradigms to assess the relative allocation of attention to the startle probes versus pictures [35]. Specifically, the P3 to startle probes is reduced during viewing of arousing (unpleasant or pleasant) pictures versus neutral pictures [36, 37]. This is consistent with the idea that more attentional resources are drawn to arousing pictures than to neutral pictures and thus, that fewer attentional resources are available to process the additional startle probe during arousing than neutral pictures. Therefore, across participants, we expected to find a general effect of picture arousal on P3 amplitudes, with smaller P3 amplitudes to startle probes presented on trials in which arousing pictures were shown than when neutral pictures were shown. In sum, as a consequence of arousal effects, responses were expected to be greater for arousing than neutral pictures for self-reported arousal, skin conductance responses, and LPP. In contrast, responses were expected to be lower (i.e., less positive) for arousing than neutral pictures for the EPN and P3. Self-reported trait mindfulness was predicted to moderate these response differences with higher mindfulness being associated with relatively smaller response differences, indicating decreased affective reactivity.
What the sources say
- Supportedcites [33] S Wiens, 2013, Directed attention reduces processing of emotional distracters irrespective of valence and arousal level, Biol Psychol source
The Introduction states that the LPP is a positive amplitude difference between emotional and neutral pictures and notes that an LPP can also be observed for neutral pictures. It also reports that LPP amplitude increases with arousal, supporting the citing sentence's description of arousal effects in difference waveforms. (LLM, conf=0.92)
plainstates a cause- Asserted: passes — The authors put it forward as true.
- Checkable: passes — It can be checked against evidence.
- Load-bearing: passes — The paper’s conclusions depend on it.
- Based: passes — The paper gives a reason why it holds.
- Supported
31 more claims · 3 with their cited sources checked
Create a free account to see all 133 claims and to verify the 3 references still open.
- Probably not a substantial claim. 60
- It may state two separate claims as one. 59
- The quote only partly states this claim. 3
Statistics recomputed
Every reported test result, recomputed from its test statistic and degrees of freedom. A result shows as not adding up only once an independent check has confirmed it.
- ConsistentF(1, 49) = 6.6reported p < .013 · recomputed p = .013
“F(1, 49) = 6.6, p < .013”
- ConsistentF(2, 98) = 4.8reported p = .033 · recomputed p = .010
“F(2, 98) = 4.8, p = .033”
The paper states a sphericity correction
Self-check
Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.
Self-check results appear here once an independent check has confirmed them.
Citations
Cites
(1970) · Cited by 24,983
The benefits of being present: Mindfulness and its role in psychological well-being
Brown, K. W., & Ryan, R. M. (2003) · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology · doi:10.1037/0022-3514.84.4.822 · Cited by 13,448
Psychometric properties of the Beck Depression Inventory: Twenty-five years of evaluation
Beck, A. T., Steer, R. A., & Carbin, M. G. (1988) · Clinical Psychology Review · doi:10.1016/0272-7358(88)90050-5 · Cited by 11,696
Oostenveld, R., Fries, P., Maris, E., & Schoffelen, J.-M. (2011) · Computational Intelligence and Neuroscience · doi:10.1155/2011/156869 · Cited by 10,323 · cited 2×
“All physiological data was processed offline using MATLAB (version R2013b, The MathWorks Inc., Natick, Massachusetts, http://www. mathworks.com).”
MethodMeasuring emotion: The self-assessment manikin and the semantic differential
Bradley, M. M., & Lang, P. J. (1994) · Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry · doi:10.1016/0005-7916(94)90063-9 · Cited by 9,538
Using Self-Report Assessment Methods to Explore Facets of Mindfulness
Baer, R. A., Smith, G. T., Hopkins, J., Krietemeyer, J., & Toney, L. (2006) · Assessment · doi:10.1177/1073191105283504 · Cited by 7,511 · cited 5×
“Self-reported trait mindfulness was assessed using two self-report scales: the Mindfulness Awareness Attention Scale (MAAS) [23] and the Five Facet Mindfulness Questionnaire (FFMQ) [22].”
BackgroundMethodInfluentialMindfulness: A proposed operational definition.
Bishop, S. R., Lau, M., Shapiro, S., Carlson, L., Anderson, N. D., Carmody, J., Segal, Z. V., Abbey, S., Speca, M., Velting, D., et al. (2004) · Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice · doi:10.1093/clipsy.bph077 · Cited by 7,234 · cited 3×
“Within the psychological literature, it is described as consisting of two components: self-regulation of attention, and orientation to one’s current experience with an attitude of curiosity, acceptance, and openness [14].”
BackgroundInfluential(2005) · Cited by 5,977
(2005) · CTIT technical reports series · Cited by 5,307
(2001) · doi:10.1017/cbo9780511546396 · Cited by 4,482
Cited by
Carpenter, J. K., Conroy, K., Gomez, A. F., Curren, L. C., & Hofmann, S. G. (2019) · Clinical Psychology Review · doi:10.1016/j.cpr.2019.101785 · Cited by 342
A Critical Analysis on Characterizing the Meditation Experience Through the Electroencephalogram
Deolindo, C. S., Ribeiro, M. W., Aratanha, M. A., Afonso, R. F., Irrmischer, M., & Kozasa, E. H. (2020) · Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience · doi:10.3389/fnsys.2020.00053 · Cited by 96
Jaiswal, S., Tsai, S., Juan, C.-H., Liang, W., & Muggleton, N. G. (2018) · Frontiers in Psychology · doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2018.00627 · Cited by 56
“For instance, there are two independent studies on trait mindfulness in which one reported that dispositional mindfulness could successfully predict emotional reactivity (Brown et al., 2013), while other reported that it could not (Cosme and Wiens, 2015).”
BackgroundRaugh, I. M., & Strauss, G. P. (2024) · Emotion · doi:10.1037/emo0001308 · Cited by 47
Differential effects of state and trait mindfulness on the late positive potential.
Egan, R., Hill, K. E., & Foti, D. (2017) · Emotion · doi:10.1037/emo0000383 · Cited by 37
Metadata
- Authors
- Cosme, D., & Wiens, S.
- Affiliations
- Stockholm University (SE)
- Corresponding author
- Cosme, Danielle
- Wiens, Stefan
- Venue
- PLoS ONE
- Publisher
- Public Library of Science (PLoS)
- Published
- 2015-03-06
- Volume
- 10
- Issue
- 3
- Pages
- e0119466
- ISSN
- 1932-6203 (ISSN-L)
- PMC
- PMC4352075
- OpenAlex
- W2011781987
- Cited by
- 27
- References
- 65
- Citations by year
- 2026: 1 · 2025: 2 · 2024: 2 · 2023: 3 · 2021: 5 · 2020: 6 · 2019: 3 · 2018: 3 · 2017: 2
- FWCI
- 2.07
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- gold
- doi.org
- Licence
- Locations
- PLoS ONE (publishedVersion, cc-by)
- Europe PMC (PubMed Central) (publishedVersion, cc-by)
- PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
- PubMed (publishedVersion)
- DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) (submittedVersion, cc-by-sa)
- Figshare (submittedVersion, cc-by)
- Funders
- Vetenskapsrådet
- Stockholms Universitet
- Topics
- Social Sciences › Psychology › Clinical Psychology › Mindfulness and Compassion Interventions
- Social Sciences › Psychology › Social Psychology › Psychological Well-being and Life Satisfaction
- Health Sciences › Medicine › Psychiatry and Mental health › Psychosomatic Disorders and Their Treatments
- Keywords
- trait mindfulness, emotional reactivity, individual differences, emotional pictures, early posterior negativity, late positive potential, P300, skin conductance response, attentional disengagement, IAP
- MeSH terms
- Adult, Electroencephalography, Emotions, Female, Humans, Male, Middle Aged, Visual Perception, Self Report, Mindfulness
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
The claim verdicts this report counts are experimental: their accuracy is not yet measured.
A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-10-11, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).
A second model labelled each claim on 2026-10-11 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).
Cited sources are checked with a language model’s help (gpt-6-sol).
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
How to cite
Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.
- This page
- CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Self-Reported Trait Mindfulness and Affective Reactivity: A Motivational Approach Using Multiple Psychophysiological Measures. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1371/journal.pone.0119466
- The paper
- Cosme, D., & Wiens, S. (2015). Self-Reported Trait Mindfulness and Affective Reactivity: A Motivational Approach Using Multiple Psychophysiological Measures. PLoS ONE. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0119466
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.