Student or educator? Sign up with your school email and get 6 months of Pro free.
CoChat

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 90 of the 90 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

Why Does Space Feel the Way it Does? Towards a Principled Account of Spatial Experience

Open access
Haun, Andrew, Tononi, Giulio · 2019 · Entropy

Abstract

There must be a reason why an experience feels the way it does. A good place to begin addressing this question is spatial experience, because it may be more penetrable by introspection than other qualities of consciousness such as color or pain. Moreover, much of experience is spatial, from that of our body to the visual world, which appears as if painted on an extended canvas in front of our eyes. Because it is ‘right there’, we usually take space for granted and overlook its qualitative properties. However, we should realize that a great number of phenomenal distinctions and relations are required for the canvas of space to feel ‘extended’. Here we argue that, to be experienced as extended, the canvas of space must be composed of countless spots, here and there, small and large, and these spots must be related to each other in a characteristic manner through connection, fusion, and inclusion. Other aspects of the structure of spatial experience follow from extendedness: every spot can be experienced as enclosing a particular region, with its particular location, size, boundary, and distance from other spots. We then propose an account of the phenomenal properties of spatial experiences based on integrated information theory (IIT). The theory provides a principled approach for characterizing both the quantity and quality of experience by unfolding the cause-effect structure of a physical substrate. Specifically, we show that a simple simulated substrate of units connected in a grid-like manner yields a cause-effect structure whose properties can account for the main properties of spatial experience. These results uphold the hypothesis that our experience of space is supported by brain areas whose units are linked by a grid-like connectivity. They also predict that changes in connectivity, even in the absence of changes in activity, should lead to a warping of experienced space. To the extent that this approach provides an initial account of phenomenal space, it may also serve as a starting point for investigating other aspects of the quality of experience and their physical correspondents.

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.3390/e21121160

Cites

90 of 90 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Figures

Figure A1 The causal properties underlying the dimensionality of spatial structures. (A) An idealized 1D distinction ABCDEFG is refined through recursive fusion-down to the distinctions {ABC,CDE,DEF,EFG}. (B) Note that, in this refinement of ABCDEFG, every distinction is related to some other distinction by a 2nd-order connection relation. For 1D distinctions in general, every refinement is such that a distinction is always related to some other distinction by a 2nd-order connection relation; furthermore, there is always at least one refinement with no connection relations of order > 2. These two constraints characterize distinctions belonging to a 1D space. (C) An idealized 2D distinction ABCDEFGHIJKL is refined to the distinctions {CFJ, CEIJ, ABCDEFLK, BDEGH}. (D) Note that, in this refinement of ABCDEFGHIJKL, every distinction is related to some other distinction by a 3rd-order connection relation. For 2D distinctions in general, every refinement is such that a distinction is always related to some other distinction by a 3rd-order connection relation; furthermore, there is always at least one refinement with no connection relations of order >3. These two constraints characterize distinctions belonging to a 2D space. The dimensionality of extendedness corresponds to the prescribed order of the connection relation minus 1 and is a close analogue of the Lebesgue covering dimension of classical topology, as described in Appendix C.
Figure A1 The causal properties underlying the dimensionality of spatial structures. (A) An idealized 1D distinction ABCDEFG is refined through recursive fusion-down to the distinctions {ABC,CDE,DEF,EFG}. (B) Note that, in this refinement of ABCDEFG, every distinction is related to some other distinction by a 2nd-order connection relation. For 1D distinctions in general, every refinement is such that a distinction is always related to some other distinction by a 2nd-order connection relation; furthermore, there is always at least one refinement with no connection relations of order > 2. These two constraints characterize distinctions belonging to a 1D space. (C) An idealized 2D distinction ABCDEFGHIJKL is refined to the distinctions {CFJ, CEIJ, ABCDEFLK, BDEGH}. (D) Note that, in this refinement of ABCDEFGHIJKL, every distinction is related to some other distinction by a 3rd-order connection relation. For 2D distinctions in general, every refinement is such that a distinction is always related to some other distinction by a 3rd-order connection relation; furthermore, there is always at least one refinement with no connection relations of order >3. These two constraints characterize distinctions belonging to a 2D space. The dimensionality of extendedness corresponds to the prescribed order of the connection relation minus 1 and is a close analogue of the Lebesgue covering dimension of classical topology, as described in Appendix C.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 1 Phenomenology of spatial experience. (A) The extended canvas of the night sky. (B) Spots. Within the canvas, one can distinguish ‘spots’ (dashed outlines) anywhere and of any size (indicated by different colors of the dashing). (C) Fundamental properties of the phenomenal structure of spatial experience. Every spot overlaps itself and relates to other spots in a way that is characteristically extended: (a) they are connected with other partially overlapping spots (light brown) so that their intersection is also a spot (red); (b) they are fused with other partially overlapping spots (light brown) so that their union is also a spot (blue). (c) they include other spots, both up (blue) and down (red); (D) Sub-structures of spatial experience. Clock-wise from the top: a spot’s region is given by the spots it includes; its location by the spots that include it; its size by the number of spots in its region; its boundary by the set of smallest spots that connect to it; the distance between two spots by the smallest spot that extends to both; spots can encompass a inhomogeneity in the structure of space and they can be highlighted by the spotlight of attention. (photo credit, ESO/S.Brunier).
Figure 1 Phenomenology of spatial experience. (A) The extended canvas of the night sky. (B) Spots. Within the canvas, one can distinguish ‘spots’ (dashed outlines) anywhere and of any size (indicated by different colors of the dashing). (C) Fundamental properties of the phenomenal structure of spatial experience. Every spot overlaps itself and relates to other spots in a way that is characteristically extended: (a) they are connected with other partially overlapping spots (light brown) so that their intersection is also a spot (red); (b) they are fused with other partially overlapping spots (light brown) so that their union is also a spot (blue). (c) they include other spots, both up (blue) and down (red); (D) Sub-structures of spatial experience. Clock-wise from the top: a spot’s region is given by the spots it includes; its location by the spots that include it; its size by the number of spots in its region; its boundary by the set of smallest spots that connect to it; the distance between two spots by the smallest spot that extends to both; spots can encompass a inhomogeneity in the structure of space and they can be highlighted by the spotlight of attention. (photo credit, ESO/S.Brunier).CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 2 A grid, its units and states. (A) An 8-unit 1D grid network. Each unit is strongly connected to itself and weakly connected to its immediate neighbors, except for the two end units. (B) The activation rule for units in the grid. The current state of the inputs (1 for ‘On’ and 0 for ‘Off’) is weighted and summed by each unit to produce a probability of the unit’s output being On. Except for the end units, each grid unit has six distinct input levels producing different activation probabilities (blue dots), following a Naka-Rushton function of the input strength (continuous line). (C) The causal directed acyclic graph (DAG) of the grid. (D) Transition probability matrix (TPM) showing the probability with which the grid transitions from each possible current state (y-axis) to each possible output state (x-axis). (E) A close-up of the TPM shows that while the network prefers to stay in its current state, it can also drift into other states.
Figure 2 A grid, its units and states. (A) An 8-unit 1D grid network. Each unit is strongly connected to itself and weakly connected to its immediate neighbors, except for the two end units. (B) The activation rule for units in the grid. The current state of the inputs (1 for ‘On’ and 0 for ‘Off’) is weighted and summed by each unit to produce a probability of the unit’s output being On. Except for the end units, each grid unit has six distinct input levels producing different activation probabilities (blue dots), following a Naka-Rushton function of the input strength (continuous line). (C) The causal directed acyclic graph (DAG) of the grid. (D) Transition probability matrix (TPM) showing the probability with which the grid transitions from each possible current state (y-axis) to each possible output state (x-axis). (E) A close-up of the TPM shows that while the network prefers to stay in its current state, it can also drift into other states.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 3 Characterization of a causal distinction. (A) Any subset of units can be considered as a candidate mechanism. One such candidate mechanism, illustrated here (in pink), is constituted by units CD in the current state CD = [0, 0] (0 in white and 1 in yellow). Any subset of units in a state can be considered as a candidate cause (in brown) or effect (in green). (B) Four candidate effect purviews. Each effect is represented as the probability p of a future state of a subset of units (a purview) given the current state of the mechanism, for example for CDout = [0, 0], p = 0.996. (C) For each effect purview, the mechanism is partitioned (red dashed line) in the way that minimizes the difference between unpartitioned and partitioned effects. Each partitioned effect is represented as pMIP. (D) The intrinsic difference d between the partitioned and unpartitioned effects for the four candidate effects. The maximally-irreducible effect (the effect for which d is maximal) is CDout = [0, 0].
Figure 3 Characterization of a causal distinction. (A) Any subset of units can be considered as a candidate mechanism. One such candidate mechanism, illustrated here (in pink), is constituted by units CD in the current state CD = [0, 0] (0 in white and 1 in yellow). Any subset of units in a state can be considered as a candidate cause (in brown) or effect (in green). (B) Four candidate effect purviews. Each effect is represented as the probability p of a future state of a subset of units (a purview) given the current state of the mechanism, for example for CDout = [0, 0], p = 0.996. (C) For each effect purview, the mechanism is partitioned (red dashed line) in the way that minimizes the difference between unpartitioned and partitioned effects. Each partitioned effect is represented as pMIP. (D) The intrinsic difference d between the partitioned and unpartitioned effects for the four candidate effects. The maximally-irreducible effect (the effect for which d is maximal) is CDout = [0, 0].CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 4 Causal distinctions specified by the 1D grid in the all-Off state. (A) The grid specifies 133 maximally irreducible distinctions. The pink array represents the mechanisms for each maximally irreducible distinction. Four examples are shown in DAG form. For each example, the mechanism, cause, and effect states are indicated by the colors of the units (in white for state 0). (B) The remaining 122 candidate mechanisms are reducible. (C,D) Two examples of reducible mechanisms are shown in DAG form.
Figure 4 Causal distinctions specified by the 1D grid in the all-Off state. (A) The grid specifies 133 maximally irreducible distinctions. The pink array represents the mechanisms for each maximally irreducible distinction. Four examples are shown in DAG form. For each example, the mechanism, cause, and effect states are indicated by the colors of the units (in white for state 0). (B) The remaining 122 candidate mechanisms are reducible. (C,D) Two examples of reducible mechanisms are shown in DAG form.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 5 Characterization of a causal relation. (A) Two effects BCD/<BCDout> and CDE/<CDEout>. (B) These two effects are congruent over the units CD = [0, 0]. This allows for three candidate intrinsic overlaps, C = [0], D = [0], and CD = [0, 0]. (C) The candidate relation is partitioned so as to minimize the difference between the unpartitioned and partitioned causes and effects. (D) For each candidate overlap, the intrinsic difference is assessed on each effect involved, and these are summed over causes and effects. (E) The overlap CD = [0, 0] is maximally irreducible (in purple), so this is the overlap that exists intrinsically for these two effects, binding them together.
Figure 5 Characterization of a causal relation. (A) Two effects BCD/<BCDout> and CDE/<CDEout>. (B) These two effects are congruent over the units CD = [0, 0]. This allows for three candidate intrinsic overlaps, C = [0], D = [0], and CD = [0, 0]. (C) The candidate relation is partitioned so as to minimize the difference between the unpartitioned and partitioned causes and effects. (D) For each candidate overlap, the intrinsic difference is assessed on each effect involved, and these are summed over causes and effects. (E) The overlap CD = [0, 0] is maximally irreducible (in purple), so this is the overlap that exists intrinsically for these two effects, binding them together.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 6 The cause-effect structure specified by the 1D grid in the all-Off state (only 2nd and 3rd order relations are displayed). All 133 distinctions specified by the grid have been projected to unique 3D coordinates using t-SNE over the mechanism labels. The labels at each vertex stand for the union of the cause- and effect- purviews for that distinction. Each edge between 2 vertices represents a complete 2nd-order relation. Each face among 3 vertices represents a complete 3rd-order relation. Labels font size is proportional to the sum of φRelation for all the individual between-distinction relations. Face colors are assigned randomly. The inset at the upper right illustrates in more detail the relations among distinctions E, DE, and CDE.
Figure 6 The cause-effect structure specified by the 1D grid in the all-Off state (only 2nd and 3rd order relations are displayed). All 133 distinctions specified by the grid have been projected to unique 3D coordinates using t-SNE over the mechanism labels. The labels at each vertex stand for the union of the cause- and effect- purviews for that distinction. Each edge between 2 vertices represents a complete 2nd-order relation. Each face among 3 vertices represents a complete 3rd-order relation. Labels font size is proportional to the sum of φRelation for all the individual between-distinction relations. Face colors are assigned randomly. The inset at the upper right illustrates in more detail the relations among distinctions E, DE, and CDE.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 7 Extendedness of distinctions. (A) Grid distinctions are related by connection: for example, the distinction specified by mechanism CDE is connected to distinction DEF via distinction DE. CDE also connects the distinctions BCDE and CDEF. (B) A scatterplot of distinctions from the grid’s cause-effect structure. The axes are a 2D t-SNE projection of the distinction units. Each marker is labeled with the purview over which the distinction relates to itself. A grid distinction (gold) is connected with many other distinctions (open circles) through many other distinctions (olive), and it connects many other distinctions (pale brown). (C) Grid distinctions are related by fusion: for example, CDE is fused with DEF by CDEF. CDE also fuses CD and DE. (D) A grid distinction is fused with many other distinctions (open circles) into many other distinctions (olive), and it fuses many more (pale brown). (E) Grid distinctions are related by inclusion: for example, CDE is included by CDEF (in blue) and includes DE (in red). Some distinctions are mutually included (in gold). (F) Grid distinctions include (red) and are included by (blue) many other distinctions in the cause-effect structure. Note that CDE also mutually includes several other distinctions (BDE and CDF) that have the same cause-effect purviews, as represented in gold.
Figure 7 Extendedness of distinctions. (A) Grid distinctions are related by connection: for example, the distinction specified by mechanism CDE is connected to distinction DEF via distinction DE. CDE also connects the distinctions BCDE and CDEF. (B) A scatterplot of distinctions from the grid’s cause-effect structure. The axes are a 2D t-SNE projection of the distinction units. Each marker is labeled with the purview over which the distinction relates to itself. A grid distinction (gold) is connected with many other distinctions (open circles) through many other distinctions (olive), and it connects many other distinctions (pale brown). (C) Grid distinctions are related by fusion: for example, CDE is fused with DEF by CDEF. CDE also fuses CD and DE. (D) A grid distinction is fused with many other distinctions (open circles) into many other distinctions (olive), and it fuses many more (pale brown). (E) Grid distinctions are related by inclusion: for example, CDE is included by CDEF (in blue) and includes DE (in red). Some distinctions are mutually included (in gold). (F) Grid distinctions include (red) and are included by (blue) many other distinctions in the cause-effect structure. Note that CDE also mutually includes several other distinctions (BDE and CDF) that have the same cause-effect purviews, as represented in gold.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 8 Extendedness of distinctions specified by the grid network and by a random network having the same number of units. A distinction is extended if its causal relations to other distinctions satisfy the properties of connection, fusion, and inclusion. (A) The grid and its cause-effect structure. Each marker in the t-SNE plot represents a single distinction, with a label identifying units in the cause-effect purviews. If units only appear in a cause purview they are shown in superscript, if only in an effect purview in subscript (this convention is clearer in panel (B)). Circle markers are distinctions that connect to other distinctions, while diamond markers are distinctions that do not. Of the 133 distinctions specified by the 1D grid, 81/133 extend both up and down to other distinctions (gold color); 36/133 extend only down (olive) or only up (pale brown); 16/133 are not connected (gray diamonds). Marker size is scaled to the total φR value of each distinction with the rest of the structure. (B) A random network with the same number of units as the grid network but with connections reassigned randomly specifies a cause-effect structure with 153 distinctions. 18 distinctions are not reflexive (white diamonds). None of the distinctions are fully extended.
Figure 8 Extendedness of distinctions specified by the grid network and by a random network having the same number of units. A distinction is extended if its causal relations to other distinctions satisfy the properties of connection, fusion, and inclusion. (A) The grid and its cause-effect structure. Each marker in the t-SNE plot represents a single distinction, with a label identifying units in the cause-effect purviews. If units only appear in a cause purview they are shown in superscript, if only in an effect purview in subscript (this convention is clearer in panel (B)). Circle markers are distinctions that connect to other distinctions, while diamond markers are distinctions that do not. Of the 133 distinctions specified by the 1D grid, 81/133 extend both up and down to other distinctions (gold color); 36/133 extend only down (olive) or only up (pale brown); 16/133 are not connected (gray diamonds). Marker size is scaled to the total φR value of each distinction with the rest of the structure. (B) A random network with the same number of units as the grid network but with connections reassigned randomly specifies a cause-effect structure with 153 distinctions. 18 distinctions are not reflexive (white diamonds). None of the distinctions are fully extended.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 9 Properties of the distinctions specified by the 1D grid. (A) The subtext of a distinction is the set of other distinctions it down-includes (in orange). Three examples of down-inclusion by CDE are shown. (B) The supertext of a distinction is the set of other distinctions it up-includes (in blue). Three examples of up-inclusion by CDE are identified. (C) The size of a distinction is given by the number of distinctions in its subtext. (D) The boundary of a distinction is the set of the smallest distinctions that are connected to it (open circles). Here, the boundary of ABCD (region shown in orange) is just DE. Two larger distinctions connected to ABCD are shown for comparison (DEF and DEFG). (E) The distance between two distinctions is the smallest distinction to which they both extend up (their least fusion; fusions shown in olive). Here, BC and FG extend up to BCDEFG.
Figure 9 Properties of the distinctions specified by the 1D grid. (A) The subtext of a distinction is the set of other distinctions it down-includes (in orange). Three examples of down-inclusion by CDE are shown. (B) The supertext of a distinction is the set of other distinctions it up-includes (in blue). Three examples of up-inclusion by CDE are identified. (C) The size of a distinction is given by the number of distinctions in its subtext. (D) The boundary of a distinction is the set of the smallest distinctions that are connected to it (open circles). Here, the boundary of ABCD (region shown in orange) is just DE. Two larger distinctions connected to ABCD are shown for comparison (DEF and DEFG). (E) The distance between two distinctions is the smallest distinction to which they both extend up (their least fusion; fusions shown in olive). Here, BC and FG extend up to BCDEFG.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 10 Inhomogeneities. (A) 1D grid in the all-Off state. (B) The same grid in an inhomogeneous state, with CDEF-On: The cause-effect structure remains similar to the All-Off state, with the same mechanisms existing in both states. (C) As shown by its context, the distinction CDEF exists in both the all-Off and CDEF-On states. The relations between CDEF and the rest of the structure are qualitatively similar for both states. Colors indicate connection (open pale-brown symbols), inclusion up (blue), inclusion down (orange), and self-inclusion. (D) The difference in the context of CDEF for the all-Off and CDEF-On states (φR[all-Off] − φR[CDEF-On]). Solid symbols represent increased φR, hollow symbols represent decreased φR. The subtext of CDEF is generally more irreducible (higher φR) in the CDEF-On state, whereas its supertext and its connections are generally more reducible (lower φR).
Figure 10 Inhomogeneities. (A) 1D grid in the all-Off state. (B) The same grid in an inhomogeneous state, with CDEF-On: The cause-effect structure remains similar to the All-Off state, with the same mechanisms existing in both states. (C) As shown by its context, the distinction CDEF exists in both the all-Off and CDEF-On states. The relations between CDEF and the rest of the structure are qualitatively similar for both states. Colors indicate connection (open pale-brown symbols), inclusion up (blue), inclusion down (orange), and self-inclusion. (D) The difference in the context of CDEF for the all-Off and CDEF-On states (φR[all-Off] − φR[CDEF-On]). Solid symbols represent increased φR, hollow symbols represent decreased φR. The subtext of CDEF is generally more irreducible (higher φR) in the CDEF-On state, whereas its supertext and its connections are generally more reducible (lower φR).CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 11 Attentional Highlighting. (A) 1D grid in the ‘unattended’ all-Off state. (B) The 1D grid in the ‘attended’ all-Off state: to simulate the ‘spotlight’ of attention, units CDEF have increased response gain (red lines). (C) The distinction CDEF exists for both the unattended and attended grids. The relations between CDEF and the rest of the structure are qualitatively similar for both the unattended and attended grids. Colors are as in Figure 10. (D) The difference in the context of CDEF for the attended and unattended grids (φR[unattended] − φR[attended]). Symbol scaling is greater by a factor of 1.5 relative to Figure 10D. The context of CDEF is generally more irreducible when the gain of CDEF is increased by the ‘spotlight’ of attention.
Figure 11 Attentional Highlighting. (A) 1D grid in the ‘unattended’ all-Off state. (B) The 1D grid in the ‘attended’ all-Off state: to simulate the ‘spotlight’ of attention, units CDEF have increased response gain (red lines). (C) The distinction CDEF exists for both the unattended and attended grids. The relations between CDEF and the rest of the structure are qualitatively similar for both the unattended and attended grids. Colors are as in Figure 10. (D) The difference in the context of CDEF for the attended and unattended grids (φR[unattended] − φR[attended]). Symbol scaling is greater by a factor of 1.5 relative to Figure 10D. The context of CDEF is generally more irreducible when the gain of CDEF is increased by the ‘spotlight’ of attention.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 12 Extendedness in a 2D grid. (A) A hexagonal 2D, planar grid that works in a similar way to the 1D line-grid of Figure 2. Each unit pools six lateral inputs and a self-input, determining the probability of its turning On in the next time step. Here all units are Off. A small corner of the grid is selected for analysis (brown/green circle). (B) A representative sample of distinctions that have cause-effect purviews within the selected corner of the grid. For all three distinctions, the mechanism specifies causes and effects over a similar subset of units and states, as is the case with the line-grid. (C) The symmetric arrangement of the causes and effects ensures that the causal relations among the distinctions satisfy extendedness (connection, fusion, inclusion). A sample of distinctions satisfying extendedness is shown with the same conventions as in Figure 7 and Figure 8. Axes in this plot are not derived from t-SNE but are set to reflect the geometry of the grid.
Figure 12 Extendedness in a 2D grid. (A) A hexagonal 2D, planar grid that works in a similar way to the 1D line-grid of Figure 2. Each unit pools six lateral inputs and a self-input, determining the probability of its turning On in the next time step. Here all units are Off. A small corner of the grid is selected for analysis (brown/green circle). (B) A representative sample of distinctions that have cause-effect purviews within the selected corner of the grid. For all three distinctions, the mechanism specifies causes and effects over a similar subset of units and states, as is the case with the line-grid. (C) The symmetric arrangement of the causes and effects ensures that the causal relations among the distinctions satisfy extendedness (connection, fusion, inclusion). A sample of distinctions satisfying extendedness is shown with the same conventions as in Figure 7 and Figure 8. Axes in this plot are not derived from t-SNE but are set to reflect the geometry of the grid.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 13 Correspondence between phenomenal properties of spatial experience and physical properties of a grid-like substrate, given by the cause-effect structure it specifies. From left to right, phenomenal properties are listed above their proposed physical correspondent. That particular spot, which overlaps itself, is picked out by a particular causal distinction, whose cause overlaps its effect (reflexivity). A spot feels extended in that connects, fuses, and includes other spots; correspondingly, distinctions specified by a grid satisfy extendedness through relations of connection, fusion, and inclusion with other distinctions. Other properties of spatial experience, such as the region and location of a spot correspond respectively to the subtext and supertext of the corresponding distinction; the size of a spot to the number of distinctions in its subtext; the boundary of a spot to the set of the smallest distinctions connected to its corresponding distinction; its distance from other spots to the size of the smallest distinction to which their corresponding distinction extend up. A spatial inhomogeneity—here a bright star on a dark background—corresponds to a local warping in the cause-effect structure; an attended spot corresponds to a local highlighting.
Figure 13 Correspondence between phenomenal properties of spatial experience and physical properties of a grid-like substrate, given by the cause-effect structure it specifies. From left to right, phenomenal properties are listed above their proposed physical correspondent. That particular spot, which overlaps itself, is picked out by a particular causal distinction, whose cause overlaps its effect (reflexivity). A spot feels extended in that connects, fuses, and includes other spots; correspondingly, distinctions specified by a grid satisfy extendedness through relations of connection, fusion, and inclusion with other distinctions. Other properties of spatial experience, such as the region and location of a spot correspond respectively to the subtext and supertext of the corresponding distinction; the size of a spot to the number of distinctions in its subtext; the boundary of a spot to the set of the smallest distinctions connected to its corresponding distinction; its distance from other spots to the size of the smallest distinction to which their corresponding distinction extend up. A spatial inhomogeneity—here a bright star on a dark background—corresponds to a local warping in the cause-effect structure; an attended spot corresponds to a local highlighting.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 14 Space in a nutshell (see text for description).
Figure 14 Space in a nutshell (see text for description).CC BY · PubMed Central

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Claims other papers make about this one

Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?

15 more claims about this paper

Create a free account to see every claim other papers make about this one.

See all claims — free account

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Citations

Cites

Show all 89 references

Research works printed but not linked: 4

  1. James, 1879, The spatial quale, J. Specul. Philos., 13, 64
  2. Bosanquet, B. (1884). Lotze’s System of Philosophy, Clarendon Press.
  3. Munkres, J.R. (2000). Topology, Prentice Hall.
  4. 1933, Zur Psychophysik der Vergleichs und Raums [On psychophysics of comparison and space], Psychol. Res., 17, 343

Cited by

See all 159

Metadata

Authors
Haun, A., & Tononi, G.
Affiliations
University of Wisconsin–Madison (US)
Corresponding author
  • Haun, Andrew
  • Tononi, Giulio
Venue
Entropy
Publisher
MDPI AG
Published
2019-11-27
Volume
21
Issue
12
Pages
1160
ISSN
1099-4300 (ISSN-L)
OpenAlex
W2989880046
Cited by
143
References
89
Citations by year
2026: 12 · 2025: 18 · 2024: 28 · 2023: 21 · 2022: 21 · 2021: 26 · 2020: 16 · 2019: 1
FWCI
18.84
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Locations
  • Entropy (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
Funders
Tiny Blue Dot Foundation
Topics
  • Social Sciences › Arts and Humanities › Philosophy › Philosophy and Theoretical Science
  • Life Sciences › Neuroscience › Cognitive Neuroscience › Embodied and Extended Cognition
  • Life Sciences › Neuroscience › Cognitive Neuroscience › Visual perception and processing mechanisms
Keywords
spatial experience, phenomenal space, integrated information theory, qualia, causal structure, phenomenal properties, self-reflection, consciousness

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Why Does Space Feel the Way it Does? Towards a Principled Account of Spatial Experience. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.3390/e21121160
The paper
Haun, A., & Tononi, G. (2019). Why Does Space Feel the Way it Does? Towards a Principled Account of Spatial Experience. Entropy. https://doi.org/10.3390/e21121160

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.