Student or educator? Sign up with your school email and get 6 months of Pro free.
CoChat

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 146 of the 146 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; 24 of the 36 sources its claims cite were checked for support.

Whole-brain annotation and multi-connectome cell typing of Drosophila

Open access
Schlegel, Philipp, Yin, Yijie, Bates, Alexander S., Dorkenwald, Sven, Eichler, Katharina, Brooks, Paul, Han, Daniel S., Gkantia, Marina, dos Santos, Marcia, Munnelly, Eva J., Badalamente, Griffin, Serratosa Capdevila, Laia, Sane, Varun A., Fragniere, Alexandra M. C., Kiassat, Ladann, Pleijzier, Markus W., Stürner, Tomke, Tamimi, Imaan F. M., Dunne, Christopher R., Salgarella, Irene, Javier, Alexandre, Fang, Siqi, Perlman, Eric, Kazimiers, Tom, Jagannathan, Sridhar R., Matsliah, Arie, Sterling, Amy R., Yu, Szi-chieh, McKellar, Claire E., FlyWire Consortium, Kruk, Krzysztof, Bland, Doug, Lenizo, Zairene, Burke, Austin T., Willie, Kyle Patrick, Bates, Alexander S., Serafetinidis, Nikitas, Hadjerol, Nashra, Willie, Ryan, Silverman, Ben, Ocho, John Anthony, Bañez, Joshua, Candilada, Rey Adrian, Gager, Jay, Kristiansen, Anne, Panes, Nelsie, Yadav, Arti, Tancontian, Remer, Serona, Shirleyjoy, Dolorosa, Jet Ivan, Vinson, Kendrick Joules, Garner, Dustin, Salem, Regine, Dagohoy, Ariel, Skelton, Jaime, Lopez, Mendell, Stocks, Thomas, Pandey, Anjali, Akiatan, Darrel Jay, Hebditch, James, David, Celia, Sapkal, Dharini, Monungolh, Shaina Mae, Sane, Varun, Pielago, Mark Lloyd, Albero, Miguel, Laude, Jacquilyn, dos Santos, Márcia, Deutsch, David, Vohra, Zeba, Wang, Kaiyu, Gogo, Allien Mae, Kind, Emil, Mandahay, Alvin Josh, Martinez, Chereb, Asis, John David, Nair, Chitra, Patel, Dhwani, Manaytay, Marchan, Lim, Clyde Angelo, Ampo, Philip Lenard, Pantujan, Michelle Darapan, Bautista, Daril, Rana, Rashmita, Seguido, Jansen, Parmar, Bhargavi, Saguimpa, John Clyde, Moore, Merlin, Pleijzier, Markus W., Larson, Mark, Hsu, Joseph, Joshi, Itisha, Kakadiya, Dhara, Braun, Amalia, Pilapil, Cathy, Parmar, Kaushik, Vanderbeck, Quinn, Dunne, Christopher, Munnelly, Eva, Kang, Chan Hyuk, Lörsch, Lena, Lee, Jinmook, Kmecova, Lucia, Sancer, Gizem, Baker, Christa, Joroff, Jenna, Calle, Steven, Patel, Yashvi, Sato, Olivia, Salocot, Janice, Salman, Farzaan, Molina-Obando, Sebastian, Bui, Mai, Lichtenberger, Matthew, Tamboboy, Edmark, Molloy, Katie, Santana-Cruz, Alexis E., Hernandez, Anthony, Yu, Seongbong, Sorek, Marissa, Diwan, Arzoo, Patel, Monika, Aiken, Travis R., Morejohn, Sarah, Koskela, Sanna, Yang, Tansy, Lehmann, Daniel, Chojetzki, Jonas, Sisodiya, Sangeeta, Koolman, Selden, Shiu, Philip K., Cho, Sky, Bast, Annika, Reicher, Brian, Blanquart, Marlon, Houghton, Lucy, Choi, Hyungjun, Ioannidou, Maria, Collie, Matt, Eckhardt, Joanna, Gorko, Benjamin, Guo, Li, Zheng, Zhihao, Poh, Alisa, Lin, Marina, Taisz, István, Murfin, Wes, Díez, Álvaro Sanz, Reinhard, Nils, Gibb, Peter, Patel, Nidhi, Kumar, Sandeep, Yun, Minsik, Wang, Megan, Jones, Devon, Encarnacion-Rivera, Lucas, Oswald, Annalena, Jadia, Akanksha, Erginkaya, Mert, Drummond, Nik, Walter, Leonie, Tastekin, Ibrahim, Zhong, Xin, Mabuchi, Yuta, Figueroa Santiago, Fernando J., Verma, Urja, Byrne, Nick, Kunze, Edda, Crahan, Thomas, Margossian, Ryan, Kim, Haein, Georgiev, Iliyan, Szorenyi, Fabianna, Adachi, Atsuko, Bargeron, Benjamin, Stürner, Tomke, Demarest, Damian, Gür, Burak, Becker, Andrea N., Turnbull, Robert, Morren, Ashley, Sandoval, Andrea, Moreno-Sanchez, Anthony, Pacheco, Diego A., Samara, Eleni, Croke, Haley, Thomson, Alexander, Laughland, Connor, Dutta, Suchetana B., de Antón, Paula Guiomar Alarcón, Huang, Binglin, Pujols, Patricia, Haber, Isabel, González-Segarra, Amanda, Lin, Albert, Choe, Daniel T., Lukyanova, Veronika, Mancini, Nino, Liu, Zequan, Okubo, Tatsuo, Flynn, Miriam A., Vitelli, Gianna, Laturney, Meghan, Li, Feng, Cao, Shuo, Manyari-Diaz, Carolina, Yim, Hyunsoo, Duc Le, Anh, Maier, Kate, Yu, Seungyun, Nam, Yeonju, Bąba, Daniel, Abusaif, Amanda, Francis, Audrey, Gayk, Jesse, Huntress, Sommer S., Barajas, Raquel, Kim, Mindy, Cui, Xinyue, Sterling, Amy R., Sterne, Gabriella R., Li, Anna, Park, Keehyun, Dempsey, Georgia, Mathew, Alan, Kim, Jinseong, Kim, Taewan, Wu, Guan-ting, Dhawan, Serene, Brotas, Margarida, Zhang, Cheng-hao, Bailey, Shanice, Del Toro, Alexander, Lee, Kisuk, Macrina, Thomas, Schneider-Mizell, Casey, Popovych, Sergiy, Ogedengbe, Oluwaseun, Yang, Runzhe, Halageri, Akhilesh, Silversmith, Will, Gerhard, Stephan, Champion, Andrew, Eckstein, Nils, Ih, Dodam, Kemnitz, Nico, Castro, Manuel, Jia, Zhen, Wu, Jingpeng, Mitchell, Eric, Nehoran, Barak, Mu, Shang, Bae, J. Alexander, Lu, Ran, Morey, Ryan, Kuehner, Kai, Brittain, Derrick, Jordan, Chris S., Anderson, David J., Behnia, Rudy, Bidaye, Salil S., Borst, Alexander, Chiappe, Eugenia, Collman, Forrest, Colodner, Kenneth J., Dacks, Andrew, Dickson, Barry, Funke, Jan, Garcia, Denise, Hampel, Stefanie, Hartenstein, Volker, Hassan, Bassem, Helfrich-Forster, Charlotte, Huetteroth, Wolf, Kim, Jinseop, Kim, Sung Soo, Kim, Young-Joon, Kwon, Jae Young, Lee, Wei-Chung, Linneweber, Gerit A., Maimon, Gaby, Mann, Richard, Noselli, Stéphane, Pankratz, Michael, Prieto-Godino, Lucia, Read, Jenny, Reiser, Michael, von Reyn, Katie, Ribeiro, Carlos, Scott, Kristin, Seeds, Andrew M., Selcho, Mareike, Silies, Marion, Simpson, Julie, Waddell, Scott, Wernet, Mathias F., Wilson, Rachel I., Wolf, Fred W., Yao, Zepeng, Yapici, Nilay, Zandawala, Meet, Costa, Marta, Seung, H. Sebastian, Murthy, Mala, Hartenstein, Volker, Bock, Davi D., Jefferis, Gregory S. X. E. · 2024 · Nature

Abstract

A consensus cell type atlas for the fly brain provides both an intellectual framework and open-source toolchains for brain-scale comparative connectomics, mapping 140,000 neurons into 8,453 annotated cell types.

Overview

CoChat Summary

## TL;DR

This paper builds a hierarchical, whole-brain cell-type atlas for the adult female Drosophila FlyWire connectome and uses it to compare cell types and connections across three hemispheres and two connectomes. It argues that most fly cell types are highly stereotyped, but some hemibrain-proposed types are not reproducible across datasets, motivating a new cross-connectome definition of cell type.

## Key findings

  • The authors annotated 8,453 terminal cell types across the FlyWire brain, covering 96.4% of all neurons; they report 3,643 previously proposed hemibrain types and 4,581 new types.
  • They identified 120 neuroblast lineages and 183 hemilineages for 88% (30,233 total) of central brain neurons; the number of neurons per hemilineage correlated strongly across brains (R² = 0.98) and differed by about 3% (±4%) between left and right hemispheres.
  • Across three hemispheres, cell counts per type were highly similar: mean difference was 0.3 (±1.8) within brains and 0.8 (±10) across brains; 59% of cell types were “singleton” types.
  • Connectivity was also stereotyped: edge weights correlated within brains (Pearson R = 0.97) and across brains (Pearson R = 0.8); edges with >10 synapses or ≥0.9% of a target’s inputs had >90% chance of being preserved, and such strong edges comprised about 79% of all synapses.
  • In the mushroom body, FlyWire had 30% more Kenyon cells per hemisphere than the hemibrain (2,597 right; 2,580 left; 1,917 hemibrain). For KCg-m cells, the paper reports 5.74, 5.89, and 8.76 ALPN types per KCg-m neuron in FlyWire left, FlyWire right, and hemibrain, respectively, and concludes this preserves the excitation/inhibition ratio despite altered cell counts.

## Methods

  • Built a hierarchical annotation scheme for the full FlyWire connectome with levels including flow, superclass, class, hemilineage, morphology group, and cell type, using extensive manual curation plus NBLAST-based morphology comparisons and connectivity clustering.
  • Compared FlyWire (two hemispheres) with the hemibrain by non-rigid registration, morphology matching, and across-dataset connectivity clustering; validation was based on shared labels and “balanced” clusters present across all three hemispheres.
  • The paper analyzes the complete FlyWire adult female brain connectome of 139,255 neurons and about 15.1 million weighted edges; it uses synapse counts, normalized connection weights, and statistical comparisons including Pearson correlation and cosine distance.

## Limitations

  • The paper states that some hemibrain types could not be cleanly matched because of truncation in the hemibrain, and that some comparisons are affected by technical noise from segmentation, proofreading status, synapse detection, and completion rates.
  • It notes that connectivity clustering depends on shared labels from prior morphological matching, so connectivity-based matching cannot function without an initial corpus of shared labels.
  • Evident from the text: the study uses three hemispheres and compares mainly one species/dataset pairing, so some conclusions about stereotypy and variability are limited to the sampled brains and connectomes (stated by the cross-brain comparison design).

Model-written summary of a shortened version of the paper’s full text (it is longer than we read). Check it against the paper before relying on it.

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1038/s41586-024-07686-5

Cites

146 of 146 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Nothing to recompute.

Figures

Fig. 1 Hierarchical annotation schema for a whole-brain connectome. a, Hierarchical annotation schema for the FlyWire dataset (see the companion paper1). Annotations for example cell type DA1 lPN (right) are highlighted in red. b, Renderings of neurons for each superclass. AN, antennal nerve; APhN, accessory pharyngeal nerve; CV, cervical connective; d, dorsal; m, medial; MxLbN, maxillary-labial nerve; NCC, corpora cardiaca nerves; OCG, ocellar ganglion; ON, occipital nerves; PhN, pharyngeal nerve; p, posterior. c, Annotation counts per field. Each colour within a bar represents discrete values; the numbers above bars count the discrete values. d, Left versus right neuron counts per superclass. Bottom, the left and right soma locations, respectively. e, Breakdown of sensory neuron counts into modalities. f, Flow chart of superclass-level, feed-forward (afferent to intrinsic to efferent) connectivity.
Fig. 1 Hierarchical annotation schema for a whole-brain connectome. a, Hierarchical annotation schema for the FlyWire dataset (see the companion paper1). Annotations for example cell type DA1 lPN (right) are highlighted in red. b, Renderings of neurons for each superclass. AN, antennal nerve; APhN, accessory pharyngeal nerve; CV, cervical connective; d, dorsal; m, medial; MxLbN, maxillary-labial nerve; NCC, corpora cardiaca nerves; OCG, ocellar ganglion; ON, occipital nerves; PhN, pharyngeal nerve; p, posterior. c, Annotation counts per field. Each colour within a bar represents discrete values; the numbers above bars count the discrete values. d, Left versus right neuron counts per superclass. Bottom, the left and right soma locations, respectively. e, Breakdown of sensory neuron counts into modalities. f, Flow chart of superclass-level, feed-forward (afferent to intrinsic to efferent) connectivity.CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 2 Annotation of developmental units. a, Illustration of the two complementary sets of annotations. b, Developmental organization of neuroblast hemilineages. c, Light-level image of an example AOTUv3 lineage clone; the lower case letters link canonical features of each hemilineage to the cartoon in b. Inset: cell body fibre tract in the EM. cb, cell body; np, neuropil. d, AOTUv3 neurons in FlyWire split into its two hemilineages. e, Cell body fibre bundles from all identified hemilineages, partially annotated on the right. f, The number of central brain neurons with an identified lineage; annotation of (putative (put.)) primary neurons is based on literature or expert assessment of morphology. g, The number of identified unique (hemi)lineages. h, Left versus right number of neurons contained in each hemilineage. i, Example morphological clustering of the AOTUv3 dorsal hemilineage reveals four distinct subgroups. j, Neurons belonging to the AOTUv3 dorsal hemilineage identified in the hemibrain connectome. k, FlyWire versus hemibrain number of neurons for cross-identified hemilineages.
Fig. 2 Annotation of developmental units. a, Illustration of the two complementary sets of annotations. b, Developmental organization of neuroblast hemilineages. c, Light-level image of an example AOTUv3 lineage clone; the lower case letters link canonical features of each hemilineage to the cartoon in b. Inset: cell body fibre tract in the EM. cb, cell body; np, neuropil. d, AOTUv3 neurons in FlyWire split into its two hemilineages. e, Cell body fibre bundles from all identified hemilineages, partially annotated on the right. f, The number of central brain neurons with an identified lineage; annotation of (putative (put.)) primary neurons is based on literature or expert assessment of morphology. g, The number of identified unique (hemi)lineages. h, Left versus right number of neurons contained in each hemilineage. i, Example morphological clustering of the AOTUv3 dorsal hemilineage reveals four distinct subgroups. j, Neurons belonging to the AOTUv3 dorsal hemilineage identified in the hemibrain connectome. k, FlyWire versus hemibrain number of neurons for cross-identified hemilineages.CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 3 Across-brain stereotypy. a, Schematic of the pipeline for matching neurons between FlyWire and the Janelia hemibrain connectomes. Conf., confidence. b, The distribution of top hemibrain to FlyWire NBLAST scores. c, Manual review for a sample of top NBLAST hits. d, The extrapolated number of hemibrain neurons with matches in FlyWire. e, Example for unlikely (left) and strong (right) morphology match. f, Example of a high-confidence cell type (PS008) that is unambiguously identifiable across all three hemispheres. g, Counts of FlyWire neurons that were assigned a hemibrain type. h, The number of hemibrain cell types that were successfully identified and the resulting number of FlyWire cell types. i,j, Examples for many:1 (i) and 1:many (j) hemibrain type matches. The dotted vertical lines indicate truncation of the hemibrain neurons. k, Graph representation of top NBLAST hits between FlyWire neurons and hemibrain types. This subgraph contains nodes within a radius of three edges from the query cell type (AVLP534). Neurons matching multiple cell types (asterisks) must be manually resolved, which is not always possible. l, The number of cells per cross-matched cell type within a brain (FlyWire left versus right) and across brains (FlyWire versus hemibrain).
Fig. 3 Across-brain stereotypy. a, Schematic of the pipeline for matching neurons between FlyWire and the Janelia hemibrain connectomes. Conf., confidence. b, The distribution of top hemibrain to FlyWire NBLAST scores. c, Manual review for a sample of top NBLAST hits. d, The extrapolated number of hemibrain neurons with matches in FlyWire. e, Example for unlikely (left) and strong (right) morphology match. f, Example of a high-confidence cell type (PS008) that is unambiguously identifiable across all three hemispheres. g, Counts of FlyWire neurons that were assigned a hemibrain type. h, The number of hemibrain cell types that were successfully identified and the resulting number of FlyWire cell types. i,j, Examples for many:1 (i) and 1:many (j) hemibrain type matches. The dotted vertical lines indicate truncation of the hemibrain neurons. k, Graph representation of top NBLAST hits between FlyWire neurons and hemibrain types. This subgraph contains nodes within a radius of three edges from the query cell type (AVLP534). Neurons matching multiple cell types (asterisks) must be manually resolved, which is not always possible. l, The number of cells per cross-matched cell type within a brain (FlyWire left versus right) and across brains (FlyWire versus hemibrain).CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 4 Connectivity stereotypy. a, Connectivity comparisons and potential sources of variability. Reconstr., reconstruction. b, The number of pre- and post-synapses per cross-matched cell type. c,d, Edge weights (c) and cosine connectivity similarity (d) between cross-matched cell types. The whiskers represent 1.5× the interquartile range. e, The percentage of edges in one hemisphere that can be found in another hemisphere. f, The probability that an edge present in the hemibrain is found in one, both or neither of the hemispheres in FlyWire. A plot with normalized edge weights is shown in Extended Data Fig. 6d. g, The probability that an edge is found within and across brains as a function of total (left) and normalized (right) edge weight. The second x axis shows the percentage of synapses below a given weight. h, Correlation of across-edge (left) and within-edge (right) edge weights. The envelopes represent quantiles. i, Model for the impact of technical noise (synaptic completion rate, synapse detection) on synaptic weight from cell types i to j. The raw weight from the connectome for each individual edge is scaled up by the computed completion rate for all neurons within the relevant neuropil; random draws of the same fraction of those edges then allow an estimate of technical noise. j, Observed variability explainable by technical noise as fraction of FlyWire left–right edge pairs that fall within the 5–95% quantiles for the modelled technical noise. k, Modelled biological variability (observed variability − technical noise). R (b and c) is the Pearson correlation coefficient. For d, statistical analysis was performed using unpaired t-tests; ***P < 0.001.
Fig. 4 Connectivity stereotypy. a, Connectivity comparisons and potential sources of variability. Reconstr., reconstruction. b, The number of pre- and post-synapses per cross-matched cell type. c,d, Edge weights (c) and cosine connectivity similarity (d) between cross-matched cell types. The whiskers represent 1.5× the interquartile range. e, The percentage of edges in one hemisphere that can be found in another hemisphere. f, The probability that an edge present in the hemibrain is found in one, both or neither of the hemispheres in FlyWire. A plot with normalized edge weights is shown in Extended Data Fig. 6d. g, The probability that an edge is found within and across brains as a function of total (left) and normalized (right) edge weight. The second x axis shows the percentage of synapses below a given weight. h, Correlation of across-edge (left) and within-edge (right) edge weights. The envelopes represent quantiles. i, Model for the impact of technical noise (synaptic completion rate, synapse detection) on synaptic weight from cell types i to j. The raw weight from the connectome for each individual edge is scaled up by the computed completion rate for all neurons within the relevant neuropil; random draws of the same fraction of those edges then allow an estimate of technical noise. j, Observed variability explainable by technical noise as fraction of FlyWire left–right edge pairs that fall within the 5–95% quantiles for the modelled technical noise. k, Modelled biological variability (observed variability − technical noise). R (b and c) is the Pearson correlation coefficient. For d, statistical analysis was performed using unpaired t-tests; ***P < 0.001.CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 5 Variability in the mushroom body. a, Schematic of mushroom body circuits. K refers to the number of ALPN types that a KC samples from. Neuron types not shown are as follows: DANs, DPM and OANs. b, Rendering of KC types. c, Per-type KC counts across the three hemispheres. d, KC post-synapse counts, normalized to total KC post-synapses in each dataset. e, The fraction of ALPN to KC budget spent on individual KC types. f, The number of ALPN types a KC receives input from K. The dotted vertical lines represent the mean. g, The fraction of APL to KC budget spent on individual KC types. h, The normalized excitation/inhibition ratio for KCs. An explanation of enhanced box plots is provided in the Methods. i, The fraction of MBON input budget coming from KCs. Each line represents an MBON type. j, MBON09 as an example for KC to MBON connectivity. All MBONs are shown in Extended Data Fig. 7. k, Dimensionality (dim(h)) as function of a modelled K. The arrowheads mark observed mean K values. l, Summarizing schematic. Exc., excitatory. For f and h, Cohen’s d effect size values are shown for pairwise comparisons where P ≤ 0.01; Welch’s tests (f) and Kolmogorov–Smirnov tests (h) were applied.
Fig. 5 Variability in the mushroom body. a, Schematic of mushroom body circuits. K refers to the number of ALPN types that a KC samples from. Neuron types not shown are as follows: DANs, DPM and OANs. b, Rendering of KC types. c, Per-type KC counts across the three hemispheres. d, KC post-synapse counts, normalized to total KC post-synapses in each dataset. e, The fraction of ALPN to KC budget spent on individual KC types. f, The number of ALPN types a KC receives input from K. The dotted vertical lines represent the mean. g, The fraction of APL to KC budget spent on individual KC types. h, The normalized excitation/inhibition ratio for KCs. An explanation of enhanced box plots is provided in the Methods. i, The fraction of MBON input budget coming from KCs. Each line represents an MBON type. j, MBON09 as an example for KC to MBON connectivity. All MBONs are shown in Extended Data Fig. 7. k, Dimensionality (dim(h)) as function of a modelled K. The arrowheads mark observed mean K values. l, Summarizing schematic. Exc., excitatory. For f and h, Cohen’s d effect size values are shown for pairwise comparisons where P ≤ 0.01; Welch’s tests (f) and Kolmogorov–Smirnov tests (h) were applied.CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 6 Across-brain cell typing. a, Cell type is defined as a group of neurons that are each more similar to a group in another brain than to any neurons in the same brain. We expect cell type clusters to be balanced, that is, contain neurons from all three hemispheres in approximately even numbers. b, Example of a hemibrain cell type (AOTU063) that is morphologically homogeneous but has two cross-brain consistent connectivity types and can therefore be split. c, Main neuropils making up the central complex (CX). d, Overview of all CX cells (left) and two subsets of fan-shaped body (FB, dotted outlines) cell types: FC1–3 and FB1–9 (right). e, Hierarchical clustering from connectivity embedding for FC1–3 cells. A magnification of cross-brain cell type clusters is shown. The asterisk marks a cluster that was manually adjusted. f, Renderings of FC1–3 across-brain types; the FB is outlined. The tiling of FC1–3 neurons can be discerned. g, Comparison of FC1–3 hemibrain and cross-brain cell types. The colours correspond to those in f. h, Mappings between hemibrain and cross-brain cell types for FB1–9. A detailed flow chart is provided in Extended Data Fig. 8. i, The pipeline for generating types for neurons without a hemibrain cell type. Hemilineage LHl2 dorsal is shown as an example. The box plot shows the fraction of FlyWire neurons with a hemibrain-derived cell type. j, Cell type source broken down by super class.
Fig. 6 Across-brain cell typing. a, Cell type is defined as a group of neurons that are each more similar to a group in another brain than to any neurons in the same brain. We expect cell type clusters to be balanced, that is, contain neurons from all three hemispheres in approximately even numbers. b, Example of a hemibrain cell type (AOTU063) that is morphologically homogeneous but has two cross-brain consistent connectivity types and can therefore be split. c, Main neuropils making up the central complex (CX). d, Overview of all CX cells (left) and two subsets of fan-shaped body (FB, dotted outlines) cell types: FC1–3 and FB1–9 (right). e, Hierarchical clustering from connectivity embedding for FC1–3 cells. A magnification of cross-brain cell type clusters is shown. The asterisk marks a cluster that was manually adjusted. f, Renderings of FC1–3 across-brain types; the FB is outlined. The tiling of FC1–3 neurons can be discerned. g, Comparison of FC1–3 hemibrain and cross-brain cell types. The colours correspond to those in f. h, Mappings between hemibrain and cross-brain cell types for FB1–9. A detailed flow chart is provided in Extended Data Fig. 8. i, The pipeline for generating types for neurons without a hemibrain cell type. Hemilineage LHl2 dorsal is shown as an example. The box plot shows the fraction of FlyWire neurons with a hemibrain-derived cell type. j, Cell type source broken down by super class.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 1 Completion of the FlyWire whole-brain connectome and cell typing reveal a left-right inversion of EM image data during acquisition of the underlying FAFB EM dataset. A Frontal views of the adult fly brain are by convention shown in 2D projection, placing the fly’s right on the left of the page. In this view, the asymmetric body (AB), which is nearly always larger on the fly’s right112–114, therefore appears on the left of the page (left panel). During acquisition of the FAFB dataset, image mosaics were acquired and inadvertently stored to disk with the left-right axis inverted. Therefore in frontal view, the right side of the FAFB/FlyWire brain, and the larger AB, appear on the viewer’s right (right panel). Insets show axons of SA1-3 neurons, which form the major input to the AB. B Direct examination of an original EM-imaged grid using differential interference contrast (DIC) microscopy and an acquired EM mosaic in neuroglancer/catmaid confirms a left-right inversion during image acquisition. A grid with a crack in the support film and staining artefact precipitate was selected in order to provide fiducials easily visible by light microscopy (left panel). These same artefacts can be seen in the EM mosaic (right panel). C Showcase of how to programmatically correct the inversion of FAFB/FlyWire data. Due to the large size of the original and derived datasets, it was not technically practical to correct the left-right inversion once it was detected. Therefore this must be corrected post hoc. Code samples show how this can be done for e.g. mesh or skeleton data using Python or R (Methods, “FAFB Laterality”).
Extended Data Fig. 1 Completion of the FlyWire whole-brain connectome and cell typing reveal a left-right inversion of EM image data during acquisition of the underlying FAFB EM dataset. A Frontal views of the adult fly brain are by convention shown in 2D projection, placing the fly’s right on the left of the page. In this view, the asymmetric body (AB), which is nearly always larger on the fly’s right112–114, therefore appears on the left of the page (left panel). During acquisition of the FAFB dataset, image mosaics were acquired and inadvertently stored to disk with the left-right axis inverted. Therefore in frontal view, the right side of the FAFB/FlyWire brain, and the larger AB, appear on the viewer’s right (right panel). Insets show axons of SA1-3 neurons, which form the major input to the AB. B Direct examination of an original EM-imaged grid using differential interference contrast (DIC) microscopy and an acquired EM mosaic in neuroglancer/catmaid confirms a left-right inversion during image acquisition. A grid with a crack in the support film and staining artefact precipitate was selected in order to provide fiducials easily visible by light microscopy (left panel). These same artefacts can be seen in the EM mosaic (right panel). C Showcase of how to programmatically correct the inversion of FAFB/FlyWire data. Due to the large size of the original and derived datasets, it was not technically practical to correct the left-right inversion once it was detected. Therefore this must be corrected post hoc. Code samples show how this can be done for e.g. mesh or skeleton data using Python or R (Methods, “FAFB Laterality”).CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 2 Hierarchical annotation examples. A Examples for cell class annotations. B Examples for labels derived from the hierarchical annotations. Abbreviations: ALRN, antennal lobe receptor neuron; MBON, mushroom body output neuron; ALLN, antennal lobe local neuron; ORN, olfactory receptor neuron; AN, antennal nerve.
Extended Data Fig. 2 Hierarchical annotation examples. A Examples for cell class annotations. B Examples for labels derived from the hierarchical annotations. Abbreviations: ALRN, antennal lobe receptor neuron; MBON, mushroom body output neuron; ALLN, antennal lobe local neuron; ORN, olfactory receptor neuron; AN, antennal nerve.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 3 Hemilineage atlas. Anterior views of neurons within a hemilineage (based on37,129), or neurons whose cell bodies form a cluster in a lineage clone (also referred to as “hemilineages” hereafter), based on the light-level data from31–34,130. The names of the hemilineages are at the bottom of each panel (top: Hartenstein nomenclature; bottom: ItoLee nomenclature). The snapshots only include neurons with cell bodies on the right hemisphere, and the central unpaired lineages. Except for the hemilineages that tile the optic lobe, the neurons are coloured by morphological groups (see Methods, Hemilineage annotations section). The neurons that form cohesive tracts with their cell body fibres in the Type II lineages (see Methods) are at the lower part of the panels. The last panel of the “Type II’ section is for orientation purposes. The bottom right panel is a histogram of the number of morphological groups per hemilineage (blue: hemibrain; orange: FlyWire right; green: FlyWire left). Inset is the number of neurons per hemisphere in each morphological group, with points coloured by their density (yellow: denser). Corresponding group names, together with FlyWire and neuroglancer links are available in Supplementary Files 2 and 3.
Extended Data Fig. 3 Hemilineage atlas. Anterior views of neurons within a hemilineage (based on37,129), or neurons whose cell bodies form a cluster in a lineage clone (also referred to as “hemilineages” hereafter), based on the light-level data from31–34,130. The names of the hemilineages are at the bottom of each panel (top: Hartenstein nomenclature; bottom: ItoLee nomenclature). The snapshots only include neurons with cell bodies on the right hemisphere, and the central unpaired lineages. Except for the hemilineages that tile the optic lobe, the neurons are coloured by morphological groups (see Methods, Hemilineage annotations section). The neurons that form cohesive tracts with their cell body fibres in the Type II lineages (see Methods) are at the lower part of the panels. The last panel of the “Type II’ section is for orientation purposes. The bottom right panel is a histogram of the number of morphological groups per hemilineage (blue: hemibrain; orange: FlyWire right; green: FlyWire left). Inset is the number of neurons per hemisphere in each morphological group, with points coloured by their density (yellow: denser). Corresponding group names, together with FlyWire and neuroglancer links are available in Supplementary Files 2 and 3.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 4 Across-brain neuron matching. A Distribution of the fraction of each FlyWire neuron’s cable that is contained within the hemibrain volume: 1 = fully contained; 0 = entirely outside the volume. Note that where necessary FlyWire neurons were transformed onto the opposite side of the brain to better overlap with the hemibrain. B Distribution of top FlyWire → hemibrain NBLAST scores. C Top NBLAST score vs fraction of neuron contained within hemibrain volume. In a fraction of cases, even heavily truncated neurons can produce good scores and be successfully matched. D Top: distribution of top NBLAST scores and fraction which was type matched. Bottom: probability that the correct hit was the top NBLAST hit (green) or at least among (yellow) the top 10% as a function of the top NBLAST score. E When some FlyWire neurons had good NBLAST matches against multiple hemibrain cell types, we cross-compared within-dataset morphological clustering (dendrograms). We tried to assign hemibrain types to those ambiguous FlyWire neurons to exactly match clusters in the two dendrograms (“easy case”). When this failed because a cluster in the dendrogram contained clear matches to >1 hemibrain types, we merged types (“hard case”). F Cross-brain NBLAST co-clustering for example cell types in Fig. 3: SIP078/SIP080 (left) and PS090 (right). All hemibrain neurons are truncated. The FlyWire PS090 neurons (2 per hemisphere, none truncated) split into two well-separated clusters each containing one left and one right neuron, suggesting that the hemibrain cell type should be split. This is not the case for SIP078/SIP080 where the dendrogram cannot be split into subclusters containing neurons from each hemisphere. G Counts for 1:many and many:1 type matches. These also include types derived from previously untyped hemibrain neurons. H Extended version of NBLAST hit graph from Fig. 3k. Here, grey dotted arrows indicate matches to types outside of the displayed subgraph. I Fraction of cell types showing a difference in cell counts within (left/right, top) and across (bottom) brains. J Distribution of cell count differences. K Robust linear regression (Huber w/ intercept at 0) for within- and across-dataset pre/postsynapse counts from Fig. 3h. L Same data as in K but separated by superclass. Slopes are generally close to 1: 1.021 (pre-) and 1.035 (postsynapses, i.e. inputs) between the left and right hemisphere of FlyWire, and 1.176 (presynapses, i.e. outputs) 0.983 (post) between FlyWire and the hemibrain. Note that correlation and slope are noticeably worse for cell types known to be truncated such as visual projection neurons which suggests that we did not fully compensate for the hemibrain’s truncation and that the actual across-brain correlation might be even better.
Extended Data Fig. 4 Across-brain neuron matching. A Distribution of the fraction of each FlyWire neuron’s cable that is contained within the hemibrain volume: 1 = fully contained; 0 = entirely outside the volume. Note that where necessary FlyWire neurons were transformed onto the opposite side of the brain to better overlap with the hemibrain. B Distribution of top FlyWire → hemibrain NBLAST scores. C Top NBLAST score vs fraction of neuron contained within hemibrain volume. In a fraction of cases, even heavily truncated neurons can produce good scores and be successfully matched. D Top: distribution of top NBLAST scores and fraction which was type matched. Bottom: probability that the correct hit was the top NBLAST hit (green) or at least among (yellow) the top 10% as a function of the top NBLAST score. E When some FlyWire neurons had good NBLAST matches against multiple hemibrain cell types, we cross-compared within-dataset morphological clustering (dendrograms). We tried to assign hemibrain types to those ambiguous FlyWire neurons to exactly match clusters in the two dendrograms (“easy case”). When this failed because a cluster in the dendrogram contained clear matches to >1 hemibrain types, we merged types (“hard case”). F Cross-brain NBLAST co-clustering for example cell types in Fig. 3: SIP078/SIP080 (left) and PS090 (right). All hemibrain neurons are truncated. The FlyWire PS090 neurons (2 per hemisphere, none truncated) split into two well-separated clusters each containing one left and one right neuron, suggesting that the hemibrain cell type should be split. This is not the case for SIP078/SIP080 where the dendrogram cannot be split into subclusters containing neurons from each hemisphere. G Counts for 1:many and many:1 type matches. These also include types derived from previously untyped hemibrain neurons. H Extended version of NBLAST hit graph from Fig. 3k. Here, grey dotted arrows indicate matches to types outside of the displayed subgraph. I Fraction of cell types showing a difference in cell counts within (left/right, top) and across (bottom) brains. J Distribution of cell count differences. K Robust linear regression (Huber w/ intercept at 0) for within- and across-dataset pre/postsynapse counts from Fig. 3h. L Same data as in K but separated by superclass. Slopes are generally close to 1: 1.021 (pre-) and 1.035 (postsynapses, i.e. inputs) between the left and right hemisphere of FlyWire, and 1.176 (presynapses, i.e. outputs) 0.983 (post) between FlyWire and the hemibrain. Note that correlation and slope are noticeably worse for cell types known to be truncated such as visual projection neurons which suggests that we did not fully compensate for the hemibrain’s truncation and that the actual across-brain correlation might be even better.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 5 Examples of biological outliers and sample artefacts. A LC6 and LC9 neurons (lineage VPNd3) of the right and left hemispheres take different routes in FlyWire to equivalent destinations (previously reported in43). Mushroom body (MB) peduncle is shown in pink. B Example of a left/right neuron pair where one side has extra dorsal and smaller ventral dendrites (red arrowheads). C A TuBu neuron (black) with correctly placed axon but misplaced ventral dendrites. Regular TuBu neurons shown in background for reference. D A single Kenyon Cell whose axon projects outside of the mushroom body, descending through the medial antennal lobe tract. E Cell type (CB1029, DM6 ventral hemilineage) where the left neurons’ dendrites (red) take a different tract. F Example of sample artefact: the axon of the left DM3 adPN has very dark cytosol which affects both the neuron segmentation as well as synapse detection. Insets compare two locations along the axons between the left and right neurons. G A subset of neurons from the ALl1 ventral hemilineage where the right neurons are missing their entire dendrites (red arrow). The exact reason for this is unknown but it is not due to insufficient proofreading. H Quantification of recorded outliers and sampling artefacts broken down by super class. Total number of neurons (left) as well as fraction (right) are shown. The number of biological outlier neurons is ~0.4% of the total number of neurons in the brain.
Extended Data Fig. 5 Examples of biological outliers and sample artefacts. A LC6 and LC9 neurons (lineage VPNd3) of the right and left hemispheres take different routes in FlyWire to equivalent destinations (previously reported in43). Mushroom body (MB) peduncle is shown in pink. B Example of a left/right neuron pair where one side has extra dorsal and smaller ventral dendrites (red arrowheads). C A TuBu neuron (black) with correctly placed axon but misplaced ventral dendrites. Regular TuBu neurons shown in background for reference. D A single Kenyon Cell whose axon projects outside of the mushroom body, descending through the medial antennal lobe tract. E Cell type (CB1029, DM6 ventral hemilineage) where the left neurons’ dendrites (red) take a different tract. F Example of sample artefact: the axon of the left DM3 adPN has very dark cytosol which affects both the neuron segmentation as well as synapse detection. Insets compare two locations along the axons between the left and right neurons. G A subset of neurons from the ALl1 ventral hemilineage where the right neurons are missing their entire dendrites (red arrow). The exact reason for this is unknown but it is not due to insufficient proofreading. H Quantification of recorded outliers and sampling artefacts broken down by super class. Total number of neurons (left) as well as fraction (right) are shown. The number of biological outlier neurons is ~0.4% of the total number of neurons in the brain.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 6 Across-brain connectivity. A Comparison of normalized edge weights within (left) and across (right) brains. B Connectivity cosine connectivity similarity within and across brains. Each datapoint is a cell type identified across the three hemispheres. Size correlates with the number of cells per type. C Connectivity cosine similarity separated by neurotransmitter. Error bars represent the 95% CI. D Probability that an edge present in the hemibrain is found in one, both or neither of the FlyWire hemispheres. E Fraction of synapses contained in edges above given absolute (left) and normalized (right) weight. Horizontal lines mark the thresholds for a 90% chance that an edge is found in another hemisphere. F Postsynaptic completion rates. Each datapoint is a neuropil.
Extended Data Fig. 6 Across-brain connectivity. A Comparison of normalized edge weights within (left) and across (right) brains. B Connectivity cosine connectivity similarity within and across brains. Each datapoint is a cell type identified across the three hemispheres. Size correlates with the number of cells per type. C Connectivity cosine similarity separated by neurotransmitter. Error bars represent the 95% CI. D Probability that an edge present in the hemibrain is found in one, both or neither of the FlyWire hemispheres. E Fraction of synapses contained in edges above given absolute (left) and normalized (right) weight. Horizontal lines mark the thresholds for a 90% chance that an edge is found in another hemisphere. F Postsynaptic completion rates. Each datapoint is a neuropil.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 7 Across-brain mushroom body comparison. A Graph showing ALPN/APL → KC connectivity across the three datasets. Edge labels provide weights both as total synapse counts and normalized to the total output budget of the source. In FlyWire, the mushroom bodies (MB) have 57.2% (left) and 60.7% (right) postsynaptic completion rate while the hemibrain MB has been proofread to 81.3% (see also B). To compensate for this we typically used normalized synapse counts and edge weights. Note that KCab act as an internal control as their numbers are consistent across all hemispheres and we don’t expect to see any changes in their connectivity. B Total versus proofread postsynapse counts across MB compartments. Lateral horn (LH) shown for comparison. C Postsynapse density across MB compartments. D Connectivity between different MB cell classes. Inset shows an example of KC → KC and KC → MBON synapse in the hemibrain. E Presynapse counts per KC type normalized to the total number of KC synapses per dataset. F ALPN → KC edge weights. See Methods for details on enhanced box plots. G K (# of ALPN types providing input to a single KC) under different synapse thresholds. H Fraction of MBON input budget coming from individual KCab, KCg-m and KCa’b’. Abbreviations: CA, calyx; DAN, dopaminergic neuron; ALPN, antennal lobe projection neuron; KC, Kenyon Cell; MBON, mushroom body output neurons. Kolmogorov-Smirnov test (F): *, p < =0.05; **, p < =0.01; ***, p < =0.001.
Extended Data Fig. 7 Across-brain mushroom body comparison. A Graph showing ALPN/APL → KC connectivity across the three datasets. Edge labels provide weights both as total synapse counts and normalized to the total output budget of the source. In FlyWire, the mushroom bodies (MB) have 57.2% (left) and 60.7% (right) postsynaptic completion rate while the hemibrain MB has been proofread to 81.3% (see also B). To compensate for this we typically used normalized synapse counts and edge weights. Note that KCab act as an internal control as their numbers are consistent across all hemispheres and we don’t expect to see any changes in their connectivity. B Total versus proofread postsynapse counts across MB compartments. Lateral horn (LH) shown for comparison. C Postsynapse density across MB compartments. D Connectivity between different MB cell classes. Inset shows an example of KC → KC and KC → MBON synapse in the hemibrain. E Presynapse counts per KC type normalized to the total number of KC synapses per dataset. F ALPN → KC edge weights. See Methods for details on enhanced box plots. G K (# of ALPN types providing input to a single KC) under different synapse thresholds. H Fraction of MBON input budget coming from individual KCab, KCg-m and KCa’b’. Abbreviations: CA, calyx; DAN, dopaminergic neuron; ALPN, antennal lobe projection neuron; KC, Kenyon Cell; MBON, mushroom body output neurons. Kolmogorov-Smirnov test (F): *, p < =0.05; **, p < =0.01; ***, p < =0.001.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 8 Across-brain co-clustering. A FC1-3 across-brain cluster from Fig. 6d (asterisk) that was manually adjusted. This group consists of three sub-clusters that technically fulfil our definition of cell type. They were merged, however, because they individually omit columns of the fan-shaped body (arrowheads) and are complementary to each other. B Hierarchical clustering from combined morphology + connectivity embedding for FB1-9. Zoom-in shows cross-brain cell type clusters. C Number of hemibrain vs cross-brain FB1-9 cell types. D Examples from the FB1-9 cross-brain cell typing. Labels are composed from CB.FB{layer}{hemilineage-id}{subtype-id}; fan-shaped body outlined. E Flow chart comparing FB1-9 hemibrain and cross-brain cell types. Colours correspond to 1:1, 1:many, many:1 and many:many mappings between hemibrain and cross-brain cell types. F Renderings of all FB1-9 cross-brain cell types.
Extended Data Fig. 8 Across-brain co-clustering. A FC1-3 across-brain cluster from Fig. 6d (asterisk) that was manually adjusted. This group consists of three sub-clusters that technically fulfil our definition of cell type. They were merged, however, because they individually omit columns of the fan-shaped body (arrowheads) and are complementary to each other. B Hierarchical clustering from combined morphology + connectivity embedding for FB1-9. Zoom-in shows cross-brain cell type clusters. C Number of hemibrain vs cross-brain FB1-9 cell types. D Examples from the FB1-9 cross-brain cell typing. Labels are composed from CB.FB{layer}{hemilineage-id}{subtype-id}; fan-shaped body outlined. E Flow chart comparing FB1-9 hemibrain and cross-brain cell types. Colours correspond to 1:1, 1:many, many:1 and many:many mappings between hemibrain and cross-brain cell types. F Renderings of all FB1-9 cross-brain cell types.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 9 Double vs triple co-clustering analyses. A Pipeline for comparing putative cell types from double (FlyWire left/right) and triple (FlyWire + hemibrain) hemisphere co-clustering. B Flow chart for hemilineage LHl2 dorsal illustrating how individual FlyWire neurons move between double and triple clusters. Black bars represent clusters; thickness is proportional to the number of neurons in each cluster. C Summary over all 25 hemilineages that were cross-identified and are untruncated in the hemibrain connectome. Top bar chart shows unfiltered results; bottom chart shows results after denoising (removal of single neurons that cause many:many mapping because they swap clusters). D Flow chart for example hemilineage SIPa1 ventral. Unfiltered (top) and denoised (bottom). E-F Example of a cluster (red in panel F) from hemilineage SLPa&l1 lateral that only seems to exist in FlyWire although similar balanced clusters (black) are present in both datasets.
Extended Data Fig. 9 Double vs triple co-clustering analyses. A Pipeline for comparing putative cell types from double (FlyWire left/right) and triple (FlyWire + hemibrain) hemisphere co-clustering. B Flow chart for hemilineage LHl2 dorsal illustrating how individual FlyWire neurons move between double and triple clusters. Black bars represent clusters; thickness is proportional to the number of neurons in each cluster. C Summary over all 25 hemilineages that were cross-identified and are untruncated in the hemibrain connectome. Top bar chart shows unfiltered results; bottom chart shows results after denoising (removal of single neurons that cause many:many mapping because they swap clusters). D Flow chart for example hemilineage SIPa1 ventral. Unfiltered (top) and denoised (bottom). E-F Example of a cluster (red in panel F) from hemilineage SLPa&l1 lateral that only seems to exist in FlyWire although similar balanced clusters (black) are present in both datasets.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 10 CATMAID spaces. Screenshot demonstrating the use of CATMAID Spaces (https://fafb-flywire.catmaid.org/) to interrogate the FlyWire connectome. Differential inputs to AOTU63a and b are visualized (red and cyan, respectively). The Graph widget was used to show all neurons making 20 or more synapses onto AOTU63a and b, and to show only >=20 synapse connections between these neurons. Neurons whose only >=20 synapse connection was to either AOTU63a or b (but not both) were differentially coloured (blue-purples and greens, respectively).
Extended Data Fig. 10 CATMAID spaces. Screenshot demonstrating the use of CATMAID Spaces (https://fafb-flywire.catmaid.org/) to interrogate the FlyWire connectome. Differential inputs to AOTU63a and b are visualized (red and cyan, respectively). The Graph widget was used to show all neurons making 20 or more synapses onto AOTU63a and b, and to show only >=20 synapse connections between these neurons. Neurons whose only >=20 synapse connection was to either AOTU63a or b (but not both) were differentially coloured (blue-purples and greens, respectively).CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 11 Annotations in Neuroglancer. A Screenshot of neuroglancer with FlyWire 783 segmentation layer with “flytable-info-783” annotation layer subsource (scene pre-configured at http://tinyurl.com/flywire783). B Example for querying annotation. C Example for subsource “flytable-info-783-all” which includes hemilineage annotations.
Extended Data Fig. 11 Annotations in Neuroglancer. A Screenshot of neuroglancer with FlyWire 783 segmentation layer with “flytable-info-783” annotation layer subsource (scene pre-configured at http://tinyurl.com/flywire783). B Example for querying annotation. C Example for subsource “flytable-info-783-all” which includes hemilineage annotations.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 12 Matching workflow. A Workflow for matching hemibrain types to FlyWire neurons. B Workflow for generation of de-novo cell types used to fill the gaps left from the hemibrain type matching. C Workflow for cell typing in the optic lobes. D-G Examples of cell types. H2 is based on left vs right FlyWire clustering plus existing LM data; DNge139 and CB592 are based solely on left vs right FlyWire clustering; DNa01 is based on three hemispheres worth of data but was misidentified as “VES006” in the hemibrain.
Extended Data Fig. 12 Matching workflow. A Workflow for matching hemibrain types to FlyWire neurons. B Workflow for generation of de-novo cell types used to fill the gaps left from the hemibrain type matching. C Workflow for cell typing in the optic lobes. D-G Examples of cell types. H2 is based on left vs right FlyWire clustering plus existing LM data; DNge139 and CB592 are based solely on left vs right FlyWire clustering; DNa01 is based on three hemispheres worth of data but was misidentified as “VES006” in the hemibrain.CC BY · PubMed Central

Verification

Claims the paper makes

14 Valid · 4 Not valid · 4 Not checked · 102 Own results and interpretations

55 more claims · 6 with their cited sources checked

Create a free account to see all 124 claims and to verify the 1 reference still open.

See all claims — free account
  • It may state two separate claims as one. 28
  • Probably not a substantial claim. 38
  • The quote only partly states this claim. 2

Create a free account to see these claims.

Claims other papers make about this one

Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?

10 more claims about this paper

Create a free account to see every claim other papers make about this one.

See all claims — free account

Citations

Cites

Show all 142 references

Research works printed but not linked: 1

  1. Litwin-Kumar, A., Harris, K. D., Axel, R., Sompolinsky, H. & Abbott, L. F. Optimal degrees of synaptic connectivity. Neuron 93, 1153–1164 (2017). · DOI · Paper page

Cited by

See all 413

Metadata

Authors
Schlegel, P., Yin, Y., Bates, A. S., Dorkenwald, S., Eichler, K., Brooks, P., Han, D. S., Gkantia, M., dos Santos, M., Munnelly, E. J., Badalamente, G., Serratosa Capdevila, L., Sane, V. A., Fragniere, A. M. C., Kiassat, L., Pleijzier, M. W., Stürner, T., Tamimi, I. F. M., Dunne, C. R., Salgarella, I., Javier, A., Fang, S., Perlman, E., Kazimiers, T., Jagannathan, S. R., Matsliah, A., Sterling, A. R., Yu, S.-C., McKellar, C. E., FlyWire Consortium, Kruk, K., Bland, D., Lenizo, Z., Burke, A. T., Willie, K. P., Bates, A. S., Serafetinidis, N., Hadjerol, N., Willie, R., Silverman, B., Ocho, J. A., Bañez, J., Candilada, R. A., Gager, J., Kristiansen, A., Panes, N., Yadav, A., Tancontian, R., Serona, S., Dolorosa, J. I., Vinson, K. J., Garner, D., Salem, R., Dagohoy, A., Skelton, J., Lopez, M., Stocks, T., Pandey, A., Akiatan, D. J., Hebditch, J., David, C., Sapkal, D., Monungolh, S. M., Sane, V., Pielago, M. L., Albero, M., Laude, J., dos Santos, M., Deutsch, D., Vohra, Z., Wang, K., Gogo, A. M., Kind, E., Mandahay, A. J., Martinez, C., Asis, J. D., Nair, C., Patel, D., Manaytay, M., Lim, C. A., Ampo, P. L., Pantujan, M. D., Bautista, D., Rana, R., Seguido, J., Parmar, B., Saguimpa, J. C., Moore, M., Pleijzier, M. W., Larson, M., Hsu, J., Joshi, I., Kakadiya, D., Braun, A., Pilapil, C., Parmar, K., Vanderbeck, Q., Dunne, C., Munnelly, E., Kang, C. H., Lörsch, L., Lee, J., Kmecova, L., Sancer, G., Baker, C., Joroff, J., Calle, S., Patel, Y., Sato, O., Salocot, J., Salman, F., Molina-Obando, S., Bui, M., Lichtenberger, M., Tamboboy, E., Molloy, K., Santana-Cruz, A. E., Hernandez, A., Yu, S., Sorek, M., Diwan, A., Patel, M., Aiken, T. R., Morejohn, S., Koskela, S., Yang, T., Lehmann, D., Chojetzki, J., Sisodiya, S., Koolman, S., Shiu, P. K., Cho, S., Bast, A., Reicher, B., Blanquart, M., Houghton, L., Choi, H., Ioannidou, M., Collie, M., Eckhardt, J., Gorko, B., Guo, L., Zheng, Z., Poh, A., Lin, M., Taisz, I., Murfin, W., Díez, Á. S., Reinhard, N., Gibb, P., Patel, N., Kumar, S., Yun, M., Wang, M., Jones, D., Encarnacion-Rivera, L., Oswald, A., Jadia, A., Erginkaya, M., Drummond, N., Walter, L., Tastekin, I., Zhong, X., Mabuchi, Y., Figueroa Santiago, F. J., Verma, U., Byrne, N., Kunze, E., Crahan, T., Margossian, R., Kim, H., Georgiev, I., Szorenyi, F., Adachi, A., Bargeron, B., Stürner, T., Demarest, D., Gür, B., Becker, A. N., Turnbull, R., Morren, A., Sandoval, A., Moreno-Sanchez, A., Pacheco, D. A., Samara, E., Croke, H., Thomson, A., Laughland, C., Dutta, S. B., de Antón, P. G. A., Huang, B., Pujols, P., Haber, I., González-Segarra, A., Lin, A., Choe, D. T., Lukyanova, V., Mancini, N., Liu, Z., Okubo, T., Flynn, M. A., Vitelli, G., Laturney, M., Li, F., Cao, S., Manyari-Diaz, C., Yim, H., Duc Le, A., Maier, K., Yu, S., Nam, Y., Bąba, D., Abusaif, A., Francis, A., Gayk, J., Huntress, S. S., Barajas, R., Kim, M., Cui, X., Sterling, A. R., Sterne, G. R., Li, A., Park, K., Dempsey, G., Mathew, A., Kim, J., Kim, T., Wu, G.-T., Dhawan, S., Brotas, M., Zhang, C.-H., Bailey, S., Del Toro, A., Lee, K., Macrina, T., Schneider-Mizell, C., Popovych, S., Ogedengbe, O., Yang, R., Halageri, A., Silversmith, W., Gerhard, S., Champion, A., Eckstein, N., Ih, D., Kemnitz, N., Castro, M., Jia, Z., Wu, J., Mitchell, E., Nehoran, B., Mu, S., Bae, J. A., Lu, R., Morey, R., Kuehner, K., Brittain, D., Jordan, C. S., Anderson, D. J., Behnia, R., Bidaye, S. S., Borst, A., Chiappe, E., Collman, F., Colodner, K. J., Dacks, A., Dickson, B., Funke, J., Garcia, D., Hampel, S., Hartenstein, V., Hassan, B., Helfrich-Forster, C., Huetteroth, W., Kim, J., Kim, S. S., Kim, Y.-J., Kwon, J. Y., Lee, W.-C., Linneweber, G. A., Maimon, G., Mann, R., Noselli, S., Pankratz, M., Prieto-Godino, L., Read, J., Reiser, M., von Reyn, K., Ribeiro, C., Scott, K., Seeds, A. M., Selcho, M., Silies, M., Simpson, J., Waddell, S., Wernet, M. F., Wilson, R. I., Wolf, F. W., Yao, Z., Yapici, N., Zandawala, M., Costa, M., Seung, H. S., Murthy, M., Hartenstein, V., Bock, D. D., & Jefferis, G. S. X. E.
Affiliations
  • MRC Laboratory of Molecular Biology (GB)
  • University of Cambridge (GB)
  • Princeton University (US)
  • University of California, Los Angeles (US)
  • University of Vermont (US)
  • University of California, Santa Barbara (US)
  • Howard Hughes Medical Institute (US)
  • Freie Universität Berlin (DE)
  • Harvard University (US)
  • Max Planck Society (DE)
  • Sungkyunkwan University (KR)
  • Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz (DE)
  • University of Puerto Rico, Medical Sciences Campus (PR)
  • Yale University (US)
  • West Virginia University (US)
  • Mount Holyoke College (US)
  • University of California, Berkeley (US)
  • The University of Queensland (AU)
  • University of Würzburg (DE)
  • Gwangju Institute of Science and Technology (KR)
  • Stanford Medicine (US)
  • Champalimaud Foundation (PT)
  • Cornell University (US)
  • Mortimer B. Zuckerman Mind Brain Behavior Institute (US)
  • Max Planck Florida Institute for Neuroscience (US)
  • University of Bonn (DE)
  • Drexel University (US)
  • Seoul National University (KR)
  • Newcastle University (GB)
  • RWTH Aachen University (DE)
  • California Institute of Technology (US)
  • Rockefeller University (US)
  • The Francis Crick Institute (GB)
  • Allen Institute for Brain Science (US)
  • Leipzig University (DE)
  • Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (FR)
  • University of Oxford (GB)
  • University of California, Merced (US)
  • University of Florida (US)
Corresponding author
  • Bock, Davi D.
  • Jefferis, Gregory S. X. E.
Venue
Nature
Published
2024-10-02
Volume
634
Issue
8032
Pages
139-152
ISSN
  • 0028-0836 (ISSN-L)
  • 1476-4687
OpenAlex
W4403062913
Cited by
413
References
142
Citations by year
2026: 172 · 2025: 195 · 2024: 43
FWCI
71.45
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Licence
Locations
  • Nature (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
  • HAL (submittedVersion)
  • RePEc: Research Papers in Economics (submittedVersion)
  • eScholarship (California Digital Library) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • Figshare (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • Apollo (University of Cambridge) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • The Francis Crick Institute (cc-by)
Funders
  • Wellcome Trust (221300/Z/20/Z, 221300, 220343/Z/20/Z, 225192/Z/22/Z, 225192, 220343, 203261/Z/16/Z, 200846/Z/16/Z)
  • Francis Crick Institute (CC2067)
  • National Institute of Mental Health (RF1MH120679, RF1MH123400)
  • National Eye Institute (DP2EY032737)
  • National Institute of General Medical Sciences (R35GM133698)
  • National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke (U24NS126935, R01NS054814)
Topics
  • Life Sciences › Neuroscience › Cellular and Molecular Neuroscience › Neurobiology and Insect Physiology Research
  • Life Sciences › Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology › Biophysics › Cell Image Analysis Techniques
  • Life Sciences › Neuroscience › Cellular and Molecular Neuroscience › Neuroscience and Neuropharmacology Research
Keywords
Drosophila melanogaster, whole-brain connectome, neuronal cell types, cell type annotation, FlyWire, mushroom body, excitation-inhibition balance, cell type atlas
MeSH terms
Heuristics, Animals, Atlases as Topic, Brain, Drosophila melanogaster, Female, Male, Neural Inhibition, Neurons, Reproducibility of Results, Mushroom Bodies, Connectome, Data Curation

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

The claim verdicts this report counts are experimental: their accuracy is not yet measured.

A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-10-10, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).

A second model labelled each claim on 2026-10-10 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).

Cited sources are checked with a language model’s help (gpt-6-sol).

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Whole-brain annotation and multi-connectome cell typing of Drosophila. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1038/s41586-024-07686-5
The paper
Schlegel, P., Yin, Y., Bates, A. S., Dorkenwald, S., Eichler, K., Brooks, P., Han, D. S., Gkantia, M., dos Santos, M., Munnelly, E. J., Badalamente, G., Serratosa Capdevila, L., Sane, V. A., Fragniere, A. M. C., Kiassat, L., Pleijzier, M. W., Stürner, T., Tamimi, I. F. M., Dunne, C. R., . . . Jefferis, G. S. X. E. (2024). Whole-brain annotation and multi-connectome cell typing of Drosophila. Nature. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-024-07686-5

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.