The double-deficit hypothesis and difficulties in learning to read a regular orthography.

Abstract

In 2 large longitudinal studies, we selected 3 subgroups of German-speaking children (phonological awareness deficit, naming-speed deficit, double deficit) at the beginning of school and assessed reading and spelling performance about 3 years later. Quite different from findings with English-speaking children, phonological awareness deficits did not affect phonological coding in word recognition but did affect orthographic spelling and foreign-word reading. Naming-speed deficits did affect reading fluency, orthographic spelling, and foreign-word reading. Apparently, in the context of a regular orthography and a synthetic phonics teaching approach, early phases of literacy acquisition (particularly the acquisition of phonological coding) are less affected by early phonological awareness deficits than are later phases that depend on the build up of orthographic memory. The double-deficit hypothesis was developed by Maryanne Wolf and Patricia Bowers as an extension of the dominant phonological-deficit explanation of developmental dyslexia (e.g., Bowers & Wolf, 1993; Wolf & Bowers, 1999). The phonologicaldeficit hypothesis postulates an early difficulty in acquiring phonological awareness, which interferes with the acquisition of grapheme-phoneme coding as a word recognition mechanism, which in turn results in reduced self-teaching of orthographic word representations (Share, 1995). The early problem with phonological awareness is seen as resulting from less sharp phoneme boundaries in speech perception (Fowler, 1991) or from less distinct phonological word representations (Elbro & Peterson, 1998). The double-deficit hypothesis acknowledges the phonological awareness deficit of dyslexic children but stresses a deficit in naming speed as a second and equally important cause of reading difficulties. The first demonstration that dyslexic children show impaired naming speed was provided by Denckla and Rudel (1976), whose Rapid Automatized Naming (RAN) Test became the standard assessment of naming speed. In the RAN test, a large array of repeatedly presented, well-known visual patterns (pictured objects, color patches, digits) has to be named as quickly as possible. Wolf, Bally, and Morris (1986) were the In:st to show that early differences in rapid naming are predictive of later reading difficulties. The double-deficit hypothesis is based on findings (reviewed by Wolf & Bowers, 1999) showing that, typically, there are only modest correlations between phonological awareness measures and RAN performance in groups of dyslexic children and that dyslexic children as a group exhibit both phonological awareness deficits and naming-speed deficits. From these findings,

Cites (62)

1. Phonological recoding and self-teaching: sine qua non of reading acquisition
   Share, David L. · 1995 · Cognition
2. The double-deficit hypothesis for the developmental dyslexias.
   Maryanne Wolf, Patricia Greig Bowers · 1999 · Journal of Educational Psychology
3. Changing relations between phonological processing abilities and word-level reading as children develop from beginning to skilled readers: a 5-year longitudinal study.
   Wagner, Richard K., Torgesen, Joseph K., Rashotte, Carol A., Hecht, Steve A., Barker, Theodore A., Burgess, Stephen R., Donahue, John, Garon, Tamara · 1997 · Developmental Psychology
4. Explaining the Differences Between the Dyslexic and the Garden-Variety Poor Reader: The Phonological-Core Variable-Difference Model
   Stanovich, Keith E. · 1988 · Journal of Learning Disabilities
5. Untitled work
   1978 · Medical Entomology and Zoology
6. Varieties of developmental dyslexia
   Castles, Anne, Coltheart, Max · 1993 · Cognition
7. Strategies of Information Processing
   D., C. P., Underwood, Geoffrey · 1980 · The American Journal of Psychology
8. Strategies of information processing
   Hemsley, David R. · 1980 · Behaviour Research and Therapy
9. Phonological Processes in Literacy
   2013 · Routledge eBooks
10. Characteristics of developmental dyslexia in a regular writing system
    Wimmer, Heinz · 1993 · Applied Psycholinguistics

Show all 62 references

Cited by (445)

1. Phonemes, Rimes, Vocabulary, and Grammatical Skills as Foundations of Early Reading Development: Evidence From a Longitudinal Study.
   Muter, Valerie, Hulme, Charles, Snowling, Margaret J., Stevenson, Jim · 2004 · Developmental Psychology
2. Is there a causal link from phonological awareness to success in learning to read?
   Castles, Anne, Coltheart, Max · 2004 · Cognition
3. Orthographic Depth and Its Impact on Universal Predictors of Reading: A Cross-Language Investigation
   Ziegler, Johannes C., Bertrand, Daisy, Tóth, Dénes, Csépe, Valéria, Reis, Alexandra, Faísca, Luís, Saine, Nina, Lyytinen, Heikki, Vaessen, Anniek, Blomert, Leo · 2010 · Psychological Science
4. Developmental dyslexia: The visual attention span deficit hypothesis
   Bosse, Marie-Line, Tainturier, Marie Josèphe, Valdois, Sylviane · 2007 · Cognition
5. Development of word reading fluency and spelling in a consistent orthography: An 8-year follow-up.
   Landerl, Karin, Wimmer, Heinz · 2008 · Journal of Educational Psychology

See all 445

Related (10)

1. Examining the Double-Deficit Hypothesis in an Orthographically Consistent Language
   Minna Torppa, George Kyriacou Georgiou, Paula Salmi, Kenneth Eklund, Heikki Lyytinen · 2011 · Scientific Studies of Reading
2. Rapid Naming and Phonemic Awareness: Contributions to Reading, Spelling, and Orthographic Knowledge
   Kim Anne Sunseth, Patricia Greig Bowers · 2002 · Scientific Studies of Reading
3. Comparing the phonological and double deficit hypotheses for developmental dyslexia
   Bruce F. Pennington, Cláudia Cardoso‐Martins, Phyllis A. Green, Dianne L. Lefly · 2001 · Reading and Writing
4. Investigating the double-deficit hypothesis of developmental dyslexia in an orthography of intermediate depth
   Octávio Moura, Marcelino Arménio Martins Pereira, Joana Moreno, Mário Rodrigues Simões · 2020 · Annals of Dyslexia
5. Dyslexia in regular orthographies: manifestation and causation
   Heinz Wimmer, Matthias Schurz · 2010 · Dyslexia

See all