CoChat

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 81 of the 81 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

Brain clocks capture diversity and disparities in aging and dementia across geographically diverse populations

Open access
Moguilner, Sebastian, Baez, Sandra, Hernandez, Hernan, Migeot, Joaquín, Legaz, Agustina, Gonzalez-Gomez, Raul, Farina, Francesca R., Prado, Pavel, Cuadros, Jhosmary, Tagliazucchi, Enzo, Altschuler, Florencia, Maito, Marcelo Adrián, Godoy, María E., Cruzat, Josephine, Valdes-Sosa, Pedro A., Lopera, Francisco, Ochoa-Gómez, John Fredy, Hernandez, Alfredis Gonzalez, Bonilla-Santos, Jasmin, Gonzalez-Montealegre, Rodrigo A., Anghinah, Renato, d’Almeida Manfrinati, Luís E., Fittipaldi, Sol, Medel, Vicente, Olivares, Daniela, Yener, Görsev G., Escudero, Javier, Babiloni, Claudio, Whelan, Robert, Güntekin, Bahar, Yırıkoğulları, Harun, Santamaria-Garcia, Hernando, Lucas, Alberto Fernández, Huepe, David, Di Caterina, Gaetano, Soto-Añari, Marcio, Birba, Agustina, Sainz-Ballesteros, Agustin, Coronel-Oliveros, Carlos, Yigezu, Amanuel, Herrera, Eduar, Abasolo, Daniel, Kilborn, Kerry, Rubido, Nicolás, Clark, Ruaridh A., Herzog, Ruben, Yerlikaya, Deniz, Hu, Kun, Parra, Mario A., Reyes, Pablo, García, Adolfo M., Matallana, Diana L., Avila-Funes, José Alberto, Slachevsky, Andrea, Behrens, María I., Custodio, Nilton, Cardona, Juan F., Barttfeld, Pablo, Brusco, Ignacio L., Bruno, Martín A., Sosa Ortiz, Ana L., Pina-Escudero, Stefanie D., Takada, Leonel T., Resende, Elisa, Possin, Katherine L., de Oliveira, Maira Okada, Lopez-Valdes, Alejandro, Lawlor, Brian, Robertson, Ian H., Kosik, Kenneth S., Duran-Aniotz, Claudia, Valcour, Victor, Yokoyama, Jennifer S., Miller, Bruce, Ibanez, Agustin · 2024 · Nature Medicine

Published version of a preprint

Abstract

Brain clocks, which quantify discrepancies between brain age and chronological age, hold promise for understanding brain health and disease. However, the impact of diversity (including geographical, socioeconomic, sociodemographic, sex and neurodegeneration) on the brain-age gap is unknown. We analyzed datasets from 5,306 participants across 15 countries (7 Latin American and Caribbean countries (LAC) and 8 non-LAC countries). Based on higher-order interactions, we developed a brain-age gap deep learning architecture for functional magnetic resonance imaging (2,953) and electroencephalography (2,353). The datasets comprised healthy controls and individuals with mild cognitive impairment, Alzheimer disease and behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia. LAC models evidenced older brain ages (functional magnetic resonance imaging: mean directional error = 5.60, root mean square error (r.m.s.e.) = 11.91; electroencephalography: mean directional error = 5.34, r.m.s.e. = 9.82) associated with frontoposterior networks compared with non-LAC models. Structural socioeconomic inequality, pollution and health disparities were influential predictors of increased brain-age gaps, especially in LAC ( R ² = 0.37, F ² = 0.59, r.m.s.e. = 6.9). An ascending brain-age gap from healthy controls to mild cognitive impairment to Alzheimer disease was found. In LAC, we observed larger brain-age gaps in females in control and Alzheimer disease groups compared with the respective males. The results were not explained by variations in signal quality, demographics or acquisition methods. These findings provide a quantitative framework capturing the diversity of accelerated brain aging.

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1038/s41591-024-03209-x

Cites

81 of 81 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Figures

Fig. 1 Dataset characterization and analysis pipeline. Datasets included LAC and non-LAC healthy controls (HC, total n = 3,509) and participants with Alzheimer disease (AD, total n = 828), bvFTD (total n = 463) and MCI (total n = 517). The fMRI dataset included 2,953 participants from LAC (Argentina, Chile, Colombia, Mexico and Peru) as well as non-LAC (the USA, China and Japan). The EEG dataset involved 2,353 participants from Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Colombia and Cuba (LAC) as well as Greece, Ireland, Italy, Turkey and the UK (non-LAC). The raw fMRI and EEG signals were preprocessed by filtering and artifact removal and the EEG signals were normalized to project them into source space. A parcellation using the automated anatomical labeling (AAL) atlas for both the fMRI and EEG signals was performed to build the nodes from which we calculated the high-order interactions using the Ω-information metric. A connectivity matrix was obtained for both modalities, which was later represented by graphs. Data augmentation was performed only in the testing dataset. The graphs were used as input for a graph convolutional deep learning network (architecture shown in the last row), with separate models for EEG and fMRI. Finally, age prediction was obtained, and the performance was measured by comparing the predicted versus the chronological ages. This figure was partially created with BioRender.com (fMRI and EEG devices).
Fig. 1 Dataset characterization and analysis pipeline. Datasets included LAC and non-LAC healthy controls (HC, total n = 3,509) and participants with Alzheimer disease (AD, total n = 828), bvFTD (total n = 463) and MCI (total n = 517). The fMRI dataset included 2,953 participants from LAC (Argentina, Chile, Colombia, Mexico and Peru) as well as non-LAC (the USA, China and Japan). The EEG dataset involved 2,353 participants from Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Colombia and Cuba (LAC) as well as Greece, Ireland, Italy, Turkey and the UK (non-LAC). The raw fMRI and EEG signals were preprocessed by filtering and artifact removal and the EEG signals were normalized to project them into source space. A parcellation using the automated anatomical labeling (AAL) atlas for both the fMRI and EEG signals was performed to build the nodes from which we calculated the high-order interactions using the Ω-information metric. A connectivity matrix was obtained for both modalities, which was later represented by graphs. Data augmentation was performed only in the testing dataset. The graphs were used as input for a graph convolutional deep learning network (architecture shown in the last row), with separate models for EEG and fMRI. Finally, age prediction was obtained, and the performance was measured by comparing the predicted versus the chronological ages. This figure was partially created with BioRender.com (fMRI and EEG devices).CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 2 fMRI training and testing the deep learning model in different datasets. a, Ordinary least squares (OLS) regression comparing chronological age versus predicted age with the feature importance list for training (n = 1,155) and testing (n = 289) in the whole sample (P < 1 × 10−15). b, Regression comparing chronological age versus predicted age with the feature importance list for training (n = 773) and testing (n = 194) in the non-LAC dataset (P < 1 × 10−15). c, Regression comparing chronological age versus predicted age with the feature importance list for training (n = 381) and testing (n = 91) in the LAC dataset (P = 4.91 × 10−7). For a, b and c, the bars show the brain region feature importance list in descending order, with ring plots and glass brain representations of the most important network-edge connections. Feature importance (top 10) data are presented as mean values and 99% CI. The values for the features (mean, left limit, right limit) are: feature 1 = (0.975, 0.952, 0.999), feature 2 = (0.735, 0.715, 0.756), feature 3 = (0.627, 0.597, 0.656), feature 4 = (0.470, 0.449, 0.490), feature 5 = (0.375, 0.353, 0.397), feature 6 = (0.314, 0.285, 0.342), feature 7 = (0.239, 0.217, 0.262), feature 8 = (0.198, 0.169, 0.228), feature 9 = (0.161, 0.128, 0.193), feature 10 = (0.119, 0.093, 0.145) (a); feature 1 = (0.968, 0.937, 0.999), feature 2 = (0.736, 0.707, 0.764), feature 3 = (0.541, 0.518, 0.565), feature 4 = (0.434, 0.403, 0.464), feature 5 = (0.315, 0.290, 0.339), feature 6 = (0.253, 0.220, 0.286), feature 7 = (0.177, 0.156, 0.197), feature 8 = (0.140, 0.114, 0.166), feature 9 = (0.111, 0.078, 0.144), feature 10 = (0.079, 0.053, 0.106) (b); and feature 1 = (0.971, 0.944, 0.999), feature 2 = (0.847, 0.816, 0.878), feature 3 = (0.698, 0.667, 0.730), feature 4 = (0.533, 0.512, 0.555), feature 5 = (0.458, 0.430, 0.487), feature 6 = (0.371, 0.344, 0.399), feature 7 = (0.298, 0.272, 0.325), feature 8 = (0.242, 0.216, 0.269), feature 9 = (0.198, 0.169, 0.227), feature 10 = (0.163, 0.130, 0.196) (c). d, Histogram of the prediction error when training in non-LAC dataset (n = 967) and testing in LAC dataset (n = 477). e, Violin plot of the distribution and statistical comparison of training and testing with different regions using a two-sided permutation test without multiple comparisons (5,000 algorithm iterations) with a result of P < 1 × 10−15. Mean, first quartile (q1), third quartile (q3), whisker low, whisker high, minima and maxima values for violin plots are: LAC/non-LAC (−2.52, −7.74, 3.31, −22.52, 17.33, −22.52, 17.33); non-LAC/LAC (5.60, 0.85, 12.14, −12.82, 27.75, −12.82, 27.75). f, Violin plot of the distribution and statistical comparison of testing the models on females (n = 261) and males (n = 216) in LAC using a permutation test (5,000 iterations) with a result of P = 0.042. Mean, q1, q3, whisker low, whisker high, minima and maxima values for violin plots are: male (3.66, −1.83, 9.45, −12.49, 16.32, −12.49, 16.32); and female (6.93, 2.21, 12.78, −12.82, 27.75, −12.82, 27.75). ROI, region of interest. This figure was partially created with BioRender.com (fMRI device).
Fig. 2 fMRI training and testing the deep learning model in different datasets. a, Ordinary least squares (OLS) regression comparing chronological age versus predicted age with the feature importance list for training (n = 1,155) and testing (n = 289) in the whole sample (P < 1 × 10−15). b, Regression comparing chronological age versus predicted age with the feature importance list for training (n = 773) and testing (n = 194) in the non-LAC dataset (P < 1 × 10−15). c, Regression comparing chronological age versus predicted age with the feature importance list for training (n = 381) and testing (n = 91) in the LAC dataset (P = 4.91 × 10−7). For a, b and c, the bars show the brain region feature importance list in descending order, with ring plots and glass brain representations of the most important network-edge connections. Feature importance (top 10) data are presented as mean values and 99% CI. The values for the features (mean, left limit, right limit) are: feature 1 = (0.975, 0.952, 0.999), feature 2 = (0.735, 0.715, 0.756), feature 3 = (0.627, 0.597, 0.656), feature 4 = (0.470, 0.449, 0.490), feature 5 = (0.375, 0.353, 0.397), feature 6 = (0.314, 0.285, 0.342), feature 7 = (0.239, 0.217, 0.262), feature 8 = (0.198, 0.169, 0.228), feature 9 = (0.161, 0.128, 0.193), feature 10 = (0.119, 0.093, 0.145) (a); feature 1 = (0.968, 0.937, 0.999), feature 2 = (0.736, 0.707, 0.764), feature 3 = (0.541, 0.518, 0.565), feature 4 = (0.434, 0.403, 0.464), feature 5 = (0.315, 0.290, 0.339), feature 6 = (0.253, 0.220, 0.286), feature 7 = (0.177, 0.156, 0.197), feature 8 = (0.140, 0.114, 0.166), feature 9 = (0.111, 0.078, 0.144), feature 10 = (0.079, 0.053, 0.106) (b); and feature 1 = (0.971, 0.944, 0.999), feature 2 = (0.847, 0.816, 0.878), feature 3 = (0.698, 0.667, 0.730), feature 4 = (0.533, 0.512, 0.555), feature 5 = (0.458, 0.430, 0.487), feature 6 = (0.371, 0.344, 0.399), feature 7 = (0.298, 0.272, 0.325), feature 8 = (0.242, 0.216, 0.269), feature 9 = (0.198, 0.169, 0.227), feature 10 = (0.163, 0.130, 0.196) (c). d, Histogram of the prediction error when training in non-LAC dataset (n = 967) and testing in LAC dataset (n = 477). e, Violin plot of the distribution and statistical comparison of training and testing with different regions using a two-sided permutation test without multiple comparisons (5,000 algorithm iterations) with a result of P < 1 × 10−15. Mean, first quartile (q1), third quartile (q3), whisker low, whisker high, minima and maxima values for violin plots are: LAC/non-LAC (−2.52, −7.74, 3.31, −22.52, 17.33, −22.52, 17.33); non-LAC/LAC (5.60, 0.85, 12.14, −12.82, 27.75, −12.82, 27.75). f, Violin plot of the distribution and statistical comparison of testing the models on females (n = 261) and males (n = 216) in LAC using a permutation test (5,000 iterations) with a result of P = 0.042. Mean, q1, q3, whisker low, whisker high, minima and maxima values for violin plots are: male (3.66, −1.83, 9.45, −12.49, 16.32, −12.49, 16.32); and female (6.93, 2.21, 12.78, −12.82, 27.75, −12.82, 27.75). ROI, region of interest. This figure was partially created with BioRender.com (fMRI device).CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 3 EEG training and testing the deep learning model in different samples. a, OLS regression comparing chronological age versus predicted age with the feature importance list for training (n = 1,644) and testing (n = 411) in the whole sample (P < 1 × 10−15). b, Regression comparing chronological age versus predicted age with the feature importance list for training (n = 471) and testing (n = 118) in the non-LAC dataset (P < 1 × 10−15). c, Regression comparing chronological age versus predicted age with the feature importance list for training (n = 1,188) and testing (n = 298) in the LAC dataset (P = 3.51 × 10−7). For a, b and c, the bars show the brain region feature importance list in descending order, with ring plots and glass brain representations of the most important network-edge connections. Feature importance (top 10) data are presented as mean values and 99% CI. The values for the features (mean, left limit, right limit) are: feature 1 = (0.968, 0.946, 0.991), feature 2 = (0.759, 0.739, 0.779), feature 3 = (0.644, 0.617, 0.670), feature 4 = (0.531, 0.500, 0.561), feature 5 = (0.410, 0.384, 0.436), feature 6 = (0.336, 0.309, 0.363), feature 7 = (0.259, 0.239, 0.279), feature 8 = (0.218, 0.191, 0.245), feature 9 = (0.184, 0.150, 0.217), feature 10 = (0.146, 0.114, 0.177) (a); feature 1 = (0.967, 0.935, 0.999), feature 2 = (0.764, 0.741, 0.786), feature 3 = (0.569, 0.549, 0.590), feature 4 = (0.460, 0.435, 0.485), feature 5 = (0.354, 0.330, 0.377), feature 6 = (0.283, 0.256, 0.311), feature 7 = (0.216, 0.192, 0.241), feature 8 = (0.169, 0.145, 0.193), feature 9 = (0.129, 0.107, 0.150), feature 10 = (0.101, 0.077, 0.124) (b); feature 1 = (0.972, 0.949, 0.995), feature 2 = (0.833, 0.805, 0.860), feature 3 = (0.705, 0.677, 0.733), feature 4 = (0.564, 0.543, 0.584), feature 5 = (0.488, 0.463, 0.514), feature 6 = (0.408, 0.385, 0.431), feature 7 = (0.363, 0.334, 0.393), feature 8 = (0.292, 0.269, 0.314), feature 9 = (0.243, 0.222, 0.264), feature 10 = (0.221, 0.188, 0.254) (c). d, Histogram of the prediction error when training in non-LAC dataset (n = 569) and testing in LAC dataset (n = 1,486). e, Violin plot of the distribution and statistical comparison of training and testing with different regions using a two-sided permutation test without multiple comparisons (5,000 algorithm iterations) with a result of P < 1 × 10−15. Mean, q1, q3, whisker low, whisker high, minima and maxima values for violin plots are: LAC/non-LAC (−2.34, −6.07, 1.26, −13.25, 11.52, −20.08, 17.52); non-LAC/LAC (5.24, 1.95, 8.61, −5.24, 16.18, −12.73, 16.18). f, Violin plot of the distribution and statistical comparison of testing the models on females and males using a permutation test (5,000 iterations) with a result of P = 0.012. Mean, q1, q3, whisker low and whisker high values for violin plots are: male (3.66, 1.87, 7.83, −5.24, 16.18, −12.73, 16.18); female (6.19, 2.67, 9.39, −3.08, 15.52, −3.08, 15.52). This figure was partially created with BioRender.com (EEG device).
Fig. 3 EEG training and testing the deep learning model in different samples. a, OLS regression comparing chronological age versus predicted age with the feature importance list for training (n = 1,644) and testing (n = 411) in the whole sample (P < 1 × 10−15). b, Regression comparing chronological age versus predicted age with the feature importance list for training (n = 471) and testing (n = 118) in the non-LAC dataset (P < 1 × 10−15). c, Regression comparing chronological age versus predicted age with the feature importance list for training (n = 1,188) and testing (n = 298) in the LAC dataset (P = 3.51 × 10−7). For a, b and c, the bars show the brain region feature importance list in descending order, with ring plots and glass brain representations of the most important network-edge connections. Feature importance (top 10) data are presented as mean values and 99% CI. The values for the features (mean, left limit, right limit) are: feature 1 = (0.968, 0.946, 0.991), feature 2 = (0.759, 0.739, 0.779), feature 3 = (0.644, 0.617, 0.670), feature 4 = (0.531, 0.500, 0.561), feature 5 = (0.410, 0.384, 0.436), feature 6 = (0.336, 0.309, 0.363), feature 7 = (0.259, 0.239, 0.279), feature 8 = (0.218, 0.191, 0.245), feature 9 = (0.184, 0.150, 0.217), feature 10 = (0.146, 0.114, 0.177) (a); feature 1 = (0.967, 0.935, 0.999), feature 2 = (0.764, 0.741, 0.786), feature 3 = (0.569, 0.549, 0.590), feature 4 = (0.460, 0.435, 0.485), feature 5 = (0.354, 0.330, 0.377), feature 6 = (0.283, 0.256, 0.311), feature 7 = (0.216, 0.192, 0.241), feature 8 = (0.169, 0.145, 0.193), feature 9 = (0.129, 0.107, 0.150), feature 10 = (0.101, 0.077, 0.124) (b); feature 1 = (0.972, 0.949, 0.995), feature 2 = (0.833, 0.805, 0.860), feature 3 = (0.705, 0.677, 0.733), feature 4 = (0.564, 0.543, 0.584), feature 5 = (0.488, 0.463, 0.514), feature 6 = (0.408, 0.385, 0.431), feature 7 = (0.363, 0.334, 0.393), feature 8 = (0.292, 0.269, 0.314), feature 9 = (0.243, 0.222, 0.264), feature 10 = (0.221, 0.188, 0.254) (c). d, Histogram of the prediction error when training in non-LAC dataset (n = 569) and testing in LAC dataset (n = 1,486). e, Violin plot of the distribution and statistical comparison of training and testing with different regions using a two-sided permutation test without multiple comparisons (5,000 algorithm iterations) with a result of P < 1 × 10−15. Mean, q1, q3, whisker low, whisker high, minima and maxima values for violin plots are: LAC/non-LAC (−2.34, −6.07, 1.26, −13.25, 11.52, −20.08, 17.52); non-LAC/LAC (5.24, 1.95, 8.61, −5.24, 16.18, −12.73, 16.18). f, Violin plot of the distribution and statistical comparison of testing the models on females and males using a permutation test (5,000 iterations) with a result of P = 0.012. Mean, q1, q3, whisker low and whisker high values for violin plots are: male (3.66, 1.87, 7.83, −5.24, 16.18, −12.73, 16.18); female (6.19, 2.67, 9.39, −3.08, 15.52, −3.08, 15.52). This figure was partially created with BioRender.com (EEG device).CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 4 Groups, sex and macrosocial influences in brain-age gaps. a,b, Violin plots for the distribution of prediction gaps for different groups and sex effects using (a) fMRI and (b) EEG datasets. Statistical comparisons were calculated using two-sided subsample permutation testing without multiple comparisons and with 5,000 algorithm iterations. c, Associations between macrosocial and disease disparity factors with brain-age gaps were assessed with a multi-method approach comprising SHAP values, feature importance (MDI) and permutation importance. Plots show the mean importance values for each method, along with their 99% CI, as well as the average R2 and Cohen’s f². *Features whose lower CI boundary does not cross zero. Shaded bars indicate significance across the three methods. We conducted a two-sided F-test to evaluate the overall significance of the regression models. The three models were significant: healthy controls LAC (R² = 0.37 (99% CI ±0.17), F² = 0.59 (99% CI ±0.21), r.m.s.e. = 6.9 (99% CI ±0.92), F = 138.78 (P < 1 × 10−15)); healthy controls non-LAC (R² = 0.41 (99% CI ±0.17), F² = 0.71 (99% CI ±0.21), r.m.s.e. = 6.57 (99% CI ±1.31), F = 135.91 (P < 1 × 10−15)) and total dataset (R² = 0.41 (99% CI ±0.12), F² = 0.71 (99% CI ±0.14), r.m.s.e. = 6.76 (99% CI ±0.89), F = 253.39 (P < 1 × 10−15)). The relevance of the features and their respective CI values are available in Supplementary Table 2. F, females; HC LAC, healthy controls from LAC; HC non-LAC, healthy controls from non-LAC; M, males. This figure was partially created with BioRender.com (fMRI and EEG devices).
Fig. 4 Groups, sex and macrosocial influences in brain-age gaps. a,b, Violin plots for the distribution of prediction gaps for different groups and sex effects using (a) fMRI and (b) EEG datasets. Statistical comparisons were calculated using two-sided subsample permutation testing without multiple comparisons and with 5,000 algorithm iterations. c, Associations between macrosocial and disease disparity factors with brain-age gaps were assessed with a multi-method approach comprising SHAP values, feature importance (MDI) and permutation importance. Plots show the mean importance values for each method, along with their 99% CI, as well as the average R2 and Cohen’s f². *Features whose lower CI boundary does not cross zero. Shaded bars indicate significance across the three methods. We conducted a two-sided F-test to evaluate the overall significance of the regression models. The three models were significant: healthy controls LAC (R² = 0.37 (99% CI ±0.17), F² = 0.59 (99% CI ±0.21), r.m.s.e. = 6.9 (99% CI ±0.92), F = 138.78 (P < 1 × 10−15)); healthy controls non-LAC (R² = 0.41 (99% CI ±0.17), F² = 0.71 (99% CI ±0.21), r.m.s.e. = 6.57 (99% CI ±1.31), F = 135.91 (P < 1 × 10−15)) and total dataset (R² = 0.41 (99% CI ±0.12), F² = 0.71 (99% CI ±0.14), r.m.s.e. = 6.76 (99% CI ±0.89), F = 253.39 (P < 1 × 10−15)). The relevance of the features and their respective CI values are available in Supplementary Table 2. F, females; HC LAC, healthy controls from LAC; HC non-LAC, healthy controls from non-LAC; M, males. This figure was partially created with BioRender.com (fMRI and EEG devices).CC BY · PubMed Central
Fig. 5 Sensitivity analysis. a, Violin plots for the distribution of data quality metrics of fMRI (healthy controls non-LAC, n = 967, MCI non-LAC n = 215, Alzheimer disease non-LAC n = 214, bvFTD non-LAC n = 190, HC LAC n = 477, MCI LAC n = 169, AD LAC n = 505, bvFTD LAC n = 216). b, Violin plots for the distribution of data quality metrics of EEG datasets (HC non-LAC n = 569, HC LAC n = 1486, MCI LAC n = 133, Alzheimer disease LAC n = 108, bvFTD LAC n = 57). Both a and b indicate null results between groups in terms of data quality. c, Linear regression effects of scanner type, evidencing that the fMRI data quality was not significantly associated with fMRI brain-age gaps differences (P = 0.184). d, fMRI brain-age gap differences across groups controlling for scanner differences. The statistical comparisons were calculated using two-sided subsample permutation testing with 5,000 iterations. NS, not significant; ODQ, overall data quality.
Fig. 5 Sensitivity analysis. a, Violin plots for the distribution of data quality metrics of fMRI (healthy controls non-LAC, n = 967, MCI non-LAC n = 215, Alzheimer disease non-LAC n = 214, bvFTD non-LAC n = 190, HC LAC n = 477, MCI LAC n = 169, AD LAC n = 505, bvFTD LAC n = 216). b, Violin plots for the distribution of data quality metrics of EEG datasets (HC non-LAC n = 569, HC LAC n = 1486, MCI LAC n = 133, Alzheimer disease LAC n = 108, bvFTD LAC n = 57). Both a and b indicate null results between groups in terms of data quality. c, Linear regression effects of scanner type, evidencing that the fMRI data quality was not significantly associated with fMRI brain-age gaps differences (P = 0.184). d, fMRI brain-age gap differences across groups controlling for scanner differences. The statistical comparisons were calculated using two-sided subsample permutation testing with 5,000 iterations. NS, not significant; ODQ, overall data quality.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 1 Associations of sex and gender inequality with brain-age gaps. Multi-method approach comprising SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP) values, features and permutation importance. Plot shows the mean importance values for each method, along with their 99% confidence interval, as well as the average R-squared and Cohen’s f². Having a neurocognitive disorder, being female, and living in countries with larger gender inequality (particularly from LAC), were associated with higher brain age-gaps. The model was significant with R2 = 0.40 (99% CI ± 0.12), F2 = 0.66 (99% CI ± 0.14), RMSE = 6.85 (99% CI ± 0.82), F = 352.54, and p < 1e-15. We conducted a two-sided F-test to evaluate the overall significance of the regression model. The importance of the features and their respective confidence intervals can be found in Supplementary Table 1. LAC = Latin American and Caribbean countries.
Extended Data Fig. 1 Associations of sex and gender inequality with brain-age gaps. Multi-method approach comprising SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP) values, features and permutation importance. Plot shows the mean importance values for each method, along with their 99% confidence interval, as well as the average R-squared and Cohen’s f². Having a neurocognitive disorder, being female, and living in countries with larger gender inequality (particularly from LAC), were associated with higher brain age-gaps. The model was significant with R2 = 0.40 (99% CI ± 0.12), F2 = 0.66 (99% CI ± 0.14), RMSE = 6.85 (99% CI ± 0.82), F = 352.54, and p < 1e-15. We conducted a two-sided F-test to evaluate the overall significance of the regression model. The importance of the features and their respective confidence intervals can be found in Supplementary Table 1. LAC = Latin American and Caribbean countries.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 2 Prediction gaps between fMRI datasets with either eyes open or eyes closed protocols. No significant differences were observed between participants with open vs. closed eyes within the same groups (two-sided permutation test, without multiple comparisons, and with 5000 algorithm iterations). We included 124 healthy controls with closed eyes and 86 with open eyes, 269 Alzheimer’s disease participants with closed eyes and 164 with open eyes, and 88 behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia with closed eyes and 69 with open eyes. For HC eyes open vs AD eyes open p < 1e-15, for HC eyes closed vs AD eyes closed p < 1e-15, for AD eyes open vs bvFTD eyes open p = 0.026, for AD eyes closed vs bvFTD eyes closed p = 0.004. * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01, *** p < 0.001. HC = healthy controls, AD = Alzheimer’s disease, bvFTD = behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia, EC = eyes closed, EO = eyes open.
Extended Data Fig. 2 Prediction gaps between fMRI datasets with either eyes open or eyes closed protocols. No significant differences were observed between participants with open vs. closed eyes within the same groups (two-sided permutation test, without multiple comparisons, and with 5000 algorithm iterations). We included 124 healthy controls with closed eyes and 86 with open eyes, 269 Alzheimer’s disease participants with closed eyes and 164 with open eyes, and 88 behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia with closed eyes and 69 with open eyes. For HC eyes open vs AD eyes open p < 1e-15, for HC eyes closed vs AD eyes closed p < 1e-15, for AD eyes open vs bvFTD eyes open p = 0.026, for AD eyes closed vs bvFTD eyes closed p = 0.004. * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01, *** p < 0.001. HC = healthy controls, AD = Alzheimer’s disease, bvFTD = behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia, EC = eyes closed, EO = eyes open.CC BY · PubMed Central
Extended Data Fig. 3 Brain-age gaps between subsamples of mild cognitive impairment (MCI) and Alzheimer’s disease (AD) groups matched by chronological age. Results were similar to those reported for the total MCI (n fMRI = 256, n EEG = 52) and AD (n fMRI = 254, n EEG = 52) datasets in Fig. 4a,b (two-sided permutation test, without multiple comparisons, and with 5000 algorithm iterations). For fMRI LAC p < 1e-5, for fMRI non-LAC p < 1e-5, for fMRI all p < 1e-5, for EEG all p values = 0.0024. fMRI LAC violin plots (Mean, q1, q3, whisker low, whisker high, minima, maxima): MCI = (10.550, 6.216, 14.748, −3.166, 26.203, −7.616, 29.185) and AD = (16.796, 12.591, 21.568, 1.133, 33.756, 1.133, 39.751). fMRI non-LAC: MCI = (10.518, 6.216, 14.565, −3.166, 26.203, −7.616, 29.185) and AD = (15.006, 11.076, 18.222, 1.133, 26.726, 1.133, 31.797). fMRI LAC: MCI = (10.702, 6.565, 15.222, −0.325, 23.516, −0.325, 23.516) and AD = (18.057, 13.681, 22.218, 2.916, 33.756, 2.916, 39.751). EEG all MCI = (11.813, 7.739, 15.804, 1.153, 24.775, 1.153, 24.775) and AD = (15.341, 12.727, 18.343, 6.751, 26.207, 0.348, 28.932). FMRI = functional magnetic imaging, EEG = electroencephalography, LAC = Latin American and Caribbean countries, HC = healthy controls, MCI = mild cognitive impairm)ent, AD = Alzheimer’s disease, bvFTD = behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia.
Extended Data Fig. 3 Brain-age gaps between subsamples of mild cognitive impairment (MCI) and Alzheimer’s disease (AD) groups matched by chronological age. Results were similar to those reported for the total MCI (n fMRI = 256, n EEG = 52) and AD (n fMRI = 254, n EEG = 52) datasets in Fig. 4a,b (two-sided permutation test, without multiple comparisons, and with 5000 algorithm iterations). For fMRI LAC p < 1e-5, for fMRI non-LAC p < 1e-5, for fMRI all p < 1e-5, for EEG all p values = 0.0024. fMRI LAC violin plots (Mean, q1, q3, whisker low, whisker high, minima, maxima): MCI = (10.550, 6.216, 14.748, −3.166, 26.203, −7.616, 29.185) and AD = (16.796, 12.591, 21.568, 1.133, 33.756, 1.133, 39.751). fMRI non-LAC: MCI = (10.518, 6.216, 14.565, −3.166, 26.203, −7.616, 29.185) and AD = (15.006, 11.076, 18.222, 1.133, 26.726, 1.133, 31.797). fMRI LAC: MCI = (10.702, 6.565, 15.222, −0.325, 23.516, −0.325, 23.516) and AD = (18.057, 13.681, 22.218, 2.916, 33.756, 2.916, 39.751). EEG all MCI = (11.813, 7.739, 15.804, 1.153, 24.775, 1.153, 24.775) and AD = (15.341, 12.727, 18.343, 6.751, 26.207, 0.348, 28.932). FMRI = functional magnetic imaging, EEG = electroencephalography, LAC = Latin American and Caribbean countries, HC = healthy controls, MCI = mild cognitive impairm)ent, AD = Alzheimer’s disease, bvFTD = behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia.CC BY · PubMed Central

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Claims other papers make about this one

Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Citations

Cites

Show all 81 references

Research works printed but not linked: 1

  1. Kohavi, R. A study of cross-validation and bootstrap for accuracy estimation and model selection. Proc. of 14th International Joint Conference on AI 1137–1143 (1995).

Cited by

See all 140

Metadata

Authors
Moguilner, S., Baez, S., Hernandez, H., Migeot, J., Legaz, A., Gonzalez-Gomez, R., Farina, F. R., Prado, P., Cuadros, J., Tagliazucchi, E., Altschuler, F., Maito, M. A., Godoy, M. E., Cruzat, J., Valdes-Sosa, P. A., Lopera, F., Ochoa-Gómez, J. F., Hernandez, A. G., Bonilla-Santos, J., Gonzalez-Montealegre, R. A., Anghinah, R., d’Almeida Manfrinati, L. E., Fittipaldi, S., Medel, V., Olivares, D., Yener, G. G., Escudero, J., Babiloni, C., Whelan, R., Güntekin, B., Yırıkoğulları, H., Santamaria-Garcia, H., Lucas, A. F., Huepe, D., Di Caterina, G., Soto-Añari, M., Birba, A., Sainz-Ballesteros, A., Coronel-Oliveros, C., Yigezu, A., Herrera, E., Abasolo, D., Kilborn, K., Rubido, N., Clark, R. A., Herzog, R., Yerlikaya, D., Hu, K., Parra, M. A., Reyes, P., García, A. M., Matallana, D. L., Avila-Funes, J. A., Slachevsky, A., Behrens, M. I., Custodio, N., Cardona, J. F., Barttfeld, P., Brusco, I. L., Bruno, M. A., Sosa Ortiz, A. L., Pina-Escudero, S. D., Takada, L. T., Resende, E., Possin, K. L., de Oliveira, M. O., Lopez-Valdes, A., Lawlor, B., Robertson, I. H., Kosik, K. S., Duran-Aniotz, C., Valcour, V., Yokoyama, J. S., Miller, B., & Ibanez, A.
Affiliations
  • Adolfo Ibáñez University (CL)
  • University of California, Santa Barbara (US)
  • Universidad San Sebastián (CL)
  • Universidad Nacional Experimental del Táchira (VE)
  • University of San Andrés (AR)
  • University of Electronic Science and Technology of China (CN)
  • Universidad de Antioquia (CO)
  • Universidade de São Paulo (BR)
  • University of California, San Francisco (US)
  • İzmir University of Economics (TR)
  • University of Edinburgh (GB)
  • Sapienza University of Rome (IT)
  • Istanbul Medipol University (TR)
  • Universidad Complutense de Madrid (ES)
  • Universidad Icesi (CO)
  • University of Glasgow (GB)
  • University of Aberdeen (GB)
  • University of Strathclyde (GB)
  • Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (FR)
  • Dokuz Eylül University (TR)
  • Harvard University (US)
  • Pontificia Universidad Javeriana (CO)
  • Universidad de Santiago de Chile (CL)
  • Hospital del Salvador (CL)
  • Clínica Alemana (CL)
  • Instituto Peruano de Neurociencias (PE)
  • Universidad del Valle (CO)
  • Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas (AR)
  • Universidad de Buenos Aires (AR)
  • Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais (BR)
  • University of Chicago (US)
Venue
Nature Medicine
Published
2024-08-26
Volume
30
Issue
12
Pages
3646-3657
ISSN
  • 1078-8956 (ISSN-L)
  • 1546-170X
OpenAlex
W4401894695
Cited by
128
References
78
Citations by year
2026: 55 · 2025: 63 · 2024: 10
FWCI
37.43
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Licence
Locations
  • Nature Medicine (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
  • eScholarship (California Digital Library) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • IRIS Research product catalog (Sapienza University of Rome) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • Edinburgh Research Explorer (University of Edinburgh) (submittedVersion, cc-by)
  • Universidad de Chile (submittedVersion, cc-by-nc-nd)
Funders
  • Alzheimer's Association (20-725707, SG-20- 725707)
  • Universidad de Santiago de Chile
  • John E. Fogarty Foundation for Persons with Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities (R01AG083799)
  • Agencia Nacional de Investigación y Desarrollo (15150012, ANID/FONDAP/15150012, 1210195, 1210176, 1220995)
  • National Institutes of Health (15150012)
  • Departamento de Investigaciones Científicas y Tecnológicas, Universidad de Santiago de Chile (032351G_DAS)
  • National Institute on Aging (R01AG057234, P01AG019724, P30AG062422, R01AG075775, R01AG083799)
  • National Institute on Drug Abuse (75N95022C00031)
  • Fogarty International Center
  • Fondo de Financiamiento de Centros de Investigación en Áreas Prioritarias (15150012)
Topics
  • Health Sciences › Medicine › Psychiatry and Mental health › Dementia and Cognitive Impairment Research
  • Life Sciences › Neuroscience › Cognitive Neuroscience › Functional Brain Connectivity Studies
  • Health Sciences › Medicine › Radiology, Nuclear Medicine and Imaging › Advanced MRI Techniques and Applications
Keywords
brain age, brain age gap, accelerated brain aging, dementia, Alzheimer's disease, behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia, mild cognitive impairment, Latin America and the Caribbean, socioeconomic disparities, health disparities, sex differences, deep learning, functional MRI, EEG
MeSH terms
Aged, Aged, 80 and over, Aging, Alzheimer Disease, Brain, Dementia, Electroencephalography, Female, Humans, Magnetic Resonance Imaging, Male, Middle Aged, Socioeconomic Factors, Health Status Disparities, Cognitive Dysfunction

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

How to cite

Cite CoChat for the checks on this page, and the paper for its own findings.

This page
CoChat. (2026). Citation check: Brain clocks capture diversity and disparities in aging and dementia across geographically diverse populations. https://app.cochat.ai/papers/10.1038/s41591-024-03209-x
The paper
Moguilner, S., Baez, S., Hernandez, H., Migeot, J., Legaz, A., Gonzalez-Gomez, R., Farina, F. R., Prado, P., Cuadros, J., Tagliazucchi, E., Altschuler, F., Maito, M. A., Godoy, M. E., Cruzat, J., Valdes-Sosa, P. A., Lopera, F., Ochoa-Gómez, J. F., Hernandez, A. G., Bonilla-Santos, J., . . . Ibanez, A. (2024). Brain clocks capture diversity and disparities in aging and dementia across geographically diverse populations. Nature Medicine. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41591-024-03209-x

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.