Autonomy in children's learning: An experimental and individual difference investigation.

Abstract

Ninety-one fifth-grade children participated in a study that assessed the effects of motivationally relevant conditions and individual differences on emotional experience and performance on a learning task. Two directed-learning conditions, one controlling and one noncontrolling, were contrasted with each other and with a third nondirected, spontaneous-learning context. Both directed sets resulted in greater rote learning compared with the nondirected-learning condition. However, both the nondirected and the noncontrolling directed-learning sets resulted in greater interest and conceptual learning compared with the controlling set, presumably because they were more conducive to autonomy or an internal perceived locus of causality. Furthermore, children in the controlling condition experienced more pressure and evidenced a greater deterioration in rote learning over an 8-(+/- 1) day follow-up. Individual differences in children's autonomy for school-related activities as measured by the Self-Regulation Questionnaire (Connell & Ryan, 1985) also related to outcomes, with more self-determined styles predicting greater conceptual learning. Results are discussed in terms of the role of autonomy in learning and development and the issue of directed versus nondirected learning.

Cites (7)

1. The Perceived Competence Scale for Children
   Harter, Susan · 1982 · Child Development
2. Control and information in the intrapersonal sphere: An extension of cognitive evaluation theory.
   Ryan, Richard M. · 1982 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
3. Setting limits on children's behavior: The differential effects of controlling vs. informational styles on intrinsic motivation and creativity
   Koestner, Richard, Ryan, Richard M., Bernieri, Frank, Holt, Kathleen · 1984 · Journal of Personality
4. The hidden costs of rewards
   Deci, Edward L. · 1976 · Organizational Dynamics
5. Effects of no feedback, task-related comments, and grades on intrinsic motivation and performance.
   Butler, Ruth, Nisan, Mordecai · 1986 · Journal of Educational Psychology
6. Effect of interest on attentional shift, recognition, and recall in young children
   Renninger, K. Ann, Wozniak, Robert H. · 1985 · Developmental Psychology
7. Intentional and Incidental Learning with Instructional Texts: A Meta-Analysis for 1970–1980
   Klauer, Karl J. · 1984 · American Educational Research Journal

Cited by (65)

1. The "what" and "why" of goal pursuits: Human needs and the self-determination of behavior
   Deci, Edward L., Ryan, Richard M. · 2000 · Psychological Inquiry
2. Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivations: Classic Definitions and New Directions
   Ryan, Richard M., Deci, Edward L. · 2000 · Contemporary Educational Psychology
3. School Engagement: Potential of the Concept, State of the Evidence
   Fredricks, Jennifer A, Blumenfeld, Phyllis C, Paris, Alison H · 2004 · Review of Educational Research
4. Assessment and Classroom Learning
   Black, Paul, Wiliam, Dylan · 1998 · Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice
5. Self‐determination theory and work motivation
   Gagné, Marylène, Deci, Edward L. · 2005 · Journal of Organizational Behavior
6. A meta-analytic review of experiments examining the effects of extrinsic rewards on intrinsic motivation.
   Deci, Edward L., Koestner, Richard, Ryan, Richard M. · 1999 · Psychological Bulletin
7. Classrooms: Goals, structures, and student motivation.
   Ames, Carole · 1992 · Journal of Educational Psychology
8. Intrinsic and extrinsic motivation from a self-determination theory perspective: Definitions, theory, practices, and future directions
   Ryan, Richard M., Deci, Edward L. · 2020 · Contemporary Educational Psychology
9. Self-Efficacy and Academic Motivation
   Schunk, Dale H. · 1991 · Educational Psychologist
10. Toward a hierarchical model of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation
    Vallerand, Robert J. · 1997 · Advances in experimental social psychology
11. Facilitating optimal motivation and psychological well-being across life's domains.
    Deci, Edward L., Ryan, Richard M. · 2008 · Canadian Psychology / Psychologie canadienne
12. Autonomy, competence, and relatedness in the classroom: Applying self-determination theory to educational practice
    Niemiec, Christopher P., Ryan, Richard M. · 2009 · Theory and Research in Education
13. Engagement and disaffection in the classroom: Part of a larger motivational dynamic?
    Skinner, Ellen, Furrer, Carrie, Marchand, Gwen, Kindermann, Thomas · 2008 · Journal of Educational Psychology
14. Student engagement with school: Critical conceptual and methodological issues of the construct
    Appleton, James J., Christenson, Sandra L., Furlong, Michael J. · 2008 · Psychology in the Schools
15. Motivating Learning, Performance, and Persistence: The Synergistic Effects of Intrinsic Goal Contents and Autonomy-Supportive Contexts.
    Vansteenkiste, Maarten, Simons, Joke, Lens, Willy, Sheldon, Kennon M., Deci, Edward L. · 2004 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
16. Why Teachers Adopt a Controlling Motivating Style Toward Students and How They Can Become More Autonomy Supportive
    REEVE, JOHNMARSHALL · 2009 · Educational Psychologist
17. Engaging students in learning activities: It is not autonomy support or structure but autonomy support and structure.
    Jang, Hyungshim, Reeve, Johnmarshall, Deci, Edward L. · 2010 · Journal of Educational Psychology
18. Enhancing Students' Engagement by Increasing Teachers' Autonomy Support
    Reeve, Johnmarshall, Jang, Hyungshim, Carrell, Dan, Jeon, Soohyun, Barch, Jon · 2004 · Motivation and Emotion
19. Inner resources for school achievement: Motivational mediators of children's perceptions of their parents.
    Grolnick, Wendy S., Ryan, Richard M., Deci, Edward L. · 1991 · Journal of Educational Psychology
20. The effects of choice on intrinsic motivation and related outcomes: A meta-analysis of research findings.
    Patall, Erika A., Cooper, Harris, Robinson, Jorgianne Civey · 2008 · Psychological Bulletin
21. Motivational profiles from a self-determination perspective: The quality of motivation matters.
    Vansteenkiste, Maarten, Sierens, Eline, Soenens, Bart, Luyckx, Koen, Lens, Willy · 2009 · Journal of Educational Psychology
22. The Multidimensional Work Motivation Scale: Validation evidence in seven languages and nine countries
    Gagné, Marylène, Forest, Jacques, Vansteenkiste, Maarten, Crevier-Braud, Laurence, van den Broeck, Anja, Aspeli, Ann Kristin, Bellerose, Jenny, Benabou, Charles, Chemolli, Emanuela, Güntert, Stefan Tomas et al. · 2015 · European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology
23. Experiences of Autonomy and Control Among Chinese Learners: Vitalizing or Immobilizing?
    Vansteenkiste, Maarten, Zhou, Mingming, Lens, Willy, Soenens, Bart · 2005 · Journal of Educational Psychology
24. The regulation of explicit and implicit race bias: The role of motivations to respond without prejudice.
    Devine, Patricia G., Plant, E. Ashby, Amodio, David M., Harmon-Jones, Eddie, Vance, Stephanie L. · 2002 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
25. A motivational model of rural students' intentions to persist in, versus drop out of, high school.
    Hardre, Patricia L., Reeve, Johnmarshall · 2003 · Journal of Educational Psychology
26. Motivation and dropout in female handballers: a 21-month prospective study
    Sarrazin, P., Vallerand, R., Guillet, E., Pelletier, L., Cury, F. · 2002 · European Journal of Social Psychology
27. Directly controlling teacher behaviors as predictors of poor motivation and engagement in girls and boys: The role of anger and anxiety
    Assor, Avi, Kaplan, Haya, Kanat-Maymon, Yaniv, Roth, Guy · 2005 · Learning and Instruction
28. A model of knowledge‐sharing motivation
    Gagné, Marylène · 2009 · Human Resource Management
29. Test anxiety and the hierarchical model of approach and avoidance achievement motivation.
    Elliot, Andrew J., McGregor, Holly A. · 1999 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
30. The Emerging Neuroscience of Intrinsic Motivation: A New Frontier in Self-Determination Research
    Di Domenico, Stefano I., Ryan, Richard M. · 2017 · Frontiers in Human Neuroscience
31. Identifying configurations of perceived teacher autonomy support and structure: Associations with self-regulated learning, motivation and problem behavior
    Vansteenkiste, Maarten, Sierens, Eline, Goossens, Luc, Soenens, Bart, Dochy, Filip, Mouratidis, Athanasios, Aelterman, Nathalie, Haerens, Leen, Beyers, Wim · 2012 · Learning and Instruction
32. Testing models of the experience of self-determination in intrinsic motivation and the conundrum of choice.
    Reeve, Johnmarshall, Nix, Glen, Hamm, Diane · 2003 · Journal of Educational Psychology
33. Exploring the role of e-learning readiness on student satisfaction and motivation in flipped classroom
    Yilmaz, Ramazan · 2017 · Computers in Human Behavior
34. Testing a continuum structure of self-determined motivation: A meta-analysis.
    Howard, Joshua L., Gagné, Marylène, Bureau, Julien S. · 2017 · Psychological Bulletin
35. Performance Effects of Motivational State: A Meta-Analysis
    Utman, Christopher H. · 1997 · Personality and Social Psychology Review
36. When rewards compete with nature
    Ryan, Richard M., Deci, Edward L. · 2000 · Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivation
37. Autonomy and Need Satisfaction in Close Relationships: Relationships Motivation Theory
    Deci, Edward L., Ryan, Richard M. · 2014 · Human Motivation and Interpersonal Relationships
38. A Motivational Model of Work Turnover
    Richer, Sylvie F., Blanchard, Cealine, Vallerand, Robert J. · 2002 · Journal of Applied Social Psychology
39. Predicting Long-Term Growth in Students' Mathematics Achievement: The Unique Contributions of Motivation and Cognitive Strategies
    Murayama, Kou, Pekrun, Reinhard, Lichtenfeld, Stephanie, vom Hofe, Rudolf · 2013 · Child Development
40. Let Us Not Throw Out the Baby With the Bathwater: Applying the Principle of Universalism Without Uniformity to Autonomy-Supportive and Controlling Parenting
    Soenens, Bart, Vansteenkiste, Maarten, Van Petegem, Stijn · 2015 · Child Development Perspectives
41. Reexamining the impact of self-determination theory on learning outcomes in the online learning environment
    Hsu, Hui-Ching Kayla, Wang, Cong Vivi, Levesque-Bristol, Chantal · 2019 · Education and Information Technologies
42. The Development of Children's Motivation in School Contexts
    Wigfield, Allan, Eccles, Jacquelynne S., Rodriguez, Daniel · 1998 · Review of Research in Education
43. Providing a Rationale in an Autonomy-Supportive Way as a Strategy to Motivate Others During an Uninteresting Activity
    Reeve, Johnmarshall, Jang, Hyungshim, Hardre, Pat, Omura, Mafumi · 2002 · Motivation and Emotion
44. Sources of Situational Interest
    Schraw, Gregory, Bruning, Roger, Svoboda, Carla · 1995 · Journal of Reading Behavior
45. Individual differences in the activation and control of affective race bias as assessed by startle eyeblink response and self-report.
    Amodio, David M., Harmon-Jones, Eddie, Devine, Patricia G. · 2003 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
46. When change-oriented feedback enhances motivation, well-being and performance: A look at autonomy-supportive feedback in sport
    Carpentier, Joëlle, Mageau, Geneviève A. · 2013 · Psychology of Sport and Exercise
47. Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT), Irrational and Rational Beliefs, and the Mental Health of Athletes
    Turner, Martin J. · 2016 · Frontiers in Psychology
48. Self-determination, self-regulation, and the brain: Autonomy improves performance by enhancing neuroaffective responsiveness to self-regulation failure.
    Legault, Lisa, Inzlicht, Michael · 2013 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
49. Why grades engender performance-avoidance goals: The mediating role of autonomous motivation.
    Pulfrey, Caroline, Buchs, Céline, Butera, Fabrizio · 2011 · Journal of Educational Psychology
50. What humans need: Flourishing in Aristotelian philosophy and self-determination theory
    Ryan, Richard M., Curren, Randall R., Deci, Edward L. · 2013 · The best within us: Positive psychology perspectives on eudaimonia.
51. Use of techniques promoting students' self-determination: Effects on students' analytic problem-solving skills
    Boggiano, Ann K., Flink, Cheryl, Shields, Ann, Seelbach, Aubyn, Barrett, Marty · 1993 · Motivation and Emotion
52. The mediating role of positive and negative affect in the situational motivation-performance relationship
    Gillet, Nicolas, Vallerand, Robert J., Lafrenière, Marc-André K., Bureau, Julien S. · 2013 · Motivation and Emotion
53. Teacher support, student motivation, student need satisfaction, and college teacher course evaluations: testing a sequential path model
    Filak, Vincent F., Sheldon, Kennon M. · 2008 · Educational Psychology
54. The effects of experimentally induced choice on elementary school children’s intrinsic motivation: The moderating role of indecisiveness and teacher–student relatedness
    Waterschoot, Joachim, Vansteenkiste, Maarten, Soenens, Bart · 2019 · Journal of Experimental Child Psychology
55. The effects of choice on autonomous motivation, perceived autonomy support, and physical activity levels in high school physical education
    How, Yew Meng, Whipp, Peter, Dimmock, James, Jackson, Ben · 2013 · Journal of Teaching in Physical Education
56. Generative AI and education: dynamic personalization of pupils’ school learning material with ChatGPT
    Jauhiainen, Jussi S., Garagorry Guerra, Agustín · 2024 · Frontiers in Education
57. A dimensional and person-centered perspective on controlled reasons for non-participation in physical education
    Aelterman, Nathalie, Vansteenkiste, Maarten, Soenens, Bart, Haerens, Leen · 2016 · Psychology of Sport and Exercise
58. The double-edged sword of rewards for participation in psychology experiments.
    Sharp, Elizabeth C., Pelletier, Luc G., Lévesque, Chantal · 2006 · Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science / Revue canadienne des sciences du comportement
59. Need satisfaction, work–school interference and school dropout: An application of self-determination theory
    Taylor, Geneviève, Lekes, Natasha, Gagnon, Hugo, Kwan, Lisa, Koestner, Richard · 2012 · British Journal of Educational Psychology
60. Teachers' motivational prosody: A pre‐registered experimental test of children's reactions to tone of voice used by teachers
    Paulmann, Silke, Weinstein, Netta · 2023 · British Journal of Educational Psychology
61. Defeating the Potentially Deleterious Effects of Externally Imposed Deadlines: Practitioners’ Rules-of-Thumb
    Burgess, Mark, Enzle, Michael E., Schmaltz, Rodney · 2004 · Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin
62. Political engagement’s non-political roots: examining the role of basic psychological needs in the political domain
    Wuttke, Alexander · 2020 · Motivation and Emotion
63. Is self-determined motivation a useful agent to overcome perceived exercise barriers in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus?
    Kang, Heon Jin, Wang, John Chee Keng, Burns, Stephen Francis, Leow, Melvin Khee-Shing · 2021 · Frontiers in Psychology
64. The (non-)benefit of choosing: If you get what you want it is not important that you chose it
    Wilde, Matthias, Basten, Melanie, Großmann, Nadine, Haunhorst, Darius, Desch, Inga, Strüber, Matthias, Randler, Christoph · 2018 · Motivation and Emotion
65. Infants attend longer to controlling versus supportive directive speech
    Gerson, Sarah, Weinstein, Netta, Gattis, Merideth, Paulmann, Silke · 2019 · Journal of Experimental Child Psychology