The DOI matches its Crossref record; 28 of the 28 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
The Inadmissibility of What We Eat in America and NHANES Dietary Data in Nutrition and Obesity Research and the Scientific Formulation of National Dietary Guidelines
Open accessAbstract
The Scientific Report of the 2015 Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee was primarily informed by memory-based dietary assessment methods (M-BM; e.g., interviews, surveys). The reliance on M-BM to inform dietary policy continues despite decades of unequivocal evidence that M-BM data bear little relation to actual energy and nutrient consumption. M-BM data are defended as valid and valuable despite no empirical support, and no examination of the foundational assumptions regarding the validity of human memory and retrospective recall in dietary assessment. We assert that uncritical faith in the validity and value of M-BM has wasted significant resources and constitutes the greatest impediment to scientific progress in obesity and nutrition research. Herein, we present evidence that M-BM are fundamentally and fatally flawed due to well-established scientific facts and analytic truths. First, the assumption that human memory can provide accurate or precise reproductions of past ingestive behavior is indisputably false. Second, M-BM require participants to submit to protocols that mimic procedures known to induce false recall. Third, the subjective (i.e., not publicly accessible) mental phenomena (i.e., memories) from which M-BM data are derived cannot be independently observed, quantified, nor falsified; as such, these data are pseudoscientific and inadmissible in scientific research. Fourth, the failure to objectively measure physical activity in analyses renders inferences regarding diet-health relationships equivocal. Given the overwhelming evidence in support of our position, we conclude that M-BM data cannot be used to inform national dietary guidelines and the continued funding of M-BM constitutes an unscientific and significant misuse of research resources.
Overview
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Self-check
Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.
The self-check needs the paper’s full text.
Citations
Cites
Lee, I.-M., Shiroma, E. J., Lobelo, F., Puska, P., Blair, S. N., & Katzmarzyk, P. T. (2012) · The Lancet · doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(12)61031-9 · Cited by 8,215
Physical Activity in the United States Measured by Accelerometer
TROIANO, R. P., BERRIGAN, D., DODD, K. W., MÂSSE, L. C., TILERT, T., & MCDOWELL, M. (2008) · Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise · doi:10.1249/mss.0b013e31815a51b3 · Cited by 7,638 · cited 4×
“The lack of explanatory and predictive power of epidemiologic nutrition research may also be explained by the limited acknowledgement of nonnutritional determinants of health and disease, such as nongenetic evolution,6-8 PA,121,122 CRF,123 and other components of nutrient partitioning and energy balance.124-130 For ex…”
BackgroundInfluentialREMEMBERING: A STUDY IN EXPERIMENTAL AND SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY
Bartlett, F. C., & Burt, C. (1933) · British Journal of Educational Psychology · doi:10.1111/j.2044-8279.1933.tb02913.x · Cited by 7,475
Heart Disease and Stroke Statistics—2012 Update: A Report From the American Heart Association
Writing Group Members, Roger, V. L., Go, A. S., Lloyd-Jones, D. M., Benjamin, E. J., Berry, J. D., Borden, W. B., Bravata, D. M., Dai, S., Ford, E. S., et al. (2012) · Circulation · doi:10.1161/cir.0b013e31823ac046 · Cited by 7,333
Creating false memories: Remembering words not presented in lists.
Roediger, H. L., & McDermott, K. B. (1995) · Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition · doi:10.1037/0278-7393.21.4.803 · Cited by 3,792
Prince, S. A., Adamo, K. B., Hamel, M., Hardt, J., Connor Gorber, S., & Tremblay, M. (2008) · International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity · doi:10.1186/1479-5868-5-56 · Cited by 3,162
Platt, J. R. (1964) · Science · doi:10.1126/science.146.3642.347 · Cited by 2,907
Physical Fitness and All-Cause Mortality: A Prospective Study of Healthy Men and Women
Blair, S. N. (1989) · JAMA · doi:10.1001/jama.1989.03430170057028 · Cited by 2,658
Limits to the measurement of habitual physical activity by questionnaires
Shephard, R. J. (2003) · British Journal of Sports Medicine · doi:10.1136/bjsm.37.3.197 · Cited by 1,694
Markers of the Validity of Reported Energy Intake
Livingstone, M. B. E., & Black, A. E. (2003) · The Journal of Nutrition · doi:10.1093/jn/133.3.895s · Cited by 1,081
Subar, A. F. (2003) · American Journal of Epidemiology · doi:10.1093/aje/kwg092 · Cited by 1,070
The Problem of Informant Accuracy: The Validity of Retrospective Data
Bernard, H. R., Killworth, P., Kronenfeld, D., & Sailer, L. (1984) · Annual Review of Anthropology · doi:10.1146/annurev.an.13.100184.002431 · Cited by 896
THE COGNITIVE NEUROSCIENCE OF CONSTRUCTIVE MEMORY
Schacter, D. L., Norman, K. A., & Koutstaal, W. (1998) · Annual Review of Psychology · doi:10.1146/annurev.psych.49.1.289 · Cited by 827 · cited 3×
“During the ensuing 80 years, research has clearly demonstrated that the encoding of memories(69,91) and subsequent recall depend on constructive and reconstructive processes (eg, imagination)(48,69,53) that are susceptible to errors, distortions, omissions, complete fabrications, false reports, and illusions.(50,58,69…”
BackgroundThe validity of self-reported energy intake as determined using the doubly labelled water technique
Hill, R. J., & Davies, P. S. W. (2001) · British Journal of Nutrition · doi:10.1079/bjn2000281 · Cited by 589
Energy balance measurement: when something is not better than nothing
Dhurandhar, N. V., Schoeller, D., Brown, A. W., Heymsfield, S. B., Thomas, D., Sørensen, T. I. A., Speakman, J. R., Jeansonne, M., Allison, D. B., & the Energy Balance Measurement Working Group (2015) · International Journal of Obesity · doi:10.1038/ijo.2014.199 · Cited by 567
Goris, A. H., Westerterp-Plantenga, M. S., & Westerterp, K. R. (2000) · The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition · doi:10.1093/ajcn/71.1.130 · Cited by 530
Freedman, L. S., Commins, J. M., Moler, J. E., Arab, L., Baer, D. J., Kipnis, V., Midthune, D., Moshfegh, A. J., Neuhouser, M. L., Prentice, R. L., et al. (2014) · American Journal of Epidemiology · doi:10.1093/aje/kwu116 · Cited by 528 · cited 1×
“Recently, some of the strongest proponents of M-BMs have provided additional data that clearly demonstrate the futility of the continued use of these methods.(36) In the paper by Freedman et al,(36) the pooled, squared average correlation between true EI and self-reported EI were similar to our results using NHANES da…”
ResultLimitations in the assessment of dietary energy intake by self-report
Schoeller, D. A. (1995) · Metabolism · doi:10.1016/0026-0495(95)90204-x · Cited by 496
Physical activity and diabetes prevention
LaMonte, M. J., Blair, S. N., & Church, T. S. (2005) · Journal of Applied Physiology · doi:10.1152/japplphysiol.00193.2005 · Cited by 340
Schatzkin, A., Mouw, T., Park, Y., Subar, A. F., Kipnis, V., Hollenbeck, A., Leitzmann, M. F., & Thompson, F. E. (2007) · The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition · doi:10.1093/ajcn/85.5.1353 · Cited by 317
A 2-wk reduction of ambulatory activity attenuates peripheral insulin sensitivity
Krogh-Madsen, R., Thyfault, J. P., Broholm, C., Mortensen, O. H., Olsen, R. H., Mounier, R., Plomgaard, P., van Hall, G., Booth, F. W., & Pedersen, B. K. (2010) · Journal of Applied Physiology · doi:10.1152/japplphysiol.00977.2009 · Cited by 311
Druesne‐Pecollo, N., Latino‐Martel, P., Norat, T., Barrandon, E., Bertrais, S., Galan, P., & Hercberg, S. (2010) · International Journal of Cancer · doi:10.1002/ijc.25008 · Cited by 283
Do we eat less fat, or just report so?
Heitmann, B., Lissner, L., & Osler, M. (2000) · International Journal of Obesity · doi:10.1038/sj.ijo.0801176 · Cited by 235
David Wang, D., Sievenpiper, J. L., de Souza, R. J., Cozma, A. I., Chiavaroli, L., Ha, V., Mirrahimi, A., Carleton, A. J., Di Buono, M., Jenkins, A. L., et al. (2014) · Atherosclerosis · doi:10.1016/j.atherosclerosis.2013.10.019 · Cited by 191
Memory and law: what can cognitive neuroscience contribute?
Schacter, D. L., & Loftus, E. F. (2013) · Nature Neuroscience · doi:10.1038/nn.3294 · Cited by 188 · cited 1×
“Perhaps the most salient example of the fallibility of memory and recall (and misplaced confidence) is that false reporting (ie, inaccurate eyewitness testimony) was a key factor in approximately 75% of the first 100 cases of individuals exonerated by DNA evidence after conviction for crimes that they did not commit.(…”
BackgroundSelf-report-based estimates of energy intake offer an inadequate basis for scientific conclusions
Schoeller, D. A., Thomas, D., Archer, E., Heymsfield, S. B., Blair, S. N., Goran, M. I., Hill, J. O., Atkinson, R. L., Corkey, B. E., Foreyt, J., et al. (2013) · The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition · doi:10.3945/ajcn.113.062125 · Cited by 177 · cited 2×
“The Pervasiveness of Implausible Results The conclusions drawn by our study(33) and the recent British Medical Journal editorial(11) are, in fact, supported by many decades of evidence demonstrating that M-BMs have severe, intractable systematic biases that render the data implausible and, therefore, invalid.(11,13,37…”
BackgroundResultSelf-citationStraube, B. (2012) · Behavioral and Brain Functions · doi:10.1186/1744-9081-8-35 · Cited by 96
Cited by
Addressing Current Criticism Regarding the Value of Self-Report Dietary Data
Subar, A. F., Freedman, L. S., Tooze, J. A., Kirkpatrick, S. I., Boushey, C., Neuhouser, M. L., Thompson, F. E., Potischman, N., Guenther, P. M., Tarasuk, V., et al. (2015) · The Journal of Nutrition · doi:10.3945/jn.115.219634 · Cited by 1,047
Transcription Factor NRF2 as a Therapeutic Target for Chronic Diseases: A Systems Medicine Approach
Cuadrado, A., Manda, G., Hassan, A., Alcaraz, M. J., Barbas, C., Daiber, A., Ghezzi, P., León, R., López, M. G., Oliva, B., et al. (2018) · Pharmacological Reviews · doi:10.1124/pr.117.014753 · Cited by 632
“The association between disease and nutrition is frequently based on unreliable self-reporting (Archer et al., 2015).”
BackgroundDe Toro-Martín, J., Arsenault, B., Després, J.-P., & Vohl, M.-C. (2017) · Nutrients · doi:10.3390/nu9080913 · Cited by 492
Docosahexaenoic Acid and Cognition throughout the Lifespan
Weiser, M., Butt, C., & Mohajeri, M. (2016) · Nutrients · doi:10.3390/nu8020099 · Cited by 400
“While dietary DHA intake is a convenient measure, there are inherent flaws in the reliability and accuracy of data acquired from food frequency questionnaires [201].”
BackgroundLechner, K., von Schacky, C., McKenzie, A. L., Worm, N., Nixdorff, U., Lechner, B., Kränkel, N., Halle, M., Krauss, R. M., & Scherr, J. (2020) · European Journal of Preventive Cardiology · doi:10.1177/2047487319869400 · Cited by 371
Metadata
- Authors
- Archer, E., Pavela, G., & Lavie, C. J.
- Venue
- Mayo Clinic Proceedings
- Publisher
- Elsevier BV
- Published
- 2015-07
- Volume
- 90
- Issue
- 7
- Pages
- 911-926
- ISSN
- 0025-6196 (ISSN-L)
- OpenAlex
- W1826951566
- Cited by
- 235
- References
- 28
- FWCI
- 36.56
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- bronze
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.