Student or educator? Sign up with your school email and get 6 months of Pro free.
CoChat

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 70 of the 70 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

Brain Dynamics Underlying the Nonlinear Threshold for Access to Consciousness

Open access
Del Cul, Antoine, Baillet, Sylvain, Dehaene, Stanislas · 2007 · PLoS Biology

Abstract

When a flashed stimulus is followed by a backward mask, subjects fail to perceive it unless the target-mask interval exceeds a threshold duration of about 50 ms. Models of conscious access postulate that this threshold is associated with the time needed to establish sustained activity in recurrent cortical loops, but the brain areas involved and their timing remain debated. We used high-density recordings of event-related potentials (ERPs) and cortical source reconstruction to assess the time course of human brain activity evoked by masked stimuli and to determine neural events during which brain activity correlates with conscious reports. Target-mask stimulus onset asynchrony (SOA) was varied in small steps, allowing us to ask which ERP events show the characteristic nonlinear dependence with SOA seen in subjective and objective reports. The results separate distinct stages in mask-target interactions, indicating that a considerable amount of subliminal processing can occur early on in the occipito-temporal pathway (<250 ms) and pointing to a late (>270 ms) and highly distributed fronto-parieto-temporal activation as a correlate of conscious reportability.

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1371/journal.pbio.0050260

Cites

70 of 70 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Figures

Figure 1 Schematic Predictions Concerning the Brain Activation to Subliminal and Supraliminal Masked Stimuli, as Derived from a Global Neuronal Workspace Model of Consciousness Top, depth of cortical processing: subliminal stimuli (left panel) should evoke a strong activation in extrastriate visual cortex, but their intensity should quickly decrease in higher visual areas; only conscious stimuli (right panel) should trigger a late surge of activation in a global prefronto-parietal network. Bottom, schematic time course of activation as a function of masking strength. Masking is expected to have little effect on early visual activation but to modulate the strength of activation in higher visual areas. Furthermore, there should be a nonlinear effect of masking strength in prefrontal cortex, with a similar late top-down activation peak occurring simultaneously in visual areas [19–21].
Figure 1 Schematic Predictions Concerning the Brain Activation to Subliminal and Supraliminal Masked Stimuli, as Derived from a Global Neuronal Workspace Model of Consciousness Top, depth of cortical processing: subliminal stimuli (left panel) should evoke a strong activation in extrastriate visual cortex, but their intensity should quickly decrease in higher visual areas; only conscious stimuli (right panel) should trigger a late surge of activation in a global prefronto-parietal network. Bottom, schematic time course of activation as a function of masking strength. Masking is expected to have little effect on early visual activation but to modulate the strength of activation in higher visual areas. Furthermore, there should be a nonlinear effect of masking strength in prefrontal cortex, with a similar late top-down activation peak occurring simultaneously in visual areas [19–21].CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 2 Experimental Protocol and Behavioral Results Collected during ERP Recording (A) On each trial, a target numeral (16 ms) was presented at one of four possible location, and followed by a letter mask (250 ms). Gray dots and numerals are shown for spatial reference only, and were not actually presented. Six conditions of target-mask SOA=16, 33, 50, 66, 83, or 100 ms and one mask-only condition (without target) were randomly intermixed across trials. Following each such stimulus, subjects performed two consecutive tasks: (1) forced-choice comparison of the target numeral with the numeral 5 and (2) evaluation of subjective target visibility using a continuous scale labelled “not seen” at left and “maximal visibility” at right. (B and C) Objective and subjective measures of conscious perception. (B) Percentage of correct responses in numerical comparison as a function of SOA. (C) Proportion of trials subjectively rated as “seen” as a function of SOA. In both graphs, the sigmoid curve fitting the data is represented as a continuous line. Error bars represent the standard error. (D) Objective performance at different levels of subjective visibility and SOA; only cells with at least five measures per subject are included. (E) Distribution of subjective visibility ratings yielding the mean data shown in (C).
Figure 2 Experimental Protocol and Behavioral Results Collected during ERP Recording (A) On each trial, a target numeral (16 ms) was presented at one of four possible location, and followed by a letter mask (250 ms). Gray dots and numerals are shown for spatial reference only, and were not actually presented. Six conditions of target-mask SOA=16, 33, 50, 66, 83, or 100 ms and one mask-only condition (without target) were randomly intermixed across trials. Following each such stimulus, subjects performed two consecutive tasks: (1) forced-choice comparison of the target numeral with the numeral 5 and (2) evaluation of subjective target visibility using a continuous scale labelled “not seen” at left and “maximal visibility” at right. (B and C) Objective and subjective measures of conscious perception. (B) Percentage of correct responses in numerical comparison as a function of SOA. (C) Proportion of trials subjectively rated as “seen” as a function of SOA. In both graphs, the sigmoid curve fitting the data is represented as a continuous line. Error bars represent the standard error. (D) Objective performance at different levels of subjective visibility and SOA; only cells with at least five measures per subject are included. (E) Distribution of subjective visibility ratings yielding the mean data shown in (C).CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 3 Mask Subtraction Method The mask subtraction method is illustrated here for ERP activity recorded in parieto-temporal electrodes controlateral to the hemifield of stimulus presentation (averaged across right and left stimulus presentation). To separate activity evoked by target from activity evoked by the mask, the following procedure was used: (A) Alignment of ERPs on mask onset; (C) Subtraction of ERPs evoked by the mask-only condition from each of the others six target + mask conditions; (D) Realignment of these subtracted ERPs on target onset. For comparison, (B) shows the nonsubtracted ERPs aligned on target onset. The subtraction procedure allowed to recover two target-evoked components (P1a and N1) and one later mask-evoked component (P2).
Figure 3 Mask Subtraction Method The mask subtraction method is illustrated here for ERP activity recorded in parieto-temporal electrodes controlateral to the hemifield of stimulus presentation (averaged across right and left stimulus presentation). To separate activity evoked by target from activity evoked by the mask, the following procedure was used: (A) Alignment of ERPs on mask onset; (C) Subtraction of ERPs evoked by the mask-only condition from each of the others six target + mask conditions; (D) Realignment of these subtracted ERPs on target onset. For comparison, (B) shows the nonsubtracted ERPs aligned on target onset. The subtraction procedure allowed to recover two target-evoked components (P1a and N1) and one later mask-evoked component (P2).CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 4 Sequence of ERP Components Evoked by the Target and Mask Five ERP components were found to be elicited by the target, and two other components were found to be evoked by the mask. These two last components appeared as positive waveforms since they result from the subtraction of mask-only activity from the mask-evoked N1 and N2 activity for the different target + mask conditions. In the mask-subtracted data, these components appear to increase with SOA, which in reality means that the mask-induced activation (mask-evoked N1 and N2) decreases with SOA. For each component, its peak latency (in milliseconds) is represented as a function of SOA measured relative to target (continuous line) or to mask onset (dashed line). The histograms at right show peak amplitude (in microvolts). Their topography in response to left and right hemifield stimulation is illustrated by voltage maps of the scalp surface, for the target + mask after mask subtraction, SOA=100 ms (first five target-evoked components) and for the mask-only condition (for mask-evoked N1 and N2 components).
Figure 4 Sequence of ERP Components Evoked by the Target and Mask Five ERP components were found to be elicited by the target, and two other components were found to be evoked by the mask. These two last components appeared as positive waveforms since they result from the subtraction of mask-only activity from the mask-evoked N1 and N2 activity for the different target + mask conditions. In the mask-subtracted data, these components appear to increase with SOA, which in reality means that the mask-induced activation (mask-evoked N1 and N2) decreases with SOA. For each component, its peak latency (in milliseconds) is represented as a function of SOA measured relative to target (continuous line) or to mask onset (dashed line). The histograms at right show peak amplitude (in microvolts). Their topography in response to left and right hemifield stimulation is illustrated by voltage maps of the scalp surface, for the target + mask after mask subtraction, SOA=100 ms (first five target-evoked components) and for the mask-only condition (for mask-evoked N1 and N2 components).CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 5 Interruption of Target-Evoked Activity by Mask Presentation Mask-subtracted ERPs from occipito-temporal electrodes, averaged across right and left hemifields of stimulus presentation, are represented aligned respectively on target onset (left panel) and mask onset (right panel). The N2 component shows a common onset for all SOA conditions when ERPs are aligned on target onset, and a common offset when ERPs are aligned on mask onset. Thus, the N2 may reflect a process that starts with target onset and is interrupted by the mask.
Figure 5 Interruption of Target-Evoked Activity by Mask Presentation Mask-subtracted ERPs from occipito-temporal electrodes, averaged across right and left hemifields of stimulus presentation, are represented aligned respectively on target onset (left panel) and mask onset (right panel). The N2 component shows a common onset for all SOA conditions when ERPs are aligned on target onset, and a common offset when ERPs are aligned on mask onset. Thus, the N2 may reflect a process that starts with target onset and is interrupted by the mask.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 6 Sudden Onset of a Nonlinear Variation of Evoked Activity with SOA The figure shows the mean amplitude of nonsubtracted ERPs aligned on target onset, measured on central (left panel) and fronto-polar electrodes (right panel). The voltage map shows the topography at the peak of the P3 waveform (latency 370 ms), in the SOA = 100 ms condition. In both graphs, ERPs show a nonlinear increase in amplitude with SOA, with a sudden onset around 270–300 ms.
Figure 6 Sudden Onset of a Nonlinear Variation of Evoked Activity with SOA The figure shows the mean amplitude of nonsubtracted ERPs aligned on target onset, measured on central (left panel) and fronto-polar electrodes (right panel). The voltage map shows the topography at the peak of the P3 waveform (latency 370 ms), in the SOA = 100 ms condition. In both graphs, ERPs show a nonlinear increase in amplitude with SOA, with a sudden onset around 270–300 ms.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 7 Difference in Activity Evoked by Conscious and Nonconscious Masked Stimuli Left panel, mean amplitude of mask-subtracted ERPs measured on central electrodes is represented respectively for seen and not-seen trials, for SOA = 50 ms, for a subset of nine subjects who had enough measures in both conditions. Identical activity is initially observed in both conditions, but a divergence is seen starting around 270 ms, with seen trials generating an increased positivity. This difference is similar to the nonlinear divergence as a function of SOA observed on the same electrodes (see Figure 5). Note that not-seen trials evoked greater activity than mask-only trials, indicating that late subliminal activity was induced by the unseen targets. The right panel shows the topography of the difference between seen and not-seen trials at SOA = 50 ms.
Figure 7 Difference in Activity Evoked by Conscious and Nonconscious Masked Stimuli Left panel, mean amplitude of mask-subtracted ERPs measured on central electrodes is represented respectively for seen and not-seen trials, for SOA = 50 ms, for a subset of nine subjects who had enough measures in both conditions. Identical activity is initially observed in both conditions, but a divergence is seen starting around 270 ms, with seen trials generating an increased positivity. This difference is similar to the nonlinear divergence as a function of SOA observed on the same electrodes (see Figure 5). Note that not-seen trials evoked greater activity than mask-only trials, indicating that late subliminal activity was induced by the unseen targets. The right panel shows the topography of the difference between seen and not-seen trials at SOA = 50 ms.CC BY · PubMed Central
Figure 8 Sequence of Cortical Activity Evoked by the Masked Targets Left and right views of the partially inflated hemispheres show the reconstructed cortical sources at the peak of the P3 (370 ms) in the condition of maximal visibility (SOA = 100 ms). Colors indicate the activation of reconstructed cortical sources, expressed in current density units (A.m), thresholded at 50% of the maximum (yellow = 10−−7 A.m). Insets show the profiles of mask-subtracted activity (average of absolute current density) in six bilateral regions of interest (right and left posterior parietal, posterior ventral temporal, and inferior frontal areas), separately for the six conditions of SOA. Two phases of cortical activation can be distinguished. In a first phase, prior to about 300 ms, activation progresses from the occipital pole toward both parietal and ventral temporal sites, and its amplitude increases roughly linearly with target-mask SOA. In a second phase, after 300 ms, there is a sudden onset of high-amplitude activity, with a sigmoidal profile, particularly in ventral prefrontal cortex, accompanied by a concomitant reactivation of all previous posterior sites.
Figure 8 Sequence of Cortical Activity Evoked by the Masked Targets Left and right views of the partially inflated hemispheres show the reconstructed cortical sources at the peak of the P3 (370 ms) in the condition of maximal visibility (SOA = 100 ms). Colors indicate the activation of reconstructed cortical sources, expressed in current density units (A.m), thresholded at 50% of the maximum (yellow = 10−−7 A.m). Insets show the profiles of mask-subtracted activity (average of absolute current density) in six bilateral regions of interest (right and left posterior parietal, posterior ventral temporal, and inferior frontal areas), separately for the six conditions of SOA. Two phases of cortical activation can be distinguished. In a first phase, prior to about 300 ms, activation progresses from the occipital pole toward both parietal and ventral temporal sites, and its amplitude increases roughly linearly with target-mask SOA. In a second phase, after 300 ms, there is a sudden onset of high-amplitude activity, with a sigmoidal profile, particularly in ventral prefrontal cortex, accompanied by a concomitant reactivation of all previous posterior sites.CC BY · PubMed Central

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Claims other papers make about this one

Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Citations

Cites

Show all 70 references

Research works printed but not linked: 63

  1. Del Cul, 2006, Arch Gen Psychiatry, 63, 1313
  2. Kiefer, 2002, Brain Res Cogn Brain Res, 13, 27
  3. Naccache, 2005, Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 102, 7713
  4. Dehaene, 1998, Nature, 395, 597
  5. Haynes, 2005, Nat Neurosci, 8, 686
  6. Pins, 2003, Cereb Cortex, 13, 461
  7. Super, 2001, Nat Neurosci, 4, 304
  8. Lamme, 2002, J Cogn Neurosci, 14, 1044
  9. Lamme, 2006, Trends Cogn Sci, 10, 494
  10. Zeki, 2003, Trends Cogn Sci, 7, 214
  11. Tse, 2005, Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 102, 17178
  12. Tong, 2003, Nat Rev Neurosci, 4, 219
  13. Allison, 1999, Cereb Cortex, 9, 415
  14. Dehaene, 1998, Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 95, 14529
  15. Dehaene, 2001, Cognition, 79, 1
  16. Dehaene, 2001, Nat Neurosci, 4, 752
  17. Dehaene, 2003, Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 100, 8520
  18. Dehaene, 2005, PLoS Biol, 3
  19. Dehaene, 2006, Trends Cogn Sci, 10, 204
  20. Rees, 2002, Nat Rev Neurosci, 3, 261
  21. Vuilleumier, 2001, Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 98, 3495
  22. Beck, 2001, Nature Neuroscience, 4, 645
  23. Marois, 2004, Neuron, 41, 465
  24. Lumer, 1999, Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 96, 1669
  25. Lau, 2006, Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 103, 18763
  26. Tononi, 2004, BMC Neurosci, 5, 42
  27. Haynes, 2005, Neuron, 46, 811
  28. Sergent, 2005, Nat Neurosci, 8, 1391
  29. Sergent, 2004, Psychol Sci, 15, 720
  30. Naccache, 2001, Cereb Cortex, 11, 966
  31. Kunde, 2003, Cognition, 88, 223
  32. Merikle, 1990, J Exp Psychol Hum Percept Perform, 16, 574
  33. Vaughan, 1968, Science, 160, 207
  34. Woodman, 2003, Psychol Sci, 14, 605
  35. Kranczioch, 2005, Neuroimage, 24, 704
  36. Vorberg, 2003, Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 100, 6275
  37. Ferrand, 1994, Q J Exp Psychol [A], 47, 365
  38. Bridgeman, 1975, Vision Res, 15, 91
  39. Macknik, 1998, Nat Neurosci, 1, 144
  40. Kovacs, 1995, Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 92, 5587
  41. Rolls, 1999, J Cogn Neurosci, 11, 300
  42. Green, 2005, J Cogn Neurosci, 17, 13
  43. Thompson, 1999, Nat Neurosci, 2, 283
  44. Nieuwenhuis, 2001, Psychophysiology, 38, 752
  45. Brazdil, 2001, Clin Neurophysiol, 112, 650
  46. Brazdil, 1998, Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol, 107, 64
  47. Keysers, 2002, Trends Cogn Sci, 6, 120
  48. Keysers, 2001, J Cogn Neurosci, 13, 90
  49. Van Aalderen-Smeets, 2006, Adv Cogn Psych, 2, 21
  50. Clarke, 1999, Clin Neurophysiol, 110, 1226
  51. Weidner, 2006, J Cogn Neurosci, 18, 258
  52. Kouider, 2007, Cereb Cortex, 17, 2019
  53. Kleinschmidt, 2002, Neuron, 34, 659
  54. de Lafuente, 2006, Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 103, 14266
  55. de Lafuente, 2005, Nat Neurosci, 8, 1698
  56. Melloni, 2007, J Neurosci, 27, 2858
  57. Koivisto, 2006, Cereb Cortex, 16, 415
  58. Bar, 2001, Neuron, 29, 529
  59. Grill-Spector, 2000, Nat Neurosci, 3, 837
  60. Block, 1974, Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association, 1974, 127
  61. Beck, 2006, Cereb Cortex, 16, 712
  62. Huang, 1999, Phys Med Biol, 44, 423
  63. Di Lollo, 2000, J Exp Psychol Gen, 129, 481

Cited by

Metadata

Authors
Del Cul, A., Baillet, S., & Dehaene, S.
Affiliations
  • Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (FR)
  • Université Paris-Sud (FR)
Venue
PLoS Biology
Published
2007-09-25
Volume
5
Issue
10
Pages
e260
ISSN
  • 1544-9173 (ISSN-L)
  • 1545-7885
OpenAlex
W2144655282
Cited by
753
References
70
Citations by year
2026: 26 · 2025: 41 · 2024: 41 · 2023: 31 · 2022: 34 · 2021: 45 · 2020: 42 · 2019: 47 · 2018: 34 · 2017: 40 · 2016: 40 · 2015: 56 · 2014: 49 · 2013: 58 · 2012: 44
FWCI
14.19
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Locations
  • PLoS Biology (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed Central (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • PubMed (publishedVersion)
  • HAL (submittedVersion, other-oa)
  • DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) (submittedVersion, cc-by-sa)
  • Figshare (submittedVersion, cc-by)
Funders
  • James S. McDonnell Foundation
  • Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale
Topics
  • Life Sciences › Neuroscience › Cognitive Neuroscience › Visual perception and processing mechanisms
  • Social Sciences › Arts and Humanities › Philosophy › Philosophy and Theoretical Science
  • Life Sciences › Neuroscience › Cognitive Neuroscience › Neural dynamics and brain function
Keywords
conscious access, backward masking, subliminal processing, nonlinear threshold, event-related potentials, stimulus onset asynchrony, visual perception, neural correlates of consciousness
MeSH terms
Adult, Brain, Consciousness, Female, Humans, Male, Perceptual Masking, Photic Stimulation, Reaction Time, Sensory Thresholds, Visual Perception, Nonlinear Dynamics

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.