The support of autonomy and the control of behavior.

Abstract

In this article we suggest that events and contexts relevant to the initiation and regulation of intentional behavior can function either to support autonomy (i.e., to promote choice) or to control behavior (i.e., to pressure one toward specific outcomes). Research herein reviewed indicates that this distinction is relevant to specific external events and to general interpersonal contexts as well as to specific internal events and to general personality orientations. That is, the distinction is relevant whether one's analysis focuses on social psychological variables or on personality variables. The research review details those contextual and person factors that tend to promote autonomy and those that tend to control. Furthermore, it shows that autonomy support has generally been associated with more intrinsic motivation, greater interest, less pressure and tension, more creativity, more cognitive flexibility, better conceptual learning, a more positive emotional tone, higher self-esteem, more trust, greater persistence of behavior change, and better physical and psychological health than has control. Also, these results have converged across different assessment procedures, different research methods, and different subject populations. On the basis of these results, we present an organismic perspective in which we argue that the regulation of intentional behavior varies along a continuum from autonomous (i.e., self-determined) to controlled. The relation of this organismic…

Cites (11)

1. The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception
   Bornstein, Marc H., Gibson, James J. · 1980 · The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism
2. Generalized expectancies for internal versus external control of reinforcement.
   Rotter, Julian B. · 1966 · Psychological Monographs: General and Applied
3. Learned helplessness in humans: Critique and reformulation.
   Abramson, Lyn Y., Seligman, Martin E., Teasdale, John D. · 1978 · Journal of Abnormal Psychology
4. Effects of externally mediated rewards on intrinsic motivation.
   Deci, Edward L. · 1971 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
5. The Perceived Competence Scale for Children
   Harter, Susan · 1982 · Child Development
6. Control and information in the intrapersonal sphere: An extension of cognitive evaluation theory.
   Ryan, Richard M. · 1982 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
7. Undermining children's intrinsic interest with extrinsic reward: A test of the "overjustification" hypothesis.
   Lepper, Mark R., Greene, David, Nisbett, Richard E. · 1973 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
8. Setting limits on children's behavior: The differential effects of controlling vs. informational styles on intrinsic motivation and creativity
   Koestner, Richard, Ryan, Richard M., Bernieri, Frank, Holt, Kathleen · 1984 · Journal of Personality
9. On the Causal Effects of Perceived Competence on Intrinsic Motivation: A Test of Cognitive Evaluation Theory
   Vallerand, Robert J., Reid, Greg · 1984 · Journal of Sport Psychology
10. Effects of control and predictability on the physical and psychological well-being of the institutionalized aged.
    Schulz, Richard · 1976 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
11. Informational versus Controlling Verbal Rewards
    Pittman, Thane S., Davey, Margaret E., Alafat, Kimberly A., Wetherill, Kathryn V., Kramer, Nancy A. · 1980 · Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin

Cited by (87)

1. School Engagement: Potential of the Concept, State of the Evidence
   Fredricks, Jennifer A, Blumenfeld, Phyllis C, Paris, Alison H · 2004 · Review of Educational Research
2. Determinants of Perceived Ease of Use: Integrating Control, Intrinsic Motivation, and Emotion into the Technology Acceptance Model
   Venkatesh, Viswanath · 2000 · Information Systems Research
3. A cognitive-affective system theory of personality: Reconceptualizing situations, dispositions, dynamics, and invariance in personality structure
   Mischel, Walter, Shoda, Yuichi · 1995 · Psychological Review
4. The psychological conditions of meaningfulness, safety and availability and the engagement of the human spirit at work
   May, Douglas R., Gilson, Richard L., Harter, Lynn M. · 2004 · Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology
5. Motivating Project-Based Learning: Sustaining the Doing, Supporting the Learning
   Blumenfeld, Phyllis C., Soloway, Elliot, Marx, Ronald W., Krajcik, Joseph S., Guzdial, Mark, Palincsar, Annemarie · 1991 · Educational Psychologist
6. Toward a hierarchical model of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation
   Vallerand, Robert J. · 1997 · Advances in experimental social psychology
7. A dark side of the American dream: Correlates of financial success as a central life aspiration
   Kasser, Tim, Ryan, Richard M. · 1993 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
8. Intrinsic Need Satisfaction: A Motivational Basis of Performance and Weil‐Being in Two Work Settings ¹
   Baard, Paul P., Deci, Edward L., Ryan, Richard M. · 2004 · Journal of Applied Social Psychology
9. Why Teachers Adopt a Controlling Motivating Style Toward Students and How They Can Become More Autonomy Supportive
   REEVE, JOHNMARSHALL · 2009 · Educational Psychologist
10. Enhancing Students' Engagement by Increasing Teachers' Autonomy Support
    Reeve, Johnmarshall, Jang, Hyungshim, Carrell, Dan, Jeon, Soohyun, Barch, Jon · 2004 · Motivation and Emotion
11. 8 Social Hierarchy: The Self‐Reinforcing Nature of Power and Status
    Magee, Joe C., Galinsky, Adam D. · 2008 · Academy of Management Annals
12. Student engagement in high school classrooms from the perspective of flow theory
    Shernoff, David J., Csikszentmihalyi, Mihaly, Shneider, Barbara, Shernoff, Elisa Steele · 2003 · School Psychology Quarterly
13. Inner resources for school achievement: Motivational mediators of children's perceptions of their parents.
    Grolnick, Wendy S., Ryan, Richard M., Deci, Edward L. · 1991 · Journal of Educational Psychology
14. Academic Emotions and Student Engagement
    Pekrun, Reinhard, Linnenbrink-Garcia, Lisa · 2012 · Handbook of Research on Student Engagement
15. A META‐ANALYTIC EXAMINATION OF THE INSTRUCTIONAL EFFECTIVENESS OF COMPUTER‐BASED SIMULATION GAMES
    SITZMANN, TRACI · 2011 · Personnel Psychology
16. Self-threat magnifies the self-serving bias: A meta-analytic integration
    Campbell, W. Keith, Sedikides, Constantine · 1999 · Review of General Psychology
17. A motivational model of rural students' intentions to persist in, versus drop out of, high school.
    Hardre, Patricia L., Reeve, Johnmarshall · 2003 · Journal of Educational Psychology
18. Motivation and dropout in female handballers: a 21-month prospective study
    Sarrazin, P., Vallerand, R., Guillet, E., Pelletier, L., Cury, F. · 2002 · European Journal of Social Psychology
19. You Can't Always Get What You Want: Educational Attainment, Agency, and Choice.
    Snibbe, Alana Conner, Markus, Hazel Rose · 2005 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
20. Making health habitual: the psychology of ‘habit-formation’ and general practice
    Gardner, Benjamin, Lally, Phillippa, Wardle, Jane · 2012 · British Journal of General Practice
21. Self-Regulation and Academic Procrastination
    Senécal, Caroline, Koestner, Richard, Vallerand, Robert J. · 1995 · The Journal of Social Psychology
22. Dimensions of Coaching Behavior, Need Satisfaction, and the Psychological and Physical Welfare of Young Athletes
    Reinboth, Michael, Duda, Joan L., Ntoumanis, Nikos · 2004 · Motivation and Emotion
23. Testing models of the experience of self-determination in intrinsic motivation and the conundrum of choice.
    Reeve, Johnmarshall, Nix, Glen, Hamm, Diane · 2003 · Journal of Educational Psychology
24. The psychology of passion: A meta-analytical review of a decade of research on intrapersonal outcomes
    Curran, Thomas, Hill, Andrew P., Appleton, Paul R., Vallerand, Robert J., Standage, Martyn · 2015 · Motivation and Emotion
25. Orbitofrontal Cortex and Social Behavior: Integrating Self-monitoring and Emotion-Cognition Interactions
    Beer, Jennifer S., John, Oliver P., Scabini, Donatella, Knight, Robert T. · 2006 · Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience
26. On Passion for Life Activities
    Vallerand, Robert J. · 2010 · Advances in Experimental Social Psychology
27. Achievement Goals and Intrinsic Motivation: A Meta-Analytic Review
    Rawsthorne, Laird J., Elliot, Andrew J. · 1999 · Personality and Social Psychology Review
28. Performance Effects of Motivational State: A Meta-Analysis
    Utman, Christopher H. · 1997 · Personality and Social Psychology Review
29. Leader autonomy support in the workplace: A meta-analytic review
    Slemp, Gavin R., Kern, Margaret L., Patrick, Kent J., Ryan, Richard M. · 2018 · Motivation and Emotion
30. Why Do You Regulate What You Eat? Relationships Between Forms of Regulation, Eating Behaviors, Sustained Dietary Behavior Change, and Psychological Adjustment
    Pelletier, Luc G., Dion, Stéphanie C., Slovinec-D'Angelo, Monika, Reid, Robert · 2004 · Motivation and Emotion
31. Let Us Not Throw Out the Baby With the Bathwater: Applying the Principle of Universalism Without Uniformity to Autonomy-Supportive and Controlling Parenting
    Soenens, Bart, Vansteenkiste, Maarten, Van Petegem, Stijn · 2015 · Child Development Perspectives
32. The Red Sneakers Effect: Inferring Status and Competence from Signals of Nonconformity
    Bellezza, Silvia, Gino, Francesca, Keinan, Anat · 2014 · Journal of Consumer Research
33. Providing a Rationale in an Autonomy-Supportive Way as a Strategy to Motivate Others During an Uninteresting Activity
    Reeve, Johnmarshall, Jang, Hyungshim, Hardre, Pat, Omura, Mafumi · 2002 · Motivation and Emotion
34. Creating contexts for involvement in mathematics.
    Turner, Julianne C., Meyer, Debra K., Cox, Kathleen E., Logan, Candice, DiCintio, Matthew, Thomas, Cynthia T. · 1998 · Journal of Educational Psychology
35. Self-determination theory and the psychology of exercise
    Hagger, Martin, Chatzisarantis, Nikos · 2008 · International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology
36. Relational self-worth: Differences in perceived worth as a person across interpersonal contexts among adolescents
    Harter, Susan, Waters, Patricia, Whitesell, Nancy R · 1998 · Child Development
37. The role of control motivation in mortality salience effects on ingroup support and defense
    Fritsche, Immo, Jonas, Eva, Fankhänel, Thomas · 2008 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
38. Observing Physical Education Teachers’ Need-Supportive Interactions in Classroom Settings
    Haerens, Leen, Aelterman, Nathalie, Van den Berghe, Lynn, De Meyer, Jotie, Soenens, Bart, Vansteenkiste, Maarten · 2013 · Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology
39. Perceived autonomy support, behavioural regulations in physical education and physical activity intention
    Lim, B.S. Coral, Wang, C.K. John · 2009 · Psychology of Sport and Exercise
40. Determinants of help seeking: Relations between perceived reasons for classroom help-avoidance and help-seeking behaviors in an experimental context
    Butler, Ruth · 1998 · Journal of Educational Psychology
41. The need to distinguish between quantity and quality in research on parental involvement: The example of parental help with homework
    Moroni, Sandra, Dumont, Hanna, Trautwein, Ulrich, Niggli, Alois, Baeriswyl, Franz · 2015 · The Journal of Educational Research
42. When Death is Good for Life: Considering the Positive Trajectories of Terror Management
    Vail, Kenneth E., Juhl, Jacob, Arndt, Jamie, Vess, Matthew, Routledge, Clay, Rutjens, Bastiaan T. · 2012 · Personality and Social Psychology Review
43. Why grades engender performance-avoidance goals: The mediating role of autonomous motivation.
    Pulfrey, Caroline, Buchs, Céline, Butera, Fabrizio · 2011 · Journal of Educational Psychology
44. A New Look at the Science of Weight Control: How Acceptance and Commitment Strategies Can Address the Challenge of Self-Regulation
    Forman, Evan M., Butryn, Meghan L. · 2015 · Appetite
45. Performance, incentives, and needs for autonomy, competence, and relatedness: A meta-analysis
    Cerasoli, Christopher P., Nicklin, Jessica M., Nassrelgrgawi, Alexander S. · 2016 · Motivation and Emotion
46. The Chinese classroom paradox: A cross-cultural comparison of teacher controlling behaviors.
    Zhou, Ning, Lam, Shui-Fong, Chan, Kam Chi · 2012 · Journal of Educational Psychology
47. Where Do the Cultural Differences in Dynamics of Controlling Parenting Lie? Adolescents as Active Agents in the Perception of and Coping with Parental Behavior
    Chen, Beiwen, Soenens, Bart, Vansteenkiste, Maarten, Van Petegem, Stijn, Beyers, Wim · 2016 · Psychologica Belgica
48. Use of techniques promoting students' self-determination: Effects on students' analytic problem-solving skills
    Boggiano, Ann K., Flink, Cheryl, Shields, Ann, Seelbach, Aubyn, Barrett, Marty · 1993 · Motivation and Emotion
49. Distinguishing Reactive versus Reflective Autonomy
    Koestner, Richard, Losier, Gaëtan F. · 1996 · Journal of Personality
50. Investigating Differences in Cheating Behaviours of IT Undergraduate and Graduate Students: The maturity and motivation factors
    Sheard, Judy, Markham, Selby, Dick, Martin · 2003 · Higher Education Research & Development
51. Creativity and terror management: Evidence that creative activity increases guilt and social projection following mortality salience
    Arndt, Jamie, Greenberg, Jeff, Solomon, Sheldon, Pyszczynski, Tom, Schimel, Jeff · 1999 · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
52. Dropout from an eHealth intervention for adults with type 2 diabetes: a qualitative study
    Lie, Silje Stangeland, Karlsen, Bjørg, Oord, Ellen Renate, Graue, Marit, Oftedal, Bjørg · 2017 · Journal of Medical Internet Research
53. Human-Agent and Human-Robot Interaction Theory: Similarities to and Differences from Human-Human Interaction
    Krämer, Nicole C., von der Pütten, Astrid, Eimler, Sabrina · 2012 · Studies in Computational Intelligence
54. Development and Validation of a Brief Measure of the Three Psychological Needs Underlying Intrinsic Motivation: The Afs Scales
    Reeve, Johnmarshall, Sickenius, Brad · 1994 · Educational and Psychological Measurement
55. I control therefore I do: Judgments of agency influence action selection
    Karsh, N., Eitam, B. · 2015 · Cognition
56. Time for “The Talk” . . . Now What? Autonomy Support and Structure in Mother-Daughter Conversations About Sex
    Mauras, Carrie P., Grolnick, Wendy S., Friendly, Rachel W. · 2013 · The Journal of Early Adolescence
57. The effects of experimentally induced choice on elementary school children’s intrinsic motivation: The moderating role of indecisiveness and teacher–student relatedness
    Waterschoot, Joachim, Vansteenkiste, Maarten, Soenens, Bart · 2019 · Journal of Experimental Child Psychology
58. User acceptance of e-government services: examining an e-tax filing and payment system in Thailand
    Bhuasiri, Wannasiri, Zo, Hangjung, Lee, Hwansoo, Ciganek, Andrew P. · 2016 · Information Technology for Development
59. Terror Management Theory and Research: How the Desire for Death Transcendence Drives Our Strivings for Meaning and Significance
    Greenberg, Jeff, Vail, Kenneth, Pyszczynski, Tom · 2014 · Advances in Motivation Science
60. Creating a culture of data use for continuous improvement: A case study of an Edison Project school
    Sutherland, Stephanie · 2004 · American Journal of Evaluation
61. Two Types of Value-Affirmation: Implications for Self-Control Following Social Exclusion
    Burson, Aleah, Crocker, Jennifer, Mischkowski, Dominik · 2012 · Social Psychological and Personality Science
62. Does integrating physical activity in the elementary school classroom influence academic motivation?
    Vazou, Spyridoula, Gavrilou, Panagiota, Mamalaki, Evangelia, Papanastasiou, Anna, Sioumala, Nefeli · 2012 · International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology
63. An Examination and Critique of Subjective Methods to Determine Exercise Intensity: The Talk Test, Feeling Scale, and Rating of Perceived Exertion
    Bok, Daniel, Rakovac, Marija, Foster, Carl · 2022 · Sports Medicine
64. Do Some People Need Autonomy More Than Others? Implicit Dispositions Toward Autonomy Moderate the Effects of Felt Autonomy on Well‐Being
    Schüler, Julia, Sheldon, Kennon M., Prentice, Mike, Halusic, Marc · 2016 · Journal of Personality
65. Self‐determination theory, motivational interviewing, and the treatment of clients with acute suicidal ideation
    Britton, Peter C., Williams, Geoffrey C., Conner, Kenneth R. · 2008 · Journal of Clinical Psychology
66. Sociocultural and situative approaches to studying motivation
    Nolen, Susan Bobbitt, Ward, Christopher J. · 2008 · Advances in Motivation and Achievement
67. A psychological intervention programme for patients with breast cancer under chemotherapy and at a high risk of depression: a randomised clinical trial
    Kim, Yeon Hee, Choi, Kyung Sook, Han, Kihye, Kim, Hae Won · 2018 · Journal of Clinical Nursing
68. Creative terror management: Creativity as a facilitator of cultural exploration after mortality salience
    Routledge, Clay D., Arndt, Jamie · 2009 · Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin
69. The mediating role of affect in the relationship between need satisfaction and autonomous motivation
    Vandercammen, Leen, Hofmans, Joeri, Theuns, Peter · 2014 · Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology
70. Advances on self-regulation models: A new research agenda through the SR vs ER behavior theory in different psychology contexts
    de la Fuente, Jesús, Martínez-Vicente, José Manuel, Santos, Flavia H., Sander, Paul, Fadda, Salvatore, Karagiannopoulou, Evangelia, Boruchovitch, Evely, Kauffman, Douglas F. · 2022 · Frontiers in Psychology
71. The Impact of Ideology Misfit on Open Source Software Communities and Companies1
    Daniel, Sherae L., Maruping, Likoebe M., Cataldo, Marcelo, Herbsleb, Jim · 2018 · MIS Quarterly
72. Self-Determination Theory and HCI Games Research: Unfulfilled Promises and Unquestioned Paradigms
    Tyack, April, Mekler, Elisa D. · 2024 · ACM Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction
73. Effects of Perceived Autonomy Support on Academic Achievement and Motivation Among Higher Education Students: A <scp>Meta‐Analysis</scp>
    Okada, Ryo · 2023 · Japanese Psychological Research
74. Social support, physical exercise and life satisfaction in women
    Moreno-Murcia, Juan Antonio, Belando, Noelia, Huéscar, Elisa, Torres, María Dolores · 2017 · Revista Latinoamericana de Psicología
75. Task engagement after mortality salience: The effects of creativity, conformity and connectedness on worldview defence
    Routledge, Clay, Arndt, Jamie, Sheldon, Kennon M. · 2004 · European Journal of Social Psychology
76. The life and death of creativity: The effects of mortality salience on self versus social-directed creative expression
    Routledge, Clay, Arndt, Jamie, Vess, Matthew, Sheldon, Kennon M. · 2008 · Motivation and Emotion
77. Structural Relationships Between Procrastination, Academic Motivation, and Academic Achievement Within University Students: A Self-determination Theory Approach
    Tisocco, Franco, Liporace, Mercedes Fernández · 2023 · Innovative Higher Education
78. Shame and Guilt-Proneness as Mediators of Associations Between General Causality Orientations and Depressive Symptoms
    Young, Chelsie M., Neighbors, Clayton, DiBello, Angelo M., Traylor, Zachary K., Tomkins, Mary · 2016 · Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology
79. The Goose Is (Half) Cooked: a Consideration of the Mechanisms and Interpersonal Context Is Needed to Elucidate the Effects of Personal Financial Incentives on Health Behaviour
    Hagger, Martin S., Keatley, David A., Chan, Derwin C. K., Chatzisarantis, Nikos L. D., Dimmock, James A., Jackson, Ben, Ntoumanis, Nikos · 2014 · International Journal of Behavioral Medicine
80. Frequent deadlines: Evaluating the effect of learner control on healthcare executives' performance in online learning
    Fulton, Lawrence V., Ivanitskaya, Lana V., Bastian, Nathaniel D., Erofeev, Dmitry A., Mendez, Francis A. · 2013 · Learning and Instruction
81. Is less more? A randomized comparison of home practice time in a mind-body program
    Greenberg, Jonathan, Braun, Tosca D., Schneider, Marissa L., Finkelstein-Fox, Lucy, Conboy, Lisa A., Schifano, Elizabeth D., Park, Crystal, Lazar, Sara W. · 2018 · Behaviour Research and Therapy
82. An Appreciative View of the Brighter Side of Terror Management Processes
    Vail, III, Kenneth, Juhl, Jacob · 2015 · Social Sciences
83. The role of explicit need strength for emotions during learning
    Flunger, Barbara, Pretsch, Johanna, Schmitt, Manfred, Ludwig, Peter · 2013 · Learning and Individual Differences
84. Economic threat undermines the satisfaction of psychological needs for competence and autonomy
    Dupuis, Darcy R., Newby‐Clark, Ian R. · 2016 · Journal of Applied Social Psychology
85. Defeating the Potentially Deleterious Effects of Externally Imposed Deadlines: Practitioners’ Rules-of-Thumb
    Burgess, Mark, Enzle, Michael E., Schmaltz, Rodney · 2004 · Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin
86. The INternet ThERapy for deprESsion trial (INTEREST): protocol for a patient-preference, randomised controlled feasibility trial comparing iACT, iCBT and attention control among individuals with comorbid chronic pain and depression
    Bell, Louise V, Cornish, Peter, Flusk, David, Garland, Sheila N, Rash, Joshua A · 2020 · BMJ Open
87. Is Autonomy-Supportive Parenting Beneficial Only to Adolescents With an Autonomous Personality? Two Meanings of Goodness of Fit
    Mabbe, Soenens, Vansteenkiste, De Pauw · 2020 · Merrill-Palmer Quarterly