Aerobic-Exercise and resistance-training interventions have been among the least effective ways to improve executive functions of any method tried thus far
Open accessThe DOI matches its Crossref record; 49 of the 49 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.
Abstract
We appreciate that our colleagues, Hillman et al. (2018), would like to conclude that aerobic exercise improves executive functions (EFs).We, too, would like to conclude that.However, the facts thus far indicate that aerobic exercise interventions (with greater or lesser cognitive and motor skill demands), resistance training, and yoga have produced the weakest results for improving EFs of any method tried.We refer to that evidence briefly below and discuss how physical activity (in ways that researchers have largely ignored) may indeed help to improve EFs.All of this is discussed in far greater depth in Diamond and Ling (in press), which systematically reviews 179 studies reported across 193 papers.We would like to mention three important caveats: First, "weakest" evidence does not mean "no" evidence; 44% of aerobic-exercise studies and 25% of resistance-training studies have found at least suggestive evidence of EF benefits.Thus, some studies have demonstrated EF benefits from these activities.Compare that, however, to 79% of Cogmed ® studies and 100% of studies of taekwondo, t'ai chi, Chinese mind-body practices, and Quadrato motor training (which can all be considered mindfulness practices involving movement) finding at least suggestive evidence of EF benefits (see Table 1 below).Second, our focus is exclusively on EF outcomes.We are not saying that physical activity has shown weak benefits across all domains; we are saying that physical activity interventions have thus far shown weak benefits specifically for EFs.Ours was never meant to be a review of the whole exercise-cognition literature nor a review of the physical fitness, health, or neural benefits of exercise.Third, we are not saying that physical activity does not benefit EFs.There are reasons to think it does.We are saying that interventions used to try to prove that have generally met with disappointing results.As scientists we need to set the record straight.We show below that almost all of the many criticisms leveled by Hillman et al. (2018) of the summary of our review presented in Diamond and Ling (2016) are wholly incorrect or at best misguided.It does not advance science to mischaracterize what we said.We acknowledge, however, that two of the criticisms leveled by Hillman et al. are well-taken; we apologize for those errors.Correcting those errors, though, does not change our conclusions.1.The overwhelming preponderance of evidence is that resistance training and aerobic exercise interventions have thus far generally not been successful in improving EFs Diamond and Ling (2016) was part of a special issue presenting invited addresses from the Flux International Society for Integrative Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience Meeting in 2014.Both that paper, and the invited address on which it was based, were explicitly a brief summary of the initial findings of the systematic review by Diamond and Ling (in press).Diamond and Ling (in press) is an especially comprehensive and extensive review of interventions, programs, and approaches that have tried to improve EFs: "Previous reviews have focused on the large literature on cognitive training approaches to improving EFs or the large literature on physical activity approaches to improving EFs, often concentrating only on studies in children or adults.This review looks at all the different methods that have been tried for improving EFs (including cognitive training and physical exercise, but also all the other approaches) and at all ages (not only children or only the elderly)" (Diamond and Ling, in press) To locate studies for review, "we searched PubMed and PsycNET for all publications that had any keyword, or word in the title or abstract, from both of the following sets (Set 1: evaluate, evaluation, intervention, program, randomized control trial, train, or training; Set 2: attention (apart from Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder [ADHD]), cognitive control, cognitive flexibility, EF, inhibition, inhibitory control, fluid intelligence, mental flexibility, reasoning, self-control, self-regulation, set shifting, task switching, or WM)" (Diamond and Ling, in press).Initially that search was limited to papers published by 2014.(That search did not pick up some important papers, such as the seminal one by Kramer et al. (1999), since none of our search terms was in its title, "Ageing, fitness and neurocognitive function," and since it had no abstract or keyword list, where terms included in our search might have appeared.)Publication of Diamond and Ling (in press) had been expected in early 2016.When that was delayed we used the time to ( a) systematically investigate the references cited in papers that had met our search criteria for still more studies meeting our 11 inclusion criteria (hence Kramer et al. (1999) appears in Diamond & Ling (in press)) and
Overview
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Integrity signals
Registry
Cites
Statistics
Verification
Claims the paper makes
The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.
Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.
Self-check
Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.
The self-check needs the paper’s full text.
Citations
Cites
Diamond, A. (2013) · Annual Review of Psychology · doi:10.1146/annurev-psych-113011-143750 · Cited by 13,268 · cited 1×
“…al. (and we, as well as most EF researchers, consider working memory to be a component of EFs; e.g., Araujo et al., 2017; Blair, 2017; Blakemore and Choudhury, 2006; Devine et al., 2016; Diamond, 2013; Gueron-Sela et al., 2018; Moriguchi et al., 2016; Ursache and Noble, 2016; White et al., 2017).”
Self-citationExercise training increases size of hippocampus and improves memory
Erickson, K. I., Voss, M. W., Prakash, R. S., Basak, C., Szabo, A., Chaddock, L., Kim, J. S., Heo, S., Alves, H., White, S. M., et al. (2011) · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences · doi:10.1073/pnas.1015950108 · Cited by 4,855
Fitness Effects on the Cognitive Function of Older Adults: A Meta-Analytic Study
Colcombe, S., & Kramer, A. F. (2003) · Psychological Science · doi:10.1111/1467-9280.t01-1-01430 · Cited by 3,782
Relation of the therapeutic alliance with outcome and other variables: a meta-analytic review
Martin, D. J., Garske, J. P., & Davis, M. K. (2000) · Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology · doi:10.1037//0022-006x.68.3.438 · Cited by 3,355
Interventions shown to aid executive function development in children 4 to 12 years old
Diamond, A., & Lee, K. (2011) · Science · doi:10.1126/science.1204529 · Cited by 2,901
Self-citationDevelopment of the adolescent brain: implications for executive function and social cognition
Blakemore, S., & Choudhury, S. (2006) · Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry · doi:10.1111/j.1469-7610.2006.01611.x · Cited by 2,328
Preschool Program Improves Cognitive Control
Diamond, A., Barnett, W. S., Thomas, J., & Munro, S. (2007) · Science · doi:10.1126/science.1151148 · Cited by 2,025
Self-citationDonnelly, J. E., Hillman, C. H., Castelli, D., Etnier, J. L., Lee, S., Tomporowski, P., Lambourne, K., & Szabo-Reed, A. N. (2016) · Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise · doi:10.1249/mss.0000000000000901 · Cited by 1,864
Cerebellum and nonmotor function
Strick, P. L., Dum, R. P., & Fiez, J. A. (2009) · Annual Review of Neuroscience · doi:10.1146/annurev.neuro.31.060407.125606 · Cited by 1,777 · cited 1×
“learning including the cerebellum, basal ganglia, motor cortex, supplementary motor area, and cingulate cortex are intimately linked with brain circuits supporting executive function and other higher order cognitive functions (Caligiore et al., 2017; Lanciego et al., 2012; Strick et al., 2009).”
Smith, P. J., Blumenthal, J. A., Hoffman, B. M., Cooper, H., Strauman, T. A., Welsh-Bohmer, K., Browndyke, J. N., & Sherwood, A. (2010) · Psychosomatic Medicine · doi:10.1097/psy.0b013e3181d14633 · Cited by 1,714
Schmidt, R. A., & Bjork, R. A. (1992) · Psychological Science · doi:10.1111/j.1467-9280.1992.tb00029.x · Cited by 1,582
Cordova, D. I., & Lepper, M. R. (1996) · Journal of Educational Psychology · doi:10.1037/0022-0663.88.4.715 · Cited by 1,568
Long-term Effects of Cognitive Training on Everyday Functional Outcomes in Older Adults
Willis, S. L., Tennstedt, S. L., Marsiske, M., Ball, K., Elias, J., Koepke, K. M., Morris, J. N., Rebok, G. W., Unverzagt, F. W., Stoddard, A. M., et al. (2006) · JAMA · doi:10.1001/jama.296.23.2805 · Cited by 1,496
Northey, J. M., Cherbuin, N., Pumpa, K. L., Smee, D. J., & Rattray, B. (2018) · British Journal of Sports Medicine · doi:10.1136/bjsports-2016-096587 · Cited by 1,380
The relationship between physical activity and cognition in children: a meta-analysis
Sibley, B. A., & Etnier, J. L. (2003) · Pediatric Exercise Science · doi:10.1123/pes.15.3.243 · Cited by 1,308
Do “brain-training” programs work?
Simons, D. J., Boot, W. R., Charness, N., Gathercole, S. E., Chabris, C. F., Hambrick, D. Z., & Stine-Morrow, E. A. L. (2016) · Psychological Science in the Public Interest · doi:10.1177/1529100616661983 · Cited by 1,183
Diamond, A., & Ling, D. S. (2016) · Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience · doi:10.1016/j.dcn.2015.11.005 · Cited by 1,177 · cited 1×
“There is not room here, but evidence that sleep (or lack thereof), mood (positive or negative), stress, and social support (or its lack) impact EFs was provided in Diamond and Ling (2016) and is elaborated in Diamond and Ling (in press) and Ling, Kelly and Diamond (2016).”
Self-citationAngevaren, M., Aufdemkampe, G., Verhaar, H., Aleman, A., & Vanhees, L. (2008) · Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews · doi:10.1002/14651858.cd005381.pub3 · Cited by 1,130
Best, J. R. (2010) · Developmental Review · doi:10.1016/j.dr.2010.08.001 · Cited by 1,078 · cited 1×
“…EFs than for aerobic exercise with little or no cognitive and/ or motor skill demands) is the same conclusion many others have reached, including Best (2010), Ericsson (2017), Ericsson and Karlsson (2014), Moreau and Conway (2013, 2014), Moreau et al. (2015), Pesce (2012), Pesce and Ben-Soussan…”
Davis, C. L., Tomporowski, P. D., McDowell, J. E., Austin, B. P., Miller, P. H., Yanasak, N. E., Allison, J. D., & Naglieri, J. A. (2011) · Health Psychology · doi:10.1037/a0021766 · Cited by 911
Exercise and Children’s Intelligence, Cognition, and Academic Achievement
Tomporowski, P. D., Davis, C. L., Miller, P. H., & Naglieri, J. A. (2008) · Educational Psychology Review · doi:10.1007/s10648-007-9057-0 · Cited by 874
Activities and Programs That Improve Children’s Executive Functions
Diamond, A. (2012) · Current Directions in Psychological Science · doi:10.1177/0963721412453722 · Cited by 750 · cited 11×
“(Diamond, 2012: 68–69).””
InfluentialSelf-citationA meta-regression to examine the relationship between aerobic fitness and cognitive performance
Etnier, J. L., Nowell, P. M., Landers, D. M., & Sibley, B. A. (2006) · Brain Research Reviews · doi:10.1016/j.brainresrev.2006.01.002 · Cited by 749
Capitalizing on cortical plasticity: influence of physical activity on cognition and brain function
Kramer, A. F., & Erickson, K. I. (2007) · Trends in Cognitive Sciences · doi:10.1016/j.tics.2007.06.009 · Cited by 741
Architecture and frontal cortical connections of the premotor cortex (area 6) in the rhesus monkey
Barbas, H., & Pandya, D. N. (1987) · Journal of Comparative Neurology · doi:10.1002/cne.902560203 · Cited by 690
Effects of the FITKids Randomized Controlled Trial on Executive Control and Brain Function
Hillman, C. H., Pontifex, M. B., Castelli, D. M., Khan, N. A., Raine, L. B., Scudder, M. R., Drollette, E. S., Moore, R. D., Wu, C.-T., & Kamijo, K. (2014) · Pediatrics · doi:10.1542/peds.2013-3219 · Cited by 661 · cited 2×
“Hillman et al. (2018) falsely claimed that Diamond and Ling (2016) reported that Tools of Mind was more successful than other approaches.”
Diamond, A., & Goldman-Rakic, P. S. (1989) · Experimental Brain Research · doi:10.1007/bf00248277 · Cited by 628 · cited 1×
“Similarly, parietal cortex activation increases during performance of an EF task, delayed response (Chafee and Goldman-Rakic, 1998), but removing parietal cortex does not affect delayed response performance (Diamond and Goldman-Rakic, 1989).”
Self-citationSingh, A. S., Saliasi, E., van den Berg, V., Uijtdewilligen, L., de Groot, R. H. M., Jolles, J., Andersen, L. B., Bailey, R., Chang, Y.-K., Diamond, A., et al. (2019) · British Journal of Sports Medicine · doi:10.1136/bjsports-2017-098136 · Cited by 588
Self-citationSolomon, P. R., & Moore, J. W. (1975) · Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology · doi:10.1037/h0077183 · Cited by 473
Promoting self-regulation through school-based martial arts training.
Lakes, K. D., & Hoyt, W. T. (2004) · Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology · doi:10.1016/j.appdev.2004.04.002 · Cited by 463
Kelly, M. E., Loughrey, D., Lawlor, B. A., Robertson, I. H., Walsh, C., & Brennan, S. (2014) · Ageing Research Reviews · doi:10.1016/j.arr.2014.05.002 · Cited by 455
Fabre, C., Chamari, K., Mucci, P., Massé-Biron, J., & Préfaut, C. (2002) · International Journal of Sports Medicine · doi:10.1055/s-2002-33735 · Cited by 416
Pesce, C. (2012) · Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology · doi:10.1123/jsep.34.6.766 · Cited by 383
Physical Activity and Cognitive Vitality
Prakash, R. S., Voss, M. W., Erickson, K. I., & Kramer, A. F. (2015) · Annual Review of Psychology · doi:10.1146/annurev-psych-010814-015249 · Cited by 376
Kamijo, K., Pontifex, M. B., O’Leary, K. C., Scudder, M. R., Wu, C.-T., Castelli, D. M., & Hillman, C. H. (2011) · Developmental Science · doi:10.1111/j.1467-7687.2011.01054.x · Cited by 365 · cited 1×
“Hillman et al. (2018) asserted that we do not understand the”
Gates, N., Fiatarone Singh, M. A., Sachdev, P. S., & Valenzuela, M. (2013) · The American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry · doi:10.1016/j.jagp.2013.02.018 · Cited by 355
Chaddock-Heyman, L., Erickson, K. I., Voss, M. W., Knecht, A. M., Pontifex, M. B., Castelli, D. M., Hillman, C. H., & Kramer, A. F. (2013) · Frontiers in Human Neuroscience · doi:10.3389/fnhum.2013.00072 · Cited by 305
Uffelen, J. G. Z. V., Chin A Paw, M. J. M., Hopman-Rock, M., & Mechelen, W. V. (2008) · Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine · doi:10.1097/jsm.0b013e3181845f0b · Cited by 296
Evidence for Neurocognitive Plasticity in At-Risk Older Adults: The Experience Corps Program
Carlson, M. C., Erickson, K. I., Kramer, A. F., Voss, M. W., Bolea, N., Mielke, M., McGill, S., Rebok, G. W., Seeman, T., & Fried, L. P. (2009) · The Journals of Gerontology Series A: Biological Sciences and Medical Sciences · doi:10.1093/gerona/glp117 · Cited by 286
Mortimer, J. A., Ding, D., Borenstein, A. R., DeCarli, C., Guo, Q., Wu, Y., Zhao, Q., & Chu, S. (2012) · Journal of Alzheimer's Disease · doi:10.3233/jad-2012-120079 · Cited by 281
Functional anatomical correlates of controlled and automatic processing
Jansma, J. M., Ramsey, N. F., Slagter, H. A., & Kahn, R. S. (2001) · Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience · doi:10.1162/08989290152541403 · Cited by 281
Vazou, S., Pesce, C., Lakes, K., & Smiley-Oyen, A. (2019) · International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology · doi:10.1080/1612197x.2016.1223423 · Cited by 273
Socioeconomic status, white matter, and executive function in children
Ursache, A., Noble, K. G., & the Pediatric Imaging, N. A. G. S. (2016) · Brain and Behavior · doi:10.1002/brb3.531 · Cited by 256
Pesce, C., Masci, I., Marchetti, R., Vazou, S., Sääkslahti, A., & Tomporowski, P. D. (2016) · Frontiers in Psychology · doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00349 · Cited by 228
Krafft, C. E., Schwarz, N. F., Chi, L., Weinberger, A. L., Schaeffer, D. J., Pierce, J. E., Rodrigue, A. L., Yanasak, N. E., Miller, P. H., Tomporowski, P. D., et al. (2014) · Obesity · doi:10.1002/oby.20518 · Cited by 178
Ericsson, I., & Karlsson, M. K. (2014) · Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports · doi:10.1111/j.1600-0838.2012.01458.x · Cited by 162
Fisher, A., Boyle, J. M., Paton, J. Y., Tomporowski, P., Watson, C., McColl, J. H., & Reilly, J. J. (2011) · BMC Pediatrics · doi:10.1186/1471-2431-11-97 · Cited by 127
Monti, J. M., Hillman, C. H., & Cohen, N. J. (2012) · Hippocampus · doi:10.1002/hipo.22023 · Cited by 95
An evaluation of the specificity of executive function impairment in developmental psychopathology
White, L. K., Moore, T. M., Calkins, M. E., Wolf, D. H., Satterthwaite, T. D., Leibenluft, E., Pine, D. S., Gur, R. C., & Gur, R. E. (2017) · Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry · doi:10.1016/j.jaac.2017.08.016 · Cited by 71
Cited by
An umbrella review of randomized control trials on the effects of physical exercise on cognition
Ciria, L. F., Román-Caballero, R., Vadillo, M. A., Holgado, D., Luque-Casado, A., Perakakis, P., & Sanabria, D. (2023) · Nature Human Behaviour · doi:10.1038/s41562-023-01554-4 · Cited by 157
“Data extraction The following data were extracted from the 274 primary studies included in the meta-analyses: (1) list of authors and year of publication; (2) list of authors and year of publication from each primary article included in the meta-analysis; (3) pooled number of participants for the experimental and cont…”
MethodAn umbrella review of randomized control trials on the effects of physical exercise on cognition
(2022) · doi:10.1101/2022.02.15.480508 · Cited by 157
Contreras-Osorio, F., Campos-Jara, C., Martínez-Salazar, C., Chirosa-Ríos, L., & Martínez-García, D. (2021) · Brain Sciences · doi:10.3390/brainsci11060755 · Cited by 86
Talar, K., Vetrovsky, T., van Haren, M., Négyesi, J., Granacher, U., Váczi, M., Martín-Arévalo, E., Del Olmo, M. F., Kałamacka, E., & Hortobágyi, T. (2022) · Ageing Research Reviews · doi:10.1016/j.arr.2022.101738 · Cited by 59
Lind, R. R., Beck, M. M., Wikman, J., Malarski, K., Krustrup, P., Lundbye‐Jensen, J., & Geertsen, S. S. (2019) · Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports · doi:10.1111/sms.13485 · Cited by 52
Metadata
- Authors
- Diamond, A., & Ling, D. S.
- Venue
- Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience
- Publisher
- Elsevier BV
- Published
- 2019-06
- Volume
- 37
- Pages
- 100572
- ISSN
- 1878-9293 (ISSN-L)
- OpenAlex
- W2808541049
- Cited by
- 134
- References
- 49
- FWCI
- 7.72
- Type
- journal article
- Language
- en
- Open access
- gold
About these checks
Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.
Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.
Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.
What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›
Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review
Data sources
Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.
Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).
Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.