CoChat

No evidence of theory of mind reasoning in the human language network

Open access
Shain, Cory, Paunov, Alexander, Chen, Xuanyi, Lipkin, Benjamin, Fedorenko, Evelina · 2023 · Cerebral Cortex

Published version of a preprint

Cited by 49

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 46 of the 46 references it cites were found in a registry or an index.

Abstract

Language comprehension and the ability to infer others’ thoughts (theory of mind [ToM]) are interrelated during development and language use. However, neural evidence that bears on the relationship between language and ToM mechanisms is mixed. Although robust dissociations have been reported in brain disorders, brain activations for contrasts that target language and ToM bear similarities, and some have reported overlap. We take another look at the language-ToM relationship by evaluating the response of the language network, as measured with fMRI, to verbal and nonverbal ToM across 151 participants. Individual-participant analyses reveal that all core language regions respond more strongly when participants read vignettes about false beliefs compared to the control vignettes. However, we show that these differences are largely due to linguistic confounds, and no such effects appear in a nonverbal ToM task. These results argue against cognitive and neural overlap between language processing and ToM. In exploratory analyses, we find responses to social processing in the “periphery” of the language network—right-hemisphere homotopes of core language areas and areas in bilateral angular gyri—but these responses are not selectively ToM-related and may reflect general visual semantic processing.

Overview

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1093/cercor/bhac505

Cites

46 of 46 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Verification

Claims the paper makes

The claims and statistics of this paper haven’t been checked yet.

Free: it reads the open-access text and checks the first 5 claims that cite a source we can check. Create a free account to check every claim.

A few free checks a day · papers already verified open instantly · results are public

Self-check

Percentages, sums and reported differences re-computed from the paper’s own numbers.

The self-check needs the paper’s full text.

Citations

Cites

Research works printed but not linked: 101

  1. 2005, Unified segmentation, Neuroimage, 26, 839, 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2005.02.018 · DOI · Paper page
  2. Astington, 2005, Why language matters for theory of mind, 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195159912.001.0001 · DOI · Paper page
  3. 2015, Fitting linear mixed-effects models using lme4, Journal of Statistical Software, 67
  4. Beeman, 2013, Right hemisphere language comprehension: perspectives from cognitive neuroscience, 10.4324/9780203763544 · DOI · Paper page
  5. Bemis, 2013, Basic linguistic composition recruits the left anterior temporal lobe and left angular gyrus during both listening and reading, Cereb Cortex, 23, 1859, 10.1093/cercor/bhs170 · DOI · Paper page
  6. Benjamini, 2001, The control of the false discovery rate in multiple testing under dependency, Ann Stat, 29, 1165, 10.1214/aos/1013699998 · DOI · Paper page
  7. Blank, 2016, Syntactic processing is distributed across the language system, NeuroImage, 127, 307, 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2015.11.069 · DOI · Paper page
  8. Blank, 2016, Expanding the language network: domain-specific hippocampal recruitment during high-level linguistic processing, BioRxiv, 91900
  9. Bonner, 2013, Heteromodal conceptual processing in the angular gyrus, NeuroImage, 71, 175, 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2013.01.006 · DOI · Paper page
  10. Bottini, 1994, The role of the right hemisphere in the interpretation of figurative aspects of language a positron emission tomography activation study, Brain, 117, 1241, 10.1093/brain/117.6.1241 · DOI · Paper page
  11. Braga, 2017, Parallel interdigitated distributed networks within the individual estimated by intrinsic functional connectivity, Neuron, 95, 457, 10.1016/j.neuron.2017.06.038 · DOI · Paper page
  12. Braga, 2020, Situating the left-lateralized language network in the broader organization of multiple specialized large-scale distributed networks, J Neurophysiol, 124, 1415, 10.1152/jn.00753.2019 · DOI · Paper page
  13. Branzi, 2021, The left angular gyrus is causally involved in context-dependent integration and associative encoding during narrative reading, J Cogn Neurosci, 33, 1082, 10.1162/jocn_a_01698 · DOI
  14. Brothers, 1992, A neuroethological framework for the representation of minds, J Cogn Neurosci, 4, 107, 10.1162/jocn.1992.4.2.107 · DOI · Paper page
  15. Bruneau, 2012, Social cognition in members of conflict groups: behavioural and neural responses in Arabs, Israelis and south Americans to each other’s misfortunes, Philo Trans R Soc B Biol Sci, 367, 717, 10.1098/rstb.2011.0293 · DOI · Paper page
  16. Bruneau, 2012, Distinct roles of the ‘shared pain’and ‘theory of mind’networks in processing others’ emotional suffering, Neuropsychologia, 50, 219, 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2011.11.008 · DOI
  17. Bryan, 1989, Language prosody and the right hemisphere, Aphasiology, 3, 285, 10.1080/02687038908249000 · DOI · Paper page
  18. Calvo, 2019, Rethinking the neural basis of prosody and non-literal language: spared pragmatics and cognitive compensation in a bilingual with extensive right-hemisphere damage, Front Psychol, 10, 10.3389/fpsyg.2019.00570 · DOI
  19. Castelli, 2000, Movement and mind: a functional imaging study of perception and interpretation of complex intentional movement patterns, NeuroImage, 12, 314, 10.1006/nimg.2000.0612 · DOI · Paper page
  20. Castelli, 2002, Autism, Asperger syndrome and brain mechanisms for the attribution of mental states to animated shapes, Brain, 125, 1839, 10.1093/brain/awf189 · DOI · Paper page
  21. Chai, 2016, Functional network dynamics of the language system, Cereb Cortex, 26, 4148, 10.1093/cercor/bhw238 · DOI · Paper page
  22. Champagne-Lavau, 2009, Pragmatics, theory of mind and executive functions after a right-hemisphere lesion: different patterns of deficits, J Neurolinguistics, 22, 413, 10.1016/j.jneuroling.2009.02.002 · DOI
  23. Davis, 2019, Features, labels, space, and time: factors supporting taxonomic relationships in the anterior temporal lobe and thematic relationships in the angular gyrus, Lang Cogn Neurosci, 34, 1347, 10.1080/23273798.2018.1479530 · DOI
  24. Villiers, 2014, The role of language in theory of mind development, Top Lang Disord, 34, 313, 10.1097/TLD.0000000000000037 · DOI · Paper page
  25. Dennis, 2013, Cognitive, affective, and conative theory of mind (ToM) in children with traumatic brain injury, Dev Cogn Neurosci, 5, 25, 10.1016/j.dcn.2012.11.006 · DOI · Paper page
  26. Diehl, 2006, Story recall and narrative coherence of high-functioning children with autism spectrum disorders, J Abnorm Child Psychol, 34, 83, 10.1007/s10802-005-9003-x · DOI · Paper page
  27. DiNicola, 2020, Parallel distributed networks dissociate episodic and social functions within the individual, J Neurophysiol, 123, 1144, 10.1152/jn.00529.2019 · DOI · Paper page
  28. Dodell-Feder, 2011, fMRI item analysis in a theory of mind task, NeuroImage, 55, 705, 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2010.12.040 · DOI · Paper page
  29. Domínguez, 2019, Structural and functional brain correlates of theory of mind impairment post-stroke, Cortex, 121, 427, 10.1016/j.cortex.2019.09.017 · DOI
  30. Dronkers, 1998, Pragmatics in the absence of verbal language: descriptions of a severe aphasic and a language-deprived adult, J Neurolinguistics, 11, 179, 10.1016/S0911-6044(98)00012-8 · DOI
  31. Farrer, 2008, The angular gyrus computes action awareness representations, Cereb Cortex, 18, 254, 10.1093/cercor/bhm050 · DOI · Paper page
  32. Fedorenko, 2011, Functional specificity for high-level linguistic processing in the human brain, Proc Natl Acad Sci, 108, 10.1073/pnas.1112937108 · DOI · Paper page
  33. 1995, Spatial registration and normalization of images, Human brain mapping, 3, 165, 10.1002/hbm.460030303 · DOI · Paper page
  34. Friston, 2011, Functional and effective connectivity: a review, Brain Connectivity, 1, 13, 10.1089/brain.2011.0008 · DOI · Paper page
  35. Gibson, 2000, Image, language, brain, 95
  36. Graff, 2007, English Gigaword third edition LDC2007T07
  37. Grice, 1975, Syntax and semantics, 41
  38. Hale, 2003, The influence of language on theory of mind: a training study, Dev Sci, 6, 346, 10.1111/1467-7687.00289 · DOI · Paper page
  39. Heafield, 2013, Proceedings of the 51st annual meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics, 690
  40. Hutchison, 2013, Dynamic functional connectivity: promise, issues, and interpretations, NeuroImage, 80, 360, 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2013.05.079 · DOI · Paper page
  41. 2017, Perceiving social interactions in the posterior superior temporal sulcus, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 114, E9145
  42. 2020, Comprehension of computer code relies primarily on domain-general executive resources, eLife, 9
  43. Joseph, 1988, The right cerebral hemisphere: emotion, music, visual-spatial skills, body-image, dreams, and awareness, J Clin Psychol, 44, 630, 10.1002/1097-4679(198809)44:5<630::AID-JCLP2270440502>3.0.CO;2-V · DOI · Paper page
  44. 2012, An algorithmic method for functionally defining regions of interest in the ventral visual pathway, Neuroimage, 60, 2357, 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2012.02.055 · DOI · Paper page
  45. Kaakinen, 2014, Processing of written irony: an eye movement study, Discourse Process, 51, 287, 10.1080/0163853X.2013.870024 · DOI
  46. Kamps, 2022, Using child-friendly movie stimuli to study the development of face, place, and object regions from age 3 to 12 years, Hum Brain Mapp, 43, 10.1002/hbm.25815 · DOI
  47. Kaplan, 1990, The effects of right hemisphere damage on the pragmatic interpretation of conversational remarks, Brain Lang, 38, 315, 10.1016/0093-934X(90)90117-Y · DOI · Paper page
  48. LeBel, 2021, Voxelwise encoding models show that cerebellar language representations are highly conceptual, J Neurosci, 41, 10341, 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.0118-21.2021 · DOI
  49. Lee, 2006, Metaphorical vs. literal word meanings: fMRI evidence against a selective role of the right hemisphere, NeuroImage, 29, 536, 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2005.08.003 · DOI · Paper page
  50. Lindell, 2006, In your right mind: right hemisphere contributions to language processing and production, Neuropsychol Rev, 16, 131, 10.1007/s11065-006-9011-9 · DOI · Paper page
  51. Lipkin, 2022, Probabilistic atlas for the language network based on precision fMRI data from >800 individuals, Scientific Data, 9
  52. Lopopolo, 2017, Using stochastic language models (SLM) to map lexical, syntactic, and phonological information processing in the brain, PLoS One, 12, e0177794, 10.1371/journal.pone.0177794 · DOI · Paper page
  53. 2016, Reliable individual-level neural markers of high-level language processing: A necessary precursor for relating neural variability to behavioral and genetic variability, Neuroimage, 139
  54. Malik-Moraleda, 2022, An investigation across 45 languages and 12 language families reveals a universal language network, Nature Neuroscience, 25, 10.1038/s41593-022-01114-5 · DOI · Paper page
  55. Marcus, 1993, Building a large annotated corpus of English: the Penn treebank, Comput Linguist, 19, 313
  56. Martin, 2022, A weak shadow of early life language processing persists in the right hemisphere of the mature brain, Neurobiol Lang, 3, 364, 10.1162/nol_a_00069 · DOI
  57. Martín-Rodríguez, 2010, Theory of mind deficits in patients with acquired brain injury: a quantitative review, Neuropsychologia, 48, 1181, 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2010.02.009 · DOI · Paper page
  58. Mason, 2011, Differentiable cortical networks for inferences concerning people’s intentions versus physical causality, Hum Brain Mapp, 32, 313, 10.1002/hbm.21021 · DOI · Paper page
  59. Matchin, 2019, Same words, different structures: an fMRI investigation of argument relations and the angular gyrus, Neuropsychologia, 125, 116, 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2019.01.019 · DOI
  60. Miller, 2006, Developmental relationships between language and theory of mind, 10.1044/1058-0360(2006/014) · doi:10.1044/1058-0360(2006/014 · Paper page
  61. Mitchell, 2005, Right hemisphere language functions and schizophrenia: the forgotten hemisphere?, Brain, 128, 963, 10.1093/brain/awh466 · DOI · Paper page
  62. Nguyen, 2012, Proceedings of COLING 2012
  63. Handbook of functional connectivity Magnetic Resonance Imaging methods in CONN
  64. Oldfield, 1971, The assessment and analysis of handedness: the Edinburgh inventory, Neuropsychologia, 9, 97, 10.1016/0028-3932(71)90067-4 · DOI · Paper page
  65. Paunov, 2019, Functionally distinct language and theory of mind networks are synchronized at rest and during language comprehension, J Neurophysiol, 121, 1244, 10.1152/jn.00619.2018 · DOI · Paper page
  66. Paunov, 2022, Differential tracking of linguistic vs. mental state content in naturalistic stimuli by language and theory of mind (ToM) brain networks, Neurobiol Lang, 3, 413, 10.1162/nol_a_00071 · DOI · Paper page
  67. Peterson, 2000, Insights into theory of mind from deafness and autism, Mind Lang, 15, 123, 10.1111/1468-0017.00126 · DOI · Paper page
  68. Pritchett, 2018, High-level language processing regions are not engaged in action observation or imitation, J Neurophysiol, 120, 2555, 10.1152/jn.00222.2018 · DOI · Paper page
  69. Quillen, 2021, Distinct neural correlates of linguistic and non-linguistic demand, Neurobiol Lang, 2, 202, 10.1162/nol_a_00031 · DOI
  70. Rajimehr, 2022, Complementary hemispheric lateralization of language and social processing in the human brain, 10.1016/j.celrep.2022.111617 · DOI
  71. Rapp, 2007, Laterality in metaphor processing: lack of evidence from functional magnetic resonance imaging for the right hemisphere theory, Brain Lang, 100, 142, 10.1016/j.bandl.2006.04.004 · DOI · Paper page
  72. Rapp, 2012, Where in the brain is nonliteral language? A coordinate-based meta-analysis of functional magnetic resonance imaging studies, NeuroImage, 63, 600, 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2012.06.022 · DOI · Paper page
  73. Rayner, 2000, The effect of clause wrap-up on eye movements during reading, Q J Exp Psychol A, 53, 1061, 10.1080/713755934 · doi:10.1080/713755934 · Paper page
  74. Regel, 2011, Isn’t it ironic? An electrophysiological exploration of figurative language processing, J Cogn Neurosci, 23, 277, 10.1162/jocn.2010.21411 · DOI · Paper page
  75. Richardson, 2018, Development of the social brain from age three to twelve years, Nat Commun, 9, 1, 10.1038/s41467-018-03399-2 · DOI · Paper page
  76. Richardson, 2020, Reduced neural selectivity for mental states in deaf children with delayed exposure to sign language, Nat Commun, 11, 1, 10.1038/s41467-020-17004-y · DOI
  77. Roberts, 2012, Information structure: towards an integrated formal theory of pragmatics, Semant Pragmat, 5, 1, 10.3765/sp.5.6 · DOI · Paper page
  78. Ross, 1979, Dominant language functions of the right hemisphere? Prosody and emotional gesturing, Arch Neurol, 36, 144, 10.1001/archneur.1979.00500390062006 · DOI · Paper page
  79. Ruby, 2003, What you believe versus what you think they believe: a neuroimaging study of conceptual perspective-taking, Eur J Neurosci, 17, 2475, 10.1046/j.1460-9568.2003.02673.x · DOI · Paper page
  80. Ruffman, 2003, How language relates to belief, desire, and emotion understanding, Cogn Dev, 18, 139, 10.1016/S0885-2014(03)00002-9 · DOI · Paper page
  81. Saxe, 2010, Handbook of theory of mind, 1
  82. Schurz, 2017, Specifying the brain anatomy underlying temporo-parietal junction activations for theory of mind: a review using probabilistic atlases from different imaging modalities, Hum Brain Mapp, 38, 4788, 10.1002/hbm.23675 · DOI · Paper page
  83. Schuster, 2016, Words in context: the effects of length, frequency, and predictability on brain responses during natural reading, Cereb Cortex, 26, 3889, 10.1093/cercor/bhw184 · DOI · Paper page
  84. Shain, 2019, Proceedings of the 2019 conference of the north American chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: human language technologies, volume 1 (long and short papers), 4086
  85. Shain, 2022, Robust effects of working memory demand during naturalistic language comprehension in language-selective cortex, J Neurosci, 42, 7412, 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1894-21.2022 · DOI · Paper page
  86. Shibata, 2010, Neural substrates of irony comprehension: a functional MRI study, Brain Res, 1308, 114, 10.1016/j.brainres.2009.10.030 · DOI · Paper page
  87. Slade, 2005, How language does (and does not) relate to theory of mind: a longitudinal study of syntax, semantics, working memory and false belief, Br J Dev Psychol, 23, 117, 10.1348/026151004X21332 · DOI · Paper page
  88. Small, 2021, Proceedings of the thirteenth annual meeting of the Society for the Neurobiology of language, 264.
  89. Sperber, 1987, Précis of relevance: communication and cognition, Behav Brain Sci, 10, 697, 10.1017/S0140525X00055345 · DOI · Paper page
  90. Tager-Flusberg, 2005, Handbook of autism and pervasive developmental disorders, 335, 10.1002/9780470939345.ch12 · DOI · Paper page
  91. Thothathiri, 2012, The neural basis of reversible sentence comprehension: evidence from voxel-based lesion symptom mapping in aphasia, J Cogn Neurosci, 24, 212, 10.1162/jocn_a_00118 · DOI · Paper page
  92. Uddin, 2010, Dissociable connectivity within human angular gyrus and intraparietal sulcus: evidence from functional and structural connectivity, Cereb Cortex, 20, 2636, 10.1093/cercor/bhq011 · DOI · Paper page
  93. Van Lancker, 1997, Rags to riches: our increasing appreciation of cognitive and communicative abilities of the human right cerebral hemisphere, Brain Lang, 57, 1, 10.1006/brln.1997.1850 · DOI
  94. Schijndel, 2013, A model of language processing as hierarchic sequential prediction, Top Cogn Sci, 5, 522, 10.1111/tops.12034 · DOI · Paper page
  95. Varley, 2001, Severe impairment in grammar does not preclude theory of mind, Neurocase, 7, 489, 10.1093/neucas/7.6.489 · DOI · Paper page
  96. Vogeley, 2001, Mind reading: neural mechanisms of theory of mind and self-perspective, NeuroImage, 14, 170, 10.1006/nimg.2001.0789 · DOI · Paper page
  97. Willems, 2011, Communicating without a functioning language system: implications for the role of language in mentalizing, Neuropsychologia, 49, 3130, 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2011.07.023 · DOI
  98. Willems, 2014, On the other hand: including left-handers in cognitive neuroscience and neurogenetics, Nat Rev Neurosci, 15, 193, 10.1038/nrn3679 · DOI · Paper page
  99. Wimmer, 1983, Beliefs about beliefs: representation and constraining function of wrong beliefs in young children’s understanding of deception, Cognition, 13, 103, 10.1016/0010-0277(83)90004-5 · DOI · Paper page
  100. Winner, 1998, Distinguishing lies from jokes: theory of mind deficits and discourse interpretation in right hemisphere brain-damaged patients, Brain Lang, 62, 89, 10.1006/brln.1997.1889 · DOI · Paper page
  101. Zaidel, 1987, Hemispheric asymmetry in long-term semantic relationships, Cogn Neuropsychol, 4, 321, 10.1080/02643298708252042 · doi:10.1080/02643298708252042

Cited by

See all 49

Metadata

Authors
Shain, C., Paunov, A., Chen, X., Lipkin, B., & Fedorenko, E.
Venue
Cerebral Cortex
Published
2022-12-28
Volume
33
Issue
10
Pages
6299-6319
ISSN
  • 1047-3211 (ISSN-L)
  • 1460-2199
OpenAlex
W4313340061
Cited by
49
References
46
FWCI
11.83
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
bronze
Funders
  • Simons Foundation to the Simons Center for the Social Brain at MIT
  • NIH (U01-NS121471, R01-DC016950, R01-DC016607)

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.