CoChat

Entanglement wedge reconstruction and the information paradox

Open access
Penington, Geoffrey · 2020 · Journal of High Energy Physics

The DOI matches its Crossref record; 184 of the 184 references it cites were found in a registry or an index; 66 of the 99 sources its claims cite were checked for support.

Abstract

A bstract When absorbing boundary conditions are used to evaporate a black hole in AdS/CFT, we show that there is a phase transition in the location of the quantum Ryu-Takayanagi surface, at precisely the Page time. The new RT surface lies slightly inside the event horizon, at an infalling time approximately the scrambling time β/ 2 π log S BH into the past. We can immediately derive the Page curve, using the Ryu-Takayanagi formula, and the Hayden-Preskill decoding criterion, using entanglement wedge reconstruction. Because part of the interior is now encoded in the early Hawking radiation, the decreasing entanglement entropy of the black hole is exactly consistent with the semiclassical bulk entanglement of the late-time Hawking modes, despite the absence of a firewall. By studying the entanglement wedge of highly mixed states, we can understand the state dependence of the interior reconstructions. A crucial role is played by the existence of tiny, non-perturbative errors in entanglement wedge reconstruction. Directly after the Page time, interior operators can only be reconstructed from the Hawking radiation if the initial state of the black hole is known. As the black hole continues to evaporate, reconstructions become possible that simultaneously work for a large class of initial states. Using similar techniques, we generalise Hayden-Preskill to show how the amount of Hawking radiation required to reconstruct a large diary, thrown into the black hole, depends on both the energy and the entropy of the diary. Finally we argue that, before the evaporation begins, a single, state-independent interior reconstruction exists for any code space of microstates with entropy strictly less than the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy, and show that this is sufficient state dependence to avoid the AMPSS typical-state firewall paradox.

Overview

CoChat Summary

TL;DR

The paper argues that, assuming semiclassical bulk evaporation plus entanglement wedge reconstruction in AdS/CFT, the Page curve and Hayden-Preskill decoding follow from the quantum extremal surface’s motion during evaporation. It also shows that state dependence is necessary and sufficient to reconcile interior reconstruction with approximate quantum error correction, avoiding firewall-style paradoxes.

Key findings

  • For an evaporating black hole with absorbing boundary conditions, the quantum Ryu-Takayanagi surface undergoes a phase transition at the Page time and lies just inside the event horizon, at an infalling time of roughly one scrambling time,

\(v \approx -\beta/2\pi \log S_{\rm BH}/c_{\rm evap} + O(\beta)\).

  • Before the Page time, no information escapes in the Hawking radiation; after the Page time, part of the interior is encoded in the early radiation, and a diary thrown in can be decoded after the scrambling time if it entered sufficiently early.
  • The paper derives the Page curve with \(S = \min(S_{\rm rad}, A_{\rm hor}/4G_N)\) and states that the entanglement entropy peaks at the Page time \(S_{\rm rad} = A_{\rm hor}/4G_N\).
  • For large diaries, recovery requires

\(S_{\rm new\ rad} - \delta A_{\rm diary} + \delta A_{\rm evap}/4G_N > \log|H_{\rm diary}|\),

so the amount of radiation needed depends on both the diary’s energy and entropy.

  • In the state-dependence analysis, state-independent reconstruction is possible only when the code space obeys

\(\log|H_{\rm code}| < S_{\rm BH}\) before evaporation, and after evaporation the relevant condition becomes \(S_{\rm code} < S_{\rm rad} - S_{\rm BH}\) for reconstructing from the reservoir.

  • The paper argues that the required reconstruction errors are non-perturbatively small and can become \(O(1)\) only when amplified by large code spaces, consistent with toy-model results.

Methods

  • The paper studies a semiclassical evaporating black hole formed from collapse in AdS/CFT, using absorbing boundary conditions and an auxiliary Markovian reservoir \(H_{\rm rad}\) to store Hawking radiation.
  • It computes quantum extremal surfaces using the generalized entropy \(A/4G_N + S_{\rm bulk}\), often via the maximin prescription and, when needed, explicit calculations in Eddington-Finkelstein or Kruskal-like coordinates.
  • It analyzes entanglement wedge reconstruction as approximate operator-algebra quantum error correction, then applies it to Hayden-Preskill decoding, the Page curve, large diaries, and state-dependent interior reconstruction.

Limitations

  • The paper itself says it assumes semiclassical bulk evaporation and does not derive the Hawking process from first principles; this is a stated assumption.
  • It notes that greybody factors prevent an explicit calculation of the quantum extremal surface in general, though the Page curve and Hayden-Preskill criterion can still be derived.
  • It also states that the size of entanglement wedge reconstruction errors is not known exactly; some conclusions rely on lower bounds or approximate saturation of those bounds.

Model-written summary. Check it against the paper before relying on it.

Integrity signals

Registry

Crossref · 10.1007/jhep09(2020)002

Cites

184 of 184 references verified0 citation errors · 0 not checkable

Statistics

Nothing to recompute.

Figures

Figure 1 With reflecting boundary conditions, outgoing modes in a surface ending on the boundary at time t 1 may become ingoing modes on a surface ending at time t 2 , but the same degrees of freedom will always be contained in each surface. The bulk entropy cannot depend on the boundary time. In contrast, with absorbing boundary conditions, outgoing modes at time t 1 may escape the bulk in the reservoir H rad by time t 2 , and so no longer be contained in a surface ending at time t 2 . The bulk entropy, and hence the notion of quantum extremality, depends on the boundary time.
Figure 1 With reflecting boundary conditions, outgoing modes in a surface ending on the boundary at time t 1 may become ingoing modes on a surface ending at time t 2 , but the same degrees of freedom will always be contained in each surface. The bulk entropy cannot depend on the boundary time. In contrast, with absorbing boundary conditions, outgoing modes at time t 1 may escape the bulk in the reservoir H rad by time t 2 , and so no longer be contained in a surface ending at time t 2 . The bulk entropy, and hence the notion of quantum extremality, depends on the boundary time.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 2 Schematic drawings of Cauchy slices through the black hole interior, both before the Page time (left) and after the Page time (right). The blue lines indicate entanglement between the interior of the black hole and the reservoir H rad . Before the Page time, there exist Cauchy slices where the empty surface is the surface homologous to the boundary with minimal generalised entropy. It is therefore the Ryu-Takayanagi surface χ . For illustrative purposes, we draw this surface cutting the entanglement between the interior and the reservoir. After the Page time, however, no such Cauchy slice exists. Within any Cauchy slice, there will always exist a surface, near the horizon and homologous to the boundary, with smaller generalised entropy. The Ryu-Takayanagi surface must become non-empty at the Page time.
Figure 2 Schematic drawings of Cauchy slices through the black hole interior, both before the Page time (left) and after the Page time (right). The blue lines indicate entanglement between the interior of the black hole and the reservoir H rad . Before the Page time, there exist Cauchy slices where the empty surface is the surface homologous to the boundary with minimal generalised entropy. It is therefore the Ryu-Takayanagi surface χ . For illustrative purposes, we draw this surface cutting the entanglement between the interior and the reservoir. After the Page time, however, no such Cauchy slice exists. Within any Cauchy slice, there will always exist a surface, near the horizon and homologous to the boundary, with smaller generalised entropy. The Ryu-Takayanagi surface must become non-empty at the Page time.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 3 The bulk entropy of the region, shown in blue, between the Ryu-Takayanagi surface and the boundary can be decomposed into the entropy of the ingoing and outgoing modes. The ingoing modes are in the infalling vacuum, and the bulk region includes ingoing modes spread over approximately the scrambling time, which diverges in the semiclassical limit. This means that the gradient, in units of infalling time, of the entropy of the infalling modes tends to zero. In contrast, as the RT surface approaches the past lightcone of the boundary, there will be a negative logarithmic divergence in the (renormalised) entropy of the outgoing modes. This divergence should stabilise the location of the quantum extremal surface a small distance away from the outgoing lightcone.
Figure 3 The bulk entropy of the region, shown in blue, between the Ryu-Takayanagi surface and the boundary can be decomposed into the entropy of the ingoing and outgoing modes. The ingoing modes are in the infalling vacuum, and the bulk region includes ingoing modes spread over approximately the scrambling time, which diverges in the semiclassical limit. This means that the gradient, in units of infalling time, of the entropy of the infalling modes tends to zero. In contrast, as the RT surface approaches the past lightcone of the boundary, there will be a negative logarithmic divergence in the (renormalised) entropy of the outgoing modes. This divergence should stabilise the location of the quantum extremal surface a small distance away from the outgoing lightcone.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 4 The quantum Ryu-Takayanagi surface χ q , the classical maximin surface χ c , and the entanglement wedges E rad and E CFT of the reservoir and CFT, in Eddington-Finkelstein coordinates (left) and in a Penrose diagram (right). In the interests of simplicity, the Penrose diagram does not include the post-evaporation region, which would be in the top right. The classical maximin surfaces lies at the intersection of the past lightcone (dashed) with the apparent horizon r s (dotted), which is outside the event horizon. The quantum RT surface, in contrast, lies slightly inside the event horizon. Much of the interior is in the entanglement wedge E rad of the reservoir (green), although part of the interior still lies in the entanglement wedge E CFT of the CFT (blue). As the black hole continues to evaporate, the RT surface moves forward in infalling time along a spacelike trajectory, following the red arrow. On timescales that are small compared to the evaporation time, it remains a fixed radial distance inside the event horizon.
Figure 4 The quantum Ryu-Takayanagi surface χ q , the classical maximin surface χ c , and the entanglement wedges E rad and E CFT of the reservoir and CFT, in Eddington-Finkelstein coordinates (left) and in a Penrose diagram (right). In the interests of simplicity, the Penrose diagram does not include the post-evaporation region, which would be in the top right. The classical maximin surfaces lies at the intersection of the past lightcone (dashed) with the apparent horizon r s (dotted), which is outside the event horizon. The quantum RT surface, in contrast, lies slightly inside the event horizon. Much of the interior is in the entanglement wedge E rad of the reservoir (green), although part of the interior still lies in the entanglement wedge E CFT of the CFT (blue). As the black hole continues to evaporate, the RT surface moves forward in infalling time along a spacelike trajectory, following the red arrow. On timescales that are small compared to the evaporation time, it remains a fixed radial distance inside the event horizon.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 5 Because the absorbing boundary conditions are only deterministic when evolving forwards in time, the domain of dependence of the boundary is the future boundary. The entanglement wedge E CFT of the CFT (light blue) contains the causal wedge C CFT (dark blue). When time is reversed using standard reflective boundary conditions, the entanglement wedge still contains the causal wedge because the backreaction on the geometry creates a white hole.
Figure 5 Because the absorbing boundary conditions are only deterministic when evolving forwards in time, the domain of dependence of the boundary is the future boundary. The entanglement wedge E CFT of the CFT (light blue) contains the causal wedge C CFT (dark blue). When time is reversed using standard reflective boundary conditions, the entanglement wedge still contains the causal wedge because the backreaction on the geometry creates a white hole.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 6 If a diary was thrown into the black hole more than the scrambling time into the past (left), it will now lie in the entanglement wedge of the reservoir H rad and can in principle be decoded using only the Hawking radiation. A diary thrown into the black hole more recently (right) remains in the entanglement wedge of, and encoded in, the CFT.
Figure 6 If a diary was thrown into the black hole more than the scrambling time into the past (left), it will now lie in the entanglement wedge of the reservoir H rad and can in principle be decoded using only the Hawking radiation. A diary thrown into the black hole more recently (right) remains in the entanglement wedge of, and encoded in, the CFT.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 7 The next Hawking modes to escape the black hole and be extracted into H rad will be entangled with interior modes that are mostly in the entanglement wedge of the reservoir H rad . This causes the entanglement between the black hole and the reservoir to decrease as the new radiation is extracted, in accordance with the Page curve. (Left: Eddington-Finkelstein coordinates; right: a Penrose diagram.)
Figure 7 The next Hawking modes to escape the black hole and be extracted into H rad will be entangled with interior modes that are mostly in the entanglement wedge of the reservoir H rad . This causes the entanglement between the black hole and the reservoir to decrease as the new radiation is extracted, in accordance with the Page curve. (Left: Eddington-Finkelstein coordinates; right: a Penrose diagram.)CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 8 Hawking modes that will escape the black hole only an O ( β ) time into the future are entangled with interior modes that are almost entirely in the entanglement wedge of the CFT. This is very different from a simple random unitary toy model, but is consistent with toy models where the thermodynamic entropy (i.e. number of qubits) increases over time. (Left: Eddington-Finkelstein coordinates; right: Penrose diagram.)
Figure 8 Hawking modes that will escape the black hole only an O ( β ) time into the future are entangled with interior modes that are almost entirely in the entanglement wedge of the CFT. This is very different from a simple random unitary toy model, but is consistent with toy models where the thermodynamic entropy (i.e. number of qubits) increases over time. (Left: Eddington-Finkelstein coordinates; right: Penrose diagram.)CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 9 A simple toy model of black hole evaporation that takes into account the increase in thermodynamic entropy as the black holes evaporates. At each timestep, two qubits escape the black hole as Hawking radiation, but then a random isometry is applied to the black hole that increases the number of qubits by one. The total number of qubits (corresponding to the total thermodynamic entropy) therefore increases by one qubit at each timestep. Even if we collect the radiation qubits until long after the Page time, qubits that are radiated only a few timesteps into the future will be completely unentangled with the radiation that we have collected.
Figure 9 A simple toy model of black hole evaporation that takes into account the increase in thermodynamic entropy as the black holes evaporates. At each timestep, two qubits escape the black hole as Hawking radiation, but then a random isometry is applied to the black hole that increases the number of qubits by one. The total number of qubits (corresponding to the total thermodynamic entropy) therefore increases by one qubit at each timestep. Even if we collect the radiation qubits until long after the Page time, qubits that are radiated only a few timesteps into the future will be completely unentangled with the radiation that we have collected.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 10 In the left figure, infalling modes near the quantum extremal surface are in a infallingtime-translation invariant mixed state. These mixed state modes (black) are purified by modes deep in the interior, together with modes that escaped into the reservoir (both red). Both of these are in the entanglement wedge of the reservoir H rad . In the right figure, outgoing modes near the quantum extremal surface (black) are entangled with outgoing modes in the interior, but also with outgoing modes that recently escaped into the reservoir and late-time infalling modes that were reflected back into the black hole (all in red). The first two are in the entanglement wedge of H rad , while the last is in the entanglement wedge of the CFT. The bulk entropy of the modes in the entanglement wedge of the CFT depends on U no longer depends on U in the same simple way that it did when no greybody factors were present in section 2.2.
Figure 10 In the left figure, infalling modes near the quantum extremal surface are in a infallingtime-translation invariant mixed state. These mixed state modes (black) are purified by modes deep in the interior, together with modes that escaped into the reservoir (both red). Both of these are in the entanglement wedge of the reservoir H rad . In the right figure, outgoing modes near the quantum extremal surface (black) are entangled with outgoing modes in the interior, but also with outgoing modes that recently escaped into the reservoir and late-time infalling modes that were reflected back into the black hole (all in red). The first two are in the entanglement wedge of H rad , while the last is in the entanglement wedge of the CFT. The bulk entropy of the modes in the entanglement wedge of the CFT depends on U no longer depends on U in the same simple way that it did when no greybody factors were present in section 2.2.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 11 The exterior geometry of a black hole, with horizon area A 0 , in AdS/CFT. The boundary is divided into two regions B and ¯ B ; there exists a locally minimal surface separating B from ¯ B on either side of the black hole, with areas A 2 and A 1 . These divide the bulk into three regions b , b ′ and ¯ b , where region b ′ lies between the two minimal surfaces and contains the black hole. If A 2 > A 1 , region b ′ is contained in the entanglement wedge of region B for all pure microstates, shown in figure 11a. However, if the black hole is entangled with a reference system with S bulk / 4 G N > A 2 -A 1 , as shown in figure 11b, the Ryu-Takayanagi surface will jump to A 2 and the entanglement wedge of B will no longer contain region b ′ . As a result, a state-independent reconstruction of region b ′ on region B only exists for code spaces of microstates with dimension |H code | ≤ e ( A 2 -A 1 ) / 4 G N .
Figure 11 The exterior geometry of a black hole, with horizon area A 0 , in AdS/CFT. The boundary is divided into two regions B and ¯ B ; there exists a locally minimal surface separating B from ¯ B on either side of the black hole, with areas A 2 and A 1 . These divide the bulk into three regions b , b ′ and ¯ b , where region b ′ lies between the two minimal surfaces and contains the black hole. If A 2 > A 1 , region b ′ is contained in the entanglement wedge of region B for all pure microstates, shown in figure 11a. However, if the black hole is entangled with a reference system with S bulk / 4 G N > A 2 -A 1 , as shown in figure 11b, the Ryu-Takayanagi surface will jump to A 2 and the entanglement wedge of B will no longer contain region b ′ . As a result, a state-independent reconstruction of region b ′ on region B only exists for code spaces of microstates with dimension |H code | ≤ e ( A 2 -A 1 ) / 4 G N .CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 12 After the Page time, the entanglement wedge of the reservoir contains most of the interior for any pure initial black hole microstate. However, if we only know that the initial state was in some large class of possible microstates, we cannot take advantage of this fact to do a Hayden-Preskill recovery, unless the interior is also contained in the entanglement wedge for states in the code space of possible microstates that are highly entangled with a reference system. This entanglement entropy increases the generalised entropy of the non-empty quantum extremal surface (dotted lines) and can make the Ryu-Takayanagi surface χ rad become empty (solid line), preventing us for doing a Hayden-Preskill reconstruction until the black hole has evaporated further.
Figure 12 After the Page time, the entanglement wedge of the reservoir contains most of the interior for any pure initial black hole microstate. However, if we only know that the initial state was in some large class of possible microstates, we cannot take advantage of this fact to do a Hayden-Preskill recovery, unless the interior is also contained in the entanglement wedge for states in the code space of possible microstates that are highly entangled with a reference system. This entanglement entropy increases the generalised entropy of the non-empty quantum extremal surface (dotted lines) and can make the Ryu-Takayanagi surface χ rad become empty (solid line), preventing us for doing a Hayden-Preskill reconstruction until the black hole has evaporated further.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 13 Before the Page time, the interior is in the entanglement wedge of the CFT for any pure state. However, if the initial state is allowed to be highly entangled with a reference system, the Ryu-Takayanagi surface χ CFT for the CFT may jump to the non-empty quantum extremal surface. (In contrast, the RT surface χ rad of the reservoir will remain empty.) This means that a reconstruction of the interior that acts only on the CFT, and not on the reservoir, will have to be at least somewhat state dependent, if the code space is too large.
Figure 13 Before the Page time, the interior is in the entanglement wedge of the CFT for any pure state. However, if the initial state is allowed to be highly entangled with a reference system, the Ryu-Takayanagi surface χ CFT for the CFT may jump to the non-empty quantum extremal surface. (In contrast, the RT surface χ rad of the reservoir will remain empty.) This means that a reconstruction of the interior that acts only on the CFT, and not on the reservoir, will have to be at least somewhat state dependent, if the code space is too large.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 14 When a large diary is thrown into a black hole, the radius r hor of the event horizon (solid line) begins increasing in anticipation of the diary falling in, while the radius r s of the apparent horizon (dotted line) continues to slowly decrease until the diary is actually thrown into the black hole. As the black hole continues to evaporate, the past lightcone (dashed line) of the current boundary remains outside the event horizon. The Ryu-Takayanagi surface χ 1 asymptotes to a point approximately the scrambling time before the diary was thrown in. There is a second quantum extremal surface χ 2 at an infalling time after the diary is thrown in. Initially, this extremal surface is not the RT surface because its area is larger than the area of χ 1 . However, eventually, at the new Page time, there will be a phase transition, with χ 2 becoming the new RT surface, and the diary can finally be reconstructed from the Hawking radiation, so long as its entropy is small. (Left: Eddington-Finkelstein coordinates, right: a Penrose diagram.)
Figure 14 When a large diary is thrown into a black hole, the radius r hor of the event horizon (solid line) begins increasing in anticipation of the diary falling in, while the radius r s of the apparent horizon (dotted line) continues to slowly decrease until the diary is actually thrown into the black hole. As the black hole continues to evaporate, the past lightcone (dashed line) of the current boundary remains outside the event horizon. The Ryu-Takayanagi surface χ 1 asymptotes to a point approximately the scrambling time before the diary was thrown in. There is a second quantum extremal surface χ 2 at an infalling time after the diary is thrown in. Initially, this extremal surface is not the RT surface because its area is larger than the area of χ 1 . However, eventually, at the new Page time, there will be a phase transition, with χ 2 becoming the new RT surface, and the diary can finally be reconstructed from the Hawking radiation, so long as its entropy is small. (Left: Eddington-Finkelstein coordinates, right: a Penrose diagram.)CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 15 If a heavy diary, left, is thrown into the black hole, it can only be reconstructed from H rad once the generalised entropy (solid lines) of the surface χ 1 for H rad is greater than the generalised entropy (dotted lines) of the surface χ 2 . The generalised entropy of χ 1 has contributions from both the area term and the entropy of Hawking radiation emitted after the diary was thrown into the black hole. In contrast, so long as the diary has small entropy, the surface χ 2 only has a contribution from its area, plus an O (1) bulk entropy correction. However, if the diary also has a large entropy (right), the diary also needs to be in the entanglement wedge, even when it is in a highly mixed state, or is entangled with a reference system. This increases the generalised entropy of χ 2 .
Figure 15 If a heavy diary, left, is thrown into the black hole, it can only be reconstructed from H rad once the generalised entropy (solid lines) of the surface χ 1 for H rad is greater than the generalised entropy (dotted lines) of the surface χ 2 . The generalised entropy of χ 1 has contributions from both the area term and the entropy of Hawking radiation emitted after the diary was thrown into the black hole. In contrast, so long as the diary has small entropy, the surface χ 2 only has a contribution from its area, plus an O (1) bulk entropy correction. However, if the diary also has a large entropy (right), the diary also needs to be in the entanglement wedge, even when it is in a highly mixed state, or is entangled with a reference system. This increases the generalised entropy of χ 2 .CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 16 After the black hole has completely evaporated, the bulk encoded in the CFT will be in the vacuum state. However, we can choose a (disconnected) bulk Cauchy slice where the radiation in the reservoir H rad is still be entangled with the pinched-off interior wormhole, which lies in its entanglement wedge. The Ryu-Takayanagi surface is empty and has zero generalised entropy; the two systems H CFT and H rad are therefore unentangled.
Figure 16 After the black hole has completely evaporated, the bulk encoded in the CFT will be in the vacuum state. However, we can choose a (disconnected) bulk Cauchy slice where the radiation in the reservoir H rad is still be entangled with the pinched-off interior wormhole, which lies in its entanglement wedge. The Ryu-Takayanagi surface is empty and has zero generalised entropy; the two systems H CFT and H rad are therefore unentangled.CC-BY · From the PDF
Figure 17 The states | B s ( β ) 〉 have a gravity description as a one sided black hole, ending on an end-of-the-world brane (black). If the system is evolved using the unperturbed SYK Hamiltonian, shown in figure 17a, the bulk operator φ lies behind the black hole horizon (blue). However if the Hamiltonian is perturbed in a state-dependent way, shown in figure 17b, the boundary (green) is pulled inwards and so the operator no longer lies behind a horizon. In the original construction, the Hamiltonian was precisely tuned for a single state | B s ( β ) 〉 . However one can easily adapt the Hamiltonian to work for a large set of states.
Figure 17 The states | B s ( β ) 〉 have a gravity description as a one sided black hole, ending on an end-of-the-world brane (black). If the system is evolved using the unperturbed SYK Hamiltonian, shown in figure 17a, the bulk operator φ lies behind the black hole horizon (blue). However if the Hamiltonian is perturbed in a state-dependent way, shown in figure 17b, the boundary (green) is pulled inwards and so the operator no longer lies behind a horizon. In the original construction, the Hamiltonian was precisely tuned for a single state | B s ( β ) 〉 . However one can easily adapt the Hamiltonian to work for a large set of states.CC-BY · From the PDF

Verification

Claims the paper makes

47 Valid · 24 Not valid · 29 Not checked · 477 Own results and interpretations

395 more claims · 24 with their cited sources checked

Create a free account to see all 577 claims and to verify the 20 references still open.

See all claims — free account
  • Probably not a substantial claim. 58
  • It may state two separate claims as one. 132
  • The quote only partly states this claim. 2

Create a free account to see these claims.

Claims other papers make about this one

Each is checked against this paper’s own text: does it say what the citing paper says it does?

12 more claims about this paper

Create a free account to see every claim other papers make about this one.

See all claims — free account

Citations

Cites

Cited by

See all 970

Metadata

Authors
Penington, G.
Venue
Journal of High Energy Physics
Published
2020-09
Volume
2020
Issue
9
ISSN
1029-8479 (ISSN-L)
OpenAlex
W2945121003
Cited by
968
References
116
Citations by year
2026: 90 · 2025: 155 · 2024: 124 · 2023: 167 · 2022: 169 · 2021: 202 · 2020: 55
FWCI
65.76
Type
journal article
Language
en
Open access
Licence
Locations
  • Journal of High Energy Physics (publishedVersion, cc-by)
  • DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) (submittedVersion, cc-by-sa)
Funders
  • U.S. Department of Energy (DESC0019380)
  • Air Force Office of Scientific Research (FA9550-, FA9550-16-1-0082, FA9550-16, -16-1-, FA9550-16-1)
Topics
  • Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Nuclear and High Energy Physics › Black Holes and Theoretical Physics
  • Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Nuclear and High Energy Physics › Noncommutative and Quantum Gravity Theories
  • Physical Sciences › Physics and Astronomy › Atomic and Molecular Physics, and Optics › Quantum many-body systems
Keywords
entanglement wedge reconstruction, black hole information paradox, Page curve, Ryu-Takayanagi surface, AdS/CFT correspondence, black hole evaporation, Hawking radiation, quantum phase transitions, scrambling time, entanglement entropy, firewall paradox, black hole microstates, Bekenstein-Hawking entropy

About these checks

Registry, retraction, Cites and statistics results are computed, not judged, with one exception: a printed reference that no index lists is read once by a model before it counts as a citation error. Claims are extracted by a model and kept only when their quote appears verbatim in the text; each cited source is then checked, with a model’s help, for whether it says what the claim relies on. Those verdicts can be wrong — read the claim’s quote and the cited source before relying on one.

The claim verdicts this report counts are experimental: their accuracy is not yet measured.

A language model drew the claims from the paper on 2026-10-10, under version 3 of the claim definition (model deepseek-v4.1-flash, prompt extract-v3).

A second model labelled each claim on 2026-10-10 (model jev-1.13-20260917, definition revision gold-guideline-v0.2).

Cited sources are checked with a language model’s help (gpt-6-sol and qwen3.8-omni-flash).

Statistics and arithmetic are recomputed, not judged.

Confidence bands are shown only for fields calibrated on our annotated test set. None is calibrated yet, so no band is shown.

What counts as a claim ›How we measure confidence ›How we check this ›

Are you an author, or do you see a problem with this page? Request a review

Data sources

Bibliographic data: Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex, Crossref.

Contains information from the Semantic Scholar Academic Graph Datasets, made available under the ODC Attribution License (ODC-BY 1.0).

Semantic Scholar’s data is described in: Kinney, R., et al. (2023). The Semantic Scholar Open Data Platform. arXiv:2301.10140.